prague, february 2017 · prague, february 2017 prague model united nations conference ... this...
TRANSCRIPT
Prague, February 2017 Prague Model United Nations Conference Model United Nations Prague z.s. Jaurisova 515/4 140 00 Prague 4 The Czech Republic Web: www.praguemun.cz Author: Clarissa Tabosa and Aurélien Sailler Graphic Design: Jiří Drozd, MUN Pragu
Contents Contents .................................................................................................................................................................................. 2
General introduction:........................................................................................................................................................... 1
An introduction to the UNESCO .............................................................................................................................. 1
What is expected of delegates for this agenda: .............................................................................................. 4
Topic A: Safeguarding cultural heritage in conflict zones ................................................................................. 5
Introduction: .................................................................................................................................................................... 5
Legal aspects: ................................................................................................................................................................ 7
Definition of armed conflict: ................................................................................................................................ 7
The protection of cultural heritage: ....................................................................................................................... 7
Case study: Syria ................................................................................................................................................................. 11
Quick overview of the situation of the Syrian conflict:.................................................................................. 11
Syrian cultural heritage: ............................................................................................................................................. 11
The impact of the conflict over Syrian Cultural Heritage: .......................................................................... 12
UNESCO initiatives to protect Syrian Cultural Heritage: ............................................................................ 13
Core issues to discuss: ............................................................................................................................................... 15
Additional readings: .................................................................................................................................................... 15
Sources: ............................................................................................................................................................................ 15
Topic B: Access to education and health care in conflict and post-conflict zones ............................... 17
Introduction: ................................................................................................................................................................... 17
Definition of key terms: ............................................................................................................................................ 19
The emergence of new threats linked to the evolution of the notion of conflict: ........................... 20
Access to education and Healthcare as weapons: ..................................................................................... 20
The importance of transition towards durable institutions: ...................................................................... 21
Legal aspects: ............................................................................................................................................................. 23
Proposed means of action and points of reflexion: .................................................................................... 23
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
Block positions: ........................................................................................................................................................... 24
Further readings: ........................................................................................................................................................ 26
Sources: .......................................................................................................................................................................... 26
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
1
General introduction:
An introduction to the UNESCO:
The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) is a specialized
agency of the United Nations. Its headquarters are based in Paris. The UNESCO is composed of
two mains bodies:
The General Conference, which meets every two years, and is attended by Member States and
Associate Members, together with observers for non-Member States, intergovernmental
organizations and non-governmental organizations (NGOs). Each country has one vote,
irrespective of its size or the extent of its contribution to the budget. It determines the policies and
the main lines of work of the Organization. Its duty is to set the programmes and the budget of
UNESCO. It also elects the Members of the Executive Board and appoints, every four years, the
Director-General.
The Executive Board ensures the overall management of UNESCO. It prepares the work of the
General Conference and sees that its decisions are properly carried out. The functions and
responsibilities of the Executive Board are derived primarily from the Constitution and from rules
or directives laid down by the General Conference.
In this committee, delegates will simulate the General Conference of the UNESCO.
The UNESCO was founded in 1945 at the occasion of a United Nations Conference for the
establishment of an educational and cultural organization. The Constitution of UNESCO, signed
on 16 November 1945, came into force on 4 November 1946 after ratification by twenty countries.
Today, the UNESCO is composed of 195 Member States and ten associate members.
UNESCO
2
According to its Constitution, the purpose of the Organization is: "to contribute to peace and
security by promoting collaboration among nations through education, science and culture in
order to further universal respect for justice, for the rule of law and for the human rights and
fundamental freedoms which are affirmed for the peoples of the world, without distinction of race,
sex, language or religion, by the Charter of the United Nations".
In order to work towards the achievement of these goals, the UNESCO was initially granted the
following functions, defined under the article I of its Constitution:
Collaborate in the work of advancing the mutual knowledge and understanding of
peoples, through all means of mass communication and to that end recommend such
international agreements as may be necessary to promote the free flow of ideas by word
and image;
Give fresh impulse to popular education and to the spread of culture: Maintain, increase
and diffuse knowledge.
Today, the agenda of the UNESCO is aimed at the advancement towards the Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs) established at the 70th Session of the United Nations General
Assembly:
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
3
To advance towards these aims, the UNESCO acts through five major programs:
education, natural sciences, social/human sciences, culture and communication/information.
The Organization operates by cooperating with all sorts of actors, including States, Non-
Governmental Organizations. The UNESCO is represented worldwide through field offices,
whether they are national, multi-national or regionalIn practice, UNESCO means of actions
includes, but are not limited to:
The creation of international 3 types of legal instruments:
International Conventions, which are subject to ratification, acceptance or accession by States.
They define rules with which the States undertake to comply. They will require a two-third majority
to be adopted.
Recommendations to Member States, which are not subject to ratification, acceptance or
accession by States and in the General Conference formulates “principles and norms for the
international regulation of any particular question and invites Member States to take whatever
legislative or other steps may be required”. They only require a simple majority vote.
Declarations, which are rarely-used and extremely formal and solemn tools that are also not
subject to ratification, acceptance or accession by States. They aim at promoting, in exceptional
UNESCO
4
circumstances, general principles acknowledged by the Members of the General Assembly. They
only require a simple majority vote.
The establishment and financing of programmes of cooperation
The establishment and communication of international guidelines and standards
What is expected of delegates for this agenda: It is important for every delegate to be able to understand the scope and powers of the UNESCO
as it will guide their discussion towards solutions to be implemented to the issues that will be
discussed in this committee.
Delegates are also urged to study previous UN resolutions and more specifically UNESCO
resolutions, to understand the process and format of such MUNs, and the scope of solutions.
This Study Guide was made in order to provide delegates with a basic knowledge of the topics
that will be discussed. However, it is necessary that delegates commit to personal researches,
including, but not limited to the additional readings and sources provided in this document.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
5
Topic A: Safeguarding cultural heritage in conflict zones
Introduction:
As mentioned previously, the protection and promotion of Culture is considered by the UNESCO
as a fundamental pillar of its goal towards the establishment of Peace. The notion of Cultural
heritage can be broadly defined as “pieces of cultural expression or information inherited from the
past of mankind”, and will be legally defined later in this document. The protection of such
heritage is considered as a key mission of the UNESCO. The protection of these sites must be
conciliated with the needs for economic, touristic, urban and social development that are also core
issues for the UNESCO and its member states.
As it will be detailed later in this document, the UNESCO has established a certain number of lists
and status for Cultural heritage sites. The map hereunder provides us with an idea of the
important number of protected cultural sites across the world.
UNESCO
6
Map of Cultural Heritage Sites in the world. Source: Screenshot of the interactive map by the UNESCO
The issue of protection of cultural heritage is even more difficult to be dealt with in time of conflict,
given the instability and destruction that come with conflicts. The core point of discussion in this
topic should be the protection of tangible cultural considering the fact that intangible cultural
heritage such as artistic performances is less threatened by conflict, being less subject to
irreparable damages. Tangible cultural heritage, as Cultural sites or artefacts, on the other hand,
are subject to a certain number of grave and beyond repair damages during conflicts, due to
direct effects of the conflicts, such as destructions caused by weapons, which have come to be
more destructive than ever with the systematic use of shelling in modern conflicts. Irreparable
damages are also caused by an indirect effect of conflicts: the instability of states and territories
is a fertile ground for the looting of cultural sites, which results in irreparable damages to such
cultural properties.
It is therefore the responsibility of the UNESCO to provide member states and actors of cultural
protection with the necessary means to protect cultural heritage even in times of instability and
lack of information.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
7
Legal aspects:
Definition of armed conflict: The Geneva Conventions defines armed conflict in multiple ways, depending on the situation:
The Common article 2 to the Geneva Conventions of 1949 defines “armed conflict” as:
“cases of declared war or of any other armed conflict which may arise between two or
more of the High Contracting Parties, even if the state of war is not recognized by one of
them”; “cases of partial or total occupation of the territory of a [State party to the Geneva
Convention], even if the said occupation meets with no armed resistance".
Are also considered armed conflicts, “conflicts not of an international character occurring
in the territory of one of the High Contracting Parties" as stated in the Common Article 3
of the same Convention.
Are also considered armed conflicts, conflicts "which take place in the territory of a High
Contracting Party between its armed forces and dissident armed forces or other organized
armed groups which, under responsible command”, in application of the article 1 of
Additional Protocol II to the Geneva Convention.
The protection of cultural heritage:
The International legislation regarding the issue of protection of cultural property in time of conflict
is mainly stated in The Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed
Conflict of 1954. It is strongly advised for each delegate to read the integral convention in order to
get a global legal knowledge of the topic, though, a certain number of important features of this
Convention will be explained below:
The article 1 of the convention broadly defines “cultural property” as:
(a) movable or immovable property of great importance to the cultural heritage of every people,
such as monuments of architecture, art or history, whether religious or secular; archaeological
UNESCO
8
sites; groups of buildings which, as a whole, are of historical or artistic interest; works of art;
manuscripts, books and other objects of artistic, historical or archaeological interest; as well as
scientific collections and important collections of books or archives or of reproductions of the
property defined above;
(b) buildings whose main and effective purpose is to preserve or exhibit the movable cultural
property defined in sub-paragraph such as museums, large libraries and depositories of archives,
and refuges intended to shelter, in the event of armed conflict, the movable cultural property
defined in sub-paragraph [...]
The article 3 of the convention sets forth the obligation for contracting States to take all measures
that would appear reasonable, in time of Peace, to ensure the protection of “cultural property” in
the possible times of war to come.
The article 4 of this convention se the basic legal ground of the obligation of States parties to the
Convention to respect such “cultural property”, by stating that :
1. The High Contracting Parties (i.e. States parties to the Convention) undertake to respect cultural
property situated within their own territory as well as within the territory of other High Contracting
Parties by refraining from any use of the property and its immediate surroundings or of the
appliances in use for its protection for purposes which are likely to expose it to destruction or
damage in the event of armed conflict; and by refraining from any act of hostility, directed against
such property.
[...]
3. The High Contracting Parties further undertake to prohibit, prevent and, if necessary, put a stop
to any form of theft, pillage or misappropriation of, and any acts of vandalism directed against,
cultural property. They shall refrain from requisitioning movable cultural property situated in the
territory of another High Contracting Party.
4. They shall refrain from any act directed by way of reprisals against cultural property.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
9
The article 8 provides that refuges intended to provide protection to movable cultural property
may receive a status of special protection, subject to the conditions that those sites:
(a) are situated at an adequate distance from any large industrial centre or from any important
military objective constituting a vulnerable point, such as, for example, an aerodrome,
broadcasting station, establishment engaged upon work of national defence, a port or railway
station of relative importance or a main line of communication;
(b) are not used for military purposes.
The application and withdrawal of this statute of special protection is contained in the articles 9,
10 and 11 of the Convention.
The article 16 and 17 of the Chart, which composes the Chapter V of the Convention, establish a
distinctive emblem used to notify the existence of cultural property in various cases (see the full
text of the convention for more details).
Distinctive emblem for the protection of cultural property, as defined in the Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of
Armed Conflict
Various UNESCO acts and decisions have created special statuses that provide special protection
to a certain number of categories of cultural properties. For example, the Convention Concerning
the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage (1972):, adopted in Paris from 17 October
to 21 November 1972, by the UNESCO at its seventeenth session, which came into force on the
17th of December 1975 and is currently ratified by 192 states
UNESCO
10
(http://www.unesco.org/eri/la/convention.asp?KO=13055&language=E), has established the
World Heritage List, that offers special protection to sites that are of “outstanding universal value
“and meet one out of 10 criteria set by the Convention. (http://whc.unesco.org/en/criteria/).
Logo of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) World Heritage Committee
As mentioned previously, cultural properties are also threatened by the illicit looting of works of
art. Such lootings are prohibited by a certain number of International Conventions, including The
Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of
Ownership of Cultural Property (1970) and the UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally
Exported Cultural Objects (1995).
Here is a list of other relevant treaties and declarations that should help delegates in order to
expand their legal knowledge about the issue:
The Convention for the Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural Heritage (2003)
The UNESCO Declaration concerning the Intentional Destruction of Cultural heritage
(2003)
The Convention on the Protection and Promotion of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions
(2005)
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
11
Case study: Syria
Quick overview of the situation of the Syrian conflict: Since 2011, Syria is entangled in a civil war conflict that –according to the United Nations and Arab
League envoy to Syria– has killed approximately 400,000 people. If you need to know more
about the current situation in Syria, please find links to recommended article in the Additional
readings section below.
Syrian cultural heritage:
With its rich and ancient multi-cultural history, Syria has an incredibly rich and various cultural
and architectural heritage. This heritage includes architectural sites from the Antiquity (byzantine
and roman period mostly), and also an important number of sites for the history of Christianity
and Islam. There are 6 sites in Syria that are inscribed in the World Heritage list.
UNESCO
12
The impact of the conflict over Syrian Cultural Heritage:
A map of the threats to Syrian cultural heritage sites. Source: Humanitarian Information Unit, U.S Department of State. (Please click on the picture to
access the full-sized map online.)
The Syrian Civil War that rages in the country currently has been the theatre of operations of the
systematic use of shelling by all parties to the conflict, including the use of shelling over sites of
important cultural value, such as the city of Aleppo. Furthermore, this war has also been an
occasion for the world to witness intentional vandalizing of high cultural value site. It also seems
important to mention the systematic destruction and looting of major cultural sites such as the
city of Palmyra by some parties to the conflict. The growing use of satellite imagery has been a
key factor in identifying the extent of the damage of the war.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
13
According to the Observatory of Syrian culture, there is evidence that the World Heritage
properties have been and are being used for military purposes, and subjected to direct shelling
and targeted explosions, as well as extensive illicit excavations, construction violations and
temporary human occupation. In many cases, local Syrian communities are playing an important
role in efforts to protect their cultural heritage and fight illegal excavations. All six sites in Syria
that are on the World Heritage List have suffered damages during the conflict.
UNESCO initiatives to protect Syrian Cultural Heritage:
The UNESCO, with the financial support of the European Union, created in 2014 the Observatory
of Syrian Cultural Heritage. It is based in UNESCO office in Beirut, Lebanon. This organ aims at
raising international awareness over the question of the destruction of Syrian cultural heritage and
gathering the effort of the various state, non-state and international actors that since the
beginning of the conflict, are trying to monitor, prevent and stop this disaster.
UNESCO is implementing a three-part approach in order to fulfil these goals, by actions such as:
Monitoring and assessing the cultural heritage situation in Syria through updated and
continued knowledge and documentation shared by UNESCO, its partners and all
stakeholders involved in safeguarding Syria's cultural heritage, which are widely
disseminated on the Observatory of Syrian Cultural Heritage. This platform provides
information on damages and looting of sites and structures, as well as information on on-
going projects and initiatives to protect and safeguard cultural heritage. In parallel, a
database of experts and available documentation on cultural heritage in Syria are being
constantly updated to create optimal conditions for post-conflict recovery activities.
Mitigating the destruction and loss of Syrian cultural heritage through national and
international awareness-raising efforts. A multimedia awareness-raising campaign, using
international, regional and national media and social networks, and will include the
dissemination of video clips, a documentary and a publication on Syrian cultural heritage.
UNESCO
14
Educational activities on cultural heritage aimed specifically at children and educators will
be developed in the coming months.
Protecting and safeguarding Syrian cultural heritage through enhanced technical
assistance and capacity-building for national stakeholders and beneficiaries, by:
o providing technical support for the establishment of a police database of looted
artefacts;
o training police forces and customs officers in Syria and adjacent countries to fight
illicit trafficking of cultural property (and on the specific tools available to facilitate
and improve the implementation of the 1970 UNESCO Convention);
o training national stakeholders to protect movable heritage and museums during
and after the conflict;
o providing technical assistance and training for the protection of built cultural
heritage and planning conservation and restoration works in view of the recovery
phase;
o training of national stakeholders concerning the core concepts and mechanisms of
the 2003 Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage; and
o specialized training of national stakeholders, civil society organizations and
communities concerning the creation of inventories for intangible cultural heritage.
The UNESCO initiative has yet not permitted to fully protect important Syrian sites from
destruction during the current conflict.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
15
Core issues to discuss: How can existing conventions and guidelines on the protection of cultural heritage con be
improved to ensure a more complete protection?
How can the monitoring of cultural destructions be improved in the future?
How can cultural property be protected in new forms of conflict such as the fight against
terrorism?
How to improve enforcement of previously created mechanisms of protection?
Additional readings: UNESCO Website about cultural initiatives
Legal conventions mentioned above (you will be able to find most of these documents
following this link)
More about the situation in Syria:
o About the current Syrian conflict :
o http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-26116868;
http://www.understandingwar.org/sites/default/files/November18%20EDITS%2
0COT.pdf
Website of the UNESCO Syrian Observatory
Sources: http://en.unesco.org/
https://www.icrc.org/eng/assets/files/other/opinion-paper-armed-conflict.pdf
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Distinctive_emblem_for_cultural_property.svg
http://whc.unesco.org/en/statesparties/sy
https://en.unesco.org/syrian-observatory/
https://eca.state.gov/files/bureau/syria_culturalsites_2013apr11_hiu_u771_1.pdf
https://en.unesco.org/syrian-observatory/damage-assesment-reports
UNESCO
16
http://unosat-maps.web.cern.ch/unosat-
maps/SY/CE20130604SYR/Draft_UNOSAT_A3_CE20130604SYR_Palmyra_SY_30032016_L
andscape.pdf
http://www.unesco.org/new/en/safeguarding-syrian-cultural-heritage/
https://en.unesco.org/syrian-observatory/emergency-safeguarding-syrian-cultural-heritage-
project
https://en.unesco.org/syrian-observatory/emergency-safeguarding-syrian-cultural-heritage-
project
https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/vwTreaties1949.xsp
https://en.unesco.org/syrian-observatory/built-heritage
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
17
Topic B: Access to education and health care in conflict and post-conflict zones
Introduction: Access to education and Healthcare are both considered as fundamental Human Rights by the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights under its articles 25 and 26 and by many other
international conventions such as the International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural
Rights. The aim of this document is to present the various reasons threatening those basic Human
Rights in times of conflict.
Conflicts often lead to a drop of literacy and health educators of the affected population, as the
result of many factors. During a conflict, structure of the affected state is threatened and therefore
is its capacity to perform its duties towards citizens, such as education or healthcare. Actors of
conflicts often deliberately restrict access to health and education during times of war, i.e. by
shelling, looting or transforming schools and hospitals as military basis. Health and education
workers are also particularly vulnerable during time of conflict, as they can become targets of the
actors of the conflict, or even be kidnapped and forced to work for the interest of their abductors.
The breach in the access to such services in time of conflict leads to obstacles in the peace-
process. Indeed, the damage undertaken by education and healthcare system and facilities in
time of war is usually so grave that it takes years and international assistance for such services to
be operational to their pre-conflict scale. Furthermore, as stated by Jo Boyden and Paul Ryder,
the same school system to which access is being threatened in time of war is the key to the return
of Peace in the State. A parallel must be drawn between this paradox of education and conflict
and the access to healthcare in conflict and post-conflict zones. Indeed, and especially in
UNESCO
18
developing countries, the access to healthcare is a factor to the stability of the State, necessary
for maintaining peace.
The issue that should be addressed by the committee during its session is the improvement of
current framework in such fields in order not only to be able to protect civilians in times of conflict,
but also to be able to work towards a more efficient process of Peace-building.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
19
Definition of key terms:
Peace-building: “activities undertaken on the far side of conflict to reassemble the
foundations of peace and provide the tools for building on those foundations something
that is more than just the absence of war.” (Barhimi Report, 2000)
Humanitarian assistance: Aid that seeks, to save lives and alleviate suffering of a crisis
affected-population. Humanitarian assistance must be provided in accordance with the
basic humanitarian principles of humanity, impartiality and neutrality.( RELIEFWEB
glossary of Humanitarian term )
Education can be defined as the act or process of imparting or acquiring particular
knowledge or skills. It appears important to precise that a broadly accepted distinction
exist between levels of education, such as primary, secondary and tertiary education, that
are distinguished by both the depth and specialization of the teaching provided. The
UNESCO had previously set as a goal for 2015 that all children should have access to
primary education.
Healthcare: The providing of medical services through professional medical services in
order to prevent and treat diseases or injuries. Once again, it appears important to
establish a distinction between levels of Healthcare, which ranges from primary healthcare
to tertiary healthcare, which levels are distinguished by the specialization of the healthcare
provided and institutions.
For a definition of armed conflict, please report to the definition provided in the legal
framework section of topic A.
UNESCO
20
The emergence of new threats linked to the evolution of the notion of conflict:
In order to define the context of the issue in today’s world, it seems important to take a look at
the impact of new forms of conflicts over access to healthcare and education. Apart from the
previously mentioned change is the nature of weapons in conflicts and the hazards linked to it, a
certain number of issues must be underlined.
As stated by Kaldor in 2013, new wars tend to contribute to the dismantling of state over issues
of ethnic, linguistic and religious identity. These new forms of war are even more dangerous for
access to basic Human needs for civilians, as they tend to exist in form of guerrilla fights in
populated areas rather than in organized military action. Furthermore, new forms of war tend to
be even more threatening to the stability of the state, by their nature. Indeed, the motivation of
armed groups in such conflicts is rather to gain more control than the others over resources
available, in opposition to the traditional form of War opposing states over a particular territory
or resource.
On the top of this dismantlement of the state, new conflict also tends to involve civilians more
than ever, especially in the case of children soldiers. The issue of children soldiers require by itself
an adapted response in order for the educational system to be able to reintegrate former children
soldiers into the peaceful society.
Access to education and Healthcare as weapons: As mentioned earlier, during conflicts, and especially during modern forms of conflict such as
guerrilla conflicts known today, the educational or healthcare system can be used as weapons by
armed groups.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
21
For example, the control over humanitarian and medical supply is an issue in various current
conflicts, such as the conflicts in Ukraine or Yemen. The misappropriation of medical supplies
intended for the protection of civilians by armed groups for both commercial and combat
supplying must be considered as a core issue to address regarding healthcare in conflict.
As mentioned previously, education is a key factor to
rebuild society after a period of conflict, as it can be a
vector to transmit peace in the collective consciences
after a period of internal conflict.
In examples such as the war against Communism in the
late 1980s in Afghanistan, the school system was used
to convey images of war to children, leading to the
establishment of war as a durable process in the
collective conscience, and therefore creating obstacles to
the Peace-building process.
It therefore seems crucial to dissociate education and healthcare from the conflicts, and to view
access to basic human Rights as tool for Peace-building and reestablishment of a stable state
and society.
The importance of transition towards durable institutions: It is important to underline the key role played by humanitarian interventions and therefore by
humanitarian NGOs in the issues of access to healthcare and education in such contexts. Yet, it
is also important that if Humanitarian assistance is necessary to respond to immediate civilians
needs in the fields of education and healthcare, it also important to restore the systems of
education and healthcare to their pre-conflict level in order to ensure the soundness of the State
and the establishment of a durable and peaceful society.
Militarized schoolbooks distributed in Afghanistan the late
1980s and early 1990s. Source: National Army Museum.
UNESCO
22
Graph
explaining the process of transition towards sustainable development in humanitarian intervention. Source: Author, derived from Derick W. Brinkerhoff,
the Health Systems 20/20 project, USAID
In both the case of healthcare and education, if the access to primary levels of such needs appears
as a necessary first step for humanitarian assistance, it seems important to underline that in order
to restore the stability of the State and the society, it is also necessary to be able to provide
civilians with access to secondary and tertiary education and healthcare, which are key tools
towards the establishment of a peaceful and functioning society. Currently, the international
programmes have mainly tried to deal with the access to primary needs, as witnessed by the
Millennium Goal of access to primary education (2000-2015), but as mentioned by many authors
and actors of peace-building, the necessity to improve and develop this access is a more-than-
ever pressing issue.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
23
Legal aspects:
The United Nations adopts the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights (1948) in
which the right of all children to education is protected.
Geneva Conventions of 1949 and the Protocol Additional to the Geneva
Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of Armed
Conflicts provide a framework for the respect and protection of sick, wounded, and
shipwrecked military and civilian medical personnel, units, and transports. Common Article
3 and the Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 relating to the
Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts offers protection for the victims
of Non-international conflicts.
The Convention on the Rights of the Child of 1889 posed the principle of universal primary
education.
The World Declaration on Education for All and Framework for Action to Meet Basic
Learning Needs of 1990 emphasizes the role of the resolution of conflicts in the access to
basic education.
UNICEF introduced in 1996 its 10-point Anti War Agenda that emphasize the need for
protection of children in times of conflict and the role of education in conflict prevention.
The United Nations Security Council adopted its 1998th resolution in 2011, making attacks
on schools an offense to the monitoring and reporting mechanism on children in armed
conflict established by its Resolution 1612 (2005).
Proposed means of action and points of reflexion:
Establishment of a combined guide of good practice regarding the protection of access to
Healthcare and Education in conflict and post-conflict zone.
Creation of a monitoring mechanism regarding the access to Education and Healthcare in
conflict and post-conflict zones.
Establishment of a guideline regarding the improvement of cooperation between
international, states and non-state actors
UNESCO
24
Addressing the issue of the creation of aid funds for actors involved in the improvement of
the situation.
Engaging a reflexion about the involvement of children in decision-making about
humanitarian interventions in conflict zones.
How can not only primary healthcare and education, but also higher levels be protected
in times of war?
Block positions:
As a first step towards understanding of the position of their country, it is advised for delegate to
acquire knowledge about the state of the healthcare and education system of the represented
country. In order to acquire such knowledge, the World Health Organization ranking of health
systems and the results of the Programme for International Student Assessment established by
the OECD could be good starting points, but an examination of the Global Education Monitoring
Report 2016 should be considered too.
In the matter of access to education and Healthcare, it is important to keep in mind that most
States present in this committee agree on the principle of access to education and healthcare,
countries are divided on the importance to give to such issues and the means to use to realize
such goals.
For what is considered in the international as Most Developed Countries like the European Union
or the United States of America, the access to education and healthcare is a fundamental issue
and the stability or these States allow them to have what can be considered as among the best
healthcare and education institutions. More specifically, the European Union member States have
agreed on Education & Training 2020, a strategic framework and discussion forum that aims at
improving cooperation in the fields of education in order to fulfil ambitious objectives of literacy
and access to education levels. Therefore, it is expected from those countries in this committee to
push for the establishment of ambitious policies regarding the protection of access to Human
Rights in conflict.
PRAGUE MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017
25
For countries considered as developing countries like China and Russia, the situation must be
qualified. Indeed, if the quality of education and healthcare is rising in BRICS countries, the access
to those services can still not be considered as exemplar. Those countries will be expected to
underline the difficulties faced by the establishment of ambitious policies regarding healthcare
and education.
The position of what can be considered Least Developed Countries and countries in situation of
armed conflict represented in the committee (i.e Ukraine or Syrian Arab Republic) is expected to
be way less optimistic towards the protection of access to education and healthcare in conflict.
Indeed, those countries, being directly confronted to state instability and to conflict situations,
have more difficulties to provide their citizens with such needs. Therefore, those countries tend to
raise the question of the feasibility of the establishment of international policies in their countries,
taking in consideration the lack of financing they are able to allow to education or healthcare in
the context of conflicts and less favourable economical situation.
UNESCO
26
Further readings: The hidden crisis: armed conflict and education, report of the UNESCO, 2011
Impact of Conflict on Children’s Health and Disability, Background paper prepared for the
Education for All Global Monitoring Report 2011
Framework for education 2030, UNESCO
Global Education Monitoring report 2016
Relevant International Treaties mentioned above should be read and understood by
delegates.
Sources: International Review of the Red Cross (2013), 95 (889), 167–187. Violence against health care, a
Human Rights approach to health care in conflict, Katherine H. A. Footer and Leonard S.
Rubenstein.
Rohini Jonnalagadda Haar and Leonard S. Rubenstein, Health in Postconflict and Fragile States,
2012, by the United States Institute of Peace.
http://www.who.int/bulletin/volumes/90/1/12-030112/en/
http://www.un.org/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=S/RES/1998%20(2011)
Implementing the Right to Education in Areas of Armed Conflict, Jo Boyden with Paul Ryder, June
1996, Department of International Development, Queen Elizabeth House, University of Oxford
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AcKoKsHypTY
Reports A/63/881–S/2009/304, A/64/866–S/2010/386 and A/67/499-S/2012/746 of the
Secretary General to the United Nations
Kadlor M, In Defence of New Wars, Stability: International Journal of Security and Development.