practical rf measurement techniques & probing tools for ... · pdf fileılee is the...

74
Hosted by: Rohde & Schwarz and Interference Technology Presented by: Lee Hill, SILENT Solutions LLC Dates & Locations Thursday, March 10 – Austin, TX Tuesday, March 15 – Irvine, CA Thursday, March 17 – Milpitas, CA Tuesday, March 22 – Livonia, MI Thursday, March 24- Chelmsford, MA Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for EMC Troubleshooting

Upload: truongnhu

Post on 06-Feb-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Hosted by: Rohde & Schwarz and Interference TechnologyPresented by: Lee Hill, SILENT Solutions LLC

Dates & LocationsThursday, March 10 – Austin, TXTuesday, March 15 – Irvine, CAThursday, March 17 – Milpitas, CATuesday, March 22 – Livonia, MIThursday, March 24- Chelmsford, MA

Practical RF MeasurementTechniques & Probing Tools forEMC Troubleshooting

Page 2: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Program Presenter: Mr. Lee Hill

ı Lee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee is a member of adjunct faculty at Worcester Polytechnic Institute (WPI) where he teaches graduate-level classes in EMC. He is also an EMC instructor at University of Oxford (England), and for the IEEE EMC Society’s annual Global University and EMC Fundamentals program.He earned his MSEE in electromagnetics from the Missouri University of Science and Technology EMC Laboratory under Dr.’s Tom Van Doren,Todd Hubing, and James Drewniak.

ı Contact Lee or his business partner Randal Vaughn for more information about SILENT Solutions EMC Design Reviews, Troubleshooting and Intensive Courses

www.silent-solutions.com Tel: +1 [email protected]

2© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 3: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Outline

ı Energy Coupling Mechanismsı Why CURRENT is important in typical regulatory noise problemsı Key PASSIVE Probe Characteristicsı Voltage Probesı Clamp-on Current Probesı Magnetic Field Probesı Electric Field Probesı Self contained Immunity Generator “active probes”ı Our Favorite Tools

ı Special Thanks to Dr. Tom Van Doren, Professor Emeritus, Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, Missouri University of Science & Technology, for use of his original source material contained in this section

PART 1: Probing Tools

3© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 4: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

WHAT Are We Trying To Do With A Probe?

LISTEN / FIND / MEASUREa noise quantity FROM an existing source

INDUCE / REPRODUCEa noise quantity INTO an existing victim

4© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 5: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

If We Have An Electrical Noise Problem,We Must Be Able to Find:

NoiseSource “Victim”Path

5© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 6: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Most “Radiated” Noise Problems Can Be Understood by Locating the Path of the Responsible Noise Current

Radiated EMISSIONSRadio Wave

E,H

Radiated Immunity

Currentdi/dt Antenna

Radio WaveE,H

Currentdi/dt Antenna

“transmitting”

“receiving”

Radiated Emission

Radiated IMMUNITY

6© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
DEMO
Page 7: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Most “Conducted” Noise Problems Can Be Understood by Locating the Path of the Responsible Noise Current

Conducted EMISSIONS

Measured Noise Voltage

Conducted Immunity

EUTNoise

Current

Noise Generator Current

Current driven into EUT

Conducted Emission

Conducted IMMUNITY

V+-

7© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
DEMO
Page 8: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

WHY Do We Use PROBES?

ı Pass a “stupid” EMI test; fix a problem that causes EMC regulatory test failure

ı Understand or fix a “functional” noise problem

ı Characterize an environment

ı Characterize a device

8© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 9: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

What Makes a Good EMC Probe?

ı BandwidthF1 < Frequency < F2

ı Sensitivity (Listening), Efficiency (Injecting)Small signal preamplifier (listening) or big signal amplifier (injecting) necessary?

ı Impedance Loading (of circuit under test)Does the probe disturb the (SSS, I,V) quantity being measured?

ı Field PerturbationDoes the probe disturb the field quantity being measured?

ı Impedance BalanceWhen trying to measure Idm or Vdm, does Icm increase?

ı Repeatable Positioningı Ruggedness

Usually the difference between purchased and homemadeı Costı Calibration

9© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 10: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

What Are We Going to Measure with Our Probe?Coupling

MechanismQuantity

MeasuredMeasuringProcess

ConductedVoltage (V) Resistive Divider

+ Amplifier

Current (I)Resistive Shunt (I=V/R )

Magnetic Coupling (Xfrmr)

Near FieldMagnetic Field (H) Magnetic Coupling

V=Mdi/dt ∝ dH/dt

Electric Field (E) Displacement CurrentI = CdV/dt ∝ dE/dt

Far Field EM Wave (E,H) AntennaVout= AF x |E|

10© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 11: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Voltage Probes (Listening to locate sources)

Radiated Emissions:

ı Evaluating Radiated Emissions at Aperture of Conductive Chassis byMeasuring Voltage Differences Across Seams, Apertures, Connector Pins

ı Finding Circuit Nodes with “Bonus Noise” (Unexpected RF sources)

11© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 12: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Problems with Passive Voltage Probes (Listening to locate sources)

Sources of Measurement Error:

ı To Reduce Error, minimize the “CRITICAL AREA”ı Maybe Can Reduce Error by Reducing Icm with ferrite beads around coax cable

A

B

VAB

“CRITICAL AREA”

dH/dt

Vmeasured+-

Icm

-

+

|Vmeasured| = VAB ± ω1MICM ± ω2∫∫H·ds

12© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 13: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Problems with PEOPLE Trying to Measure“Noisy Ground” or “Ground Plane Inductance” or “Voltage”Sources of Measurement Error:

v+ -

V depends on location of wiresand amount of flux wrapping the plane

Do we want a wide plane or narrow plane?

“Critical Area”is obvious

13© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 14: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive, Unbalanced X10 Voltage Probe Design

ı Inexpensive. Only 500 Ω Zin . Flat Freq. Response >> 1 GHz, ESD insensitive

SolderBrass Tube

Epoxy5 mmMax

450 ΩResistor

SemirigidCoaxCable

SMA Connector

To50 ΩLoad

14© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 15: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Voltage Probes (Listening to locate noise sources)Radiated Emissions:

ı Evaluating Radiated Emissions at Aperture of Conductive Chassis byMeasuring Voltage Differences Across Seams, Apertures, Connector Pins

APERTURE CONNECTOR PIN

ı Measuring voltage difference across many different seams or pins might identify the location of a dominant energy leakage

conductiveenclosure

50 Ω450 Ω

X10 Coax Probe

50 Ω

15© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 16: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Voltage Probes (Listening to locate noise sources)Radiated Emissions or E field (dv/dt) Source:

ı Evaluating Radiated Emissions at Aperture of Conductive Chassis byMeasuring Voltage Differences Across Seams, Apertures, Connector Pins

ı Finding Circuit Nodes with “Bonus Noise” (Unexpected RF sources)

Vmeasured ≈ Vnoise

when

50 Ω >>1/ωC

50ΩC

Equivalent Circuit

Vnoise

PCB

CoaxCable

CIC

DC Block50 Ω

16© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Demo
Page 17: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Active Voltage Probes (Listening to SIGNAL during NOISE Event)

PCB

Fiber

IC50 Ω Scope

ı Fiber optic analog or digital signal detector, hardened against RF, monitors critical EUT signal via fiber to active receiver.

ı For use during conducted immunity or radiated immunity or ESD tests.Measure health of intended signals with isolated sensor to avoidRF coupling via measurement wires.

Sensor ActiveReceiver

Induce Noise

17© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Demo
Page 18: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Using an Active Voltage Probe (Generator) to Induce Noise to Locate Victim

Electrostatic Discharge

ı Identifying the precise location of victim circuits that cause system level ESD failure

ı Finding Circuit Nodes with “Bonus Sensitivity” (Unexpected RF victims)

18© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 19: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Active Noise Probes (Generators) To Localize Victim Circuits Sensitive to ESDElectrostatic Discharge (ESD)Manual Injection Methods can be Tricky / Ineffective

ı Identifying the precise location of victim circuits that cause system level ESD failure

IC

Which IC / Trace Causes System ESD Failure?

PCB

ICIC

IC

IC

19© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 20: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Active Noise Probes (Generators) To Localize Victim Circuits Sensitive to ESDElectrostatic Discharge (ESD)

ı Identifying the precise location of victim circuits that cause system level ESD failure by using handheld generator with (contact + capacitance) connection

PCB

ICIC

IC

IC

Which IC / Trace Causes System ESD Failure?

PCB

ICIC

IC

IC1.2 kV, 1.8 nS min edgetime,single or 5 kHz

|E|

20© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 21: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Current Probes (Listening for CE or REInjecting for CI or “Simulated” RI)Clamp-on Current Probe

Shielded – We only want to detect dH/dt and thus the current (listening)We only want to deliver i(t) (injecting)

Loads

Inet = Icm

Net current Enclosed = Probe withElectric Fieldshield makesthis term = 0

=•∫ dlHconduction∫ •dSJ

displacement

∫ •+ dSDdtd

lListen Inject

21© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 22: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Current Probes (Listening for RE)

Clamp-on Current Probe

Under far field conditions, at a distance of R meters from a λ/2 dipole

𝐸𝐸 = 60 𝐼𝐼𝑅𝑅

where I = current (A) at center of dipole

I < 𝑅𝑅 |𝐸𝐸𝐸𝐸𝐸𝐸𝐸𝐸|𝑅𝑅

= 3𝐸𝐸 (100 𝜇𝜇𝜇𝜇/𝐸𝐸)60 Ω

= 5 µA (FCC Class B) @ 3m)

LoadsInet = Icm

22© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 23: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Current Probes (Listening for CE or REInjecting for CI or RI)Clamp-on Current Probe - Requires Electric Field Shielding

Magnetic Core

Electric Field Shield

Gap to block eddy currents

The wire under test can capacitivelycouple to the probe winding through the slot. This is usually minor atF< ~ 400 MHz.

Some folks use a foam “donut” to prevent cables from getting veryclose to the gap, causing loadingand measurement repeatabilityproblems.

23© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 24: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Current Probes (Listening for CE or RE,Injecting for CI or “Simulated” RI)

| I | = | V | / | ZT | IdB = VdB – ZT dB , VdB = IdB + ZT dB

For listening to noise current, we want a “sensitive” probe that delivers max V for a given Inoise so we want ZT to be ___.

For inducing a noise current, for a given available RF output, we want a probe that delivers max I for a given power so ZT = _____

Clamp-on Current Probe

IL (R=50 Ω)

+V-

Magnetic CoreHow do you likea 0 dB Probe?

24© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 25: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Current Probes

Clamp-on Current Probe – Simplified Equivalent Circuit of Output

L +V-

R = 50ΩSpec An.

+

- ( ) T22ZI

LR

MRIV =ω+

ω=

|ZT|

Freq.

For ωL << R, |ZT| = ωM

For ωL >> R, |ZT| = MR/L

25© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 26: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Magnetic H Field Probes (Listening for CE or RE, or Injecting H)

I

We can use a simple loop probe to:1) Detect the relative amplitude AND direction of time-changing current(nice if it’s calibrated)

2) Detect the relative amplitude of a time changing magnetic fielde.g., if we’re failing a magnetic field emissions test or lookingfor “leaky” inductive components.

dHVdt

=•∫ dlHconduction∫ •dSJ

+ V

- +-

+ -

V +-H

Coax Cable

26© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 27: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive Magnetic Field Probes

27

Where’s the Magnetic Flux?

R+

-

1 cm loop

> 1 cm aperture

The probes below can help find larger problems, such as noise exiting an enclosure slot, a big IC, or big connector. Not calibrated. Robust. F< 2 GHz

Why Not Use This?

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 28: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive and Active Magnetic Field Probes

28

For locating sources of radiated emissions, wireless self-interference

Passive: These can localize noise to aconnector pin or region of a small IC.Calibrated. 1 GHz ≤ F ≤ 10 GHzResolution ~ 1 to 2 mm

Active: These can localize noise to a via or BGA bump.Calibrated. 100 MHz ≤ F ≤ 6 GHzResolution ~ 200 um

H

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 29: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Use Passive H field Probes for Immunity Debug

29

Some Vendors Characterize Max Forward Power and Input Match

H

H

or

PCB

ICIC

IC

IC

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 30: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive E field Probes

30

How do these work? Where is the loop of currentthat drives the spectrum analyzer input?

50 ΩE

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Demo
Page 31: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Passive E field Probes

31

How do these work? Where is the loop of currentthat drives the spectrum analyzer input?

ZOZO

CP

Circuit emittingE-field

CI

V+

-E

VO-+

ZX

V α E;|I| = |ωCV| α E

ZCp Zo

I

|V O | = |OP

O

ZCj1VC Z

ω+ω

| α E

50 ΩE

ZX

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Demo
Page 32: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Use ACTIVE H and E field Probes With Internal Noise Generator for EFT, ESD Debug

32

Non-Contact. Handheld E or H. 1 pulse or 5 KHz. Edgetime < 5 nS

PCB

ICIC

IC

IC

H

H

or

E

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 33: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Pitfalls of Homemade Probes

ı H field loop probes and current probes must be shielded, otherwise; Confusing measurement results

May interact with human’s capacitance May interact with E, dv/dt of circuit under test

Poor spatial resolution – It’s tough to makereally tiny, shielded, homemade H-field probes.

ı Homemade probes are often uncalibrated Difficult to distinguish between “interesting” and “important” when multiple

sources exist. Large bandwidth of commercial probes is often tough to duplicate.

33© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 34: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Favorite Passive Current Probes

Fischer F-61Listening

1 MHz ≤ F ≤ 1 GHz

Fischer F-16Listening

10 Hz ≤ F ≤ 70 MHz

Fischer F-16Injection

10 kHz ≤ F ≤ 400 MHz

34© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 35: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Favorite Passive Near Field E + H Probes

Van Doren CompanyMFH-23MLF-11

40 MHz ≤ F ≤ 400 MHz3 kHz ≤ F ≤ 300 kHz Langer EMV-Technik

RF-R400-1RF-E 02RF-E-10

RF-U 2.5-2RF-B 3-2

F ≤ 6 GHzFinest Spatial Res.

Rohde & SchwarzHZ-15 Probe Set

ETS 1 and 3 cm loop probesF ≤ 1.5 or 2.3 GHz

35© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 36: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Favorite “Active” E + H Probes

“Pulsers”: P1 set, P23Noise Generators

All Made By Langer EMV-Technik

MFA Active H Field Probes For Listening

36© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 37: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Where to Buy the Tools

Places to buy the good stuff that SILENT uses:

Real-Time EMC Spectrum Analyzers and Test ReceiversRohde & Schwarz www.rohde-schwarz.com

Handheld E & H Probes, Noise Generators Langer EMV-Technik www.langer-emv.comVan Doren Company www.emc-education.com/

Clamp-on Current ProbesFischer Custom Communications www.fischercc.com

37© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 38: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

PART 2: RETURN LOSS – How Good Is That RF Cable, Adapter….

39© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 39: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Let’s Do Some RF Characterizations ofPassive and Active Two Port Devicesı Insertion Loss and Return Loss RF test cables RF adapters

ı Input impedance Match & Resonant Frequency Preamplifiers Antennas Filters

ı Broadband RF "Snapshots" Antennas LISNS

ı DO IT _ALMOST_ FOR “FREE” IF you already have access to aspectrum analyzer / test receiver with internal tracking generator.

39© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 40: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Outline

ı What are the different types of equipment we can use?

ı Advantages & disadvantages of each

ı Demonstrations of measurements

ı A few recommendations of equipment to get started

40© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 41: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Different Types Of Equipment We Can Use

ı PROS: "Gold Standard". If you have one, GREAT!

ı CONS: If you've never used one, lots of things to learn; calibration, measurement

techniques, S parameters.

If already have one at work, it is often the guarded, locked up machine that belongs to product design...don't touch! And you have to SHARE

41

VECTOR NETWORK ANALYZER

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 42: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Different Types Of Equipment We Can Use

ı Vintage, entry level used machine > $20k Rohde & Schwarz ZVL

ı The Amateur Radio Community has created a number of one and two port VNAs with impressive capability. Not serviceable, No NIST – traceable calibration possible Limited dynamic range above 500 MHz, depending on instrument Require external PC and software. A good toy to sneak in the budget and practice with.

42

VECTOR NETWORK ANALYZER

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 43: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Different Types Of Equipment We Can Use

ı Many EMC folks already have them Familiar Frequency domain data lets EMC engineer apply his/her

intuition about frequency response, attenuation, bandwidth, etc

ı Can't do precise port calibrations ESRP, ESR, ESPI and ESCI offer SOL - "open", "short", "load" Need to purchase external directional coupler

ı Factors that limit dynamic range to (only) 40 dB typical Directional coupler directivity (basic figure of merit) Quality of external 50 ohm reference affects dynamic range Quality of external “plumbing” including cables and adapters Somewhere above 1 GHz, we should abandon this idea and instead use a

real VNA. Dominant issues are: lack of precise reference, plane location, and the need for RF adapters

43

Test Receiver/Spectrum Analyzer withTracking Generator

TG Input

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 44: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Measurements

ı Insertion Lossı Return (reflection) Loss

44© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 45: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Insertion Loss, (“Through”, “Transmission”)

ı Easy, most people understandı May not be sensitive enough to detect problems with "low loss" devicesı DUT must have conducted input port and conducted output port

ı Not appropriate for source or load devices, e.g., "one port" such as preamplifier, near-field probe, antenna

ı SMALL measurement result, e.g. 0.1 dB, is GOOD

45

Input Output

50 ohm load Input

CalibratedRF Source

CalibratedRF Receiver

DUT

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 46: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Insertion Loss, (“Through”, “Transmission”)

ı Plotted versus frequency, in dB, requires two (in & out) RF ports at EUT

ı Scalar result, Doesn’t distinguish between reflected & absorbed power

46

A B

RF Source(TG)

RF Receiver(Spec. An)

0 dBcoupler

Step 2: Insert Device Under Test, then measure

Step 1: Normalize test cable / path to 0 dB

A B

CalibratedRF Source

CalibratedRF Receiver

DUT

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
How about attenuator?
Page 47: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Return (Reflection Loss) Testing

ı Not everybody knows how to do

ı Appropriate for one and two port devices

ı Great for one port devices

ı Reveals resonant behavior of DUTs

ı BIG measurement result is GOOD – usually minimum of 20 dB

47

RETURN (REFLECTION) LOSS

TestReceiver

TrackingGenerator Device Under TestDirectional

Coupler

Forward Power

Reflected Power

Freq.

20 dB

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 48: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Results of Return (Reflection) Loss Testing

ı Good match Incident power is absorbed at DUT (load), very little returns (reflects) to source.

GOOD Result = Big return loss, ≥20 dB

ı Bad match Most of incident power is REFLECTED at DUT, very little is absorbed,

most of incident power returns (reflects) back to source BAD Results = Small return loss,

ı Resonant networks show INCREASE in return loss at their favorite frequenciesı With TG/Spec An, Result is a SCALAR, with VNA, a VECTOR (S11)

TestReceiver

TrackingGenerator Device Under TestDirectional

Coupler

Forward Power

Reflected Power

49© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 49: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Results of Return (Reflection) Loss Testing

ı Return Loss defined as: -20Log(ρ)ı # of dB the reflected signal is less than ("below“) the incident signal.ı GOOD MATCH = BIG RETURN LOSS!

ı Very sensitive to small +/- changes above/below Zo;ı Return Loss = 40 dB, VSWR = 1.02 (nearly perfect match)ı Return Loss = 20 dB, VSWR = 1.22 (good match)

ΓL = Vreflected ρ φ

ranges from 0 to 1.0

=ZL- Zo

ZL+ Zo

=Vincident

50© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 50: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Results of Return (Reflection) Loss Testing

TestReceiver

TrackingGenerator Device Under TestDirectional

Coupler

Forward Power into DUT

Reflected Power from DUT

51© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 51: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Return Loss Testing: How to Do It

TestReceiver

DirectionalCoupler

TrackingGenerator

ı Step1: Establish maximum measurable RL using 50 ohm reference loadı Step 2: Replace reference load with Device Under Test, and measure RL

1) 50Ω load, 2) DUT

52© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 52: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Return Loss Testing: Measurement Demos

TestReceiver

DirectionalCoupler

TrackingGenerator

ı Good 50 ohm loadı 3 dB attenuatorı Different Unmarked 50 ohm “through”

terminations

1) 50Ω load, 2) DUT

53© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 53: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Return Loss Testing: Measurement Limitations

ı "Reference plane" poorly defined – Can’t separate DUT data from fixtureı Sensitivity of measurement directly proportional to directivity of

directional coupler – typically 30-40 dB for inexpensive onesı Accuracy of load termination used for load reference calibration

Network

50

50

50TG

Spec An

DUT

Directional Coupler

54© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 54: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Return Loss Testing: Recommended Equipment

ı "Test Receiver/Spectrum Analyzer + Tracking Generatorı Rohde & Schwarz – any of these ESL, ESPI, ESCI, ESRP, ESR, ESU

with tracking generator option installedı Directional Coupler ("bridge"); Narda 3020, Mini-Circuits ZFDC-10-2 ı Key parameter is directivity, the higher the better. Match frequency range

to your interestsı An expensive 50 ohm type "N' or "SMA" termination that "bottoms out"

your return loss measurement to the claimed directivity of your coupler

Network

50

50

50TG

Spec An

DUT

Directional Coupler

55© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ

Page 55: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Faster Hardware Troubleshooting of Intermittent […] Signals UsingReal-Time FFT Spectral Analysis

Hosted by: Rohde & Schwarz and Interference TechnologyPresented by: Lee Hill, SILENT Solutions LLC

Dates & LocationsThursday, March 10 – Austin, TXTuesday, March 15 – Irvine, CAThursday, March 17 – Milpitas, CATuesday, March 22 – Livonia, MIThursday, March 24- Chelmsford, MA

Page 56: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Outline

ı Why I’m excited about“Real Time” spectral analysis.“Persistence Mod”

ı Quick review of “EMI signals”

ı Demonstrations and Debug Tips

ı Please interrupt me with questions

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 56

Page 57: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Local Oscillator3.4-6.6 GHz

PreampPreselection

Digital Magic

DetectorsDisplayMarkers

Limit linesTrace evaluation

IF (RBW) Filters

Full RF Spectrum (9 kHz - 3 GHz)

Bandpass Filtered

RF Spectrum 2-8 MHz Mixed RF

+ and -

Attenuator

Old Style “Swept” Spectrum Analyzers or “Stepped” Tune ReceiversThe “old days”ı “Swept tuned” Spectrum Analyzerı “Step tuned” Receiverı Sequentially step or sweep a narrow window across the frequency axisı Good “intercept” with “continuous wave”, periodic signal ONLYı Significant “blind time” when sweeping or stepping

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 57

Page 58: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Old Style “Swept” Spectrum Analyzers or “Stepped” Tune ReceiversThe “old days”ı “Swept tuned” Spectrum Analyzerı “Step tuned” Receiverı Sequentially step or sweep a narrow window across the frequency axisı Good “intercept” with “continuous wave”, periodic signal ONLYı Significant “blind time” when sweeping or stepping

S OL W

Freq.narrow

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 58

Page 59: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

“FFT” , “Fast Fourier Transform”“Time Domain” InstrumentsNOW, with FFT (“time domain”)

ı Much FASTERı Measure lots of signal frequencies simultaneously

“in parallel”, over a WIDE CHUNK of the freq. axisı Calculate RBW instead of waiting for filter responseı Still some “blind time” to do processing (not “100% intercept”)ı And only 1 measurement at each frequency in each chunk

Freq.wide

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 59

Page 60: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

“Real Time” FFT

“Real – Time” FFT (“time domain”)ı FASTEST – dedicated measurement hardware for FFTı WIDE (up to 40 or 80 MHz) chunk of spectrumı Calculate RBW instead of waiting for filter responseı Zero “blind time” “100% intercept”ı Multiple measurements at each frequency in each chunkı Allows for generation and display of signal statistics, i.e.,

how often and how strong a signal is present at a given frequency

Freq.40 MHz

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 60

Page 61: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Review of Signals We’re Going to See

ı Definitions and buzzwords that EMC engineers like to use when discussing different types of noise

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 61

Page 62: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

To1/To

finite rise / fall time

EMI Signals – Funny Namesı Continuous (“CW”)ı Periodicı “Power Signals”

RBW wider than line spacingF

a) Measurement value increaseswith increased RBW

b) Cannot identify (resolve)individual lines

RBW narrower than line spacingF

a) Measurement valuedoes not change with RBW

b) Can identify (resolve)individual spectral lines

“Broadband” (SMPS, motor control, sparky) “Narrowband” (clocks, steady RF)

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 62

Page 63: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

With Permission Dr. T. Hubing, Clemson University

Theoretical, perfect Impulse Infinite Energy

Freq.Time

Single, real pulse

Finite Energy is spread out

Time Freq.40 MHz chunk in Real-Time FFT

EMI Signals – Funny NamesA Single Real Pulse “Broadband Discontinuous” (Ex. ESD)ı Measurement value increases with increased RBWı Finite Energy, Average power = 0ı Represent with Fourier Transform → Energy Spectrum

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 63

Page 64: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Let’s Watch 100% Signal InterceptThat’s Possible w/ “Real Time” FFT

1) Standard FFT, spectrum view

2) Real-Time FFT, spectrum view“100% (signal) intercept”

DEMONSTRATION OF Spark Noise Similar to ESD

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 64

Page 65: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

A Totally Different Way to View, Measure, Identify EMI Sourcesı With Real Time, many measurements / frequency, can generate statisticsı The trace color shows how often a signal occurs at a

specific frequency and amplitudeı Color = “Hit Rate” = how often signal occurs at particular frequency

Height = amplitude of signal at particular frequencyı A signal histogram versus frequencyı Descriptive terms: % occupancy, amplitude, frequency

Persistence Mode

F

Amplitude

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 65

Page 66: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Next, We Are Going to Watch Multiple Signals at the same time, as they occupy the SAME frequency

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 66

Page 67: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Demonstration of Real Time FFTDisplaying “Signal under Signal”ı “Signal under Signal”ı Two signals at same frequency, but

different amplitude different % occupancy (“100% = CW” = “White hot”)

ı PWM motor + motor controller (broadband)ı USB mouse (broadband + narrowband)ı 20 MHz digital clock on PCB (narrowband)

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 67

Page 68: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Demonstration of Real Time FFTDisplaying “Signal under Signal”

ı One Bluetooth Pair. Master + Slave

ı Measuring + displaying the radiated signal with antenna

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 68

Page 69: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Demonstration of Real Time FFTMeasuring Class D Audio Amp Noise ı Common-mode current on speakerphone USB cable.

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 69

Page 70: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

A Debug Technique Not Everyone Uses

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 70

Page 71: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Demodulation (not an FFT thing )

ı Why do we only “Look At” EMI?ı In the “Old Days”, everyone listened to EMIı Can distinguish between data, clocks, ambient signals, etc.

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 71

Page 72: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Summary – Old Technology

ı Previous generation spectrum analyzers and test receivers use “swept tuned” or “stepped tuned” architecture.

ı OK for measuring continuous (i.e., not intermittent) periodic signals in narrow spans. When you ALWAYS know when (time) and where (frequency) the signal is.

ı Cannot visualize pulse spectrumsı Cannot visually distinguish between two or more broadband signals in a single

piece of spectrum ı Cannot visualize narrowband EMI signals “under” a larger broadband signalı “Blind” during large parts of sweep or step & dwell timeı Challenging to use for EMI debug expect for “trivial” signals like narrowband

clocks that have 100% occupancy

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 72

Page 73: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Summary: Real-Time FFT

ı “Real Time” FFT with persistence mode gives us anew, powerful way to visualize EMI signals that werepreviously tough or just impossible to display:

Broadband and intermittent (pulse) signals Multiple broadband signals occupying the same spectrum Multiple broadband and narrowband signals occupying the same spectrum

ı The “visualization” that is possible with Real-Time FFT is difficult to describe in words, you have to see it

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 73

Page 74: Practical RF Measurement Techniques & Probing Tools for ... · PDF fileıLee is the Founding Partner of SILENT Solutions LLC, an EMC and RF design firm he established in 1992. Lee

Summary Take-Aways

ı Real-Time FFT provides:

100% signal intercept over a 40 or 80 MHz frequency span. FFT machines without real-time hardware will “miss” signals

A new intuitive way to VISUALIZE EMI signals Especially non-periodic, “blinky” and broadband signals

(e.g., SMPS, motor control, & sparky signals - different from digital clocks)

The ability to clearly display “signal under signal” situations: Multiple broadband signals occupying the same frequency span Weak narrowband signals “underneath” larger broadband signals Multiple, co-located RF emitters that occupy the same frequency span

such as Bluetooth, WiFi, Near Field Communication (NFC)

© 2016 ROHDE&SCHWARZ 74