powerpoint presentation on directing the change itself when we need to focus on: engaging/listening...
TRANSCRIPT
11/1/2018
1
Motivational Interviewing
A client centered, goal-oriented way to enhance motivation and
to help clients move from “maybe I should” to “I did.”
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP
www.debbiegranick.com
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
We like to think if we…2
TELL THEM
ENCOURAGE THEM
TEACH THEM
BEG THEM
SCARE THEM
CONFRONT THEM
THEY WILL CHANGE. BUT THEY WON’T.
PERHAPS, THERE IS ANOTHER WAY.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Goals for Today3
INTRODUCING THE CONCEPT
Introduce the concept of motivational interviewing
as it relates to behavior change.
UNDERSTANDING THE ”SPIRIT OF “MI”
Understand the “spirit of MI” and practice concepts
of MI that move people towards sustained
behavior change:
• Engaging with the client
• Evoking ambivalence
• Rolling with resistance
• Empowering success
PRACTICING THE CORE CONCEPTS OF MI
Learn and practice the core interviewing skills of MI:
• Asking
• Affirming
• Reflecting
• Summarizing
11/1/2018
2
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
What is Motivational Interviewing?4
Motivational Interviewing is built on
the concepts that:
We believe what we hear ourselves say.
Motivation is intrinsic and based on our
individual priorities, goals, values.
Humans, when they feel deeply and
genuinely accepted for who they are, find
the freedom and courage to change and
move forward instead of to entrench and
defend.
Four clinician values are important to
support client change: compassion,
collaboration, acceptance, and evocation.
Bob Newhart – Stop It (Mad TV) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aAhA7KfbJgg
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
“People are generally better persuaded by
the reasons they have themselves
discovered than by those that enter the
minds of others.”
Blaise Pascal, Mathematician and Theologian, 1623-1662
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
MI Recognizes Key Elements of
Behavior Impact Behavior Change6
There are pros and cons to every
behavior.
We choose behavior based on
assessing these pros and cons
consciously or unconsciously.
Ambivalence is the unresolved conflict
between the pros and cons and leads
to continuing a certain behavior.
Ongoing ambivalence is the most
significant road block to change.
Ambivalence is resolved when re-
evaluation of the values that inform
and propel our actions pushes us in a
new direction.
11/1/2018
3
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
The Process of Change7
Good MI guides towards change. A
common mistake is to focus
prematurely on directing the change
itself when we need to focus on:
Engaging/listening to understand
client values and readiness for
change.
Evoking and empathizing with
ambivalence that only the client can
resolve.
Empowering the client to
autonomously initiate change.
Precontemplation
Contemplation
PreparationAction
Maintenance
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Four Concepts to the ”Spirit” of MI8
Motivational Interviewing is a spirit, an essence, a
perspective on partnering with people to help them identify
their path, resolve the roadblocks on that path, and find their
way forward towards the life they desire. How? We….
Engage Evoke Roll Empower
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Motivational Interviewing
Addresses Barriers to Change9
• Fear
• Ambivalence
• Resistance
• Lack of confidence
• Empathy and engagement
• Evoking and valuing ambivalence
• Rolling with vs arguing against resistance
• Guiding and empowering clients to see their strengths and skills
Barriers
What differentiates MI from other therapies is the focus,
the “spirit” of MI which continually comes back to
EVOCATION of client values, goals, priorities, fears, belief,
strengths, and commitments which guide their
life decisions.
This is the HOOK of MI.
Strategy
11/1/2018
4
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
“An MI approach honors people’s autonomy, trusting
in their own natural wisdom and desire to grow in a
positive direction.” Miller and Rollnick, 2013
MI Spirit | Engagement
“If you treat an individual
as he is, he will stay as
he is, but if you treat him
as if he were what he
ought to be and could be,
he will become what he
ought to be and could be.”Johann Wolfgang Von Goeth
Build rapportEnsure comfort and a sense of collaboration
Listen to client priorities and
motivation
Set a mutual agenda
Give hope
Tools for Engagement
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Engagement Done Well11
YOU
Hi Mr. Jones. Can I call you Mr. Jones?
CLIENT
Sure.
YOU
Thank you for coming today and dealing with
this required paperwork. We appreciate that.
CLIENT
No problem.
YOU
I have your referral from the Judge, but before
we go into that, would it be okay if we started
fresh by you helping me understand what
brings you here and how you hope I can help
you?
CLIENT
I don’t know why I’m here. The judge made me
come. I guess I hope you can help me get off
probation.
YOU
I see. You would like to get off probation but
are unclear why you were sent to us.
CLIENT
Yeah.
YOU
Would it be okay if I explained what our
agency does and how we have helped other
people with that goal of getting off probation in
the past?
CLIENT
Sure.
YOU
We are a job skills organization and work with
people who have ideas of what kind of job they
might want but have had a hard time finding
that in the past. Job hunting is a frustrating
process and many people really struggle with
having to expose a felony. Has that been
something you’ve had to deal with?
CLIENT
Yes. Every time I talk to someone, they shut
me out as soon as they see that checked box.
YOU
Yep. It’s really hard to make a new start.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Engagement Done Well12
CLIENT
I’m just trying to do right by my lady and my
kids.
YOU
You sound really committed to success and
like someone who really values his family.
CLIENT
I am. I cannot get locked up again. I miss my
kids too much.
YOU
I’d like to help you stay with your family. If I
understood more about the kinds of jobs that
interest you, perhaps we could make a plan
that you think could work to set up some
interviews. And I can talk with you about how
we help find employers willing to hire people
with criminal records.
CLIENT
That sounds good.
YOU
Great. Sometimes people have a lot of other
things on their mind right when they get out of
jail. Are there other things on your mind that
you might want to talk about or see if we can
help with?
CLIENT
Yes. My lady and I are pregnant again already
and I’m worried about her getting good food for
the baby.
YOU
Congratulations! Sounds like you could use
some help getting food assistance for her to
have a healthy diet for her now and for the
baby when it’s born?
CLIENT
Yeah.
11/1/2018
5
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Engagement Done Well13
YOU
If it’s okay with you, after we talk about jobs, I
can refer you to my colleague who can talk
with you about food assistance. Or if you
prefer, you could talk to her first and you and I
can meet next week to talk about jobs.
CLIENT
Nah, we can talk about jobs today. I’ll wait to
talk about the food til my lady is here, too.
YOU
Great. I’m so glad you came here today and
hope we can help you and your family. We can
start with this interest inventory you filled out
while you waited…..
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
The best way to give advice to your children is to
find out what they want and then advise them to do it.Harry S Truman
MI Spirit | Evoking
Motivational Interviewing requires the clinician to understand the clients
motivation and reasons to change, reasons to not change, fears of change,
skills, failures, goals. These must be evoked through compassionate guiding.
Our training is partly based on a deficit model--identifying what is wrong or
missing what this person needs from us. There can be value in this
approach. However, when it’s time to help the client make changes, this
paradigm decreases our effectiveness.
In MI, we assume that this person knows herself much better than we do and
has the internal resources to make changes. Our job is to help clients find
the motivations and resources within themselves (Molly Kellogg, RD, LCSW)
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
MI Spirit | Evoking15
To see if you are operating in this
spirit, ask yourself:
• Am I focused on client motivation for
change rather than my own sense of
what matters?
• Am I spending the majority of our
session exploring client knowledge,
opinions or ideas or on offering
information and suggestions?
• Is my advice, when given, within the
context of what the client needs to
move forward?
• Is this plan one that the client has
developed and embraces?
Sketch Show UK Pros & Conshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=POycYoNDu7g
11/1/2018
6
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Evoking, validating and
helping clients resolve
ambivalence
16
• I want to look better in a swimsuit
• I want to experience successful weight loss
• I want to be healthy
• I want the body I had 10 years ago
• I want to eat with my family
• I want to deny I have a weight problem
• I want to indulge
• I want to accept who I am without the
pressure of change
I want..
I also want
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Evoking ambivalence leads to
motivation to change17
YOU
So you like desserts, but
hate insulin shots. Is that
correct?
CLIENT
Ugh. I need to find a way to
get over that fear.
YOU
You love eating out. But you
don’t want to end up back
here at the hospital. Would
you sum it up that way?
CLIENT
Yes. And I’m not getting a
slimmer waist line either.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
The Spirit of Evocation18
NURSE
Tell me about your other tries at cutting down
the drinking.
PATIENT
I tried. I’ve thought about it. But the guys drink
every weekend so I don’t get too far,
NURSE
So you think about it, but doing something like
that would separate you from your friends.
PATIENT
I’ve thought about this for a long time. I want
better grades. I just like hanging out with
everyone all weekend and it’s part of the
scene.
NURSE
Makes sense. You’re a social guy and want to
hang out. But you have reasons to want to
avoid the alcohol that comes with it as well.
PATIENT
These have been my guys for years,
NURSE
They’ve been your buddies. But now you have
other goals, too. How do you try to make those
happen?
PATIENT
Not easily. And I hate to be the one who says
“sorry, gotta study.”
NURSE
You like to fit in with everyone. Does anyone
else, anyone at all, ever have to take time out
of the weekend to study?
PATIENT
There are some guys who study on the
weekends. But they miss out.
NURSE
So you wouldn’t be studying alone. There’d be
a few of you. But you wouldn’t be part of
everything, either.
PATIENT
Yeah. Which could have some
advantages….but would kinda suck, too.
NURSE
Sounds like there’s an up side and a down
side here. How have you resolved these
choices before?
11/1/2018
7
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Ambivalance19
Ambivalence is safe, normal,
healthy, and expected.
Your role is to support and guide your
client through this and help them identify
factors involved in behavior choices.
The Effective Physician:
Motivational Interviewing Demonstrationhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URiKA7CKtfc
Finding housing Staying in the shelter
Pros
Can live alone
Can smoke
Won’t get sick as much
Used to it
No pressure to work
Always heat on
Cons
Have to go to the program lectures
Miss my friends
Have to work
Sick of it
Worse on anxiety
Don’t sleep as well
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
20
• Desire
• Ability
• Reasons
• Need
• Steps
• OARS
• Pros and Cons
• Evocation
• Importance ruler
• Using extremes
• Looking forward
• Using
goals/values
• Typical day
questions
Change Talk (D.A.R.N.S.)
Tools
Evoking Change Talk
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
21 Identify the Change Talk
“I wish I could stop
smoking because my teeth
would look better.”
“I lost 10 pounds once for a
wedding and felt great.”
“I’ve got to use condoms. I
don’t want to get another
infection.”
“My boyfriend would be so
happy if I quit drinking.”
“I’d love to walk steps
without panting.”
“I could probably cut out
one coke per day.”
11/1/2018
8
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Resistance is what happens when we push for change
before a client is ready. When we see these signs,
clients are less likely to change:
MI Spirit | Rolling with Resistance
Disputing
Interrupting
Denying
Diverting
Resistance is normal.
Reasons for resistance may not be clearly known even
by the client.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Signs of Resistance23
YOU
I can imagine you want to quit drinking so
you’ll do better in school.
CLIENT
I can’t quit drinking. I’m in a fraternity!
YOU
Is your fraternity more important than your
health?
CLIENT
In some ways, yeah. I’m with them all the time.
They’re my brothers.
YOU
But your liver test results indicate a growing
problem here.
CLIENT
A big problem or a little problem?
YOU
Liver issues are never a small problem.
CLIENT
That’s gotta be due to something else. I
traveled to Tunisia last year….
YOU
Well drinking can make that worse.
CLIENT
I don’t think I’m drinking too much. I think there
are too many cops in this town with not enough
to do.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
24 Rolling with Resitance
The body craves homeostasis. You push; I pull.
You lean in; I lean out.
Don’t fall into the direct/resist trap.
If there is nothing to push against, the pushing can cease.
If we feel accepted, empowered, and understood, we are less
likely to push.
11/1/2018
9
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Tools for Rolling with Resistance25
Show empathy: “You seem to feel very disheartened about this.”
Acknowledge ambivalence: “You clearly have good reason to stay angry. It
seems you also want to feel calm enough to go out with your wife tonight.”
Reflect negative emotion: “It sounds like you feel hopeless about finishing
this outpatient program.”
Reaffirm autonomy: “You don’t have to do any of these things. The choice to
join this program or not is totally voluntary.”
Acknowledge resistance and don’t fear it: “It feels like we are arguing and
getting off track. I’m pushing for something that doesn’t feel right to you. You
know yourself better than anyone else. Let’s go back to talking about your
goals and what’s important to you.”
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Mi revolves around the concept of self efficacy and
relies on the clinician to help the client believe in their
capacity to change and gain more confidence to make
that change reality.
MI Spirit | Empowerment
Identify success with changes,
even small ones, in the past
Give positive feedback for work
already done
Recognize all signs that change
is possible
Techniques:
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
MI Spirit | Empower, Empower, Empower27
• Why hasn’t this changed?
• What gets in the way?
• You really need to do this….
• It doesn’t seem important to you because_____
• What do you think will happen if you keep doing this?
• What makes this achievable for
you?
• How will life look different when
this happens?
• What steps have you already
taken in this direction?
• What have you succeeded at in
the past that might help you do
this as well?
Diminish Build Up
11/1/2018
10
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Techniques to Empower Change | Scale Questions28
YOU
“On a scale of 1-10 with 10
being ready and 1 being not
ready at all, how ready do you
feel to return to college?
CLIENT
“I would say a 3. I’m pretty
scared of the whole process.”
YOU
“What makes you say 3. Perhaps
there is something making you
feel even a little ready?”
CLIENT
“Well, my mom has agreed to
help babysit my daughter. So
that makes me feel a bit better.”
YOU
“So your mom will babysit and
you get to come home and have
your daughter see you going
after your goal and returning to
school. What an awesome role
model for her.”
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Techniques to Empower Change | Scale Questions29
NURSE
So how important, on a scale of 1-10, is cutting
down drinking?
PATIENT
About a 4.
NURSE
What keeps it from being a 0?
PATIENT
I’m on probation and truthfully, I’m getting too fat.
NURSE
How do you see things being different when you cut
down?
PATIENT
I see my parents off my back; school off my back;
my friends giving me a hard time; but me feeling
better.
NURSE
And where do you see yourself starting this
process?
PATIENT
Maybe going home more on weekends. And maybe
cutting out Thursday happy hour and just doing
Fridays and Saturdays.
NURSE
You said it’s hard to not hang out. What’s going to
help you make this happen?
PATIENT
I can tell my girlfriend to make me. And I can put
some reminders in my phone….I sometimes work
out instead of hanging out every Thursday.
NURSE
Oh –so you were holding back on me! You’ve
already met your fitness goals by making the tough
choice to work out instead of relax with the guys on
a Thursday night. That’s not easy to do.
PATIENT
No. And they give me a hard time for it.
NURSE
And you came here – that’s a big step in the
direction you want to go. It’s no easy task to get
here on a Saturday. And you even had time to stop
for a bagel first! I’m impressed.
PATIENT
Just call me superman.
NURSE
I think I will.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Techniques to Empower Change | Take a Step Questions30
YOU
It sounds like eating three meals a day like the
Nutritionist recommended would be overwhelming
to you. If you were taking one step towards your
goal this week; one step you feel confident you
could take, what might that step be?
CLIENT
I dunno. Nothing too drastic. I could probably eat
100 extra calories this week.
YOU
Sound like a great place to start. How would that
look for you? What food do you have in mind and
what time of day works for you to eat more?
CLIENT
I like guacamole. Maybe I could add some to my
toast in the mornings.
YOU
Yum. But change is hard and I know it’s not easy for
you to add calories. What else might help you reach
your goal?
CLIENT
I think if I post those pictures of myself when I was
healthier, it would help.
YOU
Visual inspiration helps a lot of people. That’s a
great idea. Are those photos in your phone?
CLIENT
Yeah. I can stop at the drug store and print a couple
on my way home
YOU
Great idea. I look forward to hearing how the
experience is for you when you come back in two
weeks. Thanks for coming in today.
11/1/2018
11
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Techniques to Empower Change
What Advice Would You Give Someone Questions31
YOU
I know you’re working hard to stop smoking and are
disappointed that it’s not happening yet. I hear lots
of reasons why it is not working for you. What
advice would you give someone in your shoes?
CLIENT
I’d tell them not to start smoking.
YOU
I bet. It’s such an addicting habit and our society
does a great job of promoting it. But if they did start,
based on your past success even stopping for a few
hours, what would you say?
CLIENT
I think when I’ve stopped, even for a day, it’s
because I got the cigarettes out of the house,
cleaned the house, and washed all my clothes. That
made me less likely to make things smelly
again…but obviously that didn’t work for too long.
YOU
So you would tell them to make it less tempting by
cleaning and getting cigarettes out of the house.
And if you think they needed a bit more inspiration
or something that could last a bit longer, what else
would you suggests?
CLIENT
Maybe if I had done something else instead, like
start eating popcorn or chewing Nicorette, or even
forcing myself to walk the dog when I felt like
smoking. I just tried to white knuckle through the
cravings and crashed every time.
YOU
So telling folks to have more distractions available
would be helpful.
CLIENT
Yes, very. And maybe going away for a few days to
change up the routine.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Techniques to Empower Change
What Advice Would You Give Someone Questions32
YOU
You have a lot of great ideas here….remove the
temptation of tobacco by getting rid of the cigarettes
themselves and the smell in the house, distract
yourself with other activities, and even get away for
a few days to change up the routine. You sound like
you could write a book about this to help others.
How might I support you trying these again for
yourself?
CLIENT
I do think I could help others. Maybe I should go to
that stop smoking support group. It might be good
for me, too.
YOU
Awesome. It’s always great to give and get
inspiration. And you certainly have lots of
experience to share. I can give you the contact
information on your way out. Anything else you think
would be helpful today?
CLIENT
No. Baby steps. I’ll go to a meeting and see you
next week.
YOU
Yep, one thing at a time. Good luck. The people
there will be lucky to have your advice!
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
The Interview33
An MI interview, through questions,
affirmations, reflections, and summaries
offered through the spirit of MI, guides the
client through the woods of fear and
ambivalence to find the flowers of strength
and commitment.
MI asks: “Help me understand how smoking
works in your life.”
MI affirms: “I get it. You smoke for comfort.
This makes sense. You make sense.”
MI reflects: “You also see it makes sense to
cut down. You’ve expressed strong reasons
to change. “
MI summarizes: “You’ve talked about how
your past success can help this time too and
you sound ready to take a big step forward
towards success.”
11/1/2018
12
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Core Interviewing Skills of MI34
Asking Open ended questions
Affirmations
Reflective listening
Summarizing
O.A.R.S.
The focus should always be on the client
values, perspective, experience.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Motivational Interviewing | Asking Skills35
• Ask open ended questions
• Ask permission
• Ask questions focusing on the impact
of the behavior on the client
• Ask questions that look for the hook
What examples do you see in the
video?
Dr. Marilyn Herie - MI Skills
Tobacco Cessation -- Angry Clienthttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB-zchaxlNc
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
OARS | Open Ended Questions36
Have you been keeping the
diet we discussed?
He keeps hurting you.
Are you going back to him again?
Your last pregnancies were
unplanned. It seems you really
should start using birth control.
You’ve been working on weight
loss. How is it going?
This relationship seems to be
causing stress. What are you
thinking about for next steps?
What concerns do you or your
boyfriend have about different
methods of birth control?
Questions Better Questions
11/1/2018
13
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Open Ended Questions Invite
the Client Story37
How can I help?
What might be a next step?
What has worked in the past?
How would your life be different if
you made this change?
How is this behavior impacting
the people you love?
What makes this a good time to
change?
What are you most afraid of in
making this change?
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
The Client Story Leads
to the Hook38
How many pounds have you lost?
How are you feeling about yourself
two weeks into your diet?
Are you still living with your husband?
How is your living situation
impacting your children?
How many job interviews did you have
this week?
What has job hunting taught you
about what you want to do?
Are you still feeling depressed today?
What were a few significant things
that impacted your mood this week?
What were you able to do this week
with your friends?
How much did you smoke this week?
How did smoking impact your
activities this week?
How are you doing?
What would be most helpful for us
to focus on today?
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Open Ended Questions | Let the Client Have the Best Lines39
YOU
What thoughts do you have about the role alcohol
plays in your life?
CLIENT
In general, it works. Everyone in my family drinks
when they hang out. Mine has gotten a bit out of
control I guess.
YOU
In what ways?
CLIENT
Like I ended up here because I spit at a cop when I
was drunk. I can’t be doing that stuff.
YOU
How did that situation resolve?
CLIENT
This class. A fine. A ticket. And a big fight with my
girlfriend.
YOU
What is your girlfriends perspective?
CLIENT
My girlfriend wants me to quit. She’s pretty pissed.
YOU
And you?
CLIENT
I think I need to do something. At least in the short
term….if I want to keep my girlfriend and not end up
with a record.
YOU
Sounds like you have some good reasons to quit.
This class might be a step to help you reach your
goal and your girlfriend sounds like she would like to
help as well.
CLIENT
Yeah. Maybe I’ll bring her for moral support. See
you next week.
11/1/2018
14
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Open Ended Questions | Gone Bad40
YOU
So it looks like you got a citation for alcohol
recently?
CLIENT
Yes
YOU
When did that happen?
CLIENT
Last weekend.
YOU
So is that why you are here today?
CLIENT
Yes
YOU
I’d like to help you quit drinking so that doesn’t
happen again. You could derail your college
education and your future if you ended up with a
record.
CLIENT
I know. I need to stop.
YOU
I agree. Drinking can cost you everything and you’re
so lucky to be here at this school and have all these
opportunities. You have to stay for the whole class
and then come back next week.
CLIENT
Ok. Thanks.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
OARS | Affirmations41
Try responding to these:
• I’m sorry I’m late. I totally forgot my
appt today.
• I know we talked about being
positive, but I’m still spiraling thinking
about how awful this divorce is for
me.
• I didn’t manage my anger well
yesterday. Totally lost it at the store
manager and had to go apologize
and beg for mercy today.
• I know I need to totally stop drinking.
I drank this weekend but never
blacked out.
Affirmationshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VaUQ7dvwWfk
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
OARS | Reflective Listening42
What it is:
Rephrasing, paraphrasing,
reflecting emotion behind the
words
What it does:
• Reflects their perspective without
judgment
• Builds trust and reduces
defensiveness
• Reduces defensiveness
• Increases client motivation
“There is something about being heard and
understood, about being the focus of full
compassionate attention, that is in itself healing.”
11/1/2018
15
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
When listening…43
Beware the righting reflex: The
often insuppressible need and
impulse to correct, to “accurately”
inform our clients of what they
“should” do.
What this does is put them in a
corner to respond with the
opposite or to superficially accept
our rationale in place of creating
their own.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Reflective Listening Guides Towards the Issue44
NURSE
We’ve talked about your friends and your family.
Let’s talk about what brings you to this class today.
Would it be okay if we talked about your drinking?
(ask permission)
PATIENT
I don’t drink too much.
NURSE
You would say you’re a light drinker? (overcorrect)
PATIENT
Maybe not light. Maybe that I can hold my liquor
pretty well.
NURSE
So you can drink and it doesn’t affect you?
(rephrase)
PATIENT
True. I can drink quite a bit. It doesn’t affect me too
much.
NURSE
And you drink a few drinks….most nights?
PATIENT
Yeah. I guess I drink most weekends for sure.
NURSE
Most weekends you drink, but it doesn’t affect you
too much?
PATIENT
I don’t think it’s too big of a deal.
NURSE
Drinking is some degree of a deal. But not a big
one. (Guide)
PATIENT
Well, sometimes I think I need to cut back.
Especially during exams.
NURSE
You’ve thought about cutting back during exams.
Tell me how you’ve thought that would
help…(Reflect and guide)
PATIENT
I’m sometimes less sharp in morning classes.
NURSE
So drinking can affect your school work? (Reflect
and guide)
PATIENT
Yeah…I would say it hasn’t helped too much.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Reflective Listening Guides the Client to
His/Her Own Motivation45
YOU
Help me understand how drinking affects your
school work.
CLIENT
Well it did last semester, that’s why I am here. I had
to come or they’d kick me out of school.
YOU
I’m glad you picked my alcohol class over leaving
school.
CLIENT
Yes, if I left school my parents would kill me.
YOU
For your parents, it’s important that you finish
school.
CLIENT
It’s important to me, too. I want to get an MBA.
YOU
An MBA. Wow. Tell me about your career goals.
CLIENT
I’m hoping to do some CIA kinda thing. I guess I
need a clean record, too.
YOU
I’m getting a picture of a very motivated person. You
want good enough grades to stay on the CIA path.
Cutting down the drinking is part of your bigger plan
to improve grades, keep your parents off your back
and make them happy, go on to grad school, have a
clean record, and get your MBA.
CLIENT
It’d probably be a good thing for this gut I’m getting,
too.
(Both laugh…..)
11/1/2018
16
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
OARS |Reflective Listening46
YOU
What do these other guys do to get
weekend time to study?
CLIENT
My roommate sets his alarm on
Sunday and can get through his
calculus problems before the rest of us
wake up.
YOU
Does any part of that seem doable to
you at all?
CLIENT
Starbucks does. And maybe getting
time to work out. Maybe I could just try
waking early to go eat and work out
first.
YOU
So am I understanding that you could
practice waking early by using that
time to go out for breakfast and work
out – which are much more appealing
to you than studying.
CLIENT
Yeah. I guess I could try that. Who
knows, maybe I could study at some
point..
YOU
Baby steps! Sounds like coffee first is
a good plan.
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
OARS
Great Sessions End with Great Summaries47
Perfect for use in transitions or
after significant statements
Begin by saying you are going
to summarize
Focus on their hooks and their
change-promoting statements
Include the positive and
negatives they expressed
Feel free to include a little (!)
additional information
End with an invitation
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
OARS | Summary48
YOU
Let me see if I can capture some of the highlights of what
we talked about today. It sounds like you enjoy drinking
and it’s a great bonding activity for you and your friends.
But recently it’s caused you academic problems and
trouble with your family…and your weight. Right?
PATIENT
Yup.
YOU
Today you came up with some good reasons to cut down
and a couple ways to start the process. You said you could
study with a friend perhaps at the library, hang out more
with your girlfriend when she’s studying, and maybe even
post the emblem of the CIA on your mirror.
PATIENT
Yeah. Those could work.
YOU
You also told me you’ve thought about this before and
have good reason to make it work this time. Am I still
getting this?
PATIENT
Yeah, all true
YOU
It sounds like you have some support – for sure your
girlfriend and your parents and a few other guys who study
on the weekends.
.
PATIENT
Yeah – there’s a few. And my parents would probably buy
me a beer on a Saturday if that was the only day I went
out!
YOU
Even more reason to go for your goal! Sometimes people
can cut down on their own. And some people have seen
our doctors here for some medications that can reduce
cravings for alcohol. I have some information on ways to
reduce alcohol use, with and without medication, and
some more information on how it can improve your health.
Are you interested in learning more?
PATIENT
Sure. Especially if you information on buying a
breathalyzer. One thing I can’t have is a DUI.
YOU
I can get that for our next meeting. You’ve made it very
clear you have your eyes on that CIA career and that even
a misdemeanor on your record could end that dream. Did I
miss anything else we focused on today?
PATIENT
Nope, sounds good. See you next week.
YOU
I look forward to talking again.
11/1/2018
17
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
49 Bringing It All Together
Group Practice:
Case Studies & Role Play
Debbie Granick, MPH, LCSW, PMHNP • www.debbiegranick.com
Thank
You