physical properties of low-rank coal samples from the ... · • flow/transport lab – tony...

19
Paul Hagin and Mark Zoback Geophysics Department Stanford University Physical Properties of Low Physical Properties of Low - - rank rank Coal Samples from the Coal Samples from the Powder River Basin, Wyoming Powder River Basin, Wyoming

Upload: others

Post on 21-Sep-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Paul Hagin and Mark Zoback

Geophysics DepartmentStanford University

Physical Properties of LowPhysical Properties of Low--rank rank Coal Samples from the Coal Samples from the

Powder River Basin, WyomingPowder River Basin, Wyoming

Page 2: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Goals and Motivation

• Predictions of sequestration and E/CBM potential rely on numerical models

• Improve constraints and inputs by conducting laboratory experiments

• Better understand effects of adsorption on mechanical properties

(Ross, Zoback, Hagin, 2007)

Page 3: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Structure of Presentation

• Overview of the multidisciplinary experimental effort at Stanford

• Describe our particular laboratory apparatus and experimental goals

• Present some initial data and results– Adsorption– Mechanical Properties– Flow Properties

Page 4: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Overview of Lab Efforts

• Multidisciplinary approach based on complementary measurements

• Flow/Transport Lab– Tony Kovscek, ERE

• Seismic/DARS Lab– Jerry Harris, GP

• Geomechanics Lab– Mark Zoback, GP

Page 5: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Overview of Lab Efforts

• Integrated Workflow gives us internal validation of results

• Flow/Transport Lab– Adsorption/Perm

• Seismic/DARS Lab– Q/Moduli

• Geomechanics Lab– Vp/Vs/Moduli/Perm

Page 6: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Field Location

• Powder River Basin– Wyoming/Montana

• Fastest growing CBM play in the USA– ~17,000 CBM wells

• Existing CO2 sources and infrastructure for ECBM or sequestration

Page 7: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Sample Description

• Samples are from the Ft. Union Formation– Roland and Smith

Coals• Depth: 1300-1400’• Thickness: 20-100’• Matrix porosity:

~10%• Density: ~1.5 g/cc• Ash content: 10-20%

Page 8: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Experimental Setup

Page 9: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Pore Pressure Inlet

Axial and Radial Strain Gauges

Axial Load Cell

Pore Pressure Outlet

Ultrasonic P/S2Transducers

Core Holder Assembly

Page 10: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Experimental Goals

• Total Adsorption

• Static and Dynamic Elastic Moduli

• Gas Permeability

• Coal Swelling

All properties measured as a function of effective stress and He/CO2 saturation

All measurements are at 22˚C

Both pore pressure and total stresses are varied

Conventional Triaxial PressMax. Confining Pressure = 100 MPa

Pressure Vesselwith Heater Coil

CoreholderSample assembly

Page 11: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Adsorption Isotherms

Page 12: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Bulk Modulus As A Function of Adsorption and Effective Stress

StaticHe

CO2

Pp = 1 MPa

Page 13: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Dynamic Properties As A Function of Pore Pressure

He

CO2 - High Pp

Page 14: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Permeability Decrease Due To Adsorption and Effective Stress

Powdered

IntactHe

CO2

Adsorption Effect

Pp = 1 MPa

Page 15: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Coal Swelling Observations

He CO2

Effective Stress 1 MPa

Page 16: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Coal Swelling As A Function of Pore Pressure

Page 17: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Summary of Observations

• Static Bulk Modulus decreases with adsorption of CO2 at a given effective stress

• Dynamic Bulk Modulus increases with adsorption of CO2 at a given effective stress

• Permeability decreases due to effective stress and adsorption of CO2 are approximately the same magnitude

Page 18: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Future Plans

• Measurements at Higher Pore Pressure and Effective Stress

• Measurements as a function of Temperature (50 - 100 degrees C)

• Measurements for gas mixtures and as a function of water saturation

Page 19: Physical Properties of Low-rank Coal Samples from the ... · • Flow/Transport Lab – Tony Kovscek, ERE •SD/mAcsRS Lieiab – Jerry Harris, GP •GeomechanicsLab –Makr Zoback

Acknowledgements

• The Global Climate & Energy Project (GCEP) for financial support (http://gcep.stanford.edu)

• Tony Kovscek and Wenjuan Lin for data and guidance on the adsorption measurements

• Apache for field data and core samples