philosophical architecture in grails

Philosophical Architecture

(in Grails)

Philosophical Architecture

(in Grails)

David DawsonDavid Dawson

CEO @ Simplicity ItselfCEO @ Simplicity Itself

[email protected]

@davidthecoder@SimplicityItse1

[email protected]

@davidthecoder@SimplicityItse1

What is Architecture?


Architecturevs

Design

Architecturevs

Design

Limitless OptionsFor Design

Limitless OptionsFor Design

Only a few ArchitecturesOnly a few

Architectures

Grails' 'default'Architecture



N-Tier


N-Tier


N-TierData Centric


N-TierData Centric

My Green Field ProjectMy Green Field Project


Web/ MVC LayerWeb/ MVC Layer



Service LayerService Layer




Data LayerData Layer





DataControllerDataController UserControllerUserController AuthControllerAuthController

DataServiceDataService UserServiceUserService

UserUser







UserUser

OAuthControllerOAuthController

RandomServiceRandomService

UserSupportUserSupportPointPoint







UserUser

1.21.2






UserUser










UserUser

1.31.3






UserUser




DataServiceDataService


DataServiceDataService MehServ iceMehServ iceBlahServiceBlahServiceDataServiceDataService GahServiceGahService

DoWorkServiceDoWorkService







UserUser

1.31.3






UserUser






DataServiceDataService MehServ iceMehServ iceBlahServiceBlahServiceDataServiceDataService GahServiceGahService

DoWorkServiceDoWorkService

VIEWSVIEWS

Issues ..Issues ..

Issues ..

Coupling between tiers

Issues ..


Issues ..


Service Spaghetti

Issues ..


Service Spaghetti

Issues ..


Service Spaghetti

User exposed to data model

Issues ..


Service Spaghetti

User exposed to data model

ArchitectureArchitecture

ArchitectureData CentricArchitectureData Centric

ArchitectureData Centric

N-Tier

ArchitectureData Centric

N-Tier

ArchitectureIs PhilosophyArchitecture

Is Philosophy

What is yourPhilosophy?

Perfection

and How It Ruined the World

Perfection

Plato'sTheory of

Ideal Forms

Plato'sTheory of

Ideal Forms

Aristotlean CategoriesAristotlean Categories

Where did this lead?Where did this lead?

TODO, Petra

TODO, Petra

UtopiaUtopia

Waterfall!Waterfall!

Pure Functional

Programming

Pure Functional

Programming

SOA?SOA?

That's awfulThat's awful

"le mieux est l'ennemi du bien"

"le mieux est l'ennemi du bien"

- Voltaire- Voltaire

- Voltaire- Voltaire

"the perfect is the enemy of the good""the perfect is the

enemy of the good"

Back In

Time

Back In

Time

No man ever steps in the same river twice

No man ever steps in the same river twice

- Heraclitus (a long time ago)

- Heraclitus (a long time ago)

Perfection is a liePerfection is a lie

Change is the only Truth

Change is the only Truth

The StoicsThe Stoics

Stoicism for DevelopersStoicism for Developers

sick and yet happysick and yet happy


sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy


sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy dying and yet happy

sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy dying and yet happy


sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy dying and yet happyin exile and happy

sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy dying and yet happyin exile and happy


sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy dying and yet happyin exile and happyin disgrace and happy

sick and yet happyin peril and yet happy dying and yet happyin exile and happyin disgrace and happy


How can this be

applied?

How can this be

applied?

PragmatismPragmatism

Reject DogmaReject Dogma

Gather ProofGather Proof

Change is Real

Change is Real

David, show them some code


A Business ProcessA Business Process


(Workflow)(Workflow)



Create DocumentCreate Document



Create DocumentCreate DocumentCreate DocumentCreate Document Review DocumentReview Document



Create DocumentCreate DocumentCreate DocumentCreate Document Review DocumentReview Document Approve DocumentApprove Document




RejectReject




RejectReject Insert into SystemInsert into System

The ChallengesThe Challenges

●The DBA likes to change things●The DBA likes to change things


●The DBA likes to change things

●The UI will need updating every week.






●The Document system gets a new major version every 2 months.



●The Document system gets a new major version every 2 months.


The 'Life Preserver'

Approach

The 'Life Preserver'

Approach

Core Domain

Application PoliciesBusiness Rules

Core Domain

Application PoliciesBusiness Rules

DocumentWorkflowDocumentWorkflow

DatabaseDatabaseDocumentWorkflowDocumentWorkflow

DatabaseDatabase

DocumentSystemIntegration



RESTREST

DatabaseDatabase




RESTRESTUIUI

DatabaseDatabase




Events!Events!

What areEvents?What areEvents?

Asynchronous?Asynchronous?

CommunicationCommunication

Imperativeto

Declarative

Imperativeto

Declarative

Give me MilkGive me Milk

OKOK

I used all the milkI used all the milk

I'll get someI'll get some

Point of Decision moves

Caller ==> Callee

Point of Decision moves

Caller ==> Callee

we will use:we will use:

we will use:

Communication Centric

we will use:

Communication Centric

we will use:

Communication CentricDomain Based

we will use:


we will use:


Architecture

we will use:


Architecture

we will use:

No NewFrameworks

we will use:

No NewFrameworks

https://github.com/daviddawson/philosophical-architecturehttps://github.com/daviddawson/philosophical-architecture



What Next?What Next?

RESTRESTUIUI

DatabaseDatabase




Split DomainsInto Plugins

Split DomainsInto Plugins

Split DomainsInto

Microservices

Split DomainsInto

Microservices

Blatant PromoBlatant Promo

Trouble changing your software?

[email protected]

Trouble changing your software?

[email protected]


https://skillsmatter.com/conferences/6312-muconhttps://skillsmatter.com/conferences/6312-mucon

µCon: The Microservices Conference27th, 28th November, LondonµCon: The Microservices Conference27th, 28th November, London


Simplicity in Software Workshop, Friday 19th July

Simplicity in Software Workshop, Friday 19th July

Questions?Questions?

Thank you!Thank you!

@davidthecoder@davidthecoder