perception survey on truth, justice, reconciliation … of law… · justice, reconciliation and...

4
Empowered lives. Resilient nations. T he December 2013 crisis has put truth, justice, reconciliation and healing on the agenda for peace in South Sudan. Consequently, UNDP, in partnership with the South Sudan Law Society, conducted a survey to gauge the perceptions of South Sudanese on suitable responses to the legacy of conflict. The findings are informative for developing a South Sudanese agenda for transitional justice. PERCEPTION SURVEY ON TRUTH, JUSTICE, RECONCILIATION AND HEALING IN SOUTH SUDAN 1,525 51% 49% 41% showed symptoms of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) individuals surveyed Men Women Torit Malakal Mayendit Yirol West Juba Bor South Yambio Morobo Kajo-keji Lainya Yei Terekeka Magwi Ikotos Kapoeta South Budi Kapoeta North Lafon Kapoeta East Awerial Wulu Rumbek East Cueibet Rumbek N orth Rumbek Centre Yirol East Aweil South Aweil Centre Aweil West Aweil North Aweil East Panyijiar Leer Koch Mayom Guit Rubkona Abiemnhom Pariang Ton j South Ton j East Ton j N orth Gogrial East Gogrial West Twic Wau Jur River Raga Maridi Mundri West Mundri East Ibba Nzara Mvolo Ezo Tam bu ra Nagero Pibor Twic East Pochalla Duk Uror Akobo Ayod Nyirol Canal/Pigi Fangak Ulang Maiwut Luakpiny/ Nasir Longochuk Panyikang Baliet Fashoda Melut Manyo Renk Maban Undemarcated boundary Undemarcated boundary Disputed Boundary LEGEND Capital City Field Site International Boundary UGANDA KENYA ETHIOPIA DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC SUDAN EASTERN EQUATORIA EQUATORIA WESTERN EQUATORIA LAKES WARRAP UNITY UPPER NILE WESTERN BAHR EL GHAZAL EL GHAZAL NORTHERN BAHR JONGLEI CENTRAL Abyei region N Rumbek Bor Bor PoC Mingkam Terekeka Juba/Juba Town Nimule Juba PoC Mvolo Abyei Wau-Shiluk

Upload: others

Post on 23-Sep-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PERCEPTION SURVEY ON TRUTH, JUSTICE, RECONCILIATION … of Law… · justice, reconciliation and healing on the agenda for peace in South Sudan. Consequently, UNDP, in partnership

Empowered lives.Resilient nations.

T he December 2013 crisis has put truth, justice, reconciliation and healing on the agenda for peace in

South Sudan. Consequently, UNDP, in partnership with the South Sudan Law Society, conducted a survey to gauge the perceptions of South Sudanese on suitable responses to the legacy of conflict.

The findings are informative for developing a South Sudanese agenda for transitional justice.

PERCEPTION SURVEY ON TRUTH, JUSTICE, RECONCILIATION AND HEALING IN SOUTH SUDAN

1,525

51%49%

41%showed symptoms of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

individuals surveyed

Men Women

! ! ! !! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!

!

!!

! !

!!

!!

!!!!!

!

! ! ! !

!!

!!!

!!

!

!!

!!

!!

!!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!!

!!

!!

!!

!

!!

!!

!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!

Torit

Malakal

Mayendit

Yirol West

Juba

Bor South

Yambio

Morobo

Kajo-keji

LainyaYei

Terekeka

Magwi

Ikotos

KapoetaSouth

Budi

KapoetaNorthLafon

KapoetaEast

AwerialWulu

Rumbek East

Cueibet

RumbekNorth

Rumbek Centre

Yirol East

AweilSouth

Aweil Centre

AweilWest

Aweil North Aweil East

Panyijiar

Leer

Koch

MayomGuit

Rubkona

Abiemnhom

Pariang

TonjSouth

TonjEast

TonjNorth

GogrialEast

GogrialWest

Twic

WauJur

River

Raga

Maridi

MundriWest

MundriEast

Ibba

Nzara

Mvolo

Ezo

Tambura

Nagero

Pibor

Twic East

Pochalla

DukUror Akobo

Ayod

Nyirol

Canal/PigiFangak

Ulang MaiwutLuakpiny/

Nasir

Longochuk

PanyikangBaliet

Fashoda

Melut

Manyo

Renk

Maban

Undemarcated boundary

Undemarcated boundary

Disputed Boundary

!!!!!!

!!

! ! ! ! ! !

!!

LEGEND

Capital City

Field Site

International Boundary

UGANDA

KENYA

ETHIOPIA

DEMOCRATICREPUBLIC OF THE CONGO

CENTRALAFRICANREPUBLIC

SUDAN

EASTERN EQUATORIA

EQUATORIA

WESTERN EQUATORIA

LAKES

WARRAP

UNITY

UPPER NILE

WESTERN BAHR EL GHAZAL

EL GHAZALNORTHERN BAHR

JONGLEI

CENTRAL

Abyeiregion

NN

Rumbek

BorBor PoCMingkam

Terekeka

Juba/Juba Town

Nimule

Juba PoC

Mvolo

AbyeiWau-Shiluk

Page 2: PERCEPTION SURVEY ON TRUTH, JUSTICE, RECONCILIATION … of Law… · justice, reconciliation and healing on the agenda for peace in South Sudan. Consequently, UNDP, in partnership

VIEWS ON RECONCILIATIONTo achieve reconciliation the top three choices of people are:

For perpetrators, respondents prefered:

Perception Survey on Truth, Justice, Reconciliation and Healing in South Sudan UNDP

25%APOLOG

IES

41%do not know of the

IGAD-led peace process?

TRIALS

AMNESTY

THE PEACE PROCESS

82%36%Men are more likely to be aware of the IGAD process than women

36% of the Committee for National Healing, Peace and Reconciliation (CNHPR)30% are aware of

the National Platform for Peace and Reconciliation (NPPR) and

66%

33%33%CONFESSION

S

40%

FORG

IVENESS

Page 3: PERCEPTION SURVEY ON TRUTH, JUSTICE, RECONCILIATION … of Law… · justice, reconciliation and healing on the agenda for peace in South Sudan. Consequently, UNDP, in partnership

As most appropriate accountability mechanism*:

* Findings give reason to believe that had awareness of international/hybrid mechanisms been higher, more participants would have chosen such mechanisms

Perception Survey on Truth, Justice, Reconciliation and Healing in South Sudan UNDP

9% choose a hybrid mechanism

17% choose customary courts

INTER-COMMUNAL RELATIONS

Respondents with PTSD are less likely to have confidence in inter-community peace talks and reconciliation

In comparison to participants without PTSD, those with PTSD

expressed a preference for international justice

systems over national justice systems

would support the involvement of international justice mechanisms

say that people responsible for abuses should be removed from public office

say that people responsible for abuses should not be offered amnesty

prefer trials to be held in

South Sudan81%

59%

83%57%

groups cannot be trusted

38% say people from other ethnic

of oth

er eth

nic gr

oups

than men

Wome

n rep

orted

a les

s fav

ourable view

VIEWS ON CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY, ACCOUNTABILITY AND AMNESTY

32% choose the International Criminal Court

35% choose a national formal court

Page 4: PERCEPTION SURVEY ON TRUTH, JUSTICE, RECONCILIATION … of Law… · justice, reconciliation and healing on the agenda for peace in South Sudan. Consequently, UNDP, in partnership

SUPPORT FOR TRUTH-SEEKING PROCESSES

REPARATIONS

UNDP is the UN’s global development network, advocating for change and connecting countries to knowledge, experience and resources to help people build a better life. UNDP is on the ground in 177 countries and territories,

working with them on their own solutions to global and national development challenges. United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Ministries Road, UNDP Compound, P.O. Box 410, Juba, South Sudan

Website: www.ss.undp.org Email: [email protected]

Perception Survey on Truth, Justice, Reconciliation and Healing in South Sudan UNDP

There is a split between those in favor of:

Nearly 75% would be interested in speaking publicly about their traumatic experiences

The preferred symbolic reparation is a day of national remembrance (29%). Followed by the construction of monuments (24%) and education materials for schools (23%)

And those who prefer to:

PUBLIC DIALOGUE

‘PUT IT BEHIND US’

50%

75%

46%

80%66% 80% of men are willing to speak publicly about

their experience, compared with 66% of women

Those with PTSD are more likely not to want a public discussion about South Sudan’s violent past. Yet, those with PTSD (81%) are more likely to want to speak publicly about their own traumatic experiences than those without PTSD (67%).

96% of those who knew about truth commissions support the idea

32% of survey respondents do not know what a ‘truth commission’ is

81% 24% 23%

90% 90%

29%say that the government should provide compensation to victims

say that efforts should be made to honor victims of conflict in South Sudan