pccyfs 2012 annual spring conference the pursuit of positive outcomes and the obstacles to change...
TRANSCRIPT
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring Conference
The Pursuit of Positive The Pursuit of Positive Outcomes and Outcomes and
the Obstacles to Changethe Obstacles to Change
Presented byJoe Lavoritano, Martha Tavantzis & James
Black
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
2
Basic Premises
• The basis for positive outcomes is constant innovation
• Data gathering and evaluation is the cornerstone of innovation
• There are many natural obstacles to innovation making innovation rare
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
3
Saint Gabriel’s System
• Multi-component system of care
• Residential Treatment Facility (200-bed) in Audubon, PA (suburb of Philadelphia)
• Three day-treatment programs located in and around Philadelphia
• Reintegration Program for youth returning to the community post residential placement
• Several community-based outpatient mental health programs
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
4
Saint Gabriel’s Hall
• Eleven residential units, 16 beds in each
• Short-term, farm-based program (24 beds) for first-time delinquents
• All youth are followed for up to 6 months post-discharge by SGS Reintegration Program.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
6
As Professionals…
• Are we not called to innovate?
• Are we not called to create positive outcomes?
• If not us, then who?
• What is just?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
7
We Believe…
Innovation should be a part of a professional’s DNA
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
11
Before De La Salle’sInnovations and After
Before 1680
• Teaching was mainly individual
• Literacy began with Latin
• Teachers were not trained
• Teaching writing was controlled by a guild
By 1792
• Simultaneous method of teaching was used
• Teaching was entirely in French
• Teachers were trained and supervised
• A particular style of handwriting was taught
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
12
Before De La Salle’sInnovations and After
Before 1680
• The poor and the better off were seated separately
• Corporal punishment was widely used
• Teachers were not highly regarded and
had to be paid
After 1792
• Pupils took their places according to their scores on the last monthly test
• Corporal punishment was forbidden by the Brothers’ Rule of 1717
• The brotherhood had been formally approved by Pope Benedict the XIII
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
13
Before De La Salle’sInnovations and After
Before 1860
• Progress was haphazard and uncertain
• Attendance was haphazard and not controlled
After 1792
• Monthly test wereheld and results communicated to parents
• Attendance was carefully monitoredso that students did not fall behind
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
14
De La Salle Standardized andPut into Practice Many Methods Considered Standard Today• Instructing an entire class of pupils
simultaneously
• Use of the vernacular in the classroom
• Pioneered teacher training colleges
• Grouping students according to achievement
(Source: SJBDLS, His Life and Spirituality, Saint Mary’s Press)
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
15
But to focus on them as an excuse is conveniently non-productive
We are not saying that there are not real obstacles to what we do.
(There are!)
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
16
Real Obstacles in Our Work at SGS
• Youth come from neighborhoods in generational poverty and are subject to chronic trauma
• Males do not have fully developed brains until their mid-20s; mid-teens have brains that overestimate reward and underestimate risk and negative consequences
• These two factors combine to make fertile ground for delinquent behaviors
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
18
Number of SGS Graduates by Fiscal Year
57
8292 91
131
?
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
06/ 07 07/ 08 08/ 09 09/ 10 10/ 11 11/ 12
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
19
Innovations
• Sanctuary grant
• Software for rapid accrual of credit
• Night school
• Population shift to older youth
• Year-round school day
• CTE—more investment by kids
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
20
We believe that the only way forward is through innovation, and the only way to innovateis to follow the data.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
21
Why Is Innovation So Rare?
Are we just lazy by nature and happy to accept the status quo as the best we can do?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
23
What Gets in the Wayof Innovation?
• Presentism
• Rationalization
• Cognitive Dissonance
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
24
Presentism
The concept has been around for centuries, but Harvard psychologist Daniel Gilbert in his book “Stumbling on Happiness,” describes it this way:
“Each of us is trapped in a place, a time or circumstance and our attempts to use our minds to transcend these boundaries are more often than not ineffective” (p.138).
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
26
Because imagination and perception have to run in the same part of the brain. This “time-share” of parts of thebrain causes presentism.
Imagination cannot easily transcend the boundaries of the present. Why?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
28
We believe we’re thinking outside the box only becausewe can’t see how big the box really is!
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
29
Defense Mechanisms Are Unconscious
RATIONALIZATION: “The individual deals with emotional conflicts or internal or external stressors by concealing the true motivation of his or her own thoughts, feelings or actions through the elaboration of reassuring or self-serving but incorrect explanations.”
(Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
30
Rationalization is considered to be at the “disavowal level” of ego defenses. “This level of defense is characterized by keeping unpleasant or unacceptable stressors, impulses, ideas or responsibility out of awareness with or without a misattribution of these to external causes.”
(DSM)
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
31
Examples of Rationalization
• “Kids have immature brains; how can
we be expected to influence them to do better?”
• “We are doing the best we can considering where our youth are coming from.”
• “We are lucky we can keep a lid onthe school!”
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
32
MICHAEL: I don't know anyone who could get through the day without two or three juicy rationalizations. They're more important than sex.
SAM: Ah, come on. Nothing's more important than sex.
MICHAEL: Oh yeah? Ever gone a week without a rationalization?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
33
AWOLS BY FISCAL YEAR
1717
2323
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
Returned Did Not Return
5134
27 26
78
60
40 40?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
34
Innovations
• Trauma-informed care
• Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy
• CTE—more investment by kids
• “Predictable unpredictability’ of AWOLS: timing, vigilance, monitoring, policy changes, etc.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
35
Cognitive Dissonance
Is defined as an uncomfortable feeling caused by holding conflicting ideas simultaneously. The theory of cognitive dissonance proposes that people have a motivational drive to reduce dissonance. They do this by changing their attitudes, beliefs and actions. Dissonance is also reduced by justifying, blaming and denying.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
36
Cognitive Dissonance
Attempts to reduce cognitive dissonance typically follow this pattern: one desires something, finds it unattainable, and reduces one's dissonance by criticizing it.
This pattern is known as“adaptive preference formation.”
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
37
A classical example of this idea (and the origin of the expression "sour grapes") is expressed in the fable “The Fox and the Grapes” by Aesop (ca. 620–564 BCE). In the
story, a fox sees some high-hanging grapes and wishes to eat them. When the fox is unable to think of a way to
reach them, he surmises that the grapes are probably not worth eating, as they must not be ripe or that they are
sour.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
38
How Have We Diminished Our Goals?
• “Even if our kids get a diploma, they won’t get a job. What’s the big deal?”
• “I provide the kids with a safe environment. If they get re-arrested, there’s not much I can do about it.”
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
39
So, what do you currently measure, and what outcomes are you getting?
• Are your outcomes the best you can expect?
• How do you know?
• What could be holding you back from achieving even better outcomes?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
42
Cell Phones
• 2008Apple had a 25% share of $300+ phones
• 201061% share
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
43
How did we get to this point?Why did we fall behind when the
world around us evolved?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
44
NOKIA’s CEO’s Answer:
“We haven’t been delivering innovation
fast enough.”
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
45
Reason for Discharge (% Age)
0
4
42
0
29
17
36
8
36
15
22
005
1015
2025
3035
4045
AWOL/ Truancy Arrest ProbationViolation
ProgramInfraction
Br. Rosseau DelSit DelVoc
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
46
Innovations
• At Brother Rousseau, we are adding another social worker.
• At DelSit, we have added one AmeriCorps volunteer and one Lasallian volunteer who will provide more frequent relational supervision.
• At DelVoc, we funded a summer internship and will be funding a winter internship to supplement a jobs training grant that we received.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
47
Number of SGS Graduates by Fiscal Year
57
8292 91
131
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
06/ 07 07/ 08 08/ 09 09/ 10 10/ 11 11/ 12 @ 6months
56
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
48
AWOLS BY FISCAL YEAR
1717
2323
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 @6 months
Returned Did Not Return
5134
27 26248
78
60
40
4032
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
49
Reaction by the Organization: Barriers to Change
• Disbelief: “It’s a fluke!”
• Denial: “We are OK!”
• Displacement: “It’s not our fault!”
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
50
Reaction in the Community:
• Youth having a difficult time with self-regulation/emotional managements
• Staff having a difficult time managing youth: parallel processes
• Leadership pulled to use old methods to get back on track: e.g., evaluating each individual incident without defining the themes/big picture
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
51
The Sanctuary Model:We Needed to Use the Tools
• We started asking ourselves: “What is happening?”
• Began using Staff Meetings, Town Halls, Red Flags
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
52
The Sanctuary Model:We Needed to Use the Tools
Began to use S.E.L.F. as the Framework to discuss issues:
•What are the safety issues?
•Where are/who is struggling with emotional management?
•What losses are we experiencing?
•What are our hope and challenges for the future?
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
53
What’s Changed?
We now have the trauma-informed framework to process issues and solve problems.
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
54
What We Discovered When We Asked Ourselves “What Happened?”• Difficulty with a judge: loss of confidence
• Key staff person fired: Loss of trust
• Loss of talented veteran teachers: several retired
• Many brand new teachers
• Went to full-day summer school: traditional summer programming changed
• Closed CBDS/opened new fraternity
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
55
What We Discovered When We Asked Ourselves “What Happened?”
• Core team stopped meeting in late Summer and did not meet in the Fall
• Forced to change our calendar; fewer home visits (in conflict with our mission)
• Forced to change traditions; no more off-campus trips for youth/incentive loss
• Clinic and youth care staffing down: people stretched
• Youth challenging staff in ways never done before; increased “gang-like “ connections, bold behavior, K2
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
56
What Actions Are We Taking To Prevent AWOLS and Engage Youth?Increase overall physical safety
•Increased cameras and lights in the parking lots
•Tightened up movement in the building
•Conducted fraternity searches
•Brought in more staff temporarily to help with challenging youth in the school area
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
57
Increased Emotional Safety
• Work at preventing AWOLS
• Clinical therapists work to explore“push and pulls” to possible AWOL
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
58
Other Strategies
• All departments and all levels of the organization meeting together to workon specific issues identified in the Team Meetings
• Work with other Sanctuary-certified agencies to honestly discuss AWOL challenges
• Share and develop best-practice standards to address prevention, management and post-AWOLdebriefing
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
59
Has it Worked?
• In process now…we’ll see what is helpful
• Looking at solutions through a Trauma- Informed lens
• Sanctuary does not tell you how to solve your problems…it provides a model to work through issues
• We will evaluate through data to see if we are on the right track
PCCYFS 2012 Annual Spring
Conference
60
• As professionals, we believe we are compelled to innovate.
• Innovation does not come naturally—actually accepting current outcomes as the best we can do is natural.
• Collecting data and mulling over what it is indicating will encourage you to try new things and spur innovation.
• Innovation is the just thing to do.
Takeaways