origins of freedom of the press: 2 colonial-era printing press “congress shall make no...
TRANSCRIPT
Origins of freedom of the press:
2
Colonial-era printing press
“Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom…of the press…”
• Influence of the printing press
• Ideals of the Enlightenment
• Pamphlets and papers during the American Revolution
Traditional forms:
3
Non-traditional forms:
• Newspapers• Concentration of
ownership
• Magazines
• Pamphlets
• Posters
• Radio
• Television• Personalizes
communication to masses, individualizes the news
• Internet• Technology gap
• Reliable?
“Wikimedia” meet the need for people to participate in the news
Instantaneous, on demand, and tailored to their liking
Sources are interactive so the consumer can respond directly to the provider
Information consumers can also be information producers
4
Will government officials listen more to the people? Will they respond to calls for change? Will they replace negative actions with better behavior?
Will citizens become more informed or more tolerant? Will they feel that their voices are being heard? Will it be easier for them to organize and take action?
Will policy itself reflect a broader consensus of the citizens and not just private interests? Will new policies contain new and different ideas? Will such policies actually improve the situation or conditions under which people live?
5
What impact will new media have on government leaders, citizens, and policy?
Television is unique◦ Has the ability to reach millions of people and
provides almost all our political knowledge by showing us a world larger than we know
◦ Power of Cronkite
Is the media, however, unbiased and all inconclusive, or selective?
Will we admire journalists the way we did Cronkite?
Should the media be controlled?
“I did not realize the importance of communications and the overriding importance of what is on the evening television news. If I am not on, or there with a message, someone else is, with their message.” Bill Clinton
“When I think of the millions of dollars that go into one lousy 30-second television spot advertising a deodorant, it seems to me unbelievable that we don’t do a better job in seeing that presidential appearances always have the best professional advice whenever they are to be covered on TV.” Nixon
Concentration and centralization of ownership◦ A nationalization of news
occurring meaning less variety of opinions and information
◦ 6 major media companies that own TV stations, radio stations, newspapers, magazines, trade publications, movie studios, and production companies
Narrowcasting◦ Cable and internet
media catering to specialized audiences that further fragment society Telemundo and
Univision for example ESPN, History
Channel, C-SPAN
Columbia University study found:◦ 11% of time was taken
up with written or edited stories
◦ The role of the reporter was to talk, a lot
◦ Stories were repeated without new information
◦ Coverage was spotty, ignoring many important topics
All in all, Cable news was “talk radio on television”
The idealism of the potential of TV as a medium is disappearing; cable is more about profit and not about prestige
The media as the “fourth branch” of government
Important benefits of a free press:
11
— Open expression of ideas
— Advances collective knowledge and understanding
— Communication with government representatives
— Allows for peaceful social change
— Protects individual rights
Entertainment◦ Media outlets also tend to blur
between news and entertainment (larger audience means more money)
Informing the public◦ Newsworthiness (again, money)
Agenda setting◦ Effect of policy entrepreneurs
12
New York World headline from the Spanish-American War
Lasswell’s social effects of media◦ Surveillance-watchdog function “eyes and
ears to the world” Investigative journalism-how far can they go?
◦ Interpretation-civil rights movement, Iraq war, representation of poor Bias
◦ Socialization-teaching facts and values Presenting a forum for the exchange of
ideas
13
Police drag away a
civil rights protester
President Nixon leaving the White House after his resignation
Measure Public Opinion◦ Polling
Random sampling Sampling error
◦ Criticisms Creates a bandwagon effect Forces politicians to change policies becoming followers and
not leaders Pollsters can elicit certain responses by how the question is
asked Do you favor keeping a large number of US troops in Iraq until
there is a stable government or bringing most of our troops home in the next year.—Harris poll
Do you think the US should keep its military forces in Iraq until civil order is restored there, even if that means continued US military casualties, or, do you think the US should withdraw its military forces from Iraq in order to avoid further military casualties, even if it means civil order is not restored there?-- ABC/Washington Post poll
The media tends to focus on the “horse-race” and designating front-runners has a negative effect on other candidates◦ Also, how are candidates portrayed
How much candidates spend on advertising◦ @ $70 million spent on TV advertising and news
coverage of campaigns has shrunk increasing the use of sound bites (which are shorter)
The media, especially TV’s effect on a candidate’s image◦ Would Washington, Lincoln, FDR been elected if
their was TV then?◦ Is image more important then ideas?
Radio as a tool for political communication President Franklin Roosevelt’s “fireside chats” and
press conferences Inventor of modern media politics
18
FDR giving a “fireside chat”
“Eisenhower Answers America”
19
Opening shot of Eisenhower’s commercial
The Nixon–Kennedy debates President Kennedy and his use of television
20
— Facing his doubters
— Presidential press conferences
Ronald Reagan: “The Great Communicator”Choreographed public appearances
Attack advertising “Daisy Girl”: Lyndon Johnson’s 1964 presidential campaign
21
A shot of the “Daisy Girl” from LBJ’s 1964 ad
www.livingroomcandidate.com
Attack advertising Willie Horton:
George H.W. Bush’s 1988 presidential campaign
22
Bush’s “Willie Horton” ad
Perot campaigning on
television
The “infomercial”
• Ross Perot’s 1992 presidential campaign
Stories sponsored by government agencies to inform the public
Use of trial balloons◦ Announce upcoming◦ Discredit political opponents
News or propaganda? GAO report Columnists paid by government
agencies to endorse programs Practice misleads American
public
23
Freedom of press vs. national security◦ Accountability vs.
safety Right to privacy in
media◦ Public figures vs.
private figures◦ Cox Broadcasting
Corp. v. Cohn (1975) Releasing rape victim’s
name
Libel laws◦ Actual malice toward
an individual Censorship?
◦ FCC’s job Equal time rule
◦ Presidential debates exclusion of 3rd parties
◦ Fairness doctrine-hurt AM radio talk shows