optimized maspi pama april 2009 rev1 pomer point
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
CONDITION MONITORING FUEL AND OIL FOR EFFECTIVE MAINTENANCE IN MINING HEAVY EQUIPMENTS
1
Pamapersada Nusantara Total Fluid Management
Diskusi Ilmiah MASPI ke-10Jakarta, 14 April 2009
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
For most mechanical systems, the reliability engineer must define the lubricant as a critical component of the system because no shared-load system or spare exists for the function performed by the lubricant unless the host system is spared. Drew D. Troyer, "How to Lube Up Your FMEA Process". Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine. May 2000
PREFACE
LUBE FUNCTION
Lubricating Reduce friction Reduce wear Perform oil layer Transmission of power, hydraulics Cleaning Cooling Sealing Heat Transfer
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Did you know that 8 out every 10 diesel engine failures are directly related to contaminated diesel fuel?
--Diesel Fuel Polishing Service July 2006
75-85% of hydraulic system failures are caused by contamination.
-- Hydraulics & Pneumatics June 1998-- Equipment Today August 1997
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Likewise, a lubrication failure can produce significant secondary damage to other system components. Because of the lubricant’s critical nature, and the frequency with which mechanical failure is related to the lubricating system.
Drew D. Troyer, "How to Lube Up Your FMEA Process". Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine. May 2000
LUBE DEGRADATION
THERMAL BREAKDOWN Direct heat degradation of lubrication Overheating Oil Thinning
CHEMICAL BREAKDOWN Aging or Oxidation Oil Thickening
HYDROLYTIC BREAKDOWN Degradation by reaction of water Oil Thinning and milky
Contamination of the oil with solid or metal contaminant can accelerate the oxidation process.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Mark Barnes, Noria Corporation, "The Lowdown on Oil Breakdown". Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine. May 2003
The Three Common Methods of Hydrocarbon Oil Degradation
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
VISCOUS CYCLE OF THERMAL FAILURE
E.C. Fitch, Tribolics, Inc., "Temperature Stability". Machinery Lubrication Magazine. July 2002
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara 7
7
Pamapersada Nusantara Total Fluid Management
Lube Condition Monitoring System uses to minimize and control lube degradations within continuously monitoring the quality of fuel and oil.It offers significant advantages to planned equipment maintenance and make some identifications as predictive and proactive maintenance.
LUBE CONDITION MONITORING
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Fluid Properties Analysis. Information on a lubricant’s physical and chemical properties such as viscosity, acid number, additives, etc.
Fluid Contamination Analysis. The presence of uninvited guests such as dirt, glycol, soot, fuel, water, etc.
Fluid Wear Debris Analysis. Concentration and characterization of wear metals suspended in used oil.
Lube service life extension has to confirm in laboratory studies, monitoring and analyze through the experience in the field.
There are three aspects of lube analyze are :
LUBE CONDITION MONITORING
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara 9
9
Pamapersada Nusantara Total Fluid Management
CONDITION MONITORING FUEL AND OIL IN MINING OPERATION
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
LUBE CONDITION MONITORING END to END
Supplier/ Transporter
Heavy Equipment
Main Tank/ Oil Storage Lube Truck
(WHAT – WHERE – WHEN – WHO - HOW)
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
LUBE CONDITION MONITORING END to END
- WHAT : Requirement Standard Lube Specification from OEM and Standard Properties
- WHERE : Sampling Point for Every Component and Lube Line Distribution
- WHEN : Periodically based on Component Type and New Lube
Incoming - WHO : Fuel and Oil Operator, Technical Mechanic, Lube Analyst - HOW : Periodically Sampling, Monitor, Analyze, Follow Up,
Feedback and Data Recording
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Requirement Standard
Table 2: Oil Contamination Guidelines
PropertyGuideline
Viscosity change @ 100°C (ASTM-D445)
±1 SAE Viscosity grade or 5 cSt from the new oil
Fuel Dilution 5 %
Total base number (TBN) (ASTM D-4739)
2.5 number minimum or half new oil value or equal to TAN
Water content ASTM (D-95)
0.5 % maximum
Potential Contaminants:
Silicone (SI) 15 ppm increase over new oil
Sodium (Na) 20 ppm increase over new oil
Boron (B) 25 ppm increase over new oil
Potassium (K) 20 ppm increase over new oil
Cummins Engine Oil Recommendations
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Requirement Standard (KOMATSU)
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
EquipmentFuel TruckMain TankTransporter
Fuel Sampling Point
CONTOH KASUS – WHAT HAPPENED WITH MAIN TANK?
Grafik Monitor Kebersihan
5
76
5
012345678
Transporter Main Tank Fuel Truck Equipment
Lokasi
Cle
an
line
ss
NA
S
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Oil Sampling Point
Oil Engine
Hydraulic Oil
Differential Oil
Final Drive Oil
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Sampling Periodically
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
LINE DISTRIBUTION
Supplier/ Transporter
Heavy Equipment
Main Tank/ Oil Storage Lube Truck
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
SUPPLIER/ TRANSPORTER
QUALITY Water suspecting Specific gravity Lube properties Cleanliness
QUANTITY Metering Seal
Fuel Test Properties
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
STORAGE/ MAIN TANK
GOOD INFRASTRUCTURE & CONDITION Pump Metering (Calibration) Strainer/ Filtration (correct beta ratio) Breather Remove water/ daily drain Space management ? Fast fill/ dry coupler adapter Bottom fill Floating suction Microbial inhibitor Safety Environment
Water In Lube Rises Contaminant
QUALITY Water content Microbial content Cleanliness (lab analyze) Lube properties (lab analyze)
Microbial Test
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
LUBE TRUCK/ SERVICE TRUCK
GOOD INFRASTRUCTURE & CONDITION Pump Metering (Calibration) Strainer/ Filtration (correct beta ratio) Breather Remove water/ daily drain Space management ? Fast fill/ dry coupler adapter Bottom fill Safety Environment
QUALITY Cleanliness (lab analyze) Lube properties (lab analyze)
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
EQUIPMENT USED OIL ANALYSIS
Periodic oil analysis can extend the life of equipment in excess of three times the normal or historic average. In addition, the cost of replacing equipment can be reduced by 50 percent or more. Opportunities for minimizing equipment failure, reducing the cost of analysis and extend the component lifetime. M. Williamson “First Line of Defense,” Issue of Lubricants World, May 2000
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
CATEGORIES OF OIL ANALYSIS TEST
Ashley Mayer Noria Corporation, "Using the Three Categories of Oil Analysis to Assist in Diagnosis". Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine. November 2006
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
SYSTEMATIC METHOD LUBE ANALYSIS INTERPRETATION, STEP BY STEP
1. Known sample and equipment conditions
No Equipment Component Type : Engine/ Transmission/
Hydraulic etc Component Hour Meter : Oil Hour Meter : 250/ 500/ 1000/ 2000 HM Oil Type : ISO VG, SAE Sample Date : 01/01/01 Name of Mechanic : Mr P Name of Company : PT. Sampling Location : Final Drive Left Side Additional Information :
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
2. Normalization
Terminology
• Baseline – This represents the original characteristics and properties of the new oil to be applied in the equipment (viscosity, AN, BN, additive content, oxidation stability, RPVOT for turbine oils). It is important to measure the baseline data from the beginning when implementing an oil analysis program.
• Caution Limits - Exceeding caution limits results in abnormal conditions and requires corrective actions.
• Critical Limits - Exceeding critical limits indicates a critical situation and requires immediate action.
• Goal-based Limits - These limits are set as predetermined values of properties (such as ISO code cleanliness, maximum water content, etc.).
• Aging Limits - These limits are a result of the oil’s normal aging process. For example: the highest permissible limit of acidity, oxidation or nitration; the lowest additive concentration, etc.
• Statistical Limits - These limits are statistically determined. Data average and standard deviation are obtained. Caution limit is set at an average of +/-1 standard deviation, and critical limit is set at an average of +/-2 standard deviations. Statistical limits may be applied to wear metals.
• Normalization - When collecting samples with different time intervals in reference to set frequency, it is easy to make mistakes and come to the wrong conclusions. Consider the following example: If the objective is to monitor iron wear every 500 hours and the data is 40 ppm (400 hours), 55 ppm (580 hours), 30 ppm (450 hours) and 68 ppm (500 hours), then the analyst observes which samples were taken at different time intervals Therefore, the data should be normalized in the following manner: For the first data, if during 400 hours the iron wear was 40 ppm, then what would the iron wear be in 500 hours? Answer: (40 ppm iron) (500 hours) / 400 hours = 50 ppm iron.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
NORMALIZATION WEAR METAL (FROM KOMATSU)
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Reff. On Site Analysis
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
3. Identification of oil properties
Identify and label each property measured by the categories for example: S for Properties, C for Contamination and D for Wear.
Viscosity (S) Acid Number (S) Water (C) Oil Cleanliness (C) Zinc (additive) (S) Silicon (both additive and contaminant) (S/C) Copper (wear metal) (D) Iron (wear metal) (D) Viscosity Index (S) Flash Point (S)
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
4. Baseline and last sample data analysis
Compare oil analysis results with baseline information. Refer to previous oil analysis results and review data of historical samples, then identify trends.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
5. Setting limits
Based upon baseline data, determine caution and critical limits for each property. These will vary based on factors such as machine type and criticality. Write the calculated caution and critical limits next to each property.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
6. Data qualification
Use the following terms to qualify the data.
Normal : when data value is less than or between caution limits. Trend data (B) : these values are between set limits but follow a particular trend (such as continuously decreasing or increasing, cyclic behavior, etc.). Problem/Abnormal (A) : these values are termed “pivots” and are used as reference points to qualify the report. Pivots are points that are out of critical limits
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
7. Partial conclusions
Note partial conclusions for each property
Properties - Viscosity (Normal), TBN (normal), additive content (normal), viscosity index (normal)
Contamination – Oxidation (Normal) Fuel (Normal), Soot (Normal) Water (Normal)
Wear - Abnormal, Cu out of limit
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
8. Pivot analysis, conclusions and recommendations
Upon completion, assemble all the notes together. If pivots (or trend data) indicate a relationship, analyze and summarize the findings. Avoid making early conclusions, and conduct a field investigation if necessary.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Additional Tool for Analyze and Recommendation
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
Puliyur Madhavan and Neal C. Werner, Pall Corporation, "Contamination Control for Extending Fluid Service Life". Practicing Oil Analysis Magazine. March 2005
Additional Tool for Analyze and Recommendation
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
MAINTENANCE CONCEPTCorrective Maintenance Action when failure occured.- High cost- Lost production
Preventive MaintenanceSchedule maintenance according to time - Over and under-maintained equipment- No root cause analysis
Perdictive Maintenance Condition-based maintenance. Consider the unique characteristics of each component- Increase production- Less overtime- Minor problem corrected early
Proactive MaintenanceCorrective action aimed at the root cause- Analyze and anticipate rather than react and repair- Reliability through oil analysis/ wear particle analysis- Reduce the number of breakdown failure
Predictive and proactive maintenance in industrial machinery is a proven strategy in extending equipment life and reducing downtime.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
FOLLOW UP PROACTIVE MAINTENANCEBased on Conditioning Monitoring
HOSE CLEANING FOR HYDRAULIC SYSTEM
KIDNEY LOOP FOR DIFF OIL, F/D OIL, HYDRAULIC OIL,FUEL TANK TO REDUCE CONTAMINATION AND WEAR GENERATE
ADDITIONAL BY PASS FILTER TO REDUCE CONTAMINATION IN HYDRAULIC SYSTEM AND SOOT IN ENGINE
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
CONCLUSION
Lube analysis is a powerful tool condition monitoring and an important contributor to heavy equipment plant reliability.
This technology can be applied in both predictive maintenance and failure root cause investigation and is a keystone of
proactive maintenance.
Total Fluid ManagementPamapersada Nusantara
TERIMA KASIH