opioid training institute (oti): pain management vs...

71
Damon Dozier M.D., M.S. 1 Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs Diversion Part 1

Upload: others

Post on 08-May-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Damon Dozier M.D., M.S.

1

Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs Diversion Part 1

Page 2: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Disclosure / Conflict of Interest

I, ___Damon Dozier M.D., M.S.___, have no actual or potential conflict of interest in relation to this program.

2

Page 3: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Objectives

• Define pain including distinction of acute versus chronic pain syndromes

• Discuss use of pain assessment tools in opioid naive patients and opioid experienced patients

• Describe a multi-modal pain treatment approach

• Review pros/cons for available non-opioid treatment options for pain

3

Page 4: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Damon Dozier M.D., M.S.

4

• Board Certified Pain Management and Anesthesiology

• President- Tennessee Interventional Pain Physicians

• Chairman- ASAP Montgomery County

• Vice President- Montgomery County Medical Society

Page 5: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

How do we treat pain?

5

• Some believe there is no place for opioids

• Some believe patients have a right to have their pain controlled

Page 6: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Many Choices

6

• Where does one start to treat Pain?

• Here CR suggests that they have the “NEWEST, SAFEST, and Most Effective treatments”

Page 7: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Acute Pain

7

• Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts lessthan 3 to 6 months, or pain that is directly relatedto soft tissue damage such as a sprained ankle or apaper cut

• Acute pain is of short duration but it graduallyresolves as the injured tissues heal. Acute pain isdistinct from chronic pain and is relatively moresharp and severe

Veritas Health version.2019.02.046-2019.02.008

Page 8: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and other professional and governmental organizations recommend that short-acting opioids in the LOWEST EFFECTIVE DOSE for the SHORTEST TIME-FRAME (</= 3 days) rather than long-acting or extended-release opioids, should be used exclusively for treatment of acute pain in opioid naïve patients. Immediate release opioids reach peak effect within 45 to 60 minutes, compared with three to four hours for controlled release (ie, slow release or prolonged release) opioids.

Acute Pain: Moderate to Severe degree Opioid therapy may be appropriate

8

Page 9: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Acute Pain

9

Commonly Prescribed:• Oxycodone 5 mg,

• hydrocodone 5 mg,

• codeine 30 mg,

• tramadol 50 mg

Pharmacogenetics

• Best to avoid the use of codeine because of interpatient variability in metabolism to morphine, and related adverse events and unreliable analgesia.

Page 10: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Acute PainBMJ.com

10

Page 11: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Chronic Pain• What is Pain? “An unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with actual or

potential tissue damage, or described in terms of such damage.” (IASP, 2018) Chronic is longer than 3 months (or longer than 6 months).

• Incidence of Chronic Pain: It is all in the Taxonomy 2011: 100 million, 43% (IOM, 2011) 2015: “Nearly 50 million American adults have significant chronic pain or severe

pain.” (NIH, 2015) 2015: 25.3 million, 11.3% (Nahin, 2015) 2018: Diabetes 9.5% (CDC, 2018)

• “Nonetheless, regardless of the exact number of people living with chronic pain in the United States, it clearly affects the lives of millions of Americans.” (NAS, 2017)

11

Page 12: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Chronic Pain• Chronic Pain Patients - Frequently marginalized (Peppin,

2009)

• Suicidal Ideation/self-directed violence increased with forced opioid discontinuation of (Demidenki, 2017)

• Public Misconceptions “Although there were many negative aspects to using opioids daily, the

positive effects outweighed the negative ... most of the negative aspects were socioculturally induced rather than caused by the drug itself.” (Brooks, 2015)

12

Page 13: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Multi-Modal Pain TreatmentMEDICATION:

Muscle Relaxants

Anticonvulsants

NSAIDs: oral, Topical

Analgesic-Acetaminophen, opioids

Vitamin: Vit-D3, B-complex.

Supplements: Turmeric, alpha lipoic acid

Antidepressants: Duloxetine, Venlafaxine

Mental Health: CBT

Mindfulness/Meditation

Exercise: PT, Tai Chi, Yoga, Home Exercise Program

Heat/Ice, TENS, Prosthetics

Acupuncture, Chiropractic

Surgical Intervention, Interventional pain Injections, SCS 13

Page 14: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

CDC Authors Warn: The Opioid Prescribing Guidelines Are MisinterpretedAuthors of the CDC guidelines say some state laws may be going too farBy Karen Lee Richards • ProHealth.com • May 31, 2019

• Opioid Prescribing in the United States Before and After the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's 2016 Opioid Guideline Amy S.B. Bohnert, PhD, MHS; Gery P. Guy Jr., PhD, MPH; Jan L. Losby, PhD, MSW

• Conclusion: Several opioid prescribing practices were decreasing before the CDC guideline, but the time of its release was associated with a greater decline.

Guidelines may be effective in changing prescribing practices.

>>Laws in Tennessee were being past by 2013 and reduced so-called ‘Pain Clinics’ by one third in the same year. (Many of which were Pill Mills).

>>Providers, third party payors, etc all needed REGULAR reminders (even to date) that the TN Opioid Guidelines and CDC Guidelines were intended for Primary Care Providers.

14

Page 15: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Under-treated Pain

15

Page 16: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Attorney Letter: seeking continued care

16

Page 17: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Treat the Whole Patient:Psychologic and Physiologic

• Both genetic and environmental variables contribute to the initiation of AND use of

addictive agents and to the transition from use to addiction. Addictions are moderately to

highly heritable. Family, adoption, and twin studies reveal that an individual’s risk tends to be

proportional to the degree of genetic relationship to an addicted relative.

Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2009 Apr; 85(4): 359–361. doi: 10.1038/clpt.2009.6

What are we treating:

Physiologic objective pain or Psychologic pain? (mood: subjective pain/low sense of wellbeing; Anxiety: neuroticism,

PTSD?)

IS THERE A TEST OR A QUIZ TO HELP DETERMINE THAT? TO AVOID PRESCRIBING FOR THIS PERSON. 17

Page 18: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Screening Tools SAMHSA (substance abuse and mental health services administration)

Despite the high prevalence of mental health and substance use problems, too many Americans go without treatment — in part because their disorders go undiagnosed. Regular screenings in primary care and other healthcare settings enables earlier identification of mental health and substance use disorders, which translates into earlier care. Screenings should be provided to people of all ages, even the young and the elderly.

• Sample Screening Forms • Depression Screening Tools • Drug & Alcohol Use Screening Tools • Bipolar Disorder Screening Tools • Suicide Risk Screening Tools • Anxiety Disorders Screening Tools• Trauma Screening Tools

SAMHSA.GOV18

Page 19: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

PharmacoGeneticsHepatic CYP2D6 enzyme metabolizes a quarter of all prescribed drugs, including codeine. CYP2D6 converts codeine in to its active metabolite, morphine, which provides its analgesic effect. However, pain relief may be inadequate in individuals who carry two inactive copies of CYP2D6 (“poor metabolizers”), because of reduced morphine levels.

In contrast, individuals who carry more than two normal function copies of the CYP2D6 gene (“ultrarapid metabolizers”) are able to metabolize codeine to morphine more rapidly and more completely. As a result, even with normal doses of codeine, these individuals may experience the symptoms of morphine overdose.

Crews K.R., Gaedigk A., Dunnenberger H.M., Leeder J.S., et al. Clinical Pharmacogenetics Implementation Consortium guidelines for cytochrome P450 2D6 genotype and codeine therapy: 2014 update. Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2014;95(4):376–82.

19

Page 20: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

20

Page 21: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

21

Page 22: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

22

Page 23: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

23

Page 24: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

TENNESSEE CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINES FOR OUTPATIENT MANAGEMENT OF CHRONIC NON-MALIGNANT PAIN 2019

• The purpose of these guidelines is to define appropriate treatment of chronic pain, a common and often serious condition. We want to foster timely and appropriate treatment for pain, which improves both the ability to function and quality of life. These guidelines are intended to be used to support clinicians in their treatment of patients with chronic pain with particular reference to the prescribing of opioid medications. We want to avoid addiction and adverse outcomes. Optimal treatment of chronic pain, defined as pain lasting longer than 90 days, is an interdisciplinary process that includes many interventions which do not always involve opioid pain medications.

• The method used to formulate these guidelines included a review of national expert panel recommendations and state practice guidelines, multiple listening sessions with clinicians in Tennessee, oversight by a multidisciplinary steering committee and recommendations from an advisory committee with strong representation by clinicians with specialty training in pain medicine. Draft clinical guidelines were also circulated to a broader group of professional associations within Tennessee, including but not limited to mental health and substance abuse and workers’ compensation programs.

24

Page 25: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Michigan's top doctor accused of overprescribing opioids; he says he's innocentGeorgea Kovanis, Detroit Free Press Published 9:47 a.m. ET May 31, 2019

• Failed on "several instances" to obtain or review reports from the Michigan Automated Prescription System, which monitors prescriptions dispensed to patients. Since June 1, 2018, doctors have been required by law to review MAPS reports before prescribing patients more than a three-day supply of a controlled substance, including opioids.

• Neff's response says the doctor failed on one occasion to review a MAPS report and requests that LARA not discipline him but issue him a warning.

• Failed to consistently use urine drug screens to monitor his patients' use of medication. Also continued prescribing high dose opioids to a Patient Jane Doe 4 — even though she refused to allow a urine drug screen because she said she was afraid of what might show up in the results. Urine drug screens are used to track whether patients are taking their medications and whether they are abusing them. ALSO, The complaint says that prescribing high dose opioids to Patient Jane Doe 4 "fell below the standard of care.“ ?WHAT IS HIGH DOSE?

• Neff's response says he did not provide substandard care and that there is no agreed-upon standard for how often urine drug screens should be performed — and that frequent drug screens can erode the relationship between a doctor and patient. 25

Page 26: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Michigan's top doctor accused of overprescribing opioids; he says he's innocentGeorgea Kovanis, Detroit Free Press Published 9:47 a.m. ET May 31, 2019

• •Prescribed "several patients" opioid medication in high doses that carried "significant risks."

• According to the LARA complaint, Neff continued to prescribe fentanyl pain patches to Patient Jane Doe 2 even though she removed the patches frequently because they didn't adhere well to her skin. The result: unused fentanyl that could be easily diverted.

• Neff's response says the patient was instructed to destroy unused fentanyl, that the LARA report has mischaracterized her dosage, and that she has agreed to taper her fentanyl dosage. (Drug Disposal units at Drug stores) DEA Drug Take Back, Count-IT Lock-IT Drop-IT)

• The complaint also maintained that Neff failed to sufficiently monitor Patient John Doe 1, considering he had psychiatric risk factors for abuse or diversion of the medication he received. >Neff's response says the patient was well-monitored.

• •Failed to note in a patient's file why he increased an opioid dosage. According to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines, providers should avoid or carefully justify increasing dosages higher than 90 morphine milligram equivalents a day. The complaint says that Neff increased Patient John Doe 3's morphine dosage from 960 to 1,000 The complaint also maintained that Neff failed to sufficiently monitor Patient John Doe 1, considering he had psychiatric risk factors for abuse or diversion of the medication he received. >Neff's response says the patient was well-monitored.

26

Page 27: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Dept. of Justice: ‘Rock Doc’ charged in opioid investigation April 17, 2019 by WBBJ 7 Eyewitness News Staff

JACKSON, Tenn. — The Department of Justice announced 15 individuals in West Tennessee are facing federal charges involving eight doctors and several other medical professionals in a massive opioid sweep.

According to the Department of Justice.In a news release Wednesday, the DOJ says Young a nurse practitioner allegedly

prescribed dangerous combinations of opioids and benzodiazepines, sometimes in exchange for sexual favors. The release says over the course of about three years, Young is accused of prescribing about 500,000 hydrocodone pills, 300,000 oxycodone pills, 1,500 fentanyl patches, and more than 600,000 benzodiazepine pills along with other controlled substances.

Nov. 7, 2018 after allegations that patient records were not properly maintained, controlled substances were prescribed improperly, and other allegations, according to the Board of Nursing.

The PrevenaGenix Clinic in north Jackson, where Young was practicing, was searched by federal investigators in January 2017.

27

Page 28: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

U.S. Attorney Dunavant along with Federal, State and Local Partners Continue Efforts to Combat the Opioid Crisis

Memphis, TN – D. Michael Dunavant, United States Attorney for the Western District of Tennessee, announced today the indictment of 15 West Tennessee residents for illegally distributing prescription opioids. Those indicted included several medical doctors and nurse practitioners. The indictments were part of a coordinated effort by several U.S. Attorneys and the Department of Justice’s Appalachian Regional Prescription Opioid Strick Force (ARPO).

The indictments are part of a long-term strategy sponsored by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of Tennessee to fight the opioid epidemic. The strategy has two prongs: the office’s work with ARPO and its sponsorship of the West Tennessee Heroin Initiative. The Office’s Heroin Initiative focuses on health care professionals who violate federal drug laws, as well as drug dealers who provide opioids to illegal users that result in overdose deaths. As part of this strategy, the U.S. Attorney’s Office works with federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies and prosecutor’s offices to identify, investigate and prosecute priority cases involving the distribution of prescription opioids, heroin, and fentanyl.

28

Page 29: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

29

U.S. Attorney D. Michael Dunavant said: "Opioid misuse and abuse is an insidious epidemic, created in large part by the over-prescribing of potent opioids nationwide, and unfortunately, Tennessee is at the center. We will not stand by and allow the harmful and oftentimes deadly practice of over-prescribing highly addictive drugs to continue unchecked. Along with our partners, the U.S. Attorney’s Office will pursue medical personnel who misuse their positions of trust to blatantly disregard and endanger others’ very lives for their own financial gain.“

The recent indictments are a result of the work of the ARPO Strike Force. The strike force is made up of prosecutors and data analysts with the HCF Unit, prosecutors with the ten U.S. Attorney’s Offices in the region, including the newly added Western District of Virginia, and special agents with the FBI, HHS-OIG and DEA. The ARPO Strike Force operates out of two hubs based in the Cincinnati, Ohio/Northern Kentucky and Nashville, Tennessee, areas, supporting the ten districts that make up the ARPO Strike Force region. In addition, the APRO Strike Force works closely with other state and federal law enforcement agencies, including the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation, State Medicaid Fraud Control Units. The partners involved in the Heroin Initiative include the Shelby County Sheriff’s Department, and the Drug Enforcement Administration.

Page 30: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

30

Listed below are those defendants currently in custody:

Jackson Branch Office:

Jeffrey Young, 45, Dr. Alexander Alperovich, Dr. Andrew Rudin,

Defendant Jeff Young, a Nurse Practitioner who branded himself the "Rock Doc," allegedly prescribed powerful and dangerous combinations of opioids and benzodiazepines, sometimes in exchange for sexual favors; over approximately three years, the doctor allegedly prescribed approximately 500,000 hydrocodone pills, 300,000 oxycodone pills, 1,500 fentanyl patches, and more than 600,000 benzodiazepine pills. Count one charges conspiracy to distribute and dispense controlled substances. Counts two through seven charges, unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances to a pregnant woman and aiding and abetting. Counts eight through fourteen charges, unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances and aiding and abetting. Count fifteen charges, maintaining a drug-involved premises and aiding and abetting. If convicted on the fifteen-count indictment, each faces up to 20 years imprisonment and $1,000,000 fine. Dr. Alperovich and Dr. Rudin are also charged in the conspiracy to unlawfully distribute and dispense controlled substances.

Page 31: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

31

Dr. Thomas Kelly Ballard, III, 61

Dr. Ballard is charged with controlled substances violations for allegedly prescribed approximately 4.2 million opioid pills, sometimes in dangerous combinations with other drugs, such as benzodiazepines, and prescribed opioids to known addicts. He is also accused of unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances to a pregnant woman. Count one charges maintaining a drug-involved premises and aiding and abetting. Counts two through seven charges, unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances and aiding and abetting. The U.S. will seek criminal forfeiture. If convicted, Ballard faces a term of imprisonment of note less than twenty years or more than life, a fine of$1,000,000.

Page 32: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

32

Mary Bond, 62, and Dr. Loran Karlosky, 39, Dr. Jay Shires, 35

Mary Bond is a Nurse Practitioner who operated her medical practice out of downtown clinic in Bells, TN. Her patients were drug seekers who came in groups from great distances to get their cocktails of controlled substances. Drs. Karlosky and Shires were aware of her dispensing drugs unlawfully, and actively participated in the conspiracy. Count one charges, conspiracy to distribute and dispense controlled substances. Counts two through seven charges, unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances and aiding and abetting. The United States will seek forfeiture from proceeds generated from this crime. If convicted, they each dace not more than twenty years and a fine of up to $1,000,000.

Glenn Bonifield Jr., 73 and Michelle Bonifield, 45 (state custody)

Glenn Benfield is a licensed pharmacist, and Michelle Bonifieldis a pharmacy technician in Bells, TN. Count one charges conspiracy to distribute and dispense controlled substance. Counts two through seven charge unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances and aiding and abetting. The U.S. will seek criminal forfeiture from these crimes.

Page 33: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

33

Britney Petway, 33 and Dr. Charles Alston, 48

Petway is a Nurse Practitioner who owned and operated Superior Health in Jackson, with Dr. Alton’s supervision. Pettway prescribed the Holy Trinity and opioid/benzo combinations on many occasions. She often left pre-signed scripts for non-medical professionals to dispense. Petway is charged with conspiracy to unlawfully distribute controlled substances allegedly prescribed over 500,000 Hydrocodone pills, approximately 300,000 Oxycodone pills, and approximately 300,000 benzodiazepine pills (mostly Alprazolam), along with a myriad of other controlled substances. If convicted, she faces up to twenty years imprisonment and a fine of up to $1,000,000.

Memphis Office:

Dr. Richard Farmer, 82

Defendant Richard Farmer was a doctor of psychiatry who issued prescriptions for controlled substances at his medical clinic in Memphis, without a legitimate medical purpose and often in exchange for sexual favors or companionship. He is also accused of unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances to a pregnant woman. If convicted, Farmer faces up not more than 20 years imprisonment and a fine of up to $1,000,000.

Page 34: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

34

James Litton, 43

A former Nurse Practitioner who issued prescriptions for controlled substance, including the Scheduled II controlled substances Alprazolam, Clonazepam and Carisoprodal at medication and healthcare fraud, including billing for diagnostic testing. Count one charges, conspiracy to distribute and dispense controlled substances. If convicted, Litton faces not more than 20 years imprisonment and/or a fine of $1,000,000.

Kathryn Russell

During an eight-week period, Russell, a Registered Nurse, prescribed opioids and other cocktails to drug seeks with no legitimate medical purpose. She was under the influence of drugs while employed at Dillion Russell Health Professionals, Inc., in Memphis. Count one charges, conspiracy to distribute and dispense controlled substance. If convicted, Russell faces up to twenty years imprisonment and a fine of up to $1,000,000.

Page 35: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

35

Dr. Michael Hellman, 72

Dr. Hellman prescribed large amounts of the Schedule V controlled substance promethazine with codeine to patients, including confidential informants, over a long period without any physical examinations. Counts one through three charges, unlawfully distributing and dispensing controlled substances. If convicted, Hellman faces a term of imprisonment of not more than 20 years and a fine of up to $1,000,000.

Dr. Thomas Hughes, 69

Dr. Hughes, a licensed encrinologist, is charged with a nine-count indictment with fraudulently dispensing Scheduled III controlled substances to himself for testosterone. Counts one through nine charges, obtaining a controlled substance by fraud and aiding and abetting. The United States will seek forfeiture from funds generated from these crimes. If convicted, Hughes faces up to four years imprisonment, a fine up to $250,000.

Page 36: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Multimodal Therapeutic

Strategies for Pain and

Associated Disability

Pharmacotherapy Opioids, nonopioids, adjuvant analgesics

Interventional Approaches

Injections, neurostimulation

Psychological Support

Psychotherapy, group supportLifestyle Change

Exercise, weight loss

Complementary and Alternative

Medicine Massage,

supplements

Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation

Assistive devices, electrotherapy

Fine PG, et al. J Support Oncol. 2004;2(suppl 4):5-22; Portenoy RK, et al. In: Lowinson JH, et al, eds. Substance Abuse: A Comprehensive Textbook. 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins; 2005:863-903.

Multimodal Therapeutic Pain Strategies

36

Page 37: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Treatment Goals

• Recovery from the underlying injury, surgery, or disease Reduce neuroendocrine stress Minimize impact of pain on

recovery

• Control and reduction of pain to acceptable level

• Minimize pharmacologic side effects

• Prevent chronic pain

• Restore function Physical, emotional, social

• Improve quality of life• Decrease pain Treat underlying cause where possible Minimize medication use

• Correct secondary consequences of pain Postural deficits, weakness, overuse Maladaptive behavior, poor coping

http://prc.coh.org/pdf/Goals-FF%205-10.pdf.

ACUTE PAIN CHRONIC PAIN

37

Page 38: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Non-Opioid Treatment options for pain

PROS

• Non-addictive

• Less risk**Medications(Interventional procedures have RISKs)

CONS

• Generally More expensive:

• Access issues:

Travel

Cost/Expense>insurance coverage

Comorbidities may prevent treatment

Limited duration of improvement

38

Page 39: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

39• Graphic.com.gh

Lumbar Spondylosis and Degenerative disc disease

Page 40: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

40

LUMBAR Spine Anatomy• Healthja

de.com

Page 41: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Taking 15mg Oxycodone TID PRN

41

Page 42: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Taking 15mg Oxycodone TID PRN

• 70 yo M with CLBP

• Vertebral body fractures, repair with Cement into Vertebral body seen on xray. Radiology report reveals incomplete resolution to fracture.

• Multilevel Severe Degenerative Disc Disease

• Scoliosis

• Multilevel Facet arthrosis

• Spinal Stenosis from retropulsion

42

Page 43: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Oxycodone 15mg TID PRN

43

Page 44: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

29yo M with c/o CLBP and BLE sciatica.• L4-L5: There is disc degeneration with mild central and lateral

disc bulging with associated small fissure or tear of the

posterior disc annulus at the midline causing slight thecal sac

compression with minimal left foraminal narrowing. There is mild

hypertrophic degenerative change affecting the articular facets.

No spinal canal stenosis.

• L5-S1: There is disc degeneration with a small

central/paracentral disc protrusion with associated small tear or

fissure the posterior disc annulus; disc material is in close

proximity to the intracanalicular portion both S1 nerve roots and

mild bilateral foraminal narrowing is seen. 44

Page 45: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Oxycodone 15mg TID PRN,Which patient is at risk for OUD?two Patients Which is Legitimate?

Severe disease• *Willing to trial spinal interventions

Facet Blocks and RFA.

• Appears in pain but well-kempt and low distress.

• Has failed Epidural trial

• Has failed medical management alone

• Has failed Complementary Therapies (acupuncture, chiropractic, Physical therapy, MOVE, CBT).

Mild to moderate disease• *Refuses Spinal Interventions.

• Appears in moderate distress poor to fair hygiene; is his distress apprehension about being able to continue his opioids (legitimately or not? He states he has never failed a UDS.)

• Has failed medical management alone, desires monotherapy with opioids

• Has failed Complementary Therapies (acupuncture, chiropractic, Physical therapy, MOVE, CBT).

45

Page 46: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

There Are Many Kinds of Pain Scales

46

Page 47: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

There Are Many Kinds of Pain Scales

47

Page 48: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

There Are Many Kinds of Pain Scales

48

Page 49: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

There Are Many Kinds of Pain Scales

49

Page 50: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Pain AssessmentPQRST• Provocation/Palliation

• What makes it worse? Better?

• Quality/Quantity• What does it feel like?• Sharp, stabbing, aching• Shooting, burning, stinging

• Region/Radiation• Where is your pain located? Travel?

• Severity Scale• How would you rate your pain 0 – 10?

• Timing• Is your pain constant or does it come and go?

Clinical Pearls of Pain Assessment• Beware of patients that can’t

describe their pain. Generalized pain.

• Beware of patients that change their primary pain complaint (nuanced)

• Beware of patients that show frustration with physical assessment or pain assessment

50

Page 51: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Pain Disability Index (PDI)

51

Page 52: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Pain Disability Index (PDI)Nine (9) variables predict PDI scores:

• time spent in bed• psychosomatic symptoms• education• work status• pain duration• usual pain intensity• quality of life • pain extent• Stopping activities because of

pain

High PDI scores indicate more:• psychological distress (p < 0.001),

• severe pain characteristics (p < 0.001)

• restriction of activities (p < 0.001)

Detection of malingering Higher scores reflect exaggerationmagnified by psychological factors

• Somatization

• malingered pain related disability

52

Page 53: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Opioid Risk Tool (ORT) Category Risk Factor Score if

FemaleScore if

Male

Family History of Substance Abuse

AlcoholIllegal DrugsPrescription Drugs

124

334

Personal History of Substance Abuse

AlcoholIllegal DrugsPrescriptionDrugs

345

345

Age Age 16-45 years 1 1History of Preadolescent Sexual Abuse 3 0

Psychological DiseaseADD, OCD, Bipolar Disorder, SchizophreniaDepression

2

1

2

1

Total Risk ScoreOCD, obsessive compulsive disorder.

Total Score Risk Category

• Low Risk 0–3• Moderate Risk

4–7 • High Risk ≥8

Webster LR, et al. Pain Med. 2005;6(6):432-442. Opioid Risk Tool. www.partnersagainstpain.com/printouts/Opioid_Risk_Tool.pdf. Accessed January 8, 2013. Reprinted with permission: Lynn Webster, MD. 53

Page 54: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

SOAPP — Sample Questions

Please answer the questions below, using the following scale:

0 = Never, 1 = Seldom, 2 = Sometimes, 3 = Often, 4 = Very Often

1. How often do you have mood swings? 0 1 2 3 4

2. How often do you smoke a cigarette within an hour after you wake up? 0 1 2 3 4

3. How often have you taken medication other than the way that it was prescribed? 0 1 2 3 4

4. How often have you used illegal drugs (for example, marijuana, cocaine, etc)in the past five years? 0 1 2 3 4

5. How often, in your lifetime, have you had legal problems or been arrested? 0 1 2 3 4Used for educational purposes only. 54

Page 55: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

SOAPP-R (revised)

• Smoking question salient question on SOAPP• Smoking may reveal addictive personality

55

Page 56: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Katz NP, et al. Clin J Pain. 2007;23:103-118; Manchikanti L, et al. J Opioid Manag. 2007;3:89-100; Webster LR, Webster RM. Pain Med. 2005;6:432-442; Chang Y-P, Compton P. Addict Sci Clin Pract. 2013;8:21; Boscarino JA, et al. Addiction. 2010;105(10):1776–1782.

BIOLOGICAL• Age ≤45 years• Gender• Family history of

prescription drug or alcohol abuse

• Cigarette smoking• Sleep disorder

PSYCHIATRIC• Substance use

disorder• Preadolescent

sexual abuse (in women)

• Major psychiatric disorder (e.g., personality disorder, anxiety or depressive disorder, bipolar disorder)

SOCIAL• Prior legal problems• History of motor

vehicle accidents• Poor family support• Involvement in a

problematic subculture

Risk Factors for Aberrant Behaviors/Harm

56

Page 57: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs)• Adverse Childhood Events have been found to correlate with Addiction and Opioid

Misuse.

• Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are a risk factor for health, social, and behavioral problems, including substance abuse and addiction. Persons who experience an adverse childhood experience are more vulnerable to these dangers from childhood into adulthood.

• Recognizing ACEs as risk factors for substance abuse can help to prevent drug and alcohol abuse.

• April 2, 2019

• Content source: National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Division of Violence Prevention

57

Page 58: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Pain Assessment Tools

• Brief Pain InventoryAssesses severity and impact of pain on daily functionsSelf-report or interview (5 min for short form; 10 min for long form)Validated and available in many languagesCopyrighted but free for individual practice

http://www.mdanderson.org/education-and-research/departments-programs-and-labs/departments-and-divisions/symptom-research/symptom-assessment-tools/brief-pain-inventory.html. Used for educational purposes only. 58

Page 59: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Pain Assessment Tools

• Universal Pain Assessment Tool

Visual / analog / linguistic pain scoring

Self-report or interview

http://www.partnersagainstpain.com/hcp/pain-assessment/tools.aspx. Used for educational purposes only. 59

Page 60: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Pain and Function Assessment Tools

• Graded Chronic Pain Scale

Pain and function assessment

Von Korff M. Chronic Pain Assessment in Epidemiologic and Health Services Research: Empirical Bases and New Directions. Handbook of Pain Assessment: Third Edition. Dennis C. Turk and Ronald Melzack, Editors. Guilford Press, New York., In presshttp://www.agencymeddirectors.wa.gov/Files/OpioidGdline.pdf. Used for educational purposes only.

60

Page 61: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Chronic Pain Conditions Can Be Classified Based on Type of Pain Pathophysiology

Three Main Types of Pain Pathophysiology

Nociceptive Neuropathic

Pain without identifiable nerve or tissue damage;

thought to result from persistent neuronal dysregulation, affective

system disorderEXAMPLES:

Any pain

Pain related to damage ofsomatic or visceral tissue,

due to trauma or inflammation

EXAMPLES:rheumatoid arthritis, osteoarthritis, gout

Pain related to damageof peripheral or central nerves

EXAMPLES:painful diabetic peripheral

neuropathy (pDPN), postherpetic neuralgia

SensoryHypersensitivity

Phillips K, Clauw DF. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2011;25(2):141-154. Adapted from Stanos S, et al. Postgrad Med. 128:502-515. 61

Page 62: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Spinal Cord Stimulation

62

Page 63: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Spinal Cord Stimulation (SCS)• FDA approved and Works well for patients suffering from pain into legs,

Sciatica/Lumbar radiculopathy/sacral radiculopathy.• Indications for spinal cord stimulation include failed back surgery

syndrome (FBSS), peripheral neuropathy, chronic regional pain syndrome (CRPS), phantom limb pain, post-herpetic neuralgia.

• Spinal Cord Stimulator Trial Requires Psychological testing to test for treatable psychopathology and evaluate for realistic expectations.

• Cost: ~$30,000.00• Efficacy: • Mechanism: Low-level electrical impulses, delivered directly into the spinal

cord through the SCS that is inserted in the epidural space, interfere with the direct transmission of pain signals traveling along the spinal cord to the brain. Therefore, the term dorsal column stimulation was replaced with SCS.

63

Page 64: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Spinal Cord Stimulator

• MECHANISM OF ACTION

The exact mechanisms of pain relief by SCS still remain unknown. The basic scientific background of the SCS trials was based initially on the Gate Control Theory of pain, described by Melzack and Wall [1]. In this theory, they proposed that the stimulation of large non-nociceptive myelinated fibers of the peripheral nerves (A-β fibers) inhibited the activity of small nociceptive projections (A-δ and C) in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord. However, it seems that other mechanisms may play a more significant role in the mechanisms of action of the SCS.

Published online 2012 Jun 28. doi: 10.3344/kjp.2012.25.3.143

PMCID: PMC3389317

PMID: 22787543

Spinal Cord Stimulation in Pain Management: A Review. Young Hoon Jeon, MD corresponding author 64

Page 65: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Interventional Spine Proceduresaka: ‘nerve blockers’

• Medial Branch Blocks (C, T, L)

• Radiofrequency Ablation

• Epidural Steroid Injection (C, T, L)

• Selective Nerve Root Block (transforaminal) Injection

• Interlaminar Epidural injection

65

Page 66: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

10 MEDD• 57yo F with 1 year history of severe pain preventing her from participating in

operating her small farm with her husband. Reluctantly, asking for Hydrocodone to allow her to participate in household tasks.

• LESI reduced her Sciatic/radicular pain 80% for past 5 months but she continues to have axial CLBP severe enough to prevent her from sleeping, standing or sitting comfortably for more than 5 minutes without shifting. She has Facet arthrosis and may benefit from LMBBs diagnostic and as appropriate LMB Radiofrequency ablation.

• Her PCP refused to prescribe 5mg Hydrocodone BID and referred her to the Pain Clinic.

• Obtain spine xrays

66

Page 67: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Lumbar Epidural: at L4-5 entry from right paramedian

67

Page 68: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Lumbar Medial Branch Blocks

68

• Observe the needles placed at the superior articulating process of the facet joints

Page 69: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Buprenorphine oral and injection/depo

• B.S. 58 yo M with addiction

• Overuse and abuse narcotics

• TFESI/Surgery

• Axial low back pain LMBBs

• Mental health, SI, being discharged in a rush only for recitivism,

• Cannot separate his Chronic pain from his mental health issues

• Xrays and goals

69

Page 70: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

Ketamine: for Pain; for Opioid Cessation

• Method: Oral, IV, IN

• Treatment of Pain:

Neuropathic pain

Chronic pain

• Opioid Cessation70

Page 71: Opioid Training Institute (OTI): Pain Management vs ...pharmacy.auburn.edu/oti/pdf/oti-painmanagement.pdf · Acute Pain. 7 • Acute pain is a type of pain that typically lasts less

I appreciate the opportunity to speak and share my perspective

71

Ronald Reagan

‘There is no limit to the amount of good you can do if you don't care who gets the

credit.’