on the edge? defensive strategies for roof perimeters

42
On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters Wilma Leung Williams Engineering Canada

Upload: wwmleung

Post on 16-Apr-2017

1.062 views

Category:

Real Estate


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Wilma Leung

Williams Engineering Canada

Page 2: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Roof OverhangsRoof Overhangs Roof ParapetsRoof Parapets Environmental Barriers Environmental Barriers

at Roof Perimetersat Roof Perimeters Changes in Changes in

Environmental Loads Environmental Loads on Roof Perimeterson Roof Perimeters

An Integrative Design An Integrative Design ProcessProcess

OutlineOutlinePhoto Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 3: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

CantileveredCantilevered AppendagesAppendages Inconvenient DetailsInconvenient Details No Man’s Land ?No Man’s Land ? Confluence of Confluence of

Contradiction ?Contradiction ?

Roof Perimeters: Overhangs & ParapetsRoof Perimeters: Overhangs & Parapets

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 4: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Frontline DefenseFrontline Defense Wind DamageWind Damage Snow DamageSnow Damage Ice DamageIce Damage

Deflect Rain & SnowDeflect Rain & Snow Control Solar RadiationControl Solar Radiation Support Support

GuttersGutters Walls Walls Slabs Slabs

ProtectProtect PeoplePeople Walls & OpeningsWalls & Openings Ground & FoundationGround & Foundation

Roof Perimeters: Overhangs & ParapetsRoof Perimeters: Overhangs & Parapets

Page 5: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Discipline-based Design Discipline-based Design PerspectivesPerspectives Overlaid ?Overlaid ? Optimized ? Optimized ?

Critical Early Stages of Critical Early Stages of Building DesignBuilding Design

IntegrateIntegrate Rain, Snow, IceRain, Snow, Ice Fire, Wind, DrainageFire, Wind, Drainage Durability, AirtightnessDurability, Airtightness Thermal SeparationThermal Separation Structural StabilityStructural Stability Environmental ChangesEnvironmental Changes

Roof Perimeters: Multidisciplinary Roof Perimeters: Multidisciplinary

Page 6: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Discipline-based Design Discipline-based Design PerspectivesPerspectives Overlaid ?Overlaid ? Optimized ? Optimized ?

Critical Early Stages of Critical Early Stages of Building DesignBuilding Design

IntegrateIntegrate Rain, Snow, IceRain, Snow, Ice Fire, Wind, DrainageFire, Wind, Drainage Durability, AirtightnessDurability, Airtightness Thermal SeparationThermal Separation Structural StabilityStructural Stability Environmental ChangesEnvironmental Changes

Roof Perimeters: Multidisciplinary Roof Perimeters: Multidisciplinary

“ “ If all you have is a If all you have is a

hammer, everything hammer, everything

looks like a nail.” looks like a nail.”

– – English ProverbEnglish Proverb

Page 7: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Vernacular & UniversalVernacular & Universal Control Indoor ClimateControl Indoor Climate Passive Solar StrategiesPassive Solar Strategies Protect from WetnessProtect from Wetness Evolved to incorporateEvolved to incorporate

Vented SoffitsVented Soffits Gutters Gutters

Roof OverhangsRoof Overhangs

Page 8: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Wildfire VulnerabilityWildfire Vulnerability Flame ImpingementFlame Impingement Ember ExposureEmber Exposure

Wildfire MitigationWildfire Mitigation Narrower OverhangsNarrower Overhangs Fewer JointsFewer Joints Screened Soffit VentsScreened Soffit Vents Choice of MaterialChoice of Material Removal of PlantsRemoval of Plants

Roof Overhangs: Potential ConflictsRoof Overhangs: Potential Conflicts

High Wind & Coastal AreasHigh Wind & Coastal Areas Intensified Wind SpeedsIntensified Wind Speeds Wind-driven RainWind-driven Rain Accelerated WeatheringAccelerated Weathering

Wind MitigationWind Mitigation Narrower OverhangsNarrower Overhangs

Page 9: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

No Moisture ExhaustsNo Moisture Exhausts BoilersBoilers DryersDryers KitchensKitchens Bathrooms Bathrooms

Aggravated DamageAggravated Damage Moisture to AtticsMoisture to Attics Rapid Freeze-Thaw Rapid Freeze-Thaw

CyclingCycling Porous Material: Wood, Porous Material: Wood,

Stucco, Concrete, PaintStucco, Concrete, Paint Mildly Acidic EmissionsMildly Acidic Emissions Neighboring BuildingsNeighboring Buildings

Roof Overhangs: No Exhausts BelowRoof Overhangs: No Exhausts Below

Page 10: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Seldom Professionally Seldom Professionally DesignedDesigned

High Risk Impromptu High Risk Impromptu Gutter InstallationsGutter Installations On Eaves with No OverhangsOn Eaves with No Overhangs For Low-slope RoofsFor Low-slope Roofs Mounted on Walls & Mounted on Walls &

ParapetsParapets Ends butting against a Wall Ends butting against a Wall

or a Sloped Roof Underneathor a Sloped Roof Underneath Inadequate First DefenseInadequate First Defense

Flow ConcentrationFlow Concentration Wind UpliftWind Uplift

Roof Overhangs: EavestroughsRoof Overhangs: Eavestroughs

Page 11: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Gutters for Colder RegionsGutters for Colder Regions Overhang 12” with Drip Overhang 12” with Drip

Flashing; OrFlashing; Or Roof Edge Made Roof Edge Made

WaterproofedWaterproofed Lower Gutter Position on Lower Gutter Position on

FasciaFascia Avoid Damming of Ice or Avoid Damming of Ice or

SnowSnow Avoid Being Damaged by Ice Avoid Being Damaged by Ice

or Snowor Snow

Roof Overhangs: EavestroughsRoof Overhangs: Eavestroughs

Page 12: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Assessing HazardsAssessing Hazards Icicles Icicles Snow CornicesSnow Cornices Overhead CablesOverhead Cables Plumbing VentsPlumbing Vents

Gable Overhangs:Gable Overhangs: Safe Zone for Entrances, Safe Zone for Entrances,

Parking, Prized Plants …Parking, Prized Plants …Note: Slanted Gables are Note: Slanted Gables are

more similar to Eaves.more similar to Eaves.

Eave Overhangs: Falling Ice & SnowEave Overhangs: Falling Ice & Snow

Page 13: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Temporary FixTemporary Fix ““Beware of Falling Ice”Beware of Falling Ice” Heat Trace mayHeat Trace may

Create Path for Water Create Path for Water to Drainto Drain

Create More IciclesCreate More Icicles

MitigationMitigation Reduce Freeze-Thaw Reduce Freeze-Thaw

FactorsFactors Reduce Heat Loss into Reduce Heat Loss into

Attic, and onto RoofAttic, and onto Roof ““Cold Roof” StrategyCold Roof” Strategy

Eave Overhangs: Falling Ice & SnowEave Overhangs: Falling Ice & Snow

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 14: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Prerequisites for Cold Prerequisites for Cold RoofsRoofs Well-insulated CeilingWell-insulated Ceiling Airtight Ceiling Airtight Ceiling

1 ½” - 5” High Air Space1 ½” - 5” High Air Space Eave Air Inlets to AvoidEave Air Inlets to Avoid

Warm Air SourcesWarm Air Sources Air Exhausts & Entrance Air Exhausts & Entrance

Doors Doors Façade with High Solar Façade with High Solar

Absorption MaterialAbsorption Material Stack EffectsStack Effects

Protects Roof in WinterProtects Roof in Winter Saves $ in SummerSaves $ in Summer

Eave Overhangs: Air Inlets for “Cold Roofs”Eave Overhangs: Air Inlets for “Cold Roofs”

Page 15: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Historically Promoted to Historically Promoted to Displace Wood OverhangsDisplace Wood Overhangs For Fire Protection BenefitsFor Fire Protection Benefits

Fire Resistant Unreinforced Fire Resistant Unreinforced Masonry Parapets Masonry Parapets Hazard for FirefightersHazard for Firefighters Hazard during EarthquakesHazard during Earthquakes

Main Functions Today Main Functions Today Proper Installation of Roof Proper Installation of Roof

Membranes and FlashingsMembranes and Flashings Protect Roof Assemblies Protect Roof Assemblies

from Wind Uplift, esp. at from Wind Uplift, esp. at Roof PerimetersRoof Perimeters

Guardrail, increasinglyGuardrail, increasingly

Roof ParapetsRoof Parapets

Page 16: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Parapets Higher than 1 m Parapets Higher than 1 m Significantly Reduce Significantly Reduce Wind Uplift on Flat RoofsWind Uplift on Flat Roofs Both Low- & High-RiseBoth Low- & High-Rise Esp. near Roof PerimetersEsp. near Roof Perimeters Marginal for Corner Marginal for Corner

Regions of Low-RiseRegions of Low-Rise Lower ParapetsLower Parapets

Significantly Increase Significantly Increase Local High Uplift Local High Uplift Pressures near Roof Pressures near Roof CornersCorners

Roof Parapets: Reducing Wind UpliftRoof Parapets: Reducing Wind Uplift

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 17: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Scuppers up to 1 m Wide Scuppers up to 1 m Wide Installed near Roof Corners Installed near Roof Corners Effective for Corner Regions Effective for Corner Regions

of High-Riseof High-Rise

Short Section of Open Short Section of Open Guardrail in lieu of Parapet Guardrail in lieu of Parapet Effective for Corner RegionsEffective for Corner Regions

Low Parapets, based on Low Parapets, based on Wind Exposure & Design Wind Exposure & Design Wind SpeedWind Speed Can Prevent Blow-off of Roof Can Prevent Blow-off of Roof

Aggregate of Prescribed SizesAggregate of Prescribed Sizes

Roof Parapets: Reducing Wind UpliftRoof Parapets: Reducing Wind Uplift

Page 18: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Waterproofed Parapet Waterproofed Parapet of Adequate Height to of Adequate Height to Prevent Liabilities fromPrevent Liabilities from Drainage BlockageDrainage Blockage Roof OverflowRoof Overflow Melting of Drift IceMelting of Drift Ice

Roof Parapets: Adjoining BuildingRoof Parapets: Adjoining Building

Page 19: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Proper Installation of Roof Proper Installation of Roof Membranes and FlashingsMembranes and Flashings

Reduce Roof PenetrationsReduce Roof Penetrations Piping & Wiring to Emerge from Piping & Wiring to Emerge from

ParapetsParapets Provide Support to Roof GrillageProvide Support to Roof Grillage

Protect & Enable Sustainability Protect & Enable Sustainability Roof ServicesRoof Services Green Roofs Green Roofs

FM Global Property Loss FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet 1-35Prevention Data Sheet 1-35

Height, Scupper, VegetationHeight, Scupper, Vegetation Biophilic / Food GardensBiophilic / Food Gardens Solar ArraysSolar Arrays

Roof Parapets: Multi-TaskingRoof Parapets: Multi-Tasking

Page 20: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Effectively ReduceEffectively Reduce Wall WettingWall Wetting Water InfiltrationWater Infiltration Staining on CladdingStaining on Cladding Damage to MasonryDamage to Masonry

Uncapped Concrete / Uncapped Concrete / Masonry Copings Masonry Copings Lack WaterproofingLack Waterproofing Exposed to Extremes of Exposed to Extremes of

Moistures & TemperatureMoistures & Temperature Slanted ParapetsSlanted Parapets

No Drip EdgesNo Drip Edges More StainingMore Staining

Roof Parapets: Cap Flashings & CopingsRoof Parapets: Cap Flashings & Copings

Page 21: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

High Wind Damage High Wind Damage Initiated at Roof EdgesInitiated at Roof Edges Starting with Lifting of Cap Starting with Lifting of Cap

FlashingsFlashings Membrane DislodgementMembrane Dislodgement Flying DebrisFlying Debris Punctures & TearsPunctures & Tears

Vortex SuppressionVortex Suppression Innovative Aerodynamic Innovative Aerodynamic

Roof Edge DevicesRoof Edge Devices Minimize Vortex UpliftsMinimize Vortex Uplifts Under Full-Scale TestingUnder Full-Scale Testing Double Damage ThresholdDouble Damage Threshold Cost-EffectiveCost-Effective

Roof Parapets: Protecting Cap FlashingsRoof Parapets: Protecting Cap Flashings

Photo retrieved from http://www.professionalroofing.net Photo retrieved from http://www.professionalroofing.net

Page 22: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Durable ContinuityDurable Continuity Connects Exterior Walls Connects Exterior Walls

with Roof Assemblieswith Roof Assemblies Air BarrierAir Barrier Vapor BarrierVapor Barrier Weather BarrierWeather Barrier Thermal BarrierThermal Barrier

Intersection Intersection Avoidable StressesAvoidable Stresses

Thermal BridgingThermal Bridging Air LeakageAir Leakage

Roof Perimeters: Environment BarriersRoof Perimeters: Environment Barriers

Page 23: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Avoidable StressesAvoidable Stresses Thermal BridgingThermal Bridging Air LeakageAir Leakage

Brick Veneer ParapetBrick Veneer Parapet Freeze-Thaw Cycling Freeze-Thaw Cycling

Accelerates DeteriorationAccelerates Deterioration Worsened by Coping withWorsened by Coping with

Inadequate Inadequate WaterproofingWaterproofing

No Cross SlopeNo Cross Slope No Drip EdgeNo Drip Edge Hence Water Absorption Hence Water Absorption

& Freeze-Thaw Damage& Freeze-Thaw Damage

Roof Perimeters: Environment BarriersRoof Perimeters: Environment Barriers

Page 24: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

The Source of Moisture The Source of Moisture Issues in Steel/Wood Issues in Steel/Wood BuildingsBuildings Improper Detailing e.g. Improper Detailing e.g.

Balloon FramingBalloon Framing Design Not Ready for Design Not Ready for

ConstructionConstruction Frost in AtticsFrost in Attics Ice-Damming Ice-Damming Efflorescence Efflorescence Spalling of Brick/MortarSpalling of Brick/Mortar Metal CorrosionMetal Corrosion

Allow to Dry OutAllow to Dry Out Durable MaterialDurable Material

Roof Perimeters: Air LeakageRoof Perimeters: Air Leakage

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 25: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Protected from Severe Protected from Severe Thermal CyclingThermal Cycling

Prefer Placing Air Barrier Prefer Placing Air Barrier within Insulation or on within Insulation or on Steady Temperature Side of Steady Temperature Side of Insulation (if compatible with Insulation (if compatible with air permeance of material)air permeance of material)

Air Barrier at Roof Deck Level Air Barrier at Roof Deck Level for Curtain Wall Panelsfor Curtain Wall Panels

Structurally Supported to Structurally Supported to Withstand Stack EffectsWithstand Stack Effects

Roof Perimeters: Durable Air BarrierRoof Perimeters: Durable Air Barrier

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 26: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Structural Designers Can Structural Designers Can Significantly Reduce Significantly Reduce Energy Consumption of Energy Consumption of BuildingsBuildings

Reduce Heat LossReduce Heat Loss Reduce Condensation on Reduce Condensation on

Interior Cold SpotsInterior Cold Spots Prevent MildewsPrevent Mildews Reduce Radiant Heat LossReduce Radiant Heat Loss

Raised Heel TrussesRaised Heel Trusses Provide Space for InsulationProvide Space for Insulation

Roof Perimeters: Thermal BridgingRoof Perimeters: Thermal Bridging

Page 27: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Reducing Thermal BridgingReducing Thermal Bridging Reduce Frequency of Penetration Reduce Frequency of Penetration

by Conductive Materialby Conductive Material Strengthen Structure Outside of Strengthen Structure Outside of

Insulation and Air BarrierInsulation and Air Barrier Reduce Need to Transfer Loading Reduce Need to Transfer Loading

Across Insulation and Air BarrierAcross Insulation and Air Barrier Use Lower Conductive Material Use Lower Conductive Material

FiberglassFiberglass Foam-glassFoam-glass High Strength FoamHigh Strength Foam Use Wood / Stainless Steel instead of Use Wood / Stainless Steel instead of

Carbon Steel when Structure Carbon Steel when Structure Penetrates Insulation or Air BarrierPenetrates Insulation or Air Barrier

Separating Separating Tempered Structural Core & FrameTempered Structural Core & Frame Exposed Structural Fins & ShellsExposed Structural Fins & Shells

Roof Perimeters: Thermal BridgingRoof Perimeters: Thermal Bridging

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 28: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Intermittent Connections, Intermittent Connections, Not Continuous Not Continuous

R R Stainless Steel Stainless Steel = 3 = 3 x x R R Carbon SteelCarbon Steel

R R Stainless Steel Stainless Steel = 12 = 12 xx R R AluminumAluminum

R R Wood Wood = 400 = 400 xx R R Carbon SteelCarbon Steel

Structural StabilityStructural Stability Capacity for Lateral Capacity for Lateral

ResistanceResistance

Roof Perimeters: Possible ConfigurationsRoof Perimeters: Possible Configurations

Page 29: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Roof Perimeters: Possible ConfigurationsRoof Perimeters: Possible Configurations

Page 30: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Roof Perimeters: Possible ConfigurationsRoof Perimeters: Possible Configurations

Page 31: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Design based on Historical Climate DataDesign based on Historical Climate Data Will Past Extremes Represent Future Conditions ?Will Past Extremes Represent Future Conditions ? Currently Projected ChangesCurrently Projected Changes

More Intense PrecipitationMore Intense Precipitation Increased Summer DryingIncreased Summer Drying Intensified Peak WindsIntensified Peak Winds

Higher Frequency of Damage Thresholds Being Higher Frequency of Damage Thresholds Being ExceededExceeded

Roof Perimeters Critical in Roof Perimeters Critical in Protecting Roofs & Walls Against Wind & Storm EventsProtecting Roofs & Walls Against Wind & Storm Events Mitigating Wildfire & Earthquake DamagesMitigating Wildfire & Earthquake Damages

Roof Perimeters: Changing Environmental LoadsRoof Perimeters: Changing Environmental Loads

Page 32: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

If Building Envelope Fails If Building Envelope Fails During a StormDuring a Storm

Damage to Contents Likely 2 to 9 Damage to Contents Likely 2 to 9 times Building Repair Costtimes Building Repair Cost

Disasters Trigger Sequence Disasters Trigger Sequence of Financial Events for of Financial Events for Insurers & Reinsurers Insurers & Reinsurers Supply of Reinsurance May Supply of Reinsurance May

DwindleDwindle

Roof Perimeters: Changing Environmental LoadsRoof Perimeters: Changing Environmental Loads

Page 33: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

2 Main Concerns for Building Envelope2 Main Concerns for Building EnvelopeDurability of Building Envelope Fabric to Weather Durability of Building Envelope Fabric to Weather Additional Environmental StressesAdditional Environmental Stresses

More Frequent Freeze-Thaw Cycles in Colder RegionsMore Frequent Freeze-Thaw Cycles in Colder Regions Potentially Increased Atmospheric Chemical DepositionPotentially Increased Atmospheric Chemical Deposition Initially Increasing UV LevelsInitially Increasing UV Levels Changes to Precipitation RegimesChanges to Precipitation Regimes

Impact of Weathering Over Time on Building Impact of Weathering Over Time on Building Envelope’s Envelope’s

DurabilityDurability Resilience to Extremes Resilience to Extremes

Increasingly Critical to Increasingly Critical to Resist WindResist Wind Prevent Moisture EntryPrevent Moisture Entry

Roof Perimeters: Changing Environmental LoadsRoof Perimeters: Changing Environmental Loads

Page 34: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Building Envelopes Adapt byBuilding Envelopes Adapt by Preventative MaintenancePreventative Maintenance Better Material Formulation Better Material Formulation Changes in Engineering PracticeChanges in Engineering Practice

More DurableMore Durable Greater ResilienceGreater Resilience

Parapets & Overhangs Parapets & Overhangs Increasingly Important inIncreasingly Important in Protecting Roof Equipment & Protecting Roof Equipment &

SurfacesSurfaces Prolonging Life of Vulnerable Prolonging Life of Vulnerable

Claddings, and hence Buildings Claddings, and hence Buildings Protecting Heritage Buildings Protecting Heritage Buildings

with Effective Water Shedding & with Effective Water Shedding & Waterproofing MeasuresWaterproofing Measures

Roof Perimeters: Changing Environmental LoadsRoof Perimeters: Changing Environmental Loads

Page 35: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Identify Performance NeedsIdentify Performance Needs Apply Building Science ThinkingApply Building Science Thinking Develop & Coordinate Design Develop & Coordinate Design

ConfigurationsConfigurations Integrating Performance NeedsIntegrating Performance Needs

Adequately Develop Adequately Develop Construction Details Construction Details

Meeting All Performance NeedsMeeting All Performance Needs

An Integrative Design Process An Integrative Design Process

Page 36: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Without Building Without Building Science Thinking At Science Thinking At Early Stages of DesignEarly Stages of Design Future Roof Perimeter Future Roof Perimeter

Issues can Expect to be Issues can Expect to be Challenging Challenging

Snap Decisions Leading Snap Decisions Leading to Increased Workload to Increased Workload and Expenses for and Expenses for Building Operations & Building Operations & MaintenanceMaintenance

Less Durable BuildingLess Durable Building Missed Prevention of Missed Prevention of

Hazards & NuisanceHazards & Nuisance

An Integrative Design ProcessAn Integrative Design Process

Photo Credit: Gord RajewskiPhoto Credit: Gord Rajewski

Page 37: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

An Optimal, Cost-Effective, Safe An Optimal, Cost-Effective, Safe & Durable Design& Durable Design Unlikely Arrived at by ChanceUnlikely Arrived at by Chance Unlikely Guided Solely by Minimum Unlikely Guided Solely by Minimum

Code and Legal Requirements Code and Legal Requirements Maximizing Real Estate ValueMaximizing Real Estate Value

Range of Considerations Available to Range of Considerations Available to AssistAssist

Rising Real Estate Value of RoofsRising Real Estate Value of Roofs An Integrative Design ProcessAn Integrative Design Process

Highest Degree of Accountability for Highest Degree of Accountability for Holistic Property ValueHolistic Property Value

Begins with Owner’s Project Begins with Owner’s Project RequirementsRequirements

Verifications at Building’s Verifications at Building’s CommissioningCommissioning

An Integrative Design ProcessAn Integrative Design Process

Page 38: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

An Expressive Atrium An Expressive Atrium Roof & Canopy Roof & Canopy

Largely Eliminated Largely Eliminated Nuisance of Rain, Snow Nuisance of Rain, Snow and Iceand Ice

Improved Usability of Improved Usability of Outdoor & Indoor Outdoor & Indoor SpaceSpace

Sheds Water & Snow Sheds Water & Snow onto Parapeted Roof of onto Parapeted Roof of CarportCarport

An Integrative Design ProcessAn Integrative Design Process

Page 39: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Building Science Thinking must be present at the early stages of Building Science Thinking must be present at the early stages of

building projects when geometries determining the performance building projects when geometries determining the performance

of roof perimeters would likely be defined.of roof perimeters would likely be defined.

ConclusionConclusion

Page 40: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

Cited References & Additional InformationCited References & Additional InformationStrathopoulos, T., Baskaran, A., (1988). Turbulent Wind Loading of Roofs with Parapet Configurations.

Proceedings of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering Annual Conference in Montreal, May 1987.

Retrieved from http://www.nrcresearchpress.com/doi/pdf/10.1139/l88-077

Crandell, J., Fischer, M. (2010, March). Winds of Change: Resolving Roof Aggregate Blow-Off. Proceedings of

the RCI 25th

Anniversary Convention and Trade Show, Orlando, Florida, March 25-30, 2010. Retrieved from

http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2010CTS-Proceedings-crandell-fischer.pdf

Morrison, R.V. (2011, July). Field Investigation of Aggregate Blow-Off of Spray Polyurethane Foam Roofs.

Originally presented at the Roofing Industry Committee on Weather Issues (RICOWI) Fall Symposium,

November 11, 2010, in Rock Hill, SC. Interface Magazine, July 2011. Retrieved from http://www.rci-

online.org/interface/2011-07-morrison.pdf

Ennis, M., (2010). Fire and Wind Resistance Standards for Vegetative Roofs. Proceedings of the RCI 25th

International Convention March 25 – 30, 2010. Retrieved from http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2010CTS-

Proceedings-ennis.pdf

Arthur, S., Wright, G.B., (2005). Technical Note: Recent and Future Advances in Roof Drainage Design and

Performance. Building Service Engineering Research and Technology 26,4 (2005) pp.337-348. Retrieved from

http://web.sbe.hw.ac.uk/staffprofiles/bdgsa/Scott Arthur Papers/BSERT - Advances in roof drainage design

and performance, Building Services Engineering Research and Technology Advances in roof drainage design

and performance Arthur and Wright.pdf

Hutchinson, T., (2010). The Roof as Platform. Proceedings of the RCI 25th

International Convention March 25

– 30, 2010. Retrieved from http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2010CTS-Proceedings-hutchinson.pdf

O’Brien, C., Banks, D., (2012, June). Wind Load Analysis for Commercial Roof-Mounted Arrays. Solarpro

Magazine, June/July 2012, 72-92. Retrieved from http://www.dnvkema.com/Images/SP5_4_pg72_OBrien.pdf

SPRI (2010). Wind Design Standard for Vegetative Roofing Systems. ANSI/SPRI RP-14. Retrieved from

http://www.greenroofs.org/resources/ANSI_SPRI_RP_14_2010_Wind_Design_Standard_for_Vegetative_Roo

fing_Systems.pdf

Maurenbrecher, A.H.P. (1998, December). Water-Shedding Details Improve Masonry Performance. Institute

for Research in Construction. Construction Technology Update No.23. National Research Council of Canada.

ISSN 1206-1220. Retrieved from http://archive.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/obj/irc/doc/ctu-n23_eng.pdf

Busque, P.M. (2010). Building Envelope Failure Case Studies in High-Rise Construction. Proceedings of the

BEST2 Building Enclosure Science and Technology Conference, April 12 – 14, 2010. Retrieved from

http://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.nibs.org/resource/resmgr/BEST/BEST2_EE4-2.pdf

Kazmeierczak, K. (2010, April). Review of Curtain Walls, Focusing on Design Problems and Solutions.

Proceedings of the BEST 2 Conference, Portland, Oregon, April 2010. Retrieved from

http://www.nibs.org/resource/resmgr/best/best2_008_ee4-1.pdf

U.S. Department of Energy (2000, December). Passive Solar Design. Technology Fact Sheet. Retrieved from

http://www.southface.org/factsheets/PSD-Passivesolar 00-790.pdf

Lockyear, S. (2012). Creating Redundancy in Building Envelope Design. STRUCTURE magazine, April 2012.

Retrieved from http://www.structuremag.org/Archives/2012-4/C-GuestColumn-Lockyear-Apr12.pdf

Quarles, S.L. (2001, August 31). Conflicting Design Issues in Wood Frame Construction. Prepared for 9th

Durability Building Materials Conference, Brisbane, Australia, March 2002. Retrieved from

www.ucanr.org/sites/wildfire/files/91481.pdf

FEMA (2011, August). Coastal Construction Manual. FEMA P-55, Volume II. Retrieved from

http://www.madcad.com/media/fema/FEMA-P55-Vol2-2011.pdf

Smith, T. (2010, June). Wind Safety of the Building Envelope. Whole Building Design Guide. Retrieved from

http://www.wbdg.org/resources/env_wind.php?r=envelope

Smith, T. (2011, October). Building Envelope Design Guide – Roofing Systems. Whole Building Design Guide.

Retrieved from http://www.wbdg.org/design/env_roofing.php

Roodvoets, D.L., Mallinger, T., Banks, D. (2009, March). Ice Dams or Shingle Degradation a Concern? A New

Tool to Predict the Ventilation Performance of Insulated Steep Roofs. Proceedings of the 24th

Annual RCI

International Convention and Trade Show, Dallas, Texas, March 2009. Retrieved from http://www.rci-

online.org/interface/2010-08-roodvoets-mallinger-banks.pdf

Flick, L.D., McGowan, L.M., (2012). Cold-Roof Design Practices and Performance Case Studies. Proceedings of

the Symposium on Building Envelope Technology October 2012. Retrieved from

http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2012-bes-mcgowan-flick.pdf

Buska, J., Tobasson, W., (2001). Minimizing the Adverse Effects of Snow and Ice on Roofs. Proceedings of the

International Conference on Building Envelope Systems and Technologies (ICBEST-2001). Retrieved from

http://www.crrel.usace.army.mil/library/conferencepapers/MP-01-5663.pdf

Dunne, T., (2002, January). Parapet Collapse: A Serious Danger for Firefighters. Fire Engineering Magazine.

Retrieved from http://www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-155/issue-11/features/parapet-collapsea-

serious-danger-for-firefighters.html

FEMA (2001, January). Seismic Protection of Nonstructural Components. FEMA E-74 Part 4. Retrieved

from http://www.fema.gov/media-library-data/20130726-1756-25045-3119/fema_e_74_part4.pdf

Lstiburek, J. (2011, June 16). Parapets: Where Roofs Meet Walls. Insight, BSI-050. Retrieved from

http://www.buildingscience.com/documents/insights/bsi-050-parapets-where-roofs-meet-walls

Page 41: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters

BibliographyBibliography

Carter, M., Stangl, R., (2012, June). Considerations for Building Design in Cold Climates. Whole Building Design

Guide. Retrieved from http://www.wbdg.org/resources/bldgdesigncc.php

Resso, F. (2010, September). Effective Low-Slope Roofing Begins with Secure Roof Edges. Interface

Magazine, September 2010, 21-26. Retrieved from http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2010-09-resso.pdf

Blessing, C., Chowdhury, A.G., Lin, J., Huang, P., (2009). Full-Scale Validation of Vortex Suppression

Techniques for Mitigation of Roof Uplift. Engineering Structures 31 (2009) 2936-2946. Retrieved from

http://wow.fiu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/3.-EngStructures_1.pdf

Levy, A. (2011, October). Performance Concerns with Wood-Frame Attics. Proceedings of the RCI Symposium

on Building Envelope Technology, October 10 – 11, 2011. Retrieved from

http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2011-BES-Dell-Finch-Hubbs-Levy.pdf

Quirouette, R., Marshall, S., Rousseau, J. (2000, November). Design Considerations for Air Barrier System.

Retrieved from http://www.cmhc.ca/en/inpr/bude/himu/coedar/upload/Design-Considerations-for-an-Air-

Barrier-System-OAA.pdf

Anis, W., Waterston, W. (2007, March). Air Barriers: Walls Meet Roofs. Proceedings of the RCI 22nd

International Convention March 1 – 7, 2007. Retrieved from http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2007-cts-

proceedings-anis-waterston.pdf

Goncalves, M.D, Rousseau M.Z., (2007). Design Considerations for Curtain Wall Parapets in Cold Climates.

Proceedings of the 11th Canadian Conference on Building Science and Technology, Banff 2007. Retrieved

from http://www.cebq.org/documents/CurtainWallParapetsinColdClimates.pdf

Structural Engineering Institute (SEI) /American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC). Thermal Bridging

Solutions: Minimizing Structural Steel's Impact on Building Envelope Energy Transfer. A Supplement to

Modern Steel Construction, March 2012. Retrieved from

http://www.modernsteel.com/Uploads/Issues/March_2012/032012_thermal_bridging_March_insert.pdf

Seifert, R. (2003, December). Attics and Roofs for Northern Residential Construction. The University of

Alaska Fairbanks Cooperative Extension Service. Building in Alaska. HCM-00559. Retrieved from

http://www.uaf.edu/files/ces/publications-db/catalog/eeh/HCM-00559.pdf

Auld, H., MacIver, D. (2007). Changing Weather Patterns, Uncertainty and Infrastructure Risks: Emerging

Adaptation Requirements. Proceedings of Engineering Institute of Canada: Climate Change Technology

Conference, Ottawa, May 2006. Retrieved from http://www.ipcc-wg2.gov/njlite_download.php?id=7166

Coleman, T. (2001). The Impact of Climate Change on Insurance against Catastrophes . Insurance Australia

Group, Melbourne, Australia. Retrieved from

http://stephenschneider.stanford.edu/Publications/PDF_Papers/IAG-Climate_Change_Paper.pdf

Auld, H., Klaassen J., Comer, N. (2007). Weathering of Building Infrastructure and the Changing Climate:

Adaptation Options. Proceedings of Engineering Institute of Canada: Climate Change Technology Conference,

Ottawa, May 2006. Retrieved from http://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2012/ec/En57-41-11-

2007-eng.pdf

Quirouette, R.L. (1986). The Air Barrier Defined. Building Science Insight '86, "An Air Barrier for the Building

Envelope". Retrieved from http://archive.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/ibp/irc/bsi/86-air-barrier.html

Baskaran, A. (2002, November). Dynamic Wind Testing of Commercial Roofing Systems. Institute for Research in

Construction. Construction Technology Update No.55. National Research Council of Canada. ISSN 1206-1220.

Retrieved from http://archive.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/obj/irc/doc/ctu-n55_eng.pdf

Carter, R. R., Smith, D. A., (2009, June). Parapet Effects on Full-Scale Wind-Induced Pressures. 11th

Americas

Conference on Wind Engineering, San Juan, Puerto Rico, June 22-26, 2009. Retrieved from

http://www.iawe.org/Proceedings/11ACWE/11ACWE-Carter.pdf

City of Toronto (2010). Green Roof Construction Standard and the Supplementary Guidelines. Office of the Chief

Building Official, Toronto Building. Retrieved from http://www.toronto.ca/greenroofs/pdf/GreenRoof-supGuidelines.pdf

Elkin, J.L., Ulmer, L.E., Polk, L.E., (2012, October). Rethinking Gutter Design for Steep-Sloped Roofing. Proceedings

of the RCI Building Envelope Technology Symposium, October 22 – 23, 2012. Retrieved from http://www.rci-

online.org/interface/2013-1-elkin-ulmer-polk.pdf

Hoff, J.L., Kane, E., (2010). The Durability Planning Matrix: A Useful Tool for Achieving Sustainable Building

Envelopes. Proceedings of the RCI 25th

International Convention March 25 – 30, 2010. Retrieved from http://www.rci-

online.org/interface/2010CTS-Proceedings-hoff(2).pdf

Lstiburek, J. (2008, June 8). Roof Design Research Report – 0404. Originally prepared for Builder’s Guide for Cold

Climates, 2004 Edition. Retrieved from http://www.buildingscience.com/documents/reports/rr-0404-roof-design.pdf

Morrison Hershfield (2011). Thermal Performance of Building Envelope Details for Mid- and High-Rise Buildings

(1365-RP). ASHRAE Technical Committee 4.4. Retrieved from

http://www.morrisonhershfield.com/ashrae1365research/Documents/MH_1365RP_Final_small.pdf

Novesky, M.E. (2011, October). Effects Causing Wintertime Condensation Particular to High-Rise Buildings.

Proceedings of the RCI Symposium on Building Envelope Technology, October 10 – 11, 2011. Retrieved from

http://www.rci-online.org/interface/2011-BES-Novesky.pdf

Prevatt, D.O., Acomb, G.A., Masters, F.J., (2012, June). Comprehensive Wind Uplift Study of Modular and Built-in-

Place Green Roof Systems. Florida Building Commission. Retrieved from

http://www.floridabuilding.org/fbc/commission/FBC_0812/HRAC/Task_2_Final_Report_Green_Roof.pdf

Straube, J.F. (2001, November 21). Pressure Moderation and Rain Penetration Control. Ontario Building Envelope

Council. Proceedings of Pressure Equalized Rainscreens: Design and Performance, 2001. Retrieved from

http://www.civil.uwaterloo.ca/beg/Downloads/Pressure_Moderation_Seminar.PDF

Straube, J. (2005). OAA Rain Penetration Control Practice Guide. Retrieved from

www.oaa.on.ca/images/docs/1305204815_Rain_Penetration_Intro.pdf, Guide_pg_15_-_28.pdf, Guide_pg_29_-_50.pdf

Page 42: On the Edge? Defensive Strategies for Roof Perimeters

Thank You

Wilma Leung

Williams Engineering Canada

On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters On the Edge? Defensive Strategies For Roof Perimeters