of assad threat took out heart u.s. says strikes

1
WASHINGTON — Defense De- partment officials said on Satur- day that American-led strikes against Syria had taken out the “heart” of President Bashar al-As- sad’s chemical weapons program, but acknowledged that the Syrian government most likely retained some ability to again attack its own people with chemical agents. Warplanes and ships from the United States, Britain and France launched more than 100 missiles at three chemical weapons stor- age and research facilities near Damascus and Homs, the officials told reporters, in an operation that President Trump and Pentagon leaders hailed as a success. “A perfectly executed strike last night,” Mr. Trump wrote on Twit- ter. “Thank you to France and the United Kingdom for their wisdom and the power of their fine Mili- tary. Could not have had a better result. Mission Accomplished!” The president, in declaring the mission accomplished, invoked a phrase made infamous by Presi- dent George W. Bush in 2003, when he declared success in an Iraq conflict that would end up continuing for more than eight years before American troops fi- nally withdrew. The strikes before dawn Satur- day in Syria — which came in re- taliation for a suspected chemical attack on civilians a week ago — were the second time in just over a year that Mr. Trump had sent mis- siles crashing into Syrian military targets, adding American fire- power to a civil war that is one of the most complex and multisided conflicts in a generation. Beyond the immediate question of whether the new strikes actu- U.S. SAYS STRIKES TOOK OUT ‘HEART’ OF ASSAD THREAT CHEMICAL PROGRAM HIT Allies Risk Becoming Even More Entangled in Syria’s Conflict By HELENE COOPER and BEN HUBBARD Continued on Page 8 The Syrian Scientific Research Center in Barzeh, near Damascus, was hit by American, British and French airstrikes on Saturday. HASSAN AMMAR/ASSOCIATED PRESS Jerri Plummer was at home in Arkansas, watching television with her three children, when a stranger called to warn that her life was in danger. The caller identified herself only as Yolanda. She told Ms. Plummer that the vaginal mesh implant supporting her bladder was defective and needed to be re- moved. If Ms. Plummer didn’t act quickly, the caller urged, she might die. Ms. Plummer, 49, didn’t ask many questions. Her implant was causing her discomfort, and she was impressed by how much Yolanda knew about her medical history. She was scared. “It was like I had a ticking time bomb in- side of me,” she said. Yolanda as- sured Ms. Plummer that all her expenses would be covered and that she would be set up with a lawyer to help her sue the mesh manufacturer, Boston Scientific. Days later, court records show, Ms. Plummer was lying on an op- erating table in a medical office in a shopping mall in Orlando, Fla. Just like that, she had stumbled into a burgeoning industry that makes money by coaxing women into having surgery — sometimes unnecessarily — so that they are more lucrative plaintiffs in law- suits against medical device man- ufacturers. Lawyers building such cases sometimes turn to marketing firms to drum up clients. The mar- keters turn to finance companies to provide high-interest loans to the clients that have to be repaid only if the clients receive money from the case. Those loans are then used to pay for surgery per- formed by doctors who are often lined up by the marketers. Interviews with dozens of wom- en, lawyers, finance executives and marketers, as well as a review of court records and confidential documents, indicate that hun- dreds, perhaps thousands, of women have been sucked into this assembly-line-like system. It is fu- eled by banks, private equity firms and hedge funds, which pro- vide financial backing. How Profiteers Coax Women Into Surgery Bolstering Effort to Sue Medical Companies By MATTHEW GOLDSTEIN and JESSICA SILVER-GREENBERG Continued on Page 22 WASHINGTON — On the morning after, President Trump declared success. The surgical strike against chemical weapons facilities in Syria had been executed perfectly, he said on Saturday. “Mis- sion Accom- plished!” he wrote on Twitter. That’s a phrase presidents and politicians have studiously avoided since President George W. Bush’s ill-fated aircraft carrier visit prematurely declaring success in the Iraq war. But aside from the curious choice of words, it raised the essential question regarding Syria going beyond the one-time strike: What ex- actly is the mission? For most of Mr. Trump’s presi- dency, it has been to defeat the Islamic State and then get out. But what Mr. Trump outlined in his televised speech to the nation on Friday night was something more complicated. He promised a sustained campaign to stop Syria’s government from again using chemical weapons on its own people, while also emphasiz- ing the limits of America’s ability or willingness to do more to stop the broader bloodletting that has Talk of ‘Mission Accomplished!’ But Mission in Syria Is Unclear. By PETER BAKER NEWS ANALYSIS Continued on Page 12 The Harry Potter economy is filled with jaw-dropping numbers, including 500 million books sold and $7.7 billion in worldwide film grosses. Here’s another one: “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child,” a two-part drama now in previews and opening April 22, cost about $68.5 million to bring to Broad- way, including not only $35.5 mil- lion to capitalize the show — more than for any other nonmusical play in history — but also another $33 million to clear out and redo the theater. It’s a huge bet in a flop-prone in- dustry, but also a seemingly safe one, predicated on the expectation that “Cursed Child” will become a big hit on Broadway, a long-run- ning production that can spin off profits for years. “That’s a ton of money, no ques- tion about it, in terms of what things cost around here, but it’s Harry Potter, one of the most pop- ular brands in the history of brands,” said Tom Viertel, the ex- ecutive director of the Commer- cial Theater Institute. “It has a ti- tle the likes of which we would rarely, if ever, get to see on Broad- way.” Even in previews, as the cast finds its footing and the creative team makes adjustments, the show is setting box-office records. Potter fans have been filling up the Lyric, one of Broadway’s larg- est theaters, and the $2.1 million the play took in during the first week of April was more than any play had previously grossed in a single week. The record-setting $35.5 million capitalization the amount raised from producers and invest- ors to pay an unusually large cast and crew, rehearse an unusually long show and build an unusually elaborate production — was dis- closed in a filing with the Securi- ties and Exchange Commission. By comparison, most nonmusical plays on Broadway are between $3 million and $5 million, and even the splashiest musicals rarely top more than $25 million. But the capitalization is only a portion of what it took to pave the way for “Cursed Child” to get to Broadway. The Ambassador Theater Group, the British theater giant that operates the Lyric, spent about $23 million to persuade its previous occupant, Cirque du Soleil, to shutter its “Paramour” musical and make way for “Cursed Child,” according to two people with knowledge of the transaction. Ambassador, which competed It cost $33 million to clear out and redo the theater for the Harry Potter show, the most expensive Broadway nonmusical ever. DOROTHY HONG Continued on Page 18 Harry Potter Feathers His Nest for $68 Million Broadway Drama By MICHAEL PAULSON Joseph Robertson gives new meaning to the idea of a pensioner. An eye surgeon who retired as president of the Oregon Health & Science University last fall, Dr. Robertson receives the state’s largest government pension. It is $76,111. Per month. That is considerably more than the average Oregon family earns in a year. Oregon — like many other states and cities, including New Jersey, Kentucky and Connecticut — is caught in a fiscal squeeze of its own making. Its economy is growing, but the cost of its state- run pension system is growing faster. More government workers are retiring, including more than 2,000, like Dr. Robertson, who get pensions exceeding $100,000 a year. The state is not the most profli- gate pension payer in America, but its spiraling costs are notable in part because Oregon enjoys a reputation for fiscal discipline. Its experience shows how faulty fi- nancial decisions by states can eventually swamp local communi- ties. Oregon’s costs are inflated by Strange Pension Math Leaves States in Pinch of Own Making By MARY WILLIAMS WALSH Nathan Cherpeski, the man- ager of Klamath Falls, Ore. Its pension bills have jumped. LEAH NASH FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page 24 RUSSIA Condemnation from Pres- ident Vladimir V. Putin, but a sense of relief in Moscow. PAGE 10 In Indonesia, followers of ancient tradi- tional beliefs are hoping a court ruling will finally end decades of unofficial discrimination. PAGE 6 INTERNATIONAL 4-15 A Fight for Indigenous Rights Bill Gates once made it clear to Con- gress that he wouldn’t change his ways for Washington. Mark Zuckerberg took a different tack last week. PAGE 3 SUNDAY BUSINESS Two Tech Titans. Two Tacks. Six months after being fitted for a metal halo to heal a broken vertebra, an elite triathlete plans to run the Boston Mara- thon in 2 hours 50 minutes. PAGE 1 SPORTSSUNDAY His Therapy: A ‘Torture Device’ U(D5E71D)x+=!,!/!=!: Frank Bruni PAGE 1 SUNDAY REVIEW WASHINGTON — When Syria shipped what it claimed was the last of its chemical weapons out of the country in 2014, John Kerry, the secretary of state at the time, declared that it showed that skill- ful diplomacy could achieve far more than attacks on a few facili- ties. “We struck a deal where we got 100 percent of the chemical weap- ons out,” he said a few weeks later, as an American ship destroyed 600 metric tons of poisonous agents. A year ago, after President Trump rejected the Obama-era approach as naïve, he bombed an airfield where a new chemical at- tack by the Syrian president, Ba- shar al-Assad, had originated. Mr. Trump’s newly appointed national security adviser, Lt. Gen. H. R. McMaster, predicted “a big shift on Assad’s calculus,” because it was “the first time the United States has taken direct military action.” Years of bitter experience in Syria have shown that Mr. Kerry’s assessment was wrong, and Gen- eral McMaster’s was far too opti- mistic. Those lessons may now be inescapable: After Saturday’s predawn strike in Syria on three Lesson Learned the Hard Way: Assad Can Still Gas His People By DAVID E. SANGER and BEN HUBBARD Continued on Page 10 News reports have implied that the 95-year-old co-creator of Spider-Man and Black Panther is a victim of elder abuse. He says that’s not so. PAGE 1 SUNDAY STYLES Is Stan Lee a Prisoner? Late Edition VOL. CLXVII . . No. 57,933 © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2018 Today, rain and drizzle, breezy, much colder, high 42. Tonight, rain and drizzle, low 41. Tomorrow, heavy rain, thunderstorms, high 60. Details in SportsSunday, Page 10. $6.00

Upload: others

Post on 05-Nov-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

C M Y K Nxxx,2018-04-15,A,001,Bs-4C,E3

WASHINGTON — Defense De-partment officials said on Satur-day that American-led strikesagainst Syria had taken out the“heart” of President Bashar al-As-sad’s chemical weapons program,but acknowledged that the Syriangovernment most likely retainedsome ability to again attack itsown people with chemical agents.

Warplanes and ships from theUnited States, Britain and Francelaunched more than 100 missilesat three chemical weapons stor-age and research facilities nearDamascus and Homs, the officialstold reporters, in an operation thatPresident Trump and Pentagonleaders hailed as a success.

“A perfectly executed strike lastnight,” Mr. Trump wrote on Twit-ter. “Thank you to France and theUnited Kingdom for their wisdomand the power of their fine Mili-tary. Could not have had a betterresult. Mission Accomplished!”

The president, in declaring themission accomplished, invoked aphrase made infamous by Presi-dent George W. Bush in 2003,when he declared success in anIraq conflict that would end upcontinuing for more than eightyears before American troops fi-nally withdrew.

The strikes before dawn Satur-day in Syria — which came in re-taliation for a suspected chemicalattack on civilians a week ago —were the second time in just over ayear that Mr. Trump had sent mis-siles crashing into Syrian militarytargets, adding American fire-power to a civil war that is one ofthe most complex and multisidedconflicts in a generation.

Beyond the immediate questionof whether the new strikes actu-

U.S. SAYS STRIKESTOOK OUT ‘HEART’OF ASSAD THREAT

CHEMICAL PROGRAM HIT

Allies Risk BecomingEven More Entangled

in Syria’s Conflict

By HELENE COOPERand BEN HUBBARD

Continued on Page 8

The Syrian Scientific Research Center in Barzeh, near Damascus, was hit by American, British and French airstrikes on Saturday.HASSAN AMMAR/ASSOCIATED PRESS

Jerri Plummer was at home inArkansas, watching televisionwith her three children, when astranger called to warn that herlife was in danger.

The caller identified herselfonly as Yolanda. She told Ms.Plummer that the vaginal meshimplant supporting her bladderwas defective and needed to be re-moved. If Ms. Plummer didn’t actquickly, the caller urged, shemight die.

Ms. Plummer, 49, didn’t askmany questions. Her implant wascausing her discomfort, and shewas impressed by how muchYolanda knew about her medicalhistory. She was scared. “It waslike I had a ticking time bomb in-side of me,” she said. Yolanda as-sured Ms. Plummer that all herexpenses would be covered andthat she would be set up with alawyer to help her sue the meshmanufacturer, Boston Scientific.

Days later, court records show,Ms. Plummer was lying on an op-erating table in a medical office ina shopping mall in Orlando, Fla.

Just like that, she had stumbledinto a burgeoning industry thatmakes money by coaxing womeninto having surgery — sometimesunnecessarily — so that they aremore lucrative plaintiffs in law-suits against medical device man-ufacturers.

Lawyers building such casessometimes turn to marketingfirms to drum up clients. The mar-keters turn to finance companiesto provide high-interest loans tothe clients that have to be repaidonly if the clients receive moneyfrom the case. Those loans arethen used to pay for surgery per-formed by doctors who are oftenlined up by the marketers.

Interviews with dozens of wom-en, lawyers, finance executivesand marketers, as well as a reviewof court records and confidentialdocuments, indicate that hun-dreds, perhaps thousands, ofwomen have been sucked into thisassembly-line-like system. It is fu-eled by banks, private equityfirms and hedge funds, which pro-vide financial backing.

How ProfiteersCoax Women

Into Surgery

Bolstering Effort to SueMedical Companies

By MATTHEW GOLDSTEIN and JESSICA SILVER-GREENBERG

Continued on Page 22

WASHINGTON — On themorning after, President Trumpdeclared success. The surgicalstrike against chemical weapons

facilities in Syriahad been executedperfectly, he saidon Saturday. “Mis-sion Accom-

plished!” he wrote on Twitter.That’s a phrase presidents and

politicians have studiouslyavoided since President GeorgeW. Bush’s ill-fated aircraft carriervisit prematurely declaringsuccess in the Iraq war. But asidefrom the curious choice of words,it raised the essential question

regarding Syria going beyondthe one-time strike: What ex-actly is the mission?

For most of Mr. Trump’s presi-dency, it has been to defeat theIslamic State and then get out.But what Mr. Trump outlined inhis televised speech to the nationon Friday night was somethingmore complicated. He promiseda sustained campaign to stopSyria’s government from againusing chemical weapons on itsown people, while also emphasiz-ing the limits of America’s abilityor willingness to do more to stopthe broader bloodletting that has

Talk of ‘Mission Accomplished!’But Mission in Syria Is Unclear.

By PETER BAKER

NEWSANALYSIS

Continued on Page 12

The Harry Potter economy isfilled with jaw-dropping numbers,including 500 million books soldand $7.7 billion in worldwide filmgrosses.

Here’s another one: “HarryPotter and the Cursed Child,” atwo-part drama now in previewsand opening April 22, cost about$68.5 million to bring to Broad-way, including not only $35.5 mil-lion to capitalize the show — morethan for any other nonmusicalplay in history — but also another$33 million to clear out and redothe theater.

It’s a huge bet in a flop-prone in-dustry, but also a seemingly safeone, predicated on the expectationthat “Cursed Child” will become abig hit on Broadway, a long-run-ning production that can spin offprofits for years.

“That’s a ton of money, no ques-tion about it, in terms of whatthings cost around here, but it’sHarry Potter, one of the most pop-ular brands in the history ofbrands,” said Tom Viertel, the ex-ecutive director of the Commer-

cial Theater Institute. “It has a ti-tle the likes of which we wouldrarely, if ever, get to see on Broad-way.”

Even in previews, as the castfinds its footing and the creative

team makes adjustments, theshow is setting box-office records.Potter fans have been filling upthe Lyric, one of Broadway’s larg-est theaters, and the $2.1 millionthe play took in during the first

week of April was more than anyplay had previously grossed in asingle week.

The record-setting $35.5 millioncapitalization — the amountraised from producers and invest-ors to pay an unusually large castand crew, rehearse an unusuallylong show and build an unusuallyelaborate production — was dis-closed in a filing with the Securi-ties and Exchange Commission.By comparison, most nonmusicalplays on Broadway are between$3 million and $5 million, and eventhe splashiest musicals rarely topmore than $25 million.

But the capitalization is only aportion of what it took to pave theway for “Cursed Child” to get toBroadway.

The Ambassador TheaterGroup, the British theater giantthat operates the Lyric, spentabout $23 million to persuade itsprevious occupant, Cirque duSoleil, to shutter its “Paramour”musical and make way for“Cursed Child,” according to twopeople with knowledge of thetransaction.

Ambassador, which competed

It cost $33 million to clear out and redo the theater for the HarryPotter show, the most expensive Broadway nonmusical ever.

DOROTHY HONG

Continued on Page 18

Harry Potter Feathers His Nest for $68 Million Broadway DramaBy MICHAEL PAULSON

Joseph Robertson gives newmeaning to the idea of a pensioner.

An eye surgeon who retired aspresident of the Oregon Health &Science University last fall, Dr.Robertson receives the state’slargest government pension.

It is $76,111.Per month.That is considerably more than

the average Oregon family earnsin a year.

Oregon — like many otherstates and cities, including NewJersey, Kentucky and Connecticut— is caught in a fiscal squeeze ofits own making. Its economy isgrowing, but the cost of its state-run pension system is growingfaster. More government workersare retiring, including more than2,000, like Dr. Robertson, who getpensions exceeding $100,000 ayear.

The state is not the most profli-gate pension payer in America,but its spiraling costs are notable

in part because Oregon enjoys areputation for fiscal discipline. Itsexperience shows how faulty fi-nancial decisions by states caneventually swamp local communi-ties.

Oregon’s costs are inflated by

Strange Pension Math LeavesStates in Pinch of Own Making

By MARY WILLIAMS WALSH

Nathan Cherpeski, the man-ager of Klamath Falls, Ore. Itspension bills have jumped.

LEAH NASH FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page 24

RUSSIA Condemnation from Pres-ident Vladimir V. Putin, but asense of relief in Moscow. PAGE 10

In Indonesia, followers of ancient tradi-tional beliefs are hoping a court rulingwill finally end decades of unofficialdiscrimination. PAGE 6

INTERNATIONAL 4-15

A Fight for Indigenous RightsBill Gates once made it clear to Con-gress that he wouldn’t change his waysfor Washington. Mark Zuckerberg tooka different tack last week. PAGE 3

SUNDAY BUSINESS

Two Tech Titans. Two Tacks.Six months after being fitted for a metalhalo to heal a broken vertebra, an elitetriathlete plans to run the Boston Mara-thon in 2 hours 50 minutes. PAGE 1

SPORTSSUNDAY

His Therapy: A ‘Torture Device’

U(D5E71D)x+=!,!/!=!:

Frank Bruni PAGE 1

SUNDAY REVIEW

WASHINGTON — When Syriashipped what it claimed was thelast of its chemical weapons out ofthe country in 2014, John Kerry,the secretary of state at the time,declared that it showed that skill-ful diplomacy could achieve farmore than attacks on a few facili-ties.

“We struck a deal where we got100 percent of the chemical weap-ons out,” he said a few weeks later,as an American ship destroyed600 metric tons of poisonousagents.

A year ago, after PresidentTrump rejected the Obama-eraapproach as naïve, he bombed an

airfield where a new chemical at-tack by the Syrian president, Ba-shar al-Assad, had originated. Mr.Trump’s newly appointed nationalsecurity adviser, Lt. Gen. H. R.McMaster, predicted “a big shifton Assad’s calculus,” because itwas “the first time the UnitedStates has taken direct militaryaction.”

Years of bitter experience inSyria have shown that Mr. Kerry’sassessment was wrong, and Gen-eral McMaster’s was far too opti-mistic. Those lessons may now beinescapable: After Saturday’spredawn strike in Syria on three

Lesson Learned the Hard Way:Assad Can Still Gas His People

By DAVID E. SANGER and BEN HUBBARD

Continued on Page 10

News reports have implied that the95-year-old co-creator of Spider-Manand Black Panther is a victim of elderabuse. He says that’s not so. PAGE 1

SUNDAY STYLES

Is Stan Lee a Prisoner?

Late Edition

VOL. CLXVII . . No. 57,933 © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, SUNDAY, APRIL 15, 2018

Today, rain and drizzle, breezy,much colder, high 42. Tonight, rainand drizzle, low 41. Tomorrow,heavy rain, thunderstorms, high 60.Details in SportsSunday, Page 10.

$6.00