november - west virginia legislature november 10, 1998 ... review of legislative rules: a. ......

22
NOVEMBER

Upload: hoangphuc

Post on 12-Apr-2018

234 views

Category:

Documents


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

NOVEMBER

Page 2: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

1.

2.

TENTATIVE AGENDALEGISLATIVE RULE-MAKING REVIEW COMMITTEE

Tuesday, November 10, 1998

Beginning at 9:30 a.m.Senate Finance Gommittee Room M451

Approval of Minutes - Meetings of October 19 and 20, 1998

Review of Legislative Rules:

a. West Virginia State Treasureds OfficeRule for Enforcement of the lJniform Unclaimed Property Act, 112CSR5

b. State Tax CommissionValue of Timberland and Managed Timberland, 110CSR1 H

c. Governor's Committee on Crime Delinquency and CorrectionLaw Enforcement Training Standards, 149CSR2

d. State Tax CommissionValuation of Active and Reserue Coal Property for Ad Valorem Property TaxPurposes, 110CSR1l

State Tax CommissionTax Credits for New Value-Added Wood Manufactuing Facilities, 110CSR13M

State Tax CommissionTax Credits for New Sfeel Aluminum or Polymer Manufacturing Operations,1 1 OCSRI 3N

State Tax CommissionElectronic Data Processrng Sysfem Network for Property Tax Administration,1 1 OCSR2

Board of AcupunctureApplications for Licensure to Practice Acupuncture, 32CSR3

Board of AcupunctureFees of the Board of Acupuncture, 32CSR4

Board of AcupunctureAdveftising By Licensed Acupunctuists, 32CSR5

Board of AcupunctureStandards of Practice Of Acupuncture by Licensed Acupuncfunsfs, 32CSR6

e.

f.

g-

h.

J.

k.

Page 3: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

m.

Board of AcupunctureDisciplinary and Complaint Procedures for Acupuncturists, 32CSR7

Board of AcupunctureContin uing Education Reqgiremenfs, 32CSR9

Board of AcupunctureCode of Ethics for Licensed Acupuncfunsfs, 32CSR10

Board of AcupunctureEducation Requirements, 32CSR7 7

Board of AcupunctureTutoial Education Requirements, 32CSR1 2

Board of AcupunctureFormation and Approvalof Professional Limited Liability Companies, 32CSR/3

Division of Natural ResourcesRecyclin g Assr.sfanc e F u nd G rant P rog ram, 58CSR5

West Virginia Division of Environmental ProtectionSewage Sludge Management Rule, 33CSR2

West Virginia State Board of Registration for Professional EngineersRules of the West Virginia Sfafe Board of Registration for ProfessionalEngineer, TCSRI

Division of Health, Department of Health and Human ResourcesGeneral Sanitation, 64CSR1 IDivision of Health, Deparfinent of Health and Human ResourcesTu bercu losi s Control, 64CSR7 6

Division of Health, Department of Health and Human ResourcesLead Abatement Licensing, 64CSR45

Division of Healthlnterstate Compact on Mental Health, 64CSR72

Division of Health, Department of Health and Human ResourcesRadon Licensure, 64CSR78

Division of Health, Department of Health and Human ResourcesFees for Seruices, 64CSR51

Division of Culture and HistoryCertified Local Govemment Program, 82CSR1

p.

q.

f_

t.

V.

w.

X.

v.

aa.

Page 4: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

bb. Division of Culture and HistorySfandards and Procedures for Administering Sfafe Histoic PreseruationPrograms, S2CSR2

Other Business.

Page 5: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

November 10, 1998

9:30 a.m. - 2:45 p.m.

Earl Ray Tomblinex officio nonvoting member

Senate

Ross, ChairmanAnderson, Vice ChairmanBoleyBowman (Absent)BuckalewMacnaughtan (Absent)

Legislative Rule-Makins Review Committee(Code $29A-3-10)

Robert'oBob" Kissex officio nonvoting member

House

Hunt, ChairmanLinch, Vice ChairmanComptonFairclothJenkinsRiggs

The meeting was called to order by Mr. Hunt, Co-Chairman

The minutes of the October 19 and 20,1998, meetings were approved.

Debra Graham, Committee Counsel, stated that the rule proposed by the West Wrginia StateTreasurer's Olfice-Rulesfor Enforcement of the Uniftrm Unclaimed Propefi Act, Il2CSRi hadbeen removed from the agenda at the previous meeting. Ms. Graham explained the rule and statedthat the State Treasurer's Office has agreed to technical modifications. John Perdue, State Treasurer,responded to questions from the Committee.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham stated that the rule proposed by the State Tax Commissioner-Valae ofTimberland and Managed Timberlund, ll0CSRIHrhad been laid over from previous meeting.Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract and stated that the Commission has agreed to technicalmodifications. She and Jerry K"ight, Director of the Properly Tax Division, responded to questionsfrom the Committee.

Mr. Anderson asked unanimous consent to modiff his motion pending from the previousmeeting to allow counsel to determine the appropriate section in the proposed rule for the proposedmodification. There being no objection, motion as modified was adopted.

Bob Hoffinan, Director of the Legal Division of the Tax Division, stated that he could notaccept or reject the modification on behalf of the Commission.

Page 6: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

Mr. Anderson moved that the appropriate section of the proposed rule be amended by adding

the following language. "silvicultural activities, including harvesting, on managed timberland donot constitute a nuisance at common law, nor are those activities a nuisance under any of the stafutes

or rules of this state." The motion was adopted.

Mr. Anderson moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified and amended. Themotion was adopted.

Ms. Graham stated that the rule proposed by the Governor's Committee on Crime,Delinquency and Correcfion-Law Enforcement Training Standards, 149C5R2, had been laid overfrom the previous meeting. Ms. Graham explained the rule and stated that the Governor'sCommittee has agreed to all technical modifications. She stated that the Governor's Committeewould prefer to wait until next year to completely rewrite the proposed rule as suggested by Counsel,because the Governor's Committee had intended to completely rewrite the rule at that time.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be modified to include language requiring that theproposed rule be rewritten and resubmitted to the Committee next year. The motion was adopted.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham stated that the rule proposed by the State Tax Commissinner-Valaation ofActive and Reserve Coal Propertyfor Ad Valorem Property Tax Parposes, 110CSRld had beenmoved to the foot of the agenda during the previous meeting. She and Mr. Hoffrnan responded toquesfions from the Committee.

Mr. Ross moved the proposed rule be moved to the foot of the agenda so that Counsel fromthe Committee and the Tax Commission could research the possibility of shifting the burden ofproofof discrepancy of assessments from reserve coal properly omers to the assessors and also determineifremoving the ad valorem property tax from the coal interests and replacing it with a coal severance

tax is constitutional. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the Board of Acupancture-Applications forLicensure to Practice Acupancture, 32CSR3, and stated that the Board has agreed to technicalmodifications.

Mr. Faircloth moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was

adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Board of Acapanctare-Feesof the Board of Acupuncture, 32CSR4, and stated that the Board has agreed to technicalmodifications. She and Danell Samples, Secretary of the Board, responded to questions from theCommittee.

Page 7: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

Mr. Ross moved that subsections 3.2 and 3.3 of the proposed rule be modified to increasethe fee for out-of-state licenses by $125 and decrease the fee for in-state licenses by $125. Themotion was adopted.

IMr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the Board of Acupunctare-Advertising byLicensedAcapuncturists,32CSRS, and stated that the Board has agreed to technical modifications.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abshact on the rule proposed by the Board of Acapancture-Standards of Practice of Acupancture by Licensed Acupuncturists, 32CSR6, and stated that theBoard has agreed to technical modifications.

Mr. Ross moved that *re proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the Board of Acupuncture-Disciplinary andComplaint Procedures for Acupuncturists, 32CSR7, and stated that the Board has agreed totechnical modifications. She responded to questions from the Committee.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Board of Acupuncture-Continuing Education Requirements, 32CSR9, and stated that the Board has agreed to technicalmodifications.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Gratram explained the rule proposed by the Board of Acupuncture-Code of Ethics forLicensed Acapuncturists, 32CSRI0, and stated that the Board has agreed to technical modifications.Dr. Samples responded to questions from the Committee.

Mr. Anderson moved that Section 4 of the proposed mle be modified to include language toclariS all medications shall be over-the-counter. The motion was adopted.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Board of Acupuncture-Educatinn Reqairements, 32C5R17, andstated that the Board has agreed to technical modifications.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Page 8: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the Board of Acupunctare-Tutorial EducatianRequirements, 32C5R12, and stated that the Board has agreed to technical modifications. She andDr. Samples responded to questions from the Committee.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Board of Acapuncture-Formation andApproval of Professionul Limited Linbility Companies, 32C5R13, and stated thatthe Board has agreed to technical modifications.

Mr. Ross moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the State Tax Commissioner-TaxCredits for New Value-Added Wood Manafacturing Facilities, 110C5R13M, and stated that theCommission has agreed to technical modifications. She and Keith Larson, from the Legal Divisionof the Tax Commission, responded to questions from the Committee.

Ms. Boley moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the State Tax Commissioner-Tax CreditsforNew Steel, Alaminum or Polymer Manufacturing Operafions, 110C5R13N, and stated thatCommission has agreed to technical modifications.

Ms. Boley moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motions was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the State Tax Commissioner-Electronic Data Processing System Network for Property Tsx Administrafion, 1[0CSR2, andstated that the Commission has agreed to technical modifications. Mr. Knight responded toquestions from the Committee.

Ms. Boley moved the proposed rule be moved to the foot of the agenda to give Mr. Knighttime to provide the Committee with further information. The motion was adopted

Ms Graham explained the rule proposed by the West Wrginia State Board of Registration

for Professional Engineers-Rules of the West Wrginia State Board of Registration forProfessional Engineers, TCSRI, and stated that Board has agreed to technical modifications. She

and Frank Gaddy, a member of the Board, responded to questions from the Committee.

Mr. Hunt moved the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Joseph Alfuer, Associate Counsel, explained the rule proposed by the Division of NataralResources-Recycling Assistance Fund Grant Program, 58CSR5, and stated that the Division has

agreed to technical modifications. He and Jim Hill, Recycling Coordinator for the Division,responded to questions from the Committee.

Page 9: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

Mr. Buckalew moved that the proposed rule be modified to include language that theproposed rule be brought back before the Committee next year. The motion was adopted.

Mr. Hunt moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Mr. Altizer reviewed his abstract on the rule proposed by the West Wrginia Division ofEnvironmental Protection-Sewage Sludge Management Rule, 33CSR2, and stated that theDivision has agreed to technical modifications. Mr. Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zetowith the suggested changes for the Sewage Sludge Management Rule.

Mr. Buckalew moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion wasadopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstact on the rule proposed by the Division of Health-GeneralSanitatinn, 64CSRI8, and stated that the Division has agreed to technical modifications.

Ms. Boley moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the Division of Health-Taberculosis Control,64C5R76, and stated that the Division has agreed to technical modifications.

Mr. Hrurt moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Division of Health-LeadAbatement Licensing, 64C5R45, and stated that Division has agreed to technical modifications.Randy Curtis, Bureau of Public Health, responded to questions from the Committee.

Ms. Boley moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Gratram explained the rule proposed by the Division of Health-Interstate Compact onMental Health,64CSR72, and stated that Division has agreed to technical modifications.

Ms. Boley moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Division of Health-RadonLicensure, 64C5R78, and stated that the Division has agreed to technical modifications. BeattieDeBord, of the Division, and Mr. Curtis responded to questions from the Committee.

Mr. Hunt moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham explained the rule proposed by the Division of Health-Fees for Services,64CSRSI, and stated that Division has agreed to technical modifications. Ga.ry Thompson, StateRegistrar Vital Statistics Office, and Chris Gordorq Assistant Commissioner, responded to questionsfrom the Committee.

Page 10: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

Mr. Hunt moved that the proposed rule be moved to the foot of the agenda The motion was

adopted.

Rita Pauley, Associate Counsel, reviewed her abstract on the rule proposed by the Divisionof Culture and History-CerfiJied Local Government Program, |2CSRL, and stated that theDivision has agreed to technical modifications. Ms. Pauley responded to questions from theCommittee and stated that the Chairman of the Archives and History Board has not agreed totechnical modifications to this proposed rule or the rule proposed by the Division of Culture andHistory-Standards and procedures for Administering State Historic Preservation Programs,82CSR2.

Mr. Hunt moved that both rules proposed by the Division be laid over until the next meeting.The motion was adopted.

Ms. Graham told the Committee that, because of the number of proposed rules remaining tobe considered by the Committee, the Committee needs to meet for a full day in December. TheCommittee directed her to schedule a meeting for Wednesday, December 16, 1998.

Mr. Hunt stated that Mr. Ifuight indicated that he had the inforrnation the Committeerequested conceming the rule proposed by the State Tax Commissioner-Electronic Data ProcessingSystemNetworkfor Properfi TaxAdministration, 110C5R2. Mr. Knight responded to questions

from the Committee.

Mr. Buckalew moved that the proposed rule be approved as modified. The motion was

adopted.

Mr. Hunt stated that the Committee had reached the foot of the agenda and the rule proposed

by the State Tax Commissioner-Valuation of Active and Reserve Coal Propertyfor Ad ValoremProperty Tox Purposes, 1L0CSRII, andrecognized Mr. Altizer to report on the questions raised byCommittee members regarding shifting the burden ofproof from taxpayers to assessors and replacingcurrent ad valorem taxes on coal with a coal severance tax.

Mr. Riggs moved that the proposed rule be laid over until the next meeting. The motion was

adopted.

The meeting was adjoumed.

Page 11: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

MEMORAIIDI'M

TO: MIKE ZETOFROM: iIOE ALTIZER & RITA PAULEYDATE: NOVEMBER 6, L998RE: SUGGESTED CHANGES FOR SEWAGE SLITDGE ODOR RULE

We don't see a need for incoryorating the odor ranle. The onlyportion thaE is really applicable is the new langruage below. Odorwas Ehe only definition we feel needs to be used, so we recommendjust, adding these E,wo provisions. If you Sfuys care E,o add moredefinitions its ok with us, but we think that this one is all thatis needed.

Add one definiE,ion:

2.29. "Odor" means a sensat.ion resulting from stimulation of thehuman sense of smeIl.

Suggested revision to 3.3.b:

3.3.b.1. Any person operating a sewage sludge faciliEy shaIlconducE off-site odor monitoring. The frequency of odor monitoringshall be quarterly or as othe::trise specif ied by the director. Thebarnebey-cheney scentometer or other instrr.rment, device ortechnique designated by the director may be used as a gruide in theenforcement of the nrle and may be used in Ehe deEerminat,ion of theobjectionabiliEy of an odor.

3.3.b.2. When an odor is determined to be objectionable andrepet,itious by the director, the director may require the facilityto conduct related studies within a specified time period. Thesestudies may include but are not limit,ed to, sampling and analysisto identify the specific chemical compound(s) which are causing theobjecE,ional odor, analysis of samples by odor panels, airdispersion modeling studies, and evaluaE,ion of applicable controldevices and control programs.

Page 12: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

!tocsR4

/o

o

o

IAS Projected Difference

EXtSnMl T'IFFERENCE

$14,647.01 $2,228$33,296.24 $31.511.39 $1.784.85'$ti

$15$16.7$14

PLEASANTS

$11,820.94

$14,6s2.10

BUDGET.WKI OT 1729198 03:23 PM

Page 13: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

IAS ProiecGd Brdget

Tt2gWfIFPMla&n

Page 14: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

COUNTT Real & PP ParcelCount

n,tg1- -61,!!q ___?3,69{J__37U3_33.932

CURRENT PCINVENIORY

TIIINIMUMPC NEEDS-t

t2-l -,

7

PC Coet

$24,q-0__$48,890 __

$33,!ZL_$21.740

Mlnue-PJCAmount

0--Total l{eeds

$24AmFARtsOUR 6BERK-ELEY

-BOONE____BRA{TONBROOKE

20 $130,000 0$2J91$2r.7&

r1_4

iL2_,!q00

7 1 $23 0 $23.675CABELL 79.989 26 l6 $17 $37,130CALHOUN 29.t42 4 6 s21.740 0 $2r.740CLAY 21.t49 6 4 $19,240 $3.200 $16.040DODDRJDGE 29.O70 4 6 $2r.740 $2,300 $19,440FAYETTE 56.987 5 l1 $33.965 $12.000 $21,9653ILMER 33.247 5 7 $2r,740 0 szr.740SRANT 16.680 3 3 $r8.9s0 $s,000 $13,950SREENBRIER 54.267 t2 1l $50.lm $29.820 $20.280I{AMPSHIRE 3r.294 6 6 $24,530 0 $24.530I{ANCOCK 49.778 9 t0 $31.755 0 $31,755I{ARDY 18.552 5 4 $21.450 0 $21.4s0t{ARRISON 102.069 28 20 $80,990 $20.000 $60.990IACKSON 43.1 1 1 9 9 $39.545 $28.000 $r 1,545

IEFFERSON n.247 11 8 $38.965 $130.000 0KANAWHA 2t9.396 73 44 $64,430 0 $64.430LEWIS 39.331 8 8 $38.965 $5.000 $33,965LINCOLN 29.375 7 6 24.8ffi 0 $24.800LOGAN 4t.OEE t2 8 $38,965 $15,0m $23.96sMARTON &.u8 15 13 $59.500 $18.361 $41,139IAARSHALL 40.6n 8 8 $38,965 $1.181 s37.7U

,soN 26.962 8 5 $17,030 $25,000 0

MCDOWELL 45,524 7 9 $44.545 0 $44,s45MERCER 9.425 L6 t3 $59,49s $46.500 $12.99sMINERAL 29.ffi3 9 6 $27.320 0 s27.320\4INGO 38.680 5 8 $27,320 $37.500 0\4ONONGALIA 79.433 13 16 $48,15s $3.000 $45.155VIONROE r7,633 3 4 szI.740 0 $2t,740\4ORGAN 19.689 5 4 $19,240 $10.000 $9.240{ICHOLAS 39.429 8 8 $21.400 s22,5W 0

)HIO 42,628 10 9 $39.545 $11.7s2 $27,793PENDLETON t3.482 3 3 $18,950 0 $18,950PLEASANTS 13.429 6 3 $16.450 $19,872 0

POCAHONTAS 18.510 5 4 $10.740 $18.000 0

PRESTON 4s.816 9 9 v2,M5 $21.500 $20.545PUTNAM 50.760 13 10 $44.835 25.000 $19.83sRALEIGH 82.850 19 L7 $61,420 0 $61,420RANDOLPH 35.491 6 7 $31,700 $18,975 $12.725UTCHIE 36.074 4 7 $25.110 $11,000 $14.110ROANE 44.365 5 9 $30,100 0 $30.100

SUMMERS 19.145 3 4 $21,700 0 $2r.7WTAYLOR 25.355 7 5 $23.020 $31,557 0

TUCKER 14.006 3 3 $18,950 $15.944 $3,006rYLER 22.916 6 5 $24.s30 0 $24.530UPSHI.JR 36.630 6 7 $21.400 $38.700 0

WAYNE 43.r98 t3 9 $39,545 0 $39.s45

E(EBSTER 18.728 7 4 $1s.230 0 $15,230

ffi* 34,352 8 7 $33.900 0 $33,90014.350 4 3 $18,950 0 $18.950

wOOD 90.686 t8 18 $74.710 $8s,m0 0WYOMING 31.405 8 6 $27.320 0 s27.320

TOTALS 2,329.?33 54 ffi $1,t23,t30 $871.162 $1.190.872

Page 15: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

OCTOBER INTERIM SCIMDULELegislative Interim MeetingsOctober 18, 19 and 20, 1998

Tuesday, November 10. 1998

9:30 a.m.

Earl Ray Tomblin, exoffrcio nonvoting member

Senate

Ross, ChairAnderson, Vice ChairBowmanMacnaughtanBoleyBuckalew

Debra

Legislative Rule-Making Review Committee(Code $29A-3-10)

Robert S. Kiss, exofficio nonvoting member

House

,/Hunt, Chair n ,/Linch, Vice Chan-7/compton 4Jenkins t/Faircloth ZRiggs -74

I certify that the-

Page 16: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

OCTOBER INTERIM SCIIEDULELegislative Interim MeetingsOctober 18, 19 and 20, 1998

Tuesday, November 10. 199E

9:30 a.m.

Earl Ray Tomblin, exoffrcio nonvoting member

Senate

Ross, ChairAnderson, Vice ChairBowmanMacnaughtanBoleyBuckalew

Debra

---V.

Legislative Rule-Making Review Committee(Code $29A-3-10)

Robert S. Kiss, exofficio nonvoting member

House

Hunt, ChairLinch, ViceCompton

/,.Chair {?

=

JenkinsFairclothRiggs

I certif that the'

Page 17: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

REGISTRATION OF PUBLICAT

COMMITTEE MEETINGSWEST VIRGINIA LEGISIATURE

Ls-C-66-18Revleed 1-10-9?

Page 18: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

ShrL Veasuretr - r A,aen,"-tJ

Kort6dr&

iloproo' ar m"a,i1."(ry."i*s

L fiV (onanri,ss)a2 - T.l-/too/|'Tn.n, 4nc/ntSon, -.aoe(./| .-rah'anii 4nJuro-, -i""t./t.-rohi ?1 ohu''",H-. p""/ ;/ cul.. //' ,frhrs/,0t2 ,47.n.7 J,.l .2df deecTey' raoo( - (

Je,ry K"r/l anu'/ y uorllah"lo"on fr-Jor"/

u4, , */-

,hft^fu4"si y'Vro.oor- crrs mo{ € a--r.4r.d-

A

.Z e*p/a,h./

fiA. Q,7* 7cEF. 4

4pprou. ds ,2t.4 - adop/-(

G*nr"/ 4

)7

&ro,s O,,--|,&t=- loq r&s=:*nest rr.*rt*:

frg, Cb.n.a,!&'cn - Ar/[email protected]./ dffi;i-J*4"n -rl v,o'/ 2.1 a''.'s-s,.',o rQ

' /c*{<- o

4,1;!*e*

4, J reTa'd,g

fr'/./ avcnda'-- oa.vf/

Page 19: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

fl"1,t4d/o&1

Ratt,/r?*./

"BTPttu' a is *, . /

?4 7a.c/2agttla S- ond t a e/ea| c-,,

4 a"rslanJ

on'y'-d-sLL 4te-ao'furau. as nroo4

frppru:. a' rtool,F Tespaac(eql A ?.

("e - C.^/ t/ ,

Ro"=t4aeoV

- 1$/--vy'

Apro.ou-- 4'' tno J

- -/ |.Aoe - rryS

ftas s /?ppran aJ.--o//

Ene - ),oe.Ro" tzdqkl

*:i;4 tuP'ou'

&td.'rsa-t

Ctln-, 4

aS o', o/

froo CJ-A-. ,S--p/.. 4t.l

Kott u4ff{/Vzrorzoc aE z,o4I '--

Arsao fu\ {r/.4.d ,6oq'' //€'f vt raate- ,/ o/"o, o// m.d,.o/v.," q!

a'-^4t.

frec- - totroKoetal'p/*

6^-a/

Page 20: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

4oo - To/r.i- |4 7en.nA'ns

R;i:o,

ftoss fVprorau./ zS: rzoo/

K.,4 / *"n, rzrp .

fupran dr .nod?1 7u.nz1'^s

/3 al -v

JEJ,

frp,- S*oJ4ea rduc- at -o J

,frU K-!J/h ans'o( Tcro'rt-*rsfao* .l aTeada-6*

BrofuQ2

2., .So-p/".4lfp6arzue 4s

:

Fee - Flt a

req@ao/e /

._. /

zla?bJ

&"4,odophA

{naioeerST evpla,;..e4 4 rrqoot/..( J-

f.onL Qot"ly retpanle(- 4 j,/nn*.',< o{ mod,#,.J

On:r< -R"uro/,nq3o< e*glaiev&J d ,,r-p"4"-!- $ <-'"

ffu K-;,Kr.'n^.^ G".* ,=se =F"

O""1ffi filol,fr -uVi."sn6^,//- n<+F V.;J'r+i

t\

Page 21: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

-7"r/e lo-to%*jog 7q ,/' ,*f*/ ,, Ae-s- t/ +? 7P7

%i*

:/y7e/v-'o,fr-/

Y-- s ? zna.rll/7

,/ f'oee it// orel-

3,.ra1.,-d1r +- 'Js'J \ Ay"O ^i.-p:-@

/a/

,nd/W,/aaut s? Ut '[*tloq/

tv

aarys -T/"7/

sL * rtrMnz 7qd{:rr;'6:?tft:'ffimyo* s12 >nez/42r

o7n, - %to-l/

yluu s? =aat//V 4f/

Votu ?? nA///Fow P loe *2i

blryrPr/qo"9

o?6?(t"as\_ 4;A

Page 22: NOVEMBER - West Virginia Legislature November 10, 1998 ... Review of Legislative Rules: a. ... Ntizer distributed a memo he sent to Mike Zeto

y,,.t/r- 2771raUV W;l7r,^r'''n"3^ XT"tl^Afb4uy*u.,*Fe "ff i"?z

A4yy."- laa.t /l ,v7o tr/

/_ F__ttTf -r'nfo'// P a-r//at)

rrhYtfut /)ru /y "n taoa hr7y->u,.o1a\a 4U_

/-c

I ""//

,{4&77'y',r/o