nd preventing patient safety incidents · safety on e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014...

21
Confiden May not Fin Saf Heal Exce Every h events f protoco from oc improve 266,813 Medicar individu There a their sa safety i nation a distinct evaluat potenti These 3 expecte as meas across 1 Agency hospita AwardHow Meas When c Healthg indicato average 7 h p 7 h M 6 A o ntial © Copyrig t be reproduced nding a fety In lthgrade ellence A ospital is conc from happeni ols and approa ccurring, there ement. Health 3 serious, pote re patients. To ual residing in A are hospitals t fety related e ncidents. Hea as Healthgrad tion places thi ed for their ex ally preventab 381 Patient Sa ed performan sured by objec 13 of the 14 m y for Healthcar als by recogniz recipients (s w Patient sure Up ompared to h grades Patient ors showing th e, patients tre 3% less likely ospital compa patient safety 2% less likely ospitals perfo Medicare popu 67% less likely Acquired in the overall patient ght 2014 Healt d or redistribut and P ncide es 2014 P Award™ cerned about ng to their pat aches exist to e is evidence t hgrades found entially preve o put that in p Atlantic City, hat have been vents, but to althgrades is p es Patient Saf s elite group o xcellent perfo ble complicati afety Excellen ce in providing ctive outcome most common re Research an zing them as H see Table 4). t Safety E ospitals perfo t Safety Excel he largest diffe eated in Patien to experience ared to hospit in the Medica to experience orming worse ulation.* to experience e Hospital com safety in the th Grades, Inc. ted without the Preven nts Patient S Recipien preventing po tients as they help prevent that U.S. hosp d that over a t ntable patient perspective, th NJ. 1 n successful in outperform e pleased to reco fety Excellenc of hospitals w rmance in safe ions during th ce Award reci g safety for pa es (risk-adjust patient safet nd Quality (AH Healthgrades 2 Excellen orming worse lence Award r erence in obse nt Safety Exce e Pressure So tals performin re population e Hip Fracture than expecte e a Catheter-R mpared to per Medicare pop All Rights Res e express perm nting Safety Re nts otentially avoi y receive care. avoidable pat pitals still have hree-year (20 t safety event hat’s one even n finding ways xpectations in ognize 381 ho ce Award™ rec ithin the top 1 eguarding pat eir hospital st pient hospita atients in the ted patient sa y indicators (P HRQ). We app 2014 Patient S nce Awar than expecte recipients had erved-to-exp ellence Award ores or Bed So ng worse than .* e following sur ed for overall p Related Blood forming wors pulation.* served. mission of Heal Patie eport an idable safety- Despite that tient safety ev e room for 010-2012) tim ts occurred am nt for nearly e to not only re n the preventi ospitals across cipients for 20 10% of all hosp tients from se tays. ls showed bet Medicare pop afety indicator PSIs), as defin laud and hono Safety Excelle rd Recipi ed for patient s d three patient pected ratios. hospitals wer res Acquired i expected for rgery compare patient safety dstream Infect e than expect th Grades, Inc W A t ent nd -related many vents espan, mong every educe ion of s the 014. The pitals erious, tter than pulation, r rates) ed by the or these ence ients safety, t safety On re: in the r overall ed to in the tion ted for c. 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared to hos expected in prov Medicare populat *Statistics are ba Windows® Softw Agency for Healt to MedPAR data f represent three- only. ENT SAFETY TS ents treated at a P d™ hospital were 73% ess likely to exper sure Sores or B cquired in the hos 72% ess likely to exper Hip Fractur following surge 67% ss likely to experie elated Bloodst cquired in the hos spitals performing iding safety for pa tion.* ased on Healthgra ware (version 4.4) hcare Research a for years 2010 thr year estimates fo Y STUDY Patient Safety : rience Bed Sores spital rience re ery ence a tream Infectio spital g worse than atients in the ades application o , developed by th and Quality (AHRQ rough 2012 and or Medicare patie 1 on of QI e Q), nts

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

ConfidenMay not

FinSafHealExceEvery hevents fprotocofrom ocimprove266,813Medicarindividu

There atheir sasafety ination adistinctevaluatpotenti

These 3expecteas measacross 1AgencyhospitaAward™

HowMeasWhen cHealthgindicatoaverage

7hp

7hM

6Ao

ntial © Copyrigt be reproduced

nding afety Inlthgrade

ellence Aospital is concfrom happeni

ols and approaccurring, thereement. Health3 serious, potere patients. To

ual residing in A

are hospitals tfety related encidents. Heaas Healthgradtion places thied for their exally preventab

381 Patient Saed performansured by objec13 of the 14 m

y for Healthcarals by recogniz™ recipients (s

w Patientsure Up ompared to h

grades Patientors showing the, patients tre

3% less likelyospital compa

patient safety

2% less likelyospitals perfo

Medicare popu

67% less likelyAcquired in theoverall patient

ght 2014 Healtd or redistribut

and Pncidees 2014 PAward™

cerned about ng to their pat

aches exist toe is evidence thgrades foundentially preveo put that in pAtlantic City,

hat have beenvents, but to

althgrades is pes Patient Safs elite group o

xcellent perfoble complicati

afety Excellence in providingctive outcome

most commonre Research anzing them as Hsee Table 4).

t Safety E

ospitals perfot Safety Excelhe largest diffe

eated in Patien

to experienceared to hospitin the Medica

to experienceorming worse ulation.*

to experiencee Hospital com safety in the

th Grades, Inc.ted without the

Prevennts

Patient S Recipien preventing potients as they help prevent

that U.S. hospd that over a tntable patient

perspective, thNJ.1

n successful inoutperform e

pleased to recofety Excellencof hospitals wrmance in safeions during th

ce Award recig safety for paes (risk-adjust patient safetnd Quality (AH

Healthgrades 2

Excellen

orming worse lence Award r

ference in obsent Safety Exce

e Pressure Sotals performinre population

e Hip Fracture than expecte

e a Catheter-Rmpared to perMedicare pop

All Rights Rese express perm

nting

Safety Rents otentially avoi

y receive care. avoidable pat

pitals still havehree-year (20t safety eventhat’s one even

n finding waysxpectations inognize 381 ho

ce Award™ recithin the top 1

feguarding pateir hospital st

pient hospitaatients in the ted patient say indicators (P

HRQ). We app2014 Patient S

nce Awar

than expecterecipients haderved-to-exp

ellence Award

ores or Bed Song worse than.*

e following sured for overall p

Related Bloodforming wors

pulation.*

served. mission of Heal

Patie

eport an

idable safety- Despite that

tient safety eve room for 010-2012) timts occurred amnt for nearly e

to not only ren the preventi

ospitals acrosscipients for 20

10% of all hosptients from setays.

ls showed betMedicare pop

afety indicatorPSIs), as definlaud and honoSafety Excelle

rd Recipi

ed for patient sd three patientpected ratios. hospitals wer

res Acquired i expected for

rgery comparepatient safety

dstream Infecte than expect

th Grades, Inc

WAt

ent

nd

-related many vents

espan, mong

every

educe ion of s the 014. The pitals

erious,

tter than pulation, r rates) ed by the

or these ence

ients

safety, t safety On re:

in the r overall

ed to in the

tion ted for

c.

2014 PATIEHIGHLIGHTOn average, patieExcellence Award

le

Pressa

le

les

Catheter-Rea

compared to hosexpected in provMedicare populat

*Statistics are baWindows® SoftwAgency for Healtto MedPAR data frepresent three-only.

ENT SAFETYTS ents treated at a Pd™ hospital were

73% ess likely to exper

sure Sores or Bcquired in the hos

72% ess likely to exper

Hip Fracturfollowing surge

67% ss likely to experie

elated Bloodstcquired in the hos

spitals performingiding safety for pation.*

ased on Healthgraware (version 4.4)

hcare Research afor years 2010 thryear estimates fo

Y STUDY

Patient Safety :

rience

Bed Sores spital

rience

re ery

ence a

tream Infectiospital

g worse than atients in the

ades application o, developed by th

and Quality (AHRQrough 2012 and or Medicare patie

1

on

of QI e

Q),

nts

Page 2: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

ConfidenMay not

ImpaSafetyPatient documeincreaseconditiowhich mpool.

Using a estimatHealthglevel of have be

Not APrioriHealthg2010 thsafety eof evenindicato

Leadersrecognibe priorexpecte

Here’s a

While evnumberthis eve

Converis only eresultin

Not onlyfar exce

By focuprocedusafety e

ntial © Copyrigt be reproduced

act to thty Incident

safety incidenented in a 200es their lengthon includes th

may not be reim

model createte the increasegrades found t Patient Safet

een avoided.

All Patieitizing Whgrades evaluathrough 2012 aevents amongts, along with

ors (PSIs).

s searching toize that it’s noritized first– raed number of

an example in

vents like “cor of patients (oent is 0.43 per

sely, an eventevaluated oveng rate is nearl

y is the impaceeds the previ

sing on high rures and diagnevent.

ght 2014 Healtd or redistribut

e Systemts Increasents not only h

03 JAMA studyh of stay2. Thee financial impmbursed, furt

ed by Chunliu Ze to a patient’that from 201y Excellence A

ent Safetere to Focted approximand found 266,

g Medicare pat the rate per 1

o focus effortsot the areas wiather it’s the aevents and ha

the national d

llapsed lung dover 32 million 1,000 patient

t such as “dear a small numbly 11% (107.99

ct to the patienious example.

ate events, honoses that hav

th Grades, Inc.ted without the

m e a Patientarm the patie

y, caring for pae impact beyoplications of inther challengin

Zhan and Marl’s length of sta0 through 201

Award recipien

ty Eventscus

ately 40 millio,813 serious, ptients in U.S. h1,000 for each

s to get the larith the highesareas where thave higher rate

data.

ue to a procedn), the overall ts or 0.043%.

th following aber of patient9 per 1,000).

nt more sever

ospitals can mve a greater c

All Rights Rese express perm

t’s Lengthnt, they affectatients experi

ond the patienncreased direcng a hospital’s

lene Miller (20ay. Based on t12, if all hospitnts, 352,754 i

s Are Eq

on Medicare hopotentially prehospitals. Tabh of 14 AHRQ-

rgest positive t occurrence

hose occurrenes of occurren

dure” are eval occurrence is

serious compts (less than 20

re, the rate of

more accuratehance of expe

served. mission of Heal

h of Stay t the organizaencing these t’s experiencect costs and c

s financial and

003)3, it is possthis model, tals performednpatient days

ual

ospitalizationseventable patle 1 shows the

-defined patie

impact must of events that

nces exceed tnce.

luated over a ls very low. The

plication after00,000) but th

f this event oc

ly target patieeriencing a pat

th Grades, Inc

TAA

ation. As incidents e and

charges, resource

sible to

d at the s could

s from tient e number

ent safety

t should

the

large e rate of

r surgery” he

curring

ents, tient

c.

THREE PATACCOUNT FAVOIDABLE

TIENT SAFET FOR 79% OFE INPATIEN

TY EVENTS F

NT DAYS

2

Page 3: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

3

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

Table 1 provides a list of patient safety events prioritized by their national occurrence rate (rate per 1,000). While all patient safety events should be avoided, the Healthgrades 2014 report on patient safety has identified a set of three key avoidable patient safety events. These events have a combination of both a high rate per 1,000 and a relatively high number of events:

Respiratory failure following surgery

Bloodstream infection following surgery

Deep blood clots in the lungs or legs following surgery

Before undertaking quality improvement efforts, hospitals should undergo an in-depth analysis of their unique data and patient safety performance. Hospitals can then focus on the high-incidence events first to maximize the impact of any quality improvement initiative.

Table 1. Total Number of Patient Safety Events, Cases and Rates per 1,000 for 14 PSIs (2010-2012)

Patient Safety Event

Number of Patients

Included for PSI

Evaluation

Rate per

1,000

Number of

Events

Number of events of foreign objects left in body during a procedure N/A N/A 947

Death following a serious complication after surgery 170,419 107.99 18,403

Respiratory failure following surgery 3,761,343 17.89 67,285

Bloodstream infection following surgery 1,170,162 15.17 17,746

Deep blood clots in the lungs or legs following surgery 9,095,290 5.86 53,325

Breakdown of abdominal incision site 1,117,691 3.02 3,376

Excessive bruising or bleeding as a consequence of a procedure or surgery

9,111,522 1.82 16,566

Accidental cut, puncture, perforation or hemorrhage during medical care

34,144,165 1.76 59,945

Death in procedures where mortality is usually very low 2,022,917 1.56 3,149

Electrolyte and fluid imbalance following surgery 4,908,334 0.92 4,518

Collapsed lung due to a procedure or surgery in or around the chest 32,516,799 0.43 13,840

Catheter-related bloodstream infections acquired at the hospital 23,399,340 0.22 5,123

Pressure sores or bed sores acquired in the hospital 10,812,502 0.21 2,221

Hip fracture following surgery 5,114,655 0.07 369

Totals 266,813

Page 4: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

ConfidenMay not

The PrincKevin C.Presiden

AchieviAward™third-pabecomemeasurToledo,taken ththem to

For safeOhio Chfor Patieprinciplhealthcthis appwe’ve ahospita

What is look to one wo

Considethe firsthave bewithoutwho typdiplomacriteria key prindepend

The nucafter thindustryto 0.09 their sa2012: an2015.

The comtheir rescharact

Weick &very tryfewer th

ntial © Copyrigt be reproduced

Case forciples in . Webb, PhD, Fnt, Acute Care

ng the Health™ in 2014 is noarty validatione a High Reliabrable, positive, Bixby, and Hehe lessons leao all of our hos

ety, our latesthildren’s Hospent Safety. Paes found in Hi

care to eliminaproach to be spplied it to an

als.

a High Reliabindustries outrd: Performan

er the followint U.S. nuclear

een zero reactt an incident wpically are unda with only alg and clear the

nciples that md solely on an i

clear energy ine events of Thy average for over the fiscafety accident n 86% reduct

mmon denomsults, but the

teristics of the

& Sutcliffe chaying conditionhan their fair s

ght 2014 Healtd or redistribut

r High Re Healthc

FACE e Division, ProM

grades Patienot by accidentn that the actibility Organiza

e results for paerrick Hospita

arned from onespitals.

t quest startedpital Associatiart of that progh Reliability O

ate patient safuccessful in a

nd have rolled

ility Organizattside of health

nce.

ng: In the 60 ye submarine, thtor accidents. were deliveredder 25 years ofgebra-level ma

security checake safety a pndividual.

ndustry madehree Mile Islansignificant eve

al years of 198 rates too, froion, beating th

minator for the methods theyeir operations

racterize thats all the time a

share of accide

th Grades, Inc.ted without the

eliabilitycare

Medica

nt Safety Excet. This achieveons we’ve tak

ation (HRO) haatients seen atals. At ProMede facility and a

d in 2009 as won’s programgram’s approaOrganizationsfety events. Wddressing speit out to all of

tion and why shcare for guida

ears since thehe USS Nautilu The 6,200 rea

d by membersf age, have a hath, meet the ck. The systemprocess, rathe

safety an impnd in 1979. Thents decrease

88 – 2010. Theom 0.38 in 199heir goal to ge

se examples iy use and the .

t HROs “operaand yet managents.” Traits o

All Rights Rese express perm

y

ellence ement is a ken to ave t ProMedica

dica we’ve applied

e joined the , Solutions ach uses s outside of

We’ve found ecific issues our

should we ance? In

e launch of us, there actor hours of a team

high school physical

m is built on er than

perative e annual

ed from 0.77 ey reduced

7 to 0.05 in et to .10 by

s not only

ate under ge to have of

served. mission of Heal

orgaRelia

• As

• Rt

• Ec

If thiconc

FIVE

1 Fouble

2 Soptoe“s

3 HIncam

4 Trehapan

5 Fthuthinim

SWI

At PrundeThis sourcond

th Grades, Inc

anizations whiability include

Are hyper-comsystems that

Require tight tasks perform

Exhibit extremclearly differe

s sounds like ycepts and prac

E KEY CONC

irst, a preoccuperations. Thnderstandingoth events an

earn and impro

econd, these perations. Tho the frontlinemployee feelsstop the line.”

HROs have a renstead of grouategory, HRO

many variation

The next charaesilient. HROsappen. With trocesses to dnd errors.

inally, HROs ahe frontline ofnderstandinghat contributendividuals withmplement cha

ISS CHEESE

roMedica, we erstanding of t concept, intro

rces of accidenditions.

c.

ch benefit fro those which:

mplex: they d must coordin

coupling: whemed across the

me hierarchicaentiated and d

your hospital,ctices of an HR

CEPTS DIST

upation with fhey are focuse

them, but alsnd “almost” evove are an opp

organizationshey close holese, and make it s safe to raise”

eluctance to suping all thing

Os ask “why” mns before mak

acteristic is a cs assume that

that assumptiodetect, contain

acknowledge tf the issue are the nature of

ed to the erroh the authorityanges – deferr

E MODEL OF

implementedthe “Swiss Choduced by J. Rnts: a) active

om the princip

depend on munate for safety

ere members eir team

al differentiatefined

, you might coRO.

TINGUISH A

failure permeaed not only on so the near mivents as oppoportunity to im

s have sensitivs in processes a priority that

e their hand or

simplify interps to a more ge

many times aning their conc

commitment tt mistakes willon in mind, thn and recover

that the persoe the experts inf the error andr. They empowy to recomme

ring to their ex

F ACCIDENT

d these concepheese Model oReason in 200 failures and b

les of High

ulti-team y

depend on

tion: roles are

onsider the

AN HRO

ates the HROs errors and sses. Using

ortunities to mprove.

vity to s, pay attentiot every take action to

pretations. eneralized

nd work througclusion.

to being l indeed ey design the

r from mistake

on(s) closest tn

d the factors wer these

end and xpertise.

TS

pts within an of Accidents.” 00, outlines twb) latent

4

s

on

o

gh

ir es

o

wo

Page 5: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

ConfidenMay not

Active fby peopviolatio

Latent care presdecisionand mancan be ioccurs.

Our appdetectiovarious prevent

After evdetectioclosed tlessonsthe info

Like anyaction hme sharthe prin

PREOC

Many ofchildrencenterscalled oreportininteracthave ovprevent

We impfor highdecreasStrict adventilatin a qua

SENSI

Using thour unitourselvthe teamimplememploy

ntial © Copyrigt be reproduced

failures are disple: slips, lapsens and as such

conditions aresent within thns made by denagement. Undentified and

proach includeon and correc sources. As wt errors we es

valuating nearon methods athe holes in th

s learned in a sormation.

y model, seeinhelps us learn re specific act

nciples of an H

CCUPATION

f the processen’s hospitals as, can be vieweobsessive. Frong at shift chation with the p

ver communiction of failure.

plemented reqh risk procedurse in central vedherence to p

tor associatedrter to sustain

ITIVITY TO O

he SEER dashbts and departm

ves and othersm believes wilented an onlin

yees had a mec

ght 2014 Healtd or redistribut

stinguished byes, fumbles, mh are difficult t

e driven by “ree system. The

esigners, buildnlike the activ remedied bef

ed a plan that ction of these we determined

tablished a cu

r miss trends, and create corhe “swiss cheespecific area w

ng real, practic and apply it totions we took

HRO.

N WITH FAIL

es utilized at oas well as otheed with a persm implement

anges to hourlpatient and cacation of patie.

quired check lisres and as a reenous line infe

procedural listd pneumonia fning zero over

OPERATION

board, we havments. We revs and based onll address the ne error reporchanism to re

th Grades, Inc.ted without the

y unsafe acts cmistakes, and p

to foresee.

esident pathogey can come fders, procedure failures, thefore an advers

focused on praccidents fromd best practic

ulture of safety

we were able rrection actionese” and share

with others tha

cal examples oo our own situ at ProMedica

LURE

our hospitals, er short-term a

pective that cation of bedsiy rounding, ou

aregivers to ennt status is ro

sts and progreesult saw a 40ections over fts enabled a refrom a high of r 12 quarters.

NS

ve a daily safetview lessons l

n that make ch problem. In adrting system tport safety co

All Rights Rese express perm

committed procedural

gens” that from re writers, se sources

se event

revention, m their es to y.

to design ns that ed the at could use

of it in uation. Let

that follow

both acute care

could be ide ur nsure we ooted in

ess notes % quarterly

four years. eduction in three cases

ty briefing in earned from

hanges that ddition we to ensure oncerns in a

served. mission of Heal

way tvisib

We eearlyconfthat expeevenSoluindicotheretriimprventexpeoccu

REL

It’s hordecomthe Sto beclassimpaseveactio

A serresuThis occucatetherespecchan

Haviinforident

COM

Handprev

At Prprovexpeprocimple

th Grades, Inc

that removedbility to all.

expected to sey months – a dfidence emplo encourages r

ectation. We’vnts since impletions) in 2014

cator, we belieers are empow

bution, we canrovements witture to identifyectation that aur.

LUCTANCE

human nature er to make the

es to safety, tSEER safety eve highlighted isification systact, and how terity. This allowon due to the d

rious event is lting in moder type of event

urs. The opposgorized as noefore with no

cific barrier or nce.

ng this modelrmation on thetify more met

MMITMENT

dling unforesevention require

roMedica, we vide resilienceectation that icess and technementation o

c.

d any threat of

ee our safety direct result ofoyees have in treporting. Theve seen an oveementing the

4. Rather than eve this is a powered to repor

n detect, corrth others. It’s y and correct an increase in

TO SIMPLIF

to want to ore complex simthis has a detrvent classificain understandtem uses the lthe event is dews more specdetail provide

classified as rrate to severet is detected rsite scenario it having reach impact, and w process in pla

l deployed at Pe contributingthods to preve

T TO RESILIE

een issues, reces more than

use people, p. Approachingncidents will o

nology. Someof smart pump

f backlash and

event numbef the opennesthe culture we

e data validateerall increase i online report take that as a

ositive. As emprt issues withorect and share important to safety issues reported eve

FY

ganize and caple. However

rimental effecation that enc

ding an event. evers of patie

etected to detcific analysis aed.

reaching the pe harm includinretroactively –is described ahed the patien

was detected aace, or in som

ProMedica givg factors, allowent it in the fu

ENCE

covering, and protocols.

process and teg planning witoccur, we inte examples inc

ps, CPOE, and

d provided

rs to rise in thss and e’ve created ed that in reported

ting system (Ra negative ployees and out threat of

e the ensure any includes an nts can and w

tegorize in r, when it ct. We employ courages deta This

ent interactiontermine its nd resulting

patient, ng up to death– after it s a near miss;

nt, and as a result of ae cases by

ves us rich wing us to ture.

moving to

echnology to h an

egrate people,clude our

medication

5

e

L

will

il

n,

h.

a

Page 6: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

ConfidenMay not

reconcipreventmisses,enablingcommitresourc

DEFER

Finally wemployexpect more hatreat ththis is thexpectawould dbehavionurse b

To ensuwe detesafe to an errorto patiethat comtheir haor obse

Empowcontrol not meeto help we knoweliminatthat by and appused in differen

LESSO

I’ll end o

1. Safepossprinc

2. “AttsenioHROwhe

ntial © Copyrigt be reproduced

liation softwat events and h, so we may ang a consistenttment is backeces and invest

RENCE TO E

we embarked yee, patient, an

that in their caarm, they’d be

hem with respehe same ordeation of care. W

deliver just thaor amongst teullying or phy

ure our frontlinermined an esreport both er. Finally, we e

ents, families, mmunicated t

and, alert otheerve unsafe co

wering our team to those moseting the needus solve the sw that this is hte safety erro working with

plying principle High Reliabilitnce.

ONS LEARNE

our story with

ety is a sciencesible in healthcciples.

tention is the cor leaders in t

O success and re there will b

ght 2014 Healtd or redistribut

are and hardwahelp capture dnalyze and leat quality improed by the orga

tments.

EXPERTISE

on making it knd family memare process the healed, and iect and kindner of importancWe focused o

at –one that ream members sician intimida

ne experts hacalation policyrrors and situa

extended that and visitors bthat they “hav

ers, and be voconditions.

ms and our past qualified to dds or goals set

situation. Theshard work andrs in healthca

others, like oues used by othty Organizatio

ED

some key lea

e. Ultra- high lcare by emplo

currency of leahis process is where the leae focus in the

th Grades, Inc.ted without the

are. These tooata to alert usrn from the si

ovement loopanization, our

known to evermber that theyhey would notn that procesess. Accordince a patient han building a cu

einforces appr and eliminateation.

d a way to “sty that kept thations that co concept fromy deploying a

ve permissioncal when they

atients gave uldetermine wht, and empowse efforts are will take timere. However, wur hospital assher industriesons we can ma

rnings:

evels of safetoying high relia

adership.” Th absolutely cr

adership pays organization.

All Rights Rese express perm

ols help us s of near tuation,

p. This time and

ry y should t experience ss we would

g to HPI, as in their ulture that ropriate

es cases of

op the line,” e employee

ould lead to m employees

campaign ” to raise experience

ltimate hen we were

wered them a journey –

e to we’ve found sociation, like those

ake a

y are indeed ability

he role of itical to attention is .

served. mission of Heal

3. Scrsa

4. Yth

5. Earin

6. Sp

www.

Kevin Presid

For mprofesmanagMemoVice Pfew yeThis wDevel

After than eHospicare h

Strateadmis

AdditiChildrhealth

In 201respoProMeand Pr

Dr. WeHospiboardAdminis a Pa

th Grades, Inc

Safety is a “dynreating and mafety.

You must engahat safety is a

Everyone makere almost alwa

ndividual huma

Staff, physicianrevention stra

promedica.org

Webb, PhD,FACEdent, Acute Care

more than 25 yearsssional and leadegement positions

orial Hospital for mPresident of Clinicears, his scope ex

wealth of experienlopment for ProM

serving as Presideight years, Dr. Wital in 2008. As Pre

hospital and the re

egic direction for ssions, 80,000 ER

ionally, in 2008, Dren’s Hospital, a 1hcare needs of ch

12, he was namedonsibilities for sevedica St. Luke’s, ProMedica Fostori

ebb is a Fellow of ital Association b

d member, and fornistrators. Locallyast President of th

c.

namic, non-evmaintaining a c

age the medica core value in

es errors, but ays a result ofan’s error.

ns and leadersategies a habi

E division

s, Kevin Webb, Phr in healthcare. Ass at both ProMedmore than a decacal Services for Lixpanded to includnce led him to bec

Medica Health Sys

ent of ProMedicaWebb was named P

esident of ProMeegion’s leading te

the 774-bed hos visits and 15,000

Dr. Webb was nam151-bed hospital dhildren and adoles

d President, Acuteveral additional hoProMedica Wildwoa Community Ho

f the American Cooard member, Ohrmer President ofy, Dr. Webb is a mhe Sylvania Cham

vent.” Everyoulture of high

al staff in effo all you do.

serious patienf the “system”

s must make pit for their pra

hD, FACHE, has bes an audiologist, Dica Toledo Hospitde. In 1991, Dr. Wma Memorial Hos

de additional manacome Corporate Dstem.

a Flower Hospital President of ProM

edica Health Systeertiary care facility

pital, which provid0 surgical procedu

med President of Pdedicated exclusi

scents.

e Care Division of ospitals including:ood Orthopaedic

ospital

ollege of Healthcahio Children's Hosf Ohio Council of S

member of the Tolmber of Commerc

ne has a role i reliability and

rts and ensure

nt harm event” failing, not a

proven error ctice.

een a medical Dr. Webb held tal and Lima

Webb was named spital. Over the neagement functionDirector of Busine

in Sylvania for moMedica Toledo em’s largest acutey, he provides

des 30,000 ures each year.

ProMedica Toledoively to serving th

f ProMedica with ProMedica Bay P

c & Spine Hospital

are Executives, Ohspital AssociationSpeech and Hearledo Rotary Club ae.

6

n d

e

ts n

ext ns. ess

ore

e

o he

ark, ,

hio n ing and

Page 7: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

7

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

How Healthgrades Determines Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award™ recognizes the 381 hospitals out of 4,729 evaluated that have the lowest occurrences of 13 of 14 serious, potentially preventable complications and adverse events during a patient’s hospital stay.

To evaluate hospital patient safety, Healthgrades uses Medicare inpatient data from the Medicare Provider Analysis and Review (MedPAR) database purchased from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). We evaluate all short-term acute care hospitals in the MedPAR file for three years (2010 through 2012. In addition, Healthgrades uses the QI Windows® Software (version 4.4) developed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ).

For most patient safety indicators (PSIs), the AHRQ software uses advanced statistical algorithms that can predict the number of patient safety incidents that are likely to occur at a hospital based on the types of patients treated at that hospital. This is the expected rate.

We analyze 14 AHRQ-defined PSIs, each of which represents a serious, potentially preventable complication. Table 3 provides AHRQ’s translation for each of the 14 PSIs, as well as its description used in Healthgrades reports.*

Table 2. Patient Safety Indicators and Translation

Patient Safety Indicator Translated in Healthgrades Reports as…

Death Rate Among Surgical Inpatients With

Serious Treatable Complications

Death following a serious complication after surgery

Death Rate in Low-Mortality Diagnosis

Related Groups (DRGs)

Death in procedures where mortality is usually very

low

Pressure Ulcer Rate Pressure sores or bed sores acquired in the hospital

Iatrogenic Pneumothorax Rate

Collapsed lung due to a procedure or surgery in or

around the chest

Central Venous Catheter-Related

Bloodstream Infection Rate

Catheter-related bloodstream infections acquired at

the hospital

Postoperative Hip Fracture Rate Hip fracture following surgery

Postoperative Hemorrhage or Hematoma

Rate

Excessive bruising or bleeding as a consequence of a

procedure or surgery

Postoperative Physiologic and Metabolic

Derangement Rate

Electrolyte and fluid imbalance following surgery

Postoperative Respiratory Failure Rate Respiratory failure following surgery

Postoperative Pulmonary Embolism or Deep

Vein Thrombosis Rate

Deep blood clots in the lungs or legs following

surgery

Postoperative Sepsis Rate Bloodstream infection following surgery

Postoperative Wound Dehiscence Rate Breakdown of abdominal incision site

Accidental Puncture or Laceration Rate Accidental cut, puncture, perforation or hemorrhage

during medical care

Foreign Object Left During Surgery or

Procedure

Foreign objects left in body during a surgery or

procedure (reported as number of events)

*Healthgrades ratings reflect 14 PSIs, 13 of which are presented as rates and are used to determine Patient Safety Excellence Award recipients. One PSI, Foreign Object Left During Surgery or Procedure, is not used in award determination because it is a count as opposed to a rate.

Page 8: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

8

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

To be eligible for the Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award™, a hospital must meet clinical quality thresholds, have zero occurrences of PSI Foreign Object Left During Surgery or Procedure, and have data on at least seven out of eight core PSIs.

Clinical Quality Threshold – Eligible hospitals must be in the top 80% of hospitals for clinical quality as ranked by average z-score across the conditions and procedures that Healthgrades evaluates using Medicare data. Hospitals that have patient safety data but no Healthgrades ratings, such as cancer centers, are also eligible.

Zero Occurrences of PSI Foreign Object Left During Surgery or Procedure – Eligible hospitals must not have any occurrences of the PSI: Foreign Object Left During Surgery or Procedure. A hospital is ineligible for this award if even one patient has experienced this adverse event.

Data for Seven of Eight Core PSIs – Healthgrades identifies a core set of eight PSIs that are serious, but potentially preventable, complications related to medical or surgical inpatient hospital care. This core set of PSIs is included in the CMS Inpatient Quality Reporting program and represents events that are most amenable to prevention when hospitals make changes. Eligible hospitals may have data for all 13 PSIs, but they must have data for at least seven of the eight core PSIs (see Table 3).

To recognize hospitals that provide excellent patient safety, Healthgrades:

1. Creates a composite patient safety z-score.

2. Calculates a significance level associated with each composite patient safety z-score.

3. Identifies those hospitals with a “Better than Expected” overall patient safety significance level (using a 90% confidence interval) as Patient Safety Excellence Award recipients.

Table 3. Healthgrades Core Set of Eight PSIs and Translation

Patient Safety Indicator Translated in Healthgrades Reports as…

Pressure Ulcer Rate Pressure sores or bed sores acquired in the hospital

Iatrogenic Pneumothorax Rate Collapsed lung due to a procedure or surgery in or

around the chest

Central Venous Catheter-Related

Bloodstream Infection Rate

Catheter-related bloodstream infections acquired at

the hospital

Postoperative Hip Fracture Rate Hip fracture following surgery

Postoperative Respiratory Failure Rate Respiratory failure following surgery

Postoperative Pulmonary Embolism or

Deep Vein Thrombosis Rate

Deep blood clots in the lungs or legs following surgery

Postoperative Wound Dehiscence Rate Breakdown of abdominal incision site

Accidental Puncture or Laceration Rate Accidental cut, puncture, perforation or hemorrhage

during medical care

For more information, please see Healthgrades Patient Safety Ratings and Patient Safety Excellence Award™ 2014 Methodology at www.healthgrades.com/quality.

Page 9: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

ConfidenMay not

AbouSince 19health qinformacare forto the pby doct

Over 25propertcredible

Healthg

Rfo

Rfr

HA

Hs

Ino

Healthgperformcategoroutcomwww.he

Healthgcomprevisitorswith phyempowoutcomdecisionwww.he

ntial © Copyrigt be reproduced

ut Health998, Healthgr

quality outcomation at the timr themselves o

public, Healthgtors and hospi

50 million annuties the premie consumer he

grades consum

Risk-adjusted or Medicare an

Risk-adjusted rom hospitals

Hospital patienAssessment of

Hospital patienafety develop

nformation onof Columbia.

grades awardsmance, speciaries. For detai

mes data and qealthgrades.c

grades, headqehensive infor

use the Healtysicians and h

wered through mes, satisfactio

ns and take acealthgrades.c

ght 2014 Healtd or redistribut

hgradesrades has collemes to consumme they need or family memgrades is on thtals.

ual visitors haere destinatioealthcare info

mer informatio

hospital qualitnd Medicaid S

hospital qualit representing

nt experiencef Healthcare P

nt safety perfoped by the Age

n more than 90

s hospital quallty area perfoled performan

quality achievecom/find-a-ho

uartered in Dermation aboutthgrades web

hospitals that use of the Heon, safety, and

ction. For morcom and www.

th Grades, Inc.ted without the

s ected, reportemers. We prov it most: when

mbers. In addithe forefront o

ve made the Hon for objectivrmation.

on includes:

ty outcomes bServices (CMS

ty outcomes bg 17 states.

metrics baseProviders and

ormance outcency for Healt

00,000 physic

lity achievemermance, and once informatioements for indospital.

enver, Colorat physicians ansites to searc best meet the

ealthgrades prd health cond

re information.bettermedici

All Rights Rese express perm

ed and explainvide consumen selecting a ption, by reportf driving high-

Healthgrades ve, comprehen

based upon an) MedPAR dat

based upon an

d on Hospital Systems (HCA

comes for 13 ithcare Resear

cians in all 50 s

ents for cohoroverall best peon such as cohdividual hospit

do, is the leadnd hospitals. Mh, evaluate, co

eir treatment roprietary infoitions to make

n, please visit ine.com.

served. mission of Heal

ned the importrs with criticahysician or ho

ting quality inf-quality perfo

family of webnsive, consist

nalysis of the Cta.

nalysis of All P

Consumer AHPS) data.

ndicators of pch and Quality

states and the

rt-specific erformance inhort-specific tals, please vis

ding online resMore than 250ompare, and c needs. Consu

ormation aboue informed he

th Grades, Inc

CFc

FpSVOs

FpSDOs

ASA

EABESCS

H9Dw

R1

2

3

tance of al ospital to formation rmance

b tent and

Centers

Payer data

patient y.

e District

n these

sit

source for 0 million connect umers are ut clinical

ealthcare

c.

CONTACT IFor questions on contact marketin

For general questplease contact thSonja Baro Vice President, QOffice 303.390.25sbaro@healthgra

For questions relaplease contact: Susan Roughton, Director, Quality Office 303.716.65sroughton@healt

ACKNOWLEStatistical AnAlex Brown, MPE

Editors: Alex Brown, MPE Bill Wyatt, PhD Evan Marks Susan McBratneyCarol Nicholas, MSusan Roughton,

Healthgrade999 18th Street, SDenver, Coloradowww.healthgrade

REFERENCE1 U.S. Census Bu

United States:

2 Zhan, C. & MilleCharges, and MInjuries during 1974

3 Zhan, C. & MilleCharges, and MInjuries during 1974

INFORMATI your hospital quag@healthgrades

tions about this rehe author:

Quality Products a553 ades.com

ated to methodol

PhD, MHA Measurement 522 thgrades.com

EDGEMENTnalysis:

y, PhD TC PhD, MHA

es Suite 600 o 80202 es.com

ES ureau, Statistical A 2012

er, M. R. (2003) ExMortality Attributa Hospitalization, J

er, M. R. (2003) ExMortality Attributa Hospitalization, J

ION ality data please .com

eport,

nd Media

logies,

TS

Abstract of the

xcess Length of Stable to Medical JAMA, 290(14) 18

xcess Length of Stable to Medical JAMA, 290(14) 18

9

tay,

68-

tay,

68-

Page 10: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

10

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award™ Recipients 2014 The following hospitals are recipients of the Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award in 2014. Some of the award recipients have multiple locations. In these cases, Healthgrades analyzes the results for all locations and recognizes each of the facilities as a recipient of the award. Information on the award recipients and the rating methodology is available at www.healthgrades.com.

Table 4. Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Alabama Huntsville Hospital Huntsville

Including: Huntsville Hospital for Women and Children Huntsville

Jack Hughston Memorial Hospital Phenix City

Arizona Arizona Spine and Joint Hospital Mesa

Arrowhead Hospital Glendale

Banner Boswell Medical Center Sun City

Banner Del E. Webb Medical Center Sun City West

Banner Heart Hospital Mesa

Scottsdale Healthcare - Osborn Medical Center Scottsdale

Scottsdale Healthcare - Shea Medical Center Scottsdale

Scottsdale Healthcare - Thompson Peak Hospital Scottsdale

Surgical Specialty Hospital of Arizona Phoenix

Verde Valley Medical Center Cottonwood

Arkansas Arkansas Heart Hospital Little Rock

Arkansas Surgical Hospital North Little Rock

Saline Memorial Hospital Benton

Washington Regional Medical Center Fayetteville

California Alhambra Hospital Medical Center Alhambra

Bakersfield Heart Hospital Bakersfield

Bakersfield Memorial Hospital Bakersfield

Beverly Hospital Montebello

Centinela Hospital Medical Center Inglewood

Chino Valley Medical Center Chino

Desert Valley Hospital Victorville

Dominican Hospital Santa Cruz

Downey Regional Medical Center Downey

East Valley Hospital Medical Center Glendora

Enloe Medical Center Chico

Page 11: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

11

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

California (cont) French Hospital Medical Center San Luis Obispo

Garden Grove Hospital and Medical Center Garden Grove

Glendale Memorial Hospital and Health Center Glendale

Good Samaritan Hospital Los Angeles

Hollywood Presbyterian Medical Center Los Angeles

Huntington Beach Hospital Huntington Beach

John Muir Medical Center - Concord Concord

John Muir Medical Center - Walnut Creek Walnut Creek

Kaiser Foundation Hospital - Roseville Roseville

Kaiser Permanente Antioch Medical Center Antioch

Kaiser Permanente Baldwin Park Medical Center Baldwin Park

Kaiser Permanente Downey Medical Center Downey

Kaiser Permanente Fresno Medical Center Fresno

Kaiser Permanente Hayward Medical Center Hayward

Including: Kaiser Permanente Fremont Medical Center Fremont

Kaiser Permanente Riverside Medical Center Riverside

Kaiser Permanente San Diego Medical Center - Kaiser Foundation San Diego

Kaiser Permanente San Jose Medical Center San Jose

Kaiser Permanente South Sacramento Medical Center Sacramento

La Palma Intercommunity Hospital La Palma

Los Angeles Community Hospital at Los Angeles Los Angeles

Including: Los Angeles Community Hospital at Norwalk Norwalk

Mark Twain Medical Center San Andreas

Memorial Hospital of Gardena Gardena

Oroville Hospital Oroville

Palm Drive Hospital Sebastopol

Paradise Valley Hospital National City

Petaluma Valley Hospital Petaluma

Providence Little Company of Mary Medical Center Torrance Torrance

Saddleback Memorial Medical Center - Laguna Hills Laguna Hills

Including: Saddleback Memorial Medical Center San Clemente San Clemente

Saint Francis Medical Center Lynwood

Saint John's Health Center Santa Monica

Saint Vincent Medical Center Los Angeles

San Dimas Community Hospital San Dimas

Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital Santa Rosa

Page 12: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

12

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

California (cont) Sequoia Hospital Redwood City

Sherman Oaks Hospital Sherman Oaks

Sonoma Valley Hospital Sonoma

Sonora Regional Medical Center Sonora

Southwest Healthcare System - Rancho Springs Medical Center Murrieta

Including: Southwest Healthcare System - Inland Valley Medical Center Wildomar

St. Mary Medical Center Long Beach

St. Jude Medical Center Fullerton

Sutter Coast Hospital Crescent City

Sutter Surgical Hospital - North Valley Yuba City

Temple Community Hospital Los Angeles

Tri - City Regional Medical Center Hawaiian Gardens

West Anaheim Medical Center Anaheim

White Memorial Medical Center Los Angeles

Whittier Hospital Medical Center Whittier

Colorado Animas Surgical Hospital Durango

Exempla Saint Joseph Hospital Denver

McKee Medical Center Loveland

North Colorado Medical Center Greeley

OrthoColorado Hospital Lakewood

Porter Adventist Hospital Denver

Poudre Valley Hospital Fort Collins

Yampa Valley Medical Center Steamboat Springs

Connecticut Griffin Hospital Derby

Saint Francis Care Hartford

Delaware Saint Francis Hospital Wilmington

District of Columbia Sibley Memorial Hospital Washington

Florida Coral Gables Hospital Coral Gables

Fishermen's Hospital Marathon

Florida Hospital Orlando Orlando

Including: Florida Hospital - Altamonte Altamonte Springs

Florida Hospital - Apopka Apopka

Celebration Health Celebration

Holy Cross Hospital Fort Lauderdale

Leesburg Regional Medical Center Leesburg

Mayo Clinic Jacksonville

Page 13: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

13

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Florida (cont) Metropolitan Hospital of Miami Miami

Sacred Heart Hospital On the Emerald Coast Miramar Beach

Saint Luke's Hospital Jacksonville

Saint Vincent's Medical Center Jacksonville

The Villages Regional Hospital The Villages

Georgia Emory Johns Creek Hospital Johns Creek

Floyd Medical Center Rome

Habersham County Medical Center Demorest

Hughston Hospital Columbus

Meadows Regional Medical Center Vidalia

Phoebe Sumter Medical Center Americus

St. Mary's Health Care System Athens

West Georgia Medical Center Lagrange

Idaho Northwest Specialty Hospital Post Falls

Illinois Advocate Good Samaritan Hospital Downers Grove

Advocate Lutheran General Hospital Park Ridge

Advocate South Suburban Hospital Hazel Crest

Alexian Brothers Medical Center Elk Grove Village

Centegra Hospital - McHenry McHenry

Elmhurst Memorial Hospital Elmhurst

Good Samaritan Regional Health Center Mount Vernon

Hopedale Medical Complex Hopedale

Mendota Community Hospital Mendota

Methodist Medical Center of Illinois Peoria

Morris Hospital and Healthcare Centers Morris

Presence St. Mary’s Hospital Kankakee

Riverside Medical Center Kankakee

Saint Joseph’s Hospital Breese

Swedish Covenant Hospital Chicago

Indiana Adams Memorial Hospital Decatur

Elkhart General Hospital Elkhart

Franciscan St. Francis Health - Mooresville Mooresville

Indiana Orthopaedic Hospital Indianapolis

Indiana University Health Ball Memorial Hospital Muncie

Indiana University Health Methodist Hospital Indianapolis

Including: Indiana University Health University Hospital Indianapolis

Indiana University Health North Hospital Carmel

Page 14: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

14

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Indiana (cont) Lutheran Health Network - The Orthopedic Hospital Fort Wayne

Major Hospital Shelbyville

Parkview Hospital Fort Wayne

Including: Parkview North Hospital Fort Wayne

Parkview Ortho Hospital Fort Wayne

Saint Joseph Regional Medical Center Mishawaka

St. Vincent Carmel Hospital Carmel

St. Vincent Heart Center of Indiana Indianapolis

Unity Medical and Surgical Hospital Mishawaka

Iowa Allen Memorial Hospital Waterloo

Genesis Medical Center West - Davenport Davenport

Iowa Lutheran Hospital Des Moines

Mary Greeley Medical Center Ames

Mercy Medical Center - Dubuque Dubuque

Mercy Medical Center - North Iowa Mason City

Pella Regional Health Center Pella

Saint Anthony Regional Hospital Carroll

Kansas Great Bend Regional Hospital Great Bend

Heartland Spine and Specialty Hospital Overland Park

Kansas City Orthopaedic Institute Leawood

Kansas Heart Hospital Wichita

Kansas Surgery & Recovery Center Wichita

Newton Medical Center Newton

Salina Surgical Hospital Salina

Shawnee Mission Medical Center Shawnee Mission

Via Christi Hospital on Saint Francis Wichita

Kentucky Baptist Health Lexington Lexington

T.J. Samson Community Hospital Glasgow

Louisiana Louisiana Heart Hospital Lacombe

Ochsner Medical Center New Orleans

Including: Ochsner Medical Center- West Bank Campus Gretna

Ochsner Hospital - Elmwood Harahan

Ochsner Medical Center - Baton Rouge Baton Rouge

Our Lady of Lourdes Regional Medical Center Lafayette

P. and S. Surgical Hospital Monroe

Specialists Hospital Shreveport Shreveport

Thibodaux Regional Medical Center Thibodaux

Page 15: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

15

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Maine Cary Medical Center Caribou

Mercy Hospital Portland

Miles Memorial Hospital Damariscotta

Maryland Holy Cross Hospital Silver Spring

MedStar St. Mary's Hospital Leonardtown

University of Maryland St. Joseph Medical Center Towson

Massachusetts Baystate Medical Center Springfield

Metrowest Medical Center Framingham

Including: Leonard Morse Hospital Natick

New England Baptist Hospital Boston

Newton - Wellesley Hospital Newton

Norwood Hospital Norwood

Saint Elizabeth's Medical Center Brighton

Southcoast Hospitals Group - Charlton Memorial Fall River

Including: Southcoast Hospitals Group - St. Luke's Hospital New Bedford

Southcoast Hospitals Group - Tobey Hospital Wareham

Michigan Allegiance Health Jackson

Beaumont Hospital - Troy Troy

Botsford Hospital Farmington Hills

Chelsea Community Hospital Chelsea

Covenant Medical Center Saginaw

Garden City Hospital Garden City

Huron Medical Center Bad Axe

Lakeland Hospital Saint Joseph Saint Joseph

Including: Lakeland Medical Center Niles Niles

Marquette General Hospital Marquette

McLaren Bay Region Bay City

Otsego Memorial Hospital Gaylord

ProMedica Bixby Hospital Adrian

ProMedica Herrick Hospital Tecumseh

Saint Mary Mercy Hospital Livonia

Spectrum Health Zeeland Community Hospital Zeeland

Spectrum Health- Butterworth Hospital Grand Rapids

Including: Spectum Health - Blodgett Hospital Grand Rapids

University of Michigan Health System Ann Arbor

Page 16: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

16

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Minnesota Chippewa County-Montevideo Hospital and Medical Clinic Montevideo

Essentia Health - St. Mary's Medical Center Duluth

Grand Itasca Clinic and Hospital Grand Rapids

Healtheast Saint John's Hospital Maplewood

Lakeview Hospital Stillwater

Mercy Hospital Coon Rapids

New Ulm Medical Center New Ulm

North Memorial Medical Center Robbinsdale

Owatonna Hospital Owatonna

Rice Memorial Hospital Willmar

Saint Joseph's Hospital Saint Paul

Mississippi Forrest General Hospital Hattiesburg

Greenwood Leflore Hospital Greenwood

Hancock Medical Center Bay Saint Louis

Missouri Citizens Memorial Hospital Bolivar

Northeast Regional Medical Center Kirksville

Including: Grim - Smith Hospital and Clinic Kirksville

Ozarks Medical Center West Plains

Montana Billings Clinic Billings

Great Falls Clinic Medical Center Great Falls

Health Center Northwest Kalispell

Saint Patrick Hospital Missoula

Nebraska Alegent Creighton Health Immanuel Medical Center Omaha

Good Samaritan Hospital Kearney

Great Plains Regional Medical Center North Platte

Lincoln Surgical Hospital Lincoln

Midwest Surgical Hospital Omaha

Nebraska Heart Institute and Heart Hospital Lincoln

Nebraska Orthopaedic Hospital Omaha

Nebraska Spine Hospital Omaha

The Nebraska Medical Center Omaha

New Hampshire Franklin Regional Hospital Franklin

Frisbie Memorial Hospital Rochester

New Jersey AtlantiCare Regional Medical Center - Atlantic City Atlantic City

Including: AtlantiCare Regional Medical Center - Mainland Pomona

Bayshore Community Hospital Holmdel

Page 17: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

17

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

New Jersey (cont) Clara Maass Medical Center Belleville

Englewood Hospital & Medical Center Englewood

Libertyhealth - Jersey City Medical Center Jersey City

New Mexico Rehoboth McKinley Christian Health Care Services Gallup

San Juan Regional Medical Center Farmington

New York Albany Medical Center Hospital Albany

Benedictine Hospital Kingston

Community Memorial Hospital Hamilton

Franklin Hospital Valley Stream

Hospital for Special Surgery New York

Huntington Hospital Huntington

Our Lady of Lourdes Memorial Hospital Binghamton

St. Luke's Cornwall Hospital Newburgh

North Carolina CarolinaEast Medical Center New Bern

Carolinas Medical Center - Northeast Concord

Duke Health Raleigh Hospital Raleigh

Frye Regional Medical Center Hickory

Hugh Chatham Memorial Hospital Elkin

Kings Mountain Hospital Kings Mountain

New Hanover Regional Medical Center Wilmington

Including: Cape Fear Hospital Wilmington

North Carolina Specialty Hospital Durham

Rex Hospital Raleigh

Saint Luke’s Hospital Columbus

Stanly Regional Medical Center Albemarle

The Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital Greensboro

Including: Wesley Long Community Hospital Greensboro

Annie Penn Memorial Hospital Reidsville

Vidant Roanoke-Chowan Hospital Ahoskie

Ohio Crystal Clinic Orthopaedic Center Akron

Dublin Methodist Hospital Dublin

Euclid Hospital Euclid

Grandview Medical Center Dayton

Highland District Hospital Hillsboro

Kettering Medical Center Kettering

Marion General Hospital Marion

Page 18: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

18

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Ohio (cont) Mercy Health - Anderson Hospital Cincinnati

Mercy Health - Western Hills Hospital Cincinnati

Mount Carmel New Albany Surgical Hospital New Albany

O'Bleness Memorial Hospital Athens

Pomerene Hospital Millersburg

ProMedica Toledo Hospital Toledo

Riverside Methodist Hospital Columbus

Samaritan Regional Health System Ashland

Including: Peoples Hospital Mansfield

St. John Medical Center Westlake

Union Hospital Dover

University Hospitals Geauga Medical Center Chardon

Wayne HealthCare Greenville

Oklahoma McBride Orthopedic Hospital Oklahoma City

Medical Center of Southeastern Oklahoma Durant

Oklahoma Center for Orthopaedic & Multi - Specialty Surgeries Oklahoma City

Oklahoma Heart Hospital Oklahoma City

Oklahoma Heart Hospital South Oklahoma City

Oklahoma Surgical Hospital Tulsa

Saint John Broken Arrow Broken Arrow

Tulsa Spine and Specialty Hospital Tulsa

Oregon Kaiser Sunnyside Medical Center Clackamas

Mercy Medical Center Roseburg

Providence Saint Vincent Medical Center Portland

Saint Charles Medical Center - Redmond Redmond

Pennsylvania Doylestown Hospital Doylestown

Dubois Regional Medical Center Du Bois

Excela Health Frick Hospital Mount Pleasant

Excela Health Latrobe Hospital Latrobe

Geisinger - Community Medical Center Scranton

Mount Nittany Medical Center State College

OSS Orthopaedic Hospital York

Regional Hospital of Scranton Scranton

Saint Vincent Health Center Erie

Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hospital Wellsboro

Surgical Specialty Center at Coordinated Health Allentown

Page 19: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

19

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Rhode Island Kent Hospital Warwick

South Carolina AnMed Health Medical Center Anderson

Sisters of Charity Providence Hospitals Columbia

Spartanburg Regional Medical Center Spartanburg

Waccamaw Community Hospital Murrells Inlet

South Dakota Avera Heart Hospital of South Dakota Sioux Falls

Avera Sacred Heart Hospital Yankton

Avera St. Luke's Hospital Aberdeen

Black Hills Surgical Hospital Rapid City

Siouxland Surgery Center Dakota Dunes

Tennessee Franklin Woods Community Hospital Johnson City

Jackson - Madison County General Hospital Jackson

Saint Thomas West Hospital Nashville

Texas Baptist Beaumont Hospital Beaumont

Baylor Jack and Jane Hamilton Heart and Vascular Hospital Dallas

Baylor Medical Center at Uptown Dallas

Baylor Orthopedic and Spine Hospital at Arlington Arlington

Baylor Surgical Hospital at Fort Worth Fort Worth

CHRISTUS Spohn Hospital Alice Alice

CHRISTUS Spohn Hospital Kleberg Kingsville

East Texas Medical Center Athens Athens

Fort Duncan Regional Medical Center Eagle Pass

Good Shepherd Medical Center Longview

Grace Medical Center Lubbock

Harlingen Medical Center Harlingen

Hendrick Medical Center Abilene

Hill Country Memorial Hospital Fredericksburg

Houston Methodist West Hospital Houston

Houston Physicians' Hospital Webster

Kell West Regional Hospital Wichita Falls

Matagorda Regional Medical Center Bay City

Memorial Hermann Katy Hospital Katy

Methodist Ambulatory Surgery Hospital - Northwest San Antonio

Methodist Hospital for Surgery Addison

North Central Surgical Center Dallas

Northwest Hills Surgical Hospital Austin

Page 20: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

20

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Texas (cont) Quail Creek Surgical Hospital Amarillo

San Angelo Community Medical Center San Angelo

Scott and White Hospital - Llano Llano

Scott and White Memorial Hospital Temple

Including: McLane Children's Hospital- Scott & White Temple

Shannon Medical Center San Angelo

Including: Shannon Medical Center - St. John's San Angelo

South Texas Spine & Surgical Hospital San Antonio

South Texas Surgical Hospital Corpus Christi

St. Anthony's Hospital Houston

St. David's Medical Center Austin

Including: Heart Hospital of Austin Austin

St. David's Georgetown Hospital Georgetown

Texas Health Harris Methodist Azle Azle

Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Hurst - Euless - Bedford Bedford

Texas Health Harris Methodist Hospital Southlake Southlake

Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Rockwall Rockwall

Texas Orthopedic Hospital Houston

Texas Spine and Joint Hospital Tyler

The Hospital at Westlake Medical Center Austin

University General Hospital Houston

USMD Hospital at Arlington Arlington

Utah Lakeview Hospital Bountiful

Logan Regional Hospital Logan

The Orthopedic Specialty Hospital Murray

Vermont Central Vermont Medical Center Berlin

Porter Medical Center Middlebury

Rutland Regional Medical Center Rutland

Virginia Augusta Health Fishersville

Bon Secours - Maryview Medical Center Portsmouth

Carilion New River Valley Medical Center Christiansburg

Inova Alexandria Hospital Alexandria

Inova Loudoun Hospital Leesburg

Johnston Memorial Hospital Abingdon

Sentara Williamsburg Regional Medical Center Williamsburg

Shenandoah Memorial Hospital Woodstock

Page 21: nd Preventing Patient Safety Incidents · safety On e: in the r ed to in the ion ed for . 2014 PATIE HIGHLIGHT On average, patie Excellence Award le Press a le les Catheter-Re a compared

21

Confidential © Copyright 2014 Health Grades, Inc. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced or redistributed without the express permission of Health Grades, Inc.

State Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award Recipients 2014 City

Washington Kittitas Valley Community Hospital Ellensburg

Providence Holy Family Hospital Spokane

Providence Sacred Heart Medical Center Spokane

Providence Saint Mary Medical Center Walla Walla

West Virginia Fairmont General Hospital Fairmont

Mon General Hospital Morgantown

Weirton Medical Center Weirton

Wisconsin Aurora BayCare Medical Center Green Bay

Aurora Memorial Hospital Burlington Burlington

Aurora Saint Luke’s Medical Center Milwaukee

Including: Saint Luke’s Medical Center Cudahy

Aurora Sinai Medical Center Milwaukee

Columbus Community Hospital Columbus

Mayo Clinic Health System - Northland Barron

Memorial Medical Center Ashland

Mercy Medical Center Oshkosh

Oakleaf Surgical Hospital Eau Claire

Richland Hospital Richland Center

Saint Mary's Hospital Madison

Saint Vincent Hospital Green Bay

Sauk Prairie Memorial Hospital Prairie Du Sac