multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust: first evidence of ca. 950 ma (zircon u-pb...

23
Multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust: first evidence of ca. 950 Ma (zircon U-Pb SHRIMP) compressional reworking of UHT aluminous granulites from the Eastern Ghats Belt, India KAUSHIK DAS 1 * , SANKAR BOSE 2 , SUBRATA KARMAKAR 3 , DANIEL J. DUNKLEY 4 and SOMNATH DASGUPTA 5 1 Department of Geology, Bengal Engineering and Science University, Howrah, India 2 Department of Geology, Presidency College, Kolkata, India 3 Department of Geological Sciences, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, India 4 National Institute of Polar Research, Tokyo, Japan 5 Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Kolkata, India Integrated structural, petrological and geochronological study on a suite of granulites from the central part of the Eastern Ghats Belt (EGB), India unveils polyphase tectonothermal evolution. We document (a) M 1 ultrahigh temperature (UHT) metamorphism (10008C at 6.5–8.5 kbar) on an anticlockwise PT trajectory simultaneously with early deformations D 1 –D 2 involving partial melting, (b) cooling down to 8008C, 6 kbar that produced a variety of coronae/symplectites (M 1R ), (c) an unrelated compressional orogeny (D 3 ) that produced deep crustal shears and mylonitic foliation (S 3m ) at low angles to D 1 –D 2 structures and was associated with slight loading, and possible partial melt extraction under granulite facies condition (M 2 7 kbar, 8508C), and (d) localized retrogression (M 3 ) in the presence of melt accompanying D 4 deformation. This is the first record of the prograde PT path of the superimposed granulite facies metamorphism in the EGB. U-Pb SHRIMP data of zircon preserves an inherited grain domain of ca. 1700 Ma ( 207 Pb- 206 Pb age) that traces back the history of EGB with a lineage of the Mesoproterozoic supercontinent, Columbia. The UHT metamorphosed (peak M 1 at ca. 1000 Ma) and subsequently cooled crustal segment (M 1R ) was subjected to strong tectonothermal reworking (M 2 ) along a clockwise PT path at 953 þ 6 Ma (concordia age) that partially exhumed the rocks to mid-crustal levels. A later fluid-induced retrogressive event vis-a `-vis melt crystallization occurred at ca. 900 Ma ( 207 Pb- 206 Pb age). The post-peak evolution reveals striking similarities with those recorded in the rocks of the Rayner Complex of east Antarctica, thereby strengthening the notion of Indo-Antarctic correlation as part of Rodinia. Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Received 27 November 2009; accepted 29 March 2010 KEY WORDS deep crustal reworking; Eastern Ghats Belt; India; UHT aluminous granulites; zircon U-Pb SHRIMP ages Supporting information (supplementary tables S2-S6) may be found in the online version of this paper. 1. INTRODUCTION Many of the ultrahigh temperature (UHT, > 9008C, Harley, 1998; Kelsey, 2008) metamorphosed terrains record a nearly isobaric cooling retrograde P–T trajectory (reviewed in Harley, 1989, 1998, 2004; see also Santosh et al., 2007; Santosh and Kusky, 2010; Liu et al., 2011). Two prominent examples include the Archaean Napier Complex in east Antarctica (Harley and Hensen, 1990; Harley, 2003) and the Proterozoic Eastern Ghats Belt in India (Dasgupta and Sengupta, 2003). Exhumation of these isobarically cooled terranes occurred in response to unrelated later orogenic events. In case of the Napier Complex, the Rayner orogeny of broadly ca. 940–910 Ma age reworked the early granulites, records of which are found in marginal shear zones (Harley and Hensen, 1990; Kelly et al., 2000, references therein). Limited radiometric dates on the Eastern Ghats rocks show overprinting by ca. 1000–950 Ma orogeny on the early UHT granulites during a second granulite facies metamorphism characterized by near isothermal decompression during retrogression (Grew and Manton, 1986; Shaw et al., 1997; Mezger and Cosca, 1999; Dasgupta et al., 1994, 1995; Dasgupta and Sengupta, 2003). However, the prograde path of the second granulite GEOLOGICAL JOURNAL Geol. J. 46: 217–239 (2011) Published online 24 June 2010 in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI: 10.1002/gj.1246 * Correspondence to: K. Das, Department of Geology, Bengal Engineering and Science University, Howrah 711103, India. E-mail: [email protected] Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Upload: kaushik-das

Post on 11-Jun-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust: rst evidenceof ca. 950Ma (zircon U-Pb SHRIMP) compressional reworking of UHT

    aluminous granulites from the Eastern Ghats Belt, India

    KAUSHIK DAS 1*, SANKAR BOSE 2, SUBRATA KARMAKAR 3,DANIEL J. DUNKLEY 4 and SOMNATH DASGUPTA5

    1Department of Geology, Bengal Engineering and Science University, Howrah, India2Department of Geology, Presidency College, Kolkata, India

    3Department of Geological Sciences, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, India4National Institute of Polar Research, Tokyo, Japan

    5Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Kolkata, India

    Integrated structural, petrological and geochronological study on a suite of granulites from the central part of the Eastern Ghats Belt (EGB),India unveils polyphase tectonothermal evolution. We document (a) M1 ultrahigh temperature (UHT) metamorphism (10008C at6.58.5 kbar) on an anticlockwise PT trajectory simultaneously with early deformations D1D2 involving partial melting, (b) coolingdown to 8008C, 6 kbar that produced a variety of coronae/symplectites (M1R), (c) an unrelated compressional orogeny (D3) that produceddeep crustal shears and mylonitic foliation (S3m) at low angles to D1D2 structures and was associated with slight loading, and possible partialmelt extraction under granulite facies condition (M2 7 kbar, 8508C), and (d) localized retrogression (M3) in the presence of meltaccompanying D4 deformation. This is the rst record of the prograde PT path of the superimposed granulite facies metamorphism in theEGB. U-Pb SHRIMP data of zircon preserves an inherited grain domain of ca. 1700Ma (207Pb-206Pb age) that traces back the history of EGBwith a lineage of the Mesoproterozoic supercontinent, Columbia. The UHT metamorphosed (peakM1 at ca. 1000Ma) and subsequentlycooled crustal segment (M1R) was subjected to strong tectonothermal reworking (M2) along a clockwise PT path at 953 6Ma (concordiaage) that partially exhumed the rocks to mid-crustal levels. A later uid-induced retrogressive event vis-a`-vismelt crystallization occurred atca. 900Ma (207Pb-206Pb age). The post-peak evolution reveals striking similarities with those recorded in the rocks of the Rayner Complex ofeast Antarctica, thereby strengthening the notion of Indo-Antarctic correlation as part of Rodinia. Copyright# 2010 JohnWiley & Sons, Ltd.

    Received 27 November 2009; accepted 29 March 2010

    KEY WORDS deep crustal reworking; Eastern Ghats Belt; India; UHT aluminous granulites; zircon U-Pb SHRIMP ages

    Supporting information (supplementary tables S2-S6) may be found in the online version of this paper.

    1. INTRODUCTION

    Many of the ultrahigh temperature (UHT, > 9008C, Harley,1998; Kelsey, 2008) metamorphosed terrains record a nearly

    isobaric cooling retrograde PT trajectory (reviewed in

    Harley, 1989, 1998, 2004; see also Santosh et al., 2007;

    Santosh and Kusky, 2010; Liu et al., 2011). Two prominent

    examples include the Archaean Napier Complex in east

    Antarctica (Harley and Hensen, 1990; Harley, 2003) and the

    Proterozoic Eastern Ghats Belt in India (Dasgupta and

    Sengupta, 2003). Exhumation of these isobarically cooled

    terranes occurred in response to unrelated later orogenic

    events. In case of the Napier Complex, the Rayner orogeny

    of broadly ca. 940910Ma age reworked the early

    granulites, records of which are found in marginal shear

    zones (Harley and Hensen, 1990; Kelly et al., 2000,

    references therein). Limited radiometric dates on the Eastern

    Ghats rocks show overprinting by ca. 1000950Ma orogeny

    on the early UHT granulites during a second granulite

    facies metamorphism characterized by near isothermal

    decompression during retrogression (Grew and Manton,

    1986; Shaw et al., 1997; Mezger and Cosca, 1999;

    Dasgupta et al., 1994, 1995; Dasgupta and Sengupta,

    2003). However, the prograde path of the second granulite

    GEOLOGICAL JOURNAL

    Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    Published online 24 June 2010 in Wiley Online Library

    (wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI: 10.1002/gj.1246

    *Correspondence to: K. Das, Department of Geology, Bengal Engineeringand Science University, Howrah 711103, India.E-mail: [email protected]

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

  • facies metamorphism in the Eastern Ghats and the nature of

    deformation associated with re-working of granulites remain

    undetermined. Knowledge on these aspects is a pre-requisite

    in understanding the way the isobarically cooled lower crust

    reacted in response to the later orogeny.

    Recent studies reveal that the Eastern Ghats Belt (EGB) is

    a collage of discrete crustal provinces with characteristic

    petrological, structural and isotopic histories (Rickers et al.,

    2001; Dobmeier and Raith, 2003; Bose and Das, 2007;

    Chetty, in press). The present study is concentrated in the

    central part of the Eastern Ghats Province (Dobmeier and

    Raith, 2003) or Domain 2 (Rickers et al., 2001), where

    metamorphic, magmatic and isotopic signatures are well

    constrained (reviewed in Dasgupta and Sengupta, 2003;

    Shaw et al., 1997; Mezger and Cosca, 1999; Simmat and

    Raith, 2008, Bose et al., 2008). We present structural,

    petrological and geochronological data on aluminous

    granulites to constrain multiple structural and metamorphic

    events. Our particular emphasis here is to characterize the

    structural and petrological reworking of the early UHT

    granulites of this belt.

    2. GEOLOGICAL BACKGROUND

    The EGB represents a Proterozoic orogenic belt that extends

    over 1000 km from the Brahmani river valley in Orissa to

    southeastern parts of Andhra Pradesh along the eastern coast

    of the Indian peninsula (Figure 1). The tectonometamorphic

    events in this regional terrain are distinct from those in the

    Figure 1. Geological map of the study area (Panirangini) and adjoining areas. Note the isolated occurrences of aluminous granulites within leptynite andenderbite. The inset map shows the location of the study area (Panirangini) in the broad geological framework of the Eastern Ghats Belt of India.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    218 k. das ET AL.

  • surrounding cratonic zones and at the same time, there are

    differences in evolutionary histories in different domains

    inside the belt ranging in age from at least Meso- to

    Neoproterozoic time. With all the complexity in the growth

    history, this belt stands out to be crucial for reconstruction of

    Proterozoic East Gondwana (Yoshida, 1995). Moreover,

    recent studies have shown that the EGB preserves the

    evidence for regional-scale anomalous extreme thermal

    condition of metamorphism in excess of 10008C at lowercrustal pressure of 810 kbar (Dasgupta and Sengupta, 2003;

    Harley, 2003). Such extreme metamorphic conditions are

    inferred from reaction textures in diverse mineral assem-

    blages of aluminous granulites and calc silicate granulites

    exposed in different parts of this terrain (Bhowmik et al.,

    1995; Bose et al., 2006, references therein).

    The present study area is near Panirangini (N1881826, E8285428) in the Araku Valley in the Visakhapatnamdistrict of Andhra Pradesh, India (Figure 1). The major

    lithological units in Panirangini and its adjoining

    area are khondalite (garnet-sillimanite-quartz-perthite gneiss),

    leptynite (plagioclase-garnet-perthite-quartz gneiss), enderbite

    (orthopyroxene-plagioclase-perthite-quartz garnet gneiss),mac granulite (orthopyroxene-clinopyroxene-plagioclase-

    garnet gneiss), calc-silicate granulite (scapolite-wollastonite-

    garnet-plagioclase-quartz gneiss) and aluminous granulite

    (sapphirine-cordierite-spinel-garnet-orthopyroxene-quartz-silli-

    manite gneiss). The major part of the area is dominated by

    khondalite. The unit is conformable with the associated

    enderbite and leptynite. Aluminous granulite occurs as small

    pods within leptynite and enderbite. Mac granulite occurs as

    thick bands and/or lenses within leptynite, calc-silicate granulite

    and enderbite. The gneissic foliation in leptynite is demarcated

    by alternating garnet-biotite rich and quartzofeldspathic layers.

    The general trend of this foliation is NNE that has been

    deformed by later events (discussed later) giving rise to regional-

    scale fold interference (Figure 2). The aluminous granulite near

    Panirangini occurs as small podswithin sheared leptynitic gneiss

    and shows two structural variations, (1)massive and the other (2)

    foliated. The foliated variety shows alternating layers of quartzo-

    feldspathic and mac-rich (orthopyroxene garnet) domain.This gneissic foliation in aluminous granulite and the associated

    leptynitic gneiss is subvertical. Centimetre-thick quartz veins

    show down-dip stretching lineation (rodding) on the foliation

    plane. The massive variety is coarse-grained containing

    orthopyroxene cordierite aggregate and occurs in the sameoutcrop as the foliated type. Two generations of quartzo-

    feldspathic veins occur within the leptynitic gneiss and those lie

    at low angle to the general foliation. Foliation-parallel elongated

    Figure 2. Strike map of major foliation planes in the study area showing regional folding and other variation in different places. Note the presence of shear zoneand associated foliation near the study area.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 219

  • bodies of mac granulite occur within leptynite close to the

    aluminous granulite exposed at Panirangini.

    3. STRUCTURAL RELATIONSHIPS

    The rocks of the study area were affected by four episodes of

    deformation. Superposed deformation and concomitant

    metamorphic imprints have also been identied from the

    nearby Borra Caves area (Bhowmik, 1997). The earliest

    recognizable planar fabric in mesoscopic scale is identied

    in khondalite and leptynite. This fabric is dened by layers

    of ferromagnesian minerals and quartz-feldspar that could

    represent modied compositional banding or a transposed

    gneissic fabric on compositional banding during the

    earliest D1 deformation and is termed henceforth as S1.

    3.1. D2 deformation

    D2 caused transposition of S1 and parallelism of S2 that is the

    dominant form surface in the area. Due to intense later

    deformations, folds produced on S1 are rarely preserved as

    rootless, isoclinal to tight intrafolial folds (F2) (Figure 3a)

    in local low-strain domains. The dominant transposed S2gneissic fabric is dened by alternating ferromagnesian

    Figure 3. (a) Rootless, isoclinal, intrafolial folds (F1) on compositional banding (S1) in quartzo-feldspathic gneiss. Note the feature in the centre of the photobelow the pencil. (b) Upright, plunging fold on gneissic fabric in quartzo-feldspathic gneiss. The black arrow shows the folded limb on plan, while the whitearrow is that on the transverse surface. (c) Microscopic fractures developed during D4 that healed up with biotite. (d) Crystal plastic deformation is evident inleptynites and aluminous granulites, undulose extinction in quartz and deformation twin lamellae in alkali feldspar (Kfs) clasts. (e) Porphyroblastic garnet (Grt)containing inclusion of biotite (Bt) and quartz (Qtz) in Association A. This garnet is overgrown by a dusty intergrowth of garnet, sillimanite and quartz(Grt SilQtz). (f) Spinel (Spl) and quartz (Qtz) inclusions in coarse garnet (Grt) that is also overgrown by the intergrowth of garnet, sillimanite, quartz and/orbiotite (GrtSilQtzBt). (g) A complex intergrowth of garnet (Grt), spinel (Spl) and ilmenite (Ilm) growing at the fringe of porphyroblastic garnet (Grt)associated with matrix quartz (Qtz). Note the presence of biotite (Bt) patches along the fractures of garnet. (h) BSE image showing a spongy intergrowth of

    garnet (Grt), quartz (Qtz) and sillimanite (Sil) on cordierite (Crd).

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    220 k. das ET AL.

  • (garnetiferous in favourable compositional bands) and

    quartzo-feldspathic layers.

    3.2. D3 deformation

    D3 deformation formed small-scale shear zones accom-

    panying regional-scale folding F3 on the dominant form

    surface S2. F3 folds are NESW trending open, upright,

    gently plunging on S2 and are pervasive to all the lithological

    units of the area on regional- (Figure 2) and on mesoscopic-

    scale (Figure 3b). Repetition of transposition produced a

    composite S2/S3 gneissic fabric during this event. The S3 is

    only identied at the low-strain zone, i.e. hinges of small-

    scale parasitic folds of F3. Garnetiferous leucocratic layers,

    presumably produced by partial melting (discussed later),

    participated in F3 folding. D3 therefore postdates partial

    melting. The geometries of F2 and F3 folds indicate that the

    fold axes are at acute angles.

    Localization of shear bands is conspicuous in leptynite that

    overprints the dominant S2 gneissosity. Shearing produced a

    CS fabric in this rock where C-surfaces (trending NESW)

    are at acute angles with the pervasive S2 fabric showing a

    sinistral sense on horizontal section. Apart from C-surfaces,

    subsidiary shear bands develop at an angle that affects the

    rock and drags the gneissic foliation resulting in small folds.

    The F3 fold axes, developed on the transposed S2 with S3, are

    accentuated producing sheath folds and are identied as eyed

    folds on outcrop. Locally, a steeply dipping (608 westerly tosubvertical) mylonitic foliation (S3m) striking NESW is

    developed in leptynite (Figure 2). The exposed foliation

    planes have down-dip stretching lineation. The geometry of

    folds and shear zone features illustrate bulk compression

    along SENW that produced the F3 folds and small-scale

    deep crustal compressional shearing. The horizontal com-

    ponent of the oblique down-dip shear stress shows a sinistral

    sense, i.e. the eastern part moved northeasterly and western

    part moved southwesterly. Such deep crustal compressional

    local shear planes characteristically have a steep dip (Ramsay,

    1979).

    3.3. D4 deformation

    D4 deformation produced cross folding (F4) on F3 axial trace

    (Figure 2). Regionally F3 folds are intersected by a NWSE

    trending folds of the last deformation. The superposition

    gave rise to non-plane folding and domal structure. D4 is

    evident by the presence of microscopic to small-scale

    fractures, healed up with biotite (Figure 3c).

    4. TEXTURES AND MICROSTRUCTURES

    The studied aluminous granulites have three distinct mineral

    associations that developed in closely spaced domains in

    outcrop scale. The mineral assemblages, key micro-structural

    and textural features, mineralogical evolution with defor-

    mation vis-a`-vis metamorphic events and brief mineral

    chemical characteristics are summarized in Table 1.

    Association A contains garnet porphyroblasts set in a ner

    quartzo-feldspathic matrix. The association B is distinctly

    migmatitic with alternating light and dark layers forming

    composite S2/S3 gneissic fabric and a mylonitic foliation

    (S3m). Evidences of crystal plastic deformation on a micro-

    scale are widely preserved in this sheared variety of

    aluminous granulite (Figure 3d). The association C is

    developed as massive domains within the aluminous

    granulite. Mineral abbreviations are after Kretz (1983).

    Subscripts with minerals refer to both the mineral association

    and sequence of development in each association.

    In association A, garnet porphyroblasts (GrtA1) contain

    inclusions of biotite (BtA1) (Figure 3e), spinel (SplA1),

    quartz (Figure 3f) and ilmenite. It (GrtA2) occasionally

    forms intergrowth with spinel (SplA2) and ilmenite (IlmA2)

    (Figure 3g) sapphirine. Layers of GrtA1 in Association Ashow ductile deformation forming pinch-and-swell and

    boudinage structure. Cordierite (Crd) is replaced by a

    spongy symplectic intergrowth of garnet (GrtA3), quartz and

    sillimanite (SilA3) along grain boundaries (Figure 3h). At

    places, this symplectite overgrows GrtA1. This intergrown

    assemblage after cordierite is possibly developed during the

    high-strain event producing S3m fabric (D3).

    The gneissic foliation in association B developed

    during D1D2 and is characterized by quartz-perthite-

    plagioclase-bearing leucosomes alternating with dark layers

    comprising porphyroblastic orthopyroxene (OpxB1),

    cordierite, spinel-magnetite solid solution (SplB1), quartz,

    plagioclase, ilmenite and minor prismatic sillimanite (SilB1).

    OpxB1, SplB1 and Crd grains are extremely stretched and

    attened parallel to the foliation. Porphyroblastic OpxB1commonly shows pinch and swell and en-echelon micro-

    structures. The features suggest that this assemblage

    containing OpxB1 was stabilized prior to D3. The mylonitic

    fabric (S3m), represented by ribbon quartz, is preserved in

    high-strain areas wrapping local low-strain domains.

    Dynamic recrystallization by grain boundary migration

    (GBM) is shown by quartz and feldspar in quartzo-

    feldspathic microdomains and also in OpxB1 and cordierite

    grains (Figures 4a and b). Perthite occurs as asymmetric

    grains with strings of intergrowth and quartz ribbons

    sweep around these porphyroblasts resembling CS fabric

    (Figure 4a) while plagioclase grains show bent twin

    lamellae. Asymmetric mantle structure is shown by

    recrystallized orthopyroxene grains around porphyroclasts

    of the same OpxB1 (Figure 4c). OpxB1 often forms

    aggregates and contains lamellae of spinel (SplB2) and

    cordierite along the same crystallographic plane (Figure 4d).

    OpxB1 also contains lamellae of garnet (GrtB2) along the

    same crystallographic direction along with globules of

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 221

  • Table

    1.Summaryofmineralogy,texture,mineral

    chem

    istry,eldandmicrostructure

    andPT-tconstraintsofthethreevarieties

    ofaluminousgranulites

    Mineral

    association

    Structural/micro-structural

    characters

    Key

    texturalfeatures

    D1D2(M

    1)andPost

    D2-interkinem

    atic

    (M1R)event

    D3(M

    2)event

    Mineral

    chem

    istry

    AssociationA

    GrtCrdIlm

    Spl

    Rt

    QtzPl

    KfsSilBt

    Spr

    Migmatitic

    withalternate

    leucosomes

    (Qtz,PlandKfs)

    andmelanosome(G

    rtA1,Crd,

    IlmA1,Rt,PlandQtz);fabric

    S1/S

    2;ductiledeform

    ation

    inGrtA1.

    Bt A

    1,Spl A

    1,Qtz

    andIlmA1

    inclusionin

    GrtA1,exsolved

    Hem

    inIlmA1;intergrowth

    ofGrtA2

    Spl A

    2IlmA2;GrtA3SilA3Qtz

    symplectiteafterCrd;Grtreplaced

    byBt.

    M1:peakreached

    through

    Bt-meltingreactionsproducing

    GrtA1CrdRt

    melt

    (1&

    2);GrtA2Spl A

    2IlmA2

    SprafterOpxA1.

    Crd

    breakdownto

    GrtA3SilA3

    Qtz

    (3)

    GrtA1/GrtA2:Alm

    50Prp

    46Grs2,

    GrtA3:Alm

    60Prp

    37Grs2Sps 1;Spl A

    1

    (XMg0.390.42),2.83.3wt%

    ZnO,Spl A

    2(X

    Mg0.580.60),

    2.12.4wt%

    ZnO;Spr

    (XMg0.770.80)close

    to7:9:3;Crd

    (XMg0.86);Bt A

    1(X

    Mg0.830.88),

    5.2wt%

    TiO

    2,XF

    0.29.

    AssociationB

    OpxCrdSpl SSIlm

    QtzPl

    KfsSilGrt

    Gneissic

    fabric

    (transposedS1/S

    2)with

    alternateleuco-(Q

    tz

    Plag

    Kfs)andmelanocratic

    layers

    (OpxB1,Crd,Spl,Ilm,Qtz,

    Pl

    Sil);mylonitic

    foliation

    (S3m);plastic

    deform

    ation

    inOpxB1,Spl B1,Crd

    and

    Qtz

    grains.

    OpxB2S

    ilB2coronaover

    Spl B1

    (Ilm);exsolved

    Hem

    inIlm,

    lamellaeofSpl B2,Crd

    and

    GrtB2in

    OpxB1;OpxB3SilB3

    Qtz

    intergrowth

    afterCrd.

    M1:peakthroughBtmelting

    reactionproducingOpxB1

    Spl B1Crdmelt(5);

    Spl B2CrdGrtB2intergrowth

    afterOpxB1(6&

    7).

    M1R:OpxB2SilB2afterSpl B1

    Crd/Qtz

    (8, 9, 10)

    Crd

    breakdownto

    Opx

    B3SilB3

    Qtz

    (11).

    OpxB1(X

    Mg0.630.66),9.7wt%

    Al 2O3(core),OpxB2(X

    Mg0.65)

    7.87.4%

    Al2O3;OpxB3(X

    Mg0.63,

    6.86.3wt%

    Al 2O3)Spl B1

    (XMg0.370.43)2.22.8wt%

    ZnO,0.63.1wt%

    Cr 2O3;Spl B2

    (XMg0.38)1.4wt%

    ZnO;

    GrtB2:Alm

    58Prp

    40Grs1Sps 1

    AssociationC

    Opx,Crd,Spr,Pl,Kfs,

    Sil

    Qtz

    Massive,isolatedclusters

    inlow

    strain

    domains

    wrapped

    byS3m.

    OpxC2S

    ilC2double

    coronaafter

    Spr

    Crd/Qtz;inclusionofSplin

    Spr;OpxC3SilC3Qtz

    intergrowth

    afterCrd;OpxC1replacedbylate

    Bt.

    M1:peakthroughBtmelting

    reactionproducingOpxC1

    Crd

    C1/Spl(13, 14);stability

    ofSpr(15, 17),

    M1R:coronal

    OpxC2SilC2

    (16, 18, 19)

    Crd

    breakdownto

    OpxC3SilC3Qtz

    Included

    Spl(X

    Mg

    0.380.42)0.71.0wt%

    ZnO;OpxC1/OpxC2

    (XMg0.66)8.0wt%

    Al 2O3at

    core

    to7.1wt%

    atrim;OpxC3

    (XMg0.66),6.26.9wt%

    Al 2O3;

    Spr(X

    Mg0.740.76)close

    to7:9:3

    Deform

    ation

    D1D2

    Post-D

    2interkinem

    atic

    gap

    D3

    D4

    Metamorphicevents

    Progradeto

    peakM

    1M

    1R

    M2

    M3Localized

    retrogressionin

    presence

    ofmelt

    PT

    conditions

    Progradepathfrom

    high

    T/lowPconditionsto

    10008C

    ,6.58.5kbar

    atthepeak

    Coolinganddecompression

    to

    8008C

    ,6kbar

    Loadingto7

    8kbar,8508C

    ,possibly

    accompaniedby

    partial

    meltextraction

    5008008C

    (poor

    constraint)

    PT-tpath

    ACW

    path

    Coolingwithdecompression

    CW

    path

    Unknown

    Ageconnotationand

    possiblecorrelation

    ca.1000Ma

    ca.950MaRayner

    orogeny;assembly

    ofRodinia

    ca.900MaD3D4

    ofRSEin

    Rayner

    Complex

    Denotesreactionnumber

    asdiscussed

    intext.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    222 k. das ET AL.

  • quartz (Figure 4e). The intergrown lamellae of garnet can at

    places, be traced continuously to the grain boundary.

    Sillimanite (SilB3) forms a spongy (and sometimes skeletal)

    intergrowth with granular orthopyroxene (OpxB3) and quartz

    that replaces cordierite along the margins (Figure 4f). This

    intergrowth commonly forms wispy trails and shows a

    mylonitic fabric. Occasionally, cordierite grains are com-

    pletely pseudomorphed by ne-grained intergrowth of

    OpxB3, SilB3 and quartz (Figure 4g). This symplectic

    intergrowth along with other polymineralic matrix grain

    aggregates, form an oriented fabric (S3) that sweeps

    asymmetrically around cordierite clasts (Figure 4f). This

    indicates contemporaneous shear fabric development with

    breakdown of cordierite. Extreme grain renement is

    evident in quartz and feldspar grains. An oblique foliation

    (as S-) is developed by the shape fabric of dynamically

    recrystallized polymineralic matrix grains with attened,

    recrystallized quartzose bands and ribbon quartz (C-).

    OpxB1 clasts are attened with recrystallized asymmetric

    trails giving s structure in unoriented section (Figure 4c).The ne-grained polymineralic matrix is the product of

    dynamic recrystallization by the process of subgrain rotation

    Figure 4. (a) Asymmetry in alkali feldspar clast and also bending of exsolution lamellae in alkali feldspar. (b) Orthopyroxene grains show evidences of dynamicrecrystallization. (c) Asymmetry in orthopyroxene grains is to be noted where recrystallized grain fabric wraps around it. (d) Orthopyroxene grains (Opx)containing lamellae of spinel (Spl) and cordierite along the same crystallographic plane. (e) BSE image showing orthopyroxene porphyroblast (Opx) containinglamellae of garnet (Grt) and globular quartz (Qtz) along a crystallographic plane. (f) BSE image showing symplectic intergrowths of Opx SilQtz form anoriented fabric that sweeps asymmetrically around cordierite clasts. (g) The same intergrowth of sillimanite (Sil), orthopyroxene (Opx) and quartz (Qtz)pseudomorphing cordierite (Crd) grain. (h) Bands of coarse recrystallized quartz forming ribbons engulfed within ne-grained polymineralic recrystallized

    matrix with sharp boundaries.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 223

  • (SR). Small grains in the matrix show development of

    subgrains (recovery stage). The rock contains discontinuous

    and asymmetrically tapered-head bands of coarse quartz

    either engulfed within or alternating with ne-grained

    polymineralic recrystallized matrix with sharp boundaries.

    Grain boundary area reduction (GBAR) is evident in these

    bands with curved to straight grain boundary in polygonal

    aggregates that are free from any intracrystalline defor-

    mation (Figure 4h). These grains are therefore statically

    recrystallized. Extensive recrystallization might have been

    caused by the combined effects of subgrain rotation and

    grain boundary migration with increase in temperature

    (Hirth and Tullis, 1992; Passchier and Trouw, 1998). These

    microstructural signatures collectively imply shear defor-

    mation at high-T granulite-grade metamorphic conditions.

    High temperature and presence of uid along grain

    boundaries generally favour recovery and recrystallization,

    while high strain rate promotes distortion (Passchier and

    Trouw, 1998). Secondary grain growth due to GBAR and

    development of strain-free monomineralic quartz ribbons

    are indicative of high temperature, above 7008008C(Passchier and Trouw, 1998). OpxB1clasts, surrounded by

    mantle of recrystallized grains (Figures 4b and Figure 4c),

    also suggest granulite facies metamorphic condition in the

    temperature range mentioned earlier (Passchier and Trouw,

    1998).

    Association C develops both Qtz-rich and Qtz-poor

    microdomains. Isolated clusters of porphyroblastic ortho-

    pyroxene and cordierite grains in low-strain domains impart

    a massive look to the rock. The quartz-absent domain is

    characterized by megacrystic orthopyroxene (OpxC1),

    cordierite, sapphirine, plagioclase, perthite and also

    dominance of sillimanite (SilC1). Sapphirine occurs in the

    interstices of porphyroblastic cordierite and is separated

    from the latter by a double corona of OpxC2 and SilC2(Figure 5a). The development of these coronal phases was

    possibly pre-D3. Rare inclusions of spinel are present in

    sapphirine that occurs at the contact of cordierite. On the

    other hand, the quartz-bearing domain also contains

    porphyroblastic orthopyroxene (OpxC1), cordierite, sapphir-

    ine, plagioclase, perthite and sillimanite as major minerals.

    Sapphirine (SprC1) is separated from quartz by a thick

    corona of sillimanite (SilC2) and orthopyroxene (OpxC2)

    (Figure 5b). In both the microdomains (quartz-present

    and quartz-absent) cordierite shows breakdown to

    OpxC3 SilC3 quartz intergrowth during D3 event similarto that described in Association B.

    5. MINERAL CHEMISTRY

    Representative samples of all the types were analysed by

    electron microprobe (JEOL 733) at Hokkaido University,

    Figure 5. (a) Xenoblastic sapphirine (Spr) is separated from cordierite(Crd) by a double corona of sillimanite (Sil) and orthopyroxene (Opx).Note the presence of relic spinel (Spl) in sapphirine and biotite (Bt) patcheson orthopyroxene. (b) BSE image of quartz-present microdomain wherematrix sapphirine grain (Spr) is separated from quartz by a thick corona ofsillimanite (Sil) and orthopyroxene (Opx). (c) Compositional plots ofsapphirine grains to show the extent of Tschermak substitution (alongthe line joining 2:2:1 and 7:9:3 compositions). Note that all the compo-

    sitions plot close to the latter point.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    224 k. das ET AL.

  • Japan. The instrument was operated at 15 kV accelerating

    voltage and 20 nA specimen current. Synthetic and natural

    standards are used. Raw data were processed by ZAF

    correction scheme. Individual phase chemical data are

    presented in the Supporting information (Supplementary

    Tables 26), while a summary of the phase chemical

    characteristics are given in Table 1.

    In Association A, GrtA1 and GrtA2 have similar

    compositions, while GrtA3 is more iron-rich (Alm60Prp37Grs2Sps1) (Supplementary Table 2). SplA1 has variable

    composition (XMg 0.390.42) and contains 2.83.3 wt%ZnO. SplA2 is more magnesian (XMg 0.580.60) withlower Zn (2.12.4wt% ZnO). Sapphirine is magnesian

    (XMg 0.770.80) and is close to the 7:9:3 composition(Figure 5c). Cordierite is magnesian (XMg 0.86) andhomogeneous in composition. IlmA1 contains 1015mol%

    hematite and 47mol% geikielite components. Exsolved

    hematite is titaniferous containing 16mol% ilmenite and

    negligible geikielite components. Included BtA1 is magne-

    sian (XMg 0.830.88) and contains 5.2 wt% TiO2. Thesegrains contain 2.5wt% F (XF 0.29) and negligible Cl. Latebiotite (XMg 0.0.830.91) is compositionally similar withrespect to XMg, but contains lower Ti (TiO2 2.14.2wt%)and higher F (2.93.9wt% F; XF 0.340.44).In Association B, orthopyroxene shows compositional

    variations in different textural modes. OpxB1 (XMg 0.630.66) is highly aluminous and the alumina content decreases

    from intergrowth-free core regions (maximum Al2O39.7wt%) to regions having intergrowth of SplB2 (Al2O38.0wt%) as well as near the rims (Al2O3 6.8wt%).However, XMg does not change appreciably ( 0.65). OpxB2is compositionally similar in XMg (0.65) but slightly less

    aluminous than the core of OpxB1. Thick coronal grains

    show decrease in alumina content from the core (7.8wt%) to

    rim near SplB1 (7.4wt%). OpxB3 (XMg 0.63) contains 6.36.8wt% alumina. Spinel shows compositional variations in

    different modes. SplB1 grains are compositionally more or

    less homogeneous (XMg 0.370.43) with ZnO 2.22.8wt% and 0.63.1wt% Cr2O3. Magnetite content in

    SplB1 ranges between 34mol%. SplB2 (XMg 0.38)contains 1.4wt% ZnO and is low in Cr2O3 content. All

    these phases contain insignicant amount of TiO2 (Supple-

    mentary Table 3). Ilmenite contains 1013mol% hematite

    and 34mol% geikielite components. Exsolved hematite

    contains maximum 17mol% ilmenite component. GrtB2 is

    compositionally Alm58Prp40Grs1Sps1. Cordierite is homo-

    geneous in composition (XMg 0.830.84). Sillimanitecontains 0.91.1wt% Fe2O3 (total). Plagioclase is

    Ab74An26. Late biotite (XMg 0.740.78) contains 4.45.3wt% TiO2 and 2.4wt% of F (XF 0.29).Spinel included within sapphirine in Association C has

    XMg 0.380.42 and is low in ZnO (0.71.0wt%) andCr2O3 (0.20.3wt%). SilC1 contains 1.0wt% Fe2O3 (total).

    Cordierite (XMg 0.830.85) is again homogeneous. OpxC1shows compositional homogeneity in terms of FeMg

    distributions (XMg 0.66), but exhibits Al-zoning fromcore (Al2O3 8.0wt%) to rim (Al2O3 7.1wt%). A thickcorona of OpxC2 shows a comparable composition as that

    of OpxC1. Symplectic OpxC3 (XMg 0.66) contains 6.26.9wt% alumina. Sapphirine is magnesian with XMg 0.740.76 and mostly 7:9:3 in composition (Figure 5c). Recalcu-

    lated composition shows variable amount of ferric iron

    (Fe2O3 1.94.0wt%) and appreciably high XFe3 (Supple-mentary Table 4). Late biotite (XMg 0.760.78) contains5.5 wt% TiO2, 2.3 wt% F (XF 0.27) and insignicant Clcontent.

    6. EVOLUTION OF MINERAL ASSEMBLAGES

    The textural and compositional features in the aluminous

    granulites presented earlier attest to several stages of mineral

    reconstitution.

    6.1. Association A

    High modal abundance of garnet, quartz and Fe-Ti oxides in

    this association implies a Fe-Ti-rich silica-saturated proto-

    lith. The peak metamorphic stage, culminated during the D2event, is characterized by the presence of coarse garnet

    (GrtA1) in this rock. Presence of biotite, spinel and quartz

    inclusions in garnet (Figures 3e and f) and presence of

    cordierite in close association suggest the following

    KFMASH dehydration-melting reaction during D1D2event:

    BtA1 SplA1 Qtz GrtA1 Crdmelt (1)

    This reaction has a steep dP/dT slope and occurs in the

    temperature range 8009008C under 5 kbar pressure in thehigh fO2 KFMASH grid (Dasgupta et al., 1995). In the low

    fO2 grid, however, this reaction is encountered at slightly

    lower PT condition of 7408C, < 4 kbar emanating fromthe [Opx,Spr] invariant point (Scrimgeour et al., 2001).

    The presence of included ilmenite in GrtA, highly

    titaniferous composition of BtA1 and development of

    abundant rutile would indicate a more complicated multi-

    variant reaction involving TiO2, such as

    BtA1 SplA1 Qtz IlmA1 GrtA1 Rt Crdmelt (2)

    The mesoperthite quartz plagioclase mat surroundinggarnet could indicate the former presence of melt. Owing to

    the coarse grain size of the garnet porphyroblasts and the

    presence of voluminous proportion of quartzo-feldspathic

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 225

  • minerals, we consider that a high degree of partial melting

    occurred at elevated temperatures. Both the above two

    reactions may involve K-feldspar, either as reactant or

    product (Harley, 2008). Experimental data on dehydration

    melting of biotite indicate that such reactions occur at

    T> 8128C at 10 kbar (Vielzeuf and Holloway, 1988; Patinoand Patino Douce, 1991; Gardien et al., 1995; Pickering and

    Johnston, 1998), with the volume of melt increasing with

    temperature. Experimental data also show that XMgBt, TiO2

    Bt

    and FBt increase with temperature (Munoz, 1984; LeBreton

    and Thompson, 1988; Peterson et al., 1991; Patino Douce,

    1993; Skjerlie and Johnston, 1993; Dooley and Patino

    Douce, 1996; Stevens et al., 1997; Pickering and Johnston,

    1998). The included biotite in the present study area is

    magnesian, titaniferous and uorine-rich, which attests to

    very high metamorphic temperatures in the study area.

    Coarse garnet occurs in this rock as another textural

    variety (GrtA2) where it is intergrown with sapphirine, spinel

    (SplA2) and ilmenite (IlmA2) needles (Figure 3g). This

    intergrowth may be a breakdown product of anomalously

    high aluminous orthopyroxene formed during the pre-peak

    prograde stage (Das et al., 2006a).

    Fine-grained aggregate of GrtA3 SilA3Qtz thatreplaces cordierite (Figure 3h) during the high-strain

    event D3 suggesting the reaction

    Crd GrtA3 SilA3 Qtz (3)

    This reaction has at negative dP/dT slope and operates

    due to loading. This could also ensue on melt loss and

    reduction of H2O activity (Harley, 2008).

    Late biotite was formed during M3D4 at the fringes of

    garnet grains with invasion of hydrous uid via the reaction

    GrtA1 SilA3 H2O Bt Qtz (4)

    6.2. Association B

    Abundance of spinel solid solution, plagioclase with quartz

    and rare occurrence of prismatic sillimanite and FeTi

    oxides in this association suggest a Fe-rich, Ti-poor and

    silica-saturated protolith. The peak assemblage in this rock

    is constituted of spinel (SplB1) quartz aluminous ortho-pyroxene (OpxB1) cordierite with minor rutile, monaziteand zircon. Textural data suggests that CrdQtzOpxB1SplB1 formed a stable assemblage during the peak stage.

    Stabilization of this assemblage could be achieved by biotite

    dehydration melting in a semipelitic bulk composition

    during the D1D2 event, viz.

    Bt Pl Qtz OpxB1 SplB1 Crdmelt (5)under high Tlow P conditions (Vielzeuf and Montel, 1994).

    The intergrowth of spinel, cordierite and garnet in

    orthopyroxene porphyroblasts in this association can be

    explained by the reaction relations involving Tschermak

    molecules present in the early-stabilized anomalously high

    aluminous orthopyroxene (Bose et al., 2006). The occur-

    rence of spinel and cordierite in some aluminous orthopyr-

    oxene porphyroblasts can be represented in MAS system via

    Mg-Tschermak breakdown reaction

    Mg Ts Spl Crd (6)at low Phigh T conditions.

    On the other hand, participation of garnet (Prp) in the

    intergrowth requires involvement of Mg-Tschermak com-

    bined with enstatite (En)

    Mg Ts En Prp (7)

    This reaction, modelled by Gasparik (1994) occurs due to

    loading or heating.

    The appearance of a double corona of OpxB2 SilB2separating SplB1 against cordierite porphyroblasts in local

    quartz-free microdomain indicates the operation of FMAS

    divariant reaction in the pre-D3 stage

    SplB1 Crd OpxB2 SilB2 (8)

    A similar double corona of OpxB2 SilB2 also appears onSplB1 separating it from quartz through another FMAS

    divariant reaction

    SplB1 Qtz OpxB2 SilB2 (9)

    These two reactions operate in closely spaced micro-

    domains, possibly during the same stage of metamorphic

    crystallization. These divariant reactions emanate from the

    FMAS univariant reaction

    SplB1 Crd Qtz OpxB2 SilB2 (10)

    Reaction (8) has a at positive dP/dT slope and operates

    due to cooling with or without loading.

    The unique textural feature of the studied rock is

    the breakdown of cordierite to ne-grained orthopyroxene

    (OpxB3), sillimanite (SilB3) and quartz (Figures 4f, Figure 4g).

    This suggests the reaction during high-strain event D3

    Crd Opx B3 SilB3 Qtz (11)

    This reaction has a at dP/dT slope and operates due to

    loading. However, this reaction will occur only due to

    loading in a melt-present situation (Carrington and Watt,

    1995).

    Late biotite formed along the margins of orthopyroxene at

    the last M3D4 event due to hydration in presence of melt/

    alkali feldspar via the reaction

    Opx Sil H2O Bt Qtz (12)

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    226 k. das ET AL.

  • 6.3. Association C

    As discussed earlier, this association has two microdomains

    marked by the presence or absence of quartz. In the quartz-

    absent microdomain, presence of sapphirine, and abundance

    of sillimanite and cordierite, coupled with the magnesian

    nature of all the FeMg phases clearly indicate a silica-

    undersaturated high-magnesian-aluminous domainal bulk

    composition. The early-stabilized phases in this assemblage

    are aluminous orthopyroxene and cordierite with occasional

    relict spinel grains (now enclosed in sapphirine). Such an

    assemblage could form during D1D2 by partial melting of a

    biotite-sillimanite-bearing protolith through the reactions

    Bt SilC1 Qtz OpxC1 Splmelt (13)

    Bt Spl Qtz OpxC1 CrdC1 melt (14)

    K-feldspar can participate in such reactions either as

    reactant or as product depending on the K2O/H2O ratio

    between biotite and melt (Carrington andWatt, 1995). These

    reactions occur in the pressure range of 67 kbar at a

    temperature> 8508C (Das et al., 2001). Absence of quartzin this association possibly implies complete removal of

    silica during the said melting reactions.

    Appearance of sapphirine of 7:9:3 composition engulng

    spinel close to cordierite grains (Figure 5a) suggests the

    FMAS reaction

    Spl CrdC1 Sil Spr (15)

    This reaction occurred during D1D2 prograde meta-

    morphism as it represents a part of the metamorphic peak

    assemblage. The presence of a double corona of

    OpxC2 SilC2 over sapphirine separating it from cordierite(Figure 5a) suggests the reaction

    Spr CrdC1 OpxC2 SilC2 (16)

    This reaction has a at positive dP/dT slope and operated

    due to cooling in the pre-D3 stage.

    In the quartz-present microdomain of this association, the

    appearance of sapphirine from spinel can be explained by

    FMAS reaction during D1D2 prograde metamorphism

    Spl Qtz Sil Spr (17)

    Textural evidence suggests that sapphirine and quartz in

    this microdomain are separated by thick coronae of

    sillimanite and orthopyroxene (Figure 5b). This indicates

    cooling in the pre-D3 stage across the reaction

    Spr Qtz OpxC2 SilC2 (18)

    Reactions (17) and (18) emanate from the FMAS

    univariant reaction

    Spl Spr Qtz OpxC2 SilC2 (19)

    Coarse cordierite grains show breakdown to the sym-

    plectic intergrowth of OpxC3 SilC3Qtz through reaction(11) during D3 as observed in Association B.

    Development of late biotite during M3D4 over orthopyr-

    oxene can be explained by the reaction (12) as inferred for

    Association B.

    7. THERMOBARIC CONDITIONS OF

    METAMORPHISM

    Estimation of PT conditions of metamorphism in a

    polymetamorphosd UHT terrane is plagued with two

    major problems. One is related to down-temperature re-

    equilibration of mineral composition (Harley, 1989; Frost

    and Chacko, 1989; Pattison et al., 2003). The other

    constraint lies in the identication of equilibrium mineral

    compositions at each metamorphic stage.

    First we estimate peak metamorphic temperatures from

    fossil thermometers using the reintegrated composition of

    peak phases. Reintegrated composition of mesoperthitic

    feldspar gives a temperature close to 10008C isotherm in thediagram of Elkins and Grove (1990). The orthopyroxene

    Al-isopleth diagram of Harley (2004) gives peak meta-

    morphic temperatures close to 10008C for the assemblageOpxC1-Spr-Qtz. Intergrown sapphirine and spinel in

    peak garnet (GrtA2 gives temperatures around 8608708Cfollowing the formulation of Das et al. (2006b). This lower

    estimate is probably due to down-temperature resetting of

    mineral compositions.

    Coexistence of sapphirine and quartz during the peak

    metamorphism in Association C clearly indicates tempera-

    tures in excess of 10008C based on both petrogenetic grids inthe system KFMASH (Dasgupta et al., 1995; Das et al.,

    2003; Kelsey et al., 2004) and PT pseudosections

    calculated with the internally consistent dataset of Holland

    and Powell (1998) (Kelsey et al., 2004). The pressure

    condition during peak metamorphism is difcult to estimate,

    as there is a discrepancy of 2.53 kbars between the twoapproaches that has been ascribed to variations in aH2O(Harley, 1998; Kelsey et al., 2004; Baldwin et al., 2005).

    While the experimentally constrained petrogenetic grid in

    the system KFMASH (Das et al., 2003) would indicate peak

    pressures of 9 kbar for the mineral assemblages (spinel-sapphirine-garnet-quartz-orthopyroxene) developed at this

    stage in different associations, the computed grid and

    pseudosection of Kelsey et al. (2004) would indicate 6.57 kbar for the same set of assemblages. Moreover, the

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 227

  • actual pressure estimate will be dependent on the Zn content

    in spinel (Waters, 1991), thereby adding to further

    uncertainty.

    Given the above constraints, we estimate the peak

    metamorphic conditions during the culmination of D1D2to be> 10008C and 79 kbars.Using the Al-isopleth diagram (Harley, 2004), we have

    estimated temperatures in the range of 8008508C whereorthopyroxene equilibrated with cordierite, sillimanite and

    quartz in all the three associations. Garnet (GrtB2) lamellae

    in OpxB1 give a temperature 7308308C using garnet-orthopyroxene thermometer after Lee and Ganguly (1988) in

    the pressure range of 79 kbar. This is obviously a reset

    temperature as the same compositions give temperatures of

    9309408C using the method of Pattison et al. (2003). Wehave used the composition of coexisting Spl-Crd to calculate

    temperature using the formulations of Nichols et al. (1992),

    which takes into consideration the gahnite component in

    spinel. The estimated temperature ranges from 660 to 6908Cat assumed pressures of 78 kbars. The thermometric data

    attests to signicant cooling, probably down to 8008C in thepre-D3 stage, but the pressure conditions during cooling

    could not be pinpointed.

    The appearance of orthopyroxene-sillimanite-quartz

    intergrowth (both in Associations B and C) and of garnet-

    sillimanite-quartz (in Association A) after cordierite may

    imply a rise in pressure as these reactions have at dP/dT

    slopes in the subsystem FMAS (Hensen, 1986). Therefore, it

    is likely that the cooled granulites were subjected to loading

    during D3. Using the orthopyroxene (OpxB3, C3)cordierite

    barometric formulation of Bertrand et al. (1992), we obtain

    pressures around 7.88.0 kbar at an assumed temperature of

    8008C. The garnet (GrtA3)cordierite thermometer ofNichols et al. (1992), gives 7208C at 8 kbar. It is evidentfrom the above that minor loading of 1 kbar could havetaken place during D3. In the subsequent section, we will

    explore an alternative explanation.

    Garnet-biotite thermometry (after Ferry and Spear, 1978)

    gives 4008C for late biotite (Bt2) patches on garnet occurringduring theM3D4 event. Since this formulation does not take

    into account the Ti and F content in biotite, the estimate is

    only a lower limit. An upper limit is obtained from the Ti

    content of late biotite in this rock saturated with ilmenite and

    quartz that plots above the 8008C isotherm (Henry et al.,2005).

    8. PSEUDOSECTION AND PETROGENETIC GRID

    CONSIDERATIONS

    In this section we investigate further the PT conditions and

    PT path of metamorphism using pseudosection modelling.

    Such studies are complicated in the case of polymeta-

    morphic granulites because re-metamorphism occurs in a

    bulk composition that has changed substantially from that of

    the protolith due to partial melting and melt loss during the

    earlier event (White et al., 2001). Extraction of melt in

    varying proportions is considered to be a key factor in the

    preservation of peak granulite assemblages (White and

    Powell, 2002; Kelsey et al., 2003). Drawing analogy, we can

    argue that an indenite amount of melt was extracted from

    the studied rocks as the peak UHT assemblages are

    preserved. While the breakdown of cordierite to orthopyr-

    oxene sillimanite quartz (Reaction 11) or to gar-net sillimanite quartz (Reaction 3) can be facilitatedby extraction of melt, preservation of all stages of textural

    conversions (Figures 4f and g) show that melt loss was far

    from complete. Formation of high F-bearing biotite

    during D4 attests to limited melt-solid interaction signifying

    presence of melt at even the last stage. At the same time,

    maximum reaction progress (complete pseudomorphism)

    can occur in domains of extensive melt loss. Since the

    cordierite breakdown reactions occurred simultaneously

    with D3 compression and shearing, melt extraction could

    have been facilitated in domains by tectonic squeezing. This

    would obviate the requirement of loading for cordierite to

    break down. We have undertaken a PT pseudosection

    approach to test whether loading is at all required to break

    cordierite down.

    Two general approaches have been followed to model the

    protolith composition where possible melt loss occurred.

    One approach is to use several hypothetical bulk compo-

    sitions (White et al., 2001, 2007; Johnson and Brown, 2004),

    primarily because the migmatites are themselves refractory

    from which an unspecied amount of melt has been lost. A

    more rigorous approach to resolve this problem is to use the

    changed bulk rock composition using the theoretical

    calculation matched with natural data (cf. Saha et al., 2008).

    A second approach uses an effective bulk composition,

    estimated through calculated mineral modes and mineral

    compositions have been applied to compute PT pseudosec-

    tion (Kelsey et al., 2003; Baldwin et al., 2005). In this work

    we have followed the latter because of the difculty to

    estimate the volume and composition of melt extracted from

    the system. Even where leucosomes are present, as in the

    case of Associations A and B, it is likely that part of these

    could be of cumulate origin (e.g. Johnson and Brown, 2004).We have taken up two unique microdomains in the studied

    rocks for phase relation modelling. These represent discrete

    mineralogical domains with distinct domainal chemical

    compositions. One is the intergrowth involving cordierite,

    spinel, garnet and quartz in porphyroblastic orthopyroxene

    (Figures 4d and e). The other one is the pseudomorphous

    breakdown of cordierite porphyroblasts in the high-strain

    zones to orthopyroxene, sillimanite and quartz

    (Figures 4f and g). The bulk compositions for both the

    microdomains have been calculated by the modal ratios of

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    228 k. das ET AL.

  • the phases present (using image analysis of microphoto-

    graphs and BSE images) and their respective mineral

    compositions. The recalculated bulk compositions in both

    the cases can be represented in the simplied FMAS (FeO-

    MgO-Al2O3-SiO2) system. Phase relations were modelled in

    the FMAS system using THERMOCALC v.3.2.3 (Powell

    and Holland, 1988), and the dataset of Holland and

    Powell (1998, version 5.5 s, November 2003) with the

    activity-composition model for sapphirine of Kelsey et al.

    (2004).

    The two pseudosections were constructed to characterize

    the PT history of the near-peak metamorphic condition and

    of the later high-strain event (D3). Porphyroblastic

    aluminous orthopyroxene (zoned in terms of alumina from

    core to rim) contains intergrown garnet, spinel and cordierite

    along crystallographic orientations in the presence of quartz

    in Association B. This assemblage is considered to have

    developed at near-peak metamorphic condition. In the

    earlier section, we explained the development of these

    intergrowths in porphyroblastic orthopyroxene from break-

    ing down of non-quadrilateral aluminous orthopyroxene. It

    is, however, not possible to construct pseudosections with

    ctive components, such as the Tschermak molecule in

    orthopyroxene. Instead, we have modelled the reaction

    orthopyroxene spinel quartz garnet cordierite (Spr,Sil) from the recalculated domainal bulk composition in the

    FMAS system (compositional relationship is shown in

    Figure 6a) to obtain the relative stability elds of the

    different assemblages present in the intergrowths. The

    pseudosection (Figure 6b) shows that the reaction has a

    steep slope separating different divariant and trivariant

    elds. On the low pressure side the stable trivariant

    assemblage contains orthopyroxene, spinel and cordierite.

    With increasing pressure the stable assemblages on the low

    temperature side change to orthopyroxene-cordierite-garnet,

    and subsequently to orthopyroxene-garnet-quartz through

    intermediate divariant assemblages, e.g. orthopyroxene-

    spinel-garnet-cordierite and orthopyroxene-cordierite-gar-

    net-quartz. Although it is not possible to identify any

    sequence of mineral development from Figures 4d and

    Figure 4e, stabilization of quartz with garnet (Figure 4e)

    may reect loading from an early-stabilized cordierite and

    spinel (Figure 4d), as shown in Figure 6b. Loading near to

    Figure 6. (a) Compositional plots of the phases in (AlFe3)2O3/totalFMAS vs. SiO2/total FMAS space (in atomic fraction). The tie-line ip andpiercing plane relations are elucidated in the text. Note the position ofcordierite (Crd) within the two compositional triangles, i.e. Opx-Sil-Qtz andGrt-Sil-Qtz. (b) PT pseudosection for the microdomain with recalculatedbulk composition of SiO2:Al2O3:MgO:FeO 46.55:10.25:25.28:17.91 (inmole ratio) made by THERMOCALC v3.2.3 (Powell and Holland, 1988).Internally consistent thermodynamic dataset of Holland and Powell (1998)is used. Activity-composition model of sapphirine is taken from Kelseyet al. (2004). Dashed isopleths are for y(Opx) and mixed dash-dot linerepresents isopleth for XFe of garnet, i.e. x(Grt). Note the probable PT pathshowing evolution in the near-peak metamorphic condition. (c) PT

    pseudosection for the microdomain where cordierite is broken down toorthopyroxene-sillimanite-quartz assemblage in a later structuralevent, D3. Bulk composition recalculated as SiO2:Al2O3:MgO:FeO56.06:21.94:18.16:3.85 (in mole ratio). Note the disposition of differentvariance elds (v 2 and 3) and the isopleths [y(Opx) as dashed lines,x(Opx) as dotted lines and x(Crd) as thin continuous lines]. At 8508C, aslight pressure increase of 500 bars can induce this breakdown through thedivariant eld of orthopyroxene-cordierite-sillimanite-quartz at proper uidactivity. As discussed in the text, such breakdown can be aggravated further

    by melt loss from the high-strained microdomains.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 229

  • peak metamorphic conditions is also supported by the

    garnet-spinel-sapphirine intergrowth in Association A (cf.

    Das et al., 2006a). The postulated near-peak loading is

    consistent with an anticlockwise PT path deduced from

    adjacent areas (Sengupta et al., 1990; Bose et al., 2000).

    Similar anticlockwise PT paths have also been reported

    from other UHT terranes (e.g. Santosh et al., 2007). The

    cooling segment of the PT path shown in Figure 6b is

    construed from the Al-zoning in orthopyroxene as described

    in the preceding section. Although the pseudosection is

    constructed in the FMAS system, the presence of a small

    amount of Fe3 in sapphirine, spinel and orthopyroxeneactually implies the relevant system be FMAS(O). At

    elevated oxygen fugacity, the stability of phases like spinel

    would enlarge and as a result grid topology would change

    and even some of the peak assemblages would be enlarged

    towards lower temperature (KFMASH system; Das et al.,

    2003; Harley, 2008 and references therein).

    The second pseudosection was constructed to model the

    FMAS reaction orthopyroxene cordierite sillimanitesapphirine quartz (Grt, Spl) (compositional relationship isshown in Figure 6a) using the microdomainal bulk

    composition in Association C (Figure 6c). Two divariant

    assemblages, e.g. orthopyroxene-cordierite-sillimanite-

    quartz on the lower temperature side and orthopyroxene-

    cordierite-sapphirine-quartz on the high temperature side,

    are associated with this univariant reaction. On the lower

    temperature side, cordierite breaks down to orthopyroxene,

    sillimanite and quartz with slight increase of pressure

    0.5 kbar. In Association C this reaction occurredduring D3, subsequent to cooling down to 8008 C(reactions 16, 18). The above analysis suggests possible

    minor loading of the cooled granulites at around 8508C(Figure 6c). As discussed earlier, breakdown of cordierite

    could have been aided by extraction of melt with its

    dissolved H2O along high-strain zones of the rock (tectonic

    squeezing (?) during D3 event contemporaneous with the

    development of S3m mylonitic foliation). Oxide total in all

    analysed cordierite grains ranges between 9798wt%,

    which implies the possible presence of uids. However,

    in the absence of analytical data for H2O and CO2, we can

    hardly quantify the nature of uid and its control over

    cordierite stability in the studied rocks. It is therefore

    difcult to specify whether cordierite breakdown is solely

    caused by loading or melt extraction.

    9. GEOCHRONOLOGY

    We analysed zircon grains for U-Pb ages with an ion

    microprobe to constrain major thermal imprints on the

    assemblages. Additionally, we undertook EPMA chemical

    dating of monazite included within orthopyroxene and

    sapphirine porphyroblasts in Association C to constrain the

    timing of M1 metamorphism. Monazite grains present

    within cordierite grains were also analysed for

    comparison.

    9.1. Analytical methods

    About 1 kg of the representative sample (Pan03) was

    initially crushed, and zircon grains were concentrated using

    water table and magnetic separation. Individual crystals

    were selected and hand-picked under the optical microscope

    for mounting. Analytical procedures adopted were the

    same as those followed in Shiraishi et al. (2008). Spots

    within the zircon crystals were selected using optical, BSE

    and CL imaging (Figure 7), and were analysed on the

    SHRIMP II at the National Institute of Polar Research,

    Japan. Analytical data are presented in Supplementary

    Table 5 and plotted in a TerraWasserburg diagram

    (Figure 8a). Uncertainties quoted in the tables and in the

    text for individual analyses (ratios and ages) as well as plots

    are at 68% condence level (1s), whereas concordia and

    mean age calculations were done at 95% condence level.

    Concordia age calculation has been done using the program

    SQUID (version1.02, Ludwig, 2001) which takes into

    account the error in the standard. Plots are done by the

    program ISOPLOT/EX (version 3.6, Ludwig, 2008). Back

    Scatter Emission (BSE) and Cathodoluminescence (CL)

    images of the analysed zircon grains reveal complex internal

    structure with characteristic CL responses. While neoblastic

    homogeneous to simple concentric zoned zircon shows

    virtually no inheritance, other grains contain inherited

    domains surrounded by overgrowth.

    Monazite grains included within orthopyroxene or

    associated with sapphirine were targeted for chemical

    analysis. Those grains were analysed by the CAMECA-

    SX100 electron microprobe at Indian Institute of Technol-

    ogy, Kharagpur, India. The instrument was operated with

    20 kV acceleration voltage and 200 nA beam current with

    1mm beam diameter. Details of analytical procedure areafter Bhandari et al. (2011). Natural standards were used for

    chemical analyses, while externally dated monazite standard

    with an IDTIMS age of 2546Ma were used for age

    calibration. During the entire analytical session, the above

    standard gave an age of 2558 105Ma. Counting times forPb and Th were taken as 300 s and 200 s, respectively, while

    those for other elements vary in the range 20100 s. Prior to

    analysis, the target grains were mapped for U, Th, La and Ce,

    so that different compositional domains could be identied.

    Results of all the analyses are presented in Supplementary

    Table 6. Calculation of weighted mean age is done by the

    program ISOPLOT/EX (version 3.6, Ludwig, 2008).

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    230 k. das ET AL.

  • 9.2. Results

    Mounted zircon grains are oval to circular in shape with a

    few elongated and euhedral in appearance. Grain size varies

    from 100 to 200mm in length and 100150mm in width.Apart from a few neoblastic grains, most grains show core-

    rim structure where the inner part is made of a thick

    oscillatory-zoned domain with or without inherited cores.

    Neoblastic grains are broadly homogeneous, some having

    simple concentric zoning. Few apparently neoblastic grains

    shows faint traces of hidden oscillatory/planar zoning at the

    core region (Figure 7a). The outermost domain consists

    of planar banded overgrowth with moderate CL response

    (Figures 7b and c). Inherited cores in a few grains show

    sector-zoning with brighter CL response compared to the

    overgrowths (Figures 7d and h). The overgrowth domain is

    5080mm thick and normally inclusion-free, but a fewbiotite akes were noticed in some grains. Some of these

    grains show sector-zoning (Figures 7c and e), typically

    found in zircon growing from anatectic melt (Vavra et al.,

    1996; Schaltegger et al., 1999; Kelly et al., 2002; Kelly and

    Harley, 2005). The oscillatory zoned domain is 50100mmin length often with abraded and angular outline. In a few

    grains, the oscillatory zoned domain shows prominent

    resorption (Figures 7f and i). In others, it is often blurred in

    appearance and surrounded by a somewhat dark-CL domain

    where faint traces of oscillatory zoning could be identied

    (Figure 7g). Inclusions of biotite (both aky and sub-

    rounded) and alkali feldspar are present within this domain.

    The dark-CL domain surrounding the oscillatory zoned

    domain shows evidence of recrystallization and resorption

    presumably by a coupled dissolution reprecipitation process

    (Geisler et al., 2007). The sharp contrast in CL responses and

    Th/U ratios between the oscillatory zoned and the over-

    growth domain suggest the former as inherited in origin.

    Some of the oscillatory zoned zircon grains, however,

    Figure 7. Cathodoluminescence (CL) images of analysed zircon grains showing internal structures and obtained ages. 207Pb-206Pb ages are shown inparentheses as quoted from Supplementary Table 5 with 1s uncertainty. Grain numbers are shown at the top left of each grain while spot numbers are labelled ineach spot. (a) Neoblastic grain, (b) Planar-zoned grain with detrital core, (c) Neoblastic grain with planar zoning, (d) Planar zoned overgrowth on multilayeredgrain with detrital core, (e) Sector zoned overgrowth on detrital core, (f) Planar zoned overgrowth on dark-CL core containing resorbed detrital core, (g)Oscillatory zoned grain showing faint traces of blurring of zoning towards the periphery, (h) and (i) Truncated bright-CL core surrounded by dark-CL

    recrystallized zone.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 231

  • preserve tiny relics of detrital core of rounded to irregular

    outline.

    Forty-four spots were analysed from 33 grains including

    multiple spots from oscillatory zoned, recrystallized/

    resorption and overgrowth domains. Spots from the

    oscillatory zoned domain (four spots) show varying U

    (2611176 ppm) and Th (133564 ppm) contents as

    reected in a wide variety in the Th/U ratio (0.122.23).

    Three spots give weakly discordant ages (36% discor-

    dance) and show broadly similar Th/U ratio (0.120.37).207Pb-206Pb age spans ca. 16801710Ma with a weighted

    mean of 1698 46Ma (95% conf., MSWD 2.7). Theother spot 33.1 shows a very strong reverse discordance,

    even though the U content is below 300 ppm. An irregular

    count of radiogenic Pb observed in this particular analysis

    (and a few others as shown in Supplementary Table 5), could

    be the major factor as noted in other studies (Compston,

    1992; McFarlane et al., 2006). A large number of spots

    were analysed from the dark-CL recrystallized/resorption

    domain (n 20). This combined domain shows variable U(1702594 ppm), Th (43234 ppm) and Th/U ratios (0.06

    0.95). Th/U ratios, however, lie in the much narrower range

    of 0.060.29 except spot 1.1. Obtained ages are all

    discordant (123%) in the range ca. 16001100Ma

    (207Pb-206Pb age; Supplementary Table 5). Spot ages are

    more concordant (14%) at the older age end and most

    Figure 8. (a) TerraWasserburg diagram showing plots of data points. 24 data points from oscillatory zoned and recrystallized/resorption domains are used forcalculation of intercept ages. Three spots (out of four) from oscillatory zoned domain gives 207Pb-206Pb mean age of 1698 46Ma. A group of spots (n 7)from overgrowth and neoblastic grains denes a concordia age of 953 6Ma.Weighted average ofmean 207Pb-206Pb ages from a group of 6 data points from thesame domain denes an age of 902 17Ma. Reversely discordant data are not used for group age calculation. (b) and (c) Weighted average of mean ages of two

    groups of data from overgrowth and neoblastic grain domain.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    232 k. das ET AL.

  • discordant (923%) at the midway. This observation and

    internal structure convincingly prove that the recrystalliza-

    tion/resorption domain developed due to disturbance of the

    oscillatory zoned domain and obtained ages imply mixing of

    two thermal events. When we combine all data from this

    domain with data from the oscillatory zoned domain and plot

    in the TerraWasserburg diagram, the mixing line shows

    upper and lower intercepts of 1689 62Ma and934 57Ma, respectively (Figure 8a) with high scatter(MSWD 6.0). The upper intercept age is in the range ofcalculated mean age and signies the crystallization age of

    oscillatory zoned domain, which we equate with the timing

    of magmatism in the source region from which the sediment

    was derived. This age is similar to that documented recently

    from central part of EGB (Bose et al., 2008). The lower

    intercept age broadly matches with ages from overgrowth

    and neoblastic grain domains (discussed below).

    Outer overgrowth and neoblastic grains show similar CL

    characters and a narrow range of U (211585 ppm) and Th

    (26142 ppm) contents. Th/U ratio mostly varies in the

    range 0.20.4, while a few show lower (< 0.1) and highervalues (0.60.7). Analysed spots (n 20) give concordant toweakly discordant ages. A few grains show weak to

    moderate reverse discordance as well due to irregular

    radiogenic Pb count (discussed before). 207Pb-206Pb ages

    spread in the range ca. 1020880Ma with a distinct

    cluster near ca. 950Ma (Figure 8a). A concordant age of

    953 6Ma (95% conf., MSWD 1.4) is obtained from agroup of seven spots. This is broadly similar to the mean207Pb-206Pb age of 949 10Ma (95% conf., MSWD 1.6;Figure 8b). These concordant and pooled ages imply that the

    major growth of zircon took place at ca. 950Ma. Spots with207Pb-206Pb ages in the range ca. 9601020Ma (n 6) areweakly discordant (16%). It is noted that this age group is

    shown by spots occurring at the central part of a neoblastic

    grain with hidden cores (as spot 11.1) or inner part of the

    overgrowth that partly overlaps with the oscillatory zoned

    domain (spot 21.1). These spot ages are thus not used for

    group age calculation. A group of six spots with similar CL

    character and Th/U ratios give a younger mean age of

    902 17Ma (95% conf., MSWD 1.9, Figure 8c). Thismay suggest partial modication of an older zircon by an

    unrelated much younger event (Pan African?) during which

    no new zircon growth took place. Alternatively, this age may

    signify the nal crystallization of zircon from extracted melt

    and associated hydration event (M3D4). In the absence of

    new zircon growth during any event younger than 900Ma,

    the latter possibility seems more reasonable. The three-fold

    clustering of ages is very similar to geochronologic data

    from similar rocks in the adjacent localities (Bose et al.,

    2008) and possibly the entire central part of the EGB.

    The Th/U ratio is an important criterion to distinguish zircon

    produced by magmatic (Th/U> 0.1) and metamorphic (Th/U

    < 0.1) process (Rubatto, 2002). Most of the analysed spots inthe present sample show a Th/U ratio in the range 0.50.1

    (Figure 9a). Notably, spots from oscillatory zoned domain

    are always showing Th/U > 0.1, while a few spots fromovergrowth domain show Th/U < 0.1. No clear correlationexists between Th/U ratio and spot age (Figure 9b). A simple

    correlation of Th/U ratio and zircon forming process

    (magmatic or metamorphic) is problematic because enrich-

    ment and/or depletion of Th over U is a complex function of

    multiple factors (as discussed by Harley et al., 2007). There are

    examples of zircon of undisputed metamorphic origin where

    Th/U ratio exceeds 0.1 that even reached up to > 1 (Hokadaand Harley, 2004; Kelly and Harley, 2005).

    The timing of M1 metamorphism is difcult to determine

    from mounted zircon grains since the textural contexts are

    not properly understood. Texturally constrained monazite

    grains, however, proved to be extremely useful for this

    purpose. Monazite included within orthopyroxene and

    associated with sapphirine grains (Figure 5c) are likely to

    reect the timing of near-peak condition of M1 event since

    the enclosing phases are demonstrably stabilized during the

    peak (Figures 10a and b). A weighted average of U-Pb spot

    Figure 9. (a) Plot of Th and U contents of all the spots from oscillatory-zoned, recrystallized and overgrowth/neoblastic grain domains. (b) Plot of

    Th/U ratio and 207Pb-206Pb ages from all the analysed spots.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 233

  • ages gives a mean of 987 11Ma, which is the best estimatefor this event (Figures 10c and d). This age broadly coincides

    with a few spot ages from mounted zircon grains,

    particularly those from the central part of neoblastic zircon.

    Other textural varieties of monazite grains enclosed

    within cordierite grains were also analysed for comparison.

    Those yield spot ages close to 900Ma (grain 4 in

    Supplementary Table 5), distinctly younger than the other

    population. This ca. 900Ma monazite age broadly coincides

    with a zircon U-Pb SHRIMP age for the overgrowth domain.

    10. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

    Integrated structural, petrological and geochronological

    study on a suite of aluminous granulites and associated

    gneisses from the study area in the Eastern Ghats Belt attests

    to polyphase tectonothermal evolution of the rocks. The

    deformation history is presented schematically in Figure 11

    depicting fold interference pattern arising out of three

    deformational episodes. The isoclinally folded F2 has been

    superposed by a broadly NWSE compression (D3) at low

    angles to that of the D2 compression. This fold interference

    produced upright gently plunging folds with NESW

    trending axial trace. The D3 event also witnessed develop-

    ment of localized shears accompanying F3. The nal

    architecture of the fold interference is manifested by cross

    folding at high angles during D4 producing a non-planar fold

    and domal structure.

    Aluminous granulites recorded polymetamorphic signa-

    tures with an early counter-clockwise metamorphic evol-

    ution (M1) culminating in UHT condition (> 10008C) at6.58.5 kbar, corresponding to a crustal depth of 2030 km.

    The prograde path of M1 traversed from an initial high T-low

    P condition, followed by loading contemporaneous with

    D1D2 deformations. Since it is not possible to denitely

    assign any mineral reaction specically to either D1 or D2,

    we are constrained to amalgamate these together. Never-

    theless, it is evident that extensive partial melting of the

    protolith occurred during prograde metamorphism, followed

    by limited melt segregation/extraction. Later thermal

    relaxation of the crust was achieved by cooling (M1R)

    down to 8008C, during the inter-kinematic gap D2D3. M2

    Figure 10. Chemical age data from included monazite (Mnz) grains (a) associated with sapphirine (Spr) porphyroblasts and (b) included within orthopyroxene(Opx) from the studied samples. Note that both the sapphirine and the monazite grains are surrounded by same layer of sillimanite (Sil) corona. Spot ages are

    plotted on the respective monazite BSE images. (c) Weighted mean age and (d) probability density plot for the analysed sample.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    234 k. das ET AL.

  • metamorphism was associated with a slight loading of the

    cooled granulites, and was heralded by a compressive

    event D3. D3 caused deep crustal shears accompanying

    small- to regional-scale folds due to bulk SENW

    compression. Crystal plastic deformation of ferromagnesian

    minerals indicates shearing at elevated temperatures

    under M2 granulite facies condition. It is likely that tectonic

    squeezing during D3 caused partial melt extraction thereby

    promoting mineral reactions. Since we identify D3 as a

    distinct structural event superimposed on cooled granulites,

    we propose that it is temporally unrelated to D1D2 and M1metamorphism. Regardless of the relative importance of

    the two phenomena, viz. melt extraction and loading, in

    promoting the mineral reactions during D3, we propose

    that D3M2 is a distinctly separate tectonothermal event

    superimposed on the cooled UHT granulites. Minor retro-

    gression of the mineral assemblages occurred during D4 in

    localized zones in the presence of melt. The tectonometa-

    morphic history of the studied area is summarized in Table 1

    and Figure 12.

    Previous studies on the EGB granulites (summarized in

    Dasgupta and Sengupta, 2003) also invoked granulite facies

    re-metamorphism of isobarically cooled UHT metamor-

    phosed rocks. While an anticlockwise PT trajectory has

    been established for the UHT metamorphism (Sengupta

    et al., 1990; Dasgupta et al., 1995), the PT path for the

    second granulite metamorphism remained elusive. The

    present study showed for the rst time a prograde history

    Figure 12. The overall PT-t evolutionary history of the studied rockplotted on the FMAS grid to show the important stable mineral assemblages.The evolutionary path is drawn combining PT vectors from Figures 6b andc as well as geochronological data. The stability eld of SprOpxQtzand other UHT assemblages are drawn following the data of Kelsey et al.(2004). The post-M2 retrogressive segment is shown as a broken line

    although there is no diagnostic textural feature present in the rock.

    Figure 11. Schematic block diagram showing interference of folding developed by three episodes of deformation. Note the angular relationship between the F2and F3 fold axes and also the steeply dipping shear bands produced during the D3 event.

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    multiple tectonometamorphic imprints in the lower crust, egb, india 235

  • (loading with/without heating) of the second granulite

    metamorphism (M2 in this work synchronous to a high-

    strain event triggering possible melt extraction). Available

    geochronological data on the EGB rocks is inconclusive

    with respect to the timing of M1 metamorphism (1.5 Ga,

    Shaw et al., 1997; 1.11.2 Ga, Jarick, 2000, 1.11.25 Ga,

    Simmat and Raith, 2008). A recent geochronological study

    from the Ongole Domain of the southern part of EGB reveals

    that the UHT metamorphism occurred at ca. 1.63 Ga

    (Upadhyay et al., 2009). Data presented by Upadhyay et al.

    (2009) further show that the timing of metamorphism in the

    type Eastern Ghats Province within the EGB (of which the

    present study area belongs) is much younger (ca. 1.2

    0.5Ga). The monazite chemical age data presented in our

    study suggest that the M1 event was much younger (ca.

    1000Ma) than envisaged by previous monazite age data

    (Simmat and Raith, 2008). Weakly to strongly discordant

    ages from the oscillatory zoned domains in zircon with a

    mean age of ca. 1700Ma probably record a magmatic event

    in the source region (see Bose et al., 2008). The granulite-

    grade overprint on the UHT M1 assemblages, which is

    documented as M2 in the present study is considered to be of

    younger age based on earlier isotopic data (1.00.95 Ga,

    Grew and Manton, 1986; Shaw et al., 1997; Mezger and

    Cosca, 1999; Simmat and Raith, 2008 and references

    therein). SHRIMP U-Pb data from the present study yield a

    concordant age of 953 6Ma, which tightly constrainsthe timing of M2 metamorphism. This event witnessed

    growth of new zircon (neoblastic grains) as well as zircon

    overgrowth on inherited zircon, possibly in the presence of

    melt that has subsequently been extracted during the D3mevent. This sharply dened age of M2 event matches with the

    thermal and structural events in the Rayner Complex

    (ca. 940910Ma, Kelly et al., 2002; Harley, 2003; Halpin

    et al., 2005, 2007). The UHT M1 metamorphism in the

    central EGB is temporally unrelated to the crustal

    development in the Rayner Complex. However, the timing

    and deduced PT path of M2 overprint in the EGB is similar

    to that in the Kemp Land and Oygarden areas of the Rayner

    Complex (Harley, 2003; Kelly and Harley, 2005). Ayounger

    pooled age of ca. 900Ma in the studied rock possibly

    signies the M3D4 event when zircon grains nally

    crystallized from the extracted melt. This is again similar

    to the timing of zircon growth during the D3D4 events in

    rocks from Oygarden area of the Rayner Complex (Kelly

    et al., 2002). Moreover, a striking similarity between the D3structural characteristics in the present study area and D3D4structural reworking in the Oygarden area (Kelly et al.,

    2000) reinforces the notion that the EGB and Rayner

    Complex shared a common geologic history from ca.

    950Ma to ca. 900Ma as parts of Rodinia.

    The present study provides record of a prolonged

    geological history spanning nearly 800Ma (ca. 1700

    900Ma) in the EGB, which is far longer than what has been

    conceived so far. Though the retrievable tectonometa-

    morphic history ranges from ca. 1000Ma to ca. 900Ma, the

    earliest ca. 1700Ma age domain from zircon is intriguing, as

    similar ages are reported from southern and central parts of

    the EGB in recent times (Bose et al., 2008). Moreover,

    tectonothermal events of this age have been reported from

    different crustal blocks of India (Sarkar et al., 1989, Buick

    et al., 2006) as well as crustal blocks of Antarctica,

    Australia, North China and Laurentia (Goodge et al., 2001).

    This timeframe witnessed the growth of the supercontinent

    Columbia (Rogers and Santosh, 2002, 2009; Zhao et al.,

    2004; Santosh et al., 2009). Future research in the EGB

    needs to be aimed at understanding the signicance of

    the older ages. The EGB rocks, however, record a more

    pervasive tectonothermal imprint during the assembly of

    Rodinia.

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    Authors thank Dr Ichiro Ohnishi for the EPMA analyses data

    of biotite in certain key microdomains. T. Kuwajima, H.

    Nomura andM. Ikeda of Hokkaido University helped during

    analysis. They also thank Dr N.C. Pant for monazite EMP

    analysis. Insightful comments by Drs. S.K. Bhowmik and T.

    Tsunogae helped to improve the quality of the manuscript.

    Simon Harleys comments and suggestions on an earlier

    version of this manuscript were very helpful during sub-

    sequent revision. Editorial handling by M. Santosh is thank-

    fully acknowledged. KD and SB acknowledge DST,

    Government of India for a research grant. SK has been

    supported by the CAS programme of Jadavpur University.

    SB acknowledges the Japan Society for the Promotion of

    Science (JSPS grant no. 07043) for working in Yokohama

    National University in collaboration with the National Insti-

    tute of Polar Research, Japan. SB was also supported by

    FIST programme of DST of Government of India at

    Presidency College. SDG acknowledges nancial support

    from the DST, Government of India through J.C. Bose

    Fellowship.

    REFERENCES

    Baldwin, J.A., Powell, R., Brown, M., Moraes, R., Fuck, R.A. 2005.Modeling of mineral equilibria in ultrahigh-temperature metamorphicrocks from the Anapolis-Itaucu Complex, central Brazil. Journal ofMetamorphic Geology 23, 511531.

    Bertrand, P., Ouzegane, K.H., Kienast, J.R. 1992. P-T-X relationships inthe Precambrian Al-Mg rich granulites from In Ouzzal, Hoggar, Algeria.Journal of Metamorphic Geology 10, 1731.

    Bhandari, A., Pant, N.C., Bhowmik, S.K., Goswami, S. 2011. 1.6Gaultrahigh-temperature granulite metamorphism in the Central IndianTectonic Zone: insights from metamorphic reaction history, geothermo-

    Copyright # 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Geol. J. 46: 217239 (2011)

    236 k. das ET AL.

  • barometry and monazite chemical ages. Geological Journal 46, (thisvolume).

    Bhowmik, S.K. 1997. Multiple episodes of tectonothermal processes in theEastern Ghats granulite belt. Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences (Earth and Planetary Science) 106, 131146.

    Bhowmik, S., Dasgupta, S., Hoernes, S., Bhattacharya, P.K. 1995.Extremely high temperature calc silicate granulites from the EasternGhats Belt, India: evidence for isobaric cooling, uid buffering andterminal channelized uid ow. European Journal of Mineralogy 7, 689703.

    Bose, S., Das, K. 2007. SapphirineRquartz assemblage in contrastingtextural modes from the Eastern Ghats Belt, India: implications forstability relations in UHT metamorphism and retrograde processes.Gondwana Research 11, 492503.

    Bose, S., Das, K., Dasgupta, S., Miura, H., Fukuoka, M. 2006. Inter-growth textures in orthopyroxene in aluminous granulites as indicators ofUHT metamorphism: new evidence from the Eastern Ghats Belt, India.Lithos 92, 506523.

    Bose, S., Dunkley, D.J., Arima, M. 2008. Zircon U-Pb SHRIMP ages fromEastern Ghats Belt, India and their implication in the IndoAntarcticcorrelation. Abstract V-2159, AGU Fall Meeting.

    Bose, S., Fukuoka,M., Sengupta, P., Dasgupta, S. 2000. Evolution of highMg-Al granulites from Sunkarametta, Eastern Ghats, India: evidence fora lower crustal heating-cooling trajectory. Journal of MetamorphicGeology 18, 223240.

    Buick, I.S., Allen, C., Pandit, M., Rubatto, D., Hermann, J. 2006. TheProterozoic magmatic and metamorphic history of the Banded GneissComplex, central Rajasthan, India: LA-ICP-MS UPb zircon constraints.Precambrian Research 151, 119142.

    Carrington, D.P.,Watt, G.R. 1995. A geochemical and experimental studyof the role of K-feldspar during water-undersaturated melting of meta-pelites. Chemical Geology 122, 5976.

    Chetty, T.R.K. Structural architecture of the northern composite terrane,the Eastern Ghats Mobile Belt, India: implications for Gondwana tec-tonics. Gondwana Research (in press). DOI:10.1016/j.gr.2010.02.006

    Compston, W. 1992. Geological age by instrumental analysis: the 29thHallimond lecture. Mineralogical Magazine 63, 297311.

    Das, K., Bose, S., Ohnishi, I., Dasgupta, S. 2006a. Garnet-spinel inter-growth in ultrahigh-temperature granulite, Eastern Ghats, India: possibleevidence of an early Tschermak-rich orthopyroxene during progrademetamorphism. American Mineralogist 91, 375384.

    Das, K., Fujino, K., Tomioka, N., Miura, H. 2006b. Experimental data onFe and Mg partitioning between coexisting sapphirine and spinel: anempirical thermometer and its application. European Journal of Miner-alogy 18, 4958.

    Das, K., Dasgupta, S., Miura, H. 2001. Stability of osumilite coexistingwith spinel solid solution in metapelitic granulites at high oxygenfugacity. American Mineralogist 86, 14231434.

    Das, K., Dasgupta, S., Miura, H. 2003. An experimentally constrainedpetrogenetic grid in the silica-saturated portion of the system KFMASHat high temperature and pressure. Journal of Petrology 44, 10551075.

    Dasgupta, S., Sengupta, P. 2003. Indo-Antarctic correlation: a perspectivefrom the Eastern Ghats Granulite Belt, India. In: Proterozoic EastGondwana: Supercontinent Assembly and Breakup, Yoshida, M, Wind-ley, BF, Dasgupta, S (eds). Geological Society, London, SpecialPublications 206; 131143.

    Dasgupta, S., Sengupta, P., Ehl, J., Raith,M., Bardhan, S. 1995. Reactiontextures in a suite of spinel granulites from Eastern Ghats Belt, India:evidence for polymetamorphism and a partial petrogenetic grid in thesystem KFMASH and the roles of ZnO and Fe2O3. Journal of Petrology36, 435461.

    Dasgupta, S., Sanyal, S., Sengupta, P., Fukuoka, M. 1994. Petrology ofgranulites from Anakapalle: evidence for Proterozoic decompression inthe Eastern Ghats, India. Journal of Petrology 35, 433459.

    Dobmeier, C.J., Raith, M.M. 2003. Crustal architecture and evolution ofthe Eastern Ghats Belt and adjacent regions of India. In: Proterozoic EastGondwana: Supercontinent Assembly and Breakup, Yoshida, M, Wind-ley, BF, Dasgupta, S (eds). Geological Society, London, Special Publi-cations 206, 145168.

    Dooley, D.F., Patino Douce, A.E. 1996. Fluid-absent melting of F-richphlogopiteRrutileRquartz. American Mineralogist 81, 202212.

    Elkins, L.T., Grove, T.L. 1990. Ternary feldspar experiments and thermo-dynamic models. American Mineralogist 75, 544559.

    Ferry, J.M., Spear, F.S. 1978. Experimental calibration of the partitioningof Fe and Mg between biotite and garnet. Contributions to Mineralogyand Petrology 66, 113117.

    Frost, B.R., Chacko, T. 1989. The granulite uncertainty principle: limita-tions to thermobarometry in granulites. Journal of Geology 97, 435450.

    Gardien, V., Thompson, A.B., Grujic, D., Ulmer, P. 1995. Experimentalmelting of biotiteRplagioclaseRquartzWmuscovite assemblages andimplications for crustal melting. Journal of Geophysical Research100, 1558115591.

    Gasparik, T. 1994. A petrogenetic grid for the system MgO-Al2O3-SiO2.Journal of Geology 102, 97109.

    Geisler, T., Schaltegger, U., Tomaschek, F. 2007. Reequilibration of zirconin aqueous uids and melts. Elements 3, 4350.

    Goodge, J.W., Fanning, C.M., Bennet, V.C. 2001. UPb evidence of 1.7Ga crustal tectonism during the Nimrod Orogeny in the TransantarcticMountains, Antarctica: implications for Proterozoic plate reconstruc-tions. Precambrian Research 112, 261288.

    Grew, E.S., Manton,W.J. 1986. A new correlation of sapphirine granulitesin the Indo-Antarctic metamorphic terrain: Late Proterozoic dates fromthe Eastern Ghats province of India. Precambrian Research 33, 123137.

    Halpin, J.A., Gerakiteys