modeling distribution of bod, do, … · key words: distribution, mike21, ujung pangkah estuary,...
TRANSCRIPT
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 565 [email protected]
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET)
Volume 9, Issue 2, February 2018, pp. 565–576, Article ID: IJCIET_09_02_055
Available online at http://http://www.iaeme.com/ijciet/issues.asp?JType=IJCIET&VType=9&IType=2
ISSN Print: 0976-6308 and ISSN Online: 0976-6316
© IAEME Publication Scopus Indexed
MODELING DISTRIBUTION OF BOD, DO,
PHOSPHATE, AND NITRATE OF BENGAWAN
SOLO RIVER IN UJUNG PANGKAH, GRESIK
EAST JAVA
Mahmud Mustain
Department of Ocean Engineering,
The Institute Technology of Sepuluh Nopember (ITS), Surabaya 60111, Indonesia
Agus Sufyan
Marine Reseach Centre, BRSDM,
Ministry of Marine and Fisheries, Jakarta, Indonesia
Rudhy Akhwady
Marine Reseach Centre, BRSDM,
Ministry of Marine and Fisheries, Jakarta, Indonesia
ABSTRACT
Bengawan Solo River is one of the major rivers that pass through several cities
and empties into Ujung Pangkah, Gresik East Java. The development of industry and
domestic sewage along the Solo River has affected the quality of water in the Ujung
Pangkah estuary. Estuary of the river is part of the coastal region that has an
important role in the economic, ecological, also areas with complex ecosystems. As a
result, the flow of Bengawan Solo River flowing into Ujung Pangkah estuary causing
changes in water quality, so it is necessary to model the distribution of water quality
to identify whether it is in accordance with the permitted quality standards.
Hydrodynamic models and water quality distribution were performed with the help of
Mike 21 software, with hydrodynamic module and Ecolab module used to calculate
and know the spread of BOD, DO, Phosphate and Nitrate. The tidal model of Mike 21
in this research has error 0.1%.
Key words: distribution, Mike21, Ujung Pangkah estuary, water quality.
Cite this Article: Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady, Modeling
Distribution of BOD, DO, Phosphate, and Nitrate of Bengawan Solo River in Ujung
Pangkah, Gresik East Java. International Journal of Civil Engineering and
Technology, 9(2), 2018, pp. 565-576.
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/issues.asp?JType=IJCIET&VType=9&IType=2
Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 566 [email protected]
1. INTRODUCTION
Coastal areas are areas that have the potential of natural resources as well as areas that are
easily affected by landfill waste (Bengen 2004, Cleir 1994, Lenroy 2002, Michael 2003,
Ramadhani et.al. 2016, Supriyadi 2002, Utomo and Ridho 2010, Wibowo et.al. 2014) [2, 3, 6,
7, 16, 22, 24, 26]. The water quality of the coastal area is closely related to the river flow that
leads to the estuary and the sea in a region. Changes in the river nature due to human activities
will affect the quality of aquatic waters in estuaries and coastal areas (Mustain 2003, Mustain
2016, Mustain 2017, Mustain 2018, Steward 2008, Van Rijn 1993, Yoo and Boyd 1994) [10,
12, 13, 14, 23, 25, 27]. Gresik as one of the districts that has a geographically located
industries from 7 - 8 - 80 E and 112 E - 113 - E BT has coastal areas influenced by several
rivers (Bappeda, 2013) [1]. Figure 1 shows the Study area. One of the rivers on the coast of
Gresik is Ujung Pangkah. Ujung Pangkah is one of the rivers in Gresik which is the river of
Bengawan Solo from upper course in the Solo area. The Bengawan Solo River flows that
bring residential and industrial waste will affect the estuary of Ujung Pangkah, Gresik.
Research on water quality at the end of the trench is still very minimal, generally research.
The flow of the river that empties into Ujung Pangkah will result in a decrease of water
quality in Ujung Pangkah estuary if no control is done. The decrease of water quality in
Ujung Pangkah estuary will decrease water resources and economically disadvantageous.
Water quality research that has been done around the estuary of pangkah only describes the
water quality at the end of pangkah estuary (Supriyadi, 2002) [22]. Research on water quality
around the end of Ujung Pangkah estuary has only been focused on researching water quality
conditions at certain points. Therefore, this research continues to complement and describe
water quality in Bengawan Solo river until its spreading to Ujung Pangkah estuary and the
surrounding waters.
Figure 1 Research Area of estuary of Ujung Pangkah, Gresik East Java
This study aims to determine and ensure changes in water quality due to the flow of
Bengawan Solo River through vicinity of Ujung Pangkah whether it is safe or even exceeds
the quality standards allowed (RME 2004, SNI 2004, SNI 1996) [17, 20, 21]. The study also
wanted to know the dispersion patterns of several water quality parameters, such as BOD
(Biochemical Oxygen Demand) (PESCOD,1973) [15], DO (Dissolved Oxygen) (SALMIN,
2000) [18], Phosphate (PO4) and Nitrate (NO3) using Mike 21 software with Hydrodynamic
Modeling Distribution of BOD, DO, Phosphate, and Nitrate of Bengawan Solo River in Ujung
Pangkah, Gresik East Java
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 567 [email protected]
and Ecolab modules (DHI 2012a, DHI 2012b, Mustain and Suroso 2016) [4, 5, 9]. This study
will provide information on pollution load given by the flow of Bengawan Solo River which
leads to Ujung Pangkah. Information from the output of this study is expected to be a good
reference for establishing policies on water management of coastal waters of Gresik. This is
also confirmed to the coastal planning and management in Madura Strait include Sidoarjo
Surabaya and Gresik coastal area (Mustain 2009, Mustain et al. 2015, Mustain 2016, Mustain
2017, Mustain 2018) [8, 11, 12, 13, 14].
2. BASIC THEORY OF HYDRODYNAMICS
2.1. Pollution Distribution Model in Waters
Disguise coverage in Ujung Pangkah estuary is done by numerical modeling using MIKE21
Ecolab software (DHI 2012a, DHI 2012b) [4, 5]. This model is used to simulate the
distribution of water quality for parameters: BOD, DO, Phosphate and Nitrate.
MIKE21 Ecolab uses volume methods to solve mathematical equations for hydrodynamic
parameters. These are as the main drivers of water quality distribution and advection-
dispersion parameters of each modeled water quality parameters.
2.2. Mike21 EcoLab Method
MIKE21 Ecolab is used to simulate the distribution of chemical parameters which is an
indicator of water quality in Ujung Pangkah estuary waters. From modeling MIKE21 Ecolab,
can be obtained information distribution of parameters DO, BOD, Phosphate, and Nitrate in
study area.
MIKE21 Ecolab uses the following general equation (DHI 2012a, DHI 2012b) [4, 5]:
cczyx PSz
cD
z
cD
z
cD
z
cw
y
cv
x
cu
t
c
2
2
2
2
2
2
(1)
where:
C : concentration of Ecolab variable
u, v, w : the current component
Dx : Disperse coefficient in x direction
Dy : Disperse coefficient in y direction
Dz : Disperse coefficient in z direction
Sc : source and sink components
Pc : Ecolab Process
While the transport equations for each parameter are generally written as follows,
cc PADt
c
(2)
Where ADc is a change in concentration due to advection and dispersion effects.
3. MODELING METHODOLOGY
3.1. Geometry Modeling (Bathymetry)
The study is geographically located between 7⁰ to 8⁰ South Latitude and 112⁰ Up to 113⁰ East
Longitude (Figure 1). The used research method is modeling. In this study the
Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 568 [email protected]
Hydrodynamics and Ecolab Model MIKE21 were have been conducted with the following
inputs:
- Ups and downs. These two parameters are the main factors for the occurrence of ocean
currents. Tidal data were obtained from Global MIKE21 model, while wind data was obtained
from local Meteorological institution.
- Batimetry: bathymetry secondary data obtained from several related institutions namely;
KKP, Dishidros-AL and BIG. Bathymetry data is converted in mesh format for MIKE21
calculation. Figure 2 shows the bathimetry that have been inputed.
- The pollution load as an input on the model is assumed to come only from the river.
- River flow is obtained based on secondary data analysis of PT. Jasa Tirta East Java.
Figure 2 Batimetry of Ujung Pangkah vicinity for input MIKE21
3.2. Model Scenario
Modeling is done with two scenarios that are considered to represent the seasons in Indonesia,
i.e. modeling in the West season and East season. Both seasons are representations of the
rainy season and dry season respectively. Here are the scenarios to be done in current
modeling and water quality:
- Flow model at Ujung Pangkah estuary.
- Water Quality Model of Ujung Pangkah estuary namely: BOD, DO, Phosphate and Nitrate.
- Model simulation is done for 15 days with time step of 300 seconds.
3.3. Data Measurement and Model Validation
Measurement of water quality data has been done for 9 points in the study area (Figure 1),
where the measurement data is given in the table below. Table 1 shows Data Measuring water
quality around the Ujung Pangkah estuary. Table 2 gives the burden of Polluters at the mouth
of Ujung Pangkah as the result of Laboratorium test analysis. Water quality distribution is
simulated for 15 days in west season and east season with point number 5 used as validation.
The calculation of pollutant load along the Bengawan Solo River uses upstream water
quality data. The data is then analyzed to obtain pollutant loads along the Bengawan Solo
River which leads to Ujung Pangkah which will be used as input in the water quality model
with Mike21 software.
Modeling Distribution of BOD, DO, Phosphate, and Nitrate of Bengawan Solo River in Ujung
Pangkah, Gresik East Java
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 569 [email protected]
The polluted load parameters focused on this study were dissolved residues or BOD, DO,
Nitrite, and Phosphate (Clair N. Sawyer, 1994) [3]. An indication that waste containing
organic substances is obtained by measuring the amount of oxygen required to decompose
organic components into other more stable components (Michael R. Penn, 2003) [7].
Table 1 Data Measuring water quality around the Ujung Pangkah vicinity
Sampel Easting Northing BOD
(mg/l)
DO
(mg/l)
NO3
(mg/l)
PO4
(mg/l)
UP 1A 674951 9244855 6 4,6 0,37 0,6
UP 2A 673804 9245453 4 4,8 0,17 0,54
UP 3A 674385 9246367 6 4,4 0,02 0,17
UP 4A 670361 9243733 6 4,4 0,07 0,14
UP 5A 669230 9242846 4 4,4 0,16 0,17
UP 6A 667873 9243120 4 4,6 0,04 0,78
UP 7A 671410 9246975 4 4,8 0,07 0,76
UP M1 674622 9241279 4 4,6 0,15 0,13
UP M3 672229 9240412 6 4,3 0,23 0,67
Source: Result of Laboratory Analysis of Environmental Quality of ITS Surabaya (2015)
Table 2 The burden of Polluters at the mouth of Ujung Pangkah river
No Parameter Unit Lab
Result Debit
Load
(ton/month)
1 DO mg/L 4,57 640 7.581,08
2 BOD mg/L 4,86 640 8.062,16
3 Nitrate (NO3) mg/L 0,12 640 199,07
4 Phosphate (PO4) mg/L 0,45 640 746,5
Source: Results of The Analysis
4. RESULT OF MODELING
The results of the load simulation input made polluters for 15 days for the West season and
the East season are have been given in the the table 3. Table 3 gives the comparison of results
of measurements and Model to point UP 5A.
Table 3 Comparison of results of measurements and Model to point UP 5A
Sample
Coordinat (utm) BOD (mg/l) DO (mg/l) NO3 (mg/l) PO4 (mg/l)
Easting Northing Lab Model Lab Model Lab Model Lab Model
UP 5A 669230 9242846 4 3,96 4,4 4,8 0,16 0,11 0,17 0,44
4.1. The Results of Modeling of Hydrodynamics
Current modeling MIKE21 Ecolab is one of the causes of the occurrence of water chemistry
parameters on the distribution of the water. In this study, the current in the MIKE21
generated by completing the equation of continuity of the parameter depth waters as well as
two parameters the prime mover that is tide-ebb and wind. The results of numerical modeling
of flow in the West and East season of the area Ujung Pangkah shown in Figure 3 and Figure
4 below. Figure 3 shows the result of current model for West season in the time of tide (left)
and ebb (right). Figure 4 shows the result of current model for East season in the time of tide
(left) and ebb (right).
Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 570 [email protected]
Figure 3 The West season current in the time of tide (left) and ebb (right)
Figure 4 The East Season current in the time of tide (left) and ebb (right)
Modeling results showed mainstream West season has the range of 0.02 to 0.36 m/s, while
the current of East season has the range of 0.02 to 0.34 m/s. In each season, based on the
picture above, the current is moving East toward the dominant at the time of install and at the
time of the downs, dominant moving currents to the West. At the speed of current East
season, slightly higher than the West season, especially at a time when receding. The matter is
possible because the speed of the wind at higher East season. Mainstream modelling results
with extract data that have been confirmed to the tide model at one point. This is also be
compared to the data revenue of predicted model of TMD (Tide Model Drivers) at the same
coordinates. This have error 0.1 % and it shows in Figure 5. Figure 5 shows the comparison
between predicted model of TMD MIKE21 and served on the picture below. Mustain 2018
[14] also confirms in the tide modeling of RMA2.
Figure 5 Water elevation in Ujung Pangkah during 15 days (01-15/11/2015) measurement (TMD) and
result of Mike21 model (Mike21)
Verification results show that there is a pattern of conformity between the model
predictions of TMD and MIKE21. Therefore, it can be inferred that the model has a pretty
good accuracy. The small difference is likely to occur due to local factors such as depth and
river discharge input cause an increase in the face of the water.
Modeling Distribution of BOD, DO, Phosphate, and Nitrate of Bengawan Solo River in Ujung
Pangkah, Gresik East Java
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 571 [email protected]
4.2. Pattern of Distribution
Patterns of spread of water quality Parameter based on the results of the modelling of water
quality Modeling done by two scenarios, i.e. scenario for East season and West seasion. These
are a representation of the rainy season and the dry season respectively. Simulation of water
quality parameters with the input style of hydrodynamics and load the Ujung Pangkah estuary
polluters, acquired the distribution parameters of water quality at the location of the study
presented on the pictures below as subheading for each parameter.
4.2.1. BOD (Biochemical Oxygen Demand)
BOD was much oxygen micro-organism to dissociate wide by organic materials that are
easily separate. Figure 6 shows the modeling result of West Season of BOD distribution in
tide time (left) and ebb (right). Figure 7 shows the modeling result of Eeast Season of BOD
distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right).
These modeling results indicate that the contents of the BOD at the location of the study is
on the range to below 0.03 up to 3.7 mg/L in the West season, and it reached 3.8 mg/L in East
season. During the East season, distribution of BOD smaller than in the West season. It is
probable that due to the speed of currents, a difference where the speed of currents at higher
West season compared to East season that brings water to dilute the concentration of BOD.
These difference currents are also be confirmed to Mustain (2017) [13].
Figure 6 West Season of BOD distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
Figure 7 East Season of BOD distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
4.2.2. DO (Dissolved Oxygen)
Dissolved Oxygen or DO that one of the chemical parameters is very vital. Almost all aquatic
biota need DO to the process of oxidation and reduction of organic and inorganic materials.
Figure 8 shows the result of modeling for West Season of DO distribution in tide time (left)
and ebb (right). Figure 9 shows the result of modeling for East Season of DO distribution in
tide time (left) and ebb (right).
These modeling results indicate that the content DO on location study is in the range of
4.9 mg/L for East season and 3.7 mg/L for West season. The result was still below the raw
quality of the sea water that is desirable for marine aquaculture i.e. above 5 mg/L according to
the decisions of Men. LH No. 51 Year 2004 about raw sea water quality guidelines for marine
life, these waters can be categorised so unfavourable to support cultivation of the sea (SNI
2004) [20].
Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 572 [email protected]
Figure 8 West Season of DO distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
Figure 9 East Season of DO distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
4.2.3. Phosphate (PO4)
The element phosphorus is found in nature in the form of phosphate ions, either in the form of
organic or inorganic. The main organism that requires the presence of phosphate in the water
element is the fitoplakton play an important role in determining the fertility of a waters
(Santoso, 2007) [19]. Figure 10 shows the result of model for West season of PO4 distribution
in tide time (left) and ebb (right). Figure 11 shows the result of model for East season of PO4
distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right).
These modeling results indicate that the deposits of Phosphate on the location of the study
are in the range of 0.03 to 0.55 mg/L in West season, while in the East season have a lower
range of 0.01 to 0.34 mg/L. The high concentration of phosphate of West season made
possible by the phosphate nutrient runoff from land and the river is higher due to more
intensive agricultural activities in the rainy season.
Figure 10 West Season of PO4 distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
Figure 11 East Season of PO4 distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
4.2.4. Nitrate (NO3)
Nitrates (NO3) is the main form of nitrogen in natural waters. This is a key nutrient for the
growth of plants and algae. Nitrates very easily soluble in water and a stable. Figure 12 gives
Modeling Distribution of BOD, DO, Phosphate, and Nitrate of Bengawan Solo River in Ujung
Pangkah, Gresik East Java
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 573 [email protected]
the result of modeling in West Season of NO3 distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right).
Figure 13 gives the result of modeling in East Season of NO3 distribution in tide time (left)
and ebb (right).
These modeling results indicate that the content of nitrates on site study achieve 0.09 up
0.23 mg/L at the time of the East season. On the other hand, at the time of the West season
natural nitrate at site has the range to smaller i.e. 0.01 to 0.15 mg/L. Nitrate content in this
district study high enough that possibility because of the availability of the aktivitas causeway
around site study. Yoo and Boyd (1994) [27] stated that the availability of aquaculture
activities can provide so many of organic material that has the compound of nitrates.
Figure 12 West Season of NO3 distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
Figur 13 East Season of NO3 distribution in tide time (left) and ebb (right)
4.3. Water Quality
The changes in water quality and that based on the water quality Standards for waters of the
estuary of Ujung Pangkah are figured here. The model gives four componens as the result. It
is be seen in Table 4.
Modeling water quality of the estuary of Ujung Pangkah conducted for 15 days with the
time of 300 seconds. The results of the analysis of the change of water quality are analyzed
based on Standard Quality for Raw sea life issued the decision of the Minister-LH 51 Th
2004. Appendix III of the raw quality of sea water for sealife (RME, 2004) [17] are presented
in the Table 4. This Table 4 shows that the quality of water in the estuary of Ujung Pangkah
after the Bengawan Solo River basin varies at the end of Ujung Pangkah river. There are some
criteria for each parameter, i.e. for BOD still meets, while the parameters DO, Phosphate and
Nitrates do not meet the standards set.
Table 4 Analysis of changes in water quality of the estuary of Ujung Pangkah
Water
Quality
Parameters
The maximum value of the results of the
modeling of the Western and the West
Season and East Season (mg/L)
The raw Quality standards
based on Kepmen-LH 51 Th
2004. Appendix III (mg/L)
BOD 3,7 (West season) & 3,8 (East Season) 20
DO 3,7 (West season) & 4,9 (East Season) >5
Phosphate 0,55 (West season) &0,34 (East Season) 0,015
Nitrate 0,15 (West season) & 0,23(East Season) 0,008
Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 574 [email protected]
5. DISCUSSION
Data measurement of water quality around the Ujung Pangkah estuary in Table 1 varies
except DO that shows relatively constant from each sample position. This reasonable due the
measurement in the same season, while the water quality paramtere as the result of model are
also relatively constan for each season. For instance, the difference between Figure 6 and
Figure 7 is very-very clearly differed due to difference season i.e. West season wider
distribution than Esat season even little bit difficule di distinguis between ebb and tide
periode. This is reasonable that West season more windy thane East season, then affect to the
current pattern and distribution.
The results of modeling with MIKE21 show that is a difference with the measurement
results field. The result of model shows with a lower value on all parameters except for water
quality parameters DO. This is possible because only the input comes from the mouth of the
river of the coast, when in fact, the conditions there are a load of waste from small rivers or
the coast. However, the modeling results show mostly difference between simulation results
and field measurements do not differ greatly. These results of this modeling can be used to
predict the distribution of water quality of rivers, estuaries and waterways around the Ujung
Pangkah.
The model results of most water quality parameters give same patternt of distribution. The
result of West season absolutly more wider distribution the East season model. This is well
confirmed by Mustain (2017) [13], how the longshore current in West season bigger than in
East season. Mustain (2018) [14] notes in the case of short term period, tidal term. The current
of tide time, forward to costline direction, has speed faster than the current ebb time. In this
research this case little bit difficult to distinguse. This is due to too short time or not enaugh
time for making significancy difference distribution for water quality parameters.
6. CONCLUSIONS
Modeling of the distribution of water quality in the Bengawan Solo River going down to the
Ujung Pangkah has been conducted. The results obtained that the water quality in the estuary
of Ujung Pangkah after the Bengawan Solo River basin that converge at the end of
Pangkah.There are several criteria to each parameter, i.e. for BOD still meets with a
maximum spread of values of 3.8 mg/L BOD. While parameters DO, Nitrate and Phosphate
do not meet the standards established by the value distribution of 5.6 mg/L to DO, 0.56 mg/L
for Phosphate and 0.23 mg/L for Nitrate. For standard Quality Raw based on Kepmen-LH 51
Th 2004. Appendix III at the mouth End Pangkah was 70 mg/L for TSS, 20 mg/L for BOD, >
5 mg/L to DO, 0.015 mg/L for Phosphate and 0.008 mg/L for Nitrate.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors thank the Directorate Pendayagunaan smaller islands, Directorate Jenderal
Kelautan and Small Islands of the Ministry of Fisheries on support of provided data up to this
paper then could be finished very well. This research was also supported by the Minister of
Risearch and Technology (Indonesia) and LPPM-ITS. Therefore, the authors thank and
appresiate both institutions for the funds.
REFERENCES
[1] BAPPEDA, (2013), Regional Planners Agency of Gresik Regency. Gresik, East Java,
Indonesia.
Modeling Distribution of BOD, DO, Phosphate, and Nitrate of Bengawan Solo River in Ujung
Pangkah, Gresik East Java
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 575 [email protected]
[2] Bengen, G. G., 2004, Ekosistem dan Samberdaya AIam Pesisir dan Laut serta Prinsip
Pengelolaannya, Sinopsis, Pusat Kajian Sumber daya Pesisir dan Lautan, Institut Pertanian
Bogor, pp. 59.
[3] Clair N. Sawyer, (1994). Chemistry for Environmental Engineering and Science (4th ed.).
Mc Graw Hill. p. l.
[4] DHI. ECO Lab – Short Scientific Description. MIKE by DHI. 2012a
[5] DHI. Mike 21 Flow Model FM-Hydrodynamics-Scientific Documentation. Mike by DHI.
2012b
[6] Lenroy., D.S., (2002), The condition of the waters of the estuary based on physical and
chemical parameters in the Bengawan Solo River estuary of Ujung Pangkah Gresik, East
Java. Theses courses of science and technology.
[7] Michael R. Penn, J. J. (2003). Biochemical Oxygen Demand. Encyclopedia of Life
Support Systems.
[8] Mustain, M, Analisa Pola Arus Pasang Surut pada Alur Pelayaran Tanjung Perak di Selat
Madura, Seminar Nasional Teori dan Aplikasi Teknologi Kelautan (SENTA 2009), 17
Desember 2009, pp. A38-45.
[9] Mustain, M., A. Suroso, Simplicity Design of Hybrid Energy of Marine Current and
Offshore Wind Energy Plant in Indonesia, Applied Mechanics and Materials, ISSN: 1662-
7482, 836, 2016, pp. 283-288, www.scientific.net/AMM.836.283.
[10] Mustain, M., Fundamental Conception of Mitigation due to Sea Level Rise in the Coastal
Area and Small Islands, ISSN1 412-2332, Seminar Nasional Teori dan Aplikasi Teknologi
Kelautan, Oktober 2003, p III-2 :1-5.
[11] Mustain, M., Haryo Dwito Armono, and Danu Tri Kurniawan, The Evaluation of Beach
Recreational Index for Coastal Tourism Zone of: Delegan, Kenjeran, and Wisata Bahari
Lamongan, Procedia Earth and Planetary Science 14, 2015, pp.17–24,
www.sciencedirect.com. 2015.
[12] Mustain, M., Model of Ground Water Elevation around Mud Reservoir in Coastal Area of
Porong Sidoarjo, Applied Mechanics and Materials, ISSN: 1662-7482, 836, 2016, pp.
239-244, www.scientific.net/ AMM.836.239.
[13] Mustain, M., The Model of Shoreline Change in Estuary of Porong River after Mud
Volcano, International Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences (IJEAS), ISSN:
2394-3661, 4(11), November 2017, https://www.ijeas.org/download
_data/IJEAS0411027.pdf
[14] Mustain, M., The Model of Current Pattern at the Mouth of Porong Rive Sidoarjo,
International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology (IJCIET), 9(1), January 2018,
pp. 688–701, Article ID: IJCIET_09_ 01_067,ISSN Print: 0976-6308 and ISSN Online:
0976-6316, Available online at www.iaeme.com/ ijciet/issues.asp?JType=IJCIET&
VType= 9&IType=1.
[15] PESCOD, M. D. 1973. Investigation of Rational Effluen and Stream Standards for
Tropical Countries. A.I.T. Bangkok, 59 pp
[16] Ramadhani, E., Anna. A.N., Cholil. M. (2016). Analisis Pencemaran Kualitas Air Sungai
Bengawan Solo Akibat Limbah Industri di Kecamatan Kebakkramat Kabupaten
Karanganyar. Skripsi thesis, Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta.
[17] RME (Regulation of The Minister Of The Environment-Indonesian) No. 51. (2004),
About the Raw quality of sea water. Appendix III of the raw quality of sea water for sea
life.
Mahmud Mustain, Agus Sufyan and Rudhy Akhwady
http://www.iaeme.com/IJCIET/index.asp 576 [email protected]
[18] SALMIN. 2000. Kadar Oksigen Terlarut di Perairan Sungai Dadap, Goba,
[19] Muara Karang dan Teluk Banten. Dalam : Foraminifera Sebagai Bioindikator
Pencemaran, Hasil Studi di Perairan Estuarin Sungai Dadap, Tangerang (Djoko P.
Praseno, Ricky Rositasari dan S. Hadi Riyono, eds.) P3O - LIPI hal 42 - 46
[20] Santoso, A.D. 2007. Kandungan Zat Hara Fosfat pada Musim Barat dan Musim Timur di
Teluk Hurun, Lampung. Jurnal Teknik Lingkungan, 8(3): 207-210.
[21] SNI (Standar Nasional Indonesia), SNI 06-6989.3-2004: Air dan air limbah – Bagian 3:
Cara uji padatan tersuspensi total (Total Suspended Solid, TSS) secara gravimetri. Badan
Standarisasi Nasional-Indonesia, 2004.
[22] SNI (Standar Nasional Indonesia), SNI 19-4199-1996: Pengukuran Aliran Fluida Dalam
Saluran Terbuka – Metode Pengukuran Sedimen Tersuspensi. Badan Standarisasi
Nasional- Indonesia, 1996.
[23] Supriyadi., D.S. (2002). kondisi perairan muara berdasarkan parameter fisika dan kimia di
muara Bengawan Solo Ujung Pangkah Kabupaten Gresik, Jawa Timur. Skripsi Program
studi ilmu dan teknologi kelautan, Fakultas Perikanan dan Ilmu Kelautan, Institut
Pertanian Bogor, Bogor.
[24] Steward, R., Introduction to Physical Oceanography, Texas A&M University, 2008, pp
105-
[25] Utomo. A.D. and Ridho M.R. (2010). Penceemaran di sungai Bengawan Solo antara Solo
dan Sragen, Jawa Tengah. BAWAL, 3(1), April 2010: 25-32. E-ISSN: 2502-6410
[26] Van Rijn, L., Principles of Sediment Transport in Rivers, Estuaries and Coastal Seas.
Aqua Publication. Netherlands, 1993.
[27] Wibowo. H. P. E., Purnomo. T., Ambarwati. R. (2014). Kualitas Perairan Sungai
Bengawan Solo di Wilayah Kabupaten Bojonegoro Berdasarkan Indeks Keanekaragaman
Plankton. LenteraBio 3(3), September 2014: 209–215. ISSN: 2252-3979
[28] Yoo, K.H. and C. Boyd. 1994. Hydrology and Water Supply for Aquaculture Pounds.
Chapman and Hill. New York.