mark staehlin, controller chsd 99
DESCRIPTION
“ Tips and Tools for Evaluating Financial Services: RFP Process and Banking Fees” Presented by: Aimee Briles, Wintrust Financial Kimberly Feeney, Bank of America Moderator: Mark Staehlin, Controller - CHSD 99. Community High School District 99 6301 Springside Avenue - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
“Tips and Tools for Evaluating Financial Services:RFP Process and
Banking Fees”
Presented by:
Aimee Briles, Wintrust FinancialKimberly Feeney, Bank of America
Moderator: Mark Staehlin, Controller - CHSD 99
2
Mark Staehlin, Controller CHSD 99 Community High School District 99
6301 Springside AvenueDowners Grove. IL 60516-2488(630) [email protected]
Mark has been the Controller for CHSD 99 since 1994. Prior to that he was an Audit Manager for RSM McGladrey, Inc., in charge of more than 60 school audits each year. In addition to his school clients, Mark performed audits of banks, savings and loans and other financial institutions. He also serves as President of his local Board of Education in Palos Heights, IL.
Mark is a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) and has a BS degree in Finance from Northern Illinois University.
3
Aimee Briles, Vice President Wintrust Financial
500 Roosevelt Rd., Ste 320Glen Ellyn, [email protected]
Aimee works with public entities throughout Chicagoland and has over 11 years of banking experience, with 6 years in Treasury Management and Government Banking. Aimee is a member of the Illinois Association of School Business Officials, Illinois Government Finance Officer's Association, and the Illinois Park & Recreation Association. Wintrust Financial owns over 75 community banks throughout the Chicago and Madison, WI areas.
4
Kimberly Feeney, Vice President Bank of America
231S. LaSalle StreetChicago, Illinois [email protected]
Kim is a Government Client Manager in the Midwest Region. Joining the Bank in May 2003, she came with over ten years of government finance experience and has held roles as Accounting Manager and Chief Financial Officer for the Cook County Treasurer and Comptroller for the Cook County Forest Preserve District. Her responsibilities at Bank of America include working with clients to understand their current operations and assist in improving, enhancing and automating their treasury management operations as well as meeting all their capital raising solutions.
Kim is a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) and has an MBA in Finance from Loyola University.
5
Session Agenda
Why issue a formal RFP? RFP Basics – What, Why & How? Banking services to consider
CollectionsDisbursements Investment Services Information Reporting
Paying for Services Final steps in the RFP process
6
Why Issue a Formal RFP? GFOA recommended practice – periodic
evaluation of banking services Evaluates current banking relationship Evaluates available banking/TM services Initiates competitive bidding and negotiation Mediate political situations
7
Preparation Questions Are you willing to change providers? What are your goals?
Improvement of efficiencies Implementing new technology Lowering costs
Important end results? New structure New (or renewed) banking relationship Best value vs. low cost
Bundled vs. Unbundled approach?
8
Preparation Steps
Understand current contract, services, fees and bank relationship
Determine minimum qualifications for proposers & list of banks to be included
Determine District employees to be involved Understand political issues (internal &
external)
9
RFP Section 1: Introduction
General information about District Evaluation criteria Contract specifications (duration, renewal &
termination clause) Timeline & due dates Required qualifications of vendors Questions & response instructions Proposal format requirements
10
Proposal Format Requirements: Example Include requirements of each section
Cover LetterPrincipal Officers / Bank BackgroundScope of Services Implementation ScheduleReferencesConcluding RemarksCost Proposal
11
RFP Section 2: Scope of Services Question/Response Format
Account structureRate requirements Core service requirements
• Collections, Disbursements, Information Reporting
Account Executive requirementsOther services neededBank recommendations for additional and/or new
services
12
RFP Section 3: Cost Proposal
Standardize format Provide accurate activity volumes
Mirror you Account Analysis statement
Specify annual or monthly volumes Allow space for misc. charges and new
services Include “Compensating Balance” calculation
13
TM Collection Services
Services
EFT / ACH Collection Remote Deposit Electronic Bill Payment
Solutions Merchant Services Courier Services
Benefits
Accelerates funds availability
Cost reductions Simplifies reconcilement Reduces errors / fraud Reduces bank runs
14
Questions to Consider: Collections
EFT / ACH Collection (includes wires) Is Bank a “receiving” member on the Automated
Clearing House system?Same day availability?Access to full addenda record?Costs involved?
• Receipt of addenda• Incoming wire transfer vs. ACH
15
Remote DepositCut-off time?ACH conversion? Image clearing capability?Equipment options? Cost involved?
• Monthly maintenance• Per item• Scanner (payment options)
Questions to Consider: Collections
16
Electronic Bill Payment SolutionsCustomizable to District?Reporting options?File format options?Payment options?Secure payment site? Maintained by who? Cost involved?
• Set up /programming fees• Monthly maintenance• Per item
Questions to Consider: Collections
17
Courier ServicesArmored Car or Bank Employee?
• If Bank employee are they bonded?
Same day credit for courier deposits?Costs involved?
• Per month, per stop, per day
Questions to Consider: Collections
18
TM Disbursement Services
Services
ACH (Payroll & Vendor Payments)
Wire Transfers P-Card / Credit Card
Payments
Benefits
Standard formats & templates reduce errors
Eliminates lost checks Reduces fraud Reduces paper items
19
Questions to Consider: Disbursements ACH Services
Is Bank a “sending” member on the Automated Clearing House system?
What are your options for file transmission?File transmission security?What are the cut-off times for file receipt?How are returns & NOCs communicated?Costs involved?
• Per item, transmission, returns, deletions
20
Wire Transfer Services Initiation Capabilities?Cut off times?Security features?Notifications?Costs involved?
• Online vs. fax/phone• Notification fees• Repetitive vs. Non-Repetitive
Questions to Consider: Disbursements
21
P-Card / Credit Card PaymentsOnline capabilities?
• Reporting, Administrative Functions
Card limits available? What types?Monthly statements?Billing methods and cycles available?Rebate schedule?
Questions to Consider: Disbursements
22
TM Reconciliation & Fraud Prevention Services
Services
Account Recon Services
Positive Pay ACH Blocks &
Filters
Benefits
Automates & expedites monthly reconcilement
Eliminates incorrectly posted or encoded items
Protects District funds
23
Account Reconciliation ServicesFile formats – Customizable?Timing of file transmission to & from Bank?File transmission options & security?Costs involved?
• Monthly maintenance (partial vs. full)
• Per item• File transmission
Questions to Consider: Recon & Fraud Prevention Services
24
Positive Pay ServicesPositive Pay vs. Reverse Positive Pay?Payee information verification?Teller line transactions verified?Exception notification? (phone, fax, online)
Decision deadlines?Costs involved?
• Included with Full Recon Services?• Exception items
Questions to Consider: Recon & Fraud Prevention Services
25
Questions to Consider: Recon & Fraud Prevention Services
ACH Blocks & FiltersVerification types available?
• Dollar amounts, SEC Codes, Business Names
Costs involved?• Monthly maintenance• Per suspect item
26
TM Investment Services
Services
Automated Investment Sweep (AIS or Sweep)
Public Funds Interest Checking Account (PFIC)
Benefits
Earn interest on idle funds Remains liquid to cover
inclearing items Accurate and convenient Several investment vehicle
options
27
Questions to Consider: Investments
Automated Investment Sweeps (AIS)What are the associated fees? Is it properly collateralized?What are my investment options? (i.e. repo, MM)
Is reporting available online?Can I set a peg or target balance?
28
Questions to Consider: Investments
Public Funds Interest Checking AccountsWhat are the associated fees? Is it properly collateralized?What % of balances are invested?Can I also use Compensating Balances with this?
29
TM Online Banking Services
Services
Information Reporting Internal Transfers Stop Payment Initiation Outgoing Wire Initiation ACH Origination Check Images
Benefits
Cheaper Easy to access Multiple Users Accessibility of
information Availability of
transaction history
30
Information ReportingCurrent Day and/or Previous Day reporting?Cost involved?Format of reports?Can I export?
• What formats are available?
Can I schedule reports?
Questions to Consider: Online Banking
31
Money MovementReal time or delayed information?Associated Costs?Are templates available for recurring transfers?Can controls be set to segregate duties?
Questions to Consider: Online Banking
32
FeesBundled or menu-basedPer item fees or access chargesActivity retention fees
Discounts for online initiated services • Stop payments• Wire transfers• Internal transfers
Questions to Consider: Online Banking
33
Design Comparative Evaluation Matrix
Evaluating the Proposals
Bank A Bank B Bank C Bank DBranch
Location>1 mile 1-2 miles 5 miles < 1 miles
Public Funds Specialist
yes no no yes
Total Fees
Balances
$1,040
975,000
$1,290
$1,129,500
$950
Not provided
$1,150
$1,325,00
Price Guarantee
2 years 3 years 3 years 2 years
Understands Needs
A- B+ B A
Quality of RFP A- B A B-
34
Paying for Bank Services: OptionsCompensating BalancesDirect Fee Payment
Private and Public Sector moving to payment via direct fees
Payments with direct fees are less expensive than payments with balances
Combination of Balances and Fees (Blended)
35
Compensating BalancesCompensating balances – why is this
option popular?“That’s the way we’ve always done it”“I don’t pay the banks anything”No budgeting impact
36
Direct FeesRequired bank reserves (10%) become
earning assetsDirect investment of balances normally
exceeds bank earnings credit rateLower balances mean lower FDIC
assessmentLower balances mean reduced state
collateral requirements
37
Direct Fees (Cont.)Bank charges properly expensed, not
“hidden” In some cases, fees can be charged
against the investment income account as a cost of overall investment program
38
Potential Problems Using FeesRequires budgeting Requires additional monitoring of
collected balancesRequires active investing
39
Decision Factors: Fees vs. BalancesTime/resourcesActive investorCash flow monitoringCost/yield of cash management
techniques available
40
Compensating Balances: Terms Earning Credit Rate:
Rate provided by your bank – used in computation of compensating balance
Multiplier: Balance required to support $1.00 of Service
Reserve RequirementBank’s current Federal Reserve Requirement
(percentage) as applied to the positive collective balance maintained in the demand deposit account
41
Compensating Balance Formula Compensating Balance Formula:
monthly service charge /
(1.00 - reserve requirement) / Monthly ECR
Example:Monthly service charge = $4,116Earnings credit rate: 1.15% divided by 12.167
months = .00095Reserve requirement: 10%
42
Compensating Balance: Example
CB = $4,116 /(1.00-.10) = $4,814,035 .00095
Multiplier (365/31)/1.15% For every $1.00 of service fee you need $1,023.84 in
balances
43
Evaluating Proposals Low Cost vs. Best Value
Lowest compensating balance, best interest rate, individual price points
Ability to meet service requirements Creative suggestions for enhancements Government experience of bank & RM References Finalist interviews Bank visits
44
RFP Preparation Reminders:Help Bidders and Yourself
Be specific; facilitates understanding of District needs
Allow for question submission & hold pre-bidder meeting
Provide a copy of District Investment Policy & Collateral Requirements
Provide electronic form of RFP and attachments (include any required agreements)
Goal is “apples to apples” comparison
45
Questions
Thank you!