Mapping El-Mapping El-NiñoNiño

A Production of A Production of

Oregon Sea Oregon Sea GrantGrant

Department ofDepartment of

Marine EducationMarine Education© 1998 by Oregon Sea Grant© 1998 by Oregon Sea Grant

All Rights ReservedAll Rights Reserved

GreetingsGreetingsWelcome to the

Mapping El-Niño workshop.My name is Ron Crouse. I am the Marine Educator for Oregon

State University’s Hatfield Marine Science Center in Newport, Oregon. I first heard of El-Niño in 1976 and have been following the scientific community’s study of this phenomenon ever since.

With all the recent coverage of El-Niño, I felt that I could benefit science students by designing a hands-on program in which they could actually map the development of the 1997-98 El-Niño event across the equatorial Pacific ocean.

Through the use of NOAA’s computer models of sea surface temperature recorded by the Tropical Atmosphere Ocean Buoy Array (TAO), moored in the equatorial Pacific ocean, I developed this program which I hope will assist students in the

skills of map reading, data assimilation, graphing anomalies and provide a basic understanding of an El-Niño event and how

scientists study and measure our changing oceans.

I hope that teachers and students alike will have as much fun with this program as I had in designing it and putting it

together for your classes.

Class OverviewClass OverviewThe class itself will be presented in two parts. During the first

half of this class we will:

• review the resources available to scientists for studying the ocean, primarily the TAO Buoy Array

• introduce NOAA’s computer models of sea surface temperature and learn how to read sea surface temperature maps

• understand how and why anomaly maps are necessary to visualize changing ocean conditions

• prepare and present the activity where students can actually create anomaly maps of the 1997-98 El-Niño

During the second half of this class we will:

• present the “answers” so that students can grade their work against the actual NOAA sea surface temperature anomaly maps

• present graphics illustrating the difference between “normal” ocean conditions and those found during an El-Niño event

• introduce ways that El-Niño impacts conditions in the Pacific ocean as well as around the globe

If you have any questions, comments or suggestions during the course of this workshop, feel free to contact me at (541)867-0326 or e-mail at: crouser@ucs.orst.edu

Goals, Objectives and Goals, Objectives and BenchmarksBenchmarks

During this classroom learning experience you will have the opportunity to study the development of an unusual ocean event, termed “El-Niño.” This warming of tropical ocean waters has been observed and noted by Peruvian fishermen since the 1500’s. Thanks to the establishment of global weather tracking systems, the mysteries of El-Niño are just beginning to unfold.

Our objective in offering this class is to provide a hands-on exercise that gives students the ability to effectively visualize the development of an El-Niño, how it occurs, and its effect on Pacific ecosystems.

Our Goals for this class are:Our Goals for this class are:• Provide the student with an understanding of how oceanographers

measure present ocean conditions• Understand the principles of and be able to determine latitude and

longitude• To be able to read NOAA’s computer generated Sea Surface Temperature

maps and the contours of isotherms and gather data from them• Understand the differences between “normal” ocean conditions and

present “real-time” ocean conditions• Compare the data and map the anomalies (differences) in color to produce

monthly maps exposing the El-Niño event• Follow the development of the 1997-98 El-Niño event, learning how it

occurs, its impact on ocean conditions, and subsequent effects on marine food chains

Oregon Education Common Curriculum Oregon Education Common Curriculum Goals and BenchmarksGoals and Benchmarks

Curriculum Goal: Use analysis and interpretation to formulate explanations and draw reasonable conclusions based on the results of an investigation. Use integrated scientific process skills to predict, design experiments, control variables, interpret data, define operations and formulate models.

Grade 8 Benchmark--Evaluate evidence of physical and biological changes over time. Use a model to make predictions and inferences about familiar and unfamiliar phenomena in the natural world.

Grade 10 Benchmark--Use conceptual and/or mathematical models to explain natural systems. Propose explanations that are supported by data and knowledge of science concepts and principles.

Grade 12 Benchmark--Design and conduct a scientific investigation based on questions or hypotheses related to a current issue. Analyze data collected in a scientific investigation on a current problem or issue and evaluate sources of error and/or bias.

Measuring the Measuring the OceansOceans

Scientists use many techniques to measure our oceans. Data from numerous sources are combined by computers to give us graphic images of the changing ocean conditions. Some of these include:

Moored Buoys Tide Gage Stations Satellite Data Relay

Drifting Buoys Volunteer Observing Ships

TAO Buoy ArrayTAO Buoy Array

Tropical Atmosphere Ocean ArrayTropical Atmosphere Ocean ArrayThe TAO array, consisting of approximately 70 moored ocean buoys in the

Tropical Pacific Ocean, measures ocean and atmosphere conditions. Supported by countries worldwide, it is a major component of the global

climate monitoring system.

The Buoy SystemThe Buoy SystemThere are two types of buoys

used in the TAO Array• ATLAS buoys measure

surface winds, air temperature, and relative humidity, and ocean temperatures in the upper 500 meters.

• Equatorial Current Meter buoys include additional instruments to measure ocean currents and other parameters, such as short-wave radiation, and rainfall.

Data RelayData Relay

Creating Computer ModelsCreating Computer Models

• Goals of this lab– Understand how scientists gather ocean data

– Utilize computer models to determine SST anomalies

– Create anomaly maps and plot an El-Niño event

DefinitionsDefinitions• SST SST

– Sea surface temperature, measured at one meter below the surface

• AnomalyAnomaly– The difference between the current SST value and its long

term average

• IsothermIsotherm– A line on a map connecting points having the same

temperature for a given period of time

Monthly Mean SSTMonthly Mean SST

These maps are generated by computers utilizing the data collected from the TAO Buoy Array.

• This map shows real-time SST’s (sea surface temperatures) in 0.5°C isotherms

• It is produced by mapping the mean, or average SST’s for a certain month, in this case January 1997

SST ClimatologiesSST Climatologies

• SST Climatologies show the projected “normal” sea surface temperatures in 0.5°C isotherms

• These maps indicate what we would expect the ocean SST’s to be during a “normal” month, in this case, January

• Anomalies are found by subtracting the “normal” SST from the real-time SST

SST AnomaliesSST Anomalies

Once all the SST anomalies, or differences from “normal” are plotted, the computer generates a map indicating how the average SST’s for January 1997 differed from the “normal”. In this case

the equatorial Pacific ocean appears relatively normal, no

El-Niño event is visible.

El-Niño SST AnomaliesEl-Niño SST Anomalies

When we plot the anomalies and create an SST map during an El-Niño month we see a big difference in the equatorial Pacific ocean conditions. The isotherms indicate that there are temperature

anomalies ranging from -0.5°C in the upper left corner to +4.5°C in the right center. Only by mapping SST anomalies in this way can we

visualize the occurrence of an El-Niño event.

Procedures for MappingProcedures for MappingEl-Niño El-Niño

• Collect SST data from climatology and real-time NOAA maps

• Determine real-time SST anomalies (variation from the normal SST)

• Plot the SST anomalies and create an anomaly map

• Follow the development of El-Niño in the equatorial Pacific Ocean

List of MaterialsList of Materials• Black-and-white or color monthly

map sets

• Rulers or straight-edges long enough to extend the length of the maps

• Pacific Ocean worksheets enlarged to 11”x17”(extras are recommended)

• Package of twelve colored pencils in an appropriate color spectrum and labeled with readings from Š-0.5°C to >+4.5C° in 0.5°C increments

• Pocket calculator (optional), scratch paper, pencils and erasers

Step #1 Step #1 Identify TAO Buoy LocationsIdentify TAO Buoy Locations

• We will be determining the SST anomaly value for each approximate TAO Buoy location. In this case we will assume that a buoy is moored at the intersection of every 10° longitude and 5° latitude

• We will also assume that our array spans between 160°W and 100°E longitude and 10°N and 10°S latitude

Pacific Ocean WorksheetPacific Ocean Worksheet

• The buoy locations (indicated by circles on the above map) relate directly to those indicated on your Pacific Ocean Worksheet

• Your job is to determine and fill-in the SST anomaly values, or difference from “normal, for each location in the TAO Buoy Array.

Step #2 - Determine SST Values at Step #2 - Determine SST Values at each TAO Buoy locationeach TAO Buoy location

You will find a set of TAO maps following these directions. Each page contains a one month SST mean map on top and its corresponding one month climatology map on the bottom.

Determine Real-time SSTDetermine Real-time SST

• Begin with your TAO Monthly Mean SST map• Draw latitude lines every 5° from 10°N to 10°S (ie Blue lines on the above map)• Draw longitude lines every 10° from 160°E to 100°W• Determine SST value at each intersection, or buoy location• As with all scientific procedures, you may find gaps in the data. Using your best

judgment, extend out the isotherms and make your best guess.

Determine Normal SSTDetermine Normal SST

• Using your Climatology map, repeat drawing latitude and longitude lines

• Determine SST value at each intersection• Determine your SST anomaly value for each intersection by subtracting

the normal from the real-time (this can be a positive or negative value, or a zero value)

Helpful HintsHelpful Hints• Realize that the maps have been adjusted to be equal in

scale, however the colors in the Monthly Mean maps do not quite relate to the same temperatures as they do in the climatology maps. It is recommended that you print your set of monthly maps in a gray scale if you do not have color printer capabilities. You can then draw your latitude-longitude lines on your worksheets and check any questionable values against the display on your color monitor.

• As with most computer generated maps, the numbers are not always easy to read. Be sure to go slow and double check all your SST readings for each buoy location

Step #3Step #3Develop your own SST Anomaly MapDevelop your own SST Anomaly Map

• On the following page you will find the full-size version of your Pacific ocean worksheet. You can print it and enlarge it by 150% onto a 11”x 17” sheet for easier work.• Fill-in the legend and the anomaly reading you have determined for each location with the appropriate color pencil• Draw-in the isotherms to produce a color version of your SST Anomaly map

Pacific Ocean Worksheet

Helpful HintsHelpful Hints

• When drawing in the isotherms remember that due to quick changes in ocean SST’s in some locations the isotherms will be very close together. You need to think ahead in order to get several 0.5°C isotherms in between adjacent buoy locations.

• Once your isotherms are drawn in, you may go back and shade in the appropriate color for each temperature range.

• On the next page you will find an SST Anomaly map that I have prepared for your review featuring the average SST Anomalies for March 1, 1998

The AnswersThe AnswersWhat would be the fun of a mapping activity if you

could not grade your work against the answers? On March 18 we will post the actual TAO Buoy Array SST Anomaly maps generated by the NOAA computers so that you may see how well you did at reading, comparing and mapping the data. We will also provide some further graphics comparing normal ocean conditions with those found during an El-Niño event so you may better understand what your anomaly maps are showing you.

GOOD LUCK!GOOD LUCK!

Monthly Mean SST’s & Monthly Mean SST’s & ClimatologiesClimatologies

• These are the map sets that you will want to copy. I suggest enlarging them to fit on an 11”x 17” sheet. There are sets from January 1997 through February 1998. I recommend having students work in groups of two or more.

• The 1997-98 El-Niño event was initially detected in April 1997. Before then, ocean SST conditions were near normal.

January 1997January 1997

February 1997February 1997

March 1997March 1997

April 1997April 1997

May 1997May 1997

June 1997June 1997

July 1997July 1997

August 1997August 1997

September 1997September 1997

October 1997October 1997

November 1997November 1997

December 1997December 1997

January 1998January 1998

February 1998February 1998