managing cost and realising benefits from your sap hcm or other hr system
DESCRIPTION
Conference presentation: clear process to clean up the investment portfolio from any HRIS (HR information system) using SAP HCM as an example. How to reduce cost and maximise benefits from IT in HR.TRANSCRIPT
1
© 2010 Wellesley Information Services. All rights reserved.
Strategies for Assessing the Costs and Realizing the Benefits of Your HR Technology Investments
Mr. Sven Ringling iProCon
1
In This Session ...
• We’ll introduce a process for an HR-IT Portfolio Review, helping you to: ! Fully understand the nature and benefits of spending on SAP
ERP HCM and other HR systems in your organization ! Increase efficiency and reduce cost ! Focus investment on where it delivers the highest business
benefit ! Follow through on planned results to realize benefits
• You’ll learn to use simple tools to help you through the process • You’ll understand the change management issues bespoke to this
process and learn how to tackle them • We’ll demonstrate the benefits of Portfolio Review using real
world examples – with a focus on cost reduction
2
2
What We’ll Cover …
• HR-IT portfolio review: Purpose and process • Setting the scene: Business objectives and planned spending • The analysis: Understanding benefits and cleaning the portfolio • The results: Realizing benefits • Making it happen: Change management issues • Wrap-up
The Crisis Is Over — So, Why Bother?
• Short-term cost cutting • Projects just postponed or cancelled • Resource reduction without real changes – often at cost of maintenance &
quality • Doing less with less
Crisis years triggered emergency action only
• Crisis no longer an excuse for low service level, but stay below former level • Doing more with less • Outsourcing as a long-term option
Sustainable efficiency improvement required
• To start spending on HRIS again, business leaders need to be convinced by clear business benefits
Business benefits expected
3
3
Some Data
• 10% to 25% of IT investment is wasted * • iProCon research **
! 30% over budget ! 4.3 months late ! 61% fail to meet expectations ! Indicates decreasing quality of
HRIS projects
4
* CIO Executive Board Annual IT Budget and Spending Survey, 2008
** Survey of HR Directors, Chief Information Officers and Programme Leaders from SMEs to FTSE/NYSE listed organizations regarding the effectiveness of their HRIS projects. Averaged results shown.
What Drives Overspend
5
Requirements wrong or unclear
Project scope mis-
understood
Inappropriate/lack of HRIS
strategy
Lack of stakeholder involvement
Benefits unclear or intangible
Stakeholder priorities not addressed
Budget spent for the sake of
spending it
Benefits not realized
Delivery Problems “How”
Prioritization “What”
Overspend
4
The Portfolio Review Process
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
6
Preparation
7
What We’ll Cover …
• HR-IT portfolio review: Purpose and process • Setting the scene: Business objectives and planned spending • The analysis: Understanding benefits and cleaning the portfolio • The results: Realizing benefits • Making it happen: Change management issues • Wrap-up
5
Define the Objectives of the Portfolio Review
• In general, the objective always is to align HR-IT spending with strategic requirements
• Main focus can be on: ! Refocus existing spend on business priorities ! Keep cost low
• With a focus on cost, observe the following parameters: ! Time horizon for savings
! Post-crisis, the objective usually isn’t short-term cash flow improvement, but keeping a sustainably low cost base
! What needs to be ring fenced, because ! It clearly supports strategic objectives ! It’s based on statutory requirements
8
Result of Step 1
9
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
• We know why we are doing the review and how we can deliver business benefit
6
Understand the Nature of HR-IT Spending
• Spending on SAP ERP HCM can serve a variety of purposes ! Implementing a new process to improve the effectiveness of
people management in the organization ! Making a process more efficient ! Complying with statutory requirements ! Learning about new potentially very useful technologies ! Making something look nicer ! Using up the budget
• Understanding what category a project belongs to helps to understand what results can be expected and where saving opportunities might be found
10
Structure of the Portfolio
11
Creating Business Value (e.g., e-recruitment, BW for
line managers, learning solution, performance
management)
Exploration (e.g., Web 2.0 integration,
e-learning content in virtual reality)
Must Have (e.g., correct payroll and benefits, e-filing, EEO reporting, data privacy)
Driving Efficiency (e.g., ESS applications, leave
request workflow, report automation, user interface
optimisation)
SAP ERP HCM Investment
Portfolio
7
Result of Step 2
12
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
• You know how your HR-IT budget is spread over the four categories
13
What We’ll Cover …
• HR-IT portfolio review: Purpose and process • Setting the scene: Business objectives and planned spending • The analysis: Understanding benefits and cleaning the portfolio • The results: Realizing benefits • Making it happen: Change management issues • Wrap-up
8
Bespoke Approaches to Understanding Benefits
• For each box of the portfolio you need a bespoke approach to understand the benefits ! “Creating Business Value”: Which stakeholder requirements
are satisfied? ! “Exploration”: What could be extremely important tomorrow? ! “Must Have”: What exactly is it that is legally required or
otherwise mandatory? ! “Driving Efficiency”: What exactly are the expected savings and
how are they realized? By when will they be realized? • Benefits are often vague
! It is not always possible to put a ! sign onto each project ! However, always ask for the clear link between the project and
the benefit
14
SAP ERP HCM Is a Deliverable, Not a Business Benefit
Delivering a System can never be the
aim!
Changing a process can never be the
aim!
Always aim at business benefits!
15
9
“Creating Business Value”
• Anything allegedly creating business value must satisfy the requirement of a stakeholder. Examples include: ! User friendly e-recruiting platform makes candidates happy ! Line managers need an intuitive headcount reporting tool ! The Sales Director needs a quick and efficient way to train the
sales force in new products ! Peter S. might fancy the pay slip sent to his iPhone
• The value is determined by two factors: ! How important is that stakeholder? ! How important is the requirement for this stakeholder?
• These questions cannot be answered generically, but only when put into the context of your organization
16
Prioritization
17
Stakeholder Power
Impo
rtan
ce to
Sta
keho
lder
Low
M
ediu
m
Hig
h
Low Medium High
• Print EEO data into paper forms
provided (local council)
• Colour print on pay slip
(CEO)
• Improved usability in Self-Service
(union) • Improve customer
service (line managers)
• Quick and transparent decision
process for hiring (candidates)
• Speed up money transfer
(union)
• New set of employee data
in e-filing (tax authority) • Improve sales per
employee (line managers)
• Easy to use Recruitment site
(candidates) • Expand to Russia (Executive Board)
10
“Exploration”
• Projects in this box do not deliver value immediately, but may or may not do so in the future
• They are necessary to be able to master a potentially very important task in the future
• How important they are depends on three factors: ! What is the value they are able to create, if they succeed? ! How likely is it that they succeed? ! How important is it to take the lead rather than waiting for
others to master the technology and just follow • Examples:
! If you are selling complex products with a short product life cycle in tight competition, being the first to use the latest e-learning technology for sales force training can give you a strong advantage over your competitors
18
“Must Have”
• This category comprises items that cannot be argued about because they are required by law or otherwise indispensible
• However, it tends to be overused, because: ! Legally required processes are over-delivered on ! Big chunks of the budget are ring fenced, even if only a small
part of it is really based on statutory requirements: ! E.g., While core payroll is legally required not every !
invested in a payroll system is really serving mandatory tasks ! HR shies away from discussions with the authorities when they
ask for more than the law entitles them to ! It’s just an easy excuse for spending and requires no rigorous
business case • Challenge projects allegedly sitting in this box!
19
11
“Driving Efficiencies”
• This is about saving money • While this sounds straight forward, these kind of projects very
often fail to deliver ! Savings are defined vaguely ! Savings are spread out too thin to be tracked ! Nobody is responsible for making the savings happen
• “500 assistants across the organization will save 1 hour per week” is something nobody can prove and rarely leads to real savings
• Short-term payback usually comes from this category only
20
Result of Step 3
21
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
• For each project or work stream, the business benefit they deliver is clear
12
How to Allocate
22
Creating Business Value
Exploration
Must Have
Driving Efficiency
SAP ERP HCM Investment
Portfolio
Growth mid/long term
Growth, Innovation long term
Always do the minimum
Cost cutting short/mid
term
Cleaning Up
• Focus on the strategic objectives of the review • Eliminate projects, which
! Don’t show a clear line of sight from the investment to the business benefit
! Don’t provide benefits fitting the strategic objectives and timeframe
! Nobody takes responsibility to deliver the benefits
23
13
Result of Step 4
24
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
• Resources are allocated according to business priorities
• Initiatives with no clear business benefit are scrapped, even if this leaves budget unused
• Moment of truth for change management!
New Opportunities
• Reallocate funds saved ! To opportunities promising better benefit ! But only if this new opportunity fits the objectives (e.g., short-
term cost reduction) ! Never reallocate funds just because they are there
25
14
Result of Step 5
26
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
• Funds freed up in the previous step are reassigned to more value-adding activities
• Where no value adding activities can be found, these funds need to be given back
27
What We’ll Cover …
• HR-IT portfolio review: Purpose and process • Setting the scene: Business objectives and planned spending • The analysis: Understanding benefits and cleaning the portfolio • The results: Realizing benefits • Making it happen: Change management issues • Wrap-up
15
Move Benefits from Paper into Real Life!
• Project success is not defined, when: ! All the budget has been consumed ! SAP ERP HCM “implemented” in time and in budget ! The system test has been successful ! Pilot users use the new process in SAP ERP HCM ! All users use the new process in SAP ERP HCM
• The only measures of the success of a project are: ! Whether the benefits have actually materialized ! Whether this was achieved in time and in budget
• Somebody needs to be responsible for the benefits ! IT usually cannot take the lead on this ! In most cases HR must be responsible with IT in a support role
28
Tracking Benefits Realization
Benefit Description Measurement Responsible Cut FTE in leave data maintenance
Volume of manual work in leave data is reduced by 95% so that 1 FTE can be saved
One FTE less in transactional HR
Manager “HR Administration & Payroll”
Train sales stuff faster in new products
Availability and monitoring of e-trainings for sales staff allows them to learn features and sales scripts for new products twice as fast
95% of sales staff are trained in every new product within 1 month of release of 1st specimen of the product
Each Regional Sales Director
Reduce time to hire Selection process is speeded up
Time to hire for vacancies reduced from 3 months to 2 months in the UK and from 5 months to 3 months in France & Germany
HR Director Hiring managers
…
29
16
The Benefits Network
30
What are the required changes to improve
the processes?
What are the precise benefits we are
seeking?
What infrastructure changes are required
to support the IT?
What IT support will be required to support
these changes?
Which processes will deliver the identified
benefits?
Infra-structure
IT Appli-
cations
Business Change Process Benefits
Strategic Purpose
Example for Benefits Network
31
Advertise expat positions on
internal platform
E-recruiting platform Attraction
Expats for Russia identified
quickly
Provide quality staff for Russia
quickly
IT Applications
Business Change Process Benefits Strategic
Purpose
Attract best candidates worldwide
Selection
Expat Management
Corporate database of
potential expats
Provide easy-to- use global
talent portal
Advertise all jobs on
talent portal
Simultaneous access to appl. by managers
Offer pre-arranged slots for interviews
Best fit for expats
Attract many Russian
candidates fast
Improved employer brand
(Russia and globally)
Reduce decision time
17
Process Changes Required
• Which process changes are required to deliver the benefit?
32
Process As is To be Selection • Applications are directed only to line
managers of departments candidate explicitly asked for
• Screening by line managers is sequential
• Rarely transferred between countries • Unsolicited applications are not pre-
screened until position is available • Interview arrangements take a long
time due to difficulty to arrange with line managers
• All applications are pre-screened and assessed by HR immediately
• Several line managers can check one application at the same time
• Hiring line managers offer slots for interviews, when they send a requisition. When candidates apply for a position they have already been asked which of these slots they would prefer to interview for.
…
…
Tasks to Deliver Process Changes
33
Task Actions Issues Deliverable Define and implement process to pre-arrange interview times
• Discuss process with choice of line managers, assistants, and recruiters
• Provide respective screen to capture the data in requisition and application
• Explain advantage to applicants online
• Provide integration with Microsoft Outlook
• Advertise new process with line managers and assistants
• Train assistants • Adapt process documentation
• Line managers may not commit to time slots
• Assistants may feel disempowered
• Process may seem too complicated for candidates
• SAP solution has to be enhanced
• MS Outlook integration is technologically challenging
• System available to pre-arrange time slots for interviews and staff trained and ready to use it
…
…
18
Result of Step 6
34
Clarify objectives
Categorize HR-IT spend
Define benefits
Clean up portfolio
Identify opportunities
Benefits realization
• You can demonstrate which initiatives delivered which business benefits
• Progress is tracked and benefits realization is actively managed from a programme management level, if necessary
When to Celebrate Project Success?
• Celebrating successes ! Is important for employee engagement ! Sets a clear sign, what the real objectives are
• Celebrate the go-live of a system? ! Yes, because it is an important achievement and provides
timely reward ! However, it must be clear that it is just one milestone
! Celebrate it like other milestones (e.g., blueprint approval) • When does the project end?
! The project only ends once the benefits have been delivered ! Keep it on the portfolio, track it, and hold the project manager
accountable until this is achieved ! Have a big project-success party!
35
19
36
What We’ll Cover …
• HR-IT portfolio review: Purpose and process • Setting the scene: Business objectives and planned spending • The analysis: Understanding benefits and cleaning the portfolio • The results: Realizing benefits • Making it happen: Change management issues • Wrap-up
Forces of Change and Resistance
37
Supporting change
Resisting change
Status quo
Intransparency
Ego
Fear
Pressure on cost
Reason
20
The Irresistible Power of a Clear Line of Sight
• Insights provided: ! Having gone through the exercise of assigning all projects to
the four boxes clearly shows benefits (or lack of them) ! The benefits network makes clear which changes are required
to achieve business results ! To set the scene, everybody needs to understand what the
overall strategic objectives are • These discussions usually lead to the required change naturally,
while getting a maximum amount of commitment • However:
! A big chunk of the change is about killing projects, which is always very painful
! The strongest resistance will occur in the very beginning to stop you from starting the process
38
The Importance of Being Frank
• You must promote open communication about: ! The status of running projects ! The real benefit that can be expected ! Concerns about the value of projects ! Risks
• Some ways you can do this ! Leadership team in HR and IT come forward with mistakes
they made ! Use facilitation tools like the “six thinking hats”
! You can adjust it to have five hats, each arguing for one of the boxes and one arguing for no benefit at all
! In the long run: Promote a culture of open and pro-active communication
39
21
Reduce the Risk for Sinners to Convert
• You can expect many projects hiding in the “Driving Efficiencies” box, where a certain savings is projected, but not clear how it can be tracked
• It is important that you get these doubtful “investments” off your portfolio
• A proven change management trick: ! Explain how you expect savings to be tracked and proven ! Give project owners two weeks to revisit their business cases
and adjust projected savings – no questions asked ! Make it clear that after these two weeks they will be measured
against their projections ! You’ll probably get some adjusted business cases and be able
to take some initiatives off your portfolio based on the new numbers
40
Zero-Based Budgeting
41
Spend less this year
Get reduced budget next
year
Get blamed for blowing new budget
• If the new budget is always a percentage of the budget used last year, those who don’t spend all of it are punished ! Set budgets based on the future, not based on history ! Encourage managers to give budget back that they don’t need
22
Base Your Culture on Business Value
• Changes made through policies, objectives, budgets, etc. don’t last, unless ! The new way becomes “how we do things around here” ! Basic assumptions and mindsets are changed about
! What makes us successful? ! What is dangerous and what is feasible?
• In IT teams you often find a culture valuing ! State of the art technology, perfect systems, … ! Maybe even project success, new processes, happy users
• However, core values should comprise: ! Delivering a tangible benefit for the business ! Creating shareholder value and satisfying other stakeholders
• This is a long shot! 42
Forces of Change and Resistance
Supporting change
Resisting change
Understanding of business benefits
Culture
Budgets based on future needs
Transparency & openness
Ego
Fear
43
23
What Can Be Achieved
• Example: A manufacturer with 5,000 employees and an SAP ERP HCM budget of 420.000 ! (internal IT + consultants) ! Objective: Cost reduction on short term ! Portfolio review:
! 1 week intervention + 1 day review after 1 month (approximately 15k)
! Developed portfolio in four categories and set up benefits tracking tool
! Got buy-in from stakeholders ! Set up as an ongoing process
! Results in year one: ! Savings of 60.000 ! from initiatives killed ! 100.000 ! of postponed investment as not delivering timely
benefits. Up for review in 2 years. 44
45
What We’ll Cover …
• HR-IT portfolio review: Purpose and process • Setting the scene: Business objectives and planned spending • The analysis: Understanding benefits and cleaning the portfolio • The results: Realizing benefits • Making it happen: Change management issues • Wrap-up
24
46
Resources
• HR Expert – April 2009 ! Kieren Beltrame and Sven Ringling, “Structured Portfolio
Review Reduces SAP ERP HCM Costs and Increases Returns” (HR Expert, April, 2009).
• The Six Thinking Hats method: ! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_Thinking_Hats
• iProCon HCM Insight newsletter: ! www.iprocon.co.uk/nl
• John Ward and Elizabeth Daniel, Benefits Management: Delivering Value from IS & IT Investments (John Wiley & Sons, 2005).
47
7 Key Points to Take Home
• Benefits of HR-IT spending are often unclear • A rigorous portfolio review usually saves a significant amount
without losing important benefits • Before you start the review, you must be absolutely clear about
the strategic objectives • Sorting all HR-IT spending into four categories helps to
understand the intended benefits and identify saving opportunities
• The category of “Driving Efficiencies” is often abused, as projects have explicit saving objectives, but they are never really followed through
• Make the delivery of tangible benefits your paramount priority – it is not about delivering systems or changing processes
• Such a review is threatening for some people, so you need good change management to implement it
25
48
Your Turn!
How to contact me: Sven Ringling
49
Disclaimer SAP, R/3, mySAP, mySAP.com, SAP NetWeaver®, Duet®, PartnerEdge, and other SAP products and services mentioned herein as well as their respective logos are trademarks or registered trademarks of SAP AG in Germany and in several other countries all over the world. All other product and service names mentioned are the trademarks of their respective companies. Wellesley Information Services is neither owned nor controlled by SAP.