m&a 2.0: addressing "social aspects" of mergers and acquisitions
DESCRIPTION
This point of view discusses the social challenges of M&A and provides recommendations to creatively address these challenges by leveraging emerging Social Media concepts and tools during post-merger integration.TRANSCRIPT
Avinash JhangianiInnovator. Digital Strategist. Business Technologist.
http://about.me/avi
2012
M&A 2.0Leveraging emerging technologies to address “social aspects” of mergers & acquisitions
Point of View
Mergers and acquisitions have become a familiar part of today’s business landscape. The ability to rapidly yet effectively integrate is imperative to gaining the strategic competitive advantage that companies sought for before closing the deal. However the integration of two companies not only means amalgamation of their business processes and systems, it also means combining of two organization structures, cultures, and working relationships. In order to create one company whose value is greater than the sum of its parts, effective collaboration and communications are essential. These human capital or social aspects of mergers and acquisitions are overlooked many-a-times, causing integration delays and/or merger failures.
This point of view discusses the social challenges of M&A and provides recommendations to creatively address these challenges by leveraging emerging Social Media concepts and tools during post-merger integration.
Preface
- 3 -- 3 -
The adverse impact caused by the social aspects of M&A quickly compound over time if they are not addressed before core integration activities begin
Key social challenges in
M&A integration
Communications• Inconsistent tone and
content of key messages to employees and customers
• Lack of appropriate feedback mechanisms to address concerns and risks
Communications• Inconsistent tone and
content of key messages to employees and customers
• Lack of appropriate feedback mechanisms to address concerns and risks
Collaboration• Poor interaction between
employees of the merging organizations
• Top-down approach to integration, esp. in areas decision making and sharing of best practices
Collaboration• Poor interaction between
employees of the merging organizations
• Top-down approach to integration, esp. in areas decision making and sharing of best practices
People• Loss of critical employees
and social connections
• Culture clash
• Loss of productivity
• Fear-uncertainty-doubt (FUD)
People• Loss of critical employees
and social connections
• Culture clash
• Loss of productivity
• Fear-uncertainty-doubt (FUD)
- 4 -- 4 -
CIOs can leverage emerging Social Media technologies to address these issues, thereby effectively managing and accelerating integration
Improve visibility over integration activities
Enable effective knowledge transfer
Increase employee productivityand organizational efficiencies
Enhance combined NewCo brand equity
Promote workforce stability and address external stakeholder concerns
Retain key talent to maintain business continuity
Organizational alignment towards integration objectives
Business Benefits
En
ab
lin
g
To
ols
Online Profiles Social Networks Web-based communities
CEO Blogs, Moderated consumer-facing blogs
Podcasts RSS
Co
ns
tra
ints
Organization: rigidity of the organizational structure (hierarchical vs. flat collaboration model), existing knowledge management tools, operational alignment, cultural alignment (reclusive vs. eager to engage), and level of governance
Workforce: diversity, age, and geographical distribution Business: employee turnover, importance of knowledge retention, level of transparency
with customers, level of regulation
Ho
w S
oc
ial
Me
dia
ca
n
ad
dre
ss
th
es
e i
ss
ue
s
Identify, maintain, and leverage existing working relationships in the combined organization
Define skills sets and locate SMEs to fit the job
Analyze knowledge exchanges and information flows between cross-functional teams
Manage interactions between LOBs, workstreams, partners, vendors, and other ecosystem entities
Define target operating model
Decentralize decision making
Capture best practices and facilitate learning
Create an employee feedback loop to attain real-time, ground-level feedback about the perceptions of the deal
Manage customer and community concerns and misperceptions addressed proactively
Bridge the gap between leadership and staff
M&
A
Iss
ue
s
Collaboration platforms Wikis Social Tagging Ratings
People Collaboration Communications
“Connections can help combine cultures”
“Leverage wisdom of the crowds”
“Be consistent, accurate and timely”
- 5 -- 5 -
Companies that have used Social Media for merger and acquisitions have benefited in some very compelling ways
• Collaborative decision making: Defining Target Operating Model and sharing decision documents in the Integration planning phase using employee-facing collaboration platform
• External communications: Blogging to connect with customers and address questions and concerns about the merger at http://blog.wellsfargo.com/wachovia/
• Integration efficiencies: Drastically increasing its already-increasing efficiency in merger integration efforts by collaborating using Social Media tools like Wikis
• Reduction in transaction costs: Closing acquisitions far more quickly is proof of an enterprise-scale reduction of transaction costs, thereby enabling Cisco to undertake more transactions and be more responsive and adaptive
• Tracking integration interactions: Used social network analysis to map and measure the melding of information flows, work relationships, and knowledge exchanges to track where integration was happening and where it was not occurring.
- 6 -- 6 -
Define scope, scale, and goals of the project
Develop a detailed business case
Use business case to identify and manage risks, set goals and define metrics
Develop a project plan to focus on the metrics and mitigate the risks from the business case
Incorporate best practices for launching a successful Social Media initiative
Assess Plan Execute Manage and Grow
Assess the current environment and the characteristics of Social Media
Develop a plan for using Social Media to deliver value
Launch the Social Media project and execute the plan
Determine overallbusiness strategy
Understand Social Media and specific pain points that it will address
Assess strategic alignment with goals of Social Media
Analyze technical environment
Assess alignment and readiness of organizational structure and humancapital initiative
Implement theproject plan
Focus on the goals and measures defined in the business case
Take incremental stops and measure actual metrics against assumptions inbusiness case
Make modifications where necessary based on actual results
Analyze success of the initiative: understand where things went well and also where not so well and why
Understand where value was truly created and how to leverage it
Identify a growth strategy based on experience and maximum value creation
Manage the Social Media initiative and develop a growth strategy
Following a structured approach similar to those used for other enterprise applications is the key to successful Social Media implementations
Social Media is more about people and less about technology. Developing a business case to assess its fit and value is essential.
- 7 -- 7 -
Two fundamental questions need to be addressed…
Developing a detailed business case is a key component of successfully leveraging Social Media
What value is created bythis investment and howis it measured?
What are the major project decisions and how do they affect costs?
11
22
- 8 -- 8 -
Define Quantitative Benefits: Identify components and
measures of the benefits Determine variances and
dependencies among components
Define Qualitative Benefits: Clarify operational
improvements Understand how to gauge
improvements anddetermine indirect measures
Understand project steps that will affect the quantitative benefits and the operational improvements created by qualitative benefits
Determine area’s of the organization affected by the Social Media initiative
Establish ownership of the operational changes
Define cost drivers Understand how costs are affected by project plan decisions
Determine areasof indirect costs related to changes or operational improvements
Analyze areas of future costs related to managing and growing the initiative
It is important to define the quantitative and qualitative benefits along with cost drivers for a comprehensive business case for Social Media
Determine direct costs of implementing the initiative
Social Media
Strategy:
Social Media
Strategy: Goals
Scope and Scale
Support
Goals
Scope and Scale
Support
Business Case Results:
Business Case Results:
Quantitative Analysis:
NPV
IRR
Graphical Scenario Analysis
Qualitative Analysis:
Areas of operational improvement
Indirect measures for assessing effects
Quantitative Analysis:
NPV
IRR
Graphical Scenario Analysis
Qualitative Analysis:
Areas of operational improvement
Indirect measures for assessing effects
Stakeholder buy-in, ownership responsibilities, and clear plan for realizing andmeasuring value
Stakeholder buy-in, ownership responsibilities, and clear plan for realizing andmeasuring value
- 9 -- 9 -
The answers to key questions will help maximize business value from Social Media
Category Questions and Considerations
Value Which of the M&A challenges (people, collaboration, communications) are you trying to address? Are you planning to leverage Social Media in BAU mode?
Strategy
Does Social Media align with your company strategy? Will Social Media enhance your competitive advantage? Are you already experiencing the adverse effects of not implementing Social Media?
HumanCapital
What are the demographics of your combined workforce? Has a part of your workforce already begun using Social Media for business purposes? What is the target state of the combined culture of NewCo?
OrganizationalStructure
Do you believe there may be value in exposing hidden or untapped networks within the combining organizations?
How much collaboration between employees does your current organizational structure allow? What changes to your organizational structure are necessary and how difficult will they be to
implement?
Audience What specific audience(s) are you trying to engage? Employees? Customers? Business partners? What are the risks associated with giving power to this audience?
Existing Systems
What existing systems does your company have? To what degree do you want your Social Media to be integrated with existing systems? What technical requirements does your company have?
Compliance What external government regulations does your company and industry have to follow? What are your internal compliance rules? Information-specific rules? Technology-specific rules?
Thank you for your time!
Need help?Contact Avinash Jhangiani if you need help with developing innovative social, mobile, and web strategies for your company.
Profile: http://about.me/avi
LinkedIn: http://linkedin.com/in/avijhangiani
Twitter: http://twitter.com/goodthing
Blog: http://youarenew.blogspot.com