lidings client seminar 2013 (in english)
DESCRIPTION
Our annual roundup for clients on major changes in Russian law - Civil code and court reforms, migration laws etc.TRANSCRIPT
LIDINGS
October 2013, Moscow
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Andrey ZeleninPartner, Head of Dispute Resolution
Sergey PatrakeevCounsel, Co-head of Real Estate
Vadim KonyushkevichSenior associate, Corporate
SEMINAR ON RECENT CHANGES TO THE RUSSIAN LEGISLATION
ABOUT LIDINGS
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Lidings is leading legal advisor in the Russian marketproviding unparalleled legal advice to internationalcompanies – leaders in their industry sectors, operating inRussia and the CIS on a wide range of business and legalmatters
The Firm’s offices in Moscow and St. Petersburg comprisemore than 25 lawyers
PRACTICE AREAS
BANKING AND FINANCE
CORPORATE AND M&A
DISPUTE RESOLUTION
EMPLOYMENT
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
REAL ESTATE AND CONSTRUCTION
TAX AND CUSTOMS
Leading the Way in Russian Law
LEGAL ADVICE TO FOREIGN BUSINESSESOver 90% of the Firm’s clients are multinational companies andcorporations
Lidings is currently advising over 350 international companies form 35countries worldwide with special focus on the companies frompharmaceutical, automotive, aviation, financial, and energy sectors
Leading the Way in Russian Law
This is a snapshot only of the companiesLidings offers comprehensive legalservices to. For further informationabout our expertise please refer to theLidings website www.lidings.com
*
“Best Law Firm in Real Estate and Dispute Resolution in Russia”ACQ Finance, 2012
“Best Life Sciences practice in Russia”Who is Who Legal, 2012
“Second place in the rating of the most visible Russian law firms”Martindale-Hubbell, 2011
“Foreign Business Advisory Law Firm of the Year in Russia”ACQ Finance, 2010
“TOP-15 leading M&A advisers in Russia”Mergermarket, 2011
“TOP-20 leading Russian law firms”PRAVO.RU, 2011
“Recommended legal adviser in Banking and Finance”IFLR1000, 2012
“Recommended legal adviser in all key practice areas” The Legal 500 EMEA, 2013
RECOGNITIONLeading Russian and internationaldirectories recommend Lidings in keypractice areas highlighting its expertisein advising foreign businesses in Russia
*
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Lidings’ lawyers are highly skilled multilingual legal expertswho hold degrees from the best institutions in Russia andabroad
Their expert knowledge of Russian legislation and of theintricacies of Russia’s unique business culture has built upLidings’ reputation as one of the top law firms in the nation
LAWYERS
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Our lawyers act for a broad spectrum of foreign companies operatingthroughout Russia and CIS. Geographic range of our services coversthe most dynamic regions of Russia and the CIS including: Moscowand the Moscow region, St. Petersburg and the Leningrad region,Krasnodar region, Bryansk region, Samara region, Tver region,Kaliningrad region, the Republic of Bashkortostan, Tatarstan,Sverdlovsk region, and other major regional centers
GEOGRAPHIC RANGE
Leading the Way in Russian Law
CORPORATE MATTERS
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL INFORMATION ON THE REVIEW OF THE CIVIL CODE
The policy document underlying the review –The Concept of Development of the Civil Legislation
The Concept was developed on the basis of the Decree ofthe President of the Russian Federation dated 18 July 2008№ 1108 "On improvement of the Civil Code of the RussianFederation", approved at a meeting of the Council on thecodification and improvement of the civil legislation dated07 October 2009.
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL INFORMATION ON THE REVIEW OF THE CIVIL CODE
Bringing the provisions of the Civil Code in accordance withthe current market requirements
Ensuring the stability of the civil legislation
Reflection of the court practice concerning application ofthe Civil Code
Bringing the provisions of the Civil Code in accordance withthe provisions of the European law
Achievement of uniformity in regulation of civil relations inCIS countries
Leading the Way in Russian Law
MAIN GOALS OF THE REFORM
Legislative draft № 47538-6 “On amendments to the first,second, third and fourth parts of the Civil Code of theRussian Federation and in distinctive legislative acts of theRussian Federation has been divided into separate legislativedrafts which are enacted in blocks
ENACTING THE PRINCIPLE OF GOOD FAITH
Art. 10 of the Civil Code is complemented by the conceptof “action to circumvent the law with illegal purpose, orother deliberate bad faith exercise of civil rights”
Avoidance of law is now qualified as abuse of rights
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE
AVOIDANCE OF LAW
CUSTOM IS THE SOURCE OF LAW
Para 1 Article 5 of the Civil Code fixes a broader definition of“custom” (without pointing out the specific scope of itsapplication)
Custom is the source of law
The examples of customs – sources of law formed indifferent areas of activity, for example, local custom allowingfree gathering of mushrooms or free fishing
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE
CORPORATE RELATIONS
The subject of regulation is "corporate relations“, i.e. onesconnected with participation in corporate organizations andmanaging them (Article 2 of the Civil Code)
Corporate relations belong to the category of civil law, notpublic law
The inclusion of these relations in the subject of regulationby civil law confirms the role of the Civil Code as the basis ofthe entire regulatory system of legal entities
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE
THE SUBJECT OF CIVIL LAW REGULATION
STATE REGISTRATION OF RIGHTS IN REAL ESTATE
Inclusion of a new Article 81 “State registration of rights inreal estate” in the Civil Code
Introduction of state registration of rights, restrictions andburdens not only for real estate but also of other types ofproperty in cases provided by law
Competence of Federal Service of State Registration,Cadastral and Mapping has been increased to include areview of applicant’s authorities, legality of grounds forregistration, legality of transaction, if the right to propertyarises or terminates on the basis of notarized transaction
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL PROVISIONS ON REGISTRATION
GENERAL PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE
STATE REGISTRATION OF ESTATES IN REAL ESTATE
Since 01 March 2013 the following transactions are notsubject to state registration:
Sale of residential premises (Article 558 of Civil Code)
Sale of enterprise (Article 560 of Civil Code)
Gift contract of real estate (Article 574 of Civil Code)
Annuity agreement providing for alienation of real estate(Article 584 of Civil Code)
Leading the Way in Russian Law
GENERAL PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE
CANCELLATION OF STATE REGISTRATION OF CERTAIN TYPES OF CONTRACTS
THE CONCEPT OF LEGALLY SIGNIFICANT MESSAGES
Article 165.1 of the Civil Code has introduced the concept oflegally significant messages (notifications, declarations andothers), which are associated with the occurrence of civillaw related consequences for a person
Messages are deemed to be received from the moment oftheir delivery. If the recipient did not receive or read themby circumstances under his control, the message is stillconsidered to be delivered
Special procedure of exchange of the messages can resultfrom custom or practice
The emergence of this article has great practical importanceto the participants of civil relations, particularly with respectto consent to the transaction, the exchange of offer andacceptance, communication of information about thesubject of the transaction to the other side
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
Amendments in effect since
01 September 2013
(NOTIFICATIONS, DECLARATIONS AND OTHERS)
THE GROUNDS OF DECLARING TRANSACTIONS AS VOID
The frames of the consequences of the transactionsinvalidity have been clarified with the aim to reduce theopportunity for recognition of transactions void. There is nolonger a presumption of nullity of a transaction whichviolates the requirements of the law (Article 168 of the CivilCode). Such a deal would now be recognized as voidable,unless otherwise provided by law
Challenging a transaction becomes more complicated: thelist of persons who may apply with such a claim is limited.Until recently a claim that the transaction is void could bebrought by any interested person. Now the legislator haslimited the possibility to use invalidation as a way out of thelegal relations
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
THE GROUNDS OF DECLARING TRANSACTIONS AS VOID
The court will verify presence of actual violation of therights and legitimate interests of the plaintiff by thetransaction. Now we need to wait for new court practice onthe issue in order to assess the impact of this amendment
A transaction may be declared void only if a certain set ofconditions are met:
- if the transaction violates the requirements of the law orother legal act
- if the transaction infringes public interest or the rightsand legitimate interests of third parties
- the transaction is not voidable under the law
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
THE GROUNDS OF ADMITTANCE OF TRANSACTION AS VOID
The concept of “error in essentia” has been introduced. Itrefers to the Party's obvious typographical errors,misconceptions about the nature or subject of thetransaction, etc.
The meaning of fraud includes "the intentional omission ofthe circumstances of which person acting in good faith hadto inform based on the terms of turnover
The three-year limitation period for claims for theinvalidation of the transaction and application itsconsequences shall not exceed 10 years from the date ofcommencement of the transaction. This time limit begins torun from the date when the person knew or should haveknown about the beginning of execution of the transaction
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
THE GROUNDS OF ADMITTANCE OF TRANSACTION AS VOID
General limitation period has not changed and equals to 3years. However now it is calculated from the date theperson became aware of the violation of his rights and ofwho is the proper defendant. A similar position wasexpressed in paragraph 12 of the Information Letter of theSupreme Court of the Russian Federation of 13.11.2008"Review of court practice on some issues related to therecovery of property from illegal possession." Now, thelimitation period is limited to 10 years as an absolute period,which should have a positive impact on the practice
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
INTRODUCTION OF A GENERAL RULE ON PRELIMINARY OR SUBSEQUENT CONSENT FOR CONCLUSION OF TRANSACTION
In a preliminary consent for the transaction the followingelements must be clearly defined: subject of the transactionfor conclusion of which consent is given, including itsparties, substantial terms or a method of theirestablishment
The subsequent consent (approval) to a must be specific.Silence is no longer considered as consent to the transactionor its approval
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
DECISIONS OF MEETINGS
The Civil Code amended Chapter 9.1, devoted to issues ofresolutions of general meetings
Legal consequences arise from the decisions of the meetingof members of the legal entity, as well as co-owners,creditors in bankruptcy, etc.
Decision of the meeting shall be deemed adopted if itreceives the majority of the meeting participants votes
The provisions of the Civil Code establish a number ofrequirements to the minutes of the meeting
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
The Civil Code provides for the grounds for recognition ofdecisions of meetings as invalid and a general principle ofthem being voidable unless the law establishes they are void(by analogy with the transactions)
Decision of the meeting is void, if it is rendered on a issuewhich is not included in the agenda, in the absence of aquorum on the issue, beyond the scope of competence ofthe meeting or if it is contrary to the principles of publicorder and morality (Article 181.5 of the Civil Code)
The existing company laws, i.e. Federal laws dated 08February 1998 № 14 -FZ "On Limited Liability Companies"and dated 26 December 1995 № 208- FZ "On Joint StockCompanies" ( Para 1, Article 181.1 of the Civil Code) willhave a priority in regulating the corporate meetings
Leading the Way in Russian Law
DECISIONS OF MEETINGSTRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
THE CONCEPTS OF UNLIMITED AND IRREVOCABLE POWERS OF ATTORNEY
The Civil Code for the first time introduces the concept of“irrevocable power of attorney”. Irrevocable power ofattorney:
The authority under an irrevocable power of attorney cannot be transferred to a third party. The terms of itscancellation can be stipulated in the text of the power ofattorney itself
The term of the power of attorney can be unlimited(formerly – 3 years). If no term is indicated it is valid within1 year
Leading the Way in Russian Law
- is a method to secure the performance of thebeneficiary obligations towards therepresentative;
- may be issued to a representative in connectionwith business activities;
- is subject to mandatory notarization
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
THE CONCEPTS OF UNLIMITED AND IRREVOCABLE POWERS OF ATTORNEY
Additional methods for protection of rights and legalinterests under transaction committed by unauthorizedperson (Article 183 of the Civil Code):
A party to the transaction will have the right to refuse fromit until the approval of the transaction, if such a partybecame aware of the absence of authority of representativeto commit the transaction or abuse of his authority. Thecounterparty to a transaction concluded with anunauthorized person is entitled to request the other party,whether it is going to approve the deal. If it refuses toapprove the deal or its response is not received within areasonable time period, the other party may request theunauthorized representative to fulfill the transaction or mayabandon it unilaterally and demand compensation ofdamages from the unauthorized representative
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TRANSACTIONS AND AGENCY
AMENDMENTS TO THE REGULATION OF SECURITIES
Securities are now grouped into documentary and non-documentary ones. Documentary securities are qualified asgoods, while non-documentary securities – as liabilities orother rights
Documentary securities – documents which comply withformal requirements and certify rights, for implementationand transfer of which it is necessary to present the securityitself
Vindication of documentary securities from illegalpossession is carried out under the general rules onvindication with certain particularities
Non-documentary securities – liabilities or other rights,which are stipulated in the decision on their issuance oranother act of the issuer, implementation and transfer ofthese rights are possible only under special rules of recordof such rights
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Amendments in effect since
01 October 2013
THE OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
Record of rights to non-documentary securities can only bekept by an independent registrar, acting on behalf of theissuer, or by a depositary acting under a contract with theowner of the securities. Starting from 01.10.2013, the JSCwith a number of shareholders below or equal to 50, whichare now keeping the shareholder register themselves, themust transfer the register to an independent registrar within1 year
In case the seller avoids to register a transaction withsecurities in violation of the sale contract, the purchaser hasthe right to demand to make the required entries regardingthe transfer of title to securities through a court procedure
New rules on the protection of the violated rights of theholders of securities are adopted, which take into accountthe recent developments of judicial practice
Leading the Way in Russian Law
THE OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
INDIVISIBLE ITEMS AND COMPLEX ITEMS
Indivisible item – an item that cannot be divided withoutdestruction, damage or altering its destination. It exists as asingle object property rights, even if it is composed ofseveral parts. Replacement of certain components of theindivisible items with other components does create a newitem, if its essential properties remain unchanged
Execution may be levied upon the indivisible item only as awhole
If different items are connected in such a way that suggeststheir use with a common purpose, a complex item iscreated
Effect of the transaction involving a complex item extends toall of its items, unless otherwise provided by the terms ofthe transaction
Leading the Way in Russian Law
THE OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
BENEFITS, PRODUCTS AND INCOME
The legal regime of profits, production and income haschanged
Earlier - they belonged to the holder of the property, theuse of which resulted in such benefits, products and income
Now - they belong to the owner of the property (unlessotherwise provided by law, other legal acts, contract orotherwise follows from the nature of the relationship)
Leading the Way in Russian Law
THE OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
SINGLE REAL ESTATE COMPLEX
Independent object of civil rights - a combination ofbuildings, structures and other items united by a commonpurpose
A combination of items is considered a single real estatecomplex if one of the following criteria is met:
A single real estate objects is created from moment of stateregistration of ownership over the combination of itemsthat are part of such real estate complexLeading the Way in Russian Law
- inseparable physical or technological link between thereal estate objects (e.g., railroads, power lines,pipelines, etc.)
- location of real estate objects on one land plot
THE OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
(Article 133.1 of the Civil Code)
PROTECTION OF BUSINESS REPUTATION OF LEGAL ENTITY
The rules on the protection of business reputation of anindividual apply, apart from the compensation of moraldamage
Refutation of discrediting information has to be done in thesame way that the defamatory information has beendistributed, or in other analogous way
If the defamatory information has been published in themass media, a legal entity shall have the right to demandpublishing its response in the same media, apart frompublishing the refutation
If defamatory information has become widely known andtherefore a simple refutation is insufficient, a legal entityshall have the right to request removal of the relevantinformation, suppress or prohibit its further spread byseizure / destruction of the physical media containing suchinformationLeading the Way in Russian Law
THE OBJECTS OF CIVIL RIGHTS
CONCEPTS SIMILAR TO COMMON LAW CONCEPTS
A statement on fact which is essential to the conclusion orperformance of a contract given by one party to anotherbefore or after signing of the contract
Liability arises when a party that has provided untruthfulstatement believed or had reasonable grounds to believethat the other party will rely on them
Consequences of untruthful statements:
PLANNED AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL CODE
STATEMENTS ON FACTS
- obligation to pay damages;- entitlement to cancel the contract unilaterally,
unless otherwise provided by the contract;- entitlement to invalidate the contract be due to an
errors
Similar to
“Representations”
Leading the Way in Russian Law
INSTITUTIONS SIMILAR TO COMMON LAW INSTITUTIONS
An obligation of one party under the contract tocompensate the other party property losses, if they arise inconnection with the execution, amendment or terminationof the obligation. Proving the amount of damages is notrequired, a specific amount of losses is compensated in theevent of certain circumstances
GUARANTEE OF DAMAGE COMPENSATION
Analogue to
“Indemnity”
Leading the Way in Russian Law
PLANNED AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL CODE
INSTITUTIONS SIMILAR TO COMMON LAW INSTITUTIONS
An account opened in favour of a depositor (bank’scustomer) with an the escrow agent (bank) based on aspecial conditional deposit contract (escrow)
The account is designed to isolate certain funds received bythe bank’s customers, in order to fulfill the obligations of thesaid customer towards its creditor (beneficiary)
An effective way to secure the obligations of the bank’scustomer towards its creditor
Leading the Way in Russian Law
ESCROW ACCOUNT
Analogue to
«Escrow account»
PLANNED AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL CODE
AMENDMENTS TO PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE LEGAL ENTITIES’ STATUTE*
Legal entities to be divided on corporations (bothcommercial and non-profit organizations based onmembership) and unitary entities (non-profit organization)
General provisions on corporate contracts.
Joint stock companies no longer to be divided on the closedand open, “additional” liability companies cease to exist
Classification of business entities to the public and non-public depending on the method of shares distribution (bypublic subscription or privately)
Possibility to recognize a reorganization of a legal entity asinvalid through court procedure
Leading the Way in Russian Law
*Legislative draft № 47538-6/2.The status of legislativeprocess – the second reading
PLANNED AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL CODE
AMENDMENTS TO PROVISIONS CONCERNING THE LEGAL ENTITIES’ STATUTE
Joint and several liability of the parent and subsidiarycompanies for the transactions made by a subsidiary withthe consent or pursuant to instructions of the principalcompany
A sole shareholder shall bear secondary liability for thedebts of a legal entity, if it is established that they haveresulted from execution of the sole shareholder’sinstructions
Leading the Way in Russian Law
PLANNED AMENDMENTS TO THE CIVIL CODE
CONSIDERATION OF CASES INVOLVING FOREIGNERS
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Arbitration clause between foreigners on definition of anarbitrazh court as competent to consider any current or futuredispute is recognized valid
Forum selection clause under which disputes between theparties are considered in the state of origin ofclaimant/respondent is recognized valid
Jurisdiction and venue of arbitrazh court is defined on thebasis of the APС RF, if forum selection clause does not specifythe particular arbitrazh court «APС RF» means the ArbitrazhProcedural Code of the Russian Federation
Mandatory provisions of the APС RF on jurisdiction and venueof arbitrazh courts cannot be modified by a forum selectionclause
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Information Letter of the Presidium of the Supreme arbitrazh court No. 158 dated July 9, 2013
ARBITRATION CLAUSE ISSUES (1)
In case of assignment of the claims arising out of anagreement containing a forum selection clause, such forumselection clause remains effective both for debtor andassignee (new creditor)
If a party claims existence of an enforceable arbitration clauseon exclusive case consideration by a foreign tribunal, thestatement of claim shall be dismissed by arbitrazh courtwithout further consideration
Party’s intent to have a dispute considered by a particularcourt is confirmed by absence of its objections on courtjurisdiction before its first statement in the process of caseconsideration
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Information Letter of the Presidium of the Supreme arbitrazh court No. 158 dated July 9, 2013
ARBITRATION CLAUSE ISSUES (2)
Arbitrazh courts are required to rely on the provisions of theratified international treaties containing relevant conflict oflaws provisions
Arbitrazh courts shall recognize a choice of law clause if bothdisputing parties refer to it in their litigation documents
The mere parties’ consent on a competent foreign court doesnot imply that they also have consented on substantive law ofthe state of such foreign court
Parties are entitled to use any terms and statements forindication of applicable law in choice of law clauses
Super-mandatory provisions of the Russian Civil Code shallalways apply irrespective of applicable law consented on bythe parties
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Information Letter of the Presidium of the Supreme arbitrazh court No. 158 dated July 9, 2013
CHOICE OF LAW ISSUES
Requirement to provide information on content of foreign law may beimposed on the disputing parties by a separate court ruling
Failure to meet the above requirement deprives a party of the right toinvoke objections to defining the foreign law content by thecommercial court if the letter has assumed sufficient measures for itsdefining
Parties are entitled to provide expert opinion on foreign law content
It is considered that foreign law content does not need further definingif the relevant expert opinion contains necessary and sufficientinformation and is not objected by another disputing party
In case of contradiction between the foreign law content defining bythe disputing parties an arbitrazh court may address authorizedagencies or competent experts for their own interpretation of theforeign law content
Court decision/ruling may be modified or reversed if arbitrazh courthas failed to define foreign law content properly
Leading the Way in Russian Law
FOREIGN LAW CONTENT ISSUES
If international commercial arbitration is competent toconsider a dispute, interim relief measures may be takenarbitrazh court at the place of residence or location of therespondent or his property
If foreign state court is competent to consider a dispute,interim relief measures may be taken by arbitrazh court only ifit has effective jurisdiction, namely, at the place of residenceor location of the claimant or his money/property or at theplace of breach of claimant’s rights
Arbitrazh courts shall not execute foreign state court orderson legal assistance if they are intended for recognition andenforcement of interim relief measures
Anti-suit injunctions made by foreign state courts against caseconsideration in Russia are non-enforceable
Leading the Way in Russian Law
INTERIM RELIEF MEASURES ISSUES
Arbitrazh court is not entitled to revise the arbitral award onthe merits based on evaluation of its enforcement effect tothe public order in the Russian Federation;
In case arbitrazh court finds that recognition and enforcementof the foreign court decision and arbitral award iscontradictory to the public order of the Russian Federation, itrejects such recognition and enforcement;
To find contradiction of the recognition and enforcement ofthe foreign court decision or arbitral award to the public orderof the Russian Federation, arbitrazh court evaluates thearguments and evidence of the parties to the dispute;
Arbitrazh court implements the public order only inexceptional cases, apart from those established in paragraphs1-6 and part 2 of the article 244 of Arbitral procedural code.
Leading the Way in Russian Law
NATIONAL PUBLIC ORDER (1)Information Letter of the Presidium of the Supreme arbitrazh court No. 156 dated February 26, 2013 «Review of the consideration by arbitrazh courts of the cases on the implementation of the public order clause as the ground for rejection of the recognition and enforcement of the foreign court decisions and arbitral awards»:
Content of the applicable foreign law is different from the Russian one
Evidence presented by the debtor does not prove that losses (penalty,compound interest) calculated under a civil contract and approved byforeign court/arbitration are of the punitory nature
Foreign court/arbitration orders a Russian party to the initial dispute topay the bail for case consideration in the appeal instance
Foreign legal entity does not comply with the requirements forapproval of the significant deals under its domestic law
In case of the spouses’ joint assets, collection of the assets of one ofthe spouses on the grounds of the foreign court decision or arbitralaward is adopted in absence of another spouse
There is a minor slip in the foreign court decision or arbitral award
Proceeding in foreign court/arbitration complied with therequirements of independence and impartiality of judges/arbitrators
Leading the Way in Russian Law
NATIONAL PUBLIC ORDER (2)
The public order clause DOESN’T APPLY when:
Judge/arbitrator could influence one of the parties’ actionsduring the proceedings based on his job title and authority
Foreign court decision or arbitral award was adopted incontroversy to the international law principle of sovereignequality of the states
Leading the Way in Russian Law
NATIONAL PUBLIC ORDER (2)
The public order clause APPLIES when:
Challenging transactions during bankruptcy proceedings on general grounds of invalidity provided by the Russian Civil Code
Special aspects of the challenging of the certain transactions of the credit organization, which has been declared as a bankrupt
Specific provisions for challenging transactions made by credit organizations
Leading the Way in Russian Law
BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS AMENDMENTS
Basic bankruptcy proceedings provisions addressed in the Resolution:
Resolution of the Presidium of the Supreme arbitrazh court No. 59 dated July 30, 2013 «On application of the Federal law on Bankruptcy No 63»
How to break presumptions of intention to cause harm to creditors established by law
Difference between intentionally harmful transactions and preferential ones
Legal qualification of suspicious transaction with credit organization
Legal qualification of regular business activity transaction
Collection of evidence for challenging transactions
Procedure of vindication of property obtained as a result of an invalid transaction to the bankruptcy assets mass
Vindication of property from the second (subsequent) acquirer
Vindication of property from the second (subsequent) acquirer
Calculation of interest for use of property subject to vindication to the bankruptcy assets mass
Constitution of a group of counsels with specialtechnical expertise
Analyzing/interpreting court practice in IP sphere
Granting a legislative initiative right
Granting a right on petitioning the Constitutionalcourt
Leading the Way in Russian Law
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY COURT (1)
Innovations:
Federal Constitutional Law No. 4-FCL dated December 6, 2011 «On amendments to various federal laws regarding constitution of the Intellectual property court» (the IP court’s activity commenced at the beginning of August, 2013)
Leading the Way in Russian Law
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY COURT (2)
Competence:
Federal Constitutional Law No. 4-FCL dated December 6, 2011 «On amendments to various federal laws regarding constitution of the Intellectual property court» (the IP court’s activity commenced at the beginning of August, 2013)
When competent as a FIRST-INSTANCE court
When competent as a CASSATION-INSTANCE court
Challenge of the state authorities’ legal acts in IP sphere
Cases considered by the IP court in the first instance
Challenge of the state authorities’ decisions on granting/termination of legal protection of IP, namely:
breach of anti-trust law requirements based on IP rights “juggling”
termination of trademark protection based on its non-use
patent invalidation
identification of a patent holder, etc.
All other cases involving IP issues considered by arbitrazh courts
Leading the Way in Russian Law
MOSCOW CITY COURTFederal Law No. 187-FL « On amendments to various federal laws regarding intellectual property rights protection on the Internet» (so-called «Anti-piracy law»)
Innovations:
The Moscow city court has an exclusive competence toconsider the cases re IP rights protection on the Internet
The cases involve only movies/series (extension of the list ofIP falling within the frames of the «Anti-piracy» law isupcoming)
It is possible to block Internet-site based on interim reliefmeasures before case consideration on the merits
Liability extends to Internet-site owners, hosting providers,telecom providers
Extension of the Roskomnadzor’s authority in theenforcement proceedings
Leading the Way in Russian Law
MERGER OF ARBITRAZH AND GENERAL JURISDICTION COURTS
On October 8, 2013 the President delivered to the State Duma a draft law «On merger of arbitrazh and general jurisdiction courts»
Legal effects:
Competence of arbitrazh courts will be fully delegatedto general jurisdiction courts
The Supreme court will obtain an exclusive right toanalyze/interpret court practice in all legal sphere
Courts merger will require to amend the Constitution
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
Leading the Way in Russian Law
HIGHLY SKILLED PROFESSIONALS
Order of the Federal Migration Service of Russia dated 15 January2013 № 4. defined a list of authorized regional offices of FMS ofRussia processing applications and issuing work permits to foreignhighly skilled professionals
If the highly skilled professional will carry out work activities intwo or more Russian regions including Moscow city theapplication for work permits and invitations must be submitted tothe Federal Migration Service of Russia in Moscow
If the highly skilled professional will carry out work activities intwo or more Russian regions including the Moscow region theapplication for work permits and invitations must be submitted tothe Federal Migration Service of Russia in the Moscow region
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Amendments have been introduced to the procedure of acceptance of documents
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
WORK PERMIT
The new requirement was introduced to the documentssubmitted for the purposes of drawing up of work permits forhighly skilled professionals
It is necessary to submit a notarized copy of the certificateconfirming education obtained by a foreign specialist. Anordinary copy can also be provided together with submissionof the original certificate, and no apostille is required for thesepurposes
Leading the Way in Russian Law
New requirements for documents submitted to the Department of the Federal Migration Service of Moscow
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
INVITATIONS AND WORK VISAS
The new set of requirements by the Department of theFederal Migration Service of Moscow stipulates thatnotarized translation of apostilled copy of the marriagecertificate and the birth certificates for children accompanyingfamily members should be submitted when applying forinvitations and work visas
Leading the Way in Russian Law
New requirements for documents submitted to the Department of the Federal Migration Service of Moscow
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
RESPONSIBILITY OF EMPLOYERS
• Failure to notify, or breach of order of notification ornotification form on payment of wages
• Failure to notify, or breach of order of notification ornotification form on termination of labor contract.
• Failure to notify, or breach of order of notification ornotification form on leave without pay for more than onecalendar month during the year
• Failure or delay in providing information about tax registrationof highly trained professional
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Penalties were introduced for the following offenses:
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
The following sanctions for violation will apply:
• On officials – RUR 35,000 to RUR 70,000
• On legal entities – RUR 400,000 to RUR 1,000,000
Period of administrativesuspension of theemployer for violation ofemployment of foreignnationals:
Min. = 14 days
Max. = 90 days
REMOTE LABOUR
The following issues were resolved:
• Special features of conclusion and termination of laborcontact with remote employee
• Special features of the organization and safety of remoteworkers
• Special features of working time and rest time of remoteworker
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Specific labor regulations on remote workers
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
PERSONAL DATA
Employer has no right to receive or process information aboutthe employee relating to specific categories of personalinformation in accordance with the relevant legislation of theRussian Federation in the field of personal data with exceptionof cases provided by Labor Code and other federal laws
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Receiving and processing of personal data of employees
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
RIGHTS OF EMPLOYERS
The amendments are connected with establishment of work councils. A member of the work council may not be a person, who has not an employment relationship with the employer
The purpose of these councils is the accumulation of experience and preparation of proposals for :
• improvement of production activities
• improvement of individual production processes
• the introduction of new technology
• the introduction of new technologies
• improve productivity and worker skills
The law establishes limits to the powers of the works council: its competence should not include matters governed by corporate body and trade unions
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Work counsils
LABOUR AND MIGRATION
The law stipulates that workcouncil is a special internal“production” bodyestablished on theconsultative and voluntarybasis from the number ofthe employees of theemployer
CUSTOMS UNION
Leading the Way in Russian Law
ECONOMIC INTEGRATION
Customs Union + Eurasian EconomicCommission EU ?
United Customs Territory
Eurasian Economic Space
Leading the Way in Russian Law
CUSTOMS UNION
EURASIAN ECONOMIC COMMISSION
Supreme Eurasian Economic Counsil(Heads of States level)
Eurasian Economic Commission
Leading the Way in Russian Law
EEC Collegium(competent executive bodies)
EEC Counsil(Igor Shuvalov representing Russia)
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Supreme Eurasian Economic Counsil:Approves Model Statutes (e.g., «On Competition»)
Counsil of the Eurasian Economic Commission:Approves documents having direct effect (e.g., CU TechnicalRegulations)
Collegium of the Eurasian Economic Commission:Approves documents of procedural nature (e.g.,«On Official Internet Site»)
EEC Official Internet Site: www.eurasiancommission.org(Decision of the EEC Collegium dated 16.04.2013 No.83)
EURASIAN ECONOMIC COMMISSION
CUSTOMS UNION
United Customs Territory
Uniform Customs Tarriff
Uniform Customs Code
Leading the Way in Russian Law
TECHNICAL REGULATION
CU Technical Regulations
Agreement on Uniform Principles and Rules ofTechnical Regulation dated 18.11.2010 (createsnormative basis for elaboration of technical regulations)
Agreement on Eurasian Economic Commissiondated 18.11.2011 (provides for the competences of theEEC Counsil to approve technical regulations)
Leading the Way in Russian Law
CU Technical Regulations –List of requirements which should be met by the goods approvedfor circulation on the CU territory
Standards –(list of standards is an annex to the relevant TechnicalRegulations) – national and international – provides for„threshold values“ which allow to prove the actual fulfillment ofthe CU Technical Regulations requirements
Guidelines –Only on national level – provide for procedures of tests (expertchecks) for the goods aimed to prove the fulfillment of the CUTechnical Regulations and Standards
Federal Law «On Technical Regulation» dated 27.12.2002No.184-FZ
• Compliance Confirmation
• Accreditaion procedures for the certification authorities andlaboratoriesLeading the Way in Russian Law
TECHNICAL REGULATION
CUSTOMS UNION
• New technical regulations (extensive development)
• Unification of Standards and Guidelines(intensive development)
• Anything changed following Russia‘s accessionto the WTO?
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Prospects for elaboration of the uniform „rules of the game“ in the united economic space
Sergey PatrakeevCounsel, Co-Head of Tax and Customs PracticeTel.: +7(495) [email protected]
Leading the Way in Russian Law
Вадим КонюшкевичSenior associateCorparate and M&A practiceТел.: +7(495) [email protected]
For a detailed overview of credentialsplease refer to www.lidings.com
*
Andrey ZeleninPartner, Head of Dispute Resolution Practice Tel.: +7(495) [email protected]
OUR TEAM
MOSCOW
Naberezhnaya Tower, Block C10, Presnenskaya nab.,
Moscow, 123317, Russia
[email protected].:+ 7 (495) 989-44-10Fax: +7 (495) 989-44-20
Leading the Way in Russian Law
CONTACTS