lease cite this paper as: international journal of electrical...

PIn

[Escr

Please cite thisnternational Jo

A

Dan

Fuzzy have eThis pprincipcontroexperiwithinevalua

1 Traditof theimpleand toby Loexprematheseveramost r Fuzzy20 stuintrodsuch aHoweand thcurrendiscus GUNTball-bhold tdevelorelativshould On thintuitifuzzy orientimpledigita Fuzzycomp

riba texto]

s paper as: ournal of Electr

An Edu

niel Zaldivar,

aD

controllers havenabled designepaper presents ples at undergr

ol study aims toments. The pr

n the Electronication of their im

1. Introdu

tional methode system to beementation of oo difficult orofti Zadeh [1]sses operatioematical equaal successful robust and eas

y control is anudents per semduction of fuzzas an educatioever, the numbhe existing onnt available fssed below.

T [7] providebeam model wthe ball in a opment softwve high cost ad be rather co

he other side, tive way. It pr

logic gates Atation aims toementation, it al based system

yTECH [9] isletely graphic

rical Engineeri

ucationu

, Erik Cuevas

epartamento dAv. R

ve gained populers to control coan educationalraduate level b accompany stuoposed educati

cs Department impact in the stud

ction

ds to control ae controlled. Athe control al

r impossible to] which helps onal laws of ations. Such lfuzzy controlsy to impleme

n elective courmester at eachzy control cononal platform ber of commenes are either tfuzzy logic l

es an introducwhich acts as a

specific positware FSH-Sheand large dimensidered as a

the CE124 [8]rovides a scheAND & OR, o implement does not prov

ms.

a family of cal and based

ing Education,

nal Fuzusing L

s, Marco A. PEdga

de ElectrónicaRevolución 150

larity in the pasomplex system platform base

by providing audents to the leional platform in the Universitdent performanc

any dynamic sAn accurate apgorithm. Unfoo model accuto reduce the

f a control slinguistic term approaches i

ent algorithms

rse at the secoh academic yencepts to underadically helprcially availabtoo expensiveaboratory kit

ction to digitaa mechanical stion by tiltingell and then censions have ydemonstrative

] has been desematic panel NOT blocks

fuzzy systemvide convenien

fuzzy logic aon ISO 9000

Volume 50, Nu

zzy-basLEGO

Pérez-Cisneroar O. Palafox

a, Universidad00, Guadalaja

Abstract

st few decades wms through lingued on LEGO© a simple and earning of fuzzyhas been succ

ty of Guadalajace are both prov

system requirepproximation ortunately, mo

urately. Fuzzy e complexity system in linms are expresin the literaturs.

nd year of Eleear. It has beeergraduates is ps to understable educationae or relative cots that offer

l real-time cosingle-variablg the beam. Ccompiled to yielded a none tool.

signed to allowcompound wiand a defuzz

ms by using annt programmi

and neural-fuzand IEC 1131

umber 2 (April

sed ConRobot

os, Juan H. Sx

d de Guadalajaara, Jal, Méxic

with successfuluistic-based rulNXT to assist

asy-to-follow ty control fundamcessfully applieara. The descripvided in the pap

e the use of sof the system

ost real systemlogic is a maof controlling

nguistic termssed in the fre, the fuzzy

ectronic Enginen agreed amochallenging a

and the practical fuzzy controomplex to be practical han

ontrol by fuzze system. A fuControl algorigenerate mic

n-practical ind

w users to quiith two fuzzifzifier. It is a nalogue elemng properties

zzy developm1-7 fuzzy logi

2013), Manche

ntrol ps

Sossa, Jose G.

ara, CUCEI co

l implementatioes in contrast tt the learning oteaching setup.mentals by builed to several uption of roboticper.

some knowledm is thus cruciams are nonlineathematical frag nonlinear sy

ms instead ofform of IF-THPD controller

neering. The cong our facultand that experical implicatiool laboratory kused. A quick

nds-on experie

zy methods. Tfuzzy control iithms are init

crocontroller dividual develo

ickly implemefiers, a fuzzy unique hardw

ments. Despitewhich are no

ment tools whoic standards. I

ester University

platform

. Rodríguez,

ons in many fieto traditional mof fuzzy logic . The proposedlding hands-on undergraduate cc experiments a

dge about the al for the succear, highly comamework devystems. Fuzzyf traditionallyHEN rules. Ar [2-6] is one

course attractsty members thimental comp

ons of fuzzy ckits is rather lk overview onence to stude

The setup inclis used to attetially written code. Howevopment setup

ent fuzzy logicstate table, a

ware module e delivering a ormally availab

ose programmIt provides co

y Press, pp. 15

m

lds that methods.

control d fuzzy robotic courses and the

model cessful mplex, eloped y logic y used Among

of the

s about hat the

ponents ontrol. limited n some ents is

ludes a empt to

in the ver, its

which

c in an set of

whose a quick ble for

ming is de and

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


runtimas InTtargetmost o The Ffuzzy contriMAT It is hardwappliccomprobotilasting So far19]. Twith ctheir therefengin The LwhichLEGOhardwand Cthe dproce In thisfuzzy algoritwo exconceare enplatfofuzzy emergimpactheory The pthe eorientperfor

2 In thirules a

riba texto]


me modules foTouch, LabVted at financiaof them are re

Fuzzy Logic Tlogic system

ibutions. HowLAB program

important to ware, softwarecations may blemented by rics motivates g impact on th

r, the use of roThey can quickconducted expimmediate infore not surprieering subject

LEGO© NXT h has demonsO© componenware and softwControl. Studenesigning and ssing and sens

s paper, a simcontrol conce

ithm to the stuxperiments us

erns about thencouraged to corm using RO

control issueged from expct of robotics y.

paper is organixperiments. Station project rmance and its

2. The fuzz

s work, the fuand has the str

rical Engineeri

or microcontroVIEW, FIX, aal and commeelatively comp

Toolbox for Mms. Thousandwever, the Matmming environ

consider thae, hardware-sobe learnt throrobotics exercthe learning ohe student.

obotics has bekly become faperiments tha

nterests demonising that mants.

is a friendly, strated its usnts offer interware which arnts can becomtesting their

sing units suc

mple educationepts at undergudents. The casing the fuzzy robot’s oriencode the real-

OBOTC©. Dus as their motieriments and hands-on exp

ized as followSection 3 shwhile Sections evaluation a

zy PD cont

uzzy PD contrructure illustr

ing Education,

ollers, PLCs, pand Matlab/Srcial applicati

plex to test and

MATLAB [10]ds of code extlab© license nment.

at educationaloftware, sizes ough paper-ancises. This woof fuzzy contr

een positive toamiliar to the pat strength thenstrating the ny universities

affordable, me for researcresting possibre suitable for me quickly famr own add-onh as microcon

nal platform bgraduate level.apabilities andy PD controllerntation while t-time applicaturing the whoivation is encothe programm

periments for

ws. Section 2 ehows the LEGn 5 presents thas some conclu

troller

roller [2-6] is rated in Figure

Volume 50, Nu

process controSimulink. A sions of fuzzy d more oriente

is a set of easxamples are ais very expen

l goals can band costs in and-pencil exeork has been drol by connect

o encourage thplatform and

eoretical concebenefits of hs are incorpora

motivational anch and educatbilities. Minds

implementingmiliar with then componentsntrollers, senso

based on LEG. The course s

d limitations or which are timthe second sotion by using ole process, stouraged by thming experienmotivating st

explains the fuGO System he path trackiusions and con

used to imple 1.

umber 2 (April

ol systems andspecial versiologic and neued as a final a

sy-to-use funcavailable sincnsive and requ

be achieved ba variety of plaercises, traditideveloped undting theory an

he student’s intest their ownepts. This expands-on roboating the use o

nd effective etional proposstorms LEGOg complex dee set by taking. They mightors, etc.

GO© NXT is pstarts by theorf LEGO© NXmely providedlves a robotictheir own protudents strong

he robotic applnce. The papetudents’ intere

uzzy PD contrconfiguration

ing setup. Secntributions of

ement robot e

2013), Manche

d popular softon, fuzzyTECuro-fuzzy techapplication too

ctions for builce world-widuires users to

by a wide raatforms. Fuzzyional computder the hypoth

nd exercises yi

nterest on engn ideas based opands student

otics on the clof robotics pla

educational robses [22-29]. AO kits includeesigns for Robg further stepst also interfa

presented to aretically introdXT mobile robd by the lecturc path trackingogramming skgly reinforce lication and ther also discusest on learnin

roller algorithn. Section 4ction 6 discusf the paper are

experiments. I

ester University

tware packageCH for Businhnologies. Howol.

lding and evale users have be familiar w

ange of compy control theoter programmhesis that the ielding a deep

gineering topicon project dest knowledge blassroom [20]ants to teach s

botics platformAt first glanc relatively low

botics, Mechats and adventurace the kit to

assist the learnducing the fuzbots are studierer. The first pg problem. Stkills over the

the learning he visual resulsses on the png the fuzzy c

hm which featushows the r

ses on the studrawn in Sec

It consists of

y Press, pp. 15

es such ness is wever,

luating made

with the

plexity, ory and

ming or use of

per and

cs [11-signing beyond ]. It is several

m [21] ce, the w-cost tronics ring to

o other

ning of zzy PD ed with project tudents LEGO of the lts that ositive control

ures in robot’s udent’s ction 7.

only 4

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


The vAll arthe de 2.1 Fu As it error

The ra

wheretwo mmembmembThe odetermthat Hof eac The mfollow

Were

positiv

riba texto]


values Gu, Gere to be determefuzzyficated

uzzyfication

is shown in Fis defined as:

ate is defined

e ce is the curmembership fbership functibership functioutput membmined by expeH=L. It is obsech specific con

membership fuws:

ep is the er

ve.

+ -

Set-point

-

rical Engineeri

en rn

e and Gr corremined either boutput, which

Figure 1, there

as follows:

rrent error, pefunctions (posions, one at ons: error poership functioerimentation erved that its ntrol problem

functions for t

rror positive,

rate

error

de/dt

ep

rp

L

ing Education,

n

Figure 1 Fuespond to the by experimen

h is also known

e are two inpu

error =

rate = (

e is the previositive and negeach input (sitive (ep), eron is shown [4-6]. In ordevalue dependas it is presen

the input vari

en is the er

Figure 2 In

Gr

Ge

( * )

2eL G error

L

( * )

2rL G rate

L

-L

Volume 50, Nu

uzzy PD controoutput gain,

ntation or by tn as “crisp ou

uts to the contr

= setpoint - y

(ce - pe) / sp,

ous error and gative) for ea(one for the rror negative

in Figure 3.er to reduce thds on the limit nted in Section

iables, error a

rror negative,

nput membersh

FuzzyficatiControl Ru

Defuzzyficat

)en

rn

0

1.0

umber 2 (April

ller structure the error gainthe method deutput”.

roller: error a

sp is the samach input (errerror and on(en), rate pos. H and L arhe number of

of universe on 4.1.

and rate, are

rn is the ra

hip functions

ion les tion

u*

( *

2eL G erro

L

( *

2rL G rate

L

ep

L

2013), Manche

n and error ratescribed on [3

and rate (the e

mpling period. ror and rate),ne for the rasitive (rp) andre two positicontrol param

of discourse fo

defined as de

ate negative,

u

Gu

Proc

)or

)e

rp

Ge*error Gr*rate

ester University

te gain respec30]. The value

error´s change

(1

(2

Figure 2 repr, with two paate) and fourd rate negativive constants

meters, it is asor the input va

escribed in [2

(3

and rp is th

y cess

y Press, pp. 15

ctively. e u* is

e). The

1)

2)

resents airs of r input ve (rn).

to be ssumed ariable

2-3] as

3)

he rate

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


2.2 Fu Accor

AbovMore Accor

Wher

outpu In ordthis winputs(see Ecomb

riba texto]


uzzy rules an

rding to [4] th

e, ep is the podetails about

rding to [3], th

e 1( ) 2(,R x R ut values.

der to simplifywork, follows s region (IC) Equation 6) wination of the

rical Engineeri

nd defuzzyfica

here are four ru

R1.

R2.

R3.

R4.

ositive error, ethe interpreta

he defuzzyfica

u

( ) 3( ), ,x R x R

y the controllethe design pras it is shownwith only onerror value a

-

Negativ

ing Education,

Figure 3 Ouation

ules to evalua

If error is ep

If error is ep

If error is en

If error is en

en is the negaation of these f

ation method

)(4

)(4 )(

xR

xRHu

4( )R x are the m

er algorithm anroposed in [4-n by Figure 4

ne being usedand its rate.

-H

ve Output

Volume 50, Nu

utput membersh

ate the fuzzy P

p and rate is rp

and rate is rn

and rate is rp

n and rate is rn

ative error, rnfour rules are

employs the c

(3)(2)

)(2

(

(0)

RxR

RxR

membership in

nd save comp-5]. In such a4. Nine equatid depending

0

Zero Output

umber 2 (April

hip functions

PD controller:

p then output

n then output

p then output

n then output

is the negativprovided by [

centre of mass

)(1)(

(1)(3

)

()

xRx

xRxR H

nput values and

puting time, thapproach, the ions are used on which reg

H

Positive

2013), Manche

is op

is oz

is oz

is on

ve rate and rp[4].

s method as fo

) )x

d –H,0, H are

he fuzzy PD coinput space isto calculate t

gion is activa

e Output

Output (u*)

ester University

(4)

p is the positiv

ollows:

(5)

the membersh

ontroller, adops divided intothe control ouated by the c

y Press, pp. 15

ve rate.

hip

pted at o a 20-utput u current

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


3

The bservo (alreaa commeasuheadintotallyROBO

riba texto]


3. Experim

block diagrammotors conne

ady embeddedmpass sensor frures the earthng is calculaty prepared to OTC© progra

Ierrorat

erra

ICerror

0 < ra

ICerror

-L < r

rical Engineeri

2(2 e

Lu

L G er

2(2 r

Lu

L G ra

1[ *

2 ru L G ra

1

[ *2 eu L G e

1[ *

2 ru L G r

1[ *

2 eu L G

u L for IC

u L for I

0 1u en IC

mental setu

m for the LEGected to out p

d and transparefrom HiTechni’s magnetic f

ted to the nearbe compatib

am is transpare

-L

C18 or < -L te > L

IC19 rror < -L ate < -L

C13 r < -L ate < L

C14 r < -L rate < 0

-er

-er

F

ing Education,

[ *) eG error

rror

[ *) eG error

ate

]ate for IC

]error for I

]rate for IC

* ]error for

17.C

19.IC

18, 20.IC

up

GO system forports A and Bent to the useric© is used as

field and outprest 1 ̊and ret

ble with the Lent for the use

IC12 -L < error < 0

rate > L

IC15 -L < error < 0

rate < -L

IC4 -error <rat

IC7 -error <-rat

IC5 rror >rate

IC6 rror > -rate

Figure 4 Input

Volume 50, Nu

* ]rr G rate

* ]rG rate f

9, 10.C IC

11, 12.IC IC

13, 14.C IC

15, 16.r IC IC

r both exercise as actuators. r) which is ges input signal

puts a value returned as a nuLEGO NXT©er.

L

-

IC0 < err

rate

IC0 < err

rate

te

te

er

e

IC8 error < -ra

IC3 error < rat

rate

combinations

umber 2 (April

1, 2,for IC IC I

3, 4,for IC IC IC

es is shown inSuch motors

enerated by thein port 1. Suc

epresenting thumber from 0

© electronics,

L

C11 ror < L > L

C16 ror < L < -L

IC1 rror > -rate

IC2 rror > rate

ate

te

2013), Manche

5, 6.IC IC

7, 8.C IC

n Figure 5. T are controllee LEGO brick

ch sensor is a he current hea0 to 359. Thiswhose implem

IC17 error > L rate > L

IC20 error > L rate < -L

IC10 error > L

0 < rate < L

IC9 error > L

-L < rate < 0

ester University

(6)

The system used by a PWM k. On the othedigital compa

ading. The ma third-part senmentation usi

error

y Press, pp. 15

es two signal

er side, ass that agnetic nsor is ing the

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


4

In thi

explai

as it icontro

error r

to oneEq. (6 4.1 Im This wholebeen positivUsingsoftw

riba texto]


4. Orienta

is section, the

ined. In order

is depicted byol problem is h

rate r ( /de dt

e out of 20 po6) is used to ca

mplementatio

section starts e strategy for experimentallve limit (L) is

g ROBOTC©are.

ref

rical Engineeri

tion contro

e experiment

to reach the r

y Figure 6. Chandled as fo

), the fuzzy P

ossible regionsalculate the co

on

by explainincontrolling t

ly obtained as set to 360, d

© as developm

f

ing Education,

Figure 5. Di

ol using the

to control the

reference angl

Considering thllows: Using

PD controller i

s (see Figure 4ontroller outpu

ng the implemthe robot’s orand the L valdefining the limment platform

Figure 6. Ob

Figure 7. R

F

de

dt

e

r

PWM

PWM

Volume 50, Nu

iagram of the L

e Fuzzy PD

e robot’s orie

le ref , the ang

he fuzzy appras inputs the

identifies the

4). Once the cut u.

mentation of trientation. Linlue. Since themits of interes

m, students ar

btaining the ang

Robot’s orienta

Fuzzy PD

DiM

M

umber 2 (April

LEGO system

controller

entation ref u

gle’s error eroach presentangle’s error

region (input

control region

the first expene 1 shows the angle variesst for the univre encourage

gle’s error e

ation control

Robot

u

gital input

Compass sensor

2013), Manche

using the fuz

must be calcu

ted on Sectione (see Figur

combination)

has been defi

eriment. Algohe controller’s from 360 toverse of discoud to code th

actual

ester University

zzy PD contro

ulated by ref -

n 2, the orienre 7) and the a

) which corres

ined, one of th

rithm 1 depics gains whicho -360 degreeurse at this prohe real-time c

y Press, pp. 15

oller is

- actual

ntation angle’s

sponds

he nine

cts the h have es, the oblem. control

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


Ori

In ord

been iFigure Consi

which F

riba texto]


ientation contr

G

G

G

L

r

a u r

e

e

1: G2: L While 3: e

4:

degree5: e6:

degree7:

8: r

9: e10:

11: r

12: u

13:

14:

robot r15: 16: 17:

robot r18: 19:

der to elimina

included to dee 8 shows the

idering its imp

h is shown in t

Fuzzy PD Algo

1: FUZ

2: Eva 3: if

4:

5: if

6:

7: if

8: 9: if

10:

11: if 12:

rical Engineeri

rol Algorithm

eG : error’s ga

rG : rate’s gai

uG : output’s g

L: universe of

ref : desired an

actual : actual a

u: output of tr: rate of the

: angle’s er

1 : angle’s er

eG • 20, rG •

L • 360

(true)

• ref actual

if( e > ) t

s, to turn th

• e -2

if( e <- )

s, to turn the • e +2

r •1e e

1 • e e • * ee G

r • * rr G

• FUZZY( e ,r

u • uu G*

if ( e >0

rotates antic motorA • motorB • else

rotates clock motorA • motorB •

ate the error eefine the shortinclusion of s

portance, the

the Algorithm

orithm

ZZY( e ,r)

luate the 20

( e >-r) or (

u • (L/(2*

( e <r) or (-

u • (L/(2*

(( e >L) and

u ← (L+r)/2 ((0< e <L) and

u ← (L+ e

((e<-L) and(0 u • (-L+r

ing Education,

m

ain

in

gain

f discourse l

ngle in degree

ngle in degre

the fuzzy conte angle’s errorror

rror obtained

2, uG • 0.5

then

he robot clock

then

he robot anti-

•

•

• m

• mu

r)

•

)then •

lockwise u -u ( e <0) •

wise -u u

Algorithm 1.

while efficie

test way to mesuch code thro

fuzzy PD con

m 2.

regions to fi

e >r) or (- e >

*(2*L-abs( e )

e <r) or (- e <

*(2*L-abs(r)))

(-L<r<0)) or (

d (r>L)) or ((

)/2

0<r<L)) or ((er)/2

Volume 50, Nu

imit

es

ees

troller or

from previou

• defining

• and its

• obtaining

• checking i

kwise

• checking i

-clockwise

obtaining th

obtaining the

multiplying th

ultiplying the

• calling the

• multiplying

• If the angle

If the angle’

Orientation con

ently reaching

eet the referenough a generic

ntroller is des

ind the output

>r) or (- e >-r

)))*( e +r)

<-r) or ( e <-r

))*( e +r)

((0<r<L)and( e

r>L) and(-L< e

e<-L) and (-L<

umber 2 (April

us period of t

the controll

positive limi

the angle’s

if the error

if the error

he angle’s err

e last angle’

he actual ang

e rate by its

e fuzzy funct

the output b

e’s error is p

’s error is ne

ntrol algorithm

g ref , lines 4

nce angle consc example.

scribed as a se

t u

r) then • re

r) then • re

>L)) then

<0)) then

r<0))then

2013), Manche

time

ler’s gains

it

error

is bigger tha

is smaller th

ror rate

s error

le’s error by

gain

ion to obtain

by its gain

positive then

egative then

4 and 6 of th

sidering the a

eparate functi

egions ic1, ic

egions ic3, ic

• regions

• regions ic1

• regions

ester University

an 180

han -180

y its gain

n the output

the

the

e Algorithm

ctual robot po

on (FUZZY(

c2, ic5, ic6

c4, ic7, ic8

ic9, ic10

1, ic12

ic13, ic14

y Press, pp. 15

1 have

osition.

e ,r))

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


Figure

of 90

300 it

riba texto]


13: if

14:

15: if

16: 17: if

18: 19: if

20: 21:

Figure 8

e 9 shows the

degrees. Figu

terations. Such

3 :

6 : (

7 :

e

e

if e

e

e

e

rical Engineeri

((r<-L) and (

u • (-L+ e

( e >L) and (

u ← L

( e <-L) and

u ← -L

(( e <-L) and

u • 0 return u

8. Reaching effi

e performance

ure 9, below, s

h graphic is a

3

2

)

2

32

21

2

ref actual

then

e

ing Education,

(-L< e <0)) or (

e )/2

r>L) then

(r<-L) then

(r>L)) or ((

Algorithm 2.

iciently ref , (i.

e of the real-tim

shows the evo

compulsory a

Clockwise

Volume 50, Nu

(r<-L) and (0<

e >L) and (r<-

Fuzzy PD cont

.e. deciding if it

me fuzzy con

olution of pow

assignment for

3

2ref

umber 2 (April

< e <L) then

• regi

• regi

-L)) then •

troller function

t does spin cloc

ntroller for orie

wer for the left

r each student

1

2e

Anticlock

2013), Manche

• regions ic

ions ic17

ions ic19

regions ic18,

ckwise or anticl

entation, cons

( l ) and righ

t during the co

kwise (the shortest w

ester University

c15, ic16

, ic20

lockwise).

sidering an ini

ht ( r ) motor

ourse.

0actual

way to reach ) ref

y Press, pp. 15

itial ers over

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


5

This scontroactualand thconsid

the an

PD co

the an

veloci

and 30

xref,

riba texto]


Figu

5. The path

section presenoller. Figure 1l position (xact

he relative robdering a linear

ngle error’s an

ontroller in or

ngular velocit

ities l and 0 of the algori

−

1

e θ

−

−

−

−Pow

er v

eloc

ity

yref

R

ref

rical Engineeri

ure 9. Perform

h tracking

nts an experim10 shows the tual ,yactual) andbot’s distancer gain Kp. 3. θ

nd its derivate

rder to obtain

ty at each wh

r according t

ithm 3 show t

0 50−20

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 50−40

−30

−20

−10

0

10

20

30

40

ing Education,

mance of the real

experimen

ment to contrpath tracking

d the goal posie R to the goaθref and θactual (

e, respectively

the robot’s a

heel, the linear

o their relatio

the procedure.

Figure 10. R

50 100

iter

50 100

de

dt

e

r

Volume 50, Nu

l-time fuzzy co

nt

rol the tracking control procition (xref ,yref

al position. 2.(obtained by a

y. 4. Both sign

angular veloci

r velocity v a

nship which i

.

Robot’s path tra

0 150

iteration k

0 150iteration k

Kp

Fuzzy PD

umber 2 (April

ntroller for the

ng of a givencedure step by) are used in o R is used to a compass sen

nals ( e and

ty . 5. Sinc

and the angula

s explained in

acking control

200

200

ω

ω

k

b

(x,y)

c

v

2013), Manche

orientation pro

n robot’s pathy step as folloorder to obtainregulate the

nsor) are used

r) are used as

ce the robot is

ar velocity n the robot’s m

250

250

ω r

ω l

ωlc

ester University

oblem

h using a fuzows: 1.- The rn the goal anglinear velocit

d to obtain e s inputs to the

s controlled o

are used to

model [29]. Li

300

300

ωr xactual

ac

y Press, pp. 15

zy PD robot’s gle θref, ty v by

and r,

e fuzzy

only by

obtain

ines 28

l,yactual

ctual

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


5.1 Im In thecode. algori Pa

riba texto]


mplementatio

e Algorithm 3Line 1 shows

ithm is explain

ath-tracking C

eG , rG ,ref

e

,actualx y

,refx

v,

,lw

1: eG •4.

pK •

2: b • 0the back

3: refx •

While (tr4:

rtc •

5: ltc •

6:

rrot

7: lrot

8: avrot

9: •

10: y

11: x

12:

acx

13: y

14: a

15:

16:

17: ref

18: R

19: 20: r

21:

22:

23:

24: u ← 25:

rical Engineeri

on

, the general ps the controllened to the stud

Control Algori

, uG : error, r

actual : desired

u: output

1,e : angle’s

r: rate of

actualy : actual c

refy : referenc

R : robot’s d

w : lineal an

pK : proportio

, rw : left and

7, rG •0.025,

• 0.25

0.094, c • 0.shaft, c whee

1.0, refy • 1.

rue) • _ _ (motor get count

• _ _ (motor get count

• * / 360rtc PER

• * / 360ltc PER :

ve• / 2r lrot rot

/r lrot rot b

• sin(ave actualrot

• cos(ave actualrot

tual •

actual xx

actualy • actual yy

actual •actual

ex ←ref actualx x

ey ←ref actualy y

f ← 1tan e

e

y

x

R ← 2 2e ex + y

e ← ref actual

r ←1e e

1e ← e e ← * ee G

r ← * rr G

FUZZY( e ,r)

u ← uu G*

ing Education,

procedure to ier’s gains whidents and they

ithm

rate and outpu

and actual an

of the fuzzy

s error and th

f the angle’s

coordinates

e coordinates

distance to t

nd angular ve

onal controll

right angula

uG •1.01, L•3

028, PER • 0.el’s radius,

0

( )portB

( )portA

•

•

•

•

/ 2)

•

/ 2)l

•

•

•

►

►

►

►

►

►

►

►

►

► c

► m

Volume 50, Nu

implement thech have beeny are encourag

ut gains

ngles in degr

controller

he last angle’

error

s

he next point

locities

er’s gain

r velocities

360 • defining

• defining

179 • definiand PER accou

• defining

• reading the

• reading the

• calculating

calculating

• both wheels

• obtaining th

• obtaining th

• obtaining t

calculating

• calculating

calculating

► calculating

► calculating

calculating

calculating R

obtaining the

obtaining the

obtaining the

multiplying t

multiplying t

calling the fu

multiplying t

umber 2 (April

e path trackingexperimental

ged to code it

ees

’s error

t

g gains for th

g the proport

ing robot’s counts for the r

g the robot’s

e right wheel

e left wheel r

the right whe

the left whee

robot’s rotat

he angle’s inc

he distant in

the distant in

the actualx

the actualy

the

actual

the error on

the error on

ref

R

e angle’s err

e angle’s erro

e last angle’s

the actual ang

the rate by i

uzzy function

he controller

2013), Manche

g controller islly obtained anby themselve

he fuzzy cont

ional control

onstants (b lerobot´s wheel

reference coo

robot’s tick

robot’s tick c

eel robot’s ro

el robot’s rot

tions are ave

crement

ncrement on y

ncrement on x

x y

or

or rate

s error

gle’s error by

ts gain

r’s output by

ester University

s exposed as pnd the L values in ROBOTC

roller

ller’s gain

ength of perimeter)

ordinates

counter

counter

otations

tations

raged

y its gain

its gain

y Press, pp. 15

pseudo e. This C©.

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


Figurerefere

6

This exercithis pElectr This wThe fologic after oretent Both traditicontroExamcorres

riba texto]


26: if(ufall betw if(u

27: v ←

28:

29: w

30:

31: w

32:

33:

e 11 shows thence trajectory

6. Results

section descrises whose tarpaper have bronics Departm

work considerformer refers t

concepts. Onone year of ftion after a yea

indexes consiional fuzzy cool hands-on

mination after spond to the h

−10−80

−60

−40

−20

0

20

40

60

80

cms

rical Engineeri

u> L)then ► ween L and -L u= L

u< L)then u= -L

R pK ► ro

(2l

bw v u

0.81 exp lwlw

(2r

bw v u

0.81 exp rwrw

motorA ← w

motorB ← w

he performany and the actua

Figure 11. T

and discus

ribes the posirget has beeneen incorporament of the Un

rs two performto an examinan the other hanfinishing the far for both the

ider a universontrol course arobotic subjea year in term

highest mark w

100 −800

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

ing Education,

preventing a

obot’s lineal

1)

c

►

►

1)

2

b

c

► o

► a

lw ► applyin

rw ► applyin

Algorithm 3. P

nce of the fuzal trajectory a

The fuzzy contro

sion

itive impact o the motivatioated into an niversity of G

mance indexesation that has bnd, the latter fuzzy course. e practical and

se of forty stuand the remainect. Table 1 ms of the Ave

while the Wors

−60 −40

Volume 50, Nu

an overflow of

velocity scal

obtaining the

avoiding satu

obtaining the

avoiding satur

ng the output

ng the output

Path tracking co

zzy controller re both plotted

oller performan

on students aon for learninelective seco

Guadalajara.

s: the Course Ebeen applied considers a sSuch proced

d non-practica

udents with twning referringshows the v

erage and thest value corres

0 −20cms

umber 2 (April

f the output b

led by a line

e left wheel

uration

right wheel

ration

to the robot

t to the robot

ontrol algorithm

for a genericd in centimete

nce over a path-

after the implng fuzzy contrond-year und

Examination ato student jus

second examindure aims to eal course atten

wenty correspg to those studvalues of thee Worst-Bestsponds to the

0 20s

2013), Manche

by limiting it

ear gain.

velocity

velocity

’s left motor

t’s right moto

m

c path-trackiners.

-tracking task.

lementation orol theory. Allergraduate co

and the Examst after finishinnation that is evaluate the sndees.

ponding to thdents who have Course Exobtained valulowest score.

40 6

Reference traRobot’s traje

ester University

ts value to

r

or

ng task. The r

of hands-on rl the experimeourse taught

ination after ang courses onapplied to st

student’s know

hose who attene attended the

xamination anues. The Best

60 80

trajectoryajectory

y Press, pp. 15

robot’s

robotic ents in in the

a year. n fuzzy tudents wledge

nded a e fuzzy nd the value,

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


Tablehandstrend have bindex been o

7 Fuzzyindustcontro By usnonlinbasedcourseexperwhile are prof a Lto imExperissuestrend workelearnithe stu Refe [1] L. [2] H.513-5 [3] Hcontro [4] YAnalyAlbuq [5] Econtro1998 I [6] F. applic

Ex

riba texto]


e 1 presents ths-on robotic cis observed fbeen given toaddresses low

observed for e

7. Conclus

y controllers htrial and acadol courses in m

sing fuzzy lonear systems.

d on LEGO© es. The capabiments using the second so

resented incluLEGO© NXT

mplement contrimental evides for the studto hold the kned through thing of fuzzy cudents.

erences

A. Zadeh, ´F

. Ying, W. Sil520.

H.A. Malki, hol systems´, IE

Y.C Hsu, G. ysis´ Proceedquerque, NM,

. Sanchez, L.ol´, Fuzzy SysIEEE Interna

Lara-Rojo, Ecations´, Journ

Course Examxamination af

rical Engineeri

he Course Exourse are high

for the Examino students attewer values foeither the Cou

Ta

sions

have becomedemic subjectmany technica

gic control, dIn this papeNXT to assi

bilities and lima fuzzy PD c

olves the robouding their cor

as a robust rotrol algorithmence shows anents who havnowledge of fuhe proposed econtrol by con

uzzy sets´. Inf

ler, J. J. Buckl

h. Li, G. CheEEE Transacti

Chen, E. Sandings of the

1997, pp. 141

A. Nuno, Y.Cstems Proceedtional Confer

E.N. Sanchez, nal of Applied

mination fter a year

ing Education,

xamination indher than thosenation after a ending the fuzor students atturse Examinat

able 1. The aver

popular in rts. Such trendal colleges and

designing a cr, the authorsist the learninmitations of Lcontroller. Theot’s path trackrresponding eobotic platform

ms by simplyn increase in tve attended thfuzzy control iexercises. Sucnnecting theor

formation and

ley, ´Fuzzy Co

n, ´New desiions on Fuzzy

nchez, ‘A Fu1997 IEEE

12-1417.

C. Hsu, G. Cdings, 1998. Ience on , 1, (1

D. Zaldivar, d Research an

Fuzzy con

Average 70 55

Volume 50, Nu

dex which she given to stuyear index. A

zzy hands-on tending a trad

tion or the Exa

raged scholar-p

recent decaded has indeed d universities

ontroller is res have presenng of fuzzy cLEGO© NXTe first experim

king task. Bothxperimental rm for teachin

y doing progrthe performanhe hands-on rissues for longch results indry and exercis

d control, Vol

ontrol Theory

ign and stabiy Systems, 2 (

uzzy controlleInternational

Chen, ´Fuzzy PIEEE World C1998), 302-30

´Minimal fuzzd Technology

ntrol course

Best Worst92 60 76 45

umber 2 (April

hows that the udents attendinAgain, the Bes

control coursditional fuzzyamination afte

performance res

es with succestriggered a r

around the wo

elatively simpnted the use ocontrol concepT mobile roboment addresseh algorithms aresults. The pag fuzzy controramming at a

nce and reinforobotic exercisger periods of dicates that thses yet sowin

l. 8, Academic

y: A Nonlinear

ility analysis(1994), 245 –

er for a Multl Conference

PD scheme foCongress on 06.

zy microcontry, 1(2) (2003)

Fuzzy

t Av

2013), Manche

marks for stung a traditionst index showse. On the othy control courer a year index

sults

ssful implemeremarkable aorld.

ple task yet fof a simple epts in undergrots have been s the robot’s

and their requaper has also ol. The platfoa high-level rcement of leases. Similarly

f time for thosehe use of robg a deeper an

c, New York,

r Case, Autom

of fuzzy pro254.

ti-Link Roboe on Robotics

for underactuaComputationa

roller impleme137-147.

y control courrobotic exe

verage 82 72

ester University

udents attendial course. A s

ws that higher her hand, the rse. Same trenx.

entations in savailability of

facing compleducational plraduate enginstudied with

orientation prired additionashown the po

orm enables stlanguage inte

arning fuzzy cy, evidence she students wh

botics motivatnd lasting imp

1965, pp 338-

matica, 26 (3)

oportional-deri

t Control: Sts and Autom

ated robot swal Intelligence

entation for d

rse + hands-onercises

Best 100 97

y Press, pp. 15

ing the similar marks Worst

nd has

several f fuzzy

ex and atform

neering in two roblem al tools otential tudents erface. control hows a o have tes the pact on

-353.

1990,

ivative

tability mation,

wing-up e., The

idactic

n

Worst 73 62

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


[7] GUGmbH[8] Csystem [9] Fu [10] logic/

[11] LProceFlorid

[12] Cin Au2451– [13] JLEGOTRAN [14] TEngin [15] ANoll, Cours [16] Bengin [17] Procevolum [18] Fsystem [19] PEduca [20] Lsmall, [21] Rprogra [22] Din theConfe [23] DLEGO2011, [24] AelectrAppli

riba texto]


UNT GeratebH, Fahrenberg

CE124 Fuzzy ms.pdf [Visite

uzzyTech, http

Fuzzy L/index.html;jse

L. Meeden. Ueedings of the da AI Research

C. A. Jara, F. Automatics and –2461.

J. M. Gómez-dO NXT MobNSACTIONS

T. Karp, R. Gneers With LE

A. Behrens, LK. Hameyer

se Into Practic

Beer, R. D.; Ceering. Comm

Kumar, D., eedings of theme 30(1) of SI

Fabiane Barrematic review´,

P. Ranganathation´, Procee

L. Greenwald, low-cost plat

R. Ramli, Mam´, Procedia

D. Martinec ae IEEE Intererence on Syst

D. Zermas, CO Platform, IE pp. 1381-138

A. Vourvopouical activity, ications, Athe

rical Engineeri

bau, GmbH, Rg, Barsbuttel, 2

Logic Traineed on April 20

p://www.fuzzy

Logic Toolbessionid=6524

Using RobotsNinth Florid

h Society, 199

A. Candelas, Robotics usin

de-Gabriel, Abile Robots W

ON EDUCA

Gale, L. A. LEGOs´, IEEE T

L. Atorf, R. Scr, and T. Aacal Engineerin

Chiel, H. J.; anmunications of

and Meeden,e 29th SIGCSIGCSE Bulleti

eto Vavassori, Computers &

han, R. Schultedings of the 2

d, J. Kopena, taforms´, IEE

. M. Yunus a Social and B

and Z. Hurak, rnational Contems and Con

ontrol of a LEEE Internati86.

ulos, F. Liarok2011 Third

ens, Greece, 2

ing Education,

RT 121 Fuzzy 2006. er, http://www

012].

ytech.com/ [V

box for 4973bb2b9c8

s As Introducda Artificial In96.

S. T. Puente, ng a virtual an

A. Mandow, J.With LabVIETION, 54, (20

Lowe, V. MeTRANSACTI

chwann, B. Nach, ´MATLAng´, IEEE TRA

nd Drushel, Rf the ACM 42(

, L. 1998. ASE Technical Sn, 341–344. N

i Benitti, Éxp& Education, 5

tz, M. Marda2008 ASEE N

´Mobile RoboEE Robotics an

and N. M. IBehavioral Sci

´Vehicular Pnference on Cntrol, Denver,

eader–Followional Sympos

kapis, Brain-cInternational

011, pp. 140-

Volume 50, Nu

Control: Ball

w.control-syst

Visited on Apr

MATLAB, 17e0e086100

ction to Comntelligence Re

F. Torres, ´Hand remote lab

Fernández-LEW for Unde011), 41-47.

edina, and E. IONS ON EDU

Neumann, R. SAB Meets LEANSACTION

R. F. 1999. Us(6).

A robot laborSymposium o

New York: AC

ploring the ed58 (2012), 97

ani, Úse Of North Midwest

ot Labs: on and Automation

Ishak,´ Robotiences, 15 (20

latooning ExpControl ApplCO, USA. Se

wer Mobile Rosium on Indu

controlled NXl Conference -143.

umber 2 (April

l-on-Beam Us

tems-principle

ril 2012].

http://www1f8 [Visited o

mputer Sciencesearch Sympo

ands-on experboratory´, Com

Lozano, and Aergraduate Co

Beutlich ´GeUCATION, 5

Schnitzler, J. EGO MindstoNS ON EDUC

sing autonomo

ratory for tean Computer S

CM Press.

ducational po8–988.

Lego Nxt MSectional Con

achieving edun Magazine, 1

tic teaching f011), 2528–25

periments withlications (CCptember, 201

obotic Swarmustrial Electron

XT Robot: Teleon Games a

2013), Manche

ser’s Guide, G

es.co.uk/white

w.mathworks.con April 2012

e. In John Hosium (FLAIR

riences of undmputers & Ed

A. J. García-Ceourses on M

eneration NX53, (2010), 80-

Ballé, T. Herorms—A FresCATION, 53,

ous robotics t

aching artificScience Educ

otential of rob

Mindstorms Brnference, 200

ucational and 10(2) (2003) 2

for Malaysian32.

h LEGO MINCA), Part of 1, pp. 28-30.

m Based on thnics (ISIE), 2

e-operating a and Virtual W

ester University

G.U.N.T. Gera

epapers/fuzzy

com/products/2].

H. Stewman, RS), pages 473

dergraduate stducation, 57 (

erezo, IEEE, Mechatronics´,

XT: Building Y-87.

rold, A. Telle,shman Introd(2010), 306-3

to teach scien

cial intelligencation (SIGCS

botics in scho

rick In Engin8.

research goal25-32.

n gifted enric

NDSTORMS N2011 IEEE

he NXT Educa2011 , Rio, G

robot throughWorlds for S

y Press, pp. 15

atebau,

-logic-

/fuzzy-

editor, 3--477.

tudents (2011),

Úsing IEEE

Young

, T. G. duction 317.

ce and

nce. In SE-98),

ools: A

neering

ls with

chment

NXT´, Multi-

ational Greece,

h brain Serious

57-171.

PIn

[Escr


[25] SIEEE/pp. 13 [26] YConfe [27] Confe49-53 [28] Mon thEntert

[29] E

roboti [30] JAutom

riba texto]


S. Brigandi, /ASME Intern35-139.

Y. Kim, Ćonerence on Con

C.G.L. Cao, erence on Tec3.

M.M da Silva,he Lego Mintainment, Man

E. Cuevas, D.

ics´, Internatio

Jan Jantzen, Tumation , (1998

rical Engineeri

J. Field, Y. national Conf

ntrol Systems Lntrol & Autom

E. Danahy, chnologies for

, J.F. de MagadStorms NXTnaus, Brazil, 2

Zaldivar, Pére

onal Journal o

uning Of Fuzz8) Volume: 87

ing Education,

Wang, Á LEference on Ad

Lab using a Lmation, Marrak

Íncreasing r Practical Ro

alhães Netto, T Platform´, 2010, pp.82-8

ez-Cisneros, M

of Electrical E

zy PID Contro71, Issue: 98, P

Volume 50, Nu

EGO Mindstdvanced Intel

LEGO Mindstokech, Morocco

Accessibilityobot Applicati

Án EducationBrazilian Sy

7.

M. ‘Low-cost

Engineering E

ollers, TechniPages: 1-22.

umber 2 (April

orms NXT Blligent Mecha

orms NXT Moo, 2010, pp. 1

y to Medical ions (TePRA)

nal Robotic Gymposium on

commercial L

Education, 47(

ical University

2013), Manche

Based Multiroatronics Montr

otor System´, 73-178.

Robotics Ed), Medford, M

Game for Trann Computer G

Lego™ platfor

(2) (2010), 13

y of Denmark

ester University

obot System´,réal, Canada,

18th Mediterr

ducation´, in MA, USA, 201

nsit Education Games and D

rm for mobile

2-150.

Department o

y Press, pp. 15

, 2010 2010,

ranean

IEEE 11, pp.

Based Digital

e

of

57-171.

lease cite this paper as: international journal of electrical...

Documents