learning strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning...

69
Strategic Teaching + Assessment for Learning + Differen6a6on + Metacogni6on = powerful learning for all students Faye Brownlie, Vancouver, BC, Canada Mehj Datoo, Richmond, BC, Canada Kris6 Johnson, Mission, BC, Canada IRA, Minneapolis, 2009 www.slideshare.net

Upload: faye-brownlie

Post on 21-Dec-2014

3.217 views

Category:

Education


5 download

DESCRIPTION

What are the elements that have the greatest impact on improving student learning for 11-18 years olds? How do they work together? The session presents each of the elements and explains their significance, then gives examples of these elements in humanities, English and social studies classrooms.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Strategic Teaching + Assessment for Learning + Differen6a6on + 

Metacogni6on = powerful learning for all students 

Faye Brownlie, Vancouver, BC, Canada Mehj Datoo, Richmond, BC, Canada Kris6 Johnson, Mission, BC, Canada 

IRA, Minneapolis, 2009 www.slideshare.net  

Page 2: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

•I can iden6fy powerful learning prac6ces for all students 

•I can iden6fy the 6 AFL strategies  •I can begin to make a plan to use a powerful 

literacy prac6ce and an AFL strategy 

Learning Inten6ons 

Page 3: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Powerful Learning 

Engagement & Meaning Making 

Page 4: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

•connect •process 

•personalize &   transform •self‐assess 

Strategic Teaching 

Page 5: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Assessment FOR Learning 

Purpose:    guide instruc6on, improve          learning 

Audience:  teacher and student 

Timing:    at the beginning, day by          day, minute by minute 

Form:      descrip6ve feedback 

Page 6: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Assessment FOR Learning 

Purpose:  guide instruc6on and learning 

•The Grand Event 

•Ongoing in the Class 

Page 7: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Assessment FOR Learning 

•  Descrip6ve scoring •  Coding in teams 

•  Class/grade profile of strengths and areas of need  

•  Ac6on plans developed ‐ what’s next? •  Individual students iden6fied for further assessment 

Page 8: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Standard Reading Assessment 

•  Choose a common piece of text. 

•  Build background for the reading. •  Have students respond to common prompts. 

•  Have students read a short sec6on aloud and answer several interview ques6ons. 

•  Code using the Reading Performance Standards 

•  OR 

•  DART, fall assessment FOR learning 

Page 9: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

•  Connec7ons:  How does what you read connect with what you already knew? 

•  Summarizing:  Choose a way to show the main ideas and details in what you read. 

•  Inferencing:  Read between the lines to find something that you believe to be true, but that isn’t actually said.  Explain your reasoning. 

•  Vocabulary:  Here are 3 challenging words from the text.  Explain what you think they mean. 

•  Reflec7ng:  Was this easy or hard to understand?  How did you help your self understand?       (SD, p.23) 

Page 10: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Moscrop Secondary, Burnaby 

•  Literacy teacher pulled 40/70 students who were iden6fied at risk in fall assessment 

•  1:1 assessment, Standard Reading Assessment 

•  Read text orally •  Looked for paherns 

Page 11: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Moscrop Secondary, Burnaby 

•  Encouraged kids to mark the text •  Predic6ng from 6tle, picture, cap6on – average of 4 seconds 

•  Comprehension – analyzed 3 samples, students ranked by performance standard rubric 

•  Inference – adding your thinking, not summarizing ‐ prac6ced 

Page 12: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

The Class Review 

What are the strengths of the class?

What are your concerns about the class as a whole?

What are your main goals for the class this year?

What are the individual needs in your class?

Page 13: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Class Review Learning in Safe Schools

(Brownlie & King, 2000) 

Teacher: Class:

Classroom Strengths Classroom Needs

Other Socio-Emotional Learning Language Medical

Goals Decisions

Individual Concerns

Class Review Recording Form

Page 14: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

1

From Assessment to Instruction

Brownlie, Feniak, Schnellert, 2006

2

4

3

Assess (against criteria)

Set a Goal (target)

Plan/Teach (with the goal in mind)

Reassess

Page 15: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Bill Juhasz K-7 Tait

Richmond

4-5 formative assessments/year Block out 4-5 weeks in school calendar All non-enrolling teachers & admin co-assess with CT Coding in teams at pro d or in- school collab time

Page 16: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Bill Juhasz K-7 Tait

Richmond

Sept: Class Review Meetings

Optional Jan. class review

One week later: now what meetings

Non-categorical resource model

Page 17: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Bill’s Year at a Glance‐Sept. 

Page 18: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Bill’s Year at a Glance‐Oct. 

Page 19: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Try to differentiate through…

Instructional Considerations

Page 20: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Teach Content to All 

 Learning in Safe Schools - Brownlie, King

Page 21: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Model Guided practice Independent practice Independent application

Pearson & Gallagher (1983) 

Page 22: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Shabash – Ann Walsh 

•  Whole class novel – gr. 6/7 •  Goals:   

– Build community 

– Highlight, acknowledge, respect diversity – Teach double‐entry journals as a strategy for deepening understanding  

– Build and apply criteria for success 

Page 23: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Connecting: – Gallery wall – Quick write Processing: – S6cky notes – Double‐entry journals – Criteria 

Transforming and personalizing: ‐Author’s message 

Page 24: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

The Six Big AFL Strategies 

1.    Inten6ons 2.    Criteria 3.    Descrip6ve feedback 4.    Ques6ons 5.    Self and peer assessment 

6.    Ownership 

Page 25: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Mehjabeen Datoo McMath Secondary, Richmond 

Gr. 8  Humani6es ‐ China 

3 months 

Page 26: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

The Context 

SCHOOL •  1250 students, Grades 8‐12 •  French Immersion and 

English streams 

•  Fully inclusive classrooms 

•  In a suburb south of Vancouver, BC with high ELL popula6on 

CLASS •  27 students •  18 male, 9 female •  Diversity of needs •  6 receiving support  •  2 at risk 

Grade 8 Humani6es class combined English Language Arts and Social Studies 

teacher sees class every day for 75 minutes 

Page 27: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Performance Based Reading Assessment (PBA)

1.  Predicting: What do you think this passage will be about? How do you know?

2. Summarizing : Using a web, words, diagrams, and/or drawings, show that you can identify the key ideas and

details from this passage (use the other side of this page).

3.  Connections : How does what you read connect with what you already know?

5.  Vocabulary : Define each of the following words. Explain how you figured out what they meant. Word Definition How I figured out its meaning a. Manor b. medieval c. Heiress d. commodity e. ancestral

5. Inferring : Read between the lines to find something that you believe to be true, but that isn’t actually

said. Explain your reasoning.

6.  Reflecting: Was this reading easy or hard to understand? How did you help yourself understand? (If

this was easy, what do you do to help yourself understand something more difficult?)

Page 28: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Conference Sheet: Humanities 8

Ask, after reading, the following questions:

7. When you come to a challenging word, how do you figure it out?

Word strategies: _____ reread it _____ sound it out _____ look it up in the dictionary _____ skip it _____ ask someone _____ try and figure out what makes sense in the sentence

Other: ________________________ 

8. If your reading does not make sense, what do you do?

Sense strategies: _____ reread it _____ skip it _____ try another book _____ make a picture in my mind _____ make notes on what I’ve read _____ make a connection between the text, yourself, the world, another text Other: ______________________________ 

9. What was the main idea of the whole passage that you read?

Page 29: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Fully Meets Expectations Exceeds Expectations

The student is able to read information and procedures with

some complexity, specialized language, and graphics (as

described in the chart on page 260). Work is accurate and

complete, providing specific relevant details and examples as

required.

The student is able to read elaborated information and procedures

that include specialized language and graphics, as well as complex

relationships. Work is thorough and may be insightful, providing

well-chosen details and examples as required.

! makes logical predictions about content and structure by

recalling prior knowledge and looking at the text features

(e.g., heading, diagrams)

! anticipates content and structure by recalling prior knowledge and

looking at the text features (e.g., heading, diagrams); shows insight

! uses context clues, word structure, diagrams, and classroom

resources to figure out unfamiliar words or technical terms

! draws on a wide vocabulary; figures out unfamiliar words and

technical terms independently using a variety of strategies

! checks for understanding and adjusts comprehension

strategies to deal with challenging and unfamiliar material;

may need some guidance

! checks for understanding; independently selects from a growing

repertoire of comprehension strategies, making adjustments as

needed; often rereads to clarify

! uses text features (e.g., headings, diagrams) to preview,

support understanding, and locate information

! uses text features (e.g., headings, diagrams) effectively and

efficiently to preview, support understanding, navigate the

selection, and locate information

! responses to comprehension questions or tasks are accurate,

clear and complete

! responses to comprehension questions or tasks are precise and

thorough, and often include insights or interpretations

! accurately restates main ideas in own words

! accurately restates main ideas in own words; may attempt to

synthesize the information

! locates specific, relevant details (including those in

graphics such as illustrations and charts) to respond to

questions or tasks

! locates specific, relevant details (including those in graphics such

as illustrations and charts) as needed; may use quotations and

references as appropriate

! makes accurate notes in appropriate detail using categories

or headings that reflect the main ideas or topics; may

choose an appropriate format (e.g., mind map, outline)

! makes accurate and detailed notes, using effective formats and

categories or headings

! makes some general inferences or interpretations supported

by specific evidence from the text

! makes logical inferences and interpretations supported by specific

evidence from the text

! makes some logical connections between new information

and prior knowledge and beliefs

! makes thoughtful and insightful connections between new

information and prior knowledge and beliefs that may go outside

of the reader’s immediate experiences (e.g., social issues)

! offers simple judgements or evaluations and offers some

reasons

! makes and explains logical judgements or evaluations based on

prior knowledge; provides reasons or examples

Rating Scale: Grade 8 Reading for Information

Student achievement in reading for information by March-April of Grade 8 can generally be described as

shown in this scale.*

Aspect Not Yet Within Expectations Meets Expectations (Minimal Level) Snapshot

Note: the snapshot

can be used alone as

a holistic scale for

marking some

assignments.

The student may need help to read brief,

straightforward information and procedures and to

complete required tasks. May provide limited accurate

information for some direct, concrete tasks. Work is

often vague, incomplete, inaccurate, or irrelevant.

The student is able to read information and

procedures with some complexity, specialized

language, and graphics (as described in the chart on

page 250) with basic understanding. Work is

generally accurate but may be vague or omit some

required detail.

STRATEGIES ! predictions ! has difficulty making logical predictions about

content; may offer illogical guesses

! makes simple logical predictions about content by

recalling prior knowledge and looking at the text

features

! word skills ! tends to rely on sounding out and context to deal

with unfamiliar language; often unsuccessful

! relies on context clues, word structure, and

classroom resources to figure out unfamiliar

words or technical terms; sometimes inefficient

! checks

understanding

! may check for understanding but have limited

repertoire of comprehension strategies; often

quickly frustrated by challenging material; may

give up

! checks for understanding and adjusts

comprehension strategies when needed; may need

specific direction to select appropriate strategies

for unfamiliar types of material

! text features ! may need assistance to use text features (e.g.,

headings, diagrams) to preview or locate

information

! uses text features (e.g., headings, diagrams) to

preview and locate information, but may be

inefficient

COMPREHENSION ! accuracy and

completion

! responses to comprehension questions or tasks are

often inaccurate, vague, or incomplete

! responses to comprehension questions or tasks

are generally accurate, but may be somewhat

vague, with parts incomplete

! main ideas ! may identify some main ideas; often has difficulty

distinguishing between main ideas and supporting

details

! identifies most main ideas; may have difficulty

restating them in own words

! details ! may locate some relevant supporting details

(including those in graphics such as illustrations and

charts); omits important information

! locates some specific details (including those in

graphics such as illustrations and charts) to

respond to questions or tasks

! note-making ! needs a template or given categories to make simple

notes; notes often incomplete or inaccurate

! makes notes using logical categories or headings;

may include too little or too much information

! inferences ! needs specific direction to make simple inferences

and interpretations; may be illogical or unsupported

by evidence from the text

! makes some simple inferences and

interpretations; provides some specific evidence

from the text if prompted

ANALYSIS ! connection to

prior

knowledge

! needs prompting and help to see how new

information connects to prior knowledge or beliefs

! makes simple, obvious comparisons of new

information with prior knowledge and beliefs

! evaluation/

reflections

! offers simple reactions or judgements; may be

vague or unsupported (or may offer no reaction)

! offers simple reaction or judgements; may be able

to give some reasons (may be illogical)

* Student performance that falls within the wide range of expectations for Grade 8 by March-April generally matches the “Purposeful”

description in Evaluating Reading Across Curriculum.

! Saanich additions as per grades 6/7 Performance Standards for Middle School Consistency

Scoring Rubric: Reading for Informa6on (Gr. 8 ) 

Page 30: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Data (Ac6vity) Male

Female

COMPREHENSIONGrade 8

Assessment: Fall 07Group: Male/Female Category: All Class: Humanities DG

Accuracy andCompletion

Not Yet Meets

Not Yet Meet /Meets

Meets

Fully Meets

Fully Meets/Exceeds

Meets/Fully Meets

Exceeds

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

6

22

1744

1711

2233

11

6

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

M F

15

26

15

26

4

4

4

ALL

Main Ideas Not Yet Meets

Not Yet Meet /Meets

Meets

Fully Meets

Fully Meets/Exceeds

Meets/Fully Meets

Exceeds

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

22

17

656

2833

17

11

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

M F

11

22

30

11

4

15

ALL

Details Not Yet Meets

Not Yet Meet /Meets

Meets

Fully Meets

Fully Meets/Exceeds

Meets/Fully Meets

Exceeds

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

39

1122

1767

22

11

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

M F

15

33

15

4

26

ALL

Note-making Not Yet Meets

Not Yet Meet /Meets

Meets

Fully Meets

Fully Meets/Exceeds

Meets/Fully Meets

Exceeds

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

44

11

2256

611

1711

11

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

M F

4

33

7

15

4

30

ALL

Inferences Not Yet Meets

Not Yet Meet /Meets

Meets

Fully Meets

Fully Meets/Exceeds

Meets/Fully Meets

Exceeds

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

2222

17

3322

1144

6

11

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

M F

11

30

22

4

4

22

ALL

11/6/2007 Robert Alexander McMath Secondary

Female9Male18Student Total = 27

1.  Look over the data 2.  What do you no6ce? 3.  What are the 

strengths of this class? 

4.  What areas can be worked on as a class? 

What are some instruc6onal goals that you could set based on what you learn from the data and also taking 

into considera6on the aims of the content area? 

Page 31: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Instruc6onal Goals 

•  Social Studies content  –  Development and decline of civilisa6ons –  How geography influences civilisa6on – World religions 

•  Thinking Strategies –  Note‐making  

•  Dis6nguishing Main Idea and Detail –  Visualisa6on 

•  Note‐making 

•  Paragraph wri6ng 

Page 32: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

September‐October Visualisa6on with Novels 

1.  Teacher reads a shared text aloud, models strategy of recording images that come to mind as she reads 

2.  Teacher con6nues to read aloud the shared text, students read novels in groups and record the images they see as they read in their journals 

3.  Teacher provides feedback on images (do they iden6fy a main idea? Are they symbolic? 

Page 33: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

October‐November Visualisa6on with Myth and Non‐fic6on 

1.  Students read a crea6on myth from China and record images summarizing the main ideas in the margins 

2.  As students con6nue to learn about Chinese beliefs, they con6nue to use this strategy to make sense of abstract concepts in non‐fic6on text 

Page 34: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Pangu and the

Creation of the World

!

"#! $%&! '&()##)#(! $%&*&! +,-! .,*/#&--! &0&*1+%&*&2! ,#.!

3%,4-!*56&.7!8,#(57!!9)$%)#!$%&!.,*/#&--!$%&*&!:4*;&.!,#!

&((2! ,#.! )#-).&! $%&! &((! $%&! (),#$! 8,#(5! <,;&! )#$4! '&)#(7!

=4*! ,&4#-2! -,:&61! )#-).&! $%&! &((2! 8,#(5! -6&>$! ,#.! (*&+7!

9%&#!%&!%,.!(*4+#!$4!()(,#$)<!-)?&!%&!-$*&$<%&.!%)-!%5(&!

6);'-!,#.! )#! -4!.4)#(!'*4/&! $%&!&((7!@%&! 6)(%$&*!>,*$-!4:!

$%&! &((! :64,$&.! 5>+,*.-! $4! :4*;! $%&! %&,0&#-! ,#.! $%&!

.&#-&*!>,*$-! -,#/!.4+#+,*.-2! $4!'&<4;&! $%&! &,*$%7!A#.!

-4!+,-!:4*;&.!&,*$%!,#.!-/12!B)#!,#.!B,#(7!

8,#(5!-,+!+%,$!%,.!%,>>&#&.!,#.!%&!+,-!>6&,-&.7!C5$!%&!

:&,*&.! $%,$! %&,0&#! ,#.! &,*$%!;)(%$!;&6.! $4(&$%&*! ,(,)#2!

-4! %&! >6,<&.! %);-&6:! '&$+&&#! $%&;2! %)-! %&,.! %46.)#(! 5>!

$%&! -/1! ,#.! %)-! :&&$! :)*;61! 5>4#! $%&! &,*$%7! 8,#(5!

<4#$)#5&.! $4! (*4+! ,$! ,! *,$&! 4:! $&#! :&&$! ,! .,1! :4*! DE2FFF!

1&,*-2! -4! )#<*&,-)#(! $%&! .)-$,#<&! '&$+&&#! %&,0&#! ,#.!

&,*$%2! 5#$)6! $%&1! -&&;&.! :)G&.! ,#.! -&<5*&2! HF2FFF! ;)6&-!

,>,*$7!I4+!&G%,5-$&.2!8,#(5!+&#$!',</!$4!-6&&>!,#.!#&0&*!

+4/&!5>7!

8,#(5!.)&.2!,#.!%)-!'4.1!+&#$!$4!;,/&!$%&!+4*6.!,#.!,66!

)$-! &6&;&#$-7!@%&!+)#.!,#.!<645.-!+&*&! :4*;&.! :*4;!%)-!

'*&,$%2! %)-! 04)<&! +,-! $%5#.&*! ,#.! 6)(%$#)#(2! %)-! &1&-!

'&<,;&! $%&!-5#!,#.!;44#2!%)-!,*;-!,#.!%)-! 6&(-!'&<,;&!

$%&! :45*!.)*&<$)4#-!4:! $%&! <4;>,--!,#.!%)-! $*5#/!'&<,;&!

$%&!;45#$,)#-7!J)-!:6&-%!$5*#&.!)#$4!$%&!-4)6!,#.!$%&!$*&&-!

$%,$!(*4+!4#!)$2!%)-!'644.!)#$4!$%&!*)0&*-!$%,$!:64+!,#.!%)-!

0&)#-! )#$4! >,$%-! ;&#! $*,0&67! J)-! '4.1! %,)*! '&<,;&! $%&!

(*,--! ,#.! %&*'-2! ,#.! %)-! -/)#! $%&! -,;&2! +%)6&! >*&<)45-!

-$4#&-! ,#.! ;)#&*,6-! +&*&! :4*;&.! :*4;! %)-! '4#&-! ,#.!

$&&$%7!J)-!-+&,$!'&<,;&!$%&!.&+!,#.!$%&!%,)*!4:!%)-!%&,.!

'&<,;&!$%&!-$,*-! $%,$! $*,)6! $%*45(%45$!%&,0&#7!A-! :4*! $%&!

>,*,-)$&-! 4#! %)-! '4.12! $%&-&! '&<,;&! $%&! .)0&*-! *,<&-! 4:!

%5;,#/)#.7!

!

K45*<&L!!%$$>LMM+++76)0)#(;1$%-7<4;M3%)#&-&7%$;!

Page 35: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

September – October Note‐making using fic6on 

1.  Students take notes on “Character” as they are reading their novels. 

2.  Teacher models the note‐taking on post‐its with a shared “read‐aloud” text, students prac6ce independently as they read their novels, receiving constant feedback. 

3.  The class also watches a movie and takes notes on character.  Together, led by the teacher, the class creates a mind‐map on the character in the movie. 

4.  When they complete the novel, they make a mind‐map about their character using the informa6on from their post‐its. 

Page 36: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Class‐created mind‐map on character 

Page 37: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

October‐November Note‐making using non‐fic6on 

1.  Class develops a generic mind‐map on aspects of civiliza6on 

2.  Teacher models the note‐taking using the informa6on text on the Shang dynasty and with a think‐aloud. 

3.  The class par6cipates in this crea6on of a mind‐map and then students create their own on the Zhou Dynasty. 

Page 38: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Civilisa6on 

Govern‐ment 

People 

Arts/Culture 

Beliefs 

Tech‐nology 

Transpor‐ta6on 

Page 39: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

October‐November Note‐taking using non‐fic6on 

Read pages 80 and 82 and take notes on the mind-map below:

What did the Zhou say about the Shang?_______________________________________

Zhou Dynasty

_______________

Govern-

ment

People

Beliefs

Arts/

Culture

Upper Class

Lower Class

Read pages 77-80 and take notes on the mind-map below:

Shang

Dynasty

_______________

Govern-

ment

People

Beliefs

Arts/

Culture

Upper Class

Lower Class

How were the Shang Kings

defeated?__________________________________________________________________

__

•  Turn to a person beside and discuss what you see as important and/or interes6ng in this process? 

Page 40: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Test!!! 

Page 41: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Datoo – Hum 8 China Test

Part C: Comparing Dynasties

15. Fill out the table below on the Shang and Zhou Dynasties:

SHANG ZHOU

Government (2 marks)(write at least 2 points per

column)

People (2 marks)(write at least 2 points per

column)

Arts/Culture/Technology

(4 marks)(write at least 2 points per

column)

16. Transfer the above information into the VENN diagram below (3 marks)

Shang Zhou

Both

Page 42: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

November‐December Note‐taking using non‐fic6on 

1.  Class con6nues to take notes on Chinese dynas6es using the aspects of civilisa6on – focusing on how each one develops from the other 

2.  Teacher models the note‐taking using a table format by transferring informa6on from the Shang and Zhou and then adding in the informa6on on Government and Beliefs, then the class con6nues to take notes on each following dynasty on the remaining aspects of civilisa6on 

Page 43: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

ZHOU DYNASTY Shang Zhou Qin Han Sui

Religion

Shang-ti Many gods

Ancestor Worship

Tien Many gods Ancestor Worship

Mandate of Heaven Taoism

Confucianism Legalism

Govern-ment

Feudal land

divided into

regions and ruled by nobles

Feudal land divided into regions and ruled by

nobles

Page 44: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

QIN DYNASTY Shang Zhou Qin Han Sui

Religion

Shang-ti Many gods

Ancestor Worship

Tien Many gods Ancestor Worship

Mandate of Heaven Taoism

Confucianism Legalism

Tien Many gods

Ancestor Worship Mandate of

Heaven Taoism

Confucianism Legalism

Govern-ment

Feudal land

divided into

regions and ruled by nobles

Feudal land divided into regions and ruled by

nobles

land divided in to regions and ruled

by officials appointed by

emperor

Legalism

Page 45: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

HAN DYNASTY Shang  Zhou  Qin  Han  Sui 

Religion 

Shang‐6 Many gods  Ancestor Worship 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism Buddhism 

Govern‐ment 

Feudal land divided into regions and ruled by nobles 

Feudal land divided into regions and ruled by nobles 

land divided in to regions and ruled by officials appointed by emperor 

Legalism 

become an official based on “MERIT” by wri6ng exams 

Page 46: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

SUI DYNASTY Shang  Zhou  Qin  Han  Sui 

Religion 

Shang‐6 Many gods  Ancestor Worship 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism Buddhism 

Tien Many gods  Ancestor Worship Mandate of Heaven Taoism Confucianism Legalism Buddhism 

Govern‐ment 

Feudal land divided into regions and ruled by nobles 

Feudal land divided into regions and ruled by nobles 

land divided in to regions and ruled by officials appointed by emperor 

Legalism 

become an official based on “MERIT” by wri6ng exams 

con6nued exam system of Han 

Page 47: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

November‐December Note‐taking using non‐fic6on 

1.  Class con6nues to take notes on Chinese dynas6es using the aspects of civilisa6on – focusing on how each one develops from the other 

2.  Teacher models the note‐taking using a table format by transferring informa6on from the Shang and Zhou and then adding in the informa6on on Government and beliefs, then the class con6nues to take notes on each following dynasty on the remaining aspects of civilisa6on 

3.  This process is repeated for following unit in January‐February. 

4.  By March, students are quite proficient at note‐making (using images, mind‐maps, tables, etc.) and are beginning to show evidence of deep inference and synthesis as they note‐make.  They are selec6ng their own categories and using mul6ple texts. 

Page 48: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Paragraph wri6ng 

1.  Teacher models paragraph wri6ng using content (Chinese beliefs) 

2.  Students prac6ce with a second paragraph 3.  Students receive feedback from teacher and 

peers and set a goal for the next paragraph – using specific criteria 

Page 49: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Paragraph sample 

Consider the paragraph in your package.  With reference to the criteria on the rubric, provide the following feedback to the student: 

1. What is working (what he/she did well) 2. What is not working (what needs to be improved) and how 

it can be improved 

Page 50: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 51: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Paragraph wri6ng 

1.  Teacher models paragraph wri6ng using content (Chinese beliefs) 

2.  Students prac6ce with a second paragraph 3.  Students receive feedback from teacher and peers 

and set a goal for the next paragraph 4.  Students con6nue to write incorpora6ng feedback 

and goals, receive more feedback and set new goals 5.  Students are summa6vely assessed on one final 

paragraph  6.  Students have to do one paragraph on demand on the 

China test  

Page 52: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Test!!! 

Datoo – Hum 8 China Test

Part E: Paragraph Writing (5 marks)

Choose ONE of the topics below and write a PARAGRAPH on it. Make sure you have a

topic sentence, at least three points and a concluding sentence.

Explain in detail ONE of the beliefs from the Shang and Zhou Dynasties (Mandate of

Heaven, Ancestor Worship or Confucianism).

What did you think was the most interesting thing that we learned about in this unit so far?

Explain what it is and why it is interesting.

Page 53: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 54: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Kris6 Johnson & Tracey Snipstead Heritage Park Secondary, Mission 

Gr. 8  ‐ Middle Ages 

5‐7 classes of co‐teaching 

Page 55: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Day 1‐ teacher 

•  Give students ‘I statements’ for library and content targets 

•  Give students research ques6on 

Page 56: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 57: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Day 2 ‐ teacher 

•  Same big ques6on (goal) •  Choose learning targets for the day •  Access prior knowledge (facts remembered) •  Individually ask 3 ques6ons and take notes •  Reflect on accomplishments •  Meet as a class to check off learning targets 

that have been accomplished 

Page 58: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Day 3 ‐ teacher 

•  Same process as day 2 

•  Conference with students, highligh6ng in colour, areas of targets that students needs to work on 

•  Use different colour highlighter each day  

Page 59: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Teacher Reflec6ons Students more focused in the library 

Students more able to take effec6ve notes 

Students crea6ng best projects ever! 

Tweaking an exis6ng structure with very posi6ve learning results Next challenge:  move from criteria to rubrics 

Page 60: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 61: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 62: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 63: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 64: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 65: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 66: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 67: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 68: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all
Page 69: Learning Strategies + assessment for learning + differentiation + metacognition = powerful learning for all

Resources •  Learning in Safe Schools – Brownlie & King •  Student Diversity, 2nd ed – Brownlie, Feniak, Schnellert Stenhouse/Pembroke •  Assesssment and Instruc6on of ESL Learners – Brownlie, Feniak, McCarthy •  Grand Conversa6on, Thoughwul Responses – a unique approach to 

literature circles – Brownlie •  It’s All about Thinking – Humani6es & English Language Arts – Brownlie, 

Schnellert (in press, fall, 2009) Portage and Main Press •  Reading and Responding – grades 4,5,&6 – Brownlie, Jeroski Nelson Canada •  Adolescent Literacy – Field Tested – Parris, Fisher, Headley, ed. “Finding out what we need to know” – Brownlie IRA