kilometers 0 30 60 90 12015 mapping seawall beach to model...

1
S eawall Beach is located in Phippsburg, Maine. It has two rivers on each side; the Sprague River on the west side and the Morse River on the east side, separating it from Popham Beach State Park. It is part of the Bates Morse Mountain Conservation area, managed by Bates College and owned by the St. John family. It is a unique place to study because it is the last large undeveloped sand beach in Maine. It is almost two miles long and has been studied by many Bates College geology students and Professor Mike Retelle. It is a special opportunity for Bates students to study an important location directly related to climate change. It is significant because Maine has unique beach systems. They are often protected by bedrock on either side and are referred to as ‘pocket’ beaches. The result is that their processes are more complicated than just long-shore transport and very important to understand for beaches with and without development. Beaches are a dynamic environment that consistently change with seasons, weather and sea level. Seawall Beach is important to study in order to; understand how Maine beach systems work in their natural state, how developed Maine beaches currently behave, and what to expect with a rising sea level. My research at Seawall Beach can be broken down into three categories: recording seasonal changes from summer to winter, detailed mapping of the current beach features, and modeling the beach in the future using ArcGIS. My research began in June ‘08, supported by the Hughes Summer Fellowship, and will continue through May ‘09, as my geology senior thesis project. Seasonal Changes Mapping the Present Modeling the Future Mapping Seawall Beach to Model the Future Phippsburg, Maine 2008 T he beach system changes from summer to winter profiles. Sand bars move up against the beach during the summer months by gentle wave action, and severe winter storms scarp the beach and move the sand bars back out. These off shore bars cause violent waves to break further from shore to protect the beach, then the cycle begins again. T he method for monitoring the beach’s profile requires comparing the relative elevation changes on specific transects throughout the beach. Profiles show the elevation from the dune ridge to low tide. ³ B eginning in July, Emily Chandler ’09, and I took profiles of five transects spread throughout Seawall Beach. The five transects are meant to capture the different areas of the beach system to compare how they are changing through the seasons as well as relative to one another. ‘Pocket’ Beach, image from FitzGerald et al., 1989. Longshore transport distributes sand along beach, image from Marshak 2004. T he mapping of Seawall Beach is done using a high-resolution Trimble GPS unit, which is accurate to within 0-30cm. The GPS is used to map these features of the beach: • Dune line • High tide • Low tide • Sprague River • Morse River • Sand bars in the mouth of the Morse River • Berm The reason all these features are mapped is that they are part of the changing dynamic beach system. Their locations migrate with seasonal and climatic changes. Creating an accurate snap shot of the beach system now will benefit future studies to compare how the beach has changed even within one year’s time. The present data are also incorporated in models of the beach in the future. Photo from DeLorme Photo from Chandler 2008 Photo from Oliver Utne 2006 Photo from Utne 2006 E ach transect is graphed in Excel to show change in the beach profile through time. The three examples shown represent different parts of the beach system and how the transects respond to seasonal processes. All three transects show net accretion from July to August and the progression of sand bars landward. Photo from Retelle 2008 Legend 2004 mean sea level LIDAR2004 elevation <m> -2.07 - 0.28 0.29 - 0.32 0.33 - 0.35 0.36 - 0.37 0.38 - 0.43 0.44 - 7 7.01 - 17 17.01 - 35 35.01 - 64.36 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0.25 Kilometers ³ map scale 1:15,000 I n the IPCC’s most recent assessment report in 2007 the projected global sea level rise (SLR) by the year 2100 ranges between 0.28-0.43m. These values are found from different carbon emissions scenarios and the resulting average global temperature increase. The IPCC’s estimates for SLR are highly debated considering the values are based on thermal expansion, and general estimations for ice melting. Recent research on the kinematics of ice sheets suggest a 2m rise is a realistic maximum for 2100 (Pfeffer et al. 2008). In order to create a computer model I will calculate various scenarios of SLR and project where and how fast the beach features will transgress landward. The image below shows the IPCC’s SLR estimates for 2100 with 2004 LIDAR data on a 2001 aerial photo. T he computer model will be created using ArcGIS and a series of equations and scenarios. In the model I will use between 0.3-2.0m of SLR by 2100. This will not only produce various amounts of SLR rise, but varying rates of rise, which will estimate how fast the beach can adapt and transgress, or if it will flood. The areas of the beach will be turned into polygons and have a value for erosion to estimate how wave action will change the shape of the beach and the course of the river channels. A severe storm buffer will be added based on past damage from the 1978, 1991, and 2007 storms to the beach. Legend Sand Bars 08/27/08 lowtide sandbarcrest Sand Bars 07/29/08 lowtide sandbarcrest Sand Bars 07/02/08 berm lowtide sandbarcrest Beach Features 07/14/08 dune hightide morseriver Beach Features 06/24/08 bedrock dune inlandextent lowtide seawall spragueriver 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0.25 Kilometers ³ Legend Sand Bars 08/27/08 lowtide sandbarcrest Sand Bars 07/29/08 lowtide sandbarcrest Sand Bars 07/02/08 berm lowtide sandbarcrest Beach Features 07/14/08 dune hightide morseriver Image from the IPCC 2007 AR4 Photo from Chandler 2008 map scale 1:14,000 map scale 1:7,000 J une through August the Trimble GPS was used to map the features of Seawall Beach. The image above shows the location of all the features in 2008, overlayed on a satellite image from 2001. The rivers and sand bars migrate the most and need to be mapped at least every year. T he east side of the beach has had dramatic changes in the last year with the movement of the Morse River and sand bars. The sand bar crests were mapped every four weeks to show their movement. 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 0.125 Kilometers Profile Stakes W1,5,11,15 E1 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0.25 Kilometers map scale 1:13,841 0 30 60 90 120 15 Kilometers Seawall Beach features mapped June -August ‘08 by Dana Oster ‘09 SPECIAL THANKS TO: Mike Retelle Hughes Summer Fellowship Emily Chandler Laura Sewall Imaging & Computing Center Steve Dickson (MGS) Pete Slovinsky (MGS) St. John Family Megan Arnold The Chandler Family Bates Student Research Fund SOURCES: -IPCC -FitzGerald et. al 1989, 2000, 2002 -NOAA -The Seawall Beach Project -Marshak 2004 -Pfeffer et al. 2008 -Kelley et al. 1993 -Buynevich et al. 2000 -Fenster et al. 2001 -Cohen, E.S., unpublished 2003 -Jones, M.G., unpublished 2000 -Cary, C.L., unpublished 2005 -Davis, 1985 E1 -9 -7 -5 -3 -1 1 3 5 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 distance (m) elevation (m) 17-Jul-08 5-Aug-08 14-Aug-08 21-Sep-08 W11 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 distance (m) elevation (m) 10-Jul 31-Jul 15-Aug 21-Sep-08 W15 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 0 50 100 150 200 250 distance (m) elevation (m) 16-Jul-08 31-Jul-08 15-Aug-08 21-Sep-08 ` P rojecting how Seawall Beach will respond to SLR can help predict the impacts SLR will have on developed Maine beaches. The SW end of Seawall Beach is an important part of the Small Point community with many homes near the beach. The spit has a low elevation and is below the high tide line, and it will be permanently lost by 2100. Sprague River channel Dune line Sprague River channel Trimble GPS The elevation of the SW spit is lower than the high tide line and reflects that area’s vulnerability to SLR and storm surges. Images to the left; taken from a time lapse camera located at the Southwestern point of Seawall Beach looking Northeast. SW Seawall Beach at high tide 08/02/08 08/02/08 SW Seawall Beach at low tide.

Upload: others

Post on 17-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Seawall Beach is located in Phippsburg, Maine. It has two rivers on each side; the Sprague River on the west side and the Morse River on the east side, separating it from Popham Beach State Park. It is part of the Bates Morse Mountain Conservation area, managed by Bates College and owned by the St. John family. It is a unique place to study because it is the last large undeveloped sand beach in Maine. It is almost two miles long and has been studied by many Bates College geology students and Professor Mike Retelle. It is a special opportunity for Bates students to study an important location directly related to climate change.

    It is significant because Maine has unique beach systems. They are often protected by bedrock on either side and are referred to as ‘pocket’ beaches. The result is that their processes are more complicated than just long-shore transport and very important to understand for beaches with and without development. Beaches are a dynamic environment that consistently change with seasons, weather and sea level. Seawall Beach is important to study in order to; understand how Maine beach systems work in their natural state, how developed Maine beaches currently behave, and what to expect with a rising sea level.

    My research at Seawall Beach can be broken down into three categories: recording seasonal changes from summer to winter, detailed mapping of the current beach features, and modeling the beach in the future using ArcGIS. My research began in June ‘08, supported by the Hughes Summer Fellowship, and will continue through May ‘09, as my geology senior thesis project.

    Seasonal Changes Mapping the Present Modeling the Future

    Mapping Seawall Beach to Model the FuturePhippsburg, Maine 2008

    The beach system changes from summer to winter profiles. Sand bars move up against the beach during the summer months by gentle wave action, and severe winter storms scarp the

    beach and move the sand bars back out. These off shore bars cause violent waves to break further from shore to protect the beach, then the cycle begins again.

    The method for monitoring the beach’s profile requires comparing the relative elevation changes on specific transects throughout the beach. Profiles show the elevation from the dune ridge to low tide.

    ³

    Beginning in July, Emily Chandler ’09, and I took profiles of five transects spread throughout Seawall Beach. The five transects are meant to capture the different areas of the beach system to compare how they are changing through the seasons as well as relative to one another.

    ‘Pocket’ Beach, image from FitzGerald et al., 1989.Longshore transport distributes sand along beach, image from Marshak 2004.

    The mapping of Seawall Beach is done using a high-resolution Trimble GPS unit, which is accurate to within 0-30cm. The GPS is used to map these features of the beach:

    • Dune line• High tide• Low tide• Sprague River• Morse River• Sand bars in the mouth of the Morse River• Berm

    The reason all these features are mapped is that they are part of the changing dynamic beach system. Their locations migrate with seasonal and climatic changes. Creating an accurate snap shot of the beach system now will benefit future studies to compare how the beach has changed even within one year’s time. The present data are also incorporated in models of the beach in the future.

    Photo from DeLorme

    Photo from Chandler 2008 Photo from Oliver Utne 2006

    Photo from Utne 2006

    Each transect is graphed in Excel to show change in the beach profile through time. The three examples shown represent different parts of the beach system and how the transects respond to seasonal processes. All three transects show net accretion from July to August and the progression of sand bars landward.

    Photo from Retelle 2008

    Legend2004 mean sea level

    LIDAR2004elevation

    -2.07 - 0.28

    0.29 - 0.32

    0.33 - 0.35

    0.36 - 0.37

    0.38 - 0.43

    0.44 - 7

    7.01 - 17

    17.01 - 35

    35.01 - 64.360 0.5 1 1.5 20.25

    Kilometers

    ³

    map scale 1:15,000

    In the IPCC’s most recent assessment report in 2007 the projected global sea level rise (SLR) by the year 2100 ranges between 0.28-0.43m. These values are found from different carbon emissions scenarios and the resulting average global temperature increase. The IPCC’s estimates for SLR are highly debated considering the values are based on thermal expansion, and general estimations for ice melting. Recent research on the kinematics of ice sheets suggest a 2m rise is a realistic maximum for 2100 (Pfeffer et al. 2008). In order to create a computer model I will calculate various scenarios of SLR and project where and how fast the beach features will transgress landward. The image below shows the IPCC’s SLR estimates for 2100 with 2004 LIDAR data on a 2001 aerial photo.

    The computer model will be created using ArcGIS and a series of equations and scenarios. In the model I will use between 0.3-2.0m of SLR by 2100. This will not only produce various amounts of SLR rise, but varying rates of rise, which will estimate how fast the beach can adapt and transgress, or if it will flood. The areas of the beach will be turned into polygons and have a value for erosion to estimate how wave action will change the shape of the beach and the course of the river channels. A severe storm buffer will be added based on past damage from the 1978, 1991, and 2007 storms to the beach.

    LegendSand Bars 08/27/08

    lowtide

    sandbarcrest

    Sand Bars 07/29/08

    lowtide

    sandbarcrest

    Sand Bars 07/02/08

    berm

    lowtide

    sandbarcrest

    Beach Features 07/14/08

    dune

    hightide

    morseriver

    Beach Features 06/24/08

    bedrock

    dune

    inlandextent

    lowtide

    seawall

    spragueriver

    0 0.5 1 1.5 20.25Kilometers

    ³Legend

    Sand Bars 08/27/08

    lowtide

    sandbarcrest

    Sand Bars 07/29/08

    lowtide

    sandbarcrest

    Sand Bars 07/02/08

    berm

    lowtide

    sandbarcrest

    Beach Features 07/14/08

    dune

    hightide

    morseriver

    Image from the IPCC 2007 AR4

    Photo from Chandler 2008

    map scale 1:14,000

    map scale 1:7,000

    June through August the Trimble GPS was used to map the features of Seawall Beach. The image above shows the location of all the features in 2008, overlayed on a satellite image from 2001. The rivers and sand bars migrate the most and need to be mapped at least every year.

    The east side of the beach has had dramatic changes in the last year with the movement of the Morse River and sand bars. The sand bar crests were mapped every four weeks to show their movement.

    0 0.25 0.5 0.75 10.125Kilometers

    Profile StakesW1,5,11,15

    E10 0.5 1 1.5 20.25 Kilometers

    map scale 1:13,841

    0 30 60 90 12015Kilometers

    Seawall Beach features mapped June -August ‘08

    by Dana Oster ‘09

    Special ThankS To:

    Mike RetelleHughes Summer Fellowship

    Emily ChandlerLaura Sewall

    Imaging & Computing CenterSteve Dickson (MGS)Pete Slovinsky (MGS)

    St. John FamilyMegan Arnold

    The Chandler FamilyBates Student Research Fund

    SourceS:

    -IPCC-FitzGerald et. al 1989, 2000, 2002-NOAA-The Seawall Beach Project-Marshak 2004-Pfeffer et al. 2008-Kelley et al. 1993-Buynevich et al. 2000-Fenster et al. 2001-Cohen, E.S., unpublished 2003-Jones, M.G., unpublished 2000-Cary, C.L., unpublished 2005-Davis, 1985

    E1

    -9

    -7

    -5

    -3

    -1

    1

    3

    5

    0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140

    distance (m)

    elev

    atio

    n (m

    )

    17-Jul-085-Aug-0814-Aug-0821-Sep-08

    W11

    -6

    -5

    -4

    -3

    -2

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160

    distance (m)

    eleva

    tion

    (m)

    10-Jul31-Jul15-Aug21-Sep-08

    W15

    -5

    -4

    -3

    -2

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    0 50 100 150 200 250

    distance (m)

    elev

    atio

    n (m

    )

    16-Jul-0831-Jul-0815-Aug-0821-Sep-08

    `

    Projecting how Seawall Beach will respond to SLR can help predict the impacts SLR will have on developed Maine beaches. The SW end of Seawall Beach is an important part of the Small Point community with many homes near the beach. The spit has a low elevation and is below the high tide line, and it will be permanently lost by 2100.

    Sprague River channel

    Dune line

    Sprague River channel

    Trimble GPS

    The elevation of the SW spit is lower than the high tide line and reflects that area’s vulnerability to SLR and storm surges.

    Images to the left; taken from a time lapse camera located at the Southwestern point of Seawall Beach looking Northeast. SW Seawall Beach at high tide

    08/02/0808/02/08

    SW Seawall Beach at low tide.