joint stock company (identification code: 404476205) · 2019. 11. 4. · “evex hospitals“...
TRANSCRIPT
-
1
ProspectusProspectus
Joint Stock Company
“Evex Hospitals“
(Identification Code: 404476205)
Preliminary Prospectus
GEL 50,000,000 (fifty million) Bonds with floating interest (coupon) rate. The Bonds mature in 5 years from the date
of their issue and placement. The issuer has an option to redeem bonds completely (but not partially) at any “date of
option to redemption”. (For details please refer to “Terms and conditions of the Bonds” subchapter 6 “Redemption and
Purchase”) The nominal value of each Bond is GEL 100,000 (one hundred thousand). Issue price: 100% of the nominal
value. Interest on the Bonds is payable quarterly in arrears at the rate of 310 basis points premium over the National
Bank of Georgia (the “NBG”) Monetary Policy (refinancing) Rate published on the following website:
https://www.nbg.gov.ge/index.php?m=554&lng=eng. In case any “Rating Agency” decreases Evex Hospitals’ rating
below B+ (“Base Rating”), the coupon rate shall increase by 25 basis points. (For details please refer to “Terms and
conditions of the Bonds” subchapter 5 “Interest”) The additional basis points on the refinancing rate will be determined
from book building and will be reflected in the final Prospectus.
The Bonds constitute unsecured and unsubordinated obligations of the Company
JSC “Evex Hospitals” (hereafter the “Company” or “Evex Hospitals” or the “Issuer”) accepts responsibility for the
information contained in this Prospectus. To the best of the knowledge and belief of the Company (which has taken all
reasonable care to ensure that such is the case), the information contained in this Prospectus is in accordance with the
facts and does not omit anything likely to significantly affect the accuracy and completeness of such information. In
addition, attached prospectus (the “Prospectus”) contains all the material information known to the Company and there
has not been intentionally omitted information, which could affect the content of the prospect.
Approval of this Prospectus by the National Bank of Georgia relates to its form only and may not be viewed as a
conclusion on the accuracy of the content of the Prospectus or value of the investment described herein.
Persons responsible for preparation of the document:
CEO Giorgi Mindiashvili
CFO Giorgi Lominadze
https://www.nbg.gov.ge/index.php?m=554&lng=eng
-
2
Signed on behalf of JSC Evex Hospitals:
Signatory:
Name, surname:
Position:
signature:
Date:
Signatory:
Name, surname:
Position:
signature:
Date:
Signed on behalf of JSC Galt and Taggart:
Signatory:
Name, surname: Otar Sharikadze
Position: Managing Director
signature:
Date:
-
3
IMPORTANT INFORMATION FOR THE INVESTORS:
Prospective investor must read the following disclaimer before continuing. The following disclaimer applies to the
attached prospectus (the "Prospectus") and prospective investor is therefore advised to read this carefully before
reading, accessing or making any other use of the attached Prospectus. By accessing and using the Prospectus (including
for investment purposes), prospective investor agrees to be bound by the following terms and conditions (modified from
time to time). If the prospective investor receives the Prospectus via electronic means, he acknowledges that this
electronic transmission (with attached Prospectus) is confidential and intended only for him. Therefore the investor
agrees that he will not forward, reproduce or publish this electronic transmission or the attached Prospectus to any other
person.
Responsible body for approval of this Prospectus:
National Bank of Georgia - Address. Sanapiro str. N2, Tbilisi 0114, Georgia, Tel: 2 406 406. E-mail:
[email protected]. Website: www.nbg.gov.ge
Limitation of the liability:
Approval of this Prospectus by the National Bank of Georgia relates to its form only and may not be viewed as a
conclusion on the accuracy of the content of the Prospectus or value of the investment described herein.
Further, to the fullest extent permitted by applicable law, no person (including without limitation the Placement Agent,
the Calculation and Paying Agent, the Registrar, other advisers to the Company, nor any of their affiliates, directors,
advisers or agents), other than the Issuer, accepts any responsibility whatsoever for the contents of this Prospectus, the
accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this Prospectus or for any other statement, made or purported
to be made by any of them or on its/their behalf in connection with the Company or the issue and offering of the securities
described herein. Placement Agent and the advisers to the Company accordingly disclaim all and any liability they might
otherwise have in respect of this Prospectus or any such statement.
Placement Agent is acting exclusively for the Issuer and no one else in connection with the offer. It will not regard any
other person (whether or not a recipient of this Prospectus) as its client in relation to the offer. Therefore, the Placement
Agent will not be responsible to anyone other than the Company for providing services or for giving advice in relation
to the offer or any transaction or arrangement referred to herein.
This Prospectus does not constitute and may not be used for the purposes of an offer in any jurisdiction in which such
offer is not authorized or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such an offer. No action is being taken to permit
an offering of the Bonds described in this Prospectus or the distribution of this Prospectus (or any other offering
materials relating to the Bonds) in any jurisdiction (other than Georgia).
The investor’s representation: The attached Prospectus is delivered to the prospective investor at his request and on
the basis that the investor has confirmed to JSC Galt & Taggart (Identification Code 211359206), Address: 79 D.
Agmashenebeli Avenue, Tbilisi 0179, Georgia, Tel: (995 32) 2444-132 (995 32) 24401-111; email: [email protected] (the
"Placement Agent") and the Issuer that the investor (i) is located outside United States and is not a US person (as
defined in Regulation S under the United States Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or (ii) the investor is authorized
to acquire the Notes in compliance with all the applicable law and regulation and the terms and conditions of this
Prospectus, or (iii) is a person into whose possession this Prospectus may lawfully be delivered in accordance with
the laws of the jurisdiction in which he/she/it is located.
If this Prospectus has been made available to the investor in an electronic form, neither the Company, nor the Placement
Agent or any of their respective affiliates accepts any liability or responsibility whatsoever in respect of any difference
between the Prospectus distributed to the investor in an electronic format and the hard copy version, and/or the viruses
and other destructive items arising from alterations and changes caused during the process of electronic transmission of
the Prospectus. By accessing the linked Prospectus, the investor consents to receiving it in electronic form.
For avoidance of any doubts, preference is given to the publicly issued prospectus by the company, (which is identical
to the one approved by the National Bank of Georgia).
After the submission to the approval of the prospectus, there has not been any material change in the circumstances. If
there happens to be any change the prospect will be updated respectively.
A hard copy of the Prospectus will be made available to the investor upon request made to the Placement Agent.
Restriction: If a person has gained access to this document contrary to the foregoing restrictions, he will not be
authorized to purchase any of the securities described therein.
mailto:[email protected]
-
4
Approved by the National Bank of Georgia
date
Issue State Registration Number: ____________
International Securities Identification Number (ISIN):
_______________
-
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Important Information For The Investors: .................................................................................................... 3 Table Of Contents ......................................................................................................................................... 5 Introduction: ................................................................................................................................................ 7
About The Issuer: ........................................................................................................................................ 9
Brief Overview Of The Georgia Healthcare Sector: ................................................................................. 10
Main Characteristics Of The Bonds: ......................................................................................................... 18
Brief Overview Of The Material Risks, That Are Specific To The Company’s Business: ...................... 19
Overview Of The Offering: ...................................................................................................................... 22
Risk Factors ................................................................................................................................................ 24 Risks Relating To The Company’s Business ................................................................................................... 24
Macroeconomic Risks And Political Risks Related To Georgia ........................................................................ 30
Risks Relating To The Bonds ........................................................................................................................ 36
Use Of Proceeds ......................................................................................................................................... 39 Registration Documents .............................................................................................................................. 40 Persons Responsible For Preparation Of The Document .......................................................................... 40
Capitalisation And Indebtedness ............................................................................................................... 43
Primary Activity........................................................................................................................................ 47
Primary Markets........................................................................................................................................ 52
Important Events For The Business Activity Of The Issuer ..................................................................... 58
Future Strategy And Goals ........................................................................................................................ 59
Competitive Environment Of The Issuer And Description Of Its Position On The Market ..................... 60
Investments ............................................................................................................................................... 64
Organizational Structure Of The Issuer .................................................................................................... 65
Operating And Financial Review Of The Company By Management ..................................................... 67
Financial Position...................................................................................................................................... 69
Additional Financing Needs ..................................................................................................................... 75
Operating Results ...................................................................................................................................... 76
Regulation Of Healthcare Activities In Georgia ......................................................................................... 87 Management And Governance.................................................................................................................. 90
Related Party Transactions ....................................................................................................................... 93
Statement Of Financial Position ............................................................................................................... 95
Statement Of Profit Or Loss ..................................................................................................................... 96
Cash Flow Statement ................................................................................................................................ 97
Dividends Policy ....................................................................................................................................... 98
Important Litigation Cases ........................................................................................................................ 99
Description Of Significant Changes In The Financial Or Commercial Condition Of The Issuer .......... 100
Charter Capital ........................................................................................................................................ 101
The List Of Documents That Are Mentioned / Indicated In The Registration Document ...................... 103
-
6
Overview Of The Financial Securities ...................................................................................................... 104 Working Capital Statement ..................................................................................................................... 104
Conflicts Of Interest ................................................................................................................................ 105
Offering Conditions, Expected Schedule And Procedures For Participation In The Offering ................. 106 Terms And Conditions Of The Bonds ...................................................................................................... 106 Governing Law And Jurisdiction ............................................................................................................. 120 Price Setting .............................................................................................................................................. 121 Placement Of The Bonds .......................................................................................................................... 121 Listing And Admission To Trading .......................................................................................................... 123 Taxation Of The Bonds In Georgia ..................................................................................................................... 124
-
7
GENERAL OVERVIEW OF THE PROSPECTUS
Introduction:
Name of the Security JSC “Evex Hospitals” Bonds
Name of the Issuer, legal form, identification
number and contact information
JSC “Evex Hospitals” (Identification Code: 404476205)
Georgia, Tbilisi, Didube district, Didi Digomi, Gldani
connecting highway and Beliashvili Street (Plot 4/77) / Akaki
Beliashvili str., N142.); Tel: (995 32) 255-550505 ; E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Name and contact informaion of the Placement
Agent
JSC Galt & Taggart (Identification Code 211359206),
Address: 79 D. Agmashenebeli Avenue, Tbilisi 0179, Georgia,
Tel: (995 32) 2444-132 (995 32) 24401-111; email: [email protected]
Name and contact information of the body
responsible for approving the Prospectus
National Bank of Georgia - Address. Sanapiro str. N2, Tbilisi
0114, Georgia, Tel: 2 406 406. E-mail: [email protected].
Website: www.nbg.gov.ge
Prospectus approval Date ●
Important references:
The general overview is an integral part of this Prospectus;
Any investment decision made by the investor should be based on the entire prospectus and not only on the information
presented in the general overview;
The Issuer may become liable if the information represented in the general overview is misleading or inaccurate or is not
relevant to the main prospect or does not provide the basic information to help the investors to make investment decisions
with regard to the Bonds;
An investment in Bonds involves high risk. Any prospective investor, who will purchase the Bonds, should be
prepared to face the economic risk of his investment and take into account the fact that the repayment of the
principal amount of the Bonds and accrued interest will depend on the Issuer's solvency. See "Risk Factors of the
Prospectus regarding the types of the risk factors related to investment in the Bonds. Neither this Prospectus nor
any other information supplied by the Company or the Placement Agent in connection with the Bonds is intended
to provide an evaluation of the risks involved in investing in Bonds. Each investor is advised to make his own
evaluation of the potential risks involved. In addition, the investor may lose all or part of the total invested amount.
Preliminary Prospectus and information provided therein may be subject to alteration and addition in case of change of
circumstances, which is reflected in the final Prospectus (e.g. fixing the interest rate, correction of technical deficiencies,
clarification of the issue size, etc.). The Issuer will notify the investors about such alterations and additions in accordance
with the legislation. Sale or public offering of the Bonds described herein is prohibited until the Prospectus is approved
by the National Bank of Georgia.
Offering of the Bonds described in this Prospectus is made within the jurisdiction of Georgia as allowed by the applicable
laws of Georgia. This Prospectus does not constitute an offer of securities for sale in any jurisdiction in which such offer
is unlawful.
Neither the Company nor the Placement Agent make any representation to any potential or actual purchaser of the Bonds
regarding the legality of an investment in the Bonds by such purchaser under appropriate investment or similar laws
applicable to such purchaser.
No person is authorised to give any information or to make any representation not contained in this Prospectus and any
information or representation not so contained must not be relied upon as having been authorised by or on behalf of the
Company or the Placement Agent. Neither the delivery of this Prospectus nor any sale made in connection herewith shall,
under any circumstances, create any implication that there has been no change in the affairs of the Company since the
date hereof.
mailto:[email protected]
-
8
Investors should not construe anything in this Prospectus as legal, business or tax advice. Each investor should consult its
own advisers as needed to make its investment decision and to determine whether it is legally permitted to purchase the
securities under applicable legal investment or similar laws or regulations.
Warning
Bond Prospectus is not a simple document and it can be difficult for the investors to thoroughly understand and evaluate
the product offered by this Prospectus. In making any investment decision, investors must rely on their own examination
of the Company, the Bonds and the terms of this offering, including the merits and risks involved. See "Risk Factors".
Each potential investor must determine the suitability of an investment in the Bonds in light of such investor's own
circumstances. In particular, each potential investor should:
have sufficient knowledge and experience to make a meaningful evaluation of the Bonds, the merits and risks of
investing in the Bonds and the information contained in this Prospectus or any applicable supplement;
have access to, and knowledge of, appropriate analytical tools to evaluate, in the context of its particular financial
situation, an investment in the Bonds and the impact such investment will have on its overall investment portfolio;
have sufficient financial resources and liquidity to bear all of the risks of an investment in the Bonds, including where
the currency for principal and interest payments (the Georgian Lari) is different from the potential investor's currency;
understand thoroughly the terms of the Bonds and be familiar with the behaviour of the financial markets in which
they participate; and
be able to evaluate (either alone or with the help of a financial adviser) possible scenarios for economic, interest rate
and other factors that may affect its investment and its ability to bear the applicable risks.
-
9
About the Issuer:
JSC “Evex Hospitals” (hereafter the “Company” or “Evex Hospitals”, “Group”) was established after
reorganization (demerger) of JSC Insurance Company Aldagi as “Evex Medical Corporation” in 2014 and in April
of 2019 as a result of demerger (described below) formed as JSC “Evex Hospitals”.
In 2019 the Company updated the business structure of it’s healthcare services that had previously consisted of the
polyclinics segment under separate management and the hospitals segment, including community clinics and
referral hospitals under common control but managed separately from the polyclinics. According to the new legal
structure, starting from 2019, the healthcare services business is divided into the following two legal entities: referral
hospitals under JSC “Evex Hospitals” and the clinics, which include polyclinics and community clinics – under JSC
“Evex Clinics”.
The Company is a member of Georgia Healthcare Group. Ultimate parent (holder of 57% of shares) of Georgia
Healthcare Group is Georgia Capital PLC.
Legal address of the company: Georgia, Tbilisi, Didube district, Didi Digomi, Gldani connecting highway and
Beliashvili Street (Plot 4/77) / Akaki Beliashvili str., N142.)
Group’s vertical organizational structure as of 31 June 2019 is as follows:
The issuer is JSC “Evex Hospitals”.
-
10
The primary activity of “Evex Hospitals” is operation of referral hospitals. As of June 2019, the Company operates
with 18 referral hospitals, six located in Tbilisi and other 12 in other major cities in the regions. Referral hospitals
provide comprehensive range of complex and specialist services, including secondary or tertiary level outpatient
and inpatient diagnostic, surgical and treatment services.
Brief overview of the Georgia healthcare sector:
Georgia has significantly developed its healthcare sector over the last decade, thanks to the improved infrastructure,
stronger legal framework, massive privatization and universal healthcare program (UHC) introduced by the
government in 2013. The share of new and privately owned hospital beds increased to over 75% and c.90% of the
current nationwide hospital bed capacity. Additionally, UHC provided state-sponsored basic health insurance to all
uninsured citizens of Georgia, which in turn increased the demand on healthcare. Starting from May 2017, UHC
model became more targeted to socially disadvantaged groups. Citizens with more than GEL 40,000 annual income
(c. 32,000 persons) are completely excluded from UHC coverage, while citizens with annual GEL 12,000-40,000
income can only use limited services under universal healthcare. This enabled to finance medicines for chronic
diseases for socially vulnerable families.
Georgia’s healthcare sector (hospitals, polyclinics and pharma) experienced a strong growth of 14% CAGR over
2012-17 reaching GEL 3.5bn in 2017. Moreover, healthcare services market was forecasted to expand at a compound
annual growth rate of 8% over 2018-21 reaching GEL 4.8bn by 2021, according to Frost & Sullivan estimates.
Company Shareholders:
JSC Georgia Healthcare Group (GHG, the Parent Company) is 100% shareholder of JSC Evex Hospitals.
GHG combines a whole variety of medical services, it’s core branches are: healthcare services (which include
referral hospitals (“Evex Hospitals”), clinics and polyclinics.), pharmacy & distribution, diagnostics and medical
insurance. The main financial information of GHG’s core branches as at 31 December 2018 is given in the table
below.
Total Amount Healthcare Services
(% of total)
Pharmacy &
Distribution
(% of total)
Medical
Insurance
(% of total)
Intergroup
Transactions &
Consolidation
(% of total)
Total Assets 1,240.51 74% 25% 5% -5%
Total Liabilities 665.48 67% 33% 6% -7%
Revenue 846.31 36% 61% 7% -3%
EBITDA 132.27 57% 39% 3% 0%
Company Management
Giorgi Mindiashvili - Chief Operating Officer (COO)
Prior to his appointment to the COO position at Evex Hospitals, Giorgi Mindiashvili served as Chief Financial Officer
at JSC Insurance Company Aldagi BCI since September 2009. In 2012 Giorgi Mindiashvili was CEO at the Insurance
Company Imedi L International. Mr. Giorgi Mindiashvili started his career in 2003 at the British Caucasian insurance
company.
-
11
Mr. Mindiashvili graduated from Tbilisi Technical University and the European School of Management, specializing
in the fields of financial mathematics, management systems, financial management and corporate finance.
Ekaterine Kavtaradze - Deputy Operational Excellence
Before joining “Evex Medical Corporation”, Ekaterine Kavtaradze was Deputy General Director of LEPL “National
Center for Disease Control and Public Health”, in 2012-2013 she was the Head of this Center, in 2010-2012 she was
General Director of the hospital network “Medalpha”, and in 2004 2010 she was holding various positions in the
Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs of Georgia.
In 2003 Ekaterine graduated from Tbilisi State Medial University, Therapeutic faculty; in 2008 she received Master’s
Degree in Pharmacy, in 2013-2016 she finished Caucasus Business School and Grenoble Management School and
has double Master’s Degree in Business Administration.
She is engaged in academic activities, is the author of publications, and cooperates with various universities.
Giorgi Lominadze - Deputy Finance Giorgi Lominadze was appointed as Deputy Finance of JSC Evex Hospitals in 2019, prior to which he served as a
director of commercial analysis department in Evex Medical Corporation for two years. In 2013-2016 he was project
manager in EMSC (Emergency medical service center), also 2007-2013 he was holding various position in several
insurance companies.
Mr. Lominadze received his undergraduate degree in Mathematics from the Georgian Technical University.
Mamuka Chkhaidze - Deputy Clinical
Mamuka Chkhaidze was appointed as Deputy Clinical of JSC Evex Hospitals in 2019. He has over 22 year experience
of working on managerial positions in medical sector.
Mr. Chkhaidze received his undergraduate degree in Paediatrics from the Tbilisi State Medical Institute. He is engaged
in academic activities, is the author of many publications. Also, he is Associate professor in Tbilisi state university.
Nika Songhulashvili - Deputy Legal & Risks
Nika Songhulashvili joined Evex Hospitals in 2017. He was appointed as Deputy Legal & Risks of JSC Evex Hospitals
in 2019, prior to joining Evex Hospitals he served as Assurance Manager at Ernst &Young in 2009-2017.
Mr. Songhulashvili received his undergraduate degree in Business administration from the European School of
Management in Georgia and MBA from Ilia State University
Financial Auditor of the Issuer
The Consolidated Financial Statements (Financial Statements of JSC Medical Corporation EVEX ) were audited by
the Company's independent auditors, EY Georgia LLC. Identification number: 204441158. Adress: 44 Kote Apkhazi
Str., Tbilisi, Georgia. E-mail: [email protected]
Standalone Financial Statements (Financial Statements of JSC Evex Hospitals) were audited by auditor Giorgi Lejava.
Registration number: SARAS-A-173449. Adress: 5/12 Onashvili Str., Tbilisi, Georgia. Giorgi Lejava is the director
of “Georgian Valuation Company” which, as described below, has performed valuation of Fixed Assets of the
company.
After issuing the bonds the company shall become Public Interest Entity, hence Evex Hospitals’ financial statements
for 2019 shall be audited according to the standards imposed by the Service for Accounting, Reporting and Auditing
Suprevision. Auditor Giorgi Lejava does not satisfy the abovementioned demands as at 30 June 2019.
Financial Auditor was not changed during the presented periods.
-
12
Third parties or experts
Fixed Assets of the Company have been valued by “Georgian Valuation Company” Ltd. Identification code:
205187251. Legal address: Georgia, Tbilisi, Vake-Saburtalo district, Pekini st. N 41. Director of the Georgian
Valuation Company is Giorgi Lejava. Valuation is planned and carried out by an Auditor-Valuer Giorgi Lezhava
(the certificate Z#5/343, license Z#243, issued by the Auditing Board of the Georgian Parliament, audit international
standards certificate #238, certificate #21, issued by “Caucasus Academy of Real Estate”) and Besik Diakonidze
(the certificate Z#4/455, issued by the Auditing Board of the Georgian Parliament). Valuation is conducted
according to requirements of International Valuation Standards (IVS 2013).
-
13
Main Financial Indicators
Evex Hospitals is a member of Georgia Healthcare Group PLC (“Group”), and was established after demerging JSC
Medical Corporation Evex into two companies: JSC Evex Hospitals and JSC Evex Clinics on 1st of April 2019.
Because the demerger of JSC Medical Corporation Evex JSC happened after most recent balance sheet date, this
Prospectus presents both the audited financial figures for pre-demerger JSC Medical Corporation Evex (labelled
“Consolidated”) and audited carve-out figures for JSC Evex Hospitals (labelled “Standalone”) for 2018 and 2019.
This Prospectus also contains unaudited stand-alone figures for HY 2018 and HY 2019 for JSC Evex Hospitals
(labelled “Standalone HY”).
Company consolidated and standalone (condensed) Financial Statements for the full 2018 and 2017 year and HY
for 2019 are presented below:
Balance Sheet Statement
(Condensed) ('000 GEL)
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
HY 2018
Standalone
31 Dec
2018
Standalone
31 Dec
2017
Consolidated
31 Dec 2018
Consolidated
31 Dec 2017
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents 1,999 4,217 14,404 28,790 15,051 29,203
Receivables from healthcare services 129,397 111,406 109,006 101,002 111,894 104,083
Investment in associate 7,800 7,106 7,483 7,104 7,483 7,104
Property and equipment 539,294 527,821 539,790 502,645 654,112 610,683
Goodwill and other intangible assets 48,608 45,438 49,664 42,643 63,372 57,193
Other assets 65,945 58,828 62,042 68,223 44,959 66,847
Total assets 793,043 754,816 782,389 750,407 896,871 875,113
Liabilities
Accruals for employee compensation 18,170 17,511 17,954 16,852 19,843 18,154
Accounts payable 30,436 26,974 33,280 49,581 37,441 52,801
Payables for share acquisitions 736 3,312 2,938 3,312 2,938 5,850
Borrowings 165,228 152,660 161,107 158,491 173,211 167,829
Debt securities issued 92,840 93,370 93,573 93,493 93,573 93,493
Other liabilities 4,378 4,516 6,760 4,211 4,862 4,604
Total liabilities 311,788 298,343 315,645 326,012 340,585 351,637
Equity
Share capital 47,828 47,828 47,828 45,437 56,345 53,954
Additional paid-in capital 249,373 248,073 248,173 230,313 302,753 282,260
Other reserves (8,215) (8,215) (8,215) (8,215) (175) (209)
Retained earnings 125,251 102,848 113,558 93,102 131,040 122,755
Total equity attributable to shareholders of
the Company 414,237 390,534 401,344 360,637 489,963 458,760
Non-controlling interests 67,018 65,939 65,400 63,758 66,323 64,716
Total equity 481,255 456,473 466,744 424,395 556,286 523,476
Total equity and liabilities 793,043 754,816 782,389 750,407 896,871 875,113
Statement of Profit or Loss
(Condenced), ('000 GEL)
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
HY 2018
Standalone
31 Dec
2018
Standalone
31 Dec
2017
Consolidated
31 Dec 2018
Consolidated
31 Dec 2017
Healthcare services revenue 147,998 130,618 262,703 233,334 301,988 262,688
Cost of healthcare services (85,661) (75,358) (151,135) (132,785) (174,073) (150,243)
Gross profit 62,337 55,260 111,568 100,549 127,915 112,445
-
14
Other operating income 3,076 3,773 7,558 4,601 12,478 11,149
Other operating expenses (23,424) (21,626) (45,170) (42,862) (66,521) (60,356)
EBITDA 41,989 37,407 73,956 62,288 73,872 63,238
Depreciation and amortization (13,244) (12,342) (24,785) (18,381) (30,768) (23,177)
Other non-operating expenses (14,302) (8,309) 3,532 1,007 1,233 3,845
Profit before income tax expense 14,443 16,756 29,018 25,398 17,684 18,531
Income tax expense 0 (74) (37) (11) (37) (11)
Profit for the year 14,443 16,682 28,981 25,387 17,647 18,520
Other important Information
As per audit opinion, the consolidated financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the consolidated
financial position of the Company as at 31 December 2018 and its consolidated financial performance and its
consolidated cash flows for the year ended in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).
No significant event has occurred after last reporting period before prospectus presentation date that would cast
significant doubt over company’s ability to continue as a going-concern.
The company has been awarded a credit rating by Scope Ratings, a credit rating agency recognized by NBG in July
2019. Company credit rating according to Scope Ratings is BB/Stable. The Company may additionally get the rating
from the same or the other credit rating agency recognized by the National Bank of Georgia.
The following table shows selected key financial ratios of the Company.
Financial Leverage
Ratios
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
2018
Standalone
2017
Consolidated
2018
Consolidated
2017
Long-term Debt to
equity 0.45 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.39 0.45
Return on Capital
employed 8% 8% 7% 6% 5% 5%
Interest Coverage ratio 2.53 2.53 2.25 2.37 1.62 2.33
Total Debt Ratio 0.33 0.33 0.33 0.34 0.30 0.30
Debt Service Coverage
Ratio 2.08 2,08 1.46 0.82 2.05 0.81
Total Debt/EBITDA 3.07 3.07 3.44 4.05 3.61 4.13
(EBITDA- CAPEX)/Interest
Expense1
2.28 2,28 0.72 -0.46 -0.05 -1.04
Profitability Ratios Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
2018
Standalone
2017
Consolidated
2018
Consolidated
2017
ROA 3.7% 3.7% 3.8% 3.4% 2.0% 2.3%
ROE 6.1% 6.1% 6.5% 6.0% 3.3% 3.6%
Gross profit margin 42.1% 42.1% 42.5% 43.1% 42.4% 42.8%
Operating profit margin 19.4% 19.4% 18.7% 18.8% 14.3% 15.3%
Net profit margin 9.8% 9.8% 11.0% 10.9% 5.8% 7.1%
EPS 0.604 0.604 0.621 0.559 0.313 0.343
1 The ratio is negative in several periods, which has been caused by the fact that the company finances it’s capital expenses with debt rather than
operating income.
-
15
Liquidity Ratios Standalone
HY 20192
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
2018
Standalone
2017
Consolidated
2018
Consolidated
2017
Liquid Assets/Total
Assets 0.15 0.15 0.14 0.17 0.12 0.15
Liquid Assets/Current Liabilities
1.51 1.51 1.45 1.47 0.97 1.17
Working Capital
turnover 3.11 3.11 2.84 2.46 8.21 3.73
Current Ratio 2.24 2.24 2.23 2.07 1.32 1.62
Operating Cash Flow Ratio
56% 56% 75% 53% 52% 38%
Operating Ratios Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
2018
Standalone
2017
Consolidated
2018
Consolidated
2017
Fixed Asset turnover 0.55 0.55 0.50 0.46 0.48 0.45
Days of Inventory
outstanding (DIO) 35.82 35.82 42.36 47.01 39.96 42.01
Days of Receivables
outstanding (DRO) 144.98 144.98 145.89 158.00 130.52 132.47
Days of Payables outstanding (DPO)
68.43 68.43 99.48 136.29 95.51 100.81
Cash conversion cycle 112.36 112.36 88.77 68.71 74.97 73.67
FCF3 5,514 5,514 (1,622) (23,636) (15,636) (37,953)
Other ratios related to the company operations:
Standalone
HY 2019
Standalone
HY 2018
Standalone
2018
Direct Salary rate 34.5% 34.9% 35.3%
Materials Rate 17% 16.4% 16.6%
Administrative salary rate 10.8% 10.6% 8.1%
Number of hospitals 18 184 18
Number of hospital beds 2,967 2,967 2,967
Hospital Bed occupancy rate 60.9% 56.1% 54.7%
Average length of stay in hospital 5.4 5.5 5.4
Note:
Long-term Debt to equity - Long-term debt divided by equity
Return on Capital employed – Operating income divided by equity plus long-term borrowings; when calculating the
ratio for Half Year, the operating income is extrapolated – HY figure is multiplied by 2.
Interest Coverage ratio – Operating income divided by interest expense
Total Debt Ratio – Long-term borrowings divided by total assets
Debt Service Coverage Ratio – Operating income divided by interest expense plus principal repayment
Total Debt/EBITDA – total debt divided by EBITDA
2 Adjusted with regard to the assumption that the company will issue GEL 50m bonds and refinance part of its liabilities.
3 In some periods the FCF figures are negative, which can be explained by the fact that the company finances it’s capital expenses with debt rather
than operating profit.
4 After the division of “Evex Medical Corporation” and formation of “Evex Hospitals”, the number of hospitals has been changed retrospectively.
The reason for this was retrospective reclassification of 3 clinics to hospitals due to their considerable size and reclassification of 1 hospital to
clinic, which happened at the time of formation of “Evex Hospitals”.
-
16
(EBITDA – CAPEX)/Interest Expense – EBITDA minus total capital expenses, divided by interest expense.
Return on Assets - Net Income divided by average assets of the most recent past 2 years. In case of inexistence of
prior year figures, assets’ balance of the same year is used.
Return on Equity – Net Income divided by average equity of the most recent past 2 years. In case of inexistence of
prior year figures, assets’ balance of the same year is used.
Gross profit margin – Gross profit divided by Healthcare services revenue
Operating profit margin – Operating income divided by Healthcare services revenue
Net profit margin -Net income divided by Healthcare services revenue
Earnings per Share - Net income divided by average shares outstanding. In case of inexistence of prior year figures,
shares outstanding in current year are used.
Liquid Assets/Total Assets – Cash and cash equivalents plus Receivables with less than 1 year maturity divided by
total assets
Liquid Assets/Current Liabilities – Cash and cash equivalents plus Receivables with less than 1 year divided by
current liabilities
Working Capital turnover – Healthcare services revenue divided by current assets minus current liabilities; When
calculating the HY ratio, half year revenue is extrapolated (multiplied by 2)
Current Ratio -Currents assets divided by current liabilities
Operating Cash Flow Ratio – Operating cash flow divided by current liabilities
Fixed Asset turnover – Healthcare services revenue divided by the average balance of Property and equipment. In
case of inexistence of prior year figures, balance of current year is used.
Days of Inventory on hand – Average inventory (or in case of inexistence of prior year figures – period end
Inventory) divided by the daily cost of healthcare services multiplied by number of days in a given period
Days of sales outstanding – Average Receivables (or in case of inexistence of prior year figures – period end
Receivables) divided by healthcare services daily revenue multiplied by number of days in a given period
Number of days of payables – Accounts payable (or in case of inexistence of prior year figures – period end Payables)
divided by cost of healthcare services multiplied by number of days in a given period
Cash conversion cycle – Days of inventory on hand plus days of sales outstanding minus number of days of payables
Free Cash Flows – Cash flows from operating activities minus capital expenses for the same period
Direct Salary rate – Cost of salaries and other employee benefits divided by gross revenue excluding corrections and
rebates
Materials Rate - Cost of materials and supplies divided by gross revenue excluding corrections and rebates
Administrative Salary rate - Administrative Salaries and other employee benefits divided by gross revenue
excluding corrections and rebates
-
17
Bed Occupancy rate - Number of total inpatient nights divided by the number of bed days (number of days multiplied
by number of beds, excluding emergency beds) available during the year
Average length of stay - Number of inpatient days divided by number of patients. This calculation excludes data for
the emergency department
-
18
Main characteristics of the Bonds:
Interest (coupon)
Annual interest (coupon) rate for bonds is 310 basis points premium
over the National Bank of Georgia (the “NBG”) Monetary Policy
(refinancing) Rate, as reported by NBG on the following link:
https://www.nbg.gov.ge/index.php?m=554&lng=eng. This
includes any taxes applicable by the legislation.
Final interest (coupon) is determined following the book-building
Process. (see, Condition 2(a) “Bond Offering Process” – pg.106)
Interest rate is subject to international credit rating of the Company
and may be altered in accordance with the rules set in Terms and
Conditions of the Bonds (See “Terms and conditions of the Bonds”,
Condition 5 “Interest”)
Interest Accrual and Payment
The interest is accrued on the Bonds at the abovementioned rate from the date of issuance of Bonds until the maturity date.
The interest will be accrued based on actual number of days on a
365-day year. The accrued interest will be payable quarterly on February 6, May 6, August 6 and November. The first payment of
interest will be made on February 6 2019.
Maturity Date
The Bonds will be redeemed on November 6 2024 at their principal/nominal value together with accrued and unpaid
interest (if any)
Contact Information of the Registrar JSC United Securities Registrar of Georgia (Identification Code:
205156374); Address: 11 Mosashvili Str. 0162 Tbilisi, Georgia;
Tel: (995 32) 225-1560; E-mail: [email protected]
Listing and Admission to Trading
The Issuer intends to make applications to the Georgian Stock
Exchange for the Bonds to be admitted to listing on the official list
and to the trading system of the Georgian Stock Exchange, as soon
as practicable after the placement of the Bonds.
Status and Ranking of the Bond
The Bonds constitute unsecured and unsubordinated obligations of
the Company and shall at all times rank pari passu and without
preference amongst themselves. The Bonds shall, save for such
exceptions as may be provided by applicable legislation, at all times
rank at least pari passu in right of payment equally with all other
unsubordinated creditors of the Company
Dividend disbursement policy
The company does not have declared and written dividends policy. As a
Subsidiary of Georgia Healthcare Group, the Issuer’s dividend policy is
directed by its parent company and takes into account parent company’s
own dividend policy and financing needs.
https://www.nbg.gov.ge/index.php?m=554&lng=engmailto:[email protected]
-
19
Brief overview of the material risks, that are specific to the Company’s business:
The Company might not be able to expand its business in line with its strategy or realize its revenue and growth targets.
The Company operates in an evolving regulatory environment.
The Company competes with other providers of healthcare services across Georgia.
The Company’s significant part of the business depends on revenue from the Georgian government and a small number of private insurance providers.
The Company’s success depends to a significant degree on its senior management and its ability to attract and retain qualified personnel.
The Company depends on the strength of its reputation and brands.
Healthcare services providers such as the Company can be subject of litigation by patients, and it is possible that some of these cases will be adversely determined against the Company.
The Company’s patients may contract serious infections or communicable diseases at its facilities because of the risks typically closely associated with the operation of medical care facilities.
The Company’s operations could be impaired by a failure of its information systems.
The Company’s ability to provide the services and manage its margins profitability is in part dependent on the availability of supplies.
The Company might not be able to realize the anticipated benefits of recent acquisitions or execute further opportunistic acquisitions.
The Company is an Accountable Entity and is subject to additional regulations and reporting requirements
Anti-monopoly regulations may negatively affect the activities of the Company
The business/industry in which the company operates is capital intensive, which could be subject to risks of obtaining financing.
Rapid technological advancements in Medical industry could have negative effects on the company’s fixed assets.
The stocks of the issuer’s parent company GHG PLC are listed on the London Stock Exchange (LON : GHG), which is subject to certain limitations and demands.
The company’s fixed assets are stated at fair value, which implies valuation risks – it is sensitive towards judgement and methodologies utilized.
-
20
Brief overview of the Macroeconomic risks and political risks related to Georgia
Regional tensions can negatively impact local economy and company
There are additional risks associated with investing in emerging markets such as Georgia.
The Company’s business may be materially adversely affected by any depreciation of the Georgian Lari against the U.S. dollar and Euro.
Political and governmental instability in Georgia could have a material adverse effect on the local economy and the Company’s business
There may be challenges associated with legislative harmonization of the Georgian regulatory environment with the EU driven by the DCFTA.
Uncertainties in the tax system in Georgia may result in the imposition of tax adjustments or fines against the Company and there may be changes in current tax laws and policies.
Destruction of Georgia's neighbouring countries’ markets may have a negative impact on the Georgian economy
Because the Company operates solely within Georgia, it will be affected by changes in Georgian economic conditions.
The uncertainties of the judicial system in Georgia, or any arbitrary or inconsistent state action taken in Georgia in the future, may have a material adverse effect on the local economy, which could, in turn, have an adverse
effect on the Company’s business.
-
21
Brief overview of the material risks, that are specific to the Bonds:
The market price of the Bonds may be volatile
The bonds have variable interest rate, which is influenced by the Monetary Policy Rate of NBG and the company’s credit rating.
The Bonds constitute unsecured obligations of the Company
Any change of law in Georgia in the future may have a material adverse effect on the Bonds, including their GSE listing
Investors whose financial activities are denominated in a currency or currency unit other than Georgian Lari may receive less interest or principal than expected, as a result of fluctuations in exchange rates or changes to
exchange controls
An investment in the Bonds involves certain legal investment considerations
Transfer of the Bonds will be subject to certain restrictions
Investors in the Bonds must rely on procedures of the Registrar and in corresponding cases - Nominal Holders of the Bonds
The terms and conditions of the Bonds may be modified or waivers for breaches of the terms and conditions may be issued in the future
There may not be an active trading market for the Bonds
-
22
Overview of the offering:
The Offer GEL 50,000,000 debt securities (Bonds) due on 6 November 2024
Security Coupon bond (variable interest bearing security)
Nominal Value GEL 100,000 (one hundred thousand Georgian Lari)
Number of Bonds 500 (five hundred)
Total Issue Price GEL 100,000,000
Issue Price 100% of the principal amount (nominal value) of the Bonds
Bond Issuance Date The Bonds will be issued on 6 November 2019
Bond Deferred Placement Date
Any date after the Bond Initial Issuance Date until Offering
Completion Date when the Bond is issued at the Deferred Placement
Price
Offering Completion Date 31 December, 2019, when offering and issuance of the Bonds will
be completed
Maturity Date
The Bonds will be redeemed on November 6, 2024 at their
principal/nominal value together with accrued and unpaid interest (if
any)
Bonds Currency The bonds are denominated in GEL
Rights and Limitations Related to the
Bonds
There are not any special rights and limitations related to bonds
provided by the Prospectus
Any Restriction on Free Circulation of the
Bonds Circulation of the bonds is not restricted
Bond Rating The company has been awarded BB/stable rating by Scope Ratings.
Listing and Admission to Trading
The Issuer intends to make applications to the Georgian Stock
Exchange for the Bonds to be admitted to listing on the official list
and to the trading system of the Georgian Stock Exchange, as soon
as practicable after the placement of the Bonds.
Calculation and Paying Agent JSC Galt & Taggart (Identification Code: 211359206)
Event of Default
If an Event of Default has occurred, Bondholders and/or Nominal
Holders may give notice that the Bonds are, and the Bonds shall
immediately become, due and payable at 100% of the principal
amount together with (if applicable) accrued interest. See "Terms
and Conditions of the Bonds - Condition 9 (Events of Default)".
Use of Proceeds
The net proceeds from the issuance of the bonds will be used for
refinancing existing loans. See "Use of Proceeds". pg 39
In the event of full placement of the issued bonds the net proceeds
from the bonds shall not be less than GEL 49,000,000
Selling Restrictions The offer and sale of Bonds shall only be made within the jurisdiction
of Georgia as allowed by the applicable laws of Georgia
Call option
The Bonds may be redeemed at the option of the Issuer in whole, but
not in part, on any of the Call Option Settlement Dates, on giving not
less than 30 Business Days' notice to the Bondholders and Nominal
-
23
Holders who are registered at the primary Register maintained by the
Registrar (which notice shall be irrevocable), at their principal
amount, together with accrued and unpaid interest to the Call Option
Settlement Date (if any) and Call Option Premium of 2% of the face
value of outstanding Bonds as of Call Option Settlement Date if the
bonds are called on November 6 2022 or Call Option Premium of 1%
of the face value of outstanding Bonds as of Call Option Settlement
Date if the bonds are called on November 6 2023 (“Call Option
Premium”).
Governing Law Georgian law
Jurisdiction
Any disputes related to the Bonds shall be resolved by submission to
the courts in Georgia or arbitration, pursuant to the rules set out in
the Prospectus
Contact Information of the Placement
Agent
JSC Galt & Taggart (Identification Code: 211359206); Address: 79
Aghmashenebeli Ave.; Tel: (+995 32) 2401111 E-mail: [email protected]
Bond Placement Agreement
The Bond placement agreement obliges JSC Galt & Taggart to
underwrite the Bonds only on non-guaranteed basis. The agent’s duty
is to prepare all the necessary documents for Bond placement
purposes (including the Bond Prospectus), act as a Placement Agent
and consult the Company with regards to the issuance, sale and
settlement of the Bonds.
mailto:[email protected]
-
24
RISK FACTORS
Investing in and holding the Bonds involves financial risk. Investors should carefully review all of the information
contained in this Prospectus and should pay particular attention to the following risks associated with an investment
in the Bonds. These risks should be considered together with all other information contained in this Prospectus.
If one or more of the events described below were to occur, The Company business, financial condition, results of
operations and prospects could be materially and adversely affected. In addition, investors could lose all or part of
their investment. The risks set out below may not be exhaustive and do not necessarily comprise all of the risks
associated with an investment in the Bonds. Additional risks and uncertainties not currently known to the Company
or which we currently deem immaterial may arise or become material in the future.
The risks identified in this section are those that The Company believes to be the most important. However, as the
risks relate to events and depend on circumstances that may or may not occur in the future, prospective investors
should consider not only the information on key risks summarized in this section but also, among other things, the
risks and uncertainties described below.
Risks Relating to The Company’s Business
The Company might not be able to expand its business in line with its strategy or realize its revenue and growth
targets.
The Company’s long-term strategy is concentrated on gaining one-third of Georgian referral hospitals market by beds, through organic growth (mainly by ramp-up of two major hospital facilities – Caucasus Medical Centre LLC and
Tbilisi referral hospital), and at the same time gradually increasing business EBITDA margin to c.28%-30% through
increased efficiency and cost control measures in 3-5 years period. The Company might not be able to expand the
healthcare services business in accordance with its plans and its expansion strategy might not generate the benefits
the Company expects.
The Company intends to continue to expand its healthcare services business in Georgia by increasing occupancy rates
at its existing healthcare facilities, full roll-out of newly opened flagship hospitals and adding/expanding in new
services. This will place significant demand on its management and operational resources. . Although the Company
assesses each organic growth project individually, each is subject to a number of assumptions concerning valuations,
profitability, growth, demand for services and interest rates. These projects are also subject to assumptions about
anticipated cost savings, synergies and revenue enhancements. The Company’s assessments might not prove to be
correct because other factors, not accounted for in its analyses, may cause actual developments to differ from the
expectations. The Company may not achieve the operating levels that it expects from future projects and may not be
able to achieve its targeted return on investment, intended benefits or operating synergies from these projects.
In addition, in order to manage organic growth effectively, the Company must expand and continue to improve its
operational systems and policies on a timely basis. If the Company fails to do so, it may not be able to service its patients’ needs, hire and retain new employees, pursue new business, , properly budget costs, accurately estimate operational
costs or otherwise operate its business effectively.
In view of the nature of the industry in which the Company operates, it may have to revise its management estimates
from time to time and, consequently, its funding requirements may also change over the longer term. This may result in
the rescheduling of project expenditures and an increase or decrease in its anticipated cash flows. Any unanticipated
increase in the cost of expansion could adversely affect the Company’s estimates of the cost and ability to implement
its organic growth plans as proposed.
The Company operates in an evolving regulatory environment.
Since 2007, there have been a number of legislative reforms and profound transformations in the Georgia healthcare
services market aimed at achieving higher standards of care, modernization of equipment and facilities, wider access to
healthcare and lower healthcare costs. The Company cannot predict what additional regulatory changes will be
introduced in the future or their effect. The Company expects that the regulatory environment will continue to evolve
-
25
in the advancement of these goals. Starting from 28 February 2013, the government of Georgia introduced the Universal
Healthcare Program (the UHC) to provide coverage of the basic healthcare needs of Georgian citizens. The UHC has
already been amended in 2017 and certain beneficiaries (individuals with annual income of over GEL 40,000 (c.32,000
people) and a limited UHC coverage were granted to middle-income citizens, i.e. those with an income of over GEL
1,000 per month but under GEL 40,000 per year (c.400,000 people)) were excluded from its coverage as part of the
Government’s effort to optimize costs. The UHC regulation has been significantly amended several times since its introduction and there is a risk, that it may be further amended in the future. The government may further diminish or
enhance the coverage it provides through the UHC; and it may introduce new licensing or accreditation requirements
or quality standards for healthcare providers.
Regulation may also change as Georgia harmonizes its laws with the European Union (EU) in implementing an
Association Agreement to introduce a ‘‘Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Area’’ (DCFTA) with the potential goal
of full integration into the EU market. As part of the harmonization, the Company’s management anticipates that
Georgia will adopt equivalent EU healthcare regulations at some point in the future. It is not possible to predict the
timeframe for such adoption or the extent of such changes.
The Company competes with other providers of healthcare services across Georgia.
The Company faces competition in the healthcare services industry in Georgia from a large and mainly fragmented
group of competitors. Competition is based on factors such as reputation, clinical excellence, patient satisfaction and
price. Competition is strongest in Tbilisi, although the Company faces competition in all of the regions in which it
operates. In some cases, competing healthcare providers in certain regions are more established than the Company is,
and may have greater experience, infrastructure and brand loyalty than the Company does. The Company also faces
competition from other healthcare service providers, such as stand-alone specialty centers and laboratories, for areas
such as cardiology, oncology, urology and diagnostics. Over time, the Company may also face competition from
international healthcare companies with substantially greater resources, which may begin providing services in
Georgia in the future or attracting patients from Georgia as part of medical tourism. The Company’s competitors may
consolidate, develop alliances or adopt predatory pricing policies to capture market share.
The Company’s significant part of the business depends on revenue from the Georgian government and a small
number of private insurance providers.
The Company depends on revenue from a limited number of payers, including the Georgian government. In the half year
ended 30 June 2019, the Company received 7% of its total healthcare services revenue from insurance companies,
69% from the government under the UHC and 24% from out-of-pocket payments by patients. The Company expects
that it will continue to depend on revenues from the government and a small number of private medical insurance
providers in the future. Accordingly, the Company’s future success, and its ability to obtain favorable prices, will
depend in part on its ability to maintain good working relationships with private insurance providers and may be impacted
by any changes to state-funded healthcare programs.
Following the launch of the UHC in 2013 the proportion of revenue from the government increased. Accordingly, the
Company’s future success will depend, in part, on the effect of any regulatory reform measures adopted by the Georgian
government, as well as on the government’s ability to maintain efficient administrative procedures, provide effective
payment authorizations and maintain adequate budgetary funding. A change in the process by which the government
reimburses healthcare providers, including the Company, could increase its administrative costs or result in delays in obtaining payment for its services.
The Company is also exposed to the risk that insurance companies may reject, delay or fail to make payments for
claims the Company submits for healthcare services that it has provided to patients claiming coverage under their
medical insurance policies. Evex Hospitals’ Revenue from insurance companies mainly consists of the following
companies : Imedi L-ს (60%), GPI (16%), Ardi (5%), PSP (3%), Irao (2%), Unison (2%), Alpha (2%).
The Company’s success depends to a significant degree on its senior management and its ability to attract and
retain qualified personnel.
The Company’s success depends to a significant degree on the skills, experience and efforts of its senior management
-
26
team and key members of its management staff. The Company’s success also depends on its ability to recruit, train and
retain an appropriate number of experienced physicians, nurses, technicians and other healthcare professionals at its
healthcare facilities. The factors that physicians may consider important in deciding where they will work include their
compensation package, the reputation of the hospital, the quality of equipment and facilities and the quality and number
of supporting staff. In some cases, physician recruitment and retention is affected by a shortage of physicians in certain
specialties. The Company competes with other healthcare providers located in Georgia, in neighbouring countries, and
(to a certain extent) elsewhere in Europe and Asia to recruit and retain highly-qualified physicians and other healthcare
professionals.
As a result of these factors, the Company may not be able to find adequate replacements for its senior management or
other key employees. The loss of services of one or more members of senior management or other key employees could
significantly weaken the Company’s ability to implement its strategy and to operate its business effectively. In addition,
competition for qualified managers and staff may create increasing upward pressure on the wages the Company must
pay. If the Company is unable to transfer any increase in costs to its customers effectively through the prices for its
services and products or otherwise, then such increased costs could impose downward pressure on its margins.
The Company depends on the strength of its reputation and brands.
The Company’s success depends in part upon the strength of its reputation for quality healthcare services and its “Evex
hospitals” brand. Future events that weaken or damage the Company’s reputation or brands could significantly affect
its business. For example, declines in actual or perceived service quality in the Company’s hospitals or publicity of
negative events, such as incidents of medical errors or outbreaks of infection among patients could significantly harm
its standing in the Georgia healthcare industry.
The reputation of the Company’s business depends to a great extent on its ability to provide the latest treatments and
equipment. The medical field continues to evolve rapidly with frequent technological advances. In order to compete
with other healthcare providers for physicians and patients, the Company must continually assess its equipment needs at
its facilities. Investments in medical equipment are regularly expected to be significant. If the Company is unable to
implement new technologies, it may lose patients to competing facilities and its medical practitioners may choose to
leave its hospitals for those of better equipped competitors. Rapid technological advances could also, at times, lead to
earlier-than-planned obsolescence of equipment and result in asset impairment charges, which may materially
adversely affect the Company’s results of operations.
Healthcare services providers such as the Company can be subject of litigation by patients, and it is possible that
some of these cases will be adversely determined against the Company.
Compared to Western countries, Georgia has historically experienced a very low incidence of medical malpractice claims, and the awards for successful claims have been modest. Claims have generally been made against the treating
physician, or against both the physician and the physician’s employer. Although the Company does not believe that the
risk of litigation is significant, this may change in the future. As part of the overall development of the Georgia healthcare
services market and increasing expectations as to the standards of medical care, medical error claims and awards may
increase. Consequently, these matters could require the Company to pay increased premiums for medical malpractice
insurance, or risk incurring substantial damages or amounts in judgments or settlements, harm its reputation and the
goodwill associated with its brand, require significant time and attention from the management and require the Company
to incur debt to finance any judgment or settlement.
The Company’s patients may contract serious infections or communicable diseases at its facilities because of the
risks typically closely associated with the operation of medical care facilities.
The Company’s operations involve the treatment of patients with a variety of infectious diseases. Previously healthy
or uninfected people may contract, during their stay at or visits to the Company’s facilities, serious communicable
diseases, for example, diseases associated with methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), hepatitis or
influenza.
There are relatively scarce statistical data available regarding the epidemiology of nosocomial infections or the
prevalence or incidents of multidrug resistant organisms (MDROs) in the Caucasus region due to the lack of formal
-
27
infection control systems in hospitals and insufficient knowledge about identification, surveillance and management
of hospital acquired infections (HAI). Hospital infections control and prevention (“ICP”) area remains a priority for
the Company and will be constantly monitored. In this regard, the Company closely cooperates with the representative
office of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”) in the South Caucasus region. ICP trained nurses
are attached to each hospital and, with the help of Company’s epidemiologists, supervise the hospital infections control
and prevention activities. The Company’s staff is also engaged in developing national ICP guidelines and protocols.
However, these controls and procedures may not be adequate to counter an increasing trend of MDROs and the
prevalence of HAI in Georgia may pose risks to the Company’s healthcare facilities. HAI could infect the Company’s
patients and employees and significantly reduce the treatment and care capacity of its medical facilities in the short-,
medium- and long-term. In addition to claims for damages, any of these events may lead to limitations on the activities
of the Company’s healthcare facilities as a result of regulatory restrictions and loss of reputation.
The Company’s operations could be impaired by a failure of its information systems.
The Company’s information systems are essential to a number of critical areas of its business operations. Moreover,
customer information is subject to data protection laws. Since 2018, The Company has started to work towards a fully
integrated health information system that will store and manage patients’ full electronic medical records (EMR). The EMR system will include a platform to report quality measures and indicators, which will be important contributor to
monitoring and improving the clinical quality. Any system failure that causes an interruption in service or availability
of the Company’s systems could materially adversely affect operations or delay the collection of revenue. Although
the Company has implemented network security measures and daily back-up measures, its servers are potentially
vulnerable to computer viruses, break-ins and similar disruptions from unauthorized tampering. The occurrence of
any of these events could result in interruptions, delays, the loss or corruption of data, or cessations in the availability
of systems. In addition, the Company may be subject to liability as a result of any theft or misuse of personal
information stored in its systems.
The Company’s ability to provide its services and manage its profitability is in part dependent on the availability
of supplies.
Because the Company often relies on third-party providers for pharmaceuticals (it is worth noting that as at 30 June
2019 80% of the inventory has been purchased from affiliated companies ), surgical supplies and medical equipment,
supplier bottlenecks, quality problems or the disruption of its business relationships with these providers could lead
to disruptions or deterioration in the care provided at its facilities. If the Company is not able to access high-quality
products on a cost-effective basis or if suppliers are not able to fulfil their requirements for such products, it could
face a decline in patient volumes or disruption in its relationships with physicians. In addition, the Company may face
increases in the cost of supplies that it is unable to pass through fully by way of increases in its tariffs or the Company may
be unable to obtain adequate quantities of inventory.
The Company might not be able to realize the anticipated benefits of recent acquisitions
In the past 5 years The Company has made a number of acquisitions and its goal is to capture one-third of the Georgia
healthcare market by beds for its business, through organic growth (mainly by ramp-up of two major hospital
facilities). Realization of the expected benefits of those acquisitions and further growth could be subject to many of
the risks and uncertainties, including the following:
• The Company’s valuation of acquisitions or assessment of their benefits may not be correct;
• The Company may have difficulty assimilating different corporate cultures, practices and methodologies of acquired companies;
• The Company may incur difficulties and unanticipated expenses in conforming and integrating the accounting, human resources, information technology and other internal controls, procedures and policies of the acquired
companies with its own ones;
• The Company’s due diligence may not uncover undisclosed or potential liabilities which the Company may face in connection with acquisitions; and
-
28
• The Company may not be able to retain key personnel of acquired hospitals and clinics.
Furthermore, the Company may not be able to realize the anticipated cost savings, synergies and revenue
enhancements from any such acquisitions. The costs of achieving synergies and other benefits may be higher than the
Company expects due to greater than expected expenditure on integration and implementation activities; the
Company’s inability to eliminate duplicative functions; the Company’s inability to avoid labour disruptions in
connection with any integration; and the Company’s inability to make headcount reductions due to labour laws or
other obstacles.
Although its long-term growth strategy does not depend on any further acquisitions and is concentrated on organic
growth, the Company will continue to evaluate acquisition opportunities. The Company may not be able to identify
suitable acquisition opportunities, obtain the required financing in the longer term, effectively compete with other
potential acquirers of suitable facilities or negotiate attractive terms for such acquisitions. There may be a limited
number of attractive acquisition opportunities and certain acquisition opportunities may command high valuations.
And lastly, in addition to absence of attractive acquisition opportunity, as the Company’s market share increases, its
further expansion can be restricted by the Competition Agency of Georgia, since the latter is authorized to block
certain acquisitions as part of its merger control competences.
The Company is an Accountable Entity and is subject to additional regulations and reporting requirements
The Company is an Accountable Entity within the meaning of the Law of Georgia on Securities Market ("Securities
Law"). The Securities Law sets certain approval and transparency requirements for transactions in which the members
of the governing bodies of a Reporting Company and direct or indirect owners of 20% or more of its shares are
regarded as "Interested Parties" (such cases are defined in the Securities Law). According to the Securities Law, a
transaction involving Interested Parties or transactions exceeding 10% of the value of the assets of the Company shall
be approved by the supervisory board or the general meeting of shareholders. For transactions exceeding 50% of the
value of the assets of the Company, such transactions shall be approved by the general meeting of shareholders.
Transactions with 100% subsidiaries and 100% shareholders are exempted from these requirements.
Furthermore, the Securities Law imposes specific reporting obligations on a Reporting Company. A Reporting
Company is obliged to submit to the NBG, publish or provide to the registered owners of its securities annual, semi-
annual and current reports. If the Bonds are traded on the GSE, such information must be also provided to the GSE.
The NBG is entitled to request additional information from the Reporting Companies.
Requirement of approval of transactions with Interested Parties along with the reporting requirements will pose
additional regulatory burden on the Company and may affect the efficiency of its operations. In addition, the failure
to obtain required approvals may cause invalidation of the relevant transactions in certain cases. (For ex. if the
supervisory board or partners meeting does not approve a transaction with any of the interested parties).
Anti-monopoly regulations may negatively affect the activities of the Company
In March 2014 significant amendments were made to law of Georgia on Competition ("Competition Law"). Various
restrictions were introduced in relation to concentration of economic agents, abuse of dominant position, state aid,
etc., whereas no competition regulations of general application existed in Georgia previously (except for certain
industries such as banking and telecommunications). The Competition Agency was established in April 2014 based
on the Competition Law. The Competition Agency is entitled to monitor compliance of private entities with the anti-
monopoly legislation in Georgia and has various powers including the right to impose fines for breach of the
Competition law. The Competition Agency is expected to issue various normative acts based on the Competition Law
in the nearest future. The novelty of anti-monopoly regulations and unpredictability of the process of enforcement of
such regulations by the Agency may pose additional regulatory burden on the Company and negatively affect its plans
for expansion.
As of the issue date of the bonds, the Company’s acquisitions comply with all anti-monopoly regulations.
-
29
The business/Industry in which the company operates is capital intensive, which could be subject to risks of
obtaining financing.
The company’s business model and the industry in which it operates are capital intensive. Throughout the past 2
years the company has undertook massive development projects by investing heavily in healthcare facilities. These
include renovation and development of recently purchased premises – Caucasus Medical Centre LLC and Tbilisi
referral hospital. Despite the fact that the issuer does not plan on purchasing new hospitals and it’s long term
strategy is focused on the increase of effectiveness of the existing facilities, the company will require financing in
order to maintain it’s fixed assets and to undertake certain capital expenses. There’s no guarantee that such financing
will be available with favourable terms and on time. Company’s inability to obtain necessary capital might have
significant negative effects on the company’s financial position, operating results or it’s ability to repay
Bondholders.
Rapid technological advancements in Medical industry could have negative effects on the company’s fixed assets.
The company’s business environment is dynamic and new technologies are often implemented on the market. If the
company fails to keep up with these tendencies and fails to renew it’s fixed assets/medical equipment frequently,
technological advancements in the industry might cause them to age/depreciate. This in turn, might weaken the
company’s competitiveness and/or negatively impact the company’s operations and financial position.
The stocks of the issuer’s parent company GHG PLC are listed on the London Stock Exchange (LON : GHG),
which is subject to certain limitations and demands.
The stocks of the issuer’s parent company “Georgian Healthcare Group” are traded on the London Stock Exchange,
which is subject to certain limitations and demands. There is a risk of the parent company being unable to fulfil the
abovementioned demands which could damage it’s reputation and have negative impact on it’s Subsidiary – the
issuer. Additionally, there is a risk that limitations imposed on GHG by the stock exchange or investors (such as :
restrictions on loans, compliance with various policies) could have impact on “Evex Hospitals’” and it’s indicators
or plans.
The GHG’s stock price trend (closing price, in GBP) for 2017, 2018 and 2019 is given below.
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Jan
-17
Feb
-17
Mar
-17
Ap
r-1
7
May
-17
Jun
-17
Jul-
17
Au
g-1
7
Sep
-17
Oct
-17
No
v-1
7
Dec
-17
Jan
-18
Feb
-18
Mar
-18
Ap
r-1
8
May
-18
Jun
-18
Jul-
18
Au
g-1
8
Sep
-18
Oct
-18
No
v-1
8
Dec
-18
Jan
-19
Feb
-19
Mar
-19
Ap
r-1
9
May
-19
Jun
-19
Jul-
19
-
30
The company’s fixed assets are stated at fair value, which implies valuation risks – it is sensitive towards
judgement and methodologies utilized.
Evex Hospitals uses revaluation method (according to IFRS), which implies stating property, plant and equipment at
fair value in financial statements. In order to obtain fair value valuation should be performed, which, in turn, is
connected to certain risks. Valuation of fair value is performed using certain judgement. There’s a risk of erroneous
judgement which would cause misstatement in fair value. Additionally, International Valuation Standards require
valuators to use more than one valuation method, where using only one method would not yield a high degree of
confidence in the accuracy and reliability of resulting figures. There’s a risk of utilizing only one method even in
cases where high degree of confidence has not been obtained. Moreover, International Standards of Valuation
require valuators to arrive to a single figure, by analysing and reconciling the differing values produced by different
methods, without averaging. Due to the fact that different methods yield different values, arriving at a single value
includes judgement as well, which implies a risk of misstatement. As well as this, certain methods of valuation could
be omitted completely, which would have a significant impact on a final figure.
Macroeconomic risks and political risks related to Georgia
Regional tensions can negatively impact local economy and company
Georgia shares borders with Russia, Azerbaijan, Armenia and Turkey and could be adversely affected by political
unrest within its borders and in surrounding countries. In particular, Georgia has had on-going disputes in the
breakaway regions of Abkhazia and the Tskhinvali Region/South Ossetia, and with Russia, since Georgian
independence in 1991. These disputes have led to sporadic violence and breaches of peace-keeping operations. In
August 2008, the conflict in the Tskhinvali Region/South Ossetia escalated as Georgian troops engaged with local
militias and Russian forces that crossed the international border, and Georgia declared a state of war. Although Georgia
and Russia signed a French-brokered ceasefire that called for the withdrawal of Russian forces later that month, Russia
recognized the independence of the breakaway regions and tensions persist as Russian troops continue to occupy
Abkhazia and the Tskhinvali Region/South Ossetia. For example, in summer 2013 Russian border guards erected
fences along portions of the demarcation line between Georgia and South Ossetia and similar future actions could
further increase tensions. Russia is also opposed to the eastward enlargement of NATO, potentially including former
Soviet republics such as Georgia. The Georgian government has taken certain steps towards improving relations with
Russia, but these have not currently resulted in any formal or legal changes in the relationship between the two
countries.
Relations between Azerbaijan and Armenia remain tense, and there are sporadic instances of violence between these
two countries.
Georgia has close trade relations with Turkey. In recent years, the Turkish National Currency has been significantly
devalued due to political instability which will have a negative impact on the country's current account deficit and
external debt service. Consequently, ongoing political and economic instabil