jk sciencejkscience.org/archive/volume23/bioeqivalence study... · 'irates and hence its...
TRANSCRIPT
.JK SCIENCE
---------~
organic nitrates is assessed by their drug effect
nstead ofestimation of their plasma concentrat ions (4).
Digital pulse plethysmography (DPG) has becn
~Llggestcd to be the Illost sensitive method for
he e\aluation of nitrate effects (5.6). The action of
nitrates 011 DPG is characterised by downward
di\plaeement of descending limb of the pulse cune
'nd the dicrotle noteiL
Quantifying the morphological changes obsen ed
ith refercnce to the quotient of b/a ratio (a) height of
>\\tolic pca' : (b) height of the dicrotic wave affords a
limp Ie and reliable mc;thocl for assessing the action of
'Irates and hence its bioavailability (7) - (Fig I).
Hence, we have undertaken the present study to
lIaluale the biocquivalence of two formulations of
\\1:\. b) DPG.
,dicrotic notch in the DPG \\ere excluded from the study.
The volunteers \\ere hOllsed in thc Depal1ment ofClinical
Pharnwcology and Therapeutics on the previolls night
of the study and \\ere not allowed to take all) food after
lOP. M. On the ne:\t morning. before cOll1mcnccmCnl or
the study blood pressure (B.P.) along with the heart rate
(H.R.) \\ ere recorded using (L&T Minimon 7133 A) B.P.
monitor and the pulse wave curve \\as recorded by a
photo electric transducer (L&T Mieromon 7142) fixed
to the distal phalynx of thc right index finger. The
magnified signals ortlle pulse eurve \"ere then recorded
on ECG rccorder (BPL Cardiart 1087) at a chart speed
of25 I11lll/sec. The b/a ratio was calculated by dividing
the height or dicrotic notch (b) by the height of thc
systolic peak (a) from the mean of three eonsecuti\e
digital pulse curves.
Representative tracing of Digital pulse plethysmogramshOWing systolic peak "a~ and dicrotic InCisura "b~
Fig. I
The recording of the pharmacodynamic parameters
such as B.P., H.R. and pulse \\ave curve were again
carried out in a quiet room at constanl temperature in
supine position on the bed at an il1terval orO.5, \.0, 1.5,
20.2.5.3.0,3.5.4.0.50,6.0,8.0. 10.0, 12.0, 16.0,20.0.
and 24 hours after the administration of the ISMN
formulations. Standard brea,fasl and lunch wcre
pro\ ided aler 3.0 and 6.0 hours aftcr thc drug
administration. CafTienc conlaining beverages were not
allo\\ed throughuut the stlldy period. Occurrcnceof'any
side efTeets \\ere recorded in thc case record form. If
Volunteers \\ere gi\Cll one tablet or formulation A
standard (Isosorbide 5 mononitrate: IMDUR 60 mg I:.R
tablet: KEY Pharmaceuticals) or forl11ulation B - test
(Isosorbide 5 mononitrate : IMNIT 60 mg SR tablet:
Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Hyderabad) as pcr a
randomization schedule on a cmpty stomach \\ ith 150
ml of water. The volunteers werc crossed (WCI" to the
ne:\t forlllulation after a washout period oft\\o weeks.
i. ~\ (\\f\ (\Q, I I 1\, .
llat'rial and Methods
I\\ellty four healthy male volunteers with
rlllal cardiovascular, renal, hepatic, haematological
nd biochemical parameters participated in this
ndoll1ized. double blind crossover study conducted at
,Department of Clinical Pharmacology and
"apcuties at izam's Institute of Medical Sciences.
,d,rabad. The stud) had been apprm ed by the
>lilLltional Ethical Committee. Each volunteer had
.Ien his \Hilten informed consent for participation in
dud).
\11 the volunteers who \,\ere smokers. hypotcnsives.
a history of drug allergy, or had no e\idcllcc of
~ \0 3. Jul)-Scpll.::mbcr 2000 145
I'~JK SCIENCE
-----------~<----------------I
ally volunteer complained or headache during the study
period he \\as given SOO mg of lab let paracetamol.
PhannHcodynamic Paramcters Evaluated
I. E m"x - Maximum (peak) elTect observed in b/"
ratio.
., T IllH:'\ - Time 1\1 1'l....'<.H:l1m<lxillllll11 (peak) elreel.
3. i\UC 0-2~ hrs - Area under the effect time curve
from 0-24 hrs.
Statistical Evaluation
The pharmacodynamic variables were compared by
paired ·t· test.
Results
Twellty-four healthy male volunteers with mean age
01'25.33 ± 2.46 years. me"n height of 167 ± 6.0 cms and
mean \\eight of 63 ± 8.0 kg participated in the study.
The basal values of the pharmacodynamic variables like
bla ratio. IlY. and II.R. were comparable between the
t\\O treatmcnt groups. Administration of both the ISMN
formulati'"ls produced dowl1\vard displacement of the
dicrotic notch in the descending limb of the pulse curve
producing an increase in the b/a ratio at different time
intervals as compared to the base line.
Table I. There were no significant differences between
these parameters after the administration of the two
formulations.
An equal incidence of mild to moderate headache was
reported by the volunteers in both the treatment groups
\\hich was relieved after administration of the
pnracetamol tablet.
EFFECT OF ISOSORBIDDE MONONITRATE ON blaRATIO
uta RatIO12
0·1
00 ._- I _1._ ' ........ .1..-1...--;
a 2 <1 8 8 10 12 14 10 16 ~:o 22 2~
Tirne In Hc::urs
-- STANDARD -*"'" rEST
Fig. 11
EFFECT OF ISOSORBIDDE MONONITRATE ON% CHANGE IN b/a RATIO
~ Olango 10 cta Ratio00
Both the stand"rd as well as the test formulations
increased tile b/a ratio \\ ithin hrllf an hour after the
administration of the drug and this \\as maintained till
the end 01'20 hours. The effect of IS IN on bla ratio and
00
40
2 4·
the mean percentage change in b/a ratio fromlhe baseline
at variolls time intervals is shown in Fig. II and III
respect ivc Iy. Ind i\ iduH I pharmacodynam ic parameters
Ii"e peak effect (En",x). time to obtain peak elTect (tmax)
and the area under the clTeet - time cun e (AUe 0-24
hrs) obtained \\ ith the t\\O formulations arc sho\\n in
146
20
ol--~~· ,o
~~~~'~~~---'-- ~
B 810121410162022
Time In Hoors
~ STANDN10 --+<- TES r
Fig. tll
Vol. 2 No.3. July-September 2
I\>JK SCIE CE~"f
TABLE I ,PHARMACODYNAMIC PARAMETERS
STANDARD TEST
Vol. Emax tmax AUG Emax tmax AUGb/a Ratio hr. b/a Ratio/hr. b/a Ratio hr. b/a Ratio/hr.
1. 0.88 3.5 19.40 096 10.0 21.692. 0.93 80 16.90 0.77 3.5 15.563. 1.00 1.0 20.81 1.00 6.0 21.714. 1.08 2.0 23.00 1.00 1.0 22.775. 1.10 3.0 20.30 1.05 1.5 21.006. 0.93 2.0 21.64 1.00 2.5 21.087. 1.09 2.0 23.35 1.04 8.0 21.808. 1.06 5.0 21.85 1.05 2.0 22.169. 1.08 6.0 22.23 1.17 8.0 23.18
10. 1.08 8.00 23.95 1.13 2.5 24.3511 . 1.14 2.00 23.14 1.08 4.0 226612. 0.92 26 20.17 1.00 2.5 21.6213. 1.00 1.0 21.10 0.94 5.0 18.7214. 1.00 0.5 22.63 1.13 4.0 22.6015. 1.05 4.0 22.14 1.00 1.5 19.0916. 1.06 5.0 21.31 1.09 4.0 20.6317. 1.07 1.0 22.29 1.15 1.0 19.8218. 1.10 3.0 22.64 1.11 1.0 22.2319. 100 50 18.75 1.00 4.0 19.2020. 1.00 25 19.87 0.90 8.0 17.7321. 1.00 2.5 22.34 1.08 8.0 21.3522. 1.01 2.5 20.76 1.08 10 23.0023. 1.00 8.0 20.44 106 8.0 22.3924. 1.09 2.0 22.83 1.06 2.0 20.13
MEAN 1.03 3.38 21.41 1.04 408 21.09S.D 0.07 2.22 1.65 0.09 2.81 1.97
Discussion
Although most bioequivalent sllldies are based on
plasma concentration time profi Ie curve a
rharmacodynamic approach is found to be most
appropriate with nitrates because it is difficult to estimate
ilrates in biological fluids due to their very low
,oncentrations and significant loss in vitro (8).
The pharmacological response of a drug in healthy
lunteers is clinically related to the effect of the drug
npatients (9) as seen with the prolongation of PQ
lenal with diltiazem which is observed both in healthy
2:\0. 3. JlIl~ -Scpl~lllbcr 2000
volunteers as well as in patients. This is clinically related
to the anti-arrhythemic effect ofdiltiazem (10). Similarly
the pharmacological response ofISMN was quantifiable
with reference to b/a ratio obtained from the DPG.
Bio-availability of nitrates can be measured by
different methods like measuring left ventricular or
artierial as well as pulmonary circulation pressure and
also by measuring cardiac output. In this study we had
undertaken to compare the bioequivalence of two
formulations of ISMN by using DPG because it had
147
I.-jK SCIENCE----------ci.,:"_
8. Arm Strong.li\. Slaughter SE. Marks GS. Arm Strong. P\\Rapid disappearance ufnilroglyecrine lollowing incubatiowith human blood. Can J Physiol Pharmacal 1980: 58459-462.
9. Ilub~r T. f\.h:rz PG. Ilarders. Bio\crfugbar~e it <l
hat:l11od) namischc wirkungcl1l rach applicalion \sublingllvakm Gl)ccrohnitrinilralc Arzneimittcr Forschll1991: 44: 713-18.
5. Hancmann RE. Erb R.I. Stolt mann WP el. 01. Digital pulseplethysmography for ass~ssing l:rythrithyl tetra nitrate
bioavailabilil)'. Clinical Pharmacol Ther 1981 : 29: 33-39
6. Schinl A. Gotlsauner A and Schnelle: K. Digital puts,;plethysmograph). i\ scnsitiH test urthe pharmacod)namicsor ;.Jitrates reproducibilit) and qUi.lntitalium of techniqueNitrates III cardiovascular ~rrccts. Springer Verlag
Berlin I h::iddb~rg Ncw York. 1981 : 117- 22.
7. lsenchmid M. Mullar M. Buhrer M. Vorkauf II andBircher. Absolute bioavailability of Glycerl trinitrale
from a lransdcrmal system. assessed b) digit
pleth)smograph). Inlernalional JOltrnal of Clime
Pharmacology. Therapy and TOXicology 1985
23(7): 345·51.
11. Fredrik Lund. Digital pulse plethysmography in studiesthe hacmod) namic response to nitrate. A survey of record'methods and principles ofanalysis. Acute Pharmacal Tan
1986: (Volume 59 Suppl VI).
10. Boyd RA. Chin SK. Pedro 00 el. ClI. Tho PharmacokincliC!and pharmacodynamic of diltiazcm and its metaboliteshealthy adults after a single oral dose. Clin Pharmacal T,
1989: 46: 408-19.
I. Abrams J. Use of nitrates in ischemic heart disease. Current
Problems in CardIology 1992 : 17: 481-94.
3. Nybcr G. Clinical experience with Imdur in anginapectoris a review. European Journal in Clinical
Pharmacology 1990 ; 38 : 568-78.
4. Afshagcn U. Sport Radun S. First data on effects andpharmacokinetics of isosorbide 5-mononitrate· normal man.
Ellr J Clin. Pharmacol 1981 : 19 : 423·29.
References
2. Imhof PRo Sieber A. Ilodier J et 01. Plasma concentration
and haclllod) n<lmic dTects ofnitrogl)cerinc during and alkr
intravl.:nOliS infusion in healthy volullteers. F./lr J Clill
P/wrlllacol 1982 : 23 : 99-106.
proved to be a simple. non-invasive. sensitive and
informative technique for studying the effects of the
nitrates. On the basis of observations in the DPG some
indirect conclusions of the coronary arteries are also
jusilied (II).
Administration of both the ISMN formulations
produced characteristic downward displacement of the
dicrotic notch in the descending limb of the pulse curve
producing an increase in b/a ratio at different time
intervals as compared to the baseline. There "as no
statistical significance in the values of Emax, tmax and
AUC 0-24 hours.
Editorial board encourages the submission of a,·ticles th.-ough compnter disks/floppyfor publication with a written copy of manuscript. The version of noppy and writtcnmannscript should be the same. Describe the software used, the type of computerand any special (non-keyboard) characters used. The illustrations and ligures/tablesshould be enclosed with the manuscript. Disks will not be returned to Authors.
148 Vol. 2 No 3. Jul)-Septcmbcr2
01HG1NAL ARTICLE
Bioequivalence Study of two Long Acting IsosorbideMononitrate Formulations Assessed by
Digital Pulse Plethysmography
Mohsin Mohd*, M.U.R. Naidu*, Jaydip Bhadun**, Aravinda Babu P**,T. Ramesh Kum'lr Rao*
Absl"act
T\\cnty-Iour health) human volunteers \\LTl: r<.llldomi/cd to receive 60 mg or Isosorbide 5lllononitratc or either formulation A or 13 ill a double blind, cross over study. The vasoclilalOryresponse (b/a) ratio of pulse curve was recorded by digital pulse plethysmography al various timeintenals o\er a period of24 hours. A \\ash out period of2 \\eeks was given before the administrationof the next formulation. Both the standard as \\ell as the test formulations increased the bla ratiowithin halfan hour aCter the administration of the drug and this was maintained tililhe end of20hours. The E max. tmax and AUC 0-24 hours \\ere 1.03 ± 0.07. 3.38 ± 2.22 hours and 21.41 ± 1.65bla ratio I hI' for the standard formulalion and I.O~ ± 0.09. 4.08 ± 2.81 hours and 21.09 ± 1.97 blarntio / hI' for the tcst formulation. There \\'as 110 significant differences b('lween these parametersafter the administration orllle two formulations. 1101h the forll1ulations \\ere weilioleratccl.
Key Words
Isosorbide mononilrale. Digital pulse plethysll1ography. Bioequivalcnce.
Introduction
Nitrates arc alllong the 1110St \\ idel) used antianginal
drugs (1). The anlianginal efficacy of nitrates is the result
of haemodynamic changes. like dilatation of veins.
arteries. arterioles and the coronary vessels. The
vasodilating effect of nilrates increases linearly
\\ ith increasing plasma concentrations(2). The
phannClcokinctic profile of Isosorbidc 5 mononitrate
(ISM I) is less complicated than glyceryl trinil
and isosorbidc dinitrate. ISMN does not lInder
first pass. extraction by the liver and is most ofi
used for lo"g term therapy for angina pectoris (
There is a close correlation between serulll d
levels and haemodynamic parameters obtalf
following acute administration. The bioavailabilit}
From the Otparlllleni of *C1in ical Phannacolog) & Therapeutics. Nizalll's Inslitute of ;\ Jtdical Sciences, II) der:lbad & **Or. I{rdL:lbor:ltorics I.ttl. Ilydcrabatl. India.CorTesporHlenCl' 10 : 1)1'. r. 1{,1111~sh KlIlll;lI·!{,Hl. Addt. Pro!'.. Ikpll. nrClillical Pharrn"wtng~ & ·rh~rapl.'lltics. Nil.am's Instilute of
t\ kdicat Scil.'lH.:I.'.... PlInj'lgulta. II) dcrahad .~ SO()US2 (I Ildia)
Vol. 2 No. J . .lui) -Sl.'ptcmlxi'