introduction to fractals, chaos, intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek ›...

38
Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wieslaw M. Macek (1,2) (1) Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Cardinal Stefan Wyszy´ nski University, W´ oycickiego 1/3, 01-938 Warsaw, Poland; (2) Space Research Centre, Polish Academy of Sciences, Bartycka 18 A, 00-716 Warsaw, Poland e-mail: [email protected], http://www.cbk.waw.pl/macek Mamaia, September 2015

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jun-2020

18 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency,and Multifractal Turbulence

Wiesław M. Macek(1,2)

(1) Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, CardinalStefan Wyszynski University, Woycickiego 1/3, 01-938 Warsaw, Poland;

(2) Space Research Centre, Polish Academy of Sciences,Bartycka 18 A, 00-716 Warsaw, Poland

e-mail: [email protected], http://www.cbk.waw.pl/∼macek

Mamaia, September 2015

Page 2: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Objective

The aim of the tutorial is to give students an introduction to the new developmentsin nonlinear dynamics and fractals. Based on intuition rather than mathematical proofs,emphasis will be on the basic concepts of fractals, stability, nonlinear dynamics, leadingto strange attractors, deterministic chaos, bifurcations, and intermittency. The specificexercises will also include applications to intermittent turbulence in various environments.On successful completion of this brief tutorial, students should understand and apply thefractal models to real systems and be able to evaluate the importance of nonlinearity andmultifractality, with possible applications to physics, astrophysics and space physics, andpossibly chemistry, biology, and even economy.

Mamaia, September 2015 1

Page 3: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Plan of the Tutorial1. Introduction

• Dynamical and Geometrical View of the World• Fractals• Stability of Linear Systems

2. Nonlinear Dynamics

• Attracting and Stable Fixed Points• Nonlinear Systems: Pendulum

3. Fractals and Chaos

• Strange Attractors and Deterministic Chaos• Bifurcations

Mamaia, September 2015 2

Page 4: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

4. Multifractals

• Intermittent Turbulence• Weighted Two-Scale Cantors Set• Multifractals Analysis of Turbulence

5. Applications and Conclusions

• Importance of Being Nonlinear• Importance of Multifractality

Mamaia, September 2015 3

Page 5: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Mamaia, September 2015 4

Page 6: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Mamaia, September 2015 5

Page 7: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Fractals

A fractal is a rough orfragmented geometrical objectthat can be subdivided inparts, each of which is (at leastapproximately) a reduced-sizecopy of the whole.

Fractals are generally self-similar and independent ofscale (fractal dimension).

Mamaia, September 2015 6

Page 8: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

If Nn is the number of elements ofsize rn needed to cover a set (C is aconstant) is:

Nn =C

rnD , (1)

then in case of self-similar sets:Nn+1 =C/(rn+1)

D,and hence the fractal similaritydimension D is

D = ln(Nn+1/Nn)/ ln(rn/rn+1). (2)

• Cantor set D = ln2/ ln3• Koch curve D = ln4/ ln3• Sierpinski carpet D = ln8/ ln3• Mengor sponge D = ln20/ ln3• Fractal cube D = ln6/ ln2

Mamaia, September 2015 7

Page 9: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Stability of Linear Systems

Two-Dimensional System(xy

)=

(a 00 −1

)(xy

)Solutions

x(t) = xoeat

y(t) = yoe−t

Mamaia, September 2015 8

Page 10: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Attracting and Stable Fixed PointsWe consider a fixed point x∗ of a system x = F(x), where F(x∗) = 0.

We say that x∗ is attracting if there is a δ > 0 such that limt→∞

x(t) = x∗

whenever |x(0)− x∗‖ < δ: any trajectory that starts within a distance δ of x∗ isguaranteed to converge to x∗.

A fixed point x∗ is Lyapunov stable if for each ε > 0 there is a δ > 0such that ‖x(t) − x∗‖ < ε whenever t ≥ 0 and ‖x(0) − x∗‖ < δ : alltrajectories that start within δ of x∗ remain within ε of x∗ for all positive time.

Mamaia, September 2015 9

Page 11: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Nonlinear Systems: Pendulum

Mamaia, September 2015 10

Page 12: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Attractors

An ATTRACTOR is a closed set A with the properties:

1. A is an INVARIANT SET:any trajectory x(t) that start in A stays in A for ALL time t.

2. A ATTRACTS AN OPEN SET OF INITIAL CONDITIONS:there is an open set U containing A (⊂U) such that if x(0) ∈U , then thedistance from x(t) to A tends to zero as t→ ∞.

3. A is MINIMAL:there is NO proper subset of A that satisfies conditions 1 and 2.

STRANGE ATTRACTOR is an attracting set that is a fractal: has zeromeasure in the embedding phase space and has FRACTAL dimension.Trajectories within a strange attractor appear to skip around randomly.

Dynamics on CHAOTIC ATTRACTOR exhibits sensitive (exponential)dependence on initial conditions (the ’butterfly’ effect).

Mamaia, September 2015 11

Page 13: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Deterministic ChaosCHAOS (χαoς) is

• NON-PERIODIC long-term behavior• in a DETERMINISTIC system• that exhibits SENSITIVITY TO INITIAL CONDITIONS.

We say that a bounded solution x(t) of a given dynamical system isSENSITIVE TO INITIAL CONDITIONS if there is a finite fixed distance r > 0such that for any neighborhood ‖∆x(0)‖ < δ, where δ > 0, there exists (atleast one) other solution x(t) + ∆x(t) for which for some time t ≥ 0 we have‖∆x(t)‖ ≥ r.

There is a fixed distance r such that no matter how precisely one specifyan initial state there is a nearby state (at least one) that gets a distance raway.

Given x(t) = {x1(t), . . . ,xn(t)} any positive finite value of Lyapunov

exponents λk = limt→∞

1t

ln∣∣∣∆xk(t)∆xk(0)

∣∣∣, where k = 1, . . .n, implies chaos.

Mamaia, September 2015 12

Page 14: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Mamaia, September 2015 13

Page 15: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Types of Bifurcations

Mamaia, September 2015 14

Page 16: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Bifurcation Diagram for the Logistic Map

Mamaia, September 2015 15

Page 17: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

IntermittencyIn dynamical systems theory: occurrence of a signal that alternatesrandomly between long periods of regular behavior and relatively shortirregular bursts. In other words, motion in intermittent dynamical system isnearly periodic with occasional irregular bursts.

Pomeau & Manneville, 1980

Mamaia, September 2015 16

Page 18: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Intermittent Behavior

Mamaia, September 2015 17

Page 19: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Bifurcation and Intermittency

Mamaia, September 2015 18

Page 20: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Fractals and Multifractals

A fractal is a rough or fragmentedgeometrical object that can be subdividedin parts, each of which is (at leastapproximately) a reduced-size copy ofthe whole. Fractals are generally self-similar and independent of scale (fractaldimension).

A multifractal is a set of intertwinedfractals. Self-similarity of multifractalsis scale dependent (spectrum ofdimensions). A deviation from astrict self-similarity is also calledintermittency. Two-scale Cantor set.

Mamaia, September 2015 19

Page 21: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Fractal

A measure (volume) V of a set as afunction of size l

V (l)∼ lDF

The number of elements of size lneeded to cover the set

N(l)∼ l−DF

The fractal dimension

DF = liml→0

lnN(l)ln1/l

Multifractal

A (probability) measure versussingularity strength, α

pi(l) ∝ lαi

The number of elements in a smallrange from α to α + dα

Nl(α)∼ l− f (α)

The multifractal singularity spectrum

f (α) = limε→0

liml→0

ln[Nl(α+ ε)−Nl(α− ε)]

ln1/l

The generalized dimension

Dq =1

q−1liml→0

ln∑Ni=1(pi)

q

ln lMamaia, September 2015 20

Page 22: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Multifractal Characteristics

Fig. 1. (a) The generalized dimensions Dq as a function of any real q, −∞ < q < ∞,and (b) the singularity multifractal spectrum f (α) versus the singularity strength α withsome general properties: (1) the maximum value of f (α) is D0; (2) f (D1) = D1; and (3)the line joining the origin to the point on the f (α) curve where α = D1 is tangent to thecurve (Ott et al., 1994).

Mamaia, September 2015 21

Page 23: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Generalized Scaling Property

The generalized dimensions are important characteristics of complexdynamical systems; they quantify multifractality of a given system (Ott,1993).

Using (∑ piq ≡ 〈pi

q−1〉av) a generalized average probability measure ofcascading eddies

µ(q, l)≡ q−1√〈(pi)q−1〉av (3)

we can identify Dq as scaling of the measure with size l

µ(q, l) ∝ lDq (4)

Hence, the slopes of the logarithm of µ(q, l) of Eq. (4) versus log l(normalized) provides

Dq = liml→0

log µ(q, l)log l

(5)

Mamaia, September 2015 22

Page 24: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Measures and Multifractality

Similarly, we define a one-parameter q family of (normalized) generalizedpseudoprobability measures (Chhabra and Jensen, 1989; Chhabra et al., 1989)

µi(q, l)≡pq

i (l)

∑Ni=1 pq

i (l)(6)

Now, with an associated fractal dimension index fi(q, l) ≡ logµi(q, l)/ log l for a givenq the multifractal spectrum of dimensions is defined directly as the averages taken withrespect to the measure µ(q, l) in Eq. (6) denoted by 〈. . .〉

f (q) ≡ liml→0

N

∑i=1

µi(q, l) fi(q, l) = liml→0

〈logµi(q, l)〉log(l)

(7)

and the corresponding average value of the singularity strength is given by(Chhabra and Jensen, 1987)

α(q) ≡ liml→0

N

∑i=1

µi(q, l) αi(l) = liml→0

〈log pi(l)〉log(l)

. (8)

Mamaia, September 2015 23

Page 25: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Turbulence Cascade

Fig. 1. Schematics of binomial multiplicative processes of cascading eddies. A largeeddy of size L is divided into two smaller not necessarily equal pieces of size l1 andl2. Both pieces may have different probability measures, as indicated by the differentshading. At the n-th stage we have 2n various eddies. The processes continue until theKolmogorov scale is reached (Meneveau and Sreenivasan, 1991; Macek, 2012).

Mamaia, September 2015 24

Page 26: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

In the case of turbulence cascade these generalized measures are related toinhomogeneity with which the energy is distributed between different eddies (Meneveauand Sreenivasan, 1991). In this way they provide information about dynamics ofmultiplicative process of cascading eddies. Here high positive values of q > 1 emphasizeregions of intense fluctuations larger than the average, while negative values of qaccentuate fluctuations lower than the average (cf. Burlaga 1995).

Mamaia, September 2015 25

Page 27: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Methods of Data Analysis

Structure Functions Scaling

In the inertial range (η� l � L) the averaged standard qth order (q > 0)structure function is scaling with a scaling exponent ξ(q) as

Squ(l) = 〈|u(x+ l)−u(x)|q〉av ∝ lξ(q) (9)

where u(x) and u(x+ l) are velocity components parallel to the longitudinaldirection separated from a position x by a distance l.

The existence of an inertial range for the experimental data is discussedby Horbury et al. (1997), Carbone (1994), and Szczepaniak and Macek(2008).

Mamaia, September 2015 26

Page 28: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Energy Transfer Rate and Probability Measures

ε(x, l)∼ |u(x+ l)−u(x)|3

l, (10)

To each ith eddy of size l in turbulence cascade (i = 1, . . . ,N = 2n) weassociate a probability measure

p(xi, l)≡ε(xi, l)

∑Ni=1 ε(xi, l)

= pi(l). (11)

This quantity can roughly be interpreted as a probability that the energy istransferred to an eddy of size l = υswt.

As usual the time-lags can be interpreted as longitudinal separations, x =υswt (Taylor’s hypothesis).

Mamaia, September 2015 27

Page 29: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Magnetic Field Strength Fluctuations and Generalized Measures

Given the normalized time series B(ti), where i = 1, . . . ,N = 2n (we take n =8), to each interval of temporal scale ∆t (using ∆t = 2k, with k = 0,1, . . . ,n)we associate some probability measure

p(x j, l)≡1N

j∆t

∑i=1+( j−1)∆t

B(ti) = p j(l), (12)

where j = 2n−k, i.e., calculated by using the successive (daily) averagevalues 〈B(ti,∆t)〉 of B(ti) between ti and ti +∆t. At a position υsw, at time t,where υsw is the average solar wind speed, this quantity can be interpretedas a probability that the magnetic flux is transferred to a segment of aspatial scale l = υsw∆t (Taylor’s hypothesis).

The average value of the qth moment of the magnetic field strength Bshould scale as

〈Bq(l)〉 ∼ lγ(q), (13)with the exponent γ(q) = (q−1)(Dq−1) as shown by Burlaga et al. (1995).

Mamaia, September 2015 28

Page 30: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Mutifractal Models for Turbulence

Fig. 1. Generalized two-scale Cantor set model for turbulence (Macek, 2007).

Mamaia, September 2015 29

Page 31: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Degree of Multifractality and Asymmetry

The difference of the maximum and minimum dimension (the least dense and most densepoints in the phase space) is given, e.g., by Macek (2006, 2007)

∆≡ αmax−αmin = D−∞−D∞ =

∣∣∣∣log(1− p)log l2

− log(p)log l1

∣∣∣∣. (14)

In the limit p→ 0 this difference rises to infinity (degree of multifractality).

The degree of multifractality ∆ is simply related to the deviation from a simple self-similarity. That is why ∆ is also a measure of intermittency, which is in contrast to self-similarity (Frisch, 1995, chapter 8).

Using the value of the strength of singularity α0 at which the singularity spectrum hasits maximum f (α0) = 1 we define a measure of asymmetry by

A≡ α0−αmin

αmax−α0. (15)

Mamaia, September 2015 30

Page 32: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Importance of Multifractality

Starting from seminal works of Kolmogorov (1941) and Kraichnan (1965)many authors have attempted to recover the observed scaling exponents,using multifractal phenomenological models of turbulence describingdistribution of the energy flux between cascading eddies at various scales(Meneveau and Sreenivasan, 1987, Carbone, 1993, Frisch, 1995).

The concept of multiscale multifractality is of great importance for spaceplasmas because it allows us to look at intermittent turbulence in the solarwind. In particular, the multifractal spectrum has been investigated andusing Helios (plasma) data in the inner heliosphere (e.g., Marsch et al.),Voyager (magnetic field fluctuations) data in the outer heliosphere (e.g.,Burlaga, 1991, 1995, 2001; Burlaga and Ness, 2010, 2014; Burlaga et al.,1993, 2003, 2006, 2007, 2013, 2015).

Mamaia, September 2015 31

Page 33: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

We have first analysed the multifractal spectrum directly on the solar windattractor and have shown that it is consistent with that for the multifractalmeasure of a two-scale weighted Cantor set (Macek, 2007).

Next, we have analysed solar wind plasma with frozen-in magneticfield based on data acquired during space missions onboard variousspacecraft, such as Helios (Macek and Szczepaniak, 2008), AdvancedComposition Explorer (Szczepaniak and Macek, 2008), Ulysses(Wawrzaszek and Macek, 2010), and Voyager (Macek and Wawrzaszek,2009), exploring different regions of the heliosphere during solar minimumand maximum.

Recently, we have looked at the fluctuations of the interplanetarymagnetic fields observed by both Voyager 1 and 2 spacecraft in the outerheliosphere and the heliosheath (Macek et al., 2011, 2012), i.e., aftercrossing the heliospheric termination heliospheric shock at 94 and 84AU (in 2004 and 2007, respectively), and finally at 122 AU (2012) theheliopause (Macek et al., 2014), which is the last boundary separatingthe heliospheric plasma from the local interstellar plasma.

Mamaia, September 2015 32

Page 34: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

Conclusions

• Fractal structure can describe complex shapes in the real word.

• Nonlinear systems exhibit complex phenomena, including bifurcation,intermittency, and chaos.

• Strange chaotic attractors have fractal structure and are sensitive toinitial conditions.

• Within the complex dynamics of the fluctuating intermittent parametersof turbulent media there is a detectable, hidden order described by ageneralized Cantor set that exhibits a multifractal structure.

Mamaia, September 2015 33

Page 35: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

This work was supported by the European Community’s Seventh FrameworkProgramme ([FP7/2007-2013]) under grant no. 313038/STORM and also NCN grant2014/15/B/ST9/04782.

Bibliography

• S. H. Strogatz, Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos, Addison-Wesley, Reading, 1994.• E. Ott, Chaos in Dynamical Systems, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1993.

Further reading

• H. G. Schuster, Deterministic Chaos: An Introduction, VCH Verlagsgesellschaft,Weinheim 1988.

• K. Falconer, Fractal Geometry: Mathematical Foundations and Applications, Wiley,Chichester, England, 1990.

• W. M. Macek, Multifractal Turbulence in the Heliosphere, in Exploring the Solar Wind,edited by M. Lazar, Intech, ISBN 978-953-51-0399-4 (2012).

Mamaia, September 2015 34

Page 36: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

References

• W. M. Macek, Multifractality and intermittency in the solar wind, Nonlin. Processes Geophys. 14, 695–700 (2007).

• W. M. Macek and A. Szczepaniak, Generalized two-scale weighted Cantor set model for solar windturbulence, Geophys. Res. Lett., 35, L02108 (2008).

• A. Szczepaniak and W. M. Macek, Asymmetric multifractal model for solar wind intermittent turbulence,Nonlin. Processes Geophys., 15, 615–620 (2008).

• W. M. Macek and A. Wawrzaszek, Evolution of asymmetric multifractal scaling of solar wind turbulencein the outer heliosphere, J. Geophys. Res., 114, A03108 (2009).

• W. M. Macek, Chaos and multifractals in the solar Wind, Adv. Space Res., 46, 526–531 (2010).

• W. M. Macek, A. Wawrzaszek, T. Hada, Multiscale Multifractal Intermittent Turbulence in SpacePlasmas, J. Plasma Fusion Res. Series, vol. 8, 142-147 (2009).

• W. M. Macek, Chaos and Multifractals in the Solar System Plasma, in Topics on Chaotic Systems,edited by C. H. Skiadas et al., Selected Papers from Chaos 2008 International Conference, WorldScientific, New Jersey, pp. 214-223 (2009).

• W. M. Macek and A. Wawrzaszek, Multifractal Turbulence at the Termination Shock, Solar Wind 12,American Institute of Physics, vol. CP1216 (2010a), p. 572–575.

• H. Lamy, A. Wawrzaszek, W. M. Macek, T. Chang, New Multifractal Analyses of the Solar WindTurbulence: Rank-Ordered Multifractal Analysis and Generalized Two-scale Weighted Cantor SetModel, Solar Wind 12, American Institute of Physics, vol. CP1216 (2010b), p. 124–127.

• A. Wawrzaszek and W. M. Macek , Observation of multifractal spectrum in solar wind turbulence byUlysses at high latitudes, J. Geophys. Res., 115, A07104 (2010).

Mamaia, September 2015 35

Page 37: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

• W. M. Macek and A. Wawrzaszek, Multifractal structure of small and large scales fluctuations ofinterplanetary magnetic fields, Planet. Space Sci., 59, 569-574 (2011).

• W. M. Macek, A. Wawrzaszak, Multifractal Two-Scale Cantor Set Model for Slow Solar Wind Turbulencein the Outer Heliosphere During Solar Maximum Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics, 18, 287-294(2011).

• W. M. Macek, A. Wawrzaszek, V. Carbone, Observation of the Multifractal Spectrum at the TerminationShock by Voyager 1, Geophys. Res. Lett., 38, L19103 (2011).

• W.M. Macek, A. Wawrzaszek, V. Carbone, Observation of the Multifractal Spectrum in the Heliosphereand the Heliosheath by Voyager 1 and 2, Journal of Geophysical Research, 117, A12101 (2012).

• W. M. Macek, Multifractal Turbulence in the Heliosphere, in Exploring the Solar Wind edited by M. Lazar,Intech, ISBN 978-953-51-0399-4 (2012).

• W. M. Macek and A. Wawrzaszek, Voyager 2 Observation of the Multifractal Spectrum in theHeliosphere and the Heliosheath, Nonlin. Processes Geophys., 20, 1061-1070 (2013).

• W. M. Macek, A. Wawrzaszek, L. F. Burlaga, Multifractal Structures Detected by Voyager 1 at theHeliospheric Boundaries, Astrophys. J. Lett., 793, L30 (2014).

• W. M. Macek, A. Wawrzaszek, D. G. Sibeck, THEMIS Observation of Intermittent Turbulence behindthe Quasi-parallel and Quasi-perpendicular Shocks, J. Geophys. Res., jgra52051.pdf, in press (2015),doi: 10.1002/2015JA021656.

Mamaia, September 2015 36

Page 38: Introduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and …users.cbk.waw.pl › ~macek › imf_ro_2015.pdfIntroduction to Fractals, Chaos, Intermittency, and Multifractal Turbulence Wiesław

This work was supported by the European Community’s Seventh FrameworkProgramme ([FP7/2007–2013]) under Grant agreement No. 313038/STORM andcosponsored by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education (2013–2015), Poland(MNiSW).

Mamaia, September 2015 37