international conference on emerging research for ...the tense dichotomy between shari’ah...
TRANSCRIPT
-
International Conference on Emerging Researchfor Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-
2016), Dubai-UAE
Jointly Organizedby
KS Global Research SDN BHD, MalaysiaAnd
Stratford University, USA
Dated: February 02-03, 2016Flora Grand Hotel, Dubai-UAE
ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ® KS Global Research SDN BHD,
Malaysia
International Conference on Emerging Researchfor Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-
2016), Dubai-UAE
Jointly Organizedby
KS Global Research SDN BHD, MalaysiaAnd
Stratford University, USA
Dated: February 02-03, 2016Flora Grand Hotel, Dubai-UAE
ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ® KS Global Research SDN BHD,
Malaysia
International Conference on Emerging Researchfor Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-
2016), Dubai-UAE
Jointly Organizedby
KS Global Research SDN BHD, MalaysiaAnd
Stratford University, USA
Dated: February 02-03, 2016Flora Grand Hotel, Dubai-UAE
ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ® KS Global Research SDN BHD,
Malaysia
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
2
CONTENTS
Paper Titles Page Number
Innovation and Economic Growth in Asian Tiger Cub Economies 3 ERSED-16-204
Economics of Gender Discrimination - Evidences from Patriarchal and MatrilinealSocieties
14 ERSED-16-209
Relationship study between Level of Aggression and Emotional Intelligence amongUniversity Students
27 ERSED-16-253
Impact of Multiculturalism on Indian Nationalities in Dubai-UAE 33 ERSED-16-254
AN ECONOMETRICS ANALYSIS OF THE NEXUS BETWEEN EXTERNALDEBT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN NIGERIA
55 ERSED-16-257
Relationship of International Oil Prices, Gold Prices and Stock Returns; Evidencefrom KSE
75 ERSED-16-258
Property Rights and Sustainable Economic Development Revisited 97 ERSED-16-259
DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF DEPRESSION INVENTORY FORAMPUTEES (DIA) IN PAKISTAN
122 ERSED-16-265
GENDER DIFFERENCES: A FOCUS IN MOTIVATION AND ITSRELATIONSHIP TO PHYSICS PERFORMANCE
132 ERSED-16-270
THE STANDARD APTITUDE TEST FOR TEACHERS (SATT) AND LICENSUREEXAMINATION FOR TEACHERS (LET) OF BACHELOR OF SECONDARYEDUCATION (BSEd) AND BACHELOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION(BEEd) GRADUATES OF CAVITE STATE UNIVERSITY-NAIC
143ERSED-16-277
PEER-ASSISTED LEARNING STRATEGIES(PALS): EFFECTS ON THEINTELLECTUAL AND SOCIAL ACHIVEMENTS IN CHEMISTRY OF THIRDYEAR STUDENTS OF PUBLIC HIGH SCHOOLS IN NAIC, CAVITE
165ERSED-16-278
Could educational leaders’ soft skills be considered as a challenge for organizationalgrowth?
176 ERSED-16-289
EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE AND STRESS RELIEF TECHNIQUES: ANANALYSIS OF STUDENTS STRESS MANAGEMENT
190 ERSED-16-290
The Tense Dichotomy Between Shari’ah Compliance and the Economic Goals of anIslamic Bank
200 ERSED-16-294
UHPFRC – AN ENERGY EFFICIENT GREEN CONCRETE 211 ERSED-16-295
“Effectiveness of TV commercials according to Shariah principles: A survey basedstudy
229 ERSED-16-296
Diversification and Evolutionary Genomics of Transposable Elements in BrassicaGenome
249 ERSED-16-303
PEAK-END RULE TO PROMOTE SOCIAL CAPITAL IN A VIRTUALCOMMUNITY ENVIRONMENT
250 ERSED-16-306
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
3
Innovation and Economic Growth in Asian Tiger Cub Economies
a Rudra P. Pradhan, Vinod Gupta School of Management, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur
721302, India. Email: [email protected] [corresponding author]
b Rana Pratap Maradana, Vinod Gupta School of Management, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur-
721302, India. Email: [email protected]
c Danish B. Zaki, Vinod Gupta School of Management, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur- 721302,
India. Email: [email protected]
d Saurav Dash, Vinod Gupta School of Management, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur- 721302,
India. Email: [email protected]
eManju Jayakumar, Vinod Gupta School of Management, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur-
721302, India. Email: [email protected]
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
2
Highlights
We study interactions between innovation and per capita economicgrowth.
An Autoregressive Distributive Lag model is used in this research.
Both long-run and short-run Granger causality are observed to assess theinnovation-growth nexus.
We focus on the Asian Tiger Cub Economies over 1970-2013.
Findings suggest the existence of both unidirectional and bidirectionalGranger causality between innovation and per capita economic growth.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
3
Abstract
This paper investigates the Granger causal relationship between innovation and per capita
economic growth for Asian Tiger Cub Economies (ATCE) over the period 1963-2013.
Both long-run and short-run Granger causality tests are observed to assess the innovation-
growth nexus. Our results find the existence of both unidirectional and bidirectional
causality between the innovation and per capita economic growth.
Keywords: Innovation, per capita economic growth, Granger causality, ATCE
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
4
1. Introduction
The role of innovation1 to economic growth2 has been well established in the
development literature, both theoretically as well as empirically. Schumpeter (1911) was
an earlier thinker on the relationship between innovation and economic growth at a macro
level. Since then, in the field of development economics, research on endogenous growth
theory sparked many theoretical and empirical studies exploring how and to what extent
innovation might contribute to economic growth (see, for instance, Cameron, 1998; Fan,
2011; Grossman and Helpman, 1994; Hasan and Tucci, 2010; Romer, 1990; Schumpeter,
1932).
Empirically, we have array of econometrics tools like ordinary least squares, two
stage least squares, generalized method of moments, and cointegration and Granger
causality techniques to examine the relationship between innovation and economic
growth. In this paper, we set up the Granger causality approach to study the nexus
between innovation and per capita economic growth, using the observations on four Asian
Tiger Cub Economies: Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Thailand, over the
period 1963 to 2013.
The remaining of the paper is structured as follows: Section 2 explains the data,
variables, and empirical model that used in the study; Section 3 presents and discusses
the empirical results; and Section 4 signposts the policy implication and concluding
remarks.
1 Innovation is far from being a recent phenomenon, and is inherent to human development. The emergence
of innovations with the capacity to change people’s behaviour, labour methods, and work characterizes the
history of humanity (Galindo and Mendez, 2014).
2 Among others, innovation is an important determinants of economic growth due to their direct impact on
the production process and also due to its positive externalities (Freeman and Soete, 1997; Grossman, 2009;
Howells, 2005; Romer, 1990; Stokey, 1995).
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
5
2. Data, Variables, and Empirical Model
The study deploys the annual time series data obtained from World Development
Indicators for four countries in the Asian zone (1963-2013).
We use real per capita economic growth (PEG) and three different indicators for
innovation3: number of patents by residents per thousand population (PAR), number of
patents by non-residents per thousand population (PAN), and number of patents by both
residents and non-residents per thousand population (PAT). These proxies for innovation
have previously been used, for example, by Galindo and Mendez (2014) and Kim and
Lee (2015).
We use the following vector error correction model (VECM4) to investigate the
possible directions of Granger causality between innovation and per capita economic
growth.
Growtht 1 p d11k Ld12k L Growtht k 1ECT1t1 1t
Innovation
d Ld L Innovation ECT t 2 k 1 2 1k 22k t k 2 2t 1 2t
…. [1]
The null and alternative hypotheses are to test the followings:
H0: d12k = 0; and δ1k = 0 for k = 1, 2, ..., p
HA: d12k # 0; and δ1k # 0 for k = 1, 2, ..., p
H0: d21k = 0; and δ2k = 0 for k = 1, 2, ..., p
3 Innovation, in general, can be represented in various forms, largely grouped into two types- of input [e.g.
research and development (R&D) capital stock, R&D staff], of output [e.g. new products, patents], and
using a wide range of measurements (Cruz-Cazares et al., 2013; Kim and Lee, 2015).
4 We use panel VECM for the panel data analysis (see, Holtz- Eakin et al., 1988, for more details of this
approach).
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
6
HA: d21k #0; and δ2k # 0 for k = 1, 2, ..., p
where d is the first difference filter; i is the country specification in the panel; t is the time
period; and ξ is the error term. Innovation is demarcated as PAR, PAN, and PAT.
The ECT-1’s are the lagged error-correction terms that represent the long-run
dynamics5 between innovation and per capita economic growth. The above model
provides robust results if the time series variables are integrated of order one (I (1)) and
cointegrated. If the variables used in Eq. (1) are not cointegrated, the ECT-1’s are
uninvolved in the estimation process.
Several possibilities exist. For example, if neither d12k nor d21k are significantly
different from zero, innovation and per capita economic growth are not Granger causally
related. If only d12k is statistically different from zero and d21k is not, then only innovation
Granger-causes per capita economic growth. If only d21k is statistically different from zero
and d12k is not, only economic growth Granger-causes innovation. If both d12k and d21k
are statistically different from zero, this suggests bi-directional causality between
innovation and per capita economic growth.
3. Empirical Results and Discussion
The vector error correction modelling (VECM) framework is used to examine the
possible Granger causal relationships between innovation6 and per capita economic
5 The procedure of obtaining the lagged error-correction terms are well-described in Engle and Granger
(1987).6 Innovation is used here at three levels: PAR, PAN and PAT.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
7
growth. However, the primary requirement of VECM is to know the order of integration7
and nature of cointegration8 between the two variables.
Table 1 reports the results of unit root test and cointegration test9. The unit root test
confirms that all the variables (PEG, Par, Pan and PAT) are integrated of order one [i.e.,
I (1)]. The cointegration test further demonstrates the existence of a long-run equilibrium
relationship between innovation and per capita economic growth and is true for all the
three cases.
The above findings support our VECM approach to examine the Granger causal
relationship between innovation and per capita economic growth. The results of this
section are available in Table 2. We first describe the long-run results, ascertained by
examining the statistical significance of the ECT-1 coefficients. The results indicate that
when ∆PEG is the dependent variable, the coefficients are statistically significant at a 5%
level. This implies that per capita economic growth tends to converge to its long-run
equilibrium path in response to change in innovation. This is true for maximum number
of cases that we have considered in our empirical investigation process. Therefore, the
overall conclusion is that per capita economic growth in ATCE is significantly influenced
by innovation. In other words, to stimulate long-run economic growth, it is important to
enhance the level of innovation in these emerging Asian countries. On the contrary, when
∆INN is the dependent variable, the coefficients of ECT are statistically significant in few
7 The unit root test is used to know the order of integration. For individual country, we deploy Augmented
Dickey Fuller unit root test (Dickey et al, 1981), and for panel data analysis, we deploy Levine-Lin-Chiu
panel unit root test (Levine et al., 2002). The discussion of these two tests are not available here due to
space constraints.
8 The study uses Johansen (1988) cointegration test for individual country and Pedroni (1999) panel
cointegration test for panel analysis. The discussion of these two tests are not again available here due to
space restriction.
9 There are three cases for cointegration: case 1 deals with PAR and PEG, case 2 deals with PAN and PEG,
and case 3 deals with PAT and PEG.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
8
cases10. This implies that innovation is equally determined by the level of economic
growth.
In the short run, however, the results are mostly uniform, with few exceptions. The
uniform case is the unidirectional Granger causality from per capita economic growth to
innovation. However, the reverse causality (i.e., from innovation to per capita economic
growth) is also visible in Indonesia (case 1 only) and Malaysia (case 1 only). We also find
the bidirectional causality between innovation and per capita economic growth in the
instance of panel data analysis (case 1).
4. Policy Implication and concluding remarks
The study aims to examine causal relationships between innovation and per capita
economic growth in four Asian Tiger Cub Economies (ATCE): Indonesia, Malaysia, the
Philippines, and Thailand, during the period 1963 to 2013. The main findings of this study
is that innovation and per capita economic growth are cointegrated. However, the
direction of Granger causality varies from sample to sample and case to case within a
particular sample.
The empirical results suggest that to stimulate per capita economic growth in the
ATCE, policy-makers should give priority to innovation. This requires an optimum
allocation of adequate resources for research and development (R&D) activities in order
to promote the innovation in these four countries. Furthermore, the policymakers can also
focus to have sustainable per capita economic growth in these economies and a portion
of such economic growth should be efficiently invested in order to increase the level of
innovation.
10 This includes Philippines (cases 1-3).
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
9
References
Cameron, G. (1998). Innovation and Growth: A Survey of the Empirical Evidence.
Working Paper, Nuffield College, Oxford University, Oxford.
Cruz-Cazares, C., Bayona-Saez, C., and Garcia-Marco, T. (2013). You Can’t Manage
Right What You Can’t Measure Well: Technological Innovation Efficiency. Research
Policy, 42 (6-7): 1239-1250.
Dickey, D. A. and Fuller, W. A. (1981). Likelihood Ratio Statistics for Autoregressive
Time Series with a Unit Root. Econometrica, 49 (4): 1057- 1072.
Engle, R. F. and Granger, C. W. J. (1987). Cointegration and Error Correction:
Representation, Estimation and Testing. Econometrica, 55 (2): 251-276.
Fan, P. (2011). Innovation Capacity and Economic Development: China and India.
Economic Change and Restructuring, 44 (1-2): 49-73.
Freeman, C. and Soete, L. (1997). The Economics of Industrial Innovation. MIT Press,
Cambridge.
Galindo, M. and Mendez, M.T. (2014). Entrepreneurship, economic growth, and
innovation: Are feedback effects at work. Journal of Business Research, 67 (5):825-
829.
Grossman, G. and Helpman, E. (1991). Innovation and Growth in the Global Economy.
MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Grossman, V. (2009). Entrepreneurial Innovation and Economic Growth. Journal of
Macroeconomics, 31 (4): 602-613.
Hassan, I. and Tucci, C. L. (2010). The Innovation-economic Growth Nexus: Global
Evidence. Research Policy, 39 (10): 1264-1276.
Holtz- Eakin, D., Newey, W. Rosen, H. S. (1988). Estimating Vector Auto Regressions
with Panel Data. Econometrica, 56 (6): 1371- 1395.
Howells, J. (2005). Innovation and Regional Economic Development: A Matter of
Perspective? Research Policy, 34 (8): 1220-1234.
Johansen, S. (1988). Statistical Analysis of Cointegration Vectors. Journal of Economic
Dynamics and Control, 12 (2-3): 231- 254.
Kim, J. and Lee, S. (2015). Patent Databases for Innovation Studies: A Comparative
Analysis of USPTO, EPO, JPO and KIPO. Technological Forecasting and Social
Change, 92: 332-345.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
10
Levine, A., Lin, C. F. and Chu, C. S. (2002). Unit Root Tests in Panel Data: Asymptotic
and Finite Sample Properties. Journal of Econometrics, 108 (1): 1-2 4.
Pedroni P. (1999). Critical values for Cointegration Tests in Heterogeneous Panels with
Multiple Regressors. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 61 (S1): 653-670.
Romer, P. (1990). Endogenous technological change. Journal of Political Economy,
98(5):S71-S102.
Schumpeter, J. A. (1932). Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy. Harper and Brothers,
New York.
Schumpeter, J.A. (1911). The Theory of Economic Development. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
Stokey, N. L. (1995). R&D and Economic Growth. Review of Economic Studies, 28 (4):
1661-1707.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
11
Table 1. Results of Unit Root Test and Cointegration Test
Tests Cases/ Variables==========================================================================================
Sample 1: IndonesiaCase 1 Case 2 Case 3
================= ================= =================Growth PAR Growth PAN Growth PAT
Unit Root Test -9.07* -3.37* -9.07* -7.02* -9.07* -7.38*
Cointegration Test Cointegrated Cointegrated Cointegrated
Sample 2: MalaysiaCase 1 Case 2 Case 3
================= ================= =================PEG PAR PEG PAN PEG PAT
Unit Root Test -7.23* -6.25* -7.23* -11.6* -7.23* -11.8*
Cointegration Test Cointegrated Cointegrated Cointegrated
Sample 3: The PhilippinesCase 1 Case 2 Case 3
================= ================= =================PEG PAR PEG PAN PEG PAT
Unit Root Test -7.20* -10.7* -7.20* -7.99* -7.20* -7.74*
Cointegration Test Cointegrated Cointegrated Cointegrated
Sample 4: ThailandCase 1 Case 2 Case 3
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
12
================= ================= =================PEG PAR PEG PAN PEG PAT
Unit Root Test -8.65* -5.31* -8.65* -7.96* -8.65* -8.49*
Cointegration Test Cointegrated Cointegrated Cointegrated
Sample 5: Panel of ATCECase 1 Case 2 Case 3
================= ================= =================PEG PAR PEG PAN PEG PAT
Unit Root Test -10.1* -3.49* -10.1* -8.88* -10.1* -7.73*
Cointegration Test Cointegrated Cointegrated Cointegrated
==========================================================================================Note 1: PEG: per capita economic growth rate; PAR: number of patents – residents; PAN: number of patents – non-
residents; and PAT: total patents – both residents and non-residents.Note 2: Unit root test follows the Augmented Dickey Fuller (Dickey et al. 1981) Levine el at al. (2002) and
cointegration test follows Johansen (1988) and Pedroni (1999).Note 3: Unit root test figures are reported at the first difference level only.Note 4: * indicates that parameter estimates are significant at the 5% level.
Table 2. Results of Panel Granger Causality Test
Dependent Independent variables and ECT-1Variable
==========================================================================================
Sample 1: IndonesiaCase 1
=======================Case 2
=======================Case 3
========================∆PEG ∆PAR ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAN ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAT ECT-1
∆PEG ------ 3.63** -5.05* ------ 1.19 -5.46* ------ 1.37 -5.51*∆INN 0.25 ------ -1.26 3.96** ------ -1.17 4.40* ------ -1.13Inference: PAR => PEG PEG => PAN PEG => PAT
Sample 2: MalaysiaCase 1
=======================Case 2
=======================Case 3
========================∆PEG ∆PAR ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAN ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAT ECT-1
∆PEG ------ 4.51** -1.56 ------ 0.15 -2.17 ------ 0.18 -1.19∆INN 2.56 ------ -1.84 3.55** ------ -1.61 5.44* ------ -2.52Inference: PAR => PEG PEG => PAN PEG => PAT
Sample 3: The PhilippinesCase 1
=======================Case 2
=======================Case 3
========================∆PEG ∆PAR ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAN ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAT ECT-1
∆PEG ------ 1.56 -2.61 ------ 0.97 -0.13 ------ 1.14 -0.36∆INN 6.18* ------ -3.51* 3.65* ------ -4.07* 3.69** ------ -4.10*
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
13
Inference: PEG => PAR PEG => PAN PEG => PAT
Sample 4: ThailandCase 1
=======================Case 2
=======================Case 3
========================∆PEG ∆PAR ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAN ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAT ECT-1
∆PEG ------ 0.37 -3.01** ------ 1.02 -3.04** ------ 1.37 -0.36∆INN 5.54* ------ -0.19 3.13** ------ -0.57 3.77* ------ -4.10**Inference: PEG => PAR PEG => PAN PEG => PAT
Sample 5: Panel of ATCECase 1 Case 2 Case 3
======================= ======================= ========================∆PEG ∆PAR ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAN ECT-1 ∆PEG ∆PAT ECT-1
∆PEG ------ 3.92** -6.26* ------ 1.99 -6.30* ------ 2.29 -6.28*∆INN 5.21* ------ -0.22 5.85* ------ -1.08 7.05* ------ -1.21Inference: PEG PAR PEG => PAN PEG => PAT
==========================================================================================
Note 1: PEG: per capita economic growth rate; PAR: number of patents – residents; PAN: number of patents – non-
residents; PAT: total patents – both residents and non-residents and ECT-1: lagged error-correction term.
Note 2: INN stands for innovation and indicates PAR, PAN, and PAT.
Note 3: * indicates that parameter estimates are significant at the 1 5% level.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
14
Economics of Gender Discrimination - Evidences
from Patriarchal and Matrilineal Societies
Dr. Anisa JanSenior Asst. ProfessorSchool of Business StudiesIslamic University of Science & TechnologyKashmir, India
Introduction
Preference for a particular gender is more an economical phenomenon rather than being a
social one. The preference for sons is predominant in some East and South Asian societies,
most notably South Korea, China and the northern and western states of India. According to
the World Health Organization (WHO), regions where son preference is most apparent include
Asia (China, Bangladesh, India, Korea, Nepal, Pakistan, Taiwan), the Middle East (Iran, Jor-
dan, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Turkey) and parts of Africa (Algeria, Egypt, Libya, Morocco,
Tunisia, Cameroon, Liberia, Madagascar, Senegal), as well as Latin America (Bolivia, Colom-
bia, Ecuador, Mexico, Peru, Uruguay).
Existing in various forms and across many cultures, son preference includes a broad spectrum
of customs and rituals, the foundations of which are favoritism towards male children with
concomitant disregard for daughters. In most Indian families, daughters are viewed as liabili-
ties and girls are conditioned to believe that they are inferior and subordinate to men. Sons,
meanwhile, are idolized and celebrated. According to the wisdom of various Asian proverbs, to
have a son is “good economics and good politics” and “as essential as taking food at least once
a day.” A boy’s birth is attended by a variety of celebrations and likened to “a sunrise in the
abode of gods.” For girls, however, the axioms are very different.
Over the years, son preference has resulted in unusually high death rates for female infants and
girls. Every year thousands of girls are abandoned, killed or aborted as parents wish to have
sons and not daughters. With the advent of modern technology, the identification and
abortionof female fetuses has also contributed to an unusual preponderance of boys in some
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
15
Asian pop- ulations. That attitude has resulted in the widespread neglect to baby girls in
Africa, Asia and South America (Julie Mullin, 2008). This seemingly normal and simple
phenomenon takes very ugly shapes resulting in depriving the female child the access to basic
education and amenities and in extreme cases the practice of female foeticide. The United
Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) estimates that more than one million female babies
succumb each year as a
result of inequitable access to healthcare, differential feeding and other forms of neglect. Some
researchers put the global number of “missing” females — those who should currently be liv-
ing but are not because of discriminatory practices — to between 50 million and 100 million,
telling “a terrible story of inequality and neglect.
One of the major causes of son preference in India is related to the perceived economic utility
of having sons. Several authors have studied the phenomenon and believe that economic con-
siderations drive people to yearn for sons rather than for daughters. The developing world is
full of poverty stricken families who see their daughters as an economic predicament. Powerful
economic factors support son preference. For instance, in many Asian societies, married sons
are expected to live with aging parents and provide financial support. By contrast, when a
woman marries, she joins her husband’s household and does not normally contribute to the
support of her own parents.
While as a lot of resources (both monetary as well as non-monetary) are spend in these coun-
tries to improve the condition of female child and to enhance her acceptability as an equal
counterpart to the boys in the society, there is little change on the ground. And one of the main
reasons for the same is that these measures only play a superficial role and the perception of
society towards girl child in terms of her economic utility does not change. Therefore in order
to bring a sustainable change in this situation there is need to understand the reasons
for the development of such a perception and also to suggest measures for the required change.
Objectives
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
16
Following objectives have been laid for the current study:
(a) Analyse the factors resulting in perceived less economic utility of a girl child.
(b) Understand whether there is a significant difference in the perception of patriarchal and
matrilineal societies with regard to the perceived economic utility of daughters and
(c) How to sensitise and aware masses about the said concept to lay foundation of a sustainable
gender equity development.
Reasons of Perceived Less Economic Utility of Girl
ChildCompared to daughters, sons provide help in family farms and businesses, have better earnings
prospects in the labor market, and provide for their parents during old age (Miller 1981; Bard-
han, 1988; Basu, 1989; Dharmalingam, 1996). Scholars have substantiated this claim by cer-
tain startling observations made during the course of their research. The reasons for the
perceived less economic utility of girl child, as observed by different scholars can be cate-
gorised as under:
1. Better Earning Prospects
Until the arrival of agriculture, men and women had almost equal roles in a hunter-gatherer
society. The invention of agriculture gave men a lot of advantage by controlling food produc-
tion (requires one to manage heavy beasts in farm and heavy things like ploughs). Women were
also now required to bear even more children as agriculture demanded bigger families. Bard-
han (1974, 1988) suggests that the high female mortality rates and devaluation of girls in North
India can be explained partly because women do not participate in economic and agricultural
activities since wheat production became highly mechanized. On the other hand, the lower fe-
male mortality rates in the South can be derived from the greater labor force participa-
tion and economic activities of women who are primarily employed in the highly labor
intensive rice production. Sonalde Desai (1994) says that parents have several incentives for
not educating their daughters. Foremost is the view that education of girls brings no returns to
parents. In patriarchal societies, women have less economic input into the family and are
therefore valued less (Malhotra et al. 1995). Due to the green revolution, there has been a de-
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
17
crease in dependence on female agricultural labour, again changing the economic value of
women (George 1997, Srinivasan 2005).
2. Dowry
Dowry is another important perceived economic costs associated with having girls. The use of
a dowry in marriage has risen dramatically, both in cost and prevalence in patriarchal societies
in the past few decades. Dowry also has become an important symbol of prestige for a family
particularly in rural areas where people are interested in raising their social and economic
class. Further if the parents of girls do not give the amount of dowry demanded by the hus-
band’s family, their daughters are expected to face hardships and even violence. According
to one study in South India, the average dowry equals approximately two-thirds of a house-
hold’s assets (Rao 1993). Dowry has a large impact, especially on a poor, low caste family that
may use it in an attempt to secure upwards mobility.
3. Support in Old Age
Haughton J. and Dominique H.(1995), suggest that one of the major reasons for son preference
is that parents are typically supported in their old age by their son(s), whereas girls usually
move away from their families and therefore son is more desirable as an investment. In patriar-
chal societies it is the groom’s (or his parents’) responsibility to provide housing for the newly-
weds. In the case of the oldest son, this residence would be shared with his parents, an impor-
tant form of old age support. Parents of daughters would see their daughters being provided
for, but would not benefit from co-residence with prime aged adults. Thus, it leaves parents of
daughters at a disadvantage, a common feature of pre-industrial patriarchal societies [Das Gup-
ta et al., 2003].
4. Childbirth
A childbirth takes the prime strength out of a woman for a minimum of 15 months (9 months
of pregnancy + 6 months of recovery/nursing kid). Multiply that by 5-6 childbirths and that is
close to 10 years of prime life. Until the 20th century medical marvels, life expectancy was
pretty low and mother mortality pretty high. Most women thus never had the spare time and
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
18
strength to dominate the society and the resources. Therefore again the control over resources
was concentrated with men.
5. Invisibility of Household Work
One Aspect of the perceived uneconomic value of girls/women is the invisibility of a woman’s
household contribution to economy (house/country). The assumptions that breeds this kind of
behaviour is that women’s work is unpaid housework, not crucial to the survival of the family.
While society recognizes the role of women in the conventional economy, women stand hidden
and unacknowledged in what is termed by Elson (1995) as the ‘Economy of Care’. Over 367
million women in India – or 32% of the entire population and 65% of all females – have been
classified by the Census of India as non-workers. Of the total of those listed as non-workers in
India, 74.3% are women. Such a categorization of the majority of women cannot fail to have
consequences in policies and programs aimed at women.
Available literature refer to domestic work or housework as unpaid or unwaged or
unremunerated work, and all agree that this work is performed predominantly by women in
their own homes, and while it primarily involves the care of children, is not limited to childcare
but involves a wide range of activities. Also the women’s unpaid domestic work main-
tains and reproduces labour force by ensuring workers (males) ready to work each day,
raising children to become future labourers and acting as own reserve army of labour.
6. Physical strength
Men have more brute strength than women. In ancient societies, physical strength mattered a
lot. Almost all civilizations built armies to survive the raiding armies. This gave the warriors
(most often men) a preeminent role and strong warriors got to decide a lot in the society. This
again resulted in men having more access and control over different resources and thus render-
ing them more powerful.
7. Prophesies
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
19
And finally as a result of all these men consolidated the power since the start of the civiliza-
tion, and gave self-fulfilling prophesies about how women are incapable of ruling, emerged.
These kept more women out of dreaming about power.
Difference in the perception of patriarchal and matri-
lineal societiesPatriarchy is a social system in which males hold primary power, predominate in roles of
political leadership, moral authority, social privilege and control of property; in the domain of
the family, fathers or father-figures hold authority over women and children. Historically, pa-
triarchy has manifested itself in the social, legal, political, and economic organization of a
range of different cultures(Malti-Douglas, Fedwa, 2007)
Patriarchy literally means "the rule of the father” (Green, Fiona Joy, 2010) and comes from the
Greek πατριάρχης (patriarkhēs), "father of a race" or "chief of a race, patriarch”, which is a
compound of πατριά (patria), "lineage, descent" (from πατήρ patēr, "father") and ἄρχω
(arkhō), "I rule” (Meagher, Michelle, 2011). Historically, the term patriarchy was used to refer
to autocratic rule by the male head of a family. However, in modern times, it more generally
refers to social systems in which power is primarily held by adult men (Giddens, Anthony &
Griffiths, Simon, 2006 Gordon, April A., 1996; Boynton, Victoria & Malin, Jo, eds. , 2005).
A matriarchy is a social organizational form in which the mother or oldest female heads the
family. Descent and relationship are determined through the female line. It is also government
or rule by a woman or women. Matriarchis defined a woman who rules or dominates a family,
group, or state; specifically: a mother who is head and ruler of her family and descendants
(Merriam-Webster). There are several types of matriarchal societies, including the matrifocal
family, or mother-centered families. Fathers may not always play a role in the upbringing of
children. There are also matrilineal societies, in which ancestral lineage is traced through the
mother’s line. Also characteristic of this type of society is that property is passed down through
the mother’s line. These families also center on the mother’s side of the family, with men
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
20
sometimes leaving their own family units to join their mother’s. The matriclan includes multi-
ple generations of the mother’s line, as well as her male family members.
None of these types of societies necessarily involve a matriarch in the sense of a woman as po-
litical leader, and is not necessarily in opposition to patriarchy. Instead, the term matriarchy can
be used to define woman- or mother-centered societies that are based on maternal values and
principles, like nurturing and caretaking. Matriarchies can be found at the social level, the eco-
nomical level, the political level, the spiritual and cultural level. Another contributing factor to
matriarchal societies is a connection with Mother Earth as the origins of everything, and the
lands themselves. Matrilineal societies in which women are the landowners are tied to this
concept.
For the current study we take the matrilineal aspect here as major characteristic of these
societies is transfer of property from mother to daughter(s) and thus economics becomes
the predominant characteristic of such societies.
Nnadi Ine(2013) find that excessive son preference strong enough to result in substantial levels
of excess female child mortality is prevalent in East and South Asia, including China, South
Korea and India all being patriarchal societies. Further the author argues that one basic factor
about son preference is that, the practice is rooted in culture and economics and it is stronger in
countries where patriarchy is firmly rooted. It is instructive to note that this practice inflicts on
the girl-child’s psychology a perpetual internalization of the inferior and low premium accord-
ed her by society, this has far reaching implications for the girl.
Gupta M. D. et al (2010) attribute this persisting son preference in patriarchal societies to
strong disincentives to raise daughters – whether or not their marriages require dowries – while
valuing adult women's contributions to the household.
Arnold F. et al (2010) suggest that India, being a patriarchal country, is a country with a perva-
sive preference for sons and one of the highest levels of excess child mortality for girls in the
world (child mortality for girls exceeds child mortality for boys by 43 per cent). Further they
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
21
suggest that the effects of family composition on excess child mortality for girls are more com-
plex, but girls with older sisters are often subject to the highest risk of mortality.
Wang Wendy (2005) observed a continued son preference value, based on traditional views as
well as on perceived financial returns to families leading to a lower level of educational at-
tainment among daughters in rural areas of China(a patriarchal society). The lower educational
attainment and higher labor force participation rates of rural female adolescents reflect unequal
opportunities provided by their parents in addition to social inequality in China.
Nnadi Ine(2013) finds that in Nigeria, the preference for sons is very prevalent and exists in
several cultures as it dates back to pre- historic times and it is tied to inheritance, unfortunately
it has not succumbed to societal changes. The Igbos is an ethnic group in the South Eastern
part of Nigeria with a strong penchant for patriarchy. Women who give birth to a girl-child in
Igbo land are unhappy at their first delivery, because of the fear of rejection and disappoint-
ment by the husband. Sex-preference is very prevalent in Nigeria as well and is based on the
notion of the role and value of males and females. Usually at birth, boys are valued and a
grown man is traditionally viewed as the head, caretaker and breadwinner of his family.
According to Purewal N. K. (2012) “The preference for male children transcends many soci-
eties and cultures, making it an issue of local and global dimensions. Being labelled an abu-
banat in Arabic is to be insulted as the “father of daughters”.One adage in India likens raising a
daughter to “watering the neighbour’s garden. In India, until recently, billboard messages
promised: “Invest 500 (rupees) now and save 50,000 later,” encouraging prospective parents to
abort female fetuses in order to avoid future dowry expenses.
Matrilineal tribal groups (where land and property is inherited by females)also value girls and
demonstrate less son preference than patriarchal tribes in India (Von Furer-Haimendorf, 1960;
Mitra, 2008). A marked differential in preference for a child of a particular sex exists between
the two cultures. In Manipur, which is patriarchal in nature, more couples agree to have a male
child as their next child compared to Meghalaya where more couples agree to have a daughter
as their next child(Singh Abhishek et al 2007 )
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
22
Pakyntein (1999) reveals that among the Khasis(a matrilineal society) there is a preference,
though insignificant, for a daughter over a son. Major reasons for female preference were cited
as old age security (since the youngest daughter looks after the aged parents) followed by con-
tinuation of lineage.
Q. Mark(2012) finds that a matrilineal society places a great deal of importance on a daughter
for she is the one through whom all succession, inheritance and lineage will carry on.
Narzary and Sharma(2013) using statistical data confirm that , in contrast to son preference in
patrilineal societies in general, there is a daughter preference in matrilineal tribal societies of
Meghalaya, India. In these societies, both attitudes and behaviour are significantly influenced
by a long-standing preference for daughters that is deeply rooted in the matrilineal culture and
traditions.
Suggestions
Challenging an entrenched custom and mindset is not a simple task and cannot be achieved
easily; for change to effectively take place, it must be a gradual process and therefore it is sug-
gested that vigorous and concerted efforts are needed by all concerned. Governments and civil
society should address the deeply rooted gender discrimination which lies at the heart of son
preference. This mindset must be gradually but rigorously attacked in strategic ways by remov-
ing the reasons responsible for son preference as well as exposing its negative effects on
women and invariably exposing the importance of women in society. There is the need also to
put in place measures that will enhance greater higher education of girls so that gender equity
is achieved in education and invariably in employment matters.
It is also suggested that government should develop and promote pragmatic policies in such
areas as inheritance laws as well as other social protective measures for women, which reflect a
commitment on its part to protect human rights and promote gender equality between both sex-
es. Particularly, Government should as a matter of priority adopt legislations dealing with dis-
crimination against women. On the part of civil society, continuing advocacy and awareness-
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
23
raising activities and campaigns that stimulate discussion and debate around the subject of the
equal value of boys and girls should be intensified. This view is supported by what is obtain-
able in the Republic of Korea where the preference for sons has largely been overcome through
a combination of strategies, including attention to gender equality in laws and policies, advo-
cacy, media campaigns and economic growth (UN Agencies, 2012).
As a society develops, son preference, where it is prevalent, should ordinarily diminish and
girls should be treated increasingly with more equality with their male counterparts. However,
with the pervasiveness of son preference in present times, it is obvious that modernization does
not necessarily neutralize gender preference. It therefore behooves on governments to tackle
the problem head-on using different strategies.
Efforts are needed to curb the inequality existing between males and females as well as to im-
prove the status of women, which potentially could help to decrease further the devaluation of
women. Although the elimination of under-valuation of daughters implies long-term and pro-
tracted action to change entrenched attitudes and values, it is essential to initiate short-term
measures to prevent and compensate for the health consequences that result from it. An initial
first step is to create awareness among health, religious and social workers as well as the public
of the risks run by female children in societies where discrimination exist.
It is in this area that the electronic and print media will be a major instrument of change. Peo-
ple in the media need to recognise their power and role in either changing or continuing perva-
sive dehumanizing traditions that undermine and violate human rights of women.
Urbanisation, female education and employment can only increase the flexibility of the kinship
system such that daughters and sons can be perceived as being more equally valuable. Much
can be done to accelerate this process through social movements, legislation and the mass me-
dia. Over the last several decades, the advantage of sons over daughters became weaker as
public old-age pension system was introduced and traditional social norms were gradually re-
placed by the Western-style individualism. For instance, the extended family has given way to
the nuclear reflected in a decline in co-residence with old-age parents and other forms of old-
age support from child to parent (such as transfers). While these changes applied across the
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
24
board, they may have been more important for the poor who relied more heavily on their sons
for old age support.
It is however noteworthy that the situation in South Korea has substantially reduced as a of de-
velopment that elicited tremendous normative changes in that country. This feat was achieved
by dramatic increases which occurred in the country's levels of education, industrialization, and
urbanization, as well as in women's education and participation in the formal labour force. By
the mid-1990s, South Korea was officially included as a member of the developed countries'
club, the OECD (Population and Development Review, 2007).
The last measure would ensure independence and self-reliance of women and place girls as as-
sets rather than liability. It should be borne in mind that even though there are developmental
goals, any development that is not engendered to avoid discrimination, is surely endangered.
Ultimately a combination of these efforts will go a long way to curbing son preference in Igbo
land.
References
Bardhan P.K., (1988) Rural Poverty in South Asia (jointly with T.N. Srinivasan), Columbia University Press,
New York,.
Bardhan, Pranab. (1974) “On Life and Death Questions” Economic and Political Weekly 9(32- 34) pg 1293-1304
Basu, A. M. (1989). “Is Discrimination in Food Really Necessary for Explaining Sex Differentials in Child-hood Mortality?” Population Studies 43: 193-210.
Becker, G.(1965) “A Theory of the Allocation of Time” Economic Journal September.Boynton, Victoria & Malin, Jo, eds. (2005). "Patriarchy". Encyclopedia of Women's Autobiography: K-Z.
Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 453. ISBN 978-0-313-32739-1.
Breen, R. and L.P. Cooke. (2005), “The persistence of the gendered division of domestic labour” EuropeanSociological Review 21 (1):43.
Bruce, C.(1999), Assessment of Personal Injury Damages 3rd Edition (Toronto: Butterworths, 1999)
D Blades (1975) Non-monetary Activities in the National Accounts of Developing Countries, Paris: OECD.
Das M. Gupta, Jiang Zhenghua, Li Bohua, Xie Zhenming, Woojin Chung, and Bae Hwa-Ok. (2003), “Why isson preference so persistent in East and South Asia? a cross-country study of China, India and the Republic of
Korea” Journal of Development Studies, 40(2):153–187, 2003.
Davis, S.N. and T.N. Greenstein. (2004), “Cross-national variations in the division of household labor”Journal of Marriage and Family 66 (5):1260_1271.
Dharmalingam G. (1996), “The social context of family size preference and fertility behaviour in South Indi-an village”. Genus; 52;83-103.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
25
Douglas W. Allen,(2010), “A Better Method for Assessing the Value of Housewife Services” American Jour-nal of Family Law Vol. 23(4) Winter: 219–223.
Duncan Ironmonger (1994) “The Value of Care and Nurture Provided by Unpaid Household Work”Elson, Diane. (1995) “Gender awareness in modeling structural adjustment”, in World Development, SpecialIssue on Gender, Adjustment and Macroeconomics. November, 23(11): 1851-69
Ester Boserup’s, 1970, Women’s Role in Economic Development” Family Matters, Vol No. 37, p 192.Ferguson, Kathy E. (1999). "Patriarchy". In Tierney, Helen. Women's studies encyclopedia, Volume 2. Green-
wood Publishing. p. 1048. ISBN 978-0-313-31072-0.
Fred Arnold, Minja Kim Choe & T.K. Roy(1998) “ Son Preference, the Family-building Process and ChildMortality in India” Population Studies: A Journal of Demography /abstract content Volume 52, Issue 3, 1998George S. (1997), “Female infanticide in Tamil Nadu, India: from recognition back to denial?”, ReproductiveHealth Matters.;10:124–132.Giddens, Anthony & Griffiths, Simon (2006). Sociology (5th ed.). Polity. ßp. 473. ISBN 978-0-7456-3379-4.
Gordon, April A. (1996). Transforming capitalism and patriarchy: gender and development in Africa Lynne
Reiner. p. 18. ISBN 978-1-55587-629-6.
Graeme D Snooks (1994) Portrait of the Family Within the Total Economy: A Study in Long Run Dynamics,
Australia 1788-1990, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Green, Fiona Joy (2010). "Patriarchal Ideology of Motherhood". In O'Reilly, Andrea. Encyclopedia of Moth-
erhood, Volume 1. SAGE. p. 969. ISBN 978-1-4129-6846-1.
Haughton Jonathan and Haughton Dominique, (1995), “Son Preference in Vietnam Studies in Family Plan-ning” Vol. 26, No. 6 Nov. - Dec., pp. 325-337Julie Mullin, 2008, “Gender Discrimination – Why is it still so bad and what can you do about it?”, Accessedfrom www.childerninneed.org on 15.08.2008.
Kuznets, S.(1994) National Income and its Composition , Vol II, (National Bureau of Economic Research)
Lourdes Benería, 1995, Human Development Report, United Nations Development Progra
Malhotra A, Vanneman R, Kishor S. (1995), “Fertility, dimensions of patriarchy and development in India”,Population and Development Review.;21(2):281–305.Malti-Douglas, Fedwa (2007). Encyclopedia of Sex and Gender. Detroit: Macmillan.
ISBN 0-02-865960-0.
Marilyn Waring (1988), “Counting for Nothing: What Men Value and What Women Are Worth”, Wellington:Allen & Unwin. p 21.
Marilyn Waring (1988), “Counting for Nothing: What Men Value and What Women Are WorthMeagher, Michelle (2011). "patriarchy". In Ritzer, George & Ryan, J. Michael. The Concise Encyclopedia of
Sociology. John Wiley & Sons. pp. 441–442. ISBN 978-1-4051-8353-6.Meredith Edwards, 1989, “Comments on chapter 2” in Duncan Ironmonger, Households Work:Miller, B.D. (1981), The Endangered Sex, Cornell university press, Ithaca, New York .
Mitra, A. (2008), “The Status of Women among the Scheduled Tribes in India,” Journal of Socio-Economics,37(3): 1202-1217.
Monica Das Gupta, Jiang Zhenghua, Li Bohua, Xie Zhenming, Woojin Chung & Bae Hwa-Ok (2003)The
Journal of Development Studies /abstract content, “Why is Son preference so persistent in East and SouthAsia? a cross-country study of China, India and the Republic of Korea” Volume 40, Issue 2
Nancy Folbre (1991) “The Unproductive Housewife: Her Evolution in Nineteenth-Century EconomicThought” Signs, Vol No. 16, p 482.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
26
Narzary, P.K. and Sharma S.M., (2013), “Daughter Preference and Contraceptive-use in Matrilineal TribalSocieties in Meghalaya, India”, Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition, Jun; 31(2): 278–289.Nnadi Ine,( 2013), “Son Preference – A Violation of Women’s Human Rights: A Case Study of Igbo Customin Nigeria” Journal of Politics and Law; Vol. 6, No. 1; February 26, p134
Pakyntein V (1999). Gender preference in Khasi society. In: TB Subba (Ed.): Wonder that is Culture. Delhi:
Mittal Publications, pp.171-182.
Purewal, N. K. (2012). Son Preference Sex Selection, Gender and Culture in South Asia. Retrieved from
http://www.bergpublishers.com/?TabId=11824
Rao V. (1993), “Dowry ‘inflation’ in rural India: a statistical investigation”, Population Studies.;47:283–293.Robert Eisner (1988) “Extended Accounts for National Income and Product” Journal of Economic Literature,Vol 26, No. December, pp 1611 - 84.
Singh, Abhishek, Avishek Hazra and Faujdar Ram.(2007). “Women’s Autonomy and Sex Differential in ChildMortality in India”. Genus LXIII(3-4): 55-75.Sonalde Desai, Devaki Jain, (1994), “Maternal employment and changes in family dynamics: The social con-text of women's work in rural South India”, Population and Development Review 115-136Srinivasan S. (2005), “Daughters or dowries? The changing nature of dowry practices in southern India”,World Development. 2005;33(4):593–615.
Wang Wendy (2005 ), “Son preference and educational opportunities of children in China “I wish you were aboy!”” Gender Issues June, Volume 22, Issue 2, pp 3-30
World Bank, (2001 ), Engendering development through gender, World March of Women, Women & The
Economy - UN Platform for Action Committee Manitoba (UNPAC).
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
27
Relationship study between Level of Aggression and Emotional Intelligence among
University Students
Authors: Saba Ajmal 1, Dr.Shazia khalid2,&Dr.Firoza Ahmad3
1. PhD Psychology Scholars, Preston University Islamabad
2. Head, Psychology Department, Preston University, Islamabad
3. Dean Social Sciences & DG, Gender Empowerment and Management Division, Preston University, Islamabad
Affiliation: Psychology Department, Preston University Islamabad
Abstract: The present research was designed to investigate the relationship between level of Aggression and
Emotional Intelligence among University students. The sample was consisted of 200 students (100 males &100
females) of age range of 19 to 25years from Bahauddin Zakariya University Multan, from different departments of
Social Sciences and Natural Sciences. The data was collected with the Aggression Questionnaire (Buss&Perry,
1992) modified version (Hussain&Khalid, 2000) and EQ-i developed by Baron (1997). The data was analyzed by
using percentage means standard deviation t test and Correlation. The results revealed that Males and Females differ
significantly on level of Aggression. The results further indicated no significant relationship between level of
aggression and emotional intelligence.
Keywords: Aggression, Emotional Intelligence, University students
Introduction: Aggression is the intentional infliction of some form of harm on others; it is a common form of social
behavior Huesman defines (as cited in Khalid &Hussain,2000) Aggression is hostile behavior that may hurt or upset
other people .such behavior may take the form of physical attack against people or their possessions, or verbal
abuse(Larsen,2000). Instrumental aggression aimed to obtain an object no deliberate intent to harm another person
while Hostile aggression intent to harm another person (Berk, 1999). (Anderson, 2000) explained aggression has
proximate causes (immediate situation) distal causes (individual differences, situational factors).Other biological
differences hormones (testosterone) neuro-chemicals (serotonin) linked to aggression, and it can be prevented by
reduce exposure to events that teach and rewarding aggression (Anderson,2000).Gender is the range of
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
28
characteristics pertaining to, and differentiating between, masculinity and femininity. Gender differences in
aggression was studied by( Buss and Perry,1992). Whereas Emotional intelligence refers to the ability to sense,
umderstand value and effectively apply the power and acumen of emotions as a source of human energy,
information, trust, creativity and influence (Goleman,1995).Emotional Intelligence is the innate potential to feel, use
communicate, recognize, remember, learn ,manage and understand emotions (Salvoey&Mayer,1990). Goleman
(1998) describe framework of emotional intelligence with five factors, self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation,
empathy and social skills.
Rationale of study: Emotional intelligence determines human character and success. In Pakistan Farooq, (2003)
conducted to see effect of Emotional intelligence on academic performance. A comparative study of physical and
verbal aggression in male and female factory personnel was conducted by (Munaf, Rehman&Zaidi, in 2005).In west
emotional intelligence and aggression studied together as Eniola,(2007) work on emotional intelligence and
aggressive behaviors. In Pakistan researcher together will explore the relationship between level of aggression and
level of emotional intelligence. This study will further explore the gender difference between level of aggression and
emotional intelligence.
Objectives of the study: Following are the objectives of the study
To explore level of aggression and emotional intelligence among university students.
To find out the relationship between level of aggression and emotional intelligence among students.
To explore the gender difference between level of aggression and emotional Intelligence.
Hypothesis: Hypothesis are formulated in present research to achieve the objectives
The level of aggression is high among male students as compare to female students.
The level of emotional intelligence is high among those who have low level of aggression.
The level of emotional intelligence is high among female students as compare to male students.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
29
Method:
Sample: The sample consisted of 200 students 100 males and 100 females from various departments: Sociology,
Psychology, Economics, Commerce, Mass communication, Chemistry, Biology, Computer sciences, Math, Physics
of Bahauddin Zakariya University Multan. Their age range was 19 years to 25 years and mean calculated age was 22
years.
Instruments: Following scales were used in the study:
The Aggression questionnaire originally devised by Buss and Perry (1992) which is modified by Khalid &Hussain,
(2000) was used in present study. The Aggression Questionnaire has 29 items which are based on four categories of
aggression physical (1-9) verbal (10-14) anger (15-21) hostility (22-29).The subject marked each item on a five
point rating scale according to their intensity as 1 (least), 2 (mild), 3 (average), 4(moderate) and 5(greatest).This
scoring was applicable to all items expect for items 7&18 for which reverse scoring was done.
Baron Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQ-i) The Baron EQ-I was originally designed by Ruven Baron,(1998) after
extensive research of 17 years in 11 countries. It has been translated in English, French, Spanish, German and
Swedish in order to break language barriers. Baron EQ-i consisted of 133 items arranged in five main components
comprised of 15 subscale The final version of the EQ-i has a 5-point self-rating response format (1 = very seldom or
not true of me, 2 = seldom true of me, 3 = sometimes true of me, 4 = often true of me, and 5 = very often true of me
or true of me). Baron EQ-i 55 items were positively scored and 62 items were negatively scored.
Procedure: To achieve the aim of study Aggression Questionnaire and EQ-i were used. The written departmental
permission was taken from concerned Deans. All the participants were briefed about the nature and purpose of the
current research project. Informed Consent Form was /administered to each of the participants individually to obtain
their written consent for participation in this research. The time to complete the Aggression questionnaire and EQ-i
was one hour. The booklet containing aggression questionnaire and EQ-i were administered at 200 students of
different departments of Bahuddin Zakariya University Multan. The average time to complete the inventories was 45
minutes. The completed inventories were checked when they were handed back, The data was collected in two
month. After completion of data it was statistically analyzed on SPSS version 20.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
30
Results:
Table. 1 Pearson Correlation coefficient between level of Emotional Intelligence and level of
Aggression
Value df p-value
Pearson Correlation coefficient .009 198 0.896
These results showed no significance relationship between level of Emotional Intelligence and level of Aggression
Table. 2
The Table 2 results indicate the mean, standard deviation, t-value, p-value of level of aggression of natural and
social sciences males and females students.
Gender N M SD SE t df P-value
Females 100 68.36 12.024 1.202
Aggression score 4.023 198 .000
Males 100 75.44 12.853 1.285
The results in given table shows the significant difference between male and female level of aggression
Table. 3
The Table 3 results indicate the mean, standard deviation, t-value, p-value of level emotional intelligence of students
Gender N M SD SE t df P-value
Females
Emotional Intelligence
Males
100
100
384.36
390.00
44.656
39.090
4,466
3.909
.905 198 .343
The results indicate in the given table that there is no significant difference among male and female level ofemotional Intelligence.
Discussion: The present study was aimed to explore the relationship between emotional intelligence and level of
aggression. The results revealed that there is no significant relationship between emotional intelligence and level of
aggression. Robin,(1999) work on children aggression and emotional intelligence The results further reveal that
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
31
level of aggression is high among male students as compare to female students.Mayers,(1999) describe differences
in physical strength, also provided differences in aggression levels between two sexes. Moreover no significant
difference was found among male and female emotional intelligence.
Limitations &Suggestions: The study was conducted only on students, EQ-i inventory is lengthy and it should be
translated in Urdu. The participants from other areas of lives should be included in the further study. The research
can be done with more variables.
References
Anderson, C.A (2000) Violence and Aggression In A.E Kazdin(Ed) Encyclopedia of
Psychology (pp.162-170).Oxford: Oxford University Press
Baron, (1997) The Emotional Quotient Inventory: Technical manual.Toronto,Canada:Multi-
Health Systems,Inc
Berk, L. (1999) Infant Children and Adolescents Retrieved on 10 November, 2006
from http//www.msu,edu//mandrew/mary/aggression.html
Berkowitz, L. (1993) Aggression: Its causes, consequences, and control,
New York: McGraw. Hills Buss, A.H.&
Perry.M (1992) Personality process and individual differences: The Aggression
Questionnaire Journal of personality and Social Psychology; vol: 63, 3,452-459
Eniola, M, S (2007) Retrieved on 4 March 2007 from http//www.Krepublishers.com/02
Journals/S-EM-01/html
Farooq, Amber (2003) Effect of Emotional Intelligence on academic performance Retrieved on
25December 2006 from http//eprints.hec.pk/1169/
Harris, A. (1998) Aggression. Pleasure and dangers Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 18, 31-44
Huesman, L R. (1994).Aggression: behavior Current perspective (Ed) New York Plenum Press
Goleman, D. (1995). Emotional intelligence. New York: Bantam Books.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
32
Goleman, D. (1998). Working with emotional intelligence. New York: Bantam Books.
Larsen,(2000) On Aggression. Retrieved on 15 November 2005 from
http.www.geocities.com/we_evelove/human mature.html
Mayer, J.D., & Salovey, P. (1997). "What is Emotional Intelligence?" In P. Salovey & D. Sluyter
(Eds.), Emotional development and emotional intelligence: Implications for educators
(pp. 3-31). New York: Basic. Retrieved on December 5, 2002, from http://eqi.org/mayer.htm.
MunafmS.Rehman, G,&Zaidi, U (2005).A comparative study of physical and verbal aggression
in male and female factory Personnel working in noisy environment. Journal of Social
Sciences and Humanities, 2, 49-56.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
33
Impact of Multiculturalism on Indian Nationalities in Dubai-UAE
Abstract
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) has its unique identity as it is of having rich cultural
diverse society. Workforce inside their nation is expanding daily in more ethnical and
socially differing qualities. Dubai is a little nation with bunches of distinction in socially
various individuals. Dubai is certainly a champion amongst the places on the earth for its
cultural diversity. More than 180 different culture people live there. It has high social
harmony which cannot be seen anywhere around the world. Multiculturalism in Dubai is one
of the beauties of that country. Main objective of this research paper is to identify how does
Indians live in Dubai are influenced by different culture. Sample size of 67 Indians have been
interviewed for this research and result reveals that, cultural diversity does have impact on
the lifestyles of Indians in multicultural environment, people find difficulties to move with
other culture people and have less knowledge about Emiratis.
Key words: Cultural diversity, Multiculturalism, Cross culture, Multiculturalism in Dubai,
Dubai Indians, Cultural diversity impact, Indians and Emiratis.
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
34
1. Introduction
The Indian community in the United Arab Emirates, numbering 2.6 million,
constitutes 30 percent of the aggregate populace. It is the biggest expatriate community in the
nation. The Indian group has assumed a noteworthy part in the monetary advancement of the
UAE in the course of the most recent 35 years. The Indian group regarded for its specialized
skill, feeling of order and its insignificant contribution with criminal action contrasted with
other expatriate community. However, the principle point to support it will be its non-
association in local and regional political issues. In context of these qualities, Indian exiles
appreciate leverage over different nationalities like Chinese, Koreans, Filipino, Pakistani,
Bangladeshi or Arab ostracizes (“UAE Indian community”, 2014).
South Asians call it "the best-run Indian city,” Arabs commend it as a model of Arab
achievement and Westerners have grasped it for its interminable sunshine and extravagance
way of life. With more than 150 nationalities and almost as many expressions of culture,
Dubai is one of the most diverse cities in the Middle East (Fattah, 2006). As in numerous
Gulf States, Dubai's ethnic groups also exist in plainly characterized socioeconomic
stratifications. Local Arabs are ordinarily chiefs, Westerners pick up the top remunerations,
and South Asians do the modest work (Fattah, 2006).
It is the way of life, the blended society of India and the Middle East (Lakhani, 2014).
Dubai has an immense number of expats from the sub-continent, which implies there is no
language problem, particularly for dependents. For Indians, Dubai appears to be home far
from home, since one can without much of a stretch discover individuals who communicate
in English, Hindi, Gujarati, Malayalam, and so on ("Life in Dubai for Indians", 2013). Four
Indian dialects including Hindi can be picked while showing up for driving tests here in the
UAE from September 2015. Hindi, Malayalam, Tamil, Bengali, Chinese, Russian and Persian
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
35
dialects can be picked by trying drivers other than the three current dialects for both
hypothesis tests and additionally eight obligatory addresses ("Hindi, 3 Indian dialects
discover place in Dubai driving tests", 2015). If culture is equal to food, then Dubai is right
place for having different foods. Probably one of the only places that offer affordable food
from all corners of the globes, Dubai allows to enjoy all major cuisines. (“Life in Dubai for
Indians”, 2013).
In case of Dubai living, restaurants serving Indian food are very popular and widely
available in the Emirates. Dubai conducted Dubai food festival in 2015. “It is a platform on
which to showcase the world-class restaurants and chefs in our city,” agrees His Excellency
Helal Saeed Almarri, Director-General of Dubai’s Department of Tourism and Commerce
Marketing. “Dubai’s status as a culinary destination is one that has risen considerably in
recent years and the creation of a city-wide food festival will contribute to enhancing this
further”. Her Excellency Laila Mohammed Suhail, the CEO of Dubai Festivals and Retail
Establishment said, “It will promote the diversity, creativity, and multi-cultural nature of
Dubai’s culinary offering” (Ben East, 2015).
The U.A.E. is the most cosmopolitan and Westernized country in the Middle East.
Dubai positioned as an economic center for the Gulf area. With a history of both political and
social stability, there is no wonder that a large and skilled multicultural workforce has settled
here. 21st Century economic expansion has transformed the once traditional culture into a
multicultural tapestry. The mix of traditional and modern and of Eastern and Western cultures
has made working and doing business in Dubai a one-of-a-kind experience (Miller, 2011).
Dubai is small but has more cultural diversity per square foot than perhaps anywhere has in
the world. Of its two million inhabitants, only 100,000 are citizens (Krane, 2009).
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
36
A majority of the expats are from the sub-continent (India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh)
and GCC countries. The locals, called as Emiratis, are a friendly bunch and usually prefer to
stay to themselves. However, they do interact with expats professionally (“Life in Dubai for
Indians”, 2013). Many expatriates find it difficult to learn about the country, even if they
wish to do so. It's easy to visit museums, or to get out and about in the mountains. It is not so
easy, however, to forge relationships with Emiratis so as to learn about local culture and
traditions. Language can pose a problem, since many of the Emiratis who are most familiar
with traditional culture are often fluent in Arabic, but not in any other language. There are
places for all in the UAE's multicultural society, but these people feel ill at ease in a
multicultural environment, and that in it can make cultural interchange a difficult process.
Emiratis who are fluent in another language are often also at ease with foreign cultures. But
overall only a few are able or willing to transfer their knowledge of their own culture
(Hellyer, 2013).
2. Review of literature
Every society in this world has its own culture. All countries comprise of different
society, which follows different culture. Culture is the basis of every human and has its
influences on his life. Hofstede (2001) expressed that cultural values are earned very early in
life as people are socialized into their respective environments within particular societies and
are very difficult to relearn or change. Each society has its own beliefs, values, and practices.
Culture does have significant variations among the social life and people have respect for
their own culture. Culture has its deep roots in the life of every human being of any society.
Culture refers to the cumulative deposit of knowledge, experience, beliefs, values,
attitudes, meanings, hierarchies, religion, notions of time, roles, spatial relations, concepts of
the universe, and material objects and possessions acquired by a group of people in the course
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
37
of generations through individual and group striving (Samovar et.al, 2003). The ideas,
customs, and social behavior of a particular person or society are known as culture. Culture is
the systems of knowledge shared by a relatively large group of people. Culture is the sum of
the total of the learned behavior of a group of people that are generally considered to be the
tradition of those people and are transmitted from generation to generation. Culture is a
collective programming of the mind that distinguishes the members of one group or category
of people from another (Hofstede, 1980).
According to Jaeger (1990), each and everyone strongly attached to their culture.
There is also a great difference among the people in making decisions and thinking pattern,
which has its root, starts from the culture. An individual's behavior in an organization will
mainly be guided by the outside culture from which he or she comes. Also, he stresses that
these cultural values from the environment are brought into the workplace and have a strong
impact on the behavior of persons within the organization. The founder of the European
Community, Jean Monnet, once declared, “If I were again facing the challenge to integrate
Europe, I would probably start with culture.” Culture is the context in which things happen;
out of context, even legal matters lack significance (Trompenaars and Turner, 1998).
Culture refers to our way of life, including everything that is learned, shared, and
transmitted from one generation to the next. Although culture endures over time, it is not
static. Language, values, rules, beliefs, and even the material things we create are all part of
one’s culture (Bucher, 2008). An individual’s first experience of a new culture is the less
esoteric, more concrete factors. This level consists of explicit culture. Explicit culture is the
observable reality of the language, food, buildings, houses, monuments, agriculture, shrines,
markets, fashions, and art. They are the symbols of a deeper level of culture. Prejudices
mostly start on this symbolic and observable level (Trompenaars and Turner, 1998).
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
38
In the language of Clifford Geertz, culture is the means by which people
“communicate, perpetuate, and develop their knowledge about attitudes towards life. Culture
is the fabric of meaning in terms of which human beings interpret their experience and guide
their action” (Greetz, 1973). Intercultural language learning involves developing with
learners an understanding of their own language(s) and culture(s) in relation to an additional
language and culture. Learners engaged in intercultural language learning develop a reflective
stance towards language and culture, both specifically as instances of first, second, and
additional languages and cultures, and generally as understandings of the variable ways in
which language and culture exist in the world. Learning to communicate in an additional
language involves developing an awareness of the ways in which culture interrelates with
language whenever it is used (Liddicoat.et.al, 2003).
Multiculturalism can refer to a demographic actuality, a specific set of philosophical
thoughts, or a particular introduction by government or establishments to a diverse populace.
The vast majority of the level headed discussion over multiculturalism bases on whether open
multiculturalism is the suitable approach to manage diversity and immigrant integration. The
term multiculturalism is most often used in reference to Western nation-states, which had
seemingly achieved a de facto single national identity during the 18th and/or 19th centuries
(Kramsch et.al, 2011).
Multiculturalism has been official policy in several Western nations since the 1970s,
for reasons that varied from country to country, including the fact that many of the great
cities of the Western world are increasingly made of a mosaic of cultures (Claval, 2001).
Hills and Atkins (2012) demonstrated that expatriates from different regions, including the
national Gulf Arabs, claim to diverge from their home cultures and converge on several key
cultural attributes associated with a Western model of self, while the Westerners themselves
apparently claim no significant movement towards any of the local cultures. In the UAE there
-
International Conference on Emerging Research for Sustainable Economic Development (ERSED-2016)Dated: February 02-03, 2016 ISBN: 978-969-7599-01-1All Rights Reserved ®: KS Global Research, Malaysia
39
is also the added complexity of whether the minority local national society can maintain its
own cultural heritage in the face of such plurality (Raven and O'Donnell, 2010).
In UAE, Emiratis and resident expatriates socialize and get to know each other in
relatively very few places. It is uncommon for locals and foreigners to socialize together
outside of the work place or for Moslem expats the Masque. Emiratis maintain their identity
and culture (In Praise of Emirati Students, 2015). It shows up as though the UAE has
possessed the capacity to import the worldwide comforts and necessities of advancement and
globalization however has done as such through a customary lens, never taking their eye of
what is imperative in their lives. While it is genuine that as a country they have encountered
the amassing of riches at exceptional levels, it doesn't have seemed to have a huge effect on
the societal estimations of family, tribe, group, religion, and character that have made the
country what it is today (Al-Khazraji, 2009). Changes have come about with socioeconomic
changes following the discovery of oil. The number of educated families is rising rapidly;
socialization now takes place partially outside the family (El-Islam and Fakhr, 1983).
The increasing diversity and mobility of the world’s population means that
understanding individual cultures, while necessary, is no longer sufficient in explaining how
members of particular cultures behave in different situations. This is especially true in the
case of those who have internalized more than one culture and can be described as bicultural
or multicultural (Martínez and Haritatos, 2005).
It is not possible that people can have an impact of only one culture. A number of
cultures influence people. "Individuals, however, can be amazingly complex 'cultural
composites' (Schneider and Barsoux, 1997) who belongs to several cultural entities like
country, school, sports club, company at a single point in time or over the course of a
lifetime. At the same time, different culture influences People. Therefore,