integrated governance: a way to achieve competitive advantage

97
!"#$%&’#$( *+,$&"’"-$ ! #$% &’ !()*+,+ -’./+&*&*,+ !0,$1&$2+3

Upload: peter-flemming-t-sjoelin

Post on 29-Mar-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

An essay on how to achieve integrated governance and turn it into a competitive advantage.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"#$%&'#$()

*+,$&"'"-$

!"#$%"&'"!()*+,+"-'./+&*&*,+"!0,$1&$2+3

Page 2: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"#$%&'#$()*+,$&"'"-$.)

!"#$%"&'"!()*+,+"-'./+&*&*,+"!0,$1&$2+34

! "#$%&$'()*+&),$#-&.*)*/*'&)012)34#%,&*/*/5&)67518*19&2):()1,,'(/89)18);<)9#5&$818.&)=$1%&0#$>):12&7)#8)1)

4#+&$&8.()?1819&%&8*),1$17/9%@A):B*)7B&)*#).+189&2)/8)*+&),$#:'&%)2*1*&%&8*)187)*+&)2.#,&)#=)*+&),$#-&.*A);)+15&)

.+#2&8)*#)1'*&$)*+&)*/*'&)#=)*+&),$#-&.*C

"5"6$2+"4

Page 3: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,

!"!#$%&'(%!)!#$*+&%,--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- .

!"-"!/0%!#'$1*2%!*3!/042!5*$6-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- .

!"-7!50*!80*'&(!9%:(!/042!5*$6--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- .

!"-;!#$*+&%,!8<:<%,%=<--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------.

!"->!/0%!9%&:<4*=!<*!<0%!?*=@%1<!*3!AB+'24=%22-------------------------------------------------------------------------------C

!7!D%<0*(*&*EF-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------G

!7-"!H%&4,4<:<4*=------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I

!;!/0%!#:$:(4E,----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"J

!;-"!K11&F4=E!<0%!#:$:(4E,----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "J

!;-7!#$%,42%2!*3!<0%!#:$:(4E,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "J

!>!?*$1*$:<%!8<$:<%EF-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ""

!>-"!/0%!L=<$*('@<4*=----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------""

!>-7!/0%!A=<%$1$42%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ""

!>-;!/0%!?*=@%1<!*3!8<$:<%E4@!#&:==4=E----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ""

!>->!8@0**&2!*3!8<$:<%E4@!/0*'E0<--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"7

!>-.!/0%!?*=@%1<!*3!?*,1%<4<4M%!K(M:=<:E%---------------------------------------------------------------------------------";

!>-C!/0%!N$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EF------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ">

!>-O!8F2<%,4@!/04=64=E------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ".

!>-G!/0%!N'24=%22!D*(%&----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------".

!>-I!P%:(%$2041-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"C

!>-"J!?*,,'=4@:<4*=---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"C

!>-""!H42@'224*=!*3!<0%!N$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EF-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"C

!>-"7!Q=!?*$1*$:<%!8<$:<%EF---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "O

!.!L/!8<$:<%EF-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "I

!.-"!/0%!9%&:<4*=2041!N%<R%%=!8<$:<%EF!)!S*M%$=:=@%--------------------------------------------------------------- "I

!.-7!/0%!L/!2<$:<%EF------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"I

!.-;!/0%!8%1:$:<%(!8<$:<%EF!K11$*:@0-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------7J

!.-;-"!T4=(4=E2!3*$!<0%!8%1:$:<%(!8<$:<%EF!K11$*:@0----------------------------------------------------------------7"

!.->!/0%!L=<%E$:<%(!8<$:<%EF!K11$*:@0------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 77

!.->-"!/0%!K&4E=,%=<!#0:2%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 7>

!.->-7!U:&'%!K((4=E-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------7C

!.->-;!/0%!?0:=E%!D:=:E%,%=<!#0:2%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7O

!.-.!T4=(4=E2!*3!<0%!L=<%E$:<%(!8<$:<%EF!K11$*:@0------------------------------------------------------------------------ 7G

!.-C!Q=!L/!2<$:<%EF------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7I

!C!L/!B!S*M%$=:=@%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------;"

!C-"!T*$,2!*3!E*M%$=:=@%-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ;7

!C-7!H42@'224*=!*3!L/!S*M%$=:=@%--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------;.

!C-7-"!?$4<4@42,!*3!L/!:=(!?*,1%<4<4M%!K(M:=<:E%------------------------------------------------------------------- ;.

!C-;!Q=!L/!S*M%$=:=@%-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------;C

!O!Q$E:=4V:<4*=!)!5*$63*$@%!#&:==4=E---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ;G

!O-"!/0%!9*&%!*3!D:=:E%,%=<--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------;G

!O-7!/0%!Q$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!L<2!#$*1%$<4%2--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ;I

!O-;!/$:=23*$,4=E!<0%!A=<%$1$42%--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >"

!O->!Q=!Q$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!L<2!L,1:@<---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------->;

!G!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >.

!G-"!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!:=(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%--------------------------------------------------------------->O

!G-7!L,1&%,%=<4=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------>G

!G-;!/0%!W*&42<4@!#%$21%@<4M%--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >I

!"!#$%&!'

Page 4: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!G->!Q=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- >I

!I!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------."

!I-"!/0%!?*=@%1<!*3!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ."

!I-7!S*4=E!3$*,!L/!<*!W*&42<4@!D:=:E%,%=<--------------------------------------------------------------------------------- .7

!I-;!L=2<4<'<4*=:&4V4=E!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.>

!I->!Q=!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- .>

!"J!K!T$:,%R*$6!3*$!L,1&%,%=<4=E!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%--------------------------------------------------------------.C

!"J-"!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------.C

!"J-7!/0%!T$:,%R*$6---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------.I

!"J-;!L<%$:<4*=2!/*R:$(2!:!8'2<:4=:+&%!?*,1%<4<4M%!K(M:=<:E%----------------------------------------------------C"

!"J->!U4$<'%2!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- C>

!"J->-"!#$*('@4+4&4<F------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------C>

!"J->-7!K(:1<:+4&4<F-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------C.

!"J->-;!?*,1:<4+4&4<F---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- C.

!""!?*=@&'24*=------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CC

!""-"!50:<!42!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%X------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CC

!""-7!W*R!42!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!@*,+4=%(!R4<0!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<X----------------------------CO

!""-;!W*R!@:=!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!:=(!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!+%!@*,+4=%(!4=!:!24=E&%!

3$:,%R*$6X------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CG

!""->!W*R!(*%2!<0%!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!A=:+&%!:=!Q$E:=4V:<4*=!<*!K@04%M%!?*,1%<4<4M%!

K(M:=<:E%X------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CG

!"7!H42@'224*=-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------OJ

!"7-"!50:<!?:=!+%!P%:$=%(!T$*,!/042!9%M4%RX---------------------------------------------------------------------------OJ

!"7-7!T'$<0%$!8<'(4%2----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------O"

!";!K11%=(4Y---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------O7

!">!A=@&*2'$%!"----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- O;

!">-"!8@0**&2!*3!8<$:<%E4@!/0*'E0<------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------O;

!">-"-"!/0%!H%24E=!8@0**&-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- O;

!">-"-"-"!#$%,42%2-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------O>

!">-"-"-7!?$4<4Z'%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------O>

!">-"-7!/0%!#&:==4=E!8@0**&----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- O.

!">-"-7-"!#$%,42%2-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------O.

!">-"-7-7!?$4<4Z'%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------OC

!">-"-;!/0%!A=<$%1$%=%'$!8@0**&-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------OO

!">-"-;-"!#$%,42%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ OO

!">-"-;-7!?$4<4Z'%------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------OG

!">-7!/0%!8<$:<%E4@!8@0**&2----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OG

!">-;!T*'$!T*$,2!*3!N$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EF----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- GJ

!".!A=@&*2'$%!7----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- G7

!".-"!/0%!8%1:$:<%(!8<$:<%EF!K11$*:@0-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------G7

!".-7!/0%!L=<%E$:<%(!8<$:<%EF!K11$*:@0---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- GO

!".-7-"!/0%!8<$:<%EF!K$<4@'&:<4*=!#$*@%22---------------------------------------------------------------------------------GG

!".-7-7!/0%!K&4E=,%=<!#0:2%---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- GI

!".-7-;!U:&'%!K((4=E-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------I"

!".-7->!/0%!?0:=E%!D:=:E%,%=<!#0:2%----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I7

!".-7-.!/0%!L,1&%,%=<:<4*=!#0:2%--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------I>

!"!#$%&!(

Page 5: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"!#$%&!)

Page 6: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&-& ./%$01%&2&./'#$%3

/0%$% ! :$% !,:=F ! *$E:=4V:<4*=2 ! <0:< ! %Y1%$4%=@% ! 1$*+&%,2 !R4<0 ! E:4=4=E ! 2<$:<%E4@ ! :(M:=<:E%2 ! +F!

:11&F4=E!L/![!E*M%$=:=@%\!:=(!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!*3<%=!%Y1%$4%=@%!<0:<!L/!4=!*=%!R:F!*$!<0%!*<0%$!42!

@*=24(%$%(!:!&4:+4&4<F!:=(!:!=*<:+&%!$426!3*$!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!4=2<%:(!*3!:=!:(M:=<:E%!:=(!:=!%=:+&%$-

K'<0*$2!:=(!<0%*$%<4@2!2'EE%2<2!M:$4*'2!3$:,%R*$62!<0:<!4=!*=%!R:F!*$!<0%!*<0%$!20*'&(!E4M%!<0%!

%Y%@'<4M%!E$*'1!*$!,4((&%!,:=:E%,%=<!<0%!4=4<4:<4M%!<*!1%$2':(%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!

=%%( !*3 ! L/!:2 ! := !%=:+&%$ !+'< ! 3:4& ! <* ! $%@*E=4V% ! <0:< ! <0%4$ !1:$<4@'&:$ ! 3$:,%R*$6 !(*%2=]< ! 2'4< ! :=!

4=<%E$:<%(!:11$*:@0!<*!E*M%$=:=@%-

L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!4=M%2<4E:<%!<0%!1$*+&%,!<0$*'E0!:!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!R0%$%!L!R4&&!R*$6!R4<0!M:$4*'2!

<0%*$%<4@:&!:11$*:@0%2!<*!0*R!L/BE*M%$=:=@%!:=(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!+%!@*,+4=%(!<*!@$%:<%!

:=!:11$*:@0!<0:<!%=:+&%2!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<*!E:4=!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!L<!42!:+!:11$*:@0!*=!0*R!

<*!4,1&%,%=<!:!0*&42<4@!2<F&%!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!<0$*'E0!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

L=!,F!%33*$<!<*!*1%$:<4*=:&4V%!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R\!L!0:M%!:$<4@'&:<%(!:!1$*+&%,!2<:<%,%=<!^1-!._-

!"#"!$%&!'()*+,&!+-!$%.,!/+)0

/042!1$*`%@< !:=(!<042!1:1%$! 42 !:!1$%B2<'(F!*3!,F!,:2<%$! <0%242! <0:<!L !1&:=!<*!R$4<% ! <042!:'<',=!

^K'<',=!7J"J!:=(!+%E4==4=E!*3!<0%!F%:$!7J""_-!L!R4&&!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!0%$,%=%'<4@!1:$:(4E,!<*!

4=M%2<4E:<%!<0%!4=(4M4(':&!<%Y<2!:=(!<*!,:6%!2%=2%!*3!<0%!2<'(F!:@$*22!M:$4*'2!(42@41&4=%27-

!"#1!/%+!2%+(34!5&64!$%.,!/+)0

/042 ! (*@',%=< ! <:$E%<2 ! <0% !(%@424*= !,:6%$2 ! 4= ! <0% !*$E:=4V:<4*= ! %-E-\ ! <0% !?AQ\ !?LQ\ !N*:$( !*3!

H4$%@<*$2\!<0%!,4((&%!,:=:E%$2!*$!<0*2%!4=!@0:$E%!*3!2<$:<%E4@!1$*E$:,2!:=(!1$*`%@<2-

/0%F!@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3!<042!R*$6!3*$!4=214$:<4*=!*=!0*R!<*!4=4<4:<%!:=(!,:<'$%!<0%4$!*R=!E*M%$=:=@%!

1$*E$:,2-

!"#7!')+83&9!2:6:&9&;:

/042!1$*`%@<!R4&&!3*@'2!*=!0*R!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!@:=!+%!@*,+4=%(!<*!

@$%:<%!:!3$:,%R*$6!<0:<!@:=!&%:(!<*!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!L!0:M%!:$<4@'&:<%(!3*'$!Z'%2<4*=2!<0:<!

R4&&!:4(%!,%!4=!<0%!*1%$:<4*=:&4V:<4*=!*3!<042!2<'(F-

"_ 50:<!42!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%X

7 /0%!M:$4*'2!(42@41&4=%2!R4&&!+%!*$E:=4V%(!:=(!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!=%Y<!@0:1<%$-

!"!#$%&!*

Page 7: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

7_ W*R!42!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!@*,+4=%(!R4<0!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<X

;_ W*R!@:= ! L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@% ! :=( !?*0%$%=@F !D:=:E%,%=< ! +% ! @*,+4=%( ! 4= ! : ! 24=E&%!

3$:,%R*$6X

>_ W*R ! (*%2 ! <0% ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! E*M%$=:=@% ! %=:+&% ! := ! *$E:=4V:<4*= ! <* ! :@04%M% ! @*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%X

!"#<!$%&!5&36:.+;!:+!:%&!=+;>&*:!+-!?@8(,.;&,,

/042 ! 1:1%$ ! 42 ! +:2%( ! *= ! <0% ! :22',1<4*= ! <0:< ! L=3*$,:<4*= !/%@0=*&*EF ! @:= ! %=:+&% ! @*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%2!R0%=!:11&4%(!@*$$%@<&F-

/0%!:22',1<4*=!0:2!&%(!,%!<*!+%&4%M%!<0:<!L/!:=(!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!:!1:$<!*3!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!

%B+'24=%22!24=@%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@0*2%2!<*!<:6%!@0:$E%!*3!4<2!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!:=(!'2%!L/!<*!

*1<4,4V%!4<2!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2-!50%=!@0:=E4=E!<0%!1$*@%22%2!<*!:&<%$!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!<0%=!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!0:=(&%!1*&4@4%2!3*$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!@:=!,:6%!$:<4*=:&!(%@424*=2!<0:<!

4,1:@<2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!1*24<4M%&F!4=!<0%!3'<'$%-

?0:33%F!(%34=%2!%B+'24=%22!:2!:!@*=@%1<!*3!R04@0!:=!%=<%$1$42%!42!(%24E=4=E!4<2!1$*@%22%2!:$*'=(!:=(!

'1*=!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*E4%2!:=(!4=<%E$:<%!<0%!1$*@%22%2!R4<0!L?/-

!"#$%&'&()*+%$**&#'*&,)--.&+%/$01'/$2&+%,314'/+3%&'%2&5344)%+5'/+3%&/$5#%3-30+$*&6789*: &

+%/3 & /#$+1 & 3;$1'/+3%*< & ;3/$%/+'--. & 1$2$*+0%+%0 & +/* & ()*+%$** & ;135$**$* & '13)%2 & 789 & 31 &

534;-$/$-.&1$+%=$%/+%0&+/*&()*+%$**&432$-&>?&$@()*+%$**<&+*&)%2$1*/332&/3&($&/#$&+%/$01'/+3%&

3,&'--&/#$*$&'5/+=+/+$*&A+/#&/#$&+%/$1%'-&;135$**$*&3,&()*+%$**&/#13)0#&789&6B97<&CDDD:&!&

@&!"#$$%&&^?0:33%F!7JJI\!1-!";_-

/042 ! 0:2 ! &%( ! <* !,F ! @&:22434@:<4*= ! <0:< ! <042 ! 2<'(F ! 42 ! %B+'24=%22 ! $%&:<%( ! 24=@% ! 4< ! 42 ! 4= ! +%<R%%=!

L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF\!N'24=%22!:=(!#*&4@F-!/042!42!4&&'2<$:<%(!+&*R-

!"!#$%&!+

7--)*/1'/+3%&EF&9#$&+2$%/+,+5'/+3%&

3,&$@()*+%$**?

,- ./012&00

#34156!7!8$9

Page 8: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"!#$%&!:

Page 9: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&4& 5%+6'1'$'78

/042!2<'(F!42!(%24E=%(!:2!:!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R-!L=!<0%!$%M4%R!L!R4&&!4=M%2<4E:<%!M:$4*'2!<0%*$4%2!3$*,!

<0%!210%$%!*3!2<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E!)!,:=:E%,%=<\!<%@0=*&*EF!1&:==4=E\!L/BE*M%$=:=@%\!R*$63*$@%!

1&:==4=E!:=(!A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$%- !/0%!2%Z'%=@%!*3 ! &4<%$:<'$%! 42 !1$%2%=<%( ! 4= ! <0% ! 4&&'2<$:<4*=!

+%&*R-!L<!42!=*<:+&%!<0:<!L!0:M%!R*$6%(!R4<0!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!2<$:<%E4@!,:=:E%,%=<!^@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF_!42!<0%!&%:(4=E!3*$,!*3!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!*<0%$!2<$:<%E4%2!0:M%!<*!+%!:&4E=%(!R4<0!4<-

7--)*/1'/+3%&CF&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&'%2&/#$&*$H)$%5$&3,&/#$31.?

/*!'=@*M%$!0*R!<042!1:1%$!R4&&!:11$*:@0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!<0%=!L!0:M%!*'<&4=%(!

R0:<!<0%!34M%!@0:1<%$2!R4&&!(%:&!R4<0-

._ 8<$:<%E4@!D:=:E%,%=<-!!/0%!@0:1<%$!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!2<$:<%E4@!,:=:E%,%=<!^D4=<V+%$E!"II.!

)!7JJI\!#*$<%$!"IG._!:=(!<0%!2@0**&2!:=(!:21%@<2!*3!2<$:<%E4@!,:=:E%,%=<-!

C_ /%@0=*&*EF!#&:==4=E!^L/!2<$:<%EF_-!/0%!@0:1<%$!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!L/!2<$:<%E4%2!^#*<<2!7JJI\!

9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI_!:=(!0*R!L/!2<$:<%E4%2!@:=!+%!:$<4@'&:<%(-

O_ L/!S*M%$=:=@%-!/0%!@0:1<%$!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!0*R!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!:11&4%(-!/%@0=4@:&&F!

<0%!<0%*$4%2!1$%2%=<%(!+F!9*22!)!5%4&&!^7JJ>_!R4&&!+%!(42@'22%(-

G_ 5*$6!T*$@%!#&:==4=E-!/0%!@0:1<%$!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!0*R!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^1%*1&%_!@0:=E%!<*!

R*$6!R4<04=!<0%!+*'=(:$4%2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!^Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!

"IIJ!:=(!W:,%&!7JJG_-

!"!#$%&!;

<3=>?3=5&!#4$2212%

)@

-&5A2343%6!#4$2212%

'@ ,-!B3C&=2$25&

(@

D2E&=F=10&G=5A1E&5E/=&

*@

!"#$%&'#$()*+,$&"'"-$

HE=$E&%15I$2$%&J&2E

K@

Page 10: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

I_ A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-!/0%!@0:1<%$!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!0*R!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!(%:&!

R4<0!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!^N%$=:$(!7JJ>_!:=(!,:6%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!1*224+&%-

"J_ ?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:=(!<0%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%2!*3!,:<'$4=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!

^H*'@%<!%<!:&-!7JJI_-

""_ L,1&%,%=<4=E!<0%!3$:,%R*$6!4=!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=-!/0%!@0:1<%$!R4&&!+%!(%:&4=E!R4<0!:=!

:11$*:@0!<0:<!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!:22',1<4*=2!:=(!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!<0%!4=(4M4(':&!14%@%2!*3!

<0%*$F-

/0%$%<*!R4&&!:!@0:1<%$!(%:&4=E!R4<0!<0%!@*=@&'24*=!+%!4=@&'(%(!:=(!&46%R42%!R4&&!:!@0:1<%$!(%:&4=E!

R4<0!:!(42@'224*=!*3!<0%!34=(4=E2!*3!<042!1:1%$!+%!4=@&'(%(!4=!<0%!1:1%$-

!1#"!A&3.9.:6:.+;

50%= !R*$64=E !R4<0 ! <042 ! &4<%$:<'$% ! $%M4%R ! L !R4&& ! *=&F ! (%:& !R4<0 ! <0% ! <0%*$%<4@:& ! :11$*:@0 ! :=(!

<0%$%3*$%!=*<!4=@&'(%!@:2%2!*$!*1%$:<4*=:&4V%!<0%!<0%*$F!*=!:!1:$<4@'&:$!@:2%-

!"!#$%&!L

Page 11: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&9& !6%&."/"1:73

L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!0%$,%=%'<4@2!1:$:(4E,-!/042!,%:=2!<0:<!%:@0!4=(4M4(':&!<%Y<!L!R4&&!

+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!4=!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!@:=!+%!2%%=!+*<0!4=! 4<2! 4=(4M4(':&! <%Y<2!*$!4=!:!&:$E%$!

@*=<%Y<!^8*==4@02%=!7JJI\!11-!>B._-

!7#"!B**3C.;D!:%&!'6)64.D9

L!1&:=!<*!$%:(!<0%!+**62!*=!<0%!M:$4*'2!(42@41&4=%!:0%:(!*3!R0%=!L!:,!R$4<4=E!<0%!$%M4%R!*3!<0%!

&4<%$:<'$%!4=!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!34%&(-!L!R4&&!<0%=!<$F!<*!:((!:M:4&:+&%!2*'$@%2!<*!%:@0!*3!<0%!(42@41&4=%2!:=(!

3*$,!<0:<!R$4<% !:!20*$< !@*=@&'24*=!3*$ !%:@0!(42@41&4=%- !/0%! &4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!R4&& !+%!@*=@&'(%(!

<0$*'E0!:!3*$,:& !@*=@&'24*= !*=! <0%!1$*+&%,!2<:<%,%=<\ !+'< !:&2* ! <0$*'E0!:!,*(%& !(%:&4=E!R4<0!

4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!0*R!4<!42!:@04%M%(!4=!:=!%=<%$1$42%-

!7#1!')&9.,&,!+-!:%&!'6)64.D9

K@@*$(4=E!<*!8*==4@02%=!<0%=!<0%!0%$,%=%'<4@!@4$@&%!@*=242<!*3!O!1$4=@41&%2!<0:<!0:M%!<*!+%!(%:&<!

R4<0-!/0%!34$2<!1$4=@41&%!42!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!4=(4M4(':&!<%Y<2!4=!<0%4$!4=(4M4(':&!@*=<%Y<2!!:=(!<0%!<%Y<2!

0:M%!:2!R%&&!<*!+%!2%%=!4=!:!&:$E%$!@*=<%Y<-!/042!@:=!+%!4(%=<434%(!:2!:!1*24<4M%!@4$@&%-!/0%!2%@*=(!

1$4=@41&%!42!<0:<!R0%=!<0%!:=:&F<4@:&!:11$*:@0!<*!:!<%Y<!:=(!<0%!:=:&F<4@:&!1$*@%22!%=(2!R4<0!<0%!<%Y<!

R0%= ! 4< ! E4M%2 ! : ! &*E4@:& !,%:=4=E- !/0% ! <04$( ! 1$4=@41&% ! *3 ! <0% ! 0%$,%=%'<4@ ! @4$@&% ! 42 ! <* ! <%2< ! <0%!

4=<%$1$%<:<4*=!4=!<0%!*M%$:&&!@*=<%Y<!:=(!4=!<0%!@*=<%Y<!*3!R0:<!R:2!R$4<<%=!+F!<0%!:'<0*$!4=!042!

@*=<%Y<-!/0%!3*'$<0!1$4=@41&%!0:2!<*!+%!:11&4%(!:=(!4<!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!<0%!<%Y<!(%:&2!R4<0!4<2%&3!4=!!4<2!

@*=<%Y<-!/0%!343<0!1$4=@41&%!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!<0%!<%Y<!:=(!:2!2'@0!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!<*!

'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!<%Y<!4=!3'&&-!/0%!24Y<0!1$4=@41&%!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!4=<%$1$%<:<4*=!*3!R0:<!<0%!:'<0*$!*3!<0%!

$%M4%R!+%&4%M%2!42!<0%!4=<%$1$%<:<4*=!:=(!4<!(%:&2!R4<0!R0:<!1$%`'(4@%!<0%!4=<%$1$%<%$!^:'<0*$!*3!<0%!

$%M4%R_!+$4=E2!R4<0!04,-!/0%!2%M%=<0!:=(!&:2<!1$4=@41&%!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!:((4<4*=!*3!@$%:<4M4<F!:=(!

M:&'%!<0$*'E0!,%:=4=E!<*!<0%!4=(4M4(':&!<%Y<2!:=(!<0%!*M%$:&&!@*=<%Y<-

!"!#$%&!KM

Page 12: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&;& )'/<'/"+%&=+/"+%78

!<#"!$%&!E;:)+4(>:.+;

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!:=(!0*R!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!:$<4@'&:<%(\!R0:<!$*&%!4<!

1&:F2!:=(!R0:<!1:$<4@'&:$!2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!<0:<!%Y42<-!/0%$%<*!42!<0%!4(%:!*3!a@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%b!

+%!1$%2%=<%(!:=(!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!3*@'2!*=!:11&F!<0%,-! !/0%!&:2<!1:$<!*3!<0%!@0:1<%$!42!

(%:&4=E!R4<0!:!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!*=!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

!<#1!$%&!?;:&)*).,&

N%3*$%!<0%!4=4<4:&!4(%:2!*=!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!1$%2%=<%(!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!(%34=%!R0:<!:=!

%=<%$1$42% ! 42- !/0% ! <%$, ! %=<%$1$42% !R4&& ! +% ! '2%( ! <0$*'E0 ! <042 ! $%M4%R ! :2 ! (%2@$4+4=E ! @*,1:=4%2\!

@*$1*$:<4*=2!:=(!2*@4:&!2F2<%,2!^*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!2<$'@<'$%!:=(!@'&<'$%_!<0:<!<0$*'E0!<0%4$!:@<4M4<4%2!

1$*M4(%!1$*('@<2!*$!2%$M4@%2-

/0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:=!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<0:<!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!2*@4:&!2F2<%,2!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!+'<!4=@&'(%2!

,*$%!%-E-\!<%@0=4@:&!4=3$:2<$'@<'$%!^L/\!D:@04=%2\!?:$2!%<@-_!:=(!:(,4=42<$:<4*=!:=(!%@*=*,F-!K=!

%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%!+*<0!R4<04=!<0%!1'+&4@!2%@<*$!:=(!1$4M:<%!2%@<*$!:=(!4<!@:=!+%!4=!+%<R%%=-

/0%!(%34=4<4*=!42!<0:<! !:=!%=<%$1$42%!42!:!2*@4:&!2F2<%,!^*$E:=4V:<4*=_!<0:<!4=@&'(%2!<0%!<%@0=4@:&\!

%@*=*,4@!:=(!:(,4=42<$:<4M%!:21%@<2-!L=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!<0%!1'$1*2%!*3!:=!%=<%$1$42%!42!<*!@$%:<%!

M:&'%-!U:&'%!42!(%34=%(!:2!+%4=E!R0:<!42!:22',%(!:2!M:&'%!+F!<0%!@'2<*,%$-!K!@'2<*,%$!@:=!+%!+*<0!

R4<04=!: !2*@4:& !2F2<%,!^R4<0! 4= !:=!*$E:=4V:<4*=_!*$! <* !@'2<*,%$2!*'<24(%!<0% !%=<%$1$42%- !L= ! <042!

1%$21%@<4M%!+*<0!1'+&4@!2%@<*$!%=<%$1$42%2!:=(!1$4M:<%!2%@<*$!%=<%$1$42%2!@:=!E%=%$:<%!M:&'%-!/0%!

(433%$%=@%!+%<R%%=!<0%!<R*!2%@<*$2!42!<0:<!<0%!1$4M:<%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!E%=%$:<%!$%M%='%!<0$*'E0!

2%&&4=E!1$*('@<2!<*!<0%!@*=2',%$2!:=(!<0%!@*=2',%$2!(%@4(%!43!<0%!1$*('@<!42!E**(!%=*'E0-!/0%!

%=<%$1$42%!R4<04=!<0%!1'+&4@!2%@<*$!:$%!'2':&&F!2'+2<4<'<%(!+F!E*M%$=,%=<!:=(!@:=!<0%$%3*$%!6%%1!*=!

2'$M4M4=E!%M%=!43!4<!<0%!%@*=*,4@!3'=(:,%=<!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!%M%=!43!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!(*%2=]<!E%=%$:<%!

1$*34<2-

/0%!531;31'/$&*/1'/$0.!42!2F=*=F,*'2!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!:!+'24=%22!2<$:<%EF!:=(!@:=!+%!(%34=%(!:2!

:!1&:=!3*$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!2'11*2%(!<*!(*!+'24=%22-

!<#7!$%&!=+;>&*:!+-!2:)6:&D.>!'36;;.;D

8<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E!42!(%34=%(!:2!+%4=E!<0%!2%224*=!*3!R04@0!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!*$!*<0%$!,%,+%$2!R4<04=!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!(%34=%2!0*R!:=!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!$%:@0!4<2!E*:&2\!:=(!3$*,!<0:<!4<!@:=!+%!(%('@%(!<0:<!

!"!#$%&!KK

Page 13: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E!42!<0%!1$*@%22!*3!R04@0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!(%34=4=E!4<2!2<$:<%EF-!

D4=<V+%$E!'2%2!4=!042!R*$6!a/0%!9:42%!:=(!T:&& !*3!8<$:<%E4@!#&:==4=Eb!(433%$%=<!M4%R2!*3!R0:<!

2<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E!42!:=(!0*R!4<!@:=!+%!:11&4%(!4=!:!,*(%$=!@*=<%Y<-!

Q=%!*3!<0%!:$E',%=<2!<0:<!D4=<V+%$E!:11&4%2!42!<0:<!2<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E!,4E0<!=*<!+%!$%&%M:=<!3*$!<0%!

,:$6%<!24=@%!<0%!,:$6%<!,4E0<!+%!%Y1*2%(!<*!0F1%$!@*,1%<4<4*=-!WF1%$!@*,1%<4<4*=!42!:!2%$4%2!*3!

:@<4*=2!R4<04=!<0%!(*,4=*!*3!R04@0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!*1%$:<%2-

D4=V<+%$E!@:,%!<*! <0%!@*=@&'24*=!<0:<! <0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2 !2<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!(%<%$,4=%(!+F!4<2!

1$*`%@<2!@*,1:$%(!<*!4<2!2<$:<%E4@!1&:=\!&46%R42%!@:=!<0%!&%:(%$2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!+%!:!24E=!*3!

R0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!(%:&2!R4<0!^D4=<V+%$E!"II.\!1-!""J_-!

A=<%$1$42%2 ! <0:< !*M%$ !%,10:24V%2 ! <0% !2<$:<%E4@ !1&:==4=E !1$*@%22 !,422%2 ! <0% !%,+*(4,%=< !*3 ! <0%!

2<$:<%EF-!/0%!%,+*(4,%=<!42!0*R!<0%!&%:(%$2!:@<!R4<04=!<0%!2*@4:&!2F2<%,!<*!4,1&%,%=<!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!

1&:=-!L<!42!:$E':+&%!43!<0%!<*1!,:=:E%,%=<!42!=*<!@*,,4<<%(!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!@*1%!R4<0!<0%!

@0:&&%=E%2 ! :=( ! @0:=E%2 ! <0:< ! :$% ! R4<04= ! 4<2 ! (*,4=* ! <0%= ! <0% ! 2<$:<%E4@ ! 1&:==4=E ! 1$*@%22 ! 42!

,%:=4=E&%22-

!<#<!2>%++3,!+-!2:)6:&D.>!$%+(D%:

D4=<V+%$E!%<!:&-!0:2!(%M%&*1%(!:!=':=@%(!M4%R!*3!0*R!<0%!M:$4*'2!2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!<0:<!0:M%!+%%=!

(%M%&*1%(!*M%$!<4,%\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!4=@&'(%!<0%4$!M4%R2!4=!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R-!L!

0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&\ !1&:==4=E!2@0**&!:=(!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&- !/0%!

$%:2*=!3*$!<042!42!<0:<!3*'=(!<0%2%!2@0**&2!,*2<&F!$%&%M:=<!3*$!<0%!1'$1*2%!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%-!

c*'!@:=!$%:(!,*$%!:+*'<!<0%!<0$%%!2@0**&2!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!R*$6!R4<04=!<0%!!"#$%!&'()*$+#&-

/0%!<0$%%!2@0**&2!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!:2!+%4=E!$%&%M:=<!<*!<042!2<'(F!4=!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!42!<0%!

(%24E=!2@0**&\!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!:=(!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&-!DF!$%:2*=!3*$!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%2%!

2@0**&2!R0%$%!<0:<!<0%F!:&&!@*=<:4=2!Z':&4<4%2!<0:<!:$%!4,1*$<:=<!<*!(%M%&*1!:!24E=434@:=<!2<$:<%EF-!L=!

<0%!*<0%$!0:=(!<0%!2@0**&2!(*!:&2*!@*=<:4=!M:$4*'2!R%:6=%22%2!<0:<!:$%!:(($%22%(!4=!<0%!%=@&*2'$%-

Q=%!,:`*$!R%:6=%22!<0:<!:&&!*3!<0%!<0$%%!2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!:$%!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!42!<0:<!<0%F!0:$(&F!

:(($%22 ! <0%!%=<%$1$42%! 4= !: !2F2<%,4@!R:F\ ! <0%!*=&F!%Y@%1<4*=! 42 ! <0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$4:& !2@0**&- !/0%!

%=<$%1$%=%'$4:&!2@0**&!,4E0<!<04=6!4=!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!+%@:'2%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:!2,:&&!%=<4<F!

:=(!<0%$%3*$%!,:=:E%:+&%d!0*R%M%$!4<!:&2*!2'33%$2!3$*,!<0:<!,*2<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%E4@:&!:11$*:@0%2!:$%!

<:@4<\!:=(!=*$,:&&F!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!<0:<!:$%!@*,1*2%(!:$%=]<!1$*+%(!R4<04=!:!2F2<%,:<4@!,%<0*(-!H'%!

<0%!]'=&4,4<%(!1*R%$]!<0:<!<0%!,:=:E%$!:=(!3*'=(%$!*3!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!*$E:=4V:<4*=!0:2!<0%=!4<!42!

(4334@'&<!3*$!4=(4M4(':&2!R0*!,4E0<!0:M%!:!2&4E0<&F!(433%$%=<!:11$*:@0!<*!<0%!2<$:<%EF!:$<4@'&:<4*=!<*!

!"!#$%&!K'

Page 14: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

@*,%!R4<0!2'EE%2<4*=2!<*!4,1$*M%!<0%!2<$:<%EF-

/0%!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!=%%(2!<*!+%!:!1:$<!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!<$:=23*$,4=E!R04&%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

42!@0:=E4=E!R04&%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!4,1&%,%=<%(-

50%=!:(($%224=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!4=!:!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!<04=6!:=(!R*$6!R4<0!

:!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0\!<042!,4E0<!&%:(!<*!<0%!:(:1<4*=!*3!<0%!4(%:!<0:<!:!@%=<$:&4V%(!1&:==%(!2<$:<%EF!

:=(!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!:11$*:@0!42!@&*2%!<*!4,1*224+&%!3*$!:!@*,1&%Y!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!*1%$:<%2!4=!:!

8@0',1%<%$4:=!@*,1%<4<4*=!^D4=V<+%$E!7JJG\!1-!""J_-!L=!2'@0!24<':<4*=2!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!0:M%!<*!'2%!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*`%@<2!<*!+%!<0%!E'4(4=E!:11$*:@0!<*!R0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

R:=<2!<*!:@04%M%-!H*'@%<!%<!:&!^7JJI_!:$E'%2!<0:<!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!*3!<0%!3'<'$%!R4&&!2%%!

,'@0!,*$%!:@<4M4<F!:=(!4=4<4:<4M%2!4=!<0%!(*,:4=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!1$4,:$F!3*@'2!*3!:=F!E**(!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!R*$64=E!<*R:$(2!E:4=4=E!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!

D4@0:%&!A-!#*$<%$!1$*1*2%2!:=!4=<%$%2<4=E!(%34=4<4*=!*=!R0:<!2<$:<%EF!42!:&&!:+*'<!:=(!<0:<!42!R0:<!

<0%!=%Y<!2%@<4*=!(%:&2!R4<0-

!<#F!$%&!=+;>&*:!+-!=+9*&:.:.G&!B4G6;:6D&

T*$!:=!%=<%$1$42%!@:==*<!2'2<:4=!:! &%:(4=E!1*24<4*=!R4<04=!4<2 ! 4=('2<$F!43 ! <0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2=]< !:!

@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!#*$<%$!(42@'22%2!4=!042!"IIG!1:1%$!aN:@6!<*!8<$:<%EFb!<0:<!42!3*@'24=E!*=!

*1%$:<4*=:&!%334@4%=@F!R4&&!=*<!&%:(!<*!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-

50%=!21%:64=E!*3!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%!@:=!*=&F!+%!%=:+&%(!<0$*'E0!2%M%$:&!1$*@%22%2!^:@<4M4<4%2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%_!:=(!<0%!

@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!0:2!<*!+%!2'2<:4=:+&%!+%3*$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!:@04%M%!2'@@%22-

L<!42!<0%$%3*$%!4,1*$<:=<!<0:<!<0%!,:=:E%,%=<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:(($%22%2!<0:<!<0%F!20*'&(!(*!,*$%!

<0:=!`'2<!*=%!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*@%22!*$!:@<4M4<F!R%&&\!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!4<2!:@<4M4<4%2!4=!:!

0*&42<4@!R:F!%-E-\!R*$64=E!R4<0!%334@4%=@F\!1$*@%22!$%(%24E=\!:(:1<!1$*@%22%2!<*!@*1%!R4<0!<0%!=%R%2<!

<%@0=*&*EF!:=(!&:2<!+'<!=*<!&%:2<!<$F4=E!<*!@*1%!R4<0!04$4=E!<0%!$4E0<!1%*1&%-!?*,1:$%(!<*!0*&42<4@!

,:=:E%,%=<!<0%=!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!2%%6!=%R!:(($%22!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!24=@%!4<!0:2!<*!:&4E=!

M:$4*'2!3*$,2!*3!E*M%$=:=@%\!,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!&%:(%$2041!<*!:@04%M%!<0:<!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!

:@<4M4<4%2!@:=!%=:+&%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4<0!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!Q=%!24E=434@:=<!%&%,%=<!<0:<!@:=]<!

+%!=%E&%@<%(!4=!R*$64=E!R4<0!1$*@%22%2!42!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&\!:=(!<0:<!42!R0:<!T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!

^7JJO_!:(($%22%2!4=!<0%!+**6!:=(!2<$:<%E4@!:11$*:@0!<4<&%(!a/0%!N$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EFb!<0:<!R4&&!+%!

0:=(&%(!4=!<0%!=%Y<!2%@<4*=-

L=!$%&:<4*=!<*!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<0%=!<0%!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!R4&& !+%!(%:&< !R4<0!<0$*'E0!<0%!

!"!#$%&!K(

Page 15: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

'=@*M%$4=E!1$*@%22!:=(!<0$*'E0!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!<0:<!0:2!+%%=!%=:+&%(!+F!<0%!0*&42<4@!M4%R!*3!

0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-

!<#H!$%&!I)&60+(:!2:)6:&DC

T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!^T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!7JJO\!11-GB"Cd!"G>_!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!&%:(%$2041!0:2!<*!

2%%!<0%4$!+'24=%22!,*(%&!:=(!M:&'%!1$*1*24<4*=!:2!:!2F2<%,4@!,*(%&!*$!:11$*:@0-!/0%!N$%:6*'<!

8<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!4(%=<434%(!:2!+%4=E!R4<04=!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&\!24=@%!4<!E4M%2!<0%!4,1$%224*=!<0:<!

<0% ! 3*'=(%$ !20*'&( !+%! <0% ! &%:(4=E! 3*$@% ! 4= !:11&F4=E! <0% !2<$:<%EFd !0*R%M%$ ! <0% !2<$:<%EF! 42 !:&2*!

<:$E%<4=E!,:<'$%!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!0:M%!E*=%!+%F*=(!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$4:&!2<:<%-!T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&!:$E'%2!

<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!^$%E:$(&%22!*3!24V%!:=(!24<':<4*=_!@:=!:@04%M%!:!+$%:6*'<!4=!:!21%@434@!4=('2<$F-!

/0%!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%EF!(%34=%2!<0:<!<0%!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!@:=!+%!'2%(!<*!4(%=<43F!0*R!<0%!+'24=%22!

,*(%&!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%!@0:=E%(!2*!4<!34<2!R4<0!<0*2%!@'2<*,%$2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R:=<2!^:=(!

=%%(2_!<*!:@04%M%!+%<<%$!,:$6%<!$%2'&<2-

T4$2<!*3!:&&!&%<2!%2<:+&420!<0%!=%@%22:$F!:22',1<4*=2!=%%(%(!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!R0:<!:!

2<$:<%EF!42-! !K!2<$:<%EF!42 !:!<**&!3*$!0*R!:=!%=<%$1$42%!^+'24=%22\!1'+&4@!4=2<4<'<4*=\!E*M%$=,%=<!

4=2<4<'<4*= !*$ ! *<0%$ ! 3*$, !*3 ! *$E:=4V:<4*=_ ! <* ! $%:&4V% ! <0% !E*:&2 ! <0:< ! <0% ! %Y%@'<4M% ! <%:,;! *3 ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:$<4@'&:<%(-

/0%!N$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!4(%=<434%(!:2!+%&*=E4=E!<*!<0%!2@0**&!<0:<!42!(%34=%(!+F!D4=<V+%$E!:2!

<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&-!/042!42!+:2%(!*=!:=!:22',1<4*=!<0:<! !T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!^T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!

7JJO- ! 1- ! G_ !R*$62 !R4<0 ! <0% ! <0:< ! (%:&2 !R4<0 ! <0% ! &*@:& ! &%:(%$2 ! 4= ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 0:M% ! <* ! :@< ! :2!

%=<$%1$%=%'$2!<0:<!4(%=<434%2\!(%M%&*1!:=(!%=3*$@%!:=!'1(:<%(!+'24=%22!,*(%&-

K2!2'@0!T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!%,10:24V%2!<0:<!<0%F!0:M%!:11&4%(!<0%4$!<0%*$4%2!*=!@:2%2!<0:<!0:M%!+*<0!

1$%M:4&%(!:=(!3:4&%(-!K2!2'@0!<0%!:'<0*$2!:11&4%2!<0%4$!<0%*$4%2!<*!%Y1&:4=!R0:<!0:11%=%(!:=(!R0:<!

(4(=]<!0:11%=-

,-&./#"01#2!0&$$13&$! *3 ! <0% !+**6! 42 ! <0:< ! <0% !%=<%$1$42%\ ! 4<2 !(%@424*= !,:6%$2 !:=( ! <0% !:@<4=E!

%,1&*F%%2!=%%(2!<*!<04=6!:2!<0%!@'2<*,%$2!:=(!<04=6!*3!0*R!<0%F!:((!M:&'%!<0$*'E0!<0%4$!%=<4$%!

M:&'%!@0:4=-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!:11&F4=E!:!@*0%$%=<!:11$*:@0!<*!E*M%$=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!%&%,%=<2!&46%!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!^<0%!@*$%!@*,1*=%=<_!:=(!&%:(%$2041!

@*,1*=%=<!42!%Y<$%,%&F!4,1*$<:=<!<*!(%:&!R4<0-

; L<]2!=*<:+&%!<0:<!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!:&2*!@*M%$2!<0%!&%:(%$2!*$!*R=%$!*3!2,:&&!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!0:M%=]<!:!<%:,!*3!

%Y%@'<4M%2-

!"!#$%&!K)

Page 16: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!<#J!2C,:&9.>!$%.;0.;D

/0%!@*=@%1<!*3!2F2<%,4@!<04=64=E!42!$%1$%2%=<%(!+F!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!:=(!<0$*'E0!<0%!4(%:2!*=!

4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!<0:<!T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!^T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!7JJO\!11-!GB"C_!3*@'2%2!*=!<0:<!<0%!&%:(%$!

^*$!&%:(%$2_!=%%(2!<*!<:6%!@0:$E%!:=(!%=:+&%!@0:=E%!<0$*'E0!<0%4$!:@<4*=2!^%,+*(4,%=<_-!/0%$%<*!42!

=*<:+&%!<0:<!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!42!+'4&(!'1*=!24Y!(433%$%=<!:21%@<2!*3!<0%!M:&'%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:2!:!

R0*&%!(%&4M%$!<*!4<2!@'2<*,%$2-!K2!2'@0!<0%!24Y!:21%@<2!%=3*$@%2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!M4%R!*=!R0:<!1:$<!

4<!0:2!<*!+'4&(!'1!:=(!R0:<!1:$<!4<!@:=!&4,4<!4=!4<2!2<$'EE&%!<*!:@04%M%!+%<<%$!$%2'&<2-

/0%!4(%:!*=!2F2<%,4@!<04=64=E!42!@*,1:<4+&%!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!24=@%!<0%!

1$*+&%,2!<0:<!,4E0<!*@@'$!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!+%!2*&M%(!<*!%=:+&%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!:@04%M%!4<2!

E*:&2-

/0% ! @*$1*$:<% ! 2<$:<%EF ! =%%(2 ! <* ! :(($%22 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 4= ! : ! 2F2<%,4@ !R:F ! *<0%$R42% !R4&& ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!+%@*,%!,*$%!3$:E,%=<%(!^4=@*0%$%=<_-

50%=!@*,+4=4=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!R4<0!:=!:11$*:@0!:2!<0%!aN$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EFb!<0%=!4<!42!

@&%:$ ! <0:< ! <0% !,:=:E%$2 ! :=(! <0% !%=<%$1$42% !:$@04<%@<2 !=%%(2 ! <* ! :(($%22 ! <0% !+'24=%22 !,*(%&\ ! <0%!

&%:(%$2041!:=(!0*R!<0%!@0:=E%2!:$%!@*,,'=4@:<%(!<*!<0%!,:=:E%$2\!<0%!,4((&%!,:=:E%$2!:=(!<0%!

%,1&*F%%2-!/0%2%!422'%2!:$%!(%:&<!R4<0!+%&*R-

!<#K!$%&!I(,.;&,,!L+4&3

K@@*$(4=E!<*!T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&!<0%=!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!42!+'4&(!:$*'=(!24Y!(433%$%=<!%&%,%=<2!<0:<!4=!

<*<:&!(%34=%2!R0:<!M:&'%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!1$*M4(%2!<*!4<2!@'2<*,%$2-

/0%!24Y!@*,1*=%=<2!*3!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!:$%!1$4@%\!3%:<'$%2!^*3!<0%!2%$M4@%!*$!1$*('@<2_\!Z':&4<F\!

2'11*$<\!:M:4&:+4&4<F!:=(!$%1'<:<4*=- !54<04=!%:@0!*3!<0%2%!24Y!@*,1*=%=<2!:$%!<0%$%!34M%!*1<4*=2!

R4<04= !%:@0 !*3 ! <0% !@*,1*=%=<2 ! %-E-\ ! 3*$ ! <0% !1$4@% !@*,1*=%=< !#$%,4',\ !#$%,4',!@*,1%<4<4M%\!

?*,1%<4<4M%\!?*,1%<4<4M%!e!P%:(%$!:=(!&:2<!<0%!P%:(%$>-!

T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!^T4=6%&2<%4=!7JJO\!1-"G>_!4(%=<434%2!^@*$$%@<&F_!<0:<!<0%!M424*=!*3!<0%!3'<'$%!0:2!:=!

4,1:@<!*=!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!+'24=%22!,*(%&!20*'&(!+%!&46%!:=(!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!20*'&(!@*=24(%$!<0%!

24Y!@*,1*=%=<2!R0%=!<0%F!:$%!:$<4@'&:<4=E!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

/0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!@:=!<0%$%3*$%!+%!4(%=<434%(!:2!*=%!*3!<0%!@*$%!%&%,%=<2!4=!:=!:11$*:@0!<*!@$%:<%!

:=!4=<%E$:<%(!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

> #$4@%!P%:(%$!R04@0!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!1$4@%2!:$%!<0%!&*R%2<!R4<04=!<0%!4=('2<$F-

!"!#$%&!K*

Page 17: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!<#M!N&64&),%.*

K2!2'@0!<0%!<0%*$4%2!1$%2%=<%(!4=!<0%!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%EF!:$%!3*@'2%(!*=!<0:<!<0%!&%:(%$2041!*3!<0%!

%=<%$1$42% ! ^<*1 !,:=:E%,%=< !*$ !R0:< ! 42 !(%34=%(!:2 ! <0% !%Y%@'<4M% !E$*'1_ !0:2 ! <* !20*R! <0:< ! <0%4$!

4=<%=<4*=2 !:$% ! :=( ! <0%F !0:M% ! <* !R4= !*M%$ ! <0% !%,1&*F%%2- !T4=6%&2<%4= !%< ! :&- ! :$E'%2 ! <0:< !N$4<420!

K4$R:F2!:2 !: !@:2%!R0%$% ! <0% !?AQ!3:4&%( ! <* !R4=!*M%$ ! <0%!%,1&*F%%2 !:=(!:2 ! 2'@0!0%! ^:=(! <0%!

%Y%@'<4M% ! <%:,_ ! 3:@%( ! @0:&&%=E%2- ! /0% ! +$%:6*'< ! 2<$:<%EF ! (%:&2 ! R4<0 ! R4==4=E ! *M%$ ! *11*24=E!

3$:@<4*=2-!L=<%=<4*=2!=%%(2!<*!+%!20*R=!<0$*'E0!@*,,'=4@:<4*=!:=(!<0$*'E0!:@<4*=-!K!@*,+4=:<4*=!

*3! <042!R4&& !%=:+&%!<0%!,:=:E%,%=<! <*!R4=!*M%$ ! <0%!0%:$<2 !:=(!,4=(2!*3! <0%!%,1&*F%%2 !4=! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%-

!<#"O! =+99(;.>6:.+;

T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&!%,10:24V%2!<0:<!@*,,'=4@:<4*=!*3!<0%!M:&'%2!^T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!7JJO\!1-!">.!B!

".>_\!E*:&2!:=(!M424*=!<*!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!2*!<0%F!:$%!:+&%!<*!$%:@<!<*!<0%!M424*=!:=(!:4(%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

+F!+%0:M4=E!:@@*$(4=E!<*!<0%!M424*=-

/042!42!@*,1:<4+&%!R4<0!<0%!M4%R!<0:<!f*0=!#-!g*<<%$!^g*<<%$!7JJG\!11-!>>!B!C"_!1$%2%=<2!4=!042!+**6!

aK!8%=2%!*3!h$E%=@Fb!R0%$%!0%!2'EE%2<2!<0:<!<0%!:11$*:@0!<*!21$%:(!<0%!'$E%=@F!<*!@0:=E%!<0$*'E0!

@*,,'=4@:<4=E ! 3%%&4=E2 ! <0$*'E0 ! &%@<'$%2\ ! 1%$2*= ! <* !1%$2*= ! @*=<:@< ! :=( !M4(%*2 !*3 ! 1%*1&% !R0*!

%Y1$%22!^*3<%=!(42<$%22!*$!=%E:<4M%!3%%&4=E2_!*=!<0%!1$*('@<2!*$!2%$M4@%2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!1$*('@%2-!/0%!

@*$%!1$*+&%,!<*!*M%$@*,%!42!<*!@*,,'=4@:<%!3%%&4=E2!<*!<0%!@$*R(-

?*,,'=4@:<4*=!=%%(2!<*!+%!:(($%22%(!<*!*<0%$!:@<*$2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/042!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!

,%,+%$2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!<*!@*,,'=4@:<%! <0%!'$E%=@F!R4<0!,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!

,4((&% !,:=:E%,%=<- ! !50%= !R*$64=E!R4<0 ! <042 ! <0%=! 4< ! 42 !: !=%@%224<F ! <* !R*$6!R4<0 !,:<'$% ! <0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!@'&<'$%-

/0%!422'%!*3!<0%!3$:@<:&!*$E:=4V:<4*=!R4&&!+%!(42@'22%(!4=!<0%!@0:1<%$!*=!R*$6!3*$@%!1&:==4=E-

!<#""! A.,>(,,.+;!+-!:%&!I)&60+(:!2:)6:&DC

K=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<.!@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%EF!24=@%!4<!0:2!<0%!:11$*:@0!<*!2F2<%,4@!

<04=64=E-!L< !42!=*<:+&%!<0:<!<0%!:11$*:@0!@:=!+%!'2%(!<*!%4<0%$!:4(%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<!R4<0!

%Y1&:4=4=E !0*R!%=<%$1$42% ! :$@04<%@<'$% ! :=( ! 4=<%E$:<%( !E*M%$=:=@% ! @:= ! :4(% ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% !R4<0!

*1<4,4V4=E!4<2 !+'24=%22!,*(%&!:=(!:M*4(!3:4&'$%! 4= ! <0%!%33*$< ! <*!@0:=E%- !L=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!(*%2!

T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&-!0:=(&%!<0%!422'%2!*3!<0%!@'$$%=<!2<:<%!^4=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!6=*R=!:2!<0%!<*!+%!

2<:<%_!:=(!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!%M*&M%2!4=<*!:!=%R!:=(!+%<<%$!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!42!:+&%!<*!:@04%M%!<0%!

. /042!4=@&'(%2!<0%!?04%3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<-

!"!#$%&!K+

Page 18: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

E*:&2!*3!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<!20*'&(!+%!:R:$%!*3!<0:<!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!(%34=%2!2%M%$:&!%&%,%=<2!<0:<!

4,1:@<2!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!:(:1<!<*!<0%!,:$6%<!:=(!0*R!4<!*1%$:<%2-!/0%!*1%$:<4*=!,*(%&!@:=!

4=!2*,%!:21%@<!+%!(%34=%(!:2!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!*$!:<!&%:2<!<0%$%!42!:=!*M%$&:1-!/0%!*1%$:<4*=!,*(%&!

42!(42@'22%(!+F!9*22!)!5%4&&!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJ>\!7JJI!)!9*22!%<!:&!7JJC_!:=(!:2!2'@0!4<!2%$M%2!:2!

:!,:1!*$!@*=@%1<':&!4(%:!*=!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!*1%$:<%2-

N%$=:$(!^N%$=:$(!7JJ.\!1-!;;_!(%34=%2!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!:2!+%4=E!:!1:$<!*3!2<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E\!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%\!R*$63*$@%!1&:==4=E\!@:14<:&!1&:==4=E!:=(!2%@'$4<F-!/0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<!

@:=!,:6%!'2% !*3 ! <0%!+$%:6*'< !2<$:<%EF! <* !:$<4@'&:<% !: !M424*=!3*$ !0*R!<0%!K8![!L8!2<:<% !*3 ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%!20*'&(!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!:=(!0*R!<0%!<$:=24<4*=!3$*,!<0%!K8![!L8!2<:<%!<*!<0%!/Q!

[!NA!2<:<%!@:=!+%!(*=%-

K2!2'@0!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<!20*'&(!+%!:R:$%!*3!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(=]<!,*M%!3$*,!<0%!K8!

B!L8!24<':<4*=!<0$*'E0!:!2*!@:&&%(!+4E!+:=E!@0:=E%!R0%$%!%M%$F<04=E!42!@0:=E%(!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%-!

/0%!$%:2*=!3*$! <042! 42 ! <0:< !R0%=!+4E!+:=E!@0:=E%!*@@'$! <0%=!4< !*3<%=!3:4&2-!/0%$%3*$%!+4E!+:=E!

@0:=E%!20*'&(!+%!@*=24(%$%(!:!$426!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<!:=(!<0%!@*0%$%=@F!:$@04<%@<!

20*'&(!:M*4(!'24=E!<0%!:11$*:@0-!L=2<%:(!20*'&(!<0%!3*@'2!+%!*=!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!,*M%!

E$:(':&&F!<*!:@04%M%!4<2!:11$*:@0!:=(!+F!2'@0!<0%!1$*E$:,!3*$!@0:=E%!20*'&(!:@@%1<!<042!3*@'2-

!<#"1! P;!=+)*+)6:&!2:)6:&DC

?*=@&'24M%&F!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!:$<4@'&:<%(!<0$*'E0!(433%$%=<!,%:=2!:=(!+F!(433%$%=<!

:@<*$2-!/0%!Z'%2<4*=!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!2%%2!4<2%&3!:=(!0*R!4< !:(:1<2! <*! 4<2!(*,4=*!<0%=!<0%!

M:$4*'2 ! 2<$:<%E4@ ! 2@0**&2 ! @:= ! +% ! :11&4%( ! 4= !(433%$%=< !R:F2- !D4=<V+%$E ! :$E'%2 ! <0:< ! <0% !M:$4*'2!

2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!0:M%!+*<0!2<$%=E<02!^:(M:=<:E%2_!:=(!R%:6=%22%2!^(42:(M:=<:E%2_-!/0%$%!:$%!2*,%!

@0:$:@<%$42<4@2!<0:<!@:=!+%!'=(%$2<**(!:=(!+%!:11&4%(!<*!:@04%M%!:(M:=<:E%2!4=!<0%!R:F!<0%!2<$:<%EF!

42!4,1&%,%=<%(-

I%&$J'4;-$! @*'&(!+%!<0:<! <0%!@*,+4=:<4*=!*3!%&%,%=<2!3$*,!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!&46%!<0%!%Y1&4@4<!

2<$:<%EF!<*E%<0%$!R4<0!<0%!&%:(%$2041!*3!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&!:=(!+&%=(!4<!R4<0!6=*R&%(E%:+&%!

:(M4@% !3$*,! <0% ! 1&:==4=E ! 2@0**&- ! /042 ! :11$*:@0 ! R4&& ! +% ! (42@'22%( ! 4= ! (%<:4&%( ! R4&& ! 4= ! <0%!

4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!@0:1<%$-

L<!42!(%+:<:+&%!43!2<$:<%E4@!1&:==4=E!^@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF_!42!2'4<:+&%!R0%=!<0%!<0%$%!42!@*=2<:=<!@0:=E%!

*$!]0F1%$!@*,1%<4<4*=]!:=(!43!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!<0%!($4M%$!3*$!R0:<!1$*`%@<2!<0:<!:$%!4=4<4:<%(!*$!43!<0%!

1$*`%@<2 ! :$% ! <0% ! ($4M%$ ! *3 ! <0% ! @*$1*$:<% ! 2<$:<%EF- ! T*$ !,% ! 4< ! 2%%,2 ! <0:< ! <0% ! 1$*`%@<2 ! :$% ! <0%!

!"!#$%&!K:

Page 19: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!^4(%:&42<4@:&&F_!:=(!:2!2'@0!4<!42!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!

%=:+&%2!+%0:M4*$!:=(!M:&'%-!/0%$%3*$%!4<!@:=!+%!:$E'%(!R0%=!*$!43!<0%$%!42!:!,42:&4E=,%=<!+%<R%%=!

<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!1$*`%@<2!<0%=!4<!42!:!24E=!*3!<0:<!<0%!1$*`%@<2!<0:<!42!<0%!<$'%!2<$:<%EF!

:=(!<0%!%Y1&4@4<!2<$:<%EF!42!:!,%:=4=E&%22!:$<43:@<-

L< ! 42 ! =*<:+&% ! <0:< ! T4=6%&2<%4= ! %< ! :& ! :$E'%2 ! <0:< ! <0% ! +'24=%22 ! ,*(%& ! =%%(2 ! <* ! +% ! <:6%= ! 4=<*!

@*=24(%$:<4*=\!2*!<0%!(%@424*=!,:6%$2!:$%!:+&%!<*!,:6%!<0%!1$*1%$!@0*4@%2!*=!0*R!<*!1*24<4*=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!:(`'2<!<0%!M:$4*'2!%&%,%=<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!@$%:<%!2F=%$EF-

/0%!1$4,:$F!422'%!3*$!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!<*!,:6%!:!1&:=!3*$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!E*!3$*,!

<0%!2<:<%!4<!42!4=!<*!:!=%R!(%24$:+&%!2<:<%-!/0%!1&:=2!,:(%!<*!4=4<4:<%!<0%!M:$4*'2!+'24=%22!1$*`%@<2!:=(!

24=@%!:=F!E4M%=!E$*'1!*3!%Y%@'<4M%2!R*$6!R4<0!2<$:<%EF\!<0%=!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!<*!4=@*$1*$:<%!<0%!4(%:!

*=!0*R!<*!:&4E=!<0%!M:$4*'2!1&:=2\!<:@<4@2!:=(!2<$:<%E4%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!@*0%$%=<-!/0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!42!

:!2<:$<4=E!1*4=<!<0:<!($4M%2!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

9#$&%$J/ &5#';/$1 &A+-- &($ &2$'-+%0 &A+/#&79&*/1'/$0.? &9#$&;1+4'1. & ,35)* &A+-- &($&3%& /A3&2+,,$1$%/ &

;$1*;$5/+=$*&3%&79&*/1'/$0.&'%2&#3A&/#$*$&5'%&53%/1+()/$&/3&$%'(-$&+%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$<&'%2 &

/#13)0#&/#'/&#3-+*/+5&4'%'0$4$%/?

!"!#$%&!K;

Page 20: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&>& ?!&=+/"+%78

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF\!0*R!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!42!:$<4@'&:<%(\!:=(!R0:<!:11$*:@0%2!<0:<!

@:=!+%!'2%(-!/R*!:11$*:@0%2!R4&&!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!R04@0!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!(%34=%!:2!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!

2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!^#*<<2_!:=(!<0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!^9*22!)!5%4&&_-

!F#"!$%&!5&36:.+;,%.*!I&:Q&&;!2:)6:&DC!R!S+G&);6;>&

8<$:<%EF!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!+'24=%22!1&:==4=E!^@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF_!R0%$%!E*M%$=:=@%!42!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!

*3!<0%!(%@424*=2!=%%(%(!<*!+%!<:6%!<*!2'11*$<!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!3$*,!R0:<!4<!R:2!<*!

:!(%24$%(!2<:<%-!K2!2'@0!L!@0*2%!<*!(433%$!+%<R%%=!2<$:<%EF!:=(!E*M%$=:=@%-!/042!@0:1<%$!42!(%:&4=E!

R4<0!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!<0%!@0:1<%$!R4&&!+%!(%:&4=E!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!1&:==4=E!:=(!0*R!<*!

M4%R!1&:=2!4=!@*,1:$42*=!<*!R0:<!$*&%!<0%!1&:=2!R4&&!0:M%!4=!<0%!+'24=%22!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22-

!F#1!$%&!E$!,:)6:&DC

50%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!L/!2<$:<%EF!,F!34=(4=E2!2'EE%2<!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!,:=F!M4%R2!*=!R0:<!:=!L/!2<$:<%EF!

20*'&(!+%!(%24E=%(!3*$!:=(!R0:<!4<!20*'&(!%,10:24V%!*=!R0%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!*1<4,4V:<4*=!*3!L/!'2:E%!

4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!34$2<!M4%R!@&:4,2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!:!2<$:<%EF!2%1:$:<%(!3$*,!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!^<042!

42!$%1$%2%=<%(!+F!9*22!)!5%4&&]2!M4%R!*=!L/!2<$:<%EF_!R0%$%!<0%!*11*24=E!M4%R!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!L/!

2<$:<%EF!20*'&(=]< !+%!2%1:$:<%(!3$*,!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!24=@%!,*2< !,*(%$=!@*,1:=4%2 !@:=]<!

:M*4(!<0%!'2:E%!*3!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!<*!1%$3*$,!<0%!+'24=%22!%=<%$1$42%-!

7--)*/1'/+3%&KF&9#$&3;;3*+%0&=+$A*?

/0%!*11*24=E!M4%R2!(*!20:$%!4(%:2!*=!R0F!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!:=(!0:=(&%!4=3*$,:<4*=!

<%@0=*&*EFd!0*R%M%$!<0%!<0%*$42<2!:$E'%!:E:4=2<!*=%!:=*<0%$!24=@%!<0%!<R*!:11$*:@0%2!2%%2!%:@0!

!"!#$%&!KL

?*+%7/"+%1&=+/"+%78@<</'"A6

=%<"/"+%1&=+/"+%78&@<</'"A6

Page 21: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

*<0%$!:2!:!$%<'$=4=E!<*!*&(!4(%:2!:=(!R*$&(!M4%R2-!D@g%%=!:=(!8,4<0!^D@g%%=!:=(!8,4<0!7JJ;\!11-!

G!B!";_!:$E'%2!<0:<!L=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!@:=!=*R!+%!3*'=(!4=!%M%$F!:21%@<2!*3!:=!%=<%$1$42%]2!

+'(E%<2!:=(!:22%<2\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!42!L/!:=!:22%<!<0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!E*M%$=%(-

L=!E%=%$:&!<0%!<0%*$42<2!R4<04=!<0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!@&:4,2!:=(!+%&4%M%2!<0:<!<0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=]2!'2:E%!*3!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!=%%(2!<*!+%!1$%(4@<%(!:=(!(%:&<!R4<0!3$*,!:=!L/!

2<$:<%EF!^2%1:$:<%(!3$*,!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF_!:!1%$2*=!0:2!<*!+%!0%&(!$%21*=24+&%!3*$!<0%!($43<!:=(!

(%M%&*1!*3!L/!2F2<%,2C!:=(!<0%!1&:<3*$,2!<0:<!*$E:=4V%2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!P46%R42%!(*!<0%!<0%*$42<2!

R4<04=!<0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!:$E'%!<0:<!L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF!42!:!@*,1&%Y!

10%=*,%=*=!<0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!<0$*'E0!21%@4:&42<2\!:=(!1%*1&%!R0*!:$%!:+&%!<*!+$4(E%!<0%!

E:1!+%<R%%=!L/!:=(!a<0%!+'24=%22b-

!F#7!$%&!2&*6)6:&4!2:)6:&DC!B**)+6>%

H%<:4&2!*=!0*R!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!2<$:<%E4@!:11$*:@0!R*$62!:=(!0*R!4<!:(($%22%2!<0%!M:$4*'2!422'%2!@:=!

+%!3*'=(!4=!%=@&*2'$%!<R*-!/042!1:$<4@'&:$!2%@<4*=!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!<0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!

(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!@*=<%Y<!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!:11$*:@0!<0%=!9*22!)!5%4&&!^7JJI_!R*$62!R4<0!<0%!:22',1<4*=!

<0:<!:=F!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&-!/0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!0:2!<*!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!<0$*'E0!:=!

4=M%2<4E:<4*=!<0:< ! <0%!%Y%@'<4M%2 !:=(!<0% !L/!,:=:E%$2!E*! <0$*'E0!<*!'=@*M%$ !0*R!<0%!+'24=%22!

R*$62\!:=(!<0$*'E0!<0:<!<0%!L/!,:=:E%$2!:=(!%Y%@'<4M%2!(%M%&*12!2*,%!@*,+4=%(!:11$*:@0!<*!0*R!

<0%!+'24=%22!1$*`%@<2!:$%!:&4E=%(!R4<0!<0%!L/!1$*`%@<-!L=!<0%!%=@&*2'$%!4<!42!20*R=!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

@:=!0:M%!3*'$!(433%$%=<!E%=%$4@!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!<0:<!%:@0!:$%!*$E:=4V%(!:$*'=(!0*R!,:<'$%!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!L/B'2:E%!42- !9*22!)!5%4&& !0:2!$%'2%(!<042!,*(%&!3$*,!<0%4$ !+**6!aA=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%!:2!:!8<$:<%EFb!^7JJC_!:=(!4< !+:24@:&&F!%Y1*2%2!<0:<!L/!20*'&(!+%!<0%!6%F!($4M%$!<*!

@0:=E%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!+'24=%22!1$*@%22!:=(!4<2!+'24=%22!,*(%&-!8*!3:$!<0%!+'24=%22!:=(!L/!

&%:(%$2!0:M%!'2':&&F!,:(%!'2%!*3!*&(!1$4=@41&%2!:=(!1$*@%22%2!<0:<!R0%$%!(%M%&*1%(!4=!<0%!%:$&F!1:$<!

*3!<0%!7J<0!@%=<'$F!:=(!'2':&&F!<042!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!'2:E%!*3!<%@0=*&*EF!0:2!&%(!<*!<0:<!<0%!+'24=%22!

1$*@%22%2!0:2!+%%=!:!0F+$4(!<0:<!0:2=]<!&%:(!<*!:=F!+%=%34<2!R0:<!2*!%M%$-

L=!:!@*=<%Y<!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%\!<0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!:(($%22!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62\!

:=(!<0%!:&4E=,%=<!*3!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!@:=!3$*,!<0%!1%$21%@<4M%!<0:<!8@*<<!K-!N%$=:$(!R*$62!

R4<0!4=!042!:11$*:@0!<*!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:4(%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4<0!,*M4=E!3$*,!<0%!K8BL8!

24<':<4*=!<*!<0%!/Q![!NA!24<':<4*=-

/0%!$%:2*=!3*$!R0F!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!6%%1!<0%!<R*!2<$:<%E4%2!2%1:$:<%(!42!<0:<!L/!42!$:<0%$!@*,1&%Y\!

C L=@&'(4=E!L=3*$,:<4*=!8F2<%,2-

!"!#$%&!'M

Page 22: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

:=(!4<!=%%(2!%Y1%$<2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!,*$%!(%<:4&%(!:11$*:@0!<*!0:=(&%!<0%!<%@0=4@:&!:$@04<%@<'$%-!

/0% ! <%@0=4@:& ! :$@04<%@<'$% ! 4=@&'(%2 ! 4=3*$,:<4*= ! 2F2<%,2 ! ^+'24=%22 ! 2F2<%,2 !DL8_ ! :=( ! 2%$M%$2\!

@*,1'<%$2!:=(!,*$%!<%@0=4@:&!2F2<%,2!<0:<!42!<0%!3*'=(:<4*=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

9*22!)!5%4&&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!04E0%$!:=(!+%<<%$!:&4E=%(!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!<0%!L/![!1$*@%22%2!

0:M%!+%%=!:&4E=%(!:=(!E$*'1%(!<0%!,*$%!&46%&F!42!4<!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!$%'2%!4<2!

@*,+4=%(!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!4=!=%R!,:$6%<2!<0$*'E0!%:2F!(%1&*F:+&%!@*,1*=%=<2-!/0%!@*0%$%=<!M4%R!

*3!+'24=%22!:=(!L/!1$*@%22%2!20*'&(!%=:+&%!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!:@@*$(4=E!<*!<0%!$%2%:$@0!<0:<!

9*22!)!5%4&&!1$%2%=<2-

T$*,!9*22!)!5%4&&!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!4<!42!<0%!E*M%$=:=@%!1$*@%22!<0:<!42!,*2<&F!4,1*$<:=<\!

:=(!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!42!<*!:$<4@'&:<%!*=!0*R!<*!%=B@:12'&%!<0%!M424*=!*3!R0%$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!

,*M4=E!<*R:$(2-!L=!<0%!*<0%$!0:=(!<0%!E*M%$=:=@%!1$*@%22!

L=!$%21*=2%!<*!<042!$:<0%$!L/![!@%=<$4@!:11$*:@0!<*!2<$:<%EF\!i4@0*&:2!S-!?:$$!1'+&420%(!:=!:$<4@&%!:=(!

&:<%$!:!+**6!<0:<!+:24@:&&F!@*=@&'(%2!<0:<!L/!^:=(!<%@0=*&*EF_!E%=%$:&&F!(*%2=]<!&%:(!<*!:=F!3*$,!*3!

@*,1%<4<4M% ! :(M:=<:E% ! 24=@% ! 4< !R:2 ! %:2F ! <* ! @*1F ! <0% ! <%@0=*&*EF ! :=( ! :11&F ! 4< ! 4= ! @*,1%<4=E!

%=<%$1$42%2-!P46%R42%!(*%2!0%!@*=@&'(%!<0:<!4<!42!<0%!'2:E%!*3!<%@0=*&*EF!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!+'24=%22!

1$*@%22!42!R0:<!,:6%2!<0%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!K=!L/!2<$:<%EF!(%M%&*1%(!R4<04=!<042!:11$*:@0!

R4&&!+%!%Y1&4@4<!4=!:!(*@',%=<!<0:<!R4&&!+%!1$%2%=<%(!<*!:!2%&%@<%(!3%R!R0*!:$%!:@@*'=<:+&%!!3*$!0*R!

L/!:=(!+'24=%22!4=<%$:@<-!L=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!1$*@%22!42!<F14@:&&F!+:2%(!*=!:!@%=<$:&4V%(!

1$*@%22 ! <0:< ! (*%2=]< ! 4=@&'(% ! %,%$E%=< ! 2<$:<%E4%2 ! :=( ! %,%$E%=< ! 422'%2 ! 4= ! <0% ! (*,:4= ! <0:< ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!*1%$:<%2!4=-

/0%!2<$:<%EF!42!`'2<!:!R:F!<*!<04=6!*=!0*R!<*!,:6%!1&:=2\!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!=%%(2!

<*!+%!(*=%!<0$*'E0!L/BE*M%$=:=@%\!R04@0!<0%!=%Y<!@0:1<%$!R4&&!+%!(%:&4=E!R4<0-

/0%$%!42!0*R%M%$!:!2,:&&!1$*+&%,!R4<0!<0%!:11$*:@0!R0%$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:11$*:@0%2!<0%!'2:E%!*3!

<0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF-!/0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!(%:&2!R4<0!<0:<!<0%!L/B2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!:!

1:$<!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!9#$&+%/$01'/$2&*/1'/$0.&';;13'5#&+*&2$'-/&A+/#&+%&/#$&%$J/&*$5/+3%?

!F#7#"! T.;4.;D,!-+)!:%&!2&*6)6:&4!2:)6:&DC!B**)+6>%

L= ! <0% ! 2%1:$:<%( ! 2<$:<%EF ! :11$*:@0 ! <0% ! 3*&&*R4=E ! @:= ! +% ! @*=@&'(%( ! 4= ! $%&:<4*= ! <* ! 4=<%E$:<%(!

E*M%$=:=@%-

!"!#$%&!'K

Page 23: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

"- N*<0!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!$%1$%2%=<:<4M%2!3$*,!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!0:2!<*!

@*,,'=4@:<% ! :=( ! '=@*M%$ !R0:< ! 1:$<4@'&:$ ! 1$*`%@<2 ! <0:< ! =%%(2 ! <* ! +% ! 4,4<:<%( ! <* ! @$%:<%!

@*0%$%=<!,:=:E%,%=<-

7- /0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!:!3*$,!*3!'=@*M%$4=E!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%\!:=(!:11:$%=<&F!

<0%$%!:$%!3*'$!3*$,2!*3!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&2!<0:<!4,1:@<2!0*R!R%&& !:=!%=<%$1$42%!42 !:+&%! <*!

(%1&*F!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!L/!<*!:@04%M%!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-

;- L/!42!<**!@*,1&%Y!<*!+%!,:=:E%(!+F!+'24=%22!,:=:E%$2\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!

+%!:$<4@'&:<%(!+F!<0%!L/B,:=:E%$2\!+:2%(!*=!@*&&:+*$:<4*=!R4<0!<0%!+'24=%22!,:=:E%$2-

>- /0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!@:=!0:M%!3*'$!(433%$%=<!&%M%&2!*3!,:<'$4<F!:=(!:@@*$(4=E!<*!<0%!&%:(4=E!

<0%*$42<2!R4<04=!<042!:11$*:@0\!<0%=!4<!42!M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!:@04%M%!

<0:< !+'24=%22 !1$*@%22%2 !:=(! L/!2%$M4@%2 !:$% !1%$3%@<&F !:&4E=%(!:=(!@:=! <0%$%3*$% !+%@*,%!

2*,%0*R!E%=%$4@!:=(!'=4M%$2:&-!/0%$%3*$%!@:=!<0%2%!<0%*$%<4@:&&F!+%!(%1&*F%(!:=FR0%$%!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!,4E0<!R:=<!<*!&*@:<%-

.- /0%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!R4&&!1$%M:4&!<0$*'E0!<0%!6=*R&%(E%!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62!

:=(!(42<$4+'<%!<0%!4=3*$,:<4*=!<*!<0*2%!:@<*$2!R0*!=%%(!4<\!:=(!0*R!<*!$%'2%!<0%!4=3*$,:<4*=!

:=(!4=3*$,:<4*=!2F2<%,2!<*!4(%=<43F!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!:@<-

9#$&%$J/&*$5/+3%&2$'-*&A+/#&/#$&+%/$01'/$2&*/1'/$0.&';;13'5#&'%2&+/&()+-2&);3%&/#$&+2$'&()*+%$**&

'%2 & 79 & 5'%L/ & ($ & *$;'1'/$2< & '%2 & /#'/ & 0+=$* & *34$ & ;13(-$4* & A+/# & #3A & /#$ & */1'/$0. & *#3)-2 & ($ &

'1/+5)-'/$2?

!F#<!$%&!E;:&D)6:&4!2:)6:&DC!B**)+6>%

/0%! 4=<%E$:<%(!:11$*:@0!(%:&2!R4<0!<0:< ! <0%!3*@'2 !*3!:=!%=<%$1$42% !20*'&(=]< !+%!<* !2%1:$:<%! <0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF! 4=<*!2%M%$:& !(433%$%=< ! 3*$,2 !*3 !%Y1&4@4< !1&:=2 !:=(! 4(%:2- !/042 !,%:=2! <0:< ! <0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!4=@&'(%!<0%!'2:E%!*3!L/-!/0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!0:2!+%%=!+:2%(!

*=!<0%!+**6!aT$'4<4*=b!+F!?0$42!#*<<2-!/0%!+**6!42!R$4<<%=!:2!:!=*M%&\!:=(!?0$42!#*<<2!0:M%!:((%(!:!

3%R!1:E%2!4=!<0%!%=(!*3!%:@0!@0:1<%$!(%<:4&4=E!R4<0!R0:<!@:=!+%!&%:$=%(!3$*,!%:@0!*3!<0%!@0:1<%$2-!L!

R$*<%!:!+&*E!1*2<!^8`*%&4=!7J"J_!(%:&4=E!R4<0!:!$%M4%R!*3!<0%!+**6\!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!:!

,*(434%(!%(4<4*=!*3!<0%!+&*E!1*2<!<*!(%:&!R4<0!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0-

#*<<2!R*$6%(!R4<0!,:=F!4=<%$%2<4=E!1*4=<2!<0$*'E0!042!=*M%&!:=(!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!*$E:=4V%!<0%,!

:$*'=(!<0%,%2!:2!<0%!2<$:<%EF!:$<4@'&:<4*=!1$*@%22\!<0%!:&4E=,%=<!10:2%\!<0%!M:&'%!:((4=E!10:2%\!:=(!

<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!10:2%-!/0%2%!10:2%2!:$%!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!(%<:4&!4=!<0%!2%@*=(!%=@&*2'$%-

K@@*$(4=E!<*!#*<<2!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!:(($%22!<0%!3%%(+:@6!<0:<!@*,%2!3$*,!<0%!%=M4$*=,%=<!

!"!#$%&!''

Page 24: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!*1%$:<%2!R4<04=\!&46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!&%M%&2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!%-E-\!<0%$%!20*'&(=]<!

+%!:!,4234<!+%<R%%=!*=!,4Y4=E!<0%!*1%$:<4*=:&!&%M%&!*$!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!&%M%&!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!50%=!<0%!

?LQ!*$!*<0%$!3*$,!*3!L/!,:=:E%$!:$<4@'&:<%2!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!^:<!&%:2<!:2!4<!0:2!+%%=!(*=%!<0$*'E0!<0%!

2%1:$:<42<!:11$*:@0_!<0%=!0%!*$!20%!20*'&(=]<!:22',%!*$!@:&@'&:<%!R4<0!<0:<!:! &:@6!*3!4=<%$%2<!42!

%Z'4M:&%=<!<*!:!<$'2<!4=!<0%!R*$6!0%!*$!20%!(*%2-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!2%1:$:<42<!:11$*:@0!^:=(!,*M4=E!*=!<*R:$(2!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!:11$*:@0!<*!

2<$:<%EF_!4< ! 42! 4,1*$<:=<!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%E42< !(*%2=]< !:22',%!<0:<!:=!%Y1&4@4< !2<$:<%EF!42 !%Z':&!<*!:!

2<$:<%EF-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!:!@*0%$%=<!2<$:<%E4@!:11$*:@0!*=!L/!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!(%:&!R4<0!

<0%!<0*2%!:@<*$2!R0*!*R=2!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%4$!,4=(2%<-!P46%R42%!R4&&!:=!

:$<4@'&:<%(!2<$:<%EF!20*R!R0:<!,4=(2%<!<0%!2<$:<%E42<!0:2\!:=(!3$*,!:=!L/!1*4=<!*3!M4%R!<0%=!4<!42!:!

=%@%224<F!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!43!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!42!,:=:E%(!:2!:=!%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<F!^2'11&4%$_!<0%=!4<!

42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!<$%:<!<0%!L/![!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!2'@0!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!=*<!E4M%!

<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:=F!4=3&'%=@%!4=!<0%!@$%:<4*=!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!

T$*,!:=!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!1*4=<!*3!M4%R!<0%=!4<!42!@&%:$!<0:<!4<!E4M%2!=*!M:&'%!R0:<!2*!%M%$!<*!

<$%:<!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!:=!%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<F!^F*'!@:=!+%=@0,:$6!4<!:2!:=!%Y<%$=:&!2'11&4%$!:2!F*'!

@:=!R4<0!:&&!*<0%$!(%1:$<,%=<2!4=!:=!%=<%$1$42%_!:=(!@*,1:$%(!<*!R0:<!D@g%%=!:=(!8,4<0!2:F2!4=!

<0%4$!+**6!<0%=!4<!R*'&(!+%!3'<4&%!<*!3*$@%!L/!^:=!4=@$%:24=E!1:$<!*3!<0%!@*,1:=F]2!:22%<2_!:R:F!3$*,!

<0%!2<$:<%EF!2%224*=-!#*<<2!$:42%2!<0%!1$*+&%,!R4<0!0:M4=E!<R*!(433%$%=<!2<$:<%E4%2!+F!1$*,*<4=E!<0%!

4(%:!<0:<!L/!42!4=M*&M%(!4=!:&,*2<!:&&!:@<4M4<4%2!:=!%=<%$1$42%!4=!<0%!R%2<%$!%@*=*,F!42!+'4&(!'1*=-!L<!

42!<0%$%3*$%!,%:=4=E&%22!=*<!<*!4=<%E$:<%!L/!4=!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

50%=!<0%!?LQ!42!4=!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!1$*@%22\!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!3*$!<0%!?LQ!<*!4=M%2<4E:<%!43!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!42=]<!:&$%:(F!3'&34&&4=E!<0%!M424*=!<0:<!0:2!+%%=!:E$%%(!*=-!L=!<042!1$*@%22!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!

<*!4=M%2<4E:<%!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!:=(!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:=(!4<2!:$@04<%@<'$%!42!(%24E=%(!%-E-\!42!

<0%!<%@0=4@:&!:$@04<%@<'$%!E%:$%(!<*!%=:+&%!3'$<0%$!E$*R<0-

P46%R42%!(*%2!4<!+%@*,%!:!=%@%224<F!<*!M:&4(:<%!<0%!1$*,42%!^*$!1$*,42%2_!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<0%!?LQ!

0:2!:$<4@'&:<%(-!L3!<0%!1$*,42%!42!,42:&4E=%(!3$*,!R0:<!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!E$*'1!<0%=!4<!42!

&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!R4&&!+%!$%`%@<%(!*$!43!4<!42!4,1&%,%=<%(!<0%=!4<!R4&&!&%:(!<*!,42:&4E=,%=<-!K!

2<$:<%E4@:& !,42:&4E=,%=< ! R4&& ! &%:( ! <* ! : ! E%=%$:& !,42:&4E=,%=<- !/042 ! :$E'% ! 42 ! @*,1:<4+&% ! R4<0!

N%$=:$(]2!M4%R!*=!0*R!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!(%:&<!R4<0-!50%=!<0%!<*1!*3!<0%!1F$:,4(!^<0%!

%Y%@'<4M%2_!E4M%2!*$(%$2!<0%=!4<!R4&&!E*!(*R=!<0%!&:F%$2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!:!0*&42<4@!M4%R!4=!,4=(!<0%=!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!1$*@%22!42!6%F!<*!R*$6!R4<0-!#*<<2!

:$E'%!<0:<!43!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!1$*@%22!R*$64=E2!R%&&!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!4<!42!M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!

!"!#$%&!'(

Page 25: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!'2%!L/!^E*M%$=4=E!L/_!R%&&-!T$*,!<042!1%$21%@<4M%!<0%=!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!<0%!

4=M%2<,%=<!1$*@%22!0:2!<*!+%!4=@&'(%(!4=!:=F!3*$,!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%\!:=(!<0*2%!R0*!:$%!

4=M*&M%(!4=!<0%!(%@424*=!,:64=E!20*'&(!1'<!%Y<$:!:<<%=<4*=!<*!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!1&:==4=E!1$*@%22!:=(!

4,1&%,%=<:<4*=- !50%= ! 4,1&%,%=<4=E ! <0% ! M:$4*'2 ! 4=M%2<,%=<2 ! 4=<* ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! <0%= ! 4< ! 42 ! :!

=%@%224<F!<*!:=@0*$!<0%!$%21*=24+4&4<F!:=(!:@@*'=<:+4&4<F!*3!4=M%2<4=E!4=<*!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!E$*'1!2*!

<0%F!R4&&!+%!:+&%!,:Y4,4V4=E!<0%!M:&'%!*3!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2-

/0%$%3*$%!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!L/!:=(!<0%!+'24=%22!42!*=%!:=(!<0%!2:,%!<04=E\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!@:=]<!

:!2%1:$:<4*=!*3!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!=*<!%Y42<!R4<0!:=F!,%:=4=E-!P46%R42%!@:=!4<!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!<0%!

4=<%E$:<%( ! 2<$:<%EF ! :11$*:@0 ! (%:&2 ! R4<0 ! <0% ! %,+*(4,%=< ! *3 ! <0% ! 2<$:<%EF ! :=( ! =*< ! (%M%&*14=E!

(*@',%=<2!@*=<:4=4=E!M:$4*'2!422'%2!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF-!L=!:((4<4*=!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!

@:=]< !+% !(%:&4=E !R4<0 ! aL/!:=( ! <0% !N'24=%22b ! :=( ! 4< ! 0:2 ! <* ! 4=@&'(% !0*R! 4< !(%:&2 !R4<0 ! <0% !%=(!

@'2<*,%$2!R0*!+'F2!<0%!1$*('@<2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!,:='3:@<'$%-! !P46%R42%!(*%2!<0%!#*<<2!%,10:24V%!

<0:<!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!<:6%!@0:$E%-

T$*,!:=!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%!1%$21%@<4M%!^%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%!42 !:!1:$< !*3! <0%!:11$*:@0!<*!

4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%_!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!@04%3!:$@04<%@<!:=(!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!:$@04<%@<2!=%%(2!<*!:@<!:2!

:!3*$,!*3!2*@4:&!&4=62!+%<R%%=!<0%!M:$4*'2!(%@424*=!,:6%$2!:=(!<0*2%!R0*!0:M%!<*!&4M%!:=(!R*$6!

R4<0!<0%!(%@424*=2!<:6%=!+F!<0%!,%,+%$2!*3!<0%!(%@424*=!,:6%$2-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&I-+0%4$%/&;#'*$&3,&/#$&*/1'/$0.&2$=$-3;4$%/&;135$**?

&>B;B-& !6%&@$:7*3%*+&.6",%

50%=!<0% !?LQ!*$ !*<0%$ ! L/! &%:(%$ !R*$62 !R4<0! <0% !2%@<4*=!*3 !(%M%&*14=E! <0%! L/B2<$:<%EF! 4< ! 42 !:!

=%@%224<F!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!1:@%!*3!@0:=E%!4=!<0%!(*,:4=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<0:<!0:2!:=!4=3&'%=@%!

*=!<0%!1:@%!*3!@0:=E%!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!4<!42!

4,1*$<:=<!<*!M4%R!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!:2!<0%!@%=<$:&!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!:&&!*<0%$!3*$,2!*3!2<$:<%E4%2!

=%%(2!<*!+%!:&4E=%(!R4<0-!/042!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!=%%(2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!

R4&&!@0:=E%!:2!3:2< !^:<!&%:2<!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF_!:2!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

$%:&4V%!<0:<!<0%!@*,1%<4<*$2!0:M%!4=4<4:<%(!=%R!@:,1:4E=2!<*!@*=Z'%$!,:$6%<!20:$%2-

/0% ! 1:@% ! *3 ! @0:=E% ! 0:2 ! : ! 24E=434@:=< ! %33%@< ! *= ! 0*R ! R%&& ! L=<%E$:<%( ! S*M%$=:=@% ! @:= ! +%!

4,1&%,%=<%(\!:=(!4<!@:=!&%:(!<*!<0:<!<0%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0!=%%(2!+%!:E4&%-!W*R%M%$!<0%!

*=&F!R:F!<*!%=:+&%!<0%!(%@424*=!,:6%$2!<*!,:6%!1&:=2!<0:<!:$%!@*0%$%=<!42!<0$*'E0!<0%!'2:E%!*3!:=!

%=<%$1$42%!R4(%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,!24=@%!4<!'=@*M%$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-

/0%!,4=(2%<!*3!<0%!(%@424*=!,:6%$2!,4E0<!@0:=E%!*M%$!<4,%!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!>>_!:=(!2*,%<4,%2!<0%!

!"!#$%&!')

Page 26: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

1:@%!4<!<:6%2!3*$!:!2<:6%0*&(%$!<*!@0:=E%!<0%4$!,4=(2!,4E0<!+%!M%$F!&4<<&%-!/042!,4E0<!+%@*,%!:!

1$*+&%, ! 3*$ ! 0*R ! <* ! %=:+&% ! <0% ! 0*&42<4@ ! ,:=:E%,%=< ! <0$*'E0 ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! E*M%$=:=@% ! 24=@% ! :!

@*,,4<,%=<!<*!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!42!<4,%!:=(!$%2*'$@%!@*=2',4=E!:@<4M4<F-

L=!<042!@:2%!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!3*$!<0%!L/!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^24=@%!4<!42!*3<%=!3$*,!<0%!L/!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<0:<!<0%!

@*=@%1<!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!4,1&%,%=<%(_!1$*M%2!<0:<!4<!+$4=E2!M:&'%!<*!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

:=(!<0:<!<0%!L/!*$E:=4V:<4*=!42!*=!<0%!2:,%!<%:,!:2!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%!3*@'2!*3!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!42!<0:<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF!42!3*@'24=E!*=!%Y1&*4<4=E!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!<*!@$%:<%!M:&'%\!<*!,:6%!1$*34<2!:=(!<*!

$%2<$'@<'$%!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/0%!3*@'2!*3!<0%!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!<0%!?AQ!42!=*<!

<*!%=0:=@%!<%@0=*&*EF!*$!(%M%&*1!<0%!<%@0=*&*E4@:&!:$@04<%@<'$%!43!4<!(*%2=]<!&%:(!<*!2*,%!3*$,!*3!

M:&'%- !50%=!4< !@*,%2!<*!<0%!'=(%$2<:=(!*3!M:&'%!<0%=!<0%!M:&'%!@:=!+%!(%34=%(!*3!1*$<3*&4*!*3!

,%:2'$%,%=<!:=(!<F1%2!*3!,%:2'$%,%=<-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!+'(E%<4=E!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!*<0%$!

%Y%@'<4M%2!R4&&!+%!*3!<0%!*14=4*=!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!21%=(2!:!$:=(*,!:,*'=<!*3!,*=%F!*=!L/!24=@%!

L/!42!4=<:=E4+&%-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!:!2<$:<%EF!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*$!:$<4@'&:<4*=!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!

@*,,'=4@:<4*=!:=(!&:=E':E%!24=@%!<0%2%!<R*!%&%,%=<2!0:M%!:!E$%:<!4,1:@<!*=!0*R!<0%!2<$:<%EF!@:=!

+%!'=(%$2<**(!:=(!0*R!:@<*$2!R4&&!4=<%$:@<!R4<0!<0%!2<$:<%EF-!P46%R42%!42!4<!:!=%@%224<F!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!

<0%!M:$4*'2!2<$:<%E4%2!<0%!(433%$%=<!%Y%@'<4M%2!@*,%!R4<0!0:M%!2*,%!3*$,!*3!M:&'%-!/0%!M:$4*'2!(*!

:&2*!0:M%!2*,%<04=E!(42<4=@<4M%!<*!*33%$-!P46%R42%!42!4<!:!=%@%224<F!<*!:$<4@'&:<%!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<*!:!

1:$<4@'&:$!:'(4%=@%!2*!<0%F!'=(%$2<:=(!R0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!:&&!:+*'<-

?*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!:!<%=(%=@F!<*!@0:=E%!$:<0%$!*3<%=\!:=(!<*!:M*4(!:!E:1!+%<R%%=!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!

:=(!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!=%%(2!<*!6%%1!4=3*$,%(!*=!<0%!@0:=E%2!:=(!@*1%!R4<0!

@0:=E%2-!L3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!R*$62!R4<0!2*&M4=E!:!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*+&%,!<0%=!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!=%%(2!

<*!:(($%22!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*+&%,!:2!R%&&\!R0%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!+'24=%22!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!0:2!<*!

3*@'2!*=!+%4=E!:!1:$<!*3!<0%!+'24=%22!:=(!=*<!:=!%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<Fd!43!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!42!M4%R%(!:2!:=!

%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<F!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!?LQ!@:=]<!4=3&'%=@%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF\!:=(!<0%!?LQ!R4&&!

<0%$%3*$%!+%@*,%!:=!'=(%$(*E-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!2<$:<%EF!4=!:=!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!4<!R4&&!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!<0$*'E0!

1$*`%@<2d !,*2< ! *$E:=4V:<4*=2 ! *3<%= ! <%=( ! <* ! +% ! $:<0%$ ! E**( ! :< ! :$<4@'&:<4=E ! +'24=%22 ! @:2%2 ! :=(!

(%M%&*14=E!<0%!1$*`%@<2d!0*R%M%$!R0%=!,:64=E!'2%!*3!<0%!1$*`%@<2!<0%=!,*2<!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!&*2%2-

P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!?LQ!+%!:R:$%!*3!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!(433%$%=<!3*$,2!*3!2<:6%0*&(%$2!:=(!%:@0!*3!<0%,!

,4E0<!0:M%!<0%4$!*R=!:E%=(:!:=(!<0%4$!*R=!+:@6E$*'=(-!/0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!<0%!?LQ!@'2<*,4V%!<0%!L/!

!"!#$%&!'*

Page 27: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<$:<%EF ! 3*$ ! %:@0 !*3 ! <0% ! 2<:6%0*&(%$2- !50%= !R*$64=E !R4<0 !,%:2'$4=E ! <0% ! L/! 2<$:<%EF ! :=( ! <0%!

+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!M:$4*'2!<F1%2!*3!,%:2'$%,%=<-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&='-)$&'22+%0&;#'*$&/#'/&2$'-*&A+/#&#3A&/#$&79&*/1'/$0.&A+--&51$'/$&='-)$&,31&/#$ &

$%/$1;1+*$?&I*&+/&#'*&($$%&2+*5)**$2&+%&/#+*&*$5/+3%&/#$%&+/&+*&'&%$5$**+/.&/3&2$43%*/1'/$&/#$&='-)$&3, &

79&/3&/#$&3/#$1&$J$5)/+=$*?

&>B;B4& C"$0%&@11:*7

/0%!+'24=%22!24(%!^43!F*'!@:=!(433%$!+%<R%%=!+'24=%22!:=(!L/_!%Y1%@<2!2%$M4@%!<*!+%!1$*M4(%(!<*!

<0%,!3$*,!<0% !L/!*$E:=4V:<4*=- !/*!,:6%!2'$%! <0:< ! <0% !%Y1%@<:<4*=!*=!R0:< ! <* ! $%@%4M%!3$*,!L/!

(%1:$<,%=< ! <0%=!2%$M4@%! &%M%&!:E$%%,%=<2!=%%(2!<* !+%!:$<4@'&:<%(- !/0%!2%$M4@%! &%M%&!:E$%%,%=<2!

=%%(2!<*!+%!4=@*$1*$:<%(!4=<*!<0%!2<$:<%EF-!D*2<!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%E4%2!:$%!:+*'<!=',+%$2!:=(!<0%!L/!

2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!:&2*!+%!:+*'<!=',+%$2!4=4<4:&&F-

h2':&&F!<0%$%!42!:!E:1!+%<R%%=!<0*2%!R0*!@$%:<%2!M:&'%!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<0*2%!R0*!21%=(2!<0%!

M:&'%!^1$*34<2_!:=(!<042!&%:(2!<*!,42:&4E=,%=<-

L=!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!1$*@%22!4< !+%@*,%2!$:<0%$!'$E%=<&F!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!42!:+&%!<*!(42<4=E'420!<0%!L/B

4=M%2<,%=<2!3$*,!<0%!'2':&!+'24=%22!4=M%2<,%=<2-!L=!$%&:<4*=!<*!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!4<!42!$:<0%$!

4,1*$<:=<!<*!+%!:+&%!<*!2%%!R0:<!2%@<4*=2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!4=M%2<2!4=!M:$4*'2!1$*`%@<2\!:=(!R0:<!

1:$<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!%=0:=@%2-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!L/B4=M%2<,%=<2!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!

0:2!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!2:,%!:11$*:@0!<*!%M:&':<%!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!:2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!'2%!3*$!*<0%$!2*$<2!

*3!4=M%2<,%=<\!*<0%$R42%!<0%!:11$*:@0!R4&&!,:6%!:=F!@*,1:$:+&%!M:&'%-!K@@*$(4=E!<*!#*<<2!<0%=!L/!

4=M%2<,%=<2!:$%!=*<!<0:<!(433%$%=<!3$*,!4=M%2<,%=<2!4=!,:@04=%$F\!@:$2\!*334@%!2'11&4%2!%<@-

P46%R42%!R0%=!4=M%2<4E:<4=E!<0%!$%<'$=!*=!4=M%2<,%=<2!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!".I_!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!:=(!<0%!

$%2<!*3!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!E$*'1!0:2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%E4@:&!1$*`%@<2!:$%=]<!=%@%22:$F!<0*2%!

1$*`%@<2!<0:<!:$%!E%=%$:<4=E!<0%!04E0%2<!$%<'$=!*=!4=M%2<,%=<!:=(!&46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!<$F!

<*!4=M%2<4E:<%!<0%!@:'2%!:=(!%33%@<!*3!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2-

T$*,!:=!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!1%$21%@<4M%!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!3*$!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!

0*R!<0%4$!4=M%2<,%=<2!4,1:@<!<0%!*M%$:&&!1%$3*$,:=@%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!L3!<0%F!(*=]<!:11$*:@0!<0%!

4=M%2<,%=<!1&:==4=E!R04&%!<0%F!,:6%!<0%4$!(%@424*=2!*=!0*R!<*!%M*&M%!:=(!(%M%&*1!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!

<0%=!4<!42!M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!E$*R!4=@*0%$%=<!:=(!3$:E,%=<:<4*=!R4&&!+%@*,%!:!&:$E%$!

*+2<:@&%!4=!E:4=4=E!:&4E=,%=<\!:E4&4<F!:=(!:22'$:=@%-!/0%2%!<0$%%!:+4&4<4%2!:$%!<0%!,*2<!4,1*$<:=<!<*!

:@04%M%!:=F!3*$,!*3!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!L=!:((4<4*=!<*!R0:<!0:2!+%%=!(42@'22%(!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!

+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!%2<:+&4204=E!$%&:<4*=20412!:=(!0%!*$!20%!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!+$%:64=E!(*R=!<0%!

!"!#$%&!'+

Page 28: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<%$%*<F1%2!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!,4E0<!0:M%!$%E:$(4=E!L/\!:=(!&46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!?LQ!

R*$64=E!R4<0!+$%:64=E!(*R=!042!*$!0%$!*R=!2<%$%*<F1%2!*3!<0%!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!<0%4$!R*$6B

:$%:2-!/*!@*,,'=4@:<%!4=!:!2%=24+&%!R:F!R4<0!<0%!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!

R4<0! <0%!4(%=<43F4=E!@*2<2 ! 4=M%2<%(! 4= !+'24=%22!:=(!L/!4(%=<43F!:=F!@*$$%&:<4*=!43 ! 4< ! 42 !1*224+&%-!

P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!@:'2%!:=(!%33%@<!+%!%Y1&*$%(!43!4<!42!1*224+&%-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&5#'%0$&4'%'0$4$%/&;#'*$<&/#'/&+%&4'%.&5'*$*&+*&/#$&43*/&51+/+5'-&;#'*$&*+%5$&+/ &

2$'-*&A+/#&+4;-$4$%/'/+3%<&'%2&+/&2$'-*&A+/#&5#'%0+%0&/#$&'//+/)2$&/3A'12*&/#$&;13M$5/<&*$1=+5$&31 &

;135$**&/#'/&#'*&($$%&'-/$1$2&3=$1&/+4$?

&>B;B9& !6%&)6"*7%&5"*"7%3%*+&.6",%

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!@0:=E%!,:=:E%,%=<!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!4=M*&M%2!<0%!*<0%$!2<:6%0*&(%$2!

4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!#*<<2!7JJG\!1-O7_-!L<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!R*$64=E!R4<0!@0:=E4=E!<0%!

:@<4M4<4%2 ! 4= ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 4=M*&M%2 ! *<0%$ ! 2<:6%0*&(%$2 ! <0:= ! <0% ! %Y%@'<4M% ! E$*'1 ! 2'@0 ! :2 ! <0%!

%,1&*F%%2\!,4((&%!,:=:E%$2!:=(!%Y<%$=:&!1%$2*=2!*$!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!R0*!4=<%$:@<!R4<0!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!

1$*@%22-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!@0:=E%!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0\!<0%=!<0%!3*@'2!20*'&(=]<!+%!:+'<!

=',+%$2!+'<!*=!R0:<!<0%!?LQ!6=*R2!:=(!(*%2=]<!6=*R!4=!$%&:<4*=!<*!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*@%22%2-

50%=!:$<4@'&:<4=E!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!:=(!&:<%$!*=!4,1&%,%=<4=E!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!

R*$6!R4<0!:=!4<%$:<4M%!:11$*:@0!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!G"_!R04@0!:&2*!@:=!+%!:11&4%(!<*!<0%!:11$*:@0!*=!

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-!N%3*$%!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!2<:$<2!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!3*$!

<0%!?LQ!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!0*R!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!E$*'1!'=(%$2<:=(2!,%:2'$4=E!:=(!+'(E%<4=E!<0%!

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!<0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!,:6%!2'$%!<*!+$%:6!(*R=!<0%!4,:E%!*3!

<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!:!(%1:$<,%=<!<0:<!1$*,42%2!:!&*<!+'<!=%M%$!6%%12!4<2!1$*,42%2\!:=(!<0:<!<0%!L/!

(%1:$<,%=<!@:$%2!:+*'<!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%-!?0$42!#*<<2!4=<$*('@%2!:=(!4=<%$%2<4=E!:$E',%=<!^#*<<2!

7JJG\!1-!"O._!<0:<!"JJj!:&4E=,%=<!:,*=E!<0%!M:$4*'2!2<$:<%E4%2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%@*,%!:!

$:<0%$ ! (:=E%$*'2 ! 10%=*,%=*=\ ! :=( ! R0%= ! <0% ! 2<$:<%E4%2 ! :$% ! :&4E=%( ! <0%= ! 4< ! 42 ! : ! $:<0%$ ! $:$%!

10%=*,%=*=!:2!R%&&-!/0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!+%!*=%!*3!<0*2%!1%*1&%!R0*!@:=!4=3&'%=@%!*<0%$!2<:6%0*&(%$2!

4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!@0:=E%!<0%4$!+%0:M4*$!:=(!:2!2'@0!:@<!:2!:!@0:=E%!:E%=<!:=(!*14=4*=!3*$,%$-!

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!:!=%R!L/!2<$:<%EF!R4&&!

$%2'&<!4=!:!(%,:=(!3*$!:!=%R!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!^#*<<2!7JJG\!"O._-!L=!$%&:<4*=!<*!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!

<0%=!4<!@:=!+%!@&:$434%(!<0:<!2*@4:&!=%<R*$62!:=(!'=@*M%$4=E!:=(!(%34=4=E!0*R!<0%!L/!2F2<%,2!:=(!

1$*@%22%2!0:M%!<*!R*$6!:3<%$!<0%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!+%%=!4,1&%,%=<%(-

/0%!@0:=E%!1$*@%22!R4&&!,:4=&F!+%!(%:&4=E!R4<0!@0:&&%=E4=E!<0%!*$<0*(*YF!*3!0*R!<04=E2!:$%!(*=%!

4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%d!0*R%M%$!<0%!3*@'2!42!:&2*!<0%!&:$E%2<!*+2<:@&%!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!R4&&!+%!(%:&4=E!R4<0!

!"!#$%&!':

Page 29: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0$*'E0!042!*$!0%$!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!@0:=E%!,:=:E%,%=<!1$*@%22!^#*<<2!7JJG-!1-!"GJ_-!50%=!R*$64=E!

R4<0!<0%!:22',1<4*=2!*=!@0:=E4=E!<0%!3*@'2!*=!R*$64=E!R4<0!4=<%$=:&!4=M%2<,%=<2!@*,1:$%(!<*!

L=3*$,:<4*=!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!,:4=&F!3*@'2!*=!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2!1:$<-!#*<<2!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!"I"_!

:$E'%2!3*$!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!:!?04%3!L=<%$=:&!L=M%2<,%=<2!Q334@%$!^?LLQ_\!:=(!'2':&&F!<0%!?LQ!

@*'&(!+%!: !E**(!@:=(4(:<% ! 3*$! <042 !1*24<4*=d !W*R%M%$ ! 43 ! <0%!?LQ!42 !=*< ! $%:(! <* ! <$:=23*$,!:=(!

@0:&&%=E%!042 !M4%R2!<0%=! 4< ! 42 !: !=%@%224<F ! <* !,:6%!2*,%+*(F!%&2%! <:6%!<0%! &%:(!*3! <0%!4=<%$=:&!

4=M%2<,%=<2!1*24<4*=-!50:<!42!,*$%!4,1*$<:=<!42!<0:<!<0%!(%!3:@<*!2<$:<%EF!42!3*$,%(!+F!<0%!?LQ!

<0$*'E0!042!:@<4*=2!:=(!42!<0%$%3*$%!=*<!R0:<!42!R$4<<%=!*=!:!14%@%!*3!1:1%$-

/0%$%!42!*=&F!*=%!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!,%:=2!2*,%<04=E!:=(!<0:<!42!R0:<!<0%!?LQ!(*%2!^%,+*(4,%=<!*3!

2<$:<%EF_-!#*<<2!42!*3!<0%!*14=4*=!<0:<!4<!42!$:$%!<0:<!:=F!64=(!*$!:=F!<F1%!*3!2<$:<%EF!@:=!:@04%M%!

"JJj!:&4E=,%=<-!/0%!?LQ!20*'&(!1'<!21%@4:&!:<<%=<4*=!<*!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!:=(!<0:<!

,%:=2!<0:<!042!$*&%!,4E0<!@0:=E%!3$*,!+%4=E!<0%!L/!,:=:E%$!<*!+%@*,4=E!:=(!4=M%2<,%=<!,:=:E%$\!

#*<<2!2'EE%2<2!<0%!<4<&%!?04%3!L=<%$=:&!L=M%2<,%=<2!Q334@%$-

L=!$%&:<4*=!<*!<0%!(42@'224*=!*3!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!34=(4=E2!<0:<!

=%%(2!<*!+%!@&:$434%(-

!F#F!T.;4.;D,!+-!:%&!E;:&D)6:&4!2:)6:&DC!B**)+6>%

/0%!(42@'224*=!0:2!&%(!<*!<0%!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!0*R!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!R*$62-

"_ /0% !?LQ ! =%%(2 ! <* ! <04=6 ! 0*&42<4@:&&F !R0%= ! 0% ! *$ ! 20% ! 42 !R*$64=E !R4<0 ! :$<4@'&:<4=E ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%]2 ! L/! 2<$:<%EF- !/0% !?LQ!=%%(2 ! <* ! <04=6 ! 4= !0*R ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! '2':&&F !0:=(&%2!

4=M%2<,%=<2- ! L< ! 42 ! <0$*'E0 ! <0% ! :&&*@:<4*= ! *3 ! $%2*'$@%2 ! :=( ! 4=M%2<,%=<2 ! <0:< !,:6%2 ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:+&%!<*!+%@*,%!,*$%!@*0%$%=<-

7_ /0% ! ?LQ ! =%%(2 ! <* ! R*$6 ! R4<0 ! 4=<%$1%$2*=:& ! $%&:<4*=2 ! +*<0 ! R0%= ! 4< ! @*,%2 ! <* ! <0%!

<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22!^@0:=E%!,:=:E%,%=<_!:=(!R0%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!<0%!4=M%2<4E:<4*=!:=(!

'=(%$2<:=(4=E ! *3 ! 0*R ! <0% ! %Y%@'<4M% ! <%:, ! <04=62\ ! :=( ! 0*R ! <0% ! %,1&*F%%2 ! :=( !,4((&%!

,:=:E%$2!:$%!<04=64=E!:=(!:@<4=E!R0%=!3:@4=E!@0:=E%-

;_ /0%!?LQ!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!<0%!4(%:2!*3!4=@*$1*$:<4=E!L/!4=<*!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!P46%R42%!

R4&& ! 0% ! *$ ! 20% ! =%%( ! <* ! @0:&&%=E% ! <0% ! *$<0*(*YF ! <0:< ! '2':&&F ! %Y42< ! :,*=E ! <0% ! =*=BL/!

%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!<0%!L/B,:=:E%$-!/F14@:&&F!<0%F!2%%!L/!:2!2*,%<04=E!*11*24=E!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!+F!1$*,424=E!*=%!<04=E!:=(!<0%=!=%M%$!(%&4M%$!4<-!L3!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!42!2%%=!:2!

2'@0!<0%=!4<!42!M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!4<!R4&&!0:M%!=*!4=3&'%=@%!4=!<0%!2<$:<%EF!3*$,'&:<4*=-

>_ 8<$:<%E4%2!:$%=]<!*=!1:1%$!<0%F!:$%!<0%!:@<4*=2!<0%!M:$4*'2!2<:6%0*&(%$2!,:6%-!8<$:<%E4%2!:$%!

!"!#$%&!';

Page 30: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!:@<4*=2-

9#$&%$J/&*$5/+3%&2$'-*&A+/#&79&*/1'/$0.&'%2&#3A&/#$&/A3&';;13'5#$*&'1$&2$'-/&A+/#&+%&1$-'/+3%&/3 &

A31N+%0&A+/#&+%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$?

!F#H!P;!E$!,:)6:&DC

/0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!:(M*@:<%2!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*3!:=!%Y1&4@4<!L/!2<$:<%EF!:=(!*3!2'@0!

,*2<!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!L/!,:=:E%$2!1&:=!L/!<*!+%!2*,%<04=E!:1:$<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!:@<4=E!:2!:=!

*$E:=4V:<4*= ! R4<04= ! <0% ! *$E:=4V:<4*=- ! /042 ! @:= ! *=&F ! +% ! :M*4(%( ! +F ! <0% ! L/ ! (%1:$<,%=< ! ^*$!

(%1:$<,%=<2 ! (%1%=(4=E ! *= ! 24V% ! *3 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42%_ ! <0$*'E0 ! 3*$@4=E ! <0% ! &%:(%$2041 ! *3 ! <0% ! L/B

(%1:$<,%=<!<*!<04=6!4=!$%&:<4*=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<04=6!*3!L/!:2!:=!4=<%$=:&!4=M%2<,%=<-!P46%R42%!

42!4<!(42@'22:+&%!R0:<!:=!%Y1&4@4<!:=(!R%&&!(%24E=%(!L/!2<$:<%EF!42!E**(!3*$!43!4<!42=]<!:&4E=%(!R4<0!<0%!

+'24=%22!:=(!'=(%$2<**(!+F!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2-!

L<!42!:$E':+&%!43!<0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%E4@:&!:11$*:@0!42!R*$<0!,'@0!3*$!:=!%=<%$1$42%!+%24(%2!<0:<!<0%!

?LQ!@:=!1$*M%!<*!<0%!?TQ!:=(!?QQ!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!1$*`%@<2!<0:<!:$%!

2'11*$<%(!+F!L/-

/*!%=2'$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!,:6%2!'2%!*3!:!(433%$%=<!:11$*:@0!<0:=!<0$*'E0!<0%!%Y1&4@4<!L/!2<$:<%EF-!/0%!

:&<%$=:<4M%!42!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!R0%$%!<0%!3*@'2!42!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF!4=!:=!L/!@*=<%Y<-!/0%!%,+*(4,%=<!42!(*=%!<0$*'E0!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!:!@&%:$!3*@'2!*=!4=<%$=:&!

4=M%2<,%=<2-!

P46%R42%!(*%2!#*<<2!:$E'%!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!$*&%!20*'&(!+%!:+*&420%(!:=(!$%1&:@%(!R4<0!<0%!$*&%!*3!<0%!

@04%3!L=<%$=:&!L=M%2<,%=<2!Q334@%$!^?LLQ_!<0:<!42!4=!@*=<$*&!*3!$%:&4V4=E!<0%!+%=%34<2!:=(!1$%(4@<4*=2!

*3!4=M%2<,%=<!4=<%$=:&&F!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!K@@*$(4=E!<*!#*<<2!20*'&(!<042!:4(%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4<0!

$%:&4V4=E!<0%!1$*,42%!^:=(!1$%,42%2_!<0:<!<0%!+'24=%22!@:2%2!2<:<%(!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!R*'&(-

/0%!2%1:$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!(*%2!0*R%M%$!3*@'2!*=!<0:<!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!3$*,!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<]2!1*4=<!*3!M4%R-!/0:<!3*$@%2!0%!*$!20%!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!$4262!

:=(!<0%$%3*$%!0:2!<*!<04=6!*=!0*R!<*!,4<4E:<%!<0%!$4262!<0$*'E0!1&:==4=E-!

L3!<0%!*1<4,:&!2<$:<%E4@!:11$*:@0!,4E0<!+%!:!@*,+4=:<4*=!*3!<0%!<R*!:11$*:@0%2!*3!R0%$%!<0%!?LQ!

:$<4@'&:<%2!3%R!+'<!1$%@42%!1$4=@41&%2!<0:<!:$%!%=3*$@%(!<0$*'E0!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!<0$*'E0!@'&<'$%!

R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*3!1$4=@41&%2!:$%!@*,1:<4+&%!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!^R0%=!'2%(!

:2!:!E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,_-

!"!#$%&!'L

Page 31: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

84=@% ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 42 ! =*< ! *11*24=E ! <0% ! @*=@%1< ! *3 ! <0% ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! *$ ! <0% ! 2%1:$:<%(!

:11$*:@0!<*!L/!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%F!@:=!+%!@*,+4=%(!4=!:!1$:@<4@:&!:11$*:@0-!

/0%!1$:@<4@:&!:11$*:@0!R4&&!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!@0:1<%$!<4<&%(!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=-

9#$&%$J/&5#';/$1&A+--&($&2$'-+%0&A+/#&79&03=$1%'%5$&631&/#$&$4(32+4$%/&3,&/#$&79&*/1'/$0.:?&9#$ &

5#';/$1&A+--&'%'-.O+%0&#3A&P3**&Q&"$+--&6P3**&Q&"$+--&CDDR:&/#+%N*&3,&79&03=$1%'%5$<&'%2&#3A&

/#$+1&=+$A*&5'%&($&';;-+$2&+%&53%/$J/&3,&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$?

!"!#$%&!(M

Page 32: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&D& ?!&E&F'G%/*"*A%

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!42!:!1:$<!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!R0F!L/!42!:!

=%@%224<F!<*!E*M%$=-

K2!L!0:M%!,%=<4*=%(!4=!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!@0:1<%$\!D@g%%=!:=(!8,4<0!^D@g%%=!)!8,4<0!7JJ>\!11-!""!

B!"7_!:$E'%2!<0:<!L/!42!%M%$FR0%$%!4=!<0%!+'(E%<2!*3!:=!%=<%$1$42%!24=@%!,*2<!:22%<2!:$%!%,+%((%(!4=!

4=3*$,:<4*= ! :=( ! 6=*R&%(E% ! <0:< ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 1*22%22- ! /0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! =%%(2 ! <* ! 0:=(&% ! <0%4$!

4=3*$,:<4*=!:=(!6=*R&%(E%!4=!:!1$*1%$!R:F!<*!%=:+&%!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!8<$:<%E4%2!0:M%!=*!

M:&'%!43!<0%F!:$%=]<!%,+*(4%(!4=!<0%!:@<4*=2!*3!0*R!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!<0%!&%:(%$2041!+%0:M%2-!L=!

2'@0!L/!2<$:<%EF!42!%=3*$@%(!<0$*'E0!E*M%$=:=@%-!9*22!)!5%4&&!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI_!:$E'%2!L/!

E*M%$=:=@%!42!:!R:F!<*!%=2'$%!<0%!$4E0<!+%0:M4*$!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R04&%!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!<0%!

,:=:E%$2!%=E:E%!4=!<0%4$!$%21%@<4M%!:@<4M4<4%2-

K@@*$(4=E!<*!9*22!)!5%4&&!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!24Y!(433%$%=<!3*$,2!*3!E*M%$=:=@%-!L3!4<!42!@*,1:$%(!<*!

R0:<!D@g%%=!:=(!8,4<0!:=(!<0%!R:F!<0%F!2%%!L/!<0%=!4<!42!:&2*!:=!4=(4@:<*$!3*$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

,:=:E%!:=(!'<4&4V%2!4<2!:22%<2-!/0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!%Y%@'<4M%2!<:6%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!4=<*!

@*=24(%$:<4*=!R0%=!4<!%=E:E%2!4=!<0%!M:&'%!,:Y4,4V:<4*=!*3!4<2!4=<%$=:&!4=M%2<,%=<2-

9*22!)!5%4&&!:$E'%2!<0:<!+%0:M4*$!^%,+*(4,%=<!*3!2<$:<%EF_!42!+%<<%$!<0:=!%Y1&4@4<!2<$:<%E4%2-!/042!

,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!<0%!,%,+%$2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:@<2!R0%=!<0%F!:$%!

'24=E!%-E-\!L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF!<*!@*,1&%<%!<0%4$!<:262-

ST$#'=+31*<&%3/&*/1'/$0+$*<&51$'/$&='-)$!

C- ^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJ>\!1-!C_

K2!2'@0!<042!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!+%0:M4*$!0:2!<*!+%!%=3*$@%(!<0$*'E0!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!$%21*=24+4&4<4%2!:=(!

@*,,4<,%=<!3$*,!@*,,4<<%%2!*$!E$*'12!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!0:2!<0%!1*R%$!<*!(%@4(%!R0:<!

<%@0=*&*E4%2!@:=!+%!4=M%2<%(!4=!:=(!,:(%!'2%!*3-

50%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!<0%!E*M%$=:=@%!*3!<0%!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!<0%=!9*22!)!5%4&&!(%34=%2!<0%!<0:<!

L/!E*M%$=:=@%!42!<0%!,*2<!=*<:+&%!4=(4@:<*$!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!3*$!1$%(4@<4=E!<0%!M:&'%!*3!<0%!

L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!4=M%2<%(!4=-

!"!#$%&!(K

Page 33: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

S"$&53%5-)2$&/#'/&$,,$5/+=$&79&03=$1%'%5$&+*&/#$&*+%0-$&43*/&+4;31/'%/&;1$2+5/31&3, &

/#$&='-)$&'%&310'%+O'/+3%&0$%$1'/$2&,134&79?!

O- ^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJ>\!11-!;B>_

50%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!<0%=!9*22!)!5%4&&!(%34=%2!<0%!@*=@%1<!:2!+%4=E!<0%!

:&&*@:<4*=!*3!<0%!(%@424*=!$4E0<2!:=(!:@@*'=<:+4&4<F!3*$!0*R!4=M%2<,%=<2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!L/!20*'&(!

+%-!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!,:=:E%,%=<!,:6%2!'2%!*3!L=3*$,:<4*=!

/%@0=*&*EF-

S79&03=$1%'%5$F &U;$5+,.+%0 & /#$ &2$5+*+3% &1+0#/* &'%2&'553)%/'(+-+/. & ,1'4$A31N& /3&

$%53)1'0$&2$*+1'(-$&($#'=+31&+%&/#$&)*$&3,&79?!

G- ^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJ>\!1-!G_

!H#"!T+)9,!+-!D+G&);6;>&

K@@*$(4=E!<*!9*22!)!5%4&&!<0%$%!:$%!<R*!1%$21%@<4M%2!*3!L/!E*M%$=:=@%-!/0%!34$2<!1%$21%@<4M%!42!

R0*!@:=!@*,%!R4<0!4=1'<!<*!:!(%@424*=!,:64=E!@*,,4<<%%!:=(!=%%(&%22!<*!2:F!<0%!2%@*=(!42 !:!

1%$21%@<4M%!(%:&4=E!R4<0!<0%!(%@424*=!,:64=E-!K,*=E!<0%!24Y!3*$,2!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!

3*$,2!<0:<!:$%=]<!:2!%33%@<4M%!4=!@*,1&%Y!%=<%$1$42%2!:2!*<0%$2-!/0%$%+F!2:4(!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!:&2*!2*,%!

*3!<0%!E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,2!<0:<!2'4<2!2,:&&!:=(!,%(4',!24V%(!%=<%$1$42%2!:=(!8QWQ2O-!

9*22 !) !5%4&& ! @0:$:@<%$4V%2 ! <0% ! 34$2< ! 3*$,!*3 !E*M%$=:=@% ! ^4+$"'&$$ .0*'1#(-"&$_ ! :2 ! +%4=E ! <0%!

E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,!R0%$%!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!(4@<:<%2!R0:<!2F2<%,2!<*!'2%!:=(!0*R!<*!'2%!<0%,-!/0%!

*+M4*'2!(*R=24(%!42!<0:<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!%Y%@'<4M%2!(*=]<!=%@%22:$4&F!6=*R2!:=F<04=E!:+*'<!L/!:=(!

<0%!2<$:<%E4@:&!:21%@<!*3!<%@0=*&*EF-!/0%!:(M:=<:E%!+F!,:64=E!'2%!*3!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!E*M%$=:=@%!

3*$,!42!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!,4E0<!%=3*$@%!<0%!+'24=%22!E*:&2!4=!<0%!(%@424*=!,:64=E!:=(!+F!<0:<!

:&4E=4=E!L/!R4<0!+'24=%22!E*:&2-

9*22!)!5%4&&!(%34=%2!<0%!2%@*=(!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!^5,.0*'1#(-"&$_!:2!R0%=!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!

*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:@@*'=<:+&%!:=(!$%21*=24+&%!3*$!R0:<!L/!2F2<%,2!<0:<!:$%!(%24$:+&%!'2%!:=(!4=M%2<!

4=-!/0%!:(M:=<:E%!42!<0:<!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!6=*R2!0*R!<0%!<%@0=*&*EF!R*$62!:=(!R0:<!4<!@:=!+%!

'2%(!3*$-!/0%!(42:(M:=<:E%!42!R0%=!<0%!L/!1%*1&%!42!R*$64=E!R4<0!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!<0%F!*3<%=!<%=(2!<*!

1'<!<**!,'@0!%33*$<!4=<*!<%@0=*&*EF!4=2<%:(!*3!4=M%2<4=E!<0%4$!:<<%=<4*=!<*!<0%!=%%(2!*3!<0%!+'24=%22-

O 8,:&&!Q334@%2![!W*,%!Q334@%2-

!"!#$%&!('

Page 34: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

/0%=!9*22!)!5%4&&!(%34=%2!<0%!<04$(!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!^6&+71)_!:2!R0%=!%:@0!&4=%!*3!+'24=%22!

R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!(%@4(%2!R0:<!L/!2F2<%,2!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!:=(!:2!2'@0!%:@0!(4M424*=!,:=:E%$!

(%@4(%2!R0:<!1:$<4@'&:$!2*3<R:$%!:=(!0:$(R:$%!2*&'<4*=2!<0:<!,4E0<!+%!2'4<:+&%!3*$! <0%4$ ! &4=%!*3!

+'24=%22-!K2!R4<0!<0%!<R*!E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,2!<0%$%!:$%!+*<0!:(M:=<:E%2!:=(!(42:(M:=<:E%2-!i%%(&%22!

<* ! 2:F ! <0:< ! <0% !(42:(M:=<:E% ! *3 ! <042 ! 3*$, !*3 ! E*M%$=:=@% ! 42 ! <0:< ! <0% ! L/ ! 1&:<3*$, ! ^/%@0=*&*EF!

K$@04<%@<'$%_!R4&&!+%!3$:E,%=<%(d!0*R%M%$!<0%!:(M:=<:E%!42!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22!:$%!

:+&% ! <* !*1<4,4V% ! <0%4$ !1:$<4@'&:$ ! 2'+B:$@04<%@<'$%2 ! <* !,:<@0 ! <0% ! $%Z'4$%,%=<2 !*3 ! <0%4$ !1:$<4@'&:$!

:@<4M4<4%2-!/0%!(42:(M:=<:E%!42!<0:<!<0%!04E0!&%M%&!*3!:'<*=*,F!,4E0<!&%:(!<*!:!&%22%$!(%E$%%!*3!

4=<%$*1%$:+4&4<F ! :=( ! :2 ! 2'@0 ! 4< !,4E0< !,4=4,4V% ! <0% ! M:&'% ! *3 ! <0% ! (:<: ! <0:< ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 0:2!

:@@','&:<%(-

9*22!)!5%4&&!<0%=!(%34=%2!<0%!3*$<0!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!^6&7&#1)_!:2!:!E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,!<0:<!R*$62!

:!+4<!&46%!:!1:$&4:,%=<:$F!(%,*@$:@F!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%$%!42!<R*!24(%2!<0:<!=%E*<4:<%!*=!R0:<!2*&'<4*=2!

<0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!1'$@0:2%(\!R04@0!<*!+%!(%@*,,4224*=%(!:=(!R04@0!2F2<%,2!<0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!:&<%$%(!

<*!,:<@0!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*`%@<2!<0:<!R4&&!($4M%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!$%:@0!4<!M424*=!:=(!<0%$%+F!4<2!E*:&2-!

/0%!<R*!24(%2!:$%!<0%!L/![!,:=:E%$2!:=(!<0%!+'24=%22!%Y%@'<4M%2-

9*22!)!5%4&&!<0%=!(%34=%2!<0%!343<0!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!^8+*/*)2_!:2!:!E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,!R0%$%!<0%!

L/!(%1:$<,%=<!42!$%1$%2%=<%(!:&*=E!24(%!:=*<0%$!3:@<4*=!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!9*22!)!5%4&&!,:6%2!

'2%!*3!:=!%Y:,1&%!*3!R04@0!<0%$%!@:=!+%!%4<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!*$!1$*@%22!1%*1&%!<0:<!$%1$%2%=<2!<0%!

*<0%$! 3:@<4*=- !/042! 3*$,!*3 !E*M%$=:=@%!E4M%2! <0%!%=<%$1$42%!:(M:=<:E%2 !:=(!(42:(M:=<:E%2- !/0%!

*+M4*'2!:(M:=<:E%!42!<0:<!4<!42!,*$%!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!=%E*<4:<%!:=(!:&4E=!<0%!

E*:&2!*3!<0%!L/!24(%!:=(!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=-!/0%!(42:(M:=<:E%!@:=!+%!<0:<!<0%!<R*!

24(%2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42=]<!:+&%!<*!@*,+4=%!:!2'4<:+&%!,4Y!+%<R%%=!:&4E=,%=<\!@*2<!$%('@<4*=!:=(!

4==*M:<4*=-

9*22!)!5%4&&!(%34=%2!<0%!24Y<0!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!^9'1#(-2_!:2!+%4=E!:!24<':<4*=!*3!R04@0!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!0:2!E4M%=!^4,1&4@4<!*$!%Y1&4@4<_!<0%!1*R%$!*3!(%@4(4=E!<0%!'2:E%!*3!0:$(R:$%\!2*3<R:$%!:=(!

4=3*$,:<4*= ! 2F2<%,2 ! <* !E$*'12 !*$ ! 4=(4M4(':& !'2%$2- !i%%(&%22 ! <* ! 2:F ! <0:< ! <0%$% !:$% !Z'4<% ! : ! 3%R!

(42:(M:=<:E%2!d !0*R%M%$! <0%$%!,4E0<!:&2*!+%!2*,%!:(M:=<:E%2- !K=!:(M:=<:E%!@*'&(!+%!<0:<! <0%!

4=(4M4(':&!'2%$!,4E0<!+%!,*$%!1$*('@<4M%!24=@%!*$!20%!@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!2*3<R:$%!:=(!2*&'<4*=2!

<0%F!0:M%!+%%=!3:=@F4=E!:=(!1$*+:+&F!'2%(!<0%4$!*R=!%33*$<!<*!&%:$=!:=(!<$'2<2-

9*22!)!5%4&&!@*=@&'(%2!4=!<0%4$!2'$M%F!<0:<!<0%!<*1!1%$3*$,%$2!R4<04=!:=F!E4M%=!4=('2<$F!,:6%2!'2%!

*3!%4<0%$!<0%!('*1*&F!*$!3%(%$:&!:11$*:@0!<*!4=1'<!:=(!(%@424*=!,:64=E-!K11:$%=<&F!4<!E4M%2!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%2!<0%!2F=%$EF!:,*=E!+'24=%22!:=(!L/!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!(%M%&*1!<0%!<%@0=*&*E4@:&!1&:<3*$,-

!"!#$%&!((

Page 35: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

K2!,%=<4*=%(!4=!<0%!3*$,%$!@0:1<%$!(%:&4=E!R4<0!L/!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!$%:2*=2!<*!+%&4%M%!<0:<!

<0%!20:$%!1&:==4=E!:=(!E*M%$=:=@%!*3!L/!@:=!+%!:!&4:+4&4<F!4=2<%:(!*3!:!M:&'%!:((4=E!:22%<-! !/042!

,%:=2!<0:<!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!20*'&(=]<!+%!E*M%$=%(!:2!:!2%1:$:<%!<04=E!24=@%!4<!,4E0<!E4M%!<0%!

L/B&%:(%$2 ! <0% ! 4,1$%224*= ! <0:< ! <0% ! L/B*$E:=4V:<4*= ! 42 ! 2*,%0*R ! (%<:@0%( ! 3$*, ! <0% ! $%2< ! *3 ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!:2!2'@0!2'+B*1<4,4V%-

L/!4=M%2<,%=<2!@:=!+%@*,%!2<$:<%E4@:&&F!4,1*$<:=<!3*$!:=!%=<%$1$42%\!R04@0!42!*=%!*3!<0%!@*=@&'24*=2!

*3 !D@K3%% !) !N$F=`*&322*=]2 ! $%2%:$@0 ! *= ! <0% ! 2'+`%@< ! ^D@K3%% !) !N$F=`*&322*= ! 7JJG\ ! 1- ! ;BC_-!

K@@*$(4=E!<*!D@K3%%!)!N$F=`*&322*=!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!2%M%$:&!:11$*:@0%2!<*!0*R!L/!@:=!%=:+&%!:!

@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!

L=!042!:$<4@&%!3$*,!7JJG!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!2%M%$:&!<F14@:&!,4(24V%(!K,%$4@:=!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!,:6%2!'2%!

*3!L/!<*!%=:+&%!%Y<$:*$(4=:$F!2%$M4@%2!<*!4<2!@'2<*,%$2!*$!<0$*'E0!$%B'24=E!(:<:!<*!4==*M:<%!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%]2!2%$M4@%2-!/042!*=&F!%,10:24V%2!<0%!=%%(!<*!E*M%$=!<0%!<%@0=*&*E4@:&!:$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!

,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!E*M%$=:=@%!<*!:22'$%!1$*('@<!4==*M:<4*=-

/F14@:&&F!%=<%$1$42%2\!R0%$%!<0%!E*M%$=:=@%!3*$,!0:2!+%%=!<**!+'24=%22!3*@'2%(!%=(%(!'1!R4<0\!<0:<!

*&(!1$*@%22%2!24,1&F!0:2!+%%=!4=<%E$:<%(!(4$%@<&F!<*!<0%!L/!2F2<%,2!,%:=4=E!<0:<!<0%$%!0:M%!+%%=!:!

$:<0%$!&4<<&%!1$*('@<4*=!4=@$%:2%!:=(!$:<0%$!3%R!+%=%34<2!0:M%!+%%=!$%:&4V%(!24=@%!<0%!R*$6!2F2<%,2G!

:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!=%%(2!<*!*1%=!'1!3*$!:(M4@%!3$*,!<0%!L/!*$E:=4V:<4*=!

:=(!3$*,!@*=2'&<:=<2!<0:<!@:=!@*,%!R4<0!M:&4(!4=1'<!*=!0*R!L/!@:=!E%=%$:<%!3'$<0%$!M:&'%-

L=!<0%!(4&%,,:!R4<0!:(,4=42<$:<4*=!^E*M%$=:=@%_!:=(!4==*M:<4*=!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!H*'@%<!

%<!:&-!^H*'@%<!%<!:&-!7JJI\!1-!>I>_!:$E'%2!<0:<!4<!42!:!$:<0%$!34=%!:@<!*3!+:&:=@4=E!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!0:M%!

<*!@*,,4<!<**!<*!:M*4(!<*!3:&&!4=<*!:=F!*3!<0%!<R*!(4<@0%2!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!2:,%!@:=!+%!2:4(!*=!L/!

E*M%$=:=@%-

9*22!)!5%4&&!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!""_!<0:<!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!(%:&2!R4<0!24Y!(433%$%=<!%&%,%=<2-!/0%!

34$2< ! %&%,%=< ! 42 ! L/ ! 1$4=@41&%2\ ! <0% ! 2%@*=( ! %&%,%=< ! 42 ! L/ ! :$@04<%@<'$%\ ! <0% ! <04$( ! %&%,%=< ! 42 ! L/!

L=3$:2<$'@<'$%!8<$:<%E4%2\!<0%!3*'$<0!%&%,%=<!42!+'24=%22!:11&4@:<4*=!=%%(2!:=(!<0%!24Y<0!:=(!34=:&!

%&%,%=<!42!L/!4=M%2<,%=<2-

K&&!4=!:&&!9*22!)!5%4&&!:$E'%2!<0:<!:!@*,+4=:<4*=!*3!L/!&%:(%$2!:=(!<0%!+'24=%22!&%:(%$2!^<F14@:&&F!

%Y%@'<4M%2_!<*!:&4E=!<0%!M4%R2!*3!L/!:=(!+'24=%22-!/0%!:&4E=,%=<!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!E*M%$=!4<2!4=<%$=:&!:22%<2!<0%!$4E0<!R:F-!K2!2'@0!9*22!)!5%4&&!+%&4%M%2!<0:<!4=!:&&!*3!

<0%!24Y!%&%,%=<2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!+%<<%$!*3!+F!:11&F4=E!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%!:=(!<0%!L/!24(%!4=!<0%!

G K!R*$6!2F2<%,!42!:!2*@4:&!2F2<%,!*3!R04@0!*=%!*$!,*$%!:@<4M4<4%2!<0:<!<$:=23*$,2!$%2*'$@%2!4=<*!2%$M4@%2!<0:<!@:=!+%!

'2%(!+F!%4<0%$!@'2<*,%$2!*$!*<0%$!2%@<4*=2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!K2!2'@0!:=!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%!@*=24(%$%(!:2!*=%!R*$6!

2F2<%,2!+'<!:&2*!:2!,'&<41&%!:2!E$*'12\!(%1:$<,%=<2!:=(!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22!:&&!@:=!20:$%!<0%!@0:$:@<%$42<4@2-

!"!#$%&!()

Page 36: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

4=1'<!:=(!(%@424*=!,:64=E-

!H#1!A.,>(,,.+;!+-!E$!S+G&);6;>&

L/!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=!3*$!,:=F!%=<%$1$42%2!+%!:!E**(!R:F!<*!0:=(&%!:=(!*1%$:<4*=:&4V%!*=%!*3!<0%!,*2<!

M:&':+&%!:22%<2!3*$!:=F!%=<%$1$42%!^4=!$%3%$%=@%!<*!D@g%%=!:=(!8,4<0_-!W*R%M%$!*=%!4,1*$<:=<!=*<%!

<0:< ! <0% ! %Y%@'<4M%2 ! 20*'&( ! <:6% ! 4=<* ! @*=24(%$:<4*= ! 42 ! <0:< ! E*M%$=:=@% !(%24E=:<%( ! ^:=( ! 2<$:<%EF!

:$<4@'&:<%(_!3*$!L/!,4E0<!&%:(!<*!2'+B*1<,4V:<4*=-!L=!<0%!*<0%$!0:=(!43!<0%$%!42=]<!:!3*@'2!*=!0*R!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!4=M%2<2!:=(!(%M%&*12!4<2!<%@0=*&*E4@:&!:$@04<%@<'$%!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!

'2%!:!&*<!*3!$%2*'$@%2!<*!]34E0<!34$%2]!4=2<%:(!*3!%=:+&4=E!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!L<!42!Z'4<%!@&%:$!<0:<!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!1'<!:=!%33*$<!4=<*!E*M%$=!4<2!L/!24=@%!4<!@:=!+%!:&&*@:<%(!<*!:=F!*3!<0%!+'(E%<2!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:=(!L/!42!:!6%F!%=:+&%$!3*$!0*R!*=%!*3!<0%!,*2<!@$4<4@:&!:22%<2!3*$!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!

:$%!,:=:E%(!^4=3*$,:<4*=!)!6=*R&%(E%_-

K2!4<!42!R4<0!<0%!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!<0:<!?0$42!#*<<2!:(M*@:<%2\!<0:<!(%:&2!R4<0!<0:<!,*2<!:@<4M4<4%2!*3!

:!,*(%$=!R%2<%$=!%=<%$1$42%!0:M%!<*!+%!2'11*$<%(!+F!L/!4=!2*,%!R:F-!P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF!+%!3*&&*R%(!+F!:=!4=<%$=:&!4=M%2<,%=<2!1&:=!4=2<%:(!*3!:=!L/B@%=<$4@!:11$*:@0d!<042!,%:=2!

<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:2!2'@0!=%%(2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!^E*M%$=:=@%_!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!

:=(!4<!=%%(2!<*!+%!1$4*$4<4V%(!04E0&F-!W*R%M%$!<0%!$%21*=24+4&4<4%2!20*'&(!+%!*$E:=4V%(!:$*'=(!<0%!

?QQ\!L/B,:=:E%$2!:=(!:!?LLQI!:22',4=E!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!,:Y4,4V%!M:&'%!*3!4<2!:22%<2!

('%!<*!<0%!$%2*'$@%2!@:=!+%!:&&*@:<%(!<*!,*$%!2<$:<%E4@:&!4,1*$<:=<!1$*E$:,2!<0:<!@:=!,*M%!<0%!

%=<%$1$42% ! @&*2%$ ! <* ! :@04%M% ! 4<2 ! E*:&2- !/0% !?LLQ\ ! L/ ! [ !,:=:E%$2\ !?QQ! :=( ! <0% !?AQ ! 20*'&(!

'=(%$%2<4,:<%!#*$<%$!:=(!042!4(%:2!*=!2<$:<%EF!42=]<!2*&%&F!*1%$:<4*=:&!%334@4%=@F!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%F!

20*'&( !@:$%3'&&F ! %2<4,:<% ! %:@0 !*1<4*= ! <0:< ! E4M%2 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! <0% !*11*$<'=4<F ! <* ! 4==*M:<% ! 4<2!

+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!4==*M:<%!0*R!L/!@:=!%=:+&%!+'24=%22!<*!+%!(*=%!4=!=%R!R:F2!:=(!,:6%!=%R!

1$*('@<2!*$!2%$M4@%2-

84=@% !#*$<%$ ! 42 ! 4= ! <0% !1*24<4*=4=E !2@0**& !^D4=<V+%$E !7JJI!1- !7C_! <0%= ! 4< !0:2 ! <* !+% ! <:6%=! 4=<*!

@*=24(%$:<4*=!<0:<!042!M4%R2!*3!2<$:<%EF!,4E0<!=*<!+%!:&4E=%(!R4<0!<0%!2@0**&!*3!<:'E0<!<0:<!42!,:(%!

'2%!*3!4=<%$=:&&F!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

&DB4B-& )/:+:A:,3&'(&?!&"*1&)'3<%+:+:G%&@1G"*+"7%

/%@0=*&*EF!4=!E%=%$:&!42!=*<!2'4<:+&%!R:F!3*$!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!<*!E:4=!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!24=@%!

<%@0=*&*EF!@:=!+%!(%3'2%(!<* !@*,1%<4=E!%=<%$1$42%2. ^?:$$!7JJ.\!1- !OG_:! P46%R42%! 4< !(*%2!*3<%=!

0:11%=!R0%=!%=<%$1$42%2!4=M%2<!4=!L/!<0%=!,*2<!*3!<0%!E:4=2!3$*,!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!42!R$*=E3'&&F!$%B

I ?04%3!L=<%$=:&!L=M%2<,%=<2!Q334@%$-

!"!#$%&!(*

Page 37: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

4=M%2<%(!4=!&*R%$4=E!<0%!1$4@%2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!1$*('@<2!<*!:@04%M%!:!+4EE%$!,:$6%<!20:$%!*$!<*!

3*$@%!@*,1%<4<*$2!:R:F!3$*,!<0%!,:$6%<!21:@%-!/042!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!@*=2',%$2!*3<%=!E%<!<0%!&4*=2!

20:$%!*3!<0%!+%=%34<2!*3!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<-!84=@%!<0%!@*,1%<4<*$2!$:<0%$!%:24&F!@:=!,:<@0!<0%!'2:E%!*3!

<%@0=*&*EF!<0%=!R4&&!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!3:@%!:!1$4@%!R:$!;?:$$!7JJ.\!1-!C>_-

?:$$!^?:$$!7JJ>\!1!"JOB";>_!@*=@&'(%2!<0:<!3*$!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!<0%=!4<!R*'&(!+%!1$%3%$:+&%! <*!

@*,,4<!<*!<0%2%!1$4=@41&%2!"_!T*&&*R!(*=]<!&%:(-!7_!T*@'2!*=!<0%!$426!:=(!=*<!*=!<0%!*11*$<'=4<F!

^4==*M:<%!R0%=!$4262!:$%!&*R_!:=(!;_!21%=(!&%22-

W*R%M%$!R0:<!?:$$!=%E&%@<2!4=!042!:11$*:@0!42!<0:<!=*!%=<%$1$42%!42!4(%=<4@:&!<*!*=%!:=*<0%$!:=(!:2!

2'@0!=*<!:&&!<%@0=*&*EF!%-E-\!4=3*$,:<4*=!2F2<%,2!@:=!+%!(433'2%(-!P46%R42%!4<!42!<0%!*+&4<%$:<4*=!*3!

<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!<0%!R*$6!2F2<%,2!4=!@*,+4=:<4*=!R4<0!<0%!(%1&*F,%=<!*3!L/!<0:<!,:6%2!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!:+&%!<*!@*,1%<%!R4<0!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2-

!H#7!P;!E$!S+G&);6;>&

L=!@*=@&'24*=!<0:<!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2!4=!L/!@:=!+%@*,%!:!E$%:<!1*<%=<4:&!%=:+&%$!3*$!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%2!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!!P46%R42%!42!4<!=*<!1*224+&%!3*$!,*2<!,*(%$=!%=<%$1$42%2!<*!(%<:@0!L/!

E*M%$=:=@% ! 3$*, ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! E*M%$=:=@% ! +'< ! 4= ! <0% ! *<0%$ ! 0:=( ! <0%= ! L/ ! E*M%$=:=@% ! 20*'&(=]<!

%=@*'$:E%! <0% ! L/!,:=:E%$2 ! :=(! <0% ! L/!(%1:$<,%=<2 ! <* !(%<:@0 ! <0%,2%&M%2 ! 3$*,! <0% ! $%2< !*3 ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!:2!2'@0!+%@*,%!:!+:$$4%$!<*!<0%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0-

L/!E*M%$=:=@%!20*'&(!+%!2%%=!:2!:!R:F!<*!2%%!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!,*(43F!4<2!1$*@%22%2!:=(!4=!<0%!

2:,% ! <4,% !,:Y4,4V% ! <0% !M:&'% !*3 ! <0% ! $%2*'$@%2 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% !0:2 ! 4=M%2<%( ! 4= ! 4<2 ! L=3*$,:<4*=!

/%@0=*&*EF-

L!0:M%!,%=<4*=%(!%:$&4%$!4=!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!<0:<!1&:=2!3*$!<0%!2:6%!*3!1&:=2!@$%:<%2!=*!M:&'%!:=(!

<0%!2:,%!@:=!+%!2:4(!:+*'<!L/!2<$:<%EF!)!E*M%$=:=@%-!/0%$%3*$%!@:=]<!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!+%!4E=*$%(!43!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R:=<2!<*!,:Y4,4V%!M:&'%!^*3!<0%4$!4=M%2<,%=<2_!:=(!,*$%!%334@4%=<!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2d!

0*R%M%$!R0:<!42!(%+:<:+&%!42!R0:<!3*$,!*3!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!2<$'@<'$%!<0:<!20*'&(!+%!:11&4%(!4=!:=F!

E4M%=!%=<%$1$42%-!

8,:&&!:=(!,%(4',!24V%(!%=<%$1$42%2!,4E0<!+%=%34<!3$*,!:11&F4=E!<0%!+'24=%22!,*=:$@0F!24=@%!<0%!

?AQ!*3<%=!0:2!<0%!*M%$M4%R!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!W*R%M%$!R0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!%Y1%$4%=@%!E$*R<0!

<0%=!<0%!$%21*=24+4&4<4%2!R4&&!+%!(%<:@0%(!3$*,!<0%!?AQ!:=(!E4M%=!<*!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!,4((&%!

,:=:E%$2!R04@0!,:6%2!('*1*&F!:=(!<0%!3%(%$:&!E*M%$=:=@%!:11$*:@0!,*$%!@*=M%=4%=<-

#%<%$!5%4&&!:=(!f%:==%!9*22!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!<*1!1%$3*$,%$2!,:6%2!'2%!*3!*=%!*$!<R*!*3!<0%!24Y!3*$,2!

*3!E*M%$=:=@%d!0*R%M%$!4<!(*%2=]<!,%:=!<0:<!<0%!E%=%$4@!3*$,2!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=!+%!:11&4%(!<*!

!"!#$%&!(+

Page 38: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

:@04%M%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!^%21%@4:&&F!43!%M%$F*=%!(*%2!<0%!2:,%_-

/0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!0:M%!<*!<:6%!<0%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!<0*'E0!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=]<!E4M%!

<0% !%=<%$1$42% !: !@*,1%<4<4M% !:(M:=<:E%- ! L3 ! L/!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=!E4M% ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% !: !@*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%!<0%=!4<!0:2!<*!+%!+F!+4=(4=E!*<0%$!:@<4M4<4%2!<*!4<-!/*!(*!<042!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!,:6%!'2%!

*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!:!R:F!<*!(*!<042!@:=!+%!<0$*'E0!:11&F4=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!+*<0!:!3*$,!*3!(*@',%=<:<4*=!:=(!:!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%\!:=(!4<!R*$62!:!

,%<:!,*(%&!:,*=E!(433%$%=<!3*$,2!*3!2<$:<%E4%2-

50%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:(:1<2!:=!4==*M:<4*=!<0%=!4<!R4&&!%M%=<':&&F!:(*1<!4<!<*!4<2!*R=!@*=(4<4*=2!2*!4<!

34<2 !R4<0! <0% !@'&<'$%\ ! <0%!2<$'@<'$% !:=(! <0% !1$*@%22%2 !R4<04=! <0%!%=<%$1$42%- !/0%$%3*$%!: !E%=%$4@!

:11$*:@0 ! <* ! L/!E*M%$=:=@%\ ! 4=<%E$:<%( !E*M%$=:=@% !:=( !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% !,*(%&2 !R4&& ! +%!

,*(434%(-!

9#$&%$J/&5#';/$1&A+--&($&2$'-+%0&A+/#&310'%+O'/+3%*&'%2&#3A&/#$*$&5'%&($&=+$A$2&'%2&/1'%*,314$2?&

9#$&5#';/$1&A+--&($&2$'-+%0&A+/#&/#$31+$*&,134&V3#%&W?&X3//$1<&Y1/3%&Q&"$+5N&+%5-)2+%0&/#$&=+$A*&

/#'/&G'1.&Z'4$-&#'*&+%/132)5$2&3%&4'%'0$4$%/?

!"!#$%&!(:

Page 39: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&H& I/7"*:J"+:'*&2&K'/L('/A%&.$"**:*7

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!0:M%!<*!(%:&!R4<0!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!<0%!4,1:@<!*3!

*$E:=4V:<4*=2!*=!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-!/0%!@0:1<%$!4=<$*('@%2!<0%!$*&%!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!4=!$%&:<4*=!

<*!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=\!<0%!$*&%!*3!<0%!04$4=E!1$*@%22\!:=(!<0%!$*&%!*3!@0:=E4=E!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=-!L=!<0%!

%=(!*3!<0%!@0:1<%$!:!(42@'224*=!*=!0*R!<0%2%!M:$4*'2!%&%,%=<2!4,1:@<2!L=<%E$:<%!S*M%$=:=@%!42!

3:@4&4<:<%(-

!J#"!$%&!5+3&!+-!L6;6D&9&;:

S:$F!W:,%&!R*$62!R4<0!:=!:22',1<4*=!4=!042!+**6!a/0%!T'<'$%!*3!D:=:E%,%=<b!<0:<!<0%!@'$$%=<!

3*$,!*3!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!^R0:<!L!2*!3:$!0:2!(%34=%(!:2!R*$6!2F2<%,2_!:$%!(%24E=%(!*=!:22',1<4*=2!

(:<4=E!+:@6!<*!<0%!%:$&F!+%E4==4=E!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!<0%*$F-!/0%!%:$&F!+%E4==4=E!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!

*$E:=4V:<4*=:& ! (%24E= ! R:2 ! (*,4=:<%( ! +F ! T$%(%$4@6 ! /:F&*$]2 ! :11$*:@0 ! *= ! ,*<4M:<4*= ! :=(!

,:=:E%,%=<!*3!%,1&*F%%2-!

L<!42!R*$<0!<*!,%=<4*=!<0:<!4=!042!@*=<%Y<!T$%(%$4@6!/:F&*$!R*$6%(!R4<0!:=!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!(%:&<!

R4<0!1$*3%224*=:&4V:<4*=!*3!%=<%$1$42%2"J! R04@0!4= !042 !*14=4*=!R*'&(!,:6%! <0%!%=<%$1$42%2 !,*$%!

%33%@<4M%-

/:F&*$!R*$6%(!R4<0!:=!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!R0%=!%,1&*F%%2!R:2!4=<$*('@%(!<*!:=!4=@%=<4M%!2F2<%,!<0:<!

0:(!,:=F!10:2%2!:=(!,:=F!2<%12!<0%=!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!R*'&(!R*$6!0:$(%$!<*!1%$3*$,!:@@*$(4=E!<*!

<0%!4=@%=<4M%2!1$*E$:,!:=(!:2!2'@0!20*R!(%24$:+&%!+%0:M4*$-!/:F&*$!R:2!*3!<0%!*14=4*=!<0:<!43!<0%!

4=@%=<4M%2!R%$%!<**!+4E!<0%=!<0%!4=(4M4(':&2!R*'&(!2<*1!1%$3*$,4=E-!

L= ! <0% ! 2:,% ! <4,% ! 20*'&( ! <0% ! M:$4*'2 ! +'24=%22 ! 1$*@%22%2 ! +% ! :=:&FV%( ! <0$*'E0 ! : ! 2<$4@< ! <4,%!

,%:2'$%,%=<!^'=4<!,%:2'$%,%=<_!:11$*:@0-

L=! <0%!2:,%!1%$4*(! <0%!@:$!,:='3:@<'$%- !T*$(!,*<*$2!3*'=(%(!:=(! &%(!+F!W%=$F!T*$(!2:R!<0%!

+%=%34<2 !*3 !:11&F4=E! <0% !/:F&*$42< !1$4=@41&%2 !*3 !,:=:E%,%=< !:=(!:(:1<%( ! 4< ! <* ! <0% !T*$(!D*<*$!

@*,1:=F!R04@0!+%@:,%!6=*R=!:2!T*$(42,!^/:F&*$42,!:=(!T*$(42,!0:M%!&:<%$!+%@*,%!2F=*=F,*'2!

R4<0!*=%!:=*<0%$_-!T*$(42,!0*R%M%$!R:2!1'<!4=<*!1$:@<4@%!R4<0!<0%!=*<4*=!<0:<!<0%!R*$6%$2!0:(!<*!

2%1:$:<%(!:=(!<0%4$!<:262!0:(!<*!+%!21%@4:&4V%(!2*!<0%4$!%33%@<4M%=%22!'1!:=(!<0%4$!21%@4:&42,!:2!R%&&-!

/0%!2*!@:&&%(!:22%,+&F!&4=%2!R:2!4=M%=<%(!R0%$%!<0%!R*$63*$@%!R:2!<$:4=%(!<*!(*!*=%!1:$<4@'&:$!

<04=E!R%&&-

"J K<!<0%!<4,%!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!4=!<0%!h-8-!R:2!+:2%(!*=!3*'$!1%$2*=2!:=(!,*2<!%,1&*F%%2!R:2!3*'=(!<0$*'E0!<0%!

4=(4M4(':&2!2*@4:&!=%<R*$62-!P46%R42%!R:2!,*2<!*3!<0%!R*$63*$@%!4&&4<%$:<%!:=(!@*'&(!:2!2'@0!*=&F!$%@%4M%!4=2<$'@<4*=!

<0$*'E0!*$:&!@*,,:=(2!:=(!*=&F!(*!&4,4<%(!<:262-

!"!#$%&!(;

Page 40: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

/0%!21%@4:&42<!:11$*:@0!E:M%!:=!4=@$%:2%(!21%%(!:=(!'=4<!Z':&4<F!:=(!:2!2'@0!4<!:&2*!1$*M%(!<*!+%!

@*2< !%33%@<4M% ! 3*$ ! <0% !T*$(!D*<*$ !@*,1:=F- !W*R%M%$ ! <0% !/:F&*$42< !:11$*:@0!(4( !,4=4,4V% ! <0%!

4=<%$:@<4*=!<0%!(433%$%=<!%,1&*F%%2!0:(!R4<0!*=%!:=*<0%$!:=(!<0:<!&%(!<*!<0:<!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!<0%4$!

:11$*:@0%2!<*!2*&M%!1$*+&%,2!R0%$%!2'11$%22%(!'=(%$!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!04%$:$@0F-!/0%!04%$:$@0F!

R:2!%=3*$@%(!<0$*'E0!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!+'$%:'@$:@F!<0:<!:@@*$(4=E!<*!/:F&*$!R:2!+'4&(!'1*=!<0%!

=%%(!<*!@**$(4=:<%!:=(!@*,,'=4@:<%!<0%!M:$4*'2!<:262-

K3<%$! <0%!1%:6!*3!/:F&*$42,!<0%=!<0%!3*@'2!@0:=E%(!3$*,!:!$:<0%$!,%@0:=42<4@!:11$*:@0!<*!<0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=2!:=(!%,1&*F%%2!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!&4<%$:<'$%!0:2!E*=%!<0$*'E0!2%M%$:&!10:2%2!3$*,!:$%=:2!

*3!1*R%$\!@'&<'$%!:=(!&:2<!+'<!=*<!&%:2<!6=*R&%(E%-

/0%!@'$$%=< !1:$:(4E,!3*$ !M4%R4=E!*$E:=4V:<4*=2 !(%:&2 !R4<0 ! <0:< !%:@0 ! 4=(4M4(':& ! 42 !: !2*'$@% !*3!

6=*R&%(E%!<*!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%=%34<!3$*,!<0%!2*'$@%-

W:,%&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!2<$'@<'$%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!42!:!&%3<!*M%$!3$*,!R0%=!/:F&*$!:=(!042!(42@41&%2!

1$*,*<%(-!

!J#1!$%&!P)D6;.U6:.+;!6;4!E:,!')+*&):.&,

/0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!:2!2'@0!0:2!+%%=!@0:=E4=E!*M%$!<4,%!3$*,!<0%!%:$&F!/:F&*$42<!:=(!T*$(42<!:11$*:@0!

<*!:!3*$,!*3!*$E:=4V:<4*=!R0%$%!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!,:=:E%$2!:&&!:$%!6=*R&%(E%!R*$6%$2-!/0%2%!

6=*R&%(E%!R*$6%$2!0:M%!+%@*,%!<0%!1$4,:$F!:22%<2!3*$!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!4=!<0%!R%2<%$=!:=(!1$*B

R%2<%$=!%@*=*,4%2!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%F!1&:F!:!=%R!1*R%$3'&!$*&%!24=@%!<0%F!4=!,:=F!R:F2!*'<R%4E02!

<0%!M:&'%!*3!@*=M%=<4*=:&!:22%<2-!84=@%!6=*R&%(E%!42!1*$<:+&%!:=(!E*%2!R4<0!<0%!1%$2*=!*3!R04@0!<0%!

6=*R&%(E%!42!%,+%((%(!4=-!!

/0%!1$*+&%,!42!<*!,*<4M:<%!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!<0%!,:=:E%$2!<*!R*$6!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:2!&*=E!:2!4<!

42!1$*34<:+&%!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!

W:,%&!^W:,%&!7JJO\!11-!GGBIC_!:$E'%2!<0:<!%,1&*F%%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!@*:@0%(!:=(!<0%4$!4(%:2!=%%(2!<*!

+% ! <:6%=!2%$4*'2&F !+F ! <0% !@*$1*$:<% !%Y%@'<4M%2- !T$*,! <0:< ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% !R4&& !0:M% ! <* !:4(% ! <0%!

%2<:+&420,%=<!*3!:!R*$6!%=M4$*=,%=<!<0:<!2'11*$<2!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!:=(!<0%4$!1$*`%@<2-!W:,%&!R*$62!

R4<0!4(%:2!2'@0!:2!:=!4==*M:<4*=!(%,*@$:@F!:=(!%,1&*F,%=<!2<$:<%E4%2!<0:<!2'11*$<!<0:<!*=&F!<0%!

+%2< ! %,1&*F%%2 ! :$% ! 04$%( ! :=( ! :2 ! 2'@0 ! <0%F ! @*=<$4+'<% ! <* ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42%- !/042 ! 20*'&( !E4M% ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:!&%:1!:0%:(!*3!@*,1%<4<*$2-!

W:,%&!:$E'%2!^W:,%&!7JJO\!11-!"""!B!"">_!<0:<!E4M4=E!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!<0%!<4,%!:=(!$%2*'$@%2!<*!(*!

<0%4$ !*R=!1$*`%@<2 !R4&& ! 24E=434@:=<&F !:4( ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% ! 43 ! 2*,%!*3 ! <0% !1$*`%@<2 ! <'$=2 !*'< ! <* !+%!

2*,%<04=E!'2%:+&%!%-E-\!3*$!=%R!1$*('@<2!*$!*1<4,4V:<4*=-

!"!#$%&!(L

Page 41: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

50%=!2%&%@<4=E!<0%!$4E0<!%,1&*F%%2!@:=!+%!@$'@4:&!3*$!4==*M:<4*=!:=(!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-!

W:,%&!'2%2!S**E&%!:2!:=!%Y:,1&%!*3!0*R!:=!%=<%$1$42%!R4<0!:!aN*V*!T$%%!k*=%b!@:=!R*$6!R4<0!

:M*4(4=E!%,1&*F%%2!R0*!(*=]<!1%$3*$,!*$!+%0:M%!:@@*$(4=E&F!<*!<0%!2<:=(:$(2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

^W:,%&!7JJO\!1- !"JG_- !S**E&%! 4=<%$M4%R2!<0%!1*<%=<4:& !%,1&*F%%!:=(!E4M%2!<0%!1%$2*=!:! &*< !*3!

(433%$%=<!<:262!*3!R04@0!<0%!4=(4M4(':&!0:M%!M%$F!&4<<&%!<4,%!<*!2*&M%!<0%!1$*+&%,2-!NF!2'@0!<0%!

,:=:E%$2!<0:<!%M:&':<%!<0%!@:=(4(:<%!@:=!2%%!43!<0%!R:F!<0%!1%$2*=!2*&M%2!<0%!1$*+&%,2!34<2!R4<0!<0%!

R:F!S**E&%!R*$62-!/0%!104&*2*10F!(%:&2!R4<0!<0:<!KB1%*1&%!:<<$:@<2!*<0%$!KB1%*1&%d!0*R%M%$!43!<0%!

KB1%*1&%!2<:$<2!<*!04$%!NB1%*1&%!:=(!43!<0%!(%E%=%$:<4*=!@*=<4='%2!<0%=!?B1%*1&%!2<:$<2!<*!%=<%$!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%- !S**E&% !+%&4%M%2 ! <0:< !KB1%*1&% !:$% !24E=434@:=<&F !,*$% !1$*('@<4M% ! <0:= !NB1%*1&% !:=(!

4=4<4:<%!,*$%!M:&':+&%!1$*`%@<2-!

L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!2',,:$4V%!<0%!:11$*:@0%2!<0:<!W:,%&!R*$62!R4<0!4=!<0%!<:+&%!+%&*R-

=+/"+%7:A&@<</'"A6 M%,:/"#$%&I0+A'3%

,223C$E132!N&J35=$56 -A&!&2E&=F=10&!5=&$E&0!$!060E&J!3?!9A15A!EA&!&JF436&&0!5$2!C3E&!?3=!9A$E!F=3O&5E0!EA&6!?12P!12E&=&0E12%@

Q246!A1=&!EA&!R&0E -A&!&2E&=F=10&!$C31P0!A1=12%!F&=0320!EA$E!EA&!&JF436&&0!$2P!EA&!J$2$%&=0!?12P0!0/RS0E$2P$=P@!<A&2!E&0E12%!EA&!&JF436&&0!$2P!EA&2!$C31P12%!A1=12%!0/R0E$2P$=P!12P1C1P/$40!EA&2!EA&!&2E&=F=10&!532E$120!$!93=>!&2C1=32J&2E!?3=!&41E10E!&JF436&&0!9A3!$553=P12%!E3!T$J&4!5=&$E&0!%=&$E&=!C$4/&@

U/4E/=$4!HF3203=0 <A&2!$2!&JF436&&!10!A1=&P!EA&2!4&E!32&!3?!EA&!&VF&=1&25&P!&JF436&&0!93=>!$0!$!5/4E/=$4!0F3203=!9A3!$1P0!EA&!2&946!&JF436&P!F&=032!91EA!12E&%=$E12%!91EA!EA&!R/012&00@

DJF436&&!F=3O&5E0 -A&!3=%$21W$E132!0A3/4P!F=3C1P&!EA&!=&03/=5&0!$2P!EA&!3FF3=E/21E6!?3=!&JF436&&0!E3!93=>!91EA!EA&1=!392!F=3O&5E0@!,2!EA$E!9$6!EA&!&2E&=F=10&!9144!&20/=&!53JJ1EJ&2E!$2P!1223C$E132@!

9'(-$&EF&U/1'/$0+$*&,31&$4;-3.4$%/?

/0%!M4%R2!*=!,:=:E%,%=<!<0:<!W:,%&!1$%2%=<2!4=!042!+**6!42!4=!,:=F!R:F2!$:<0%$!$%M*&'<4*=:$Fd!

0*R%M%$!<0%!4(%:2!:=(!:11$*:@0%2!<0:<!W:,%&!R*$62!R4<0!:$%!E%=%$4@-!S%=%$4@!:11$*:@0%2!=%%(2!<*!

+%!@'2<*,4V%(!+F!%=<%$1$42%2-!T*$!Z'4<%!:!3%R!%=<%$1$42%2!<0%!E%=%$4@!:11$*:@0!@:=]<!+%!,:(%!'2%!*3!

:2!4=<%=(%(!24=@%!<0%F!(*!=*<!0:M%!:@@%22!<*!<0%!2:,%!$%2*'$@%2!:2!<0*2%!@:2%2!<0:<!W:,%&!,:6%2!

'2%$!^S**E&%\!?ADAl\!:=(!5-!P-!S*$%_!:=(!,*2<!&46%&F!=*!%=<%$1$42%2!:$%!:&46%!24=@%!<0%F!:$%!

,:(%!'1!*3!1%*1&%-!/0%!4(%:2!@:=!0*R%M%$!+%!,:(%!'2%!*3!<*!3:@4&4<:<%!:!(42@'224*=!4=!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!

E$*'1!:=(!:,*=E!<0%!%,1&*F%%2-

W*M%$2<:(<!(*%2!4=!042!+**6!a/0%!T$:@<:&!Q$E:=4V:<4*=b!^W*M%$2<:(<!7JJG\!11-!">B"._!:(M*@:<%2!3*$!

!"!#$%&!)M

Page 42: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!,:=:E%,%=<!:$%!4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V%(!<0$*'E0!<0%4$!%('@:<4*=!:=(!<0%4$!R:F!*3!

R*$64=E!<*!<04=6!4=!:!1:$<4@'&:$!1:<<%$=!<0:<!42!$%B%=3*$@4=E!4<2%&3!*M%$!<4,%-!/0%$%3*$%!@:=!4<!+%!

%Y1%@<%(!<0:<!,:=:E%$2!:=(!%,1&*F%%2!,4E0<!+%@*,%!$:<0%$!$%24&4%=<!R0%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!@0:=E%!<0%4$!

1%$@%1<4*=!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62!:=(!0*R!<*!:@<!:=(!2*&M%!*=!M:$4*'2!1$*+&%,2-

P46%R42%!(*%2!W*M%$2<:(<!^W*M%$2<:(<!7JJG\!11-!>7!B!>G_!:(M*@:<%!<0:<!4<!42!=%@%224<F!<*!2%@'$%!<0:<!

<0%$% ! 42 ! 2*,% ! 3*$, !*3 ! 2<:+4&4<F ! :=( ! : ! 3*$, !*3 ! 4=2<:+4&4<F ! <* !,:6% ! 2'$% ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! :=( ! 4<2!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!(%M%&*12!:=(!:(:1<2!<*!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,4=*!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!K=(!R0%=!R*$64=E!

R4<0!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*3!:!+'24=%22!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<0:<!:&&!&%M%&2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

1:$<4@41:<%! 4=!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*=!<0%4$ !*R=!&%M%&- !L< ! 42 !:!=%@%224<F ! 43 ! <0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!:(($%22 ! <0%!

M:$4*'2!@0:=E%2!4=!4<2!(*,:4=-!T*$!<042!<0%$%!42!=%%(%(!:!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!:=(!<0:<!@:=!+%!(*=%!

<0$*'E0!@*,,'=4@:<4=E!<0$*'E0!<0%!M:$4*'2!(%1:$<,%=<2!:=(!E$*'12!*3!1%*1&%!^W*M%$2<:(<!7JJG\!

11-!"IJB"I"_-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&#3A&/3&5#'%0$&'%&$%/$1;1+*$&+%/3&'&2$*+1'(-$&*/'/$<&#3A&/#$&/1'%*,314'/+3%&3,&/#$ &

$%/$1;1+*$&5'%&($&23%$&/#13)0#&/#$&;$1*;$5/+=$*&3,&='1+3)*&/#$31+$*?

!J#7!$)6;,-+)9.;D!:%&!?;:&)*).,&

50%=!:=!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!+%!$%2<$'@<'$%(!*$!(%M%&*1%(!4=!:!(4$%@<4*=!<0:<! <0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!34=(2!

(%24$:+&%!<0%=!<0%!<0%$%!:$%!2%M%$:&!(433%$%=<!:11$*:@0%2!*=!0*R!<*!:=!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^<0%!0',:=!24(%!

*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%_!R*$62!:=(!4<!(4@<:<%2!R0:<!@*=(4<4*=2!<0:<!R*$62-

/0%!34$2< !:11$*:@0!<*!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!@0:=E%!42!1$*1%$&F!:&2*!<0%!,*2<&F!'2%(!:11$*:@0!:=(!R:2!

*$4E4=:&&F!:$<4@'&:<%(!+F!f*0=!#-!g*<<%$!4=!042!"II.!:$<4@&%!a<&17"'3.=-1'3&>.?-2.=-1'3&.@!!*#%$.

61")b-!L=!<0%!:$<4@&%!g*<<%$!1$*,*<%2!:=!%4E0<!2<%1!@0:=E%!3$:,%R*$6!<0:<!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!0:2!<*!<:6%!

4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!R0%=!@0:=E4=E!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!3$*,!<0%4$!2<:<'2!Z'*-

g*<<%$]2!@0:=E%!3$:,%R*$6!42!0*R%M%$!+:2%(!*=!g'$<!P%R4=]2!<0$%%!2<%1!@0:=E%!3$:,%R*$6!^N*$',!

"II.\!1-!>>_!*3!R04@0!@:=!*=&F!+%!'2%(!4=!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!<0:<!@:=!+%!@&:22434%(!:2!<4E0<&F!4=<%E$:<%(-!

P%R4=]2!<0$%%!2<%1!:11$*:@0!42!+'4&(!'1*=!<0%!4(%:!<0:<!:=!*$E:=4V:<4*=!@:=!+%!'=3$%%V%(\!,*M%(!:=(!

3$%%V%(!4=<*!:!=%R!2<:E%-

/0%!%4E0<!10:2%2!^g*<<%$!"II.\!1-!C"_!:$%!+'4&(!'1*=!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!:!@$4242!42!=%%(%(!<*!@$%:<%!

:!24<':<4*=!R04@0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!*M%$@*,%-!/042!R4&&!:11:$%=<&F!,:6%!2*,%!*3!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!

$%:(F!<*!R*$6!4=!:!=%R!R:F!43!<0%F!:$%!4=3*$,%(!:+*'<!<0%!@$4242!4=!<0%!@*$$%@<!,:==%$!:=(!4=!<0%!

@*$$%@<!<4,%-!N%&*R!L!0:M%!&42<%(!<0%!%4E0<!10:2%2m

a"_!A2<:+&4204=E!:!2%=2%!*3!'$E%=@F-

!"!#$%&!)K

Page 43: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

7_!T*$,4=E!:!E'4(4=E!1*R%$3'&!@*:&4<4*=-

;_!?$%:<4=E!:!M424*=-

>_!?*,,'=4@:<4=E!<0%!M424*=-

._!A,1*R%$4=E!*<0%$2!<*!:@<!*=!<0%!M424*=-

C_!#&:==4=E!3*$!:=(!@$%:<4=E!20*$<B<%$,!M4@<*$4%2-

O_!?*=2*&4(:<4=E!4,1$*M%,%=<2!:=(!1$*('@4=E!2<4&&!,*$%!@0:=E%-

G_!L=2<4<'<4*=:&4V4=E!=%R!:11$*:@0%2-b

/0%!*<0%$!M4%R!*=!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!@0:=E%!42!<0%!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!2F2<%,2!^*$E:=4V:<4*=_!:=(!<042!

3*$,!*3!%=<%$1$42%!@:=]<!+%!@0:=E%(!<0$*'E0!:!@%=<$:&4V%(!:11$*:@0!24=@%!<0%!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!2F2<%,!

42!*=&F!$%,*<%&F!:<<:@0%(!<*!<0%!@*,1*=%=<2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<0%2%!:$%!*3<%=!4=!4=<%$:@<4*=!

R4<0!%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<4%2-!W*R%M%$!<0%!Z'%2<4*=!*3!0*R!@*'1&4=E!@:=!+%!(%+:<%(-

S9+0#/-.&53);-$2&*.*/$4*&'1$&;31/1'.$2&'*&#'=+%0&1$*;3%*+=$&534;3%$%/*&/#'/&23&%3/&

'5/ & +%2$;$%2$%/-.< & A#$1$'* & -33*$-. & 53);-$2 & *.*/$4* & '1$ & ;31/1'.$2 & '* & #'=+%0&

+%2$;$%2$%/&534;3%$%/*&/#'/&23&%3/&'5/&1$*;3%*+=$-.!

! ^Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!"IIJ!1-!7J._

W*R%M%$!24=@%!,*2<!,*(%$=!%=<%$1$42%2!:$%!6=*R&%(E%!4=<%=24M%!%=<%$1$42%2!^:2!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!

3*$,%$!2%@<4*=_!<0%=!4<!42!:!1$*+:+4&4<F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!4=!2*,%!R:F!*$!<0%!*<0%$!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(-

g:$&!5%4@6!^Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!"IIJ_!R0*!42!<0%!*<0%$!,:4=!:'<0*$!R0*!L!R4&&!,:6%!'2%!*3!4=!<042!

@0:1<%$!@&:4,2!<0:<!<0%!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!%=<%$1$42%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!:!(433%$%=<!R:F!<0:=!

R4<0!@0:=E%!1$*@%22%2!<0:<!0:M%!+%%=!+:2%(!*=!g'$<!P%R4=-!/0%!$%:2*=!3*$!<042!42!<0:<!<0%!M:$4*'2!

2%,4B4=(%1%=(%=<!(%1:$<,%=<2\!E$*'12!*$!&:F%$2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%!4=3&'%=@%(!+F!3:@<*$2!

*'<24(%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:2!2'@0!0:2!<*!E4M%!(%1:$<,%=<2!<0:<!

0:M%!:@@%22!<*!@'2<*,%$2!:=(!2'11&4%$2!2*,%!2*$<!*3!3$%%(*,!<*!4=<%$:@<-!/0%!3$%%(*,!@:=!<'$=!<*!:!

(4:&%@<4@!^2<$'EE&%!3*$!$%2*'$@%2!:=(!1*R%$_!:,*=E!<0%!(%1:$<,%=<2-

Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!%4E0<!<F1%2!*3!@*'1&4=E-

S"31N+%0&A+/#&/#$&=3+5$&3,&/.;3-30.<&A$&+2$%/+,.&/#$&$+0#/&43*/&,1$H)$%/-.&1$5)11+%0&

/.;$*&3,&-33*$&53);-+%0F&[33*$&53);-+%0&'43%0&+%2+=+2)'-*<&'43%0&*)()%+/*<&'43%0&

310'%+O'/+3%*<&($/A$$%&#+$1'15#+5'-&-$=$-*<&($/A$$%&310'%+O'/+3%*&'%2&$%=+13%4$%/*<&

'43%0&+2$'*<&($/A$$%&'5/+=+/+$*&'%2&($/A$$%&+%/$%/+3%*&'%2&'5/+3%*&!

!"!#$%&!)'

Page 44: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

! ^Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!"IIJ!1-!7JG_

L=!<0%4$!1:1%$!<0%F!1$%(4@<!<0:<!:!(4:&%@<4@!:11$*:@0!*=!0*R!<0%!2*@4:&!2F2<%,2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:M%!

3*$,%(!R4&&!:4(%!<0%!4=<%$1$%<%$!^*+2%$M%$_!*3!<0%!2*@4:&!2F2<%,!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!*'<@*,%2!*3!<0%!

2*@4:&!2F2<%,-!L=!:((4<4*=!<*!<042!M4%R!*=!<0%!2*@4:&!2F2<%,2!<0%=!Q$<*=!:=(!5%4@6!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!

&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!2F2<%,2!42!:!R:F!<*!%Y1&:4=!0*R!<0%!2*@4:&!2F2<%,2!0:M%!%M*&M%(!*M%$!:!1%$4*(\!:=(!

<0%!:11$*:@0!20*'&(!+%!'2%(!R4<0!:!(%E$%%!*3!@:'<4*=!43!<0%!*+2%$M%$!1&:=2!<*!,:6%!'2%!<0%!:11$*:@0!

<*!(%2@$4+%!<0%!1$*1%$<4%2!*3!:!2*@4:&!2F2<%,!^Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!"IIJ\!1-!7"I_-

S93&'**$1/&/#'/&'&*.*/$4&+*&-33*$-.&53);-$2&+*&/3&;1$2+5'/$&*;$5+,+5&;13;$1/+$*&'%2&' &

*;$5+,+5&#+*/31.&/3&/#$&*.*/$4<&1'/#$1&/#'%&'%&'(*$%5$&3,&;13;$1/+$*!

! ^Q$<*=!)!5%4@6!"IIJ!1-!7"I_

Q$<*=!:=(!5%4@6!(%34=%2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!3:@<*$2!<0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!<:6%=!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!R0%=!

<0%!*+2%$M%$!&**62!3*$!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!2F2<%,2-

!J#<!P;!P)D6;.U6:.+;!6;4!E:,!E9*6>:

/0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!:2!:=!*$E:=4V:<4*=!=*<!+%!:+&%!<*!@0:=E%!+:@6!<*!R0:<!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!*=@%!R:2-!

h2':&&F!<042!,%:=2!<0:<!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!@:=]<!@0:=E%!+:@6!<*!R0:<!4<!*=@%!R:2!1%$@%4M%(!:2\!%-E-\!

24,1&%\!2<:+&%!:=(!%:2F!<*!E*M%$=-!L=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!<042!,%:=2!<0:<!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!0:2!+%@*,%!,*$%!

@*,1&%Y\!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!:=(!<042!&%:(2!<*!2*,%!@*,1&4@:<4*=2!*3!0*R!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

3'$<0%$-

/0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!=%%(!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!<0%!R:F!4<!*1%$:<%(!@:=]<!=%@%22:$4&F!

@0:=E%(!%:24&F!*$!:2!:!'=434%(!%=<4<F-! !/0%!<R*!(433%$%=<!:21%@<2!^P%R4=!e!g*<<%$!M%$2'2!Q$<*=!)!

5%4@6_!@:=!+%!@*,+4=%(!4=!:!3$:,%R*$6!3*$!@0:=E%-!/0%!3$:,%R*$6!@:=!<0%=!+%!'2%(!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!3$*,!<0%!2<:<'2!Z'*!<*!:!(%24$:+&%!2<:<%!<0:<!42!,:<@0%(!4=!<0%!M424*=!3*$!<0%!@*$1*$:<4*=-!

/0%!@*,+4=%(!:11$*:@0!R4&&!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!(%<:4&!4=!<0%!@0:1<%$!(%:&4=E!R4<0!74;-$4$%/'/+3%?

/0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!0:2!:!E$%:<!4,1:@<!*=!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:+&%!<*!:(:1<!<*!<0%!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!&46%R42%!0:2!<0%!2<$'@<'$%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:!M%$F!+4E!4,1:@<!*=!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!

:+&%!<*!*$E:=4V%!R*$6!:=(!%=:+&4=E!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!<*!@*=<$4+'<%!R4<0!4==*M:<4*=-

/0%$%3*$%!42!4<!:!=%@%224<F!<*!(%:&!R4<0!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!<0%!,:=:E%,%=<!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!<*!

%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!:(:1<!<*!<0%!@0:&&%=E%2!<0:<!*@@'$2!4=!<0%!(*,4=*!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!

L= ! $%&:<4*= ! <* ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! E*M%$=:=@% ! <0% ! '=(%$2<:=(4=E ! *3 ! <0% ! *$E:=4V:<4*= ! :=( ! <0% !R:F ! <0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!R*$62!42!%Y<$%,%&F!4,1*$<:=<-!/0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!<0%!M:$4*'2!@*,1*=%=<2!*3!<0%!

!"!#$%&!)(

Page 45: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

*$E:=4V:<4*= !R4&& !+% !:+&% ! <* !'=(%$,4=% ! <0% !(%M%&*1,%=< ! :=(! <0% ! 4,1&%,%=<:<4*= !*3 ! L=<%E$:<%(!

S*M%$=:=@%!24=@%!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!@'&<'$%!@:=!04=<%$!@*&&:+*$:<4*=!:,*=E!<0%!M:$4*'2!(%1:$<,%=<2\!

:=(!<0%!2<$'@<'$%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!,4E0<!%=:+&%!2'+B@'&<'$%2!<0:<!R*$62!:E:4=2<!*=%!:=*<0%$!4=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%-!P46%R42%!42!4<!4,1*$<:=<!<0:<!<0%!:11$*:@0!<*!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!2'11*$<%(!+F!<0%!

%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!*<0%$!,:=:E%$2!4=!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=d!*<0%$R42%!4<!R4&&!=*<!+%!1*224+&%!<*!4,1&%,%=<!

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-!L=!*<0%$!R*$(2!<0%!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!0*R!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!R*$62!^2<$'@<'$%\!

@'&<'$%\!,:=:E%,%=<\!,4((&%!,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!%,1&*F%%2_!42!:!@*$%!@*,1*=%=<!<*!R*$64=E!R4<0!

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

9#$&%$J/&5#';/$1&A+--&($&2$'-+%0&A+/#&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$&'%2&#3A&+/&5'%&($&';;-+$2&/3&$%'(-$&

+%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$?&7/&+*&+4;31/'%/&/3&N%3A&/#'/&310'%+O'/+3%&+*&3%$&3,&/#$&N$.&534;3%$%/*&/3 &

4'N$&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$&A31N&'*&431$&/#'%&'&,314&3,&235)4$%/'/+3%?

!"!#$%&!))

Page 46: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&N& O*+%/</:,%&@/A6:+%A+0/%

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!R0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!+%!'2%(!3*$!4=!

$%&:<4*= ! <* ! %2<:+&420 ! : ! 0*&42<4@ !,:=:E%,%=< ! :11$*:@0 ! :=( ! L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@%- ! 8* ! 3:$ ! <042!

&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!0:2!+%%=!(%:&4=E!R4<0!0*R!<*!@$%:<%!:!@*0%$%=<!M4%R!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62\!

:=(!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!+%!4,1$*M%(!<0$*'E0!<0:<-

/0%$%!:$%!<R*!<04=E2!<0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!+%!(%34=%(!:2-!K@@*$(4=E!<*!N%$=:$(!^N%$=:$(!

7JJ.\!1-!;;_!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!+*<0!:!3*$,!*3!(*@',%=<:<4*=!:=(!:!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%\!

(%1%=(4=E!*=!0*R!<0%!<*1!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!(%@4(%2!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-

N%$=:$(!(%34=%2!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:2!+%4=E!8<$:<%EF!n!/%@0=*&*EF!n!N'24=%22!!^N%$=:$(!7JJ.\!

1-!;7_!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%2%!@:=!+%!E*M%$=%(!4=!:!@*0%$%=<!,:<<%$!R0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!(*@',%=<%(!

4<2!4=4<4:&!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%!R04@0!42!<4<&%(!a:2!42b!^N%$=:$(!7JJ.\!;O_-

N%$=:$(!,:6%2!'2%!*3!R0:<!42!6=*R=!:2!<0%!AK;!?'+%!<*!4&&'2<$:<%!0*R!:=!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-!

B1'A+%0&EF&T$1%'12&CDD]<&;?&K^?

50%=!,:64=E!'2%!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!:&&*@:<%!$%2*'$@%2!<*!:=!

A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 1$*E$:, ! <0:< ! :2 ! 2'@0 !R*$62 ! : ! @*&&%@<4*= ! *3 ! 1$*`%@<2 ! <0:< !,*M%2 ! <0%!

!"!#$%&!)*

B3$40!$2P!,21E1$E1C&0

#=3P/5E0!$2P!H&=C15&0

N$E$!$2P!,2?3=J$E132

H60E&J0!$2P!GFF415$E1320

X&E93=>!$2P!,2?=$0E=/5E/=&

812&0!3?!./012&00

Y=$J&93=>!N1J&20132!

KZ!8&C&40@

Y=$J&93=>!N1J&20132!

'Z!H&%J&2E0@Y=$J&93=>!N1J&20132!

(Z!G=E1?$5E0@

U3JF32&2E0

H&5/=1E6!7!HE$2P$=P0!7!<3=>?3=5&

HE=$E&%6![!./012&00!S!-&5A2343%6

Page 47: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!(433%$%=<!&:F%$2!*3!:$@04<%@<'$%!<*R:$(2!:!(%24$%(!2<:E%-

N%$=:$(!:$E'%2!<0:<! <*!,*M%!<0%!:$@04<%@<'$%!<0%=!:=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!D:=:E%,%=<!#&:=!

^N%$=:$(!7JJ.\!1-!;>_!=%%(2!<*!+%!:$<4@'&:<%(-!/0%!1&:=!42!'2%(!<*!@*=M4=@%!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!<*!+'F!

4=<* ! <0% ! @*=@%1< ! :=( ! :&&*@:<% ! <0% ! =%@%22:$F ! $%2*'$@%2 ! :=( ! (42<$4+'<% ! <0% ! $%21*=24+4&4<F ! :=(!

:@@*'=<:+4&4<F!<*!4,1&%,%=<!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,-

/0%!:@@*'=<:+4&4<F!:=(!<0%!$%21*=24+4&4<4%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!(42<$4+'<%(!2*!M:$4*'2!(%1:$<,%=<2!R4<04=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!R*$62!<*E%<0%$!*=!@*,1&%<4=E!<0%!<:262-

L=!<0%!AK!;!?'+%!3$:,%R*$6!<0%$%!42!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!:=!:$<43:@<\!/0%!:$<43:@<2!@:=!+%!:!2<$:<%EF\!

(*@',%=<\!*$E:=4V:<4*=!@0:$<!*$!:!2',,:$F!<0:<!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!0*R!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-

K2! 4< ! 42 !20*R=! 4= ! <0% !($:R4=E! <0%=! <0% !($:R4=E! 42 !: ! $'+$4@2 !@'+%!*3 !R04@0 ! <0%$%!:$% ! &4=%2 !*3!

+'24=%22%2!^<0:<!@:=!+%!(%1:$<,%=<2!:=(!(4M424*=2_!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%- !L=! <0%!<*1!&:F%$! 42!<0%!

E*:&2 ! :=( ! 4=4<4:<4M%2- !N%&*R! <0% ! 42 ! <0% ! 1$*('@<2 ! :=( ! 2%$M4@%2 ! :=( ! +%&*R ! <0:< ! 42 ! <0% ! (:<: ! :=(!

4=3*$,:<4*=!&:F%$-!/0%!&:F%$!+%&*R!*3!(:<:!:=(!4=3*$,:<4*=!42!<0%!2F2<%,2!:=(!:11&4@:<4*=2!&:F%$!:=(!

<0%!&:2<!&:F%$!42!<0%!=%<R*$6!:=(!4=3$:2<$'@<'$%!&:F%$-

/0%!:22',1<4*=!42!<0:<!<0%!E*:&2!:=(!4=4<4:<4M%2!42!<0%!($4M4=E!&:F%$!:=(!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!&:F%$2!20*'&(!

4(%:&&F!+%!:&4E=%(!R4<0!<0%!<*1!&:F%$-d!0*R%M%$!<042!42!=*<!<0%!@:2%!3*$!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!0:M%!

%Y1%$4%=@%(!E$*R<0-

/0%!($:R4=E!20*R2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!%&%,%=<2!<0:<!E*%2!<0$*'E0!:&&!<0%!&:F%$2!4=!<0%!@'+%-

8<$:<%EF\!+'24=%22!:=(!<%@0=*&*EF!R4&&!+%!%,+%((%(!4=!%:@0!*3!<0%!&:F%$2-!/0%!:22',1<4*=!42!<0:<!

<0%2% ! <0$%% ! %&%,%=<2 ! :$% ! =%%(%( ! <* ! %=2'$% ! <0:< ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! @:= ! 1%$3*$, ! <0% ! :@<4M4<4%2 ! <0:<!

@*,+4=%(!1$*('@%2!<0%!1$*('@<2!*$!2%$M4@%2!<0:<!<0%!@'2<*,%$2!*$!@&4%=<2!R:=<2-

P46%R42%!42!<0%!R*$63*$@%\!2<:=(:$(2!:=(!2%@'$4<F!1&:==4=E!<0$%:(2!<0:<!@:=!+%!3*'=(!*=!%M%$F!&%M%&!

*3!<0%!@'+%!^:=(!<0%$%+F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%_-

/0%!@*,1*=%=<2!@:=!+%!R4<04=!`'2<!*=%!&4=%!*3!+'24=%22!:=(!<0%!4<!@:=!+%!20:$%(!:,*=E!M:$4*'2!&4=%2!

*3!+'24=%22!:=(!M:$4*'2!&%M%&2!4=!<0%!@'+%-

/0% ! AK! ; ! @'+% ! 42 ! : ! 3$:,%R*$6 ! :=( ! 42 ! =*< ! <4E0<&F ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! <* ! <0% ! @*=@%1< ! *3 ! A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%\ !24=@%! <0%$%!:$%!,:=F!*3<%$ ! 3$:,%R*$62! <0:< ! <0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@< !@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3-!

AY:,1&%2!*3!3$:,%R*$62!:$%!/QSKT""!:=(!k:@0,:=!^<0%2%!:$%!E%=%$4@_!:=(!<0%$%!:$%!%Y:,1&%2!*3!

@*,1:=F!21%@434@!3$:,%R*$62!<0:<!42!0*&(!4=24(%!%=<%$1$42%2-

"" /0%!Q1%=!S$*'1!K$@04<%@<'$%!T$:,%R*$6-

!"!#$%&!)+

Page 48: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

9*22!)!5%4&& !(%:&2 !R4<0 !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 4= ! <0%4$ !+**6 !A@'%&#/#"$& .9#(-"%&(%+#& .1$ .1.

B%#1%&32C! 3$*,!7JJC-!L=!<0%!+**6!<0%F!:(($%22!3*'$!(433%$%=<!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&2!<0:<!:=!%=<%$1$42%!

@:= !,:6% !'2% !*3 ! <* ! :@04%M% ! : ! @*,1%<4<4M% ! :(M:=<:E%\ ! :=( ! <0%2% ! :$% ! 24,4&:$ ! <* ! <0*2% ! <0:< ! :$%!

(42@'22%( ! 4= ! <0%4$ ! +**6 ! aL/B2:MMFb- !9*22 !) !5%4&& ! :$% ! $:<0%$ ! L/ ! @%=<$4@ ! 4= ! <0%4$ ! :11$*:@0 ! <*!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!24=@%!<0%F!1$*,*<%!4<!:2!:=!L/!<**&!:=(!=*<!:2!a0*&42<4@!+'24=%22!<**&b!

<0%=!4<!@:=!*=&F!+%!(%34=%(!:2!+%4=E!*=!<0%!aT*'=(:<4*=!K$@04<%@<'$%b!4=!$%3%$%=@%!<*!H*'@%<!%<!:&-!

^H*'@%<!%<!:&-!7JJI\!11-;O_-

/042!0*R%M%$!(*%2=]< !%Y@&'(%!<0%!'2:E%!*3!<0%!4(%:2!1$%2%=<%(!+F!9*22!)!5%4&&!<*!2'11*$<!<0%!

2<$:<%E4@!'2:E%!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-!L<!42!=*<:+&%!<0:<!9*22!)!5%4&&!(*=]<!1$%2%=<!:!1:$<4@'&:$!

3$:,%R*$6!3*$!0*R!<*!'=@*M%$!<0%!:$@04<%@<'$%2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2-!i%4<0%$!(*!9*22!)!5%4&&!1$%2%=<!

:!1:$<4@'&:$!,%<0*(*&*EF!3*$!0*R!<*!:11$*:@0!<0%!'=@*M%$!<0%!1$*@%22-

/*!2',,:$4V%!<0%!:11$*:@0!<0:<!9*22!)!5%4&&!R*$62!R4<0!<0%=!@*$%!*3!'24=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!

42!3*$!%&4,4=:<4=E!<0%!E:12!:=(!(433%$%=@%2!+%<R%%=!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<]2!M4%R!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

R*$62 ! :=( ! 0*R ! a<0% ! +'24=%22b ! 1%$@%1<4*= ! *3 ! <0% ! :@<4M4<4%2- ! L= ! $%&:<4*= ! <* ! <042 ! <0%= ! <0% ! L/ ! [!

(%1:$<,%=<!:=(!a<0%!+'24=%22b!+$4(E%!<0%!E:12!+%<R%%=!R0:<!R*$62!:=(!R0:<!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!<*!

%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:+&%!:@04%M%!<0%!E*:&2!:=(!<0%!M424*=!<0:<!0:2!+%%=!:$<4@'&:<%(!3*$!4<-

/042!1$*@%22!42!@:&&%(!a:$<4@'&:<4=E!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&b!+F!9*22!)!5%4&&\!:=(!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!

42!R0:<!+%!(%34=%(!:2!<0%!aK8!L8b!:$@04<%@<'$%!^:2!4<!R:2!(%34=%(!+F!N%$=:$(_-!!9*22!)!5%4&&!<0%=!

:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!<:6%!@0:$E%!:=(!,:<'$%!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-!L<!42!,F!:22',1<4*=!

<0:<!<0%F!<0$*'E0!<042!1$*@%22!<0%!?LQ!:=(!a<0%!+'24=%22b!%Y%@'<4M%2!4=4<4:<%!1$*`%@<2!<0:<!,:<'$%2!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%!3$*,!+%4=E!3$:E,%=<%(!<*!+%@*,%!2*,%<04=E!<*!+%@*,%!,*$%!:E4&%!:=(!

(%1&*F:+&%!<*!:@04%M%!+%2<!1$:@<4@%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!<%@0=*&*EF!2'11*$<!3*$!:@04%M4=E!<0%!

+%2<!1*224+&%!$%2'&<2-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&#3A&+%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$&+*&534(+%$2&A+/#&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)$?

!K#"! E;:&D)6:&4!S+G&);6;>&!6;4!?;:&)*).,&!B)>%.:&>:()&

50%=!:11&F4=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!4<!@:=!+%!'2%(!:2!:!3*$,!*3!E&'%!<*!

,:6% ! L=<%E$:<%( ! S*M%$=:=@% ! R*$6- ! N%$=:$( ! ^N%$=:$( ! 7JJ.\ ! 1- ! ;;_ ! :$E'%2 ! <0:< ! L=<%E$:<%(!

S*M%$=:=@%!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!^@0:1<%$!*=%_\!@:14<:&!1&:==4=E\!2%@'$4<F\!R*$63*$@%!

1&:==4=E!:=(!1$*E$:,!,:=:E%,%=<-

L= ! N%$=:$(]2 ! M4%R ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 42 ! : ! +$:=@0 ! *3 ! L=<%E$:<%( ! S*M%$=:=@% ! +'< ! =*< ! :=!

!"!#$%&!):

Page 49: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

4=<%E$:<%(!1:$<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

L<!42!0*R%M%$!:!=%@%224<F!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!Z':&4<4%2!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!@*,,'=4@:<%!

0*R!<0%!M:$4*'2!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!R*$6!2F2<%,2!:=(!<%@0=*&*E4@:&!2F2<%,2!4=<%$:@<!R4<0!*=%!:=*<0%$!<*!

%=2'$%!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!@:=!+%!1%$3*$,%(-

L< ! 42 ! <0%$%3*$% ! : ! =%@%224<F ! <* ! <04=6 ! 4= ! : ! 2&4E0<&F !(433%$%=< !R:F ! :=( !,:6% ! 2'$% ! <0:< !A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%!+%@*,%2!<0%!6%F!($4M%$!3*$!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!$%2'&<!

4=!:!@*0%$%=<!*M%$M4%R!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62!:=(!3$*,!<0:<!:!M424*=!3*$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

20*'&(!+%!&46%!4=!<0%!3'<'$%!@:=!+%!(%$4M%(-! !/042!42!(*=%!<0$*'E0!,:64=E!'2%!*3!$%1*24<*$4%2!<0:<!

%=:+&%2 ! @*,,'=4@:<4*= ! :,*=E! <0% !M:$4*'2 ! :@<*$2 !R4<04= ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42%\ ! 2* ! <0%F ! @:= ! @$%:<% ! :=!

'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-!/0%!@*=@%1<!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=!+%!$%:&4V%(!<0$*'E0!

:11&F4=E!<042!0*&42<4@!M4%R!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!4=!<0%!(%@424*=!,:64=E!1$*@%22-!P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!

(%@424*= !,:64=E !1$*@%22 ! 4=@&'(% ! 2*,%!*3 ! <0% ! 3%:<'$%2 ! <0:< !8@*<< !N%$=:$( !(42@'22%2 ! 4= ! $%&:<4*=!

,:=:E%,%=<!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!#$*E$:,!%-E-\!2@%=:$4*!1&:==4=E-

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!<0:<!@*,+4=%2!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!:=(!1&:==4=E!1$*@%22%2!<*!:@04%M%!<0:<!<0%$%!

:$%=]<!:=F!3*$,2!*3!4=@*0%$%=@F!4=!<0%!1&:=2!3*$!0*R!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&+4;-$4$%/+%0&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$&+%&'%&$%/$1;1+*$?&7&#'=$&4$%/+3%$2&$'1-+$1&+% &

/#+* & ;';$1 & /#'/ & 310'%+O'/+3% & 5)-/)1$ & #'* & ' & 01$'/ & +4;'5/ & /3 & /#$ & *)55$** & 1'/$ & 3, & +4;-$4$%/+%0 &

\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$&31&,31&/#'/&4'//$1&'%.&3/#$1&5#'%0$&+%&()*+%$**&;135$**$*?

!K#1! E9*3&9&;:.;D!?;:&)*).,&!B)>%.:&>:()&

#%*1&%!:=(!*$E:=4V:<4*=:& !@'&<'$%! 42 !=*< !%:2F!<* !(%:& !R4<0!24=@% !<0%4$ !1'$1*2%!42 ! <* !1$*<%@< ! <0%!

,%,+%$2 ! *3 ! <0% ! M:$4*'2 ! (%1:$<,%=<2 ! :=( ! 2%@<4*=2 ! *3 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! :E:4=2< ! @0:=E% ! :=( ! <0%!

'=@%$<:4=<F!*3!@0:=E%-

L<!42!&46%&F!R0%=!:=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,!0:2!+%%=!4=4<4:<%(!<0:<!<0%!1%$2*=2!R0*!:$%!

R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!1$*E$:,!R4&&!3:@%!*11*24<4*=!:=(!:2!2'@0!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!@*,,'=4@:<%!:=(!3:@%!

<0%!*11*24<4*=!:=(!@*,%!<0%,!(*R=!:=(!<$F!<*!,:6%!<0%,!'=(%$2<:=(!R0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!

42!:+*'<!:=(!0*R!4<!R4&&!4,1:@<!<0%4$!(:4&F!R*$6!&43%-

/0%$%3*$%!4<!42!4,1*$<:=<!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!=*<!:&&!3:@<4*=2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!R:=<2!@0:=E%!

*$! <$4%2! <*!1$*,*<%!<0%4$ !*R=!:E%=(:!<0:<! 42=]< !:&4E=%(!R4<0!<0%!:E%=(:!<0:<! <0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!0:2!

%2<:+&420%(!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

I&0$%$1+5&';;13'5#&/3&5#'%0$&A+--&($&2$'-/&A+/#&+%&/#$&5#';/$1&2$'-+%0&A+/#&+4;-$4$%/'/+3%?

!"!#$%&!);

Page 50: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!K#7!$%&!V+3.,:.>!'&),*&>:.G&

Q=%!*3 ! <0% !E*:&2 !R4<0 ! 4,1&%,%=<4=E!A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 4= !:= !%=<%$1$42% ! 42 ! <* !E4M% !:&& ! <0%!

,%,+%$2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:@@%22!<*!2%%!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62!:=(!R0%$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!

+%!<$:=23*$,%(!4=<*-

N%$=:$(!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!34=(4=E2!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,!0:2!<*!+%!20:$%(!4=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%- !/0%2% ! 34=(4=E2 !0:M% ! <* !+% !*$E:=4V%( !:$*'=( ! <0% ! @0*2%= ! 3$:,%R*$6 ! <0:< ! 42 ! %:2F ! <*!

'=(%$2<:=(\!&4=6!:$<43:@<2!<*!*=%!:=*<0%$!:=(!+%!M4%R%(!+F!(433%$%=<!1%*1&%!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%-!L<!42!

<0%$%3*$%!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!1*2<!4<!*=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]!4=<$:=%<-

/0%!Z'%2<4*=!<0%=!+%@*,%2!43!<0%!M:$4*'2!:$<43:@<2!:$%!'=(%$2<**(!<0%!2:,%!R:F!+F!%M%$F!%,1&*F%%!

:=(!<0%!2:,%!0*&42<4@!M4%R!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!'=(%$2<**(!24,1&F!+F!&**64=E!:<!<0%!3$:,%R*$6-!/0%!

:$<43:@<2!0:M%!+%%=!R$4<<%=!+F!M:$4*'2!:@<*$2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!:=(!<0%F!0:M%!<0%4$!21%@434@!

+:@6E$*'=(2 ! ^:@:(%,4@\ ! <$:4=4=E ! :=( ! 264&&2_ ! :=( ! <0:< ! R4&& ! 4= !,:=F ! @:2%2 ! &%:( ! <* ! @*,1%<4=E!

'=(%$2<:=(4=E2!*=!R0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!$%:&&F!42!:=(!R0:<!4<!R4&&!+%@*,%-

L<!42!<0%$%3*$%!=*<!%=*'E0!<*!@$%:<%!:=!*=&4=%!$%1*24<*$F!^N%$=:$(!7JJ.\!1->._!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!

4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V% ! <0% ! $%1*24<*$F ! <0$*'E0 ! 4=<$*('@4=E ! <0% ! %,1&*F%%2 ! <* ! @*=3%$%=@%2 ! :=( !,%%<4=E2!

R0%$%!<0%F!%=E:E%!*=%!:=*<0%$!4=!:!1'$2'4<!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!R0:<!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!$%:&&F!42-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&2+*5)**+3%&3%&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$<&A#$1$&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$&+%&/#$&13-$&3,&

7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&+*&2+*5)**$2?

!K#<!P;!?;:&)*).,&!B)>%.:&>:()&

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!+*<0!:!3*$,!*3!(*@',%=<:<4*=!:=(!:!3*$,!*3!,:=:E%,%=<-!N%$=:$(!2%%2!4<!

:2 ! : ! @*,1*=%=< ! *3 ! 4=<%E$:<%( !E*M%$=:=@% !+'< !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! @:= !+%@*,% ! <0% !E&'% !*3!

L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@% ! 24=@% ! 4< ! '=@*M%$2 ! <0% ! 2<:<% ! *3 ! <0% ! @'$$%=< ! 2<$'@<'$% ! *3 ! <0% !A=<%$1$42%]2!

K$@04<%@<'$%-!/0%!'=@*M%$4=E!1$*@%22!@:=!%=:+&%!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!,:=:E%,%=<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

R4<0!<0%!*M%$M4%R!<0%F!=%%(!<*!:&4E=!<0%!M:$4*'2!&:F%$2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4<0!*=%!:=*<0%$-!50%=!<0%!

*M%$M4%R!0:2 !+%%= !@$%:<%( ! <0%= ! $%:&42<4@ !1&:=2 !@:= !+% !,:(%! 3*$ !0*R! <0% !%=<%$1$42% !20*'&( !+%!

<$:=23*$,%(-!9*22!)!5%4&&!2%%2!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:2!:!<**&!3*$!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!<*!+$4(E%!<0%!

E:1!+%<R%%=!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<\!:=(!<0$*'E0!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*3!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!<0%=!<0%!L/![!

(%1:$<,%=<!:=(!a<0%!+'24=%22b!4(%=<43F!<0%!M424*=!<*!R*$6!<*R:$(2-

W*R%M%$!4<!42=]<!<0:<!%:2F!<*!<$:=23*$,!:=!%=<%$1$42%!24=@%!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!@'&<'$%!,4E0<!+%!:!+:$$4%$!

<*!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!<0%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0-!Q$E:=4V:<4*=!@'&<'$%2!:$%!*3<%=!M%$F!

!"!#$%&!)L

Page 51: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

@*=2%$M:<4M%!:=(!,4E0<!<0%$%3*$%!'=(%$,4=%!<0%!@0:=E%!%33*$<2-

h2':&&F !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% !0:2 ! +%%= ! $:<0%$ ! L/! 3*@'2%( ! ^<%@0=*&*EF ! 3*@'2%(_ ! :=( ! :2 ! 2'@0!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!=%%(2!<*!3*@'2!*=!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=\!4<2!2<$'@<'$%!:=(!<0%!R:F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

R*$62!3$*,!:!2*@4:&!1*4=<!*3!M4%R-!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!(%:&2!R4<0!0*R!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!

@:=!+%!,:<'$%(-

!"!#$%&!*M

Page 52: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&P& )'6%/%*A8&5"*"7%3%*+

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:=(!0*R!4<!@:=!+%!'2%(!<*!,:<'$4=E!A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!%=:+&%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!:@04%M%!,*$%!+%=%34<2!+F!'24=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-

!M#"!$%&!=+;>&*:!+-!=+%&)&;>C!L6;6D&9&;:

?*0%$%=@F !D:=:E%,%=< ! 42 ! (%:&4=E ! R4<0 ! <:64=E ! @0:$E% ! *3 ! := ! %=<%$1$42%]2 ! :$@04<%@<'$% ! 2* ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!'=@*M%$!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-!/0%!

E*:&!+F!:11&F4=E!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!42!<*!:@04%M%!:&4E=,%=<\!:E4&4<F!:=(!:22'$:=@%-

H*'@%<!%<!:&-!R0*!:$%!<0%!,:4=!:'<0*$2!*3!<0%!<0%*$4%2!+%04=(!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:$E'%2!<0:<!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!4=!<0%!3'<'$%!R4&&!+%!*1%$:<4=E!4=!%=M4$*=,%=<2!<0:<!:$%!(*,4=:<%(!+F!3$%Z'%=<&F!

,*$%!@*,1%<4<4*=!:=(!<0%!@'2<*,%$2!R4&&!+%!(%,:=(4=E!<*!+%!:+&%!<*!E%<!:!2<:=(:$(4V%(!^1*24<4M%_!

2%$M4@%!3$*,!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!$%E:$(&%22!*3!R0%=!*$!R0%$%!<0%F!4=<%$3:@%!R4<0!4<-!

/042!R4&&!:@@*$(4=E!<*!H*'@%<!%<!:&!<$:=23*$,!4=('2<$4%2!24=@%!*=&F!<0%,!<0:<!:$%!:+&%!<*!:(:1<!<*!<0%!

@0:=E%2!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!%M%=<':&&F!2'$M4M%!<0%!@*,1%<4<4*=-

H*'@%<!%<!:&!:$E'%2!<0:<!%M%$F!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:=!:$@04<%@<'$%\!*<0%$R42%!4<!R*'&(=]<!+%!:+&%!<*!1$*@%22!

:=F<04=E!:=(!<0:<!+F!=*<!+%!:+&%!<*!(*!:=F!+'24=%22-!/0%!Z'%2<4*=!42!43!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!^,:=:E%,%=<!

:=(!&%:(%$2041!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%_!<:6%2!@0:$E%!*3!<0%!:$@04<%@<'$%-

H*'@%<!%<!:&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!<0$%%!2<:E%2!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!^=*<!4=@&'(4=E!<0%!2<:E%!*3!

=*=B:11&4%(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%_-!/0%!34$2<!2<:E%!42!6=*R=!:2!<0%!T*'=(:<4*=!K$@04<%@<'$%-!

/0%!T*'=(:<4*=!K$@04<%@<'$%! 42 !@0:$:@<%$4V%( !+F. <0:< ! <0% !L/B(%1:$<,%=<!0:2 !+%%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!'=@*M%$!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2d!0*R%M%$!4<!42!*=&F!<0%!L/B(%1:$<,%=<!<0:<!

42 ! @*=M4=@%( ! <0:< ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! @:= ! &%:( ! <* ! +%=%34<2 ! :=( ! %M%=<':&&F ! @*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%2-!h2':&&F!42!<0%!&%:(%$!*3!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!1*24<4M%!:+*'<!<0%!'2:E%!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!:&4E=!<0%!L/!1$*`%@<2!R4<0!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*`%@<2d!0*R%M%$!0%!0:2!&4,4<%(!1*R%$!:=(!

<$'2< ! :< ! <0% !%Y%@'<4M% !E$*'1!:=(! <0%$%3*$% ! <0% ! L/!(%1:$<,%=< ! <0:< ! 42 !,:64=E !'2% !*3 !A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%-!L=!<0%!,:<'$4=E!1$*@%22!<0%!?LQ!*$!*<0%$!1%$2*=2!3$*,!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!@*=M4=@%2!

<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!E$*'1!<0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!<0%!:11$*:@0!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!<*!4,1$*M%!<0%!

*1%$:<4*=2!R4<04=!<0%!A=<%$1$42%-

L=!<0%!<$:=24<4*=!<0%=!H*'@%<!%<!:&!:$E'%$2!<0:<!4<!,4E0<!+%!:!=%@%224<F!<*!$%1&:@%!<0%!?LQ!:=(!?AQ!*3!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!2*!<0%F!%=3*$@%2!<0%!'2:E%!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,!<*!'=@*M%$!<0%!

:$@04<%@<'$%!<*!,4=4,4V%!R:2<%\!$%('=(:=@F!:=(!<*!%&4,4=:<%!<0%!=*=BM:&'%!:((4=E!1$*@%22%2-

!"!#$%&!*K

Page 53: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

/0% ! ,*$% ! ,:<'$% ! 2<:E% ! *3 ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 42 ! 6=*R= ! :2 ! <0% !@D%&'7&7 . @'%&#/#"$&.

9#(-"%&(%+#&.1'7."%."$.(-1#1(%&#"E&7! +F!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!:$@04<%@<'$%!0:2!%,+$:@%(!:=(!

:(*1<%(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<*!(%M%&*1!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/0%$%!

0:2!+%%=!%2<:+&420%(!:!E$*'1!*3!<$:4=%(!^%Y1%$<_!:$@04<%@<'$%!<0:<!:4(%2!<0%!M:$4*'2!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22!

R4<0!(*@',%=<4=E!<0%4$!1:$<!*3!<0%!:$@04<%@<'$%-

/0%!,*2<!:(M:=@%(!3*$,!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!6=*R=!:2!<0%!@0F&77&7.9#(-"%&(%+#&!2<:E%\!

:=(!4<!42!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:11&4%2!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!4=!%M%$F!:@<4M4<F-!/*!

%=3*$@%!<042!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!*334@%!<0:<!42!&*@:<%(!@&*2%!<*!<0%!?QQ\!

?LQ!:=(!<0%!?AQ!^4=!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!04%$:$@0F_-!/0%!*334@%!R4&&!&46%R42%!0:M%!:!<%:,!*3!%&4<42<!

E$*'1!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2!<0:<!(%M%&*12!*=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!T$:,%R*$6!

:=(!:4(2!<0%!M:$4*'2!:$@04<%@<2!<0:<!:$%!&*@:<%(!4=!<0%!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22%2-!K2!2'@0!,*2<!R04<%!@*&&:$!

R*$6%$2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!0:M%!2*,%<04=E!<*!(*!R4<0!<0%!:$@04<%@<'$%d!0*R%M%$!<0%$%!42!=*!=%%(!

<*!$%=:,%!<0%4$!<4<&%2!<*!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2\!L/!K$@04<%@<2!*$!:!&46%-

!M#1!S+.;D!-)+9!E$!:+!V+3.,:.>!L6;6D&9&;:

50%= !R*$64=E !?*0%$%=@F !D:=:E%,%=< ! <0%= ! <0% !?04%3 !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<\ ! <0% !?LQ !:=( ! <0%!

AY%@'<4M%2!0:M%!<*!3*@'2!*=!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!<0%!ai%Y<!S%=%$:<4*=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%b\!:=(!<0:<!

3*@'2%2 !1$4,:$4&F !*= !:11&F4=E !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% !*= ! <* !*<0%$ ! :$%:2 ! 4= ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% ! %-E-\!

E*M%$=:=@%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=\!4<2!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!2<$:<%E4@!1$*@%22%2-

/0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! =%%(2 ! <* ! E* ! +%F*=( ! <0% ! 3*'=(:<4*= ! :$@04<%@<'$%- ! /* ! E* ! 3$*, ! <0% ! 3*'=(:<4*=!

:$@04<%@<'$%!<0%=!H*'@%<!%<!:&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!<0%!Z'%2<4*=!*3!0*R!<*!R4=!

*M%$!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!:=(!%=3*$@%!<0%!:(:1<4*=!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!a<0%!+'24=%22b-

H*'@%<!%<!:&!^H*'@%<!%<!:&!7JJI\!11-!>I.B>IO_!R*$62!R4<0!<0%!4(%:!<*!$%1&:@%!<0%!?AQ!<*!R*$6!2%<!:=!

:E%=(:!2'11*$<4=E!<0%!4=4<4:<4*=!*3!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<-!/0%!34$2<!1:$<4@'&:$!422'%!<0:<!=%%(2!<*!

+%!:(($%22!42!<0%!Z'%2<4*=!*3!3:4<0!:=(!<$'2<!4=<*!<0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!4=!$%&:<4*=!<*!?*0%$%=@F!

D:=:E%,%=<!@:=!,%:=!:!(433%$%=@%!3*$!0*R!<0%!,:=:E%,%=<!1$*@%22!@:=!+%!(%:&<!R4<0\!:=(!<0:<!<0%!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,!@:=!%=3*$@%!<0%!R:F!(%@424*=2!:$%!<:6%=-!/*!+%!:+&%!<*!*1%$:<%!<0%!

@*0%$%=@F ! ,:=:E%,%=< ! 1$*E$:, ! <0% ! ?AQ ! 20*'&( ! :&&*@:<% ! <0% ! $%2*'$@%2 ! :=( ! <0% ! 1$*1%$!

$%21*=24+4&4<F!<*!<0%!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!E$*'1!2*!<0%F!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!(%:&!R4<0!1$*+&%,2!*3!

@0:=E4=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<0%!R*$6!1$*@%22%2-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!@0:=E%!1$*@%22%2!:=(!<0%!

R:F!<*!%=3*$@%!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!<0%=!<0%!=%@%22:$F!$%2*'$@%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!:&&*@:<%(!2*!<0%!

aA&4<%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2b!:$%!:+&%!(%24E=!<0%!1$4=@41&%2!:=(!E'4(%&4=%2!=%%(%(!<*!%=2'$%!*<0%$!

&%22%$!%Y1%$4%=@%(!:$@04<%@<2!R*$62-!/0%!?AQ!=%%(2!<*!%=2'$%!<0:<!20*$<!<%$,!R4=2!:$%!$%:&4V%(!2*!

!"!#$%&!*'

Page 54: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!42!:+&%!<*!2%%!<0:<!<0%$%!42!=*!*<0%$!R:F!<0:=!@*,,4<<4=E!<0%!$%2*'$@%2!<*!

:(:1<!<0%!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!1$*E$:,!P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!?AQ!R*$6!R4<0!%=:+&4=E!M:$4*'2!

@0:==%&2!<*!,:6%!2'$%!<0:<!,:=:E%$2\!,4((&%!,:=:E%$2!:=(!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!@:=!2'EE%2<!0*R!<0%!

?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!1$*E$:,!@:=!+%!4,1$*M%(-

/042!&%:(2!<*!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!@0:=E%!0:2!<*!@*,%!3$*,!<0%!<*1!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!:=(!<042!,4E0<!

+%!@*=24(%$%(!:!+4<!4=!@*=3$*=<:<4*=!R4<0!<0%!1$4=@41&%2!*3!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!A=<%$1$42%!7-J!R0%$%!,*2<!

*3!<0%!@0:=E%!0:2!+%%=!(%,*@$:<4V%(\!<042!42!4=!&4=%!R4<0!<0%!M4%R2!*3!S:$F!W:,%&\!:=(!042!R*$6!

A5''*G1%"*'.*!.H1'13&0&'%C!R0%$%!0%!:(M*@:<%2!3*$!4==*M:<4*=!(%,*@$:@F-

50%=!<0%!?AQ!0:2!%2<:+&420%(!:!]04E0![!1%$3*$,:=@%]!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!E$*'1!<0%=!4<!42!:!

=%@%224<F!<*!1$*,*<%!*=%!*3!<0%!:$@04<%@<2!<*!+%!<0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@<-!H*'@%<!%<!:&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!

?04%3!K$@04<%@<!0:2!:!34M%!2<%1!:E%=(:!<0:<!0:2!%Y<$%,%!1$4*$4<4V:<4*=-!/0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22!

0:2!+%%=!3*@'24=E!*=!,:64=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!E*!+%F*=(!L/!<*!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

^,*M4=E!3$*,!<0%!3*'=(:<4*=!:$@04<%@<'$%!<*!<0%!%Y<%=(%(!:$@04<%@<'$%_-!P46%R42%!42!4<!2'EE%2<%(!<0:<!

R0%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22!<0%=!<0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@<!20*'&(!3*@'2!*=!R0:<!<0%!

M:$4*'2!2<:6%0*&(%$2!%Y1%@<!:=(!20*'&(!<0%$%3*$%!R*$6!*=!4=3&'%=@4=E!<0%,-!L3! <0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!

<04=62!*$!:22',%2!2*,%<04=E!$:<0%$!(433%$%=<&F!<0:=!R0:<!<0%!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!1$*E$:,!R4&&!

(*!3*$!<0%,\!<0%=!4<!R4&&!:'<*,:<4@:&&F!&%:(!<*!:!(42:11*4=<,%=<!:=(!<0:<!R4&&!%M%=<':&&F!&%:(!<*!<0%!

34$2<!3:4&'$%-!/0%$%<*!20*'&(!<0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@<!R*$6!R4<0!R4==4=E!*M%$!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!2*!<0%F!20*R!

:=!%Y:,1&%!<*!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!%,10:24V%!<0:<!<0%$%!42!=*!R:F!+:@6-!50%=!<0%!4=4<4:&!

%Y%@'<4M%2!0:M%!+%%=!R*=!*M%$!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!%=2'$%!20*$<!<%$,!M4@<*$4%2\!<0%!20*$<!<%$,!

M4@<*$4%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!$%:&4V%(!2*!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!*$!*<0%$!*11*24=E!3$:@<4*=!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!P:2<!

+'<!=*<!&%:2<!<0%=!<0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@<!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!<0%!422'%2!*3!4,1$*M%,%=<2!<0:<!:$%!2'EE%2<%(!

<0$*'E0!<0%!M%$434@:<4*=!@0:==%&2!<0:<!<0%!?AQ!0:2!%2<:+&420%(-!?*=<4='*'2&F!4,1$*M%,%=<!42!6%F!<*!

,:6%!2'$%!<0:<!:22'$:=@%\!:E4&4<F!:=(!:&4E=,%=<!42!%2<:+&420%(-

!"!#$%&!*(

Page 55: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

-Q&=+%<,&'(&+'&R%"$:J%&)'6%/%*A8&5"*"7%3%*+

!6%&)OI&.%/,<%A+:G%

K -A&!UDQ!2&&P0!E3!R&41&C&!EA$E!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E!10!5=1E15$4@

' D0E$R410A!$!A1%A!F&=?3=J$25&!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E!%=3/F\!$2P!1E!10!$!2&5&001E6!E3!P&4&%$E&!E$0>0!$2P!=&0F3201R141E6!E3!1E@

( G4435$E&!=&03/=5&0!E3!EA&!%=3/F!$2P!E3!EA&!5A$2%&!F=35&00@

) -A&!UDQ!2&&P0!E3!J$>&!0/=&!EA$E!EA&!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E!%=3/F!93=>0!91EA!P&=1C12%!R&2&?1E0@

* ,20E1E/E132$41W&!EA&!?&&PR$5>!5A$22&40!$2P!C&=1?6@

!6%&)6:%(&@/A6:+%A+

+ -=$20?3=J!EA&!9$6!EA&!D2E&=F=10&!J$>&0!/0&!3?!D2E&=F=10&!G=5A1E&5E/=&@

: #=&F$=&!A39!EA&!J$2$%&=0\!J1PP4&!J$2$%&=0!$2P!EA&!&JF436&&0!9A$E!E3!&VF&5E!3?!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E!$2P!EA=3/%A!EA$E!EA&2!A&4F!0A$F&!EA&!&VF&5E$E1320@

; B&E!EA&!&V&5/E1C&0!E3!$FF=3C&!$2P!93=>!91EA!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E@!

L ,JF4&J&2E!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E!$2P!J$>&!0/=&!EA$E!EA&!R&2&?1E0!$=&!=&$41W&P@

KM -A&!UA1&?!G=5A1E&5E!2&&P0!E3!$PP=&00!EA&!100/&0!3?!1JF=3C&J&2E!3?!EA&!U3A&=&256!I$2$%&J&2E!#=3%=$J@

9'(-$&CF&9#$&I;;13'5#?&6('*$2&3%&B3)5$/&$/&'-&CDD_:

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&2+*5)**+3%&3,&+%*/+/)/+3%'-+O+%0&83#$1$%5.&`'%'0$4$%/?

!M#7! E;,:.:(:.+;63.U.;D!=+%&)&;>C!L6;6D&9&;:

H*'@%<!%<!:&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<*!<$:=23*$,!<0%!A=<%$1$42%]2!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,!42!<0$*'E0!

R4==4=E!*M%$! <0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!+%=%34<2!*3!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%- !L=! <0%!3*$,%$!

2%@<4*=!4< !R:2!,%=<4*=%(!<0:<! <0%!AY<%=(%(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!R:2!<0%!2<:E%!*3!R0%$%!<0%!

+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!$%:&4V%(!<0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@*'&(!&%:(!<*!+%=%34<2!3*$!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%-!/042!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%!,:6%2!'2%!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!'=@*M%$!4<2!

:@<4M4<4%2!:=(!<*!*1<4,4V%!4<2!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2-

50%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:(*1<%(!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!0:2!:&&*@:<%(!$%2*'$@%2!<*!:!E$*'1!*3!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2!R0*!0:=(&%2!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*3!<0%!1$4=@41&%2!:=(!:$<43:@<2!<0:<!$%1$%2%=<2!0*R!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-

!M#<!P;!=+%&)&;>C!L6;6D&9&;:

?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!@:=!+%!'2%(!<*!,:<'$4=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<'$%-!K2!2'@0!<0%$%!:$%!,:=F!

4=4<4:<4M%2!<0:<!@:=!+%!,:(%!'2%!*3!<*!1$*3%224*=:&4V%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!:$@04<%@<2-!W*R%M%$!<0%$%!

:$% ! $:<0%$ ! 3%R ! %=<%$1$42%2 ! <0:< ! 0:M% ! +%%= ! :+&% ! <* ! :11&F !?*0%$%=@F !D:=:E%,%=< ! 4= ! <0% !,*$%!

:(M:=@%(!2<:E%2!:=(!:2!2'@0!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<! 42 !:!F*'=E!:=(!4=!,:=F!:21%@<2!'=<%2<%(!

<0%*$F-

!"!#$%&!*)

Page 56: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

/0%$%3*$% ! 42 ! 4< !R4<0 !: ! 3%%&4=E !*3 !'=@%$<:4=<F !R0%= ! <0% ! <0%*$F ! 3$*,! <0% !@*=@%1< !*3 !?*0%$%=@F!

D:=:E%,%=<!42!:11&4%(\!:=(!&46%R42%!42!4<!(4334@'&<!<*!<%2<!<0%!<0%*$F!^<*!:M*4(!'<*14:=!<04=64=E_-

W*R%M%$ ! <0%$% ! :$% ! 2*,%! 4=<%$%2<4=E ! 422'%2 !R4<0 !0*R! <0% !%Y%@'<4M%2 ! ^%21%@4:&&F ! <0% !?AQ_ ! @:=!

4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!+F!%=2'$4=E!<0%!$4E0<!&%:(%$2041!*3!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:=(!

,:64=E!'2%!*3!<0%!?QQ!<*!%=2'$%!<*!(*@',%=<!1$*@%22%2!:=(!4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V%!<0%!$4E0<!AK!<04=64=E-

/0%!@*=@%1<!*3!:&4E=,%=<\!:E4&4<F!:=(!:22'$:=@%!:$%!:&&!4,1*$<:=<!<*!%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:+&%!

<*!$%21*=(!<*!@0:=E%2!4=!4<2!%=M4$*=,%=<!:=(!%=:+&%!1$*:@<4M%!,%:2'$%,%=<2-

L<!42!=*<:+&%!<0:<!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:=(!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!42!@&*2%&F!@*==%@<%(!<0$*'E0!

<0:<!:&& !2<$:<%E4@!1:$<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:M%!<*!+%! ]E&'%(] !<*!:!3$:,%R*$6!<0:<!4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V%!:!

21%@434@ !,4=(2%<- !/0%$%3*$% !(* !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$%\ !?*0%$%=@F !D:=:E%,%=< ! :=( ! L=<%E$:<%(!

S*M%$=:=@%!3:@%!<0%!2:,%!<F1%2!*3!1$*+&%,2!2'@0!:2!3:@<4*=2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!,:6%2!'2%!

*3!:!(4:&%@<4@!:11$*:@0!3*$!1*R%$!:=(!@*=<$*&!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!$%2*'$@%2!:=(!2%%2!<0:<!:!0*&42<4@!

M4%R!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!R4&&!'=(%$,4=%!<0%4$!%,14$%2-!/0%!2F=($*,%!*3!<0%!3$:E,%=<%(!:=(!&**2%&F!

@*'1&%(!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!+%!(%:&<!R4<0-!/0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!<0%!3:@<4*=!<0:<!R:=<2!<*!4,1&%,%=<!

?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!=%%(!<*!'=(%$,4=%!<0%!+:$$4%$2!3$*,!<0%!<*1!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!^:!<*1!(*R=!

:11$*:@0_!:=(!:!3*@'2!*=!,:64=E!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!:=(!%,+$:@%!<0%!@0:=E%2!^:!+*<<*,!

'1!:11$*:@0_!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%-! !P46%R42%!(*%2!4<!2%%,!&46%!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:2!:!@*=@%1<!

$%Z'4$%2!:!@%=<$:&4V%(!<*1!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0!<*!0:=(&%!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22-

I%&';;13'5#&,31&+4;-$4$%/'/+3%&3,&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&A+--&($&2$'-/&A+/#&+%&/#$&%$J/&5#';/$1? &

9#+*&;'1/+5)-'1&';;13'5#&A+--&+%5-)2$&/#3)0#/*&3%&A#'/&/#$&$J$5)/+=$*&3,&/#$&$%/$1;1+*$&%$$2*&/3 &

/'N$ & +%/3 & 53%*+2$1'/+3% & '%2 & +/ & +%5-)2$* & #3A & /#$ & '15#+/$5/ & %$$2* & /3 &A31N &A+/# & $%*)1+%0 & /#'/ &

+%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$&+*&+4;-$4$%/$2&+%&/#$&1+0#/&,'*#+3%&*3&+/&$%'(-$*&/#$&$%/$1;1+*$&+%&'5#+$=+%0 &

+/*&03'-*?

!"!#$%&!**

Page 57: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&-Q& @&S/"3%T'/L&('/&?3<$%3%*+:*7&?*+%7/"+%1&F'G%/*"*A%

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%\!:=(!0*R!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!4,1&%,%=<%(-!

/0%!1$4,:$F!:22',1<4*=!4=!<042!@0:1<%$!42!<0:<!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!:$%!@*,1&%Y!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!@:=]<!+%!

(%:&<!R4<0!<0$*'E0!:!E%=%$4@!@0:=E%!:11$*:@0!+:2%(!2*&%&F!*=!g'$<!P%R4=]2!<0%*$F!*=!@0:=E%-

L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@% !R4&& ! +% !(%34=%( ! :2 ! <0% ! 34$2< ! <04=E ! :=( ! 2%@*=(&F !R4&& ! <0% ! 3$:,%R*$6 !+%!

(%34=%(\!:=(!(42@'22%(-

!"O#"! E;:&D)6:&4!S+G&);6;>&

/0%!@*=@%1<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!(%:&2!R4<0!,:64=E!(%@424*=2!<0:<!:$%!$**<%(!4=!3:@<2!*=!0*R!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62\!:=(!,:64=E!<0%!M:$4*'2!2<:6%0*&(%$2!4=!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!R*$6!:&*=E!24(%!<0%!

(%@424*=2!+:2%(!*=!<0%!3:@<2-!/0%!1$*@%22!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!<*!%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!M:$4*'2!

1&:=2!:=(!:@<4*=2!<:6%=!<*!%,+*(F!<0%!1&:=2!:$%!@*0%$%=<-!L3!<0%!1&:=2!:$%!,42:&4E=%(!^4=@*0%$%=<_!

<0%=!4<!R4&&!=*<!E4M%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=F!64=(!*3!2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-

A-E-\ !R0:< !0:11%=2! 4= !:= !%=<%$1$42%! 43 ! <0%!@*$1*$:<% !2<$:<%EF!(4@<:<%2 ! <0:< ! <0% !%=<%$1$42%!0:2 ! <*!

+%@*,%!4==*M:<4M%\!+'<!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!=%E&%@<2!(%@%=<$:&4V:<4*=!*$!<$:4=4=E!2*!<0%!

%,1&*F%%2!:$%!:+&%!<*!<:6%!1:$<!4=!4==*M:<4*=!1$*@%22-!L<!42!Z'4<%!24,1&%!<0:<!2'@0!:=!4=@*0%$%=<!

:11$*:@0!R4&&!3:4&!*$!:<!+%2<!=*<!1%$3*$,!:2!R%&&!:2!%Y1%@<%(-

/0$*'E0 ! <042 ! 1:1%$ ! L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@% ! 0:2 !+%%= !(%34=%( ! :2 ! <0% ! @*$1*$:<% ! 2<$:<%EF\ ! <0% ! L/!

2<$:<%EF\!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!0:2!:=!4,1*$<:=<!$*&%!

4=!<0%!R*$6!R4<0!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!24=@%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:2!:!@*=@%1<!1$*M4(%2!+*<0!:!

3*$,!*3!(*@',%=<:<4*=!<0:<!$%Z'4$%2!:!$%1*24<*$F!^<0:<!42!M424+&%!3*$!<0%!:@<*$2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%_\!

<0:<!,:6%2!<0%!:@<*$2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:+&%!<*!E%<!:=!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!&**62!

&46%-!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!(*%2!:&2*!1$*M4(%!:!3*$,!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!<0:<!:(($%22%2!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%-

L=!:((4<4*=!<*!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!+%!:((%(!24=@%!<0%!@*=@%1<!(%:&2!

R4<0!0*R!<*!,:<'$%!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%\!:=(!<*!%=:+&%!<0%!(%@424*=!,:6%$2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

<*!,:6%!+%<<%$!(%@424*=2\!:=(!:@<!:@@*$(4=E!<*!<0%!(%@424*=2- !/042!3*$,!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!@:=!+%!

&:+%&%(!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<-

50%=!*=%!*3!<0%!@*,1*=%=<2!*3!:=!%=<%$1$42%!@0:=E%2!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!$%M42%!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!

:=(!<0%$%3*$%!0:2!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!<*!+%!:!@*=<4='%2!@F@&%!*3!:&4E=,%=<!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!:&2*!:!

@*=<4='%2!1$*@%22-

!"!#$%&!*+

Page 58: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%\!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:&&!2'33%$2!3$*,!<0%!

2:,%!,:`*$!(42:(M:=<:E%!R04@0!42 ! <0:<!1%*1&%!(*=]< ! <04=6!:&46%!:=(!:! &*<!*3!%33*$< !=%%(2!<*!+%!

:&&*@:<%(!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!R:F!1%*1&%!<04=6!<*!,:6%!<0%,!:+:=(*=!*&(!1:$:(4E,2-!

#%*1&%!<04=6!(433%$%=<&F!4=!,:=F!(433%$%=<!R:F2!:=(!2%%,2!<*!+%!R4&&4=E!<*!%=E:E%!4=!(4:&%@<4@!

:@<4M4<4%2!<0:<!(%:&2!R4<0!1*R%$!^:=(!<0%$%+F!@*=<$*&!*3!$%2*'$@%2_!<*!1$*,*<%!<0%4$!*R=!:E%=(:-!L<!42!

<0%$%3*$%!:!=%@%224<F!<*!:(($%22!<0%!3$:E,%=<%(!*$E:=4V:<4*=\!:=(!:(($%22!<0%!422'%2!*3!2%,:=<4@2-

50%=!:(($%224=E!<0%!3$:E,%=<%(!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<0%=!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!

4=@&'(%2!<0%!M:$4*'2!(42@41&4=%!*3!<$:=23*$,4=E!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=-!P46%R42%!@:=!4<!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!=*<!:!'<*14:=!<**&!<*!2*&M%!:&&!1$*+&%,2!<0:<!:=!%=<%$1$42%!3:@%2\!24=@%!<0%!

@*=@%1< !(%1%=(2 !*= ! <0% !@*,1*=%=< !*3 ! <0% !@*$1*$:<% ! 2<$:<%EF ! :=( ! <0% !1&:==4=E !1$*@%22 ! *3 ! <0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF- ! L3 ! <0% !@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!1&:==4=E! 42 ! 3&:R%(! <0%=! <0%!1$*@%22%2!*3 !:@04%M4=E!

L=<%E$:<%( ! S*M%$=:=@% ! 3&:R%(- ! /0% ! @*==%@<4*=2 ! :,*=E ! <0% ! M:$4*'2 ! 1&:==4=E ! @*,1*=%=<2 ! 42!

4&&'2<$:<%(!*=!<0%!=%Y<!1:E%\!4<!42!=*<:+&%!<0:<!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!<4<&%(!a8<$:<%E4@!D:=:E%,%=<b-

7--)*/1'/+3%&RF&I-+0%4$%/&3,&W-'%%+%0&'%2&*/1'/$0+$*?

/0%!4&&'2<$:<4*=!:+*M%!4&&'2<$:<%2!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!<0%!1$4,:$F!2<$:<%EF\!

:=(!:&&!*<0%$!1&:=2!:=(!2<$:<%E4%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!:&4E=%(!R4<0!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

!"!#$%&!*:

,-!%3C&=2$25&

,-!0E=$E&%6HE=$E&%15

I$2$%&J&2E

<3=>?3=5&

#4$2212%

Page 59: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

L3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!3&:R%(!%-E-\!+F!+%4=E!:!$'++%$!2<:,1!1&:=!*$!4<!42!,:(%!2*&%&F!<*!2:<423F!

2<:6%0*&(%$2\!<0%=!4<!42!M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!@:=]<!+%!:@04%M%(\!24=@%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF ! :=( ! <0% ! :@<4*=2 ! <:6%= ! +F ! <0% ! %Y%@'<4M%2 !R4&& ! =*< ! %=3*$@% ! : ! @*,,4<,%=< ! <* ! 0*&42<4@!

,:=:E%,%=<-

L!0:M%!,%=<4*=%(!%:$&4%$!<0:<!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!%,+%(2!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF\!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF\!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!<0%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!1$*@%22!:=(!R*$63*$@%!

1&:==4=E!:=(!=*<!<*!3*$E%<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!R0%=!<0%2%!%&%,%=<2!0:M%!+%%=!:&4E=%(!4=<*!:!

,%:=4=E3'&!-!50%=!,:64=E!'2%!*3!<0%2%!@*=@%1<2!<*!@$%:<%!:!@*0%$%=<!*M%$M4%R!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

<0%=!4<!42!1*224+&%!<*!:@04%M%!:!0*&42<4@!3*$,!*3!,:=:E%,%=<-!

50%=!(%34=4=E!R0:<!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%=!4<!@:=!+%!(%34=%(!:2!'=@*M%$4=E!<0%!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%\!4&&'2<$:<%!<0%!E:12!:,*=E!<0%!M:$4*'2!@*,1*=%=<2!*3!<0%!(%@424*=!,:64=E!

1$*@%22!:=(!%=2'$%!@*0%$%=<!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!:@<4*=2!<:6%=!<*!<$:=23*$,!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!3$*,!:!

2<:<%!*3!4=@*0%$%=@F!<*!:!(%24$%(!@*0%$%=<!2<:<%-!N%&*R!42!:!Z'*<%!<0:<!(%34=%2!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!

4=!*=%!2%=<%=@%m

S&9#$&53%5$;/&3,&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&2$'-*&A+/#&4'N+%0&2$5+*+3%*&/#'/&'1$&133/$2 &

+% & ,'5/* &3%&#3A&/#$ &$%/$1;1+*$ &A31N*< &'%2&4'N$& /#$ &='1+3)* &*/'N$#3-2$1*& +% & /#$ &

310'%+O'/+3%&A31N&'-3%0&*+2$&/#$&2$5+*+3%*&('*$2&3%&/#$&,'5/*?!

B!^8`*%&4=!7J"J\!1-!CC_

/*!:M*4(!3&:R2!4=!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!,:=:E%,%=<!10:2%!^@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF_!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!

:(($%22!<0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&-!/0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!4=!:!@*0%$%=<!

3:204*=!%-E-\!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@$%:<%2!M:&'%2!3*$!4<2!@'2<*,%$2!:=(!R0:<!1:$<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!

0:=(&%2!@'2<*,%$!4=<%$:@<4*=!:=(!2%=(2!<0%!4=3*$,:<4*=!<*!<0%!$%21*=24+&%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!<0:<!0:=(&%2!

<0%!1$*('@<4*=!:=(!Z':&4<F!@*=<$*&-!/0%!+'24=%22!,*(%&!,4E0<!+%!:!E**(!4=(4@:<*$!3*$!R0%$%!4=!<0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!(%@%=<$:&4V:<4*=!42!=%%(%(!:=(!R0%=-!

P46%R42%!@:=!4<!+%@*,%!:!=%@%224<F!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!<**&2!:@$*22!<0%!M:$4*'2!2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!%-E-\!<0%!

+'24=%22!,*(%&!3$*,!<0%!aN$%:6*'<!8<$:<%EFb!4=!@*,+4=:<4*=!R4<0!<0%!@*,,'=4@:<4*=!:11$*:@0!*3!

<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!:=(!<0%!:+4&4<F!<*!(%M%&*1!:!2@%=:$4*!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!<0$*'E0!:!M:&4(!

:=:&F<4@:&!,*(%&!3$*,!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!@*,+4=%(!R4<0!<0%!0',:=!4=<'4<4*=!*3!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!

2@0**&-!

/0%!,*(%&!:+*M%!(*%2!4=(4@:<%!<0:<!<0%$%!,4E0<!+%!:!2%1:$:<42<!:11$*:@0!<*!L/!2<$:<%EF!0:2!+%%=!

:11&4%(d!0*R%M%$!<0:<!42=]<!<0%!@:2%-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!<0%=!<0%!

!"!#$%&!*;

Page 60: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<$:<%E42<2!=%%(2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!0*R!<*!@$%:<%!:!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!@$%:<%2!2F=%$E4%2!R4<0!L/-!

/0%$%3*$%!42!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!%&%,%=<2!<0:<!'2':&&F!@0:$:@<%$4V%!:=!L/!2<$:<%EF!=%%(%(!<*!

4=3&'%=@%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!/042!42!4&&'2<$:<%(!+F!<0%!&4=6!<0:<!E*%2!+*<0!R:F2!3*$!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!

,:=:E%,%=<!2%@<4*=!:=(!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!2%@<4*=-

N%&*R!+*<0!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!L/!2<$:<%EF!@*,1*=%=<2!42!<0%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!@*,1*=%=<-!

/0%!$%:2*=!3*$!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!3&*R!42!<0:<!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!%,+*(4%2!+*<0!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!K2!4<!0:2!+%%=!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!@0:1<%$!<0%=!D@6%%=!:=(!8,4<0!

:$E'%2!<0%=!L/!R4&&!+%@*,%!<4E0<&F!@*'1&%(!R4<0!:&,*2<!%M%$F!:21%@<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!

42!4<!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!0:M%!<*!%,+*(F!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF\!<*!%=:+&%!

@*0%$%=<!4=M%2<,%=<!:=(!E*M%$=:=@%!*3!<0%!L/!:22%<2-

K2!,%=<4*=%(!%:$&4%$!<0%=!<0%!R*$63*$@%!1&:==4=E!@*,1*=%=<!(%:&2!R4<0!:<<$:@<4=E!:=(!*$E:=4V4=E!

%,1&*F%%2!<0:<!%=:+&%2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!:@04%M%!4<2!E*:&2d!0*R%M%$!4<!(*%2!:&2*!(%:&!R4<0!0*R!<*!

@0:=E%!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!2<$'@<'$%!:=(!@'&<'$%!<*!%=:+&%!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!3$*,!<0%!aK8!L8b!<*!<0%!

a/Q!NAb!2<:<%-

/0%!&4=6!+%<R%%=!R*$63*$@%!1&:==4=E!:=(!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!,:=:E%,%=<!@*,1*=%=<!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!

R0%=!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!2<:<%!0:2!+%%=!$%:@0%(!^:=(!('$4=E!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=_!<0%=!4<!R4&&!

%M%=<':&&F!4,1:@<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-!L<!42!M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!R4&&!@0:=E%!

('$4=E!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1%$4*(!('%!<*!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,:4=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/0%!@0:=E%2!0:M%!

<*!+%!<:6%=!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!*<0%$R42%!R4&&!<0%!1&:=2!:=(!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!<0%!1&:=2!+%!*'<!*3!

@*=<%Y<!R4<0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!4=-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&$J;-'%'/+3%&3,&/#$&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&,1'4$A31N?&9#$&$J;-'%'/+3%&A+--&2$/'+- &

/#$&,1'4$A31N&'%2&+/&A+--&/#$&,-3A&'%2&='1+3)*&$-$4$%/*&3,&/#$&,1'4$A31N&($&2+*5)**$2?

!"O#1! $%&!T)69&Q+)0

L=!<0%!3$:,%R*$6!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!%4E0<!2<%12!:=(!<0%!%4E0<!2<%12!:$%!*$E:=4V%(!4=<*!M:$4*'2!2%@<4*=2!*3!

4=<%$%2<!3*$!4,1&%,%=<4=E!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

/0%!34$2<!2<%1!^2<%1!V%$*_!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!%Y<%$=:&!1$%22'$%!3$*,!<0%!(*,:4=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!%-E-\!<0%!

(%,:=(!3*$!=%R!1$*('@<2\!&*R%$!1$4@%2!*=!<0%!1$*('@<2\!=%R!@*,1%<4<*$2\!:=(!@*,1%<4<*$!,*M%2!

<0:<!,:<@0%2!*$!*'<!,:<@0%2!<0%!:@<4*=2!<:6%=!+F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!*$!24,4&:$-

50%=!<0%!%Y<%$=:&!1$%22'$%!42!1$%2%=<!<0%=!4<!42!'1!<*!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!<*!<:6%!:@<4*=!:=(!24%E%!<0%!

,*,%=<\!:=(!4=4<4:<%!:!3*$@%!3*$!4=<%$=:&!1$%22'$%-!/0%!4=<%$=:&!1$%22'$%!42!:!3%%&4=E!:=(!:=!:E%=(:!

!"!#$%&!*L

Page 61: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0:<!:<<$:@<2!&%:(4=E!3:@<4*=2!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!

/0%!=%Y<!2<%1!(%:&2!R4<0!%2<:+&4204=E!:=!@'%&#/#"$&!9#(-"%&(%+#&!3#*+/\!:=(!%2<4,:<%!<0%!G1)+&!*3!

<0%!@'%&#/#"$&!9#(-"%&(%+#&-

L<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!%2<:+&420!+*<0!:=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!E$*'1!:=(!%2<4,:<4=E!<0%!M:&'%!('%!<*!

%2<:+&4204=E!$%21*=24+4&4<F!:=(!:@@*'=<:+4&4<F!<*!<0%!E$*'1!<*!&%:(!:=(!<:6%!@0:$E%!*3!1$*@%22!*3!

(*@',%=<4=E!:=(!<0%=!<$:=23*$,4=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!P46%R42%!0:2!<0%!?LQ!*$!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%!R0*!

2'11*$<2 ! <0% ! 1$*E$:, ! =%%( ! <* ! %2<:+&420 ! <0% ! %@*=*,4@ ! +%=%34<2 ! *3 ! <0% ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$%!

1$*E$:,-!/0%2%!+%=%34<2!0:M%!<*!4=@&'(%!2@%=:$4*2!2*!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!42!:+&%!<*!,:6%!4=<%&&4E%=<!

@0*4@%2-!/*!,:6%!4=<%&&4E%=<!@0*4@%2!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!=%%(2!2@%=:$4*2!<*!%=:+&%!<0%,!R4<0!:!M4%R2!*=!

R0:<!0:11%=2!43!<0%F!@0**2%!*=%!2@%=:$4*!*M%$!<0%!*<0%$-!/0%!%@*=*,4@!+%=%34<2!20*'&(!+%!:!1:$<!*3!

0*R!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!<*!+'4&(!<$'2<!:=(!`'2<43F!<0%!%2<:+&420,%=<!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!

1$*E$:,-!T$*,!:!@0:=E%!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!0:M%!<0%!:$E',%=<!$%:(F!<*!R4=!

*M%$!*11*24=E!3:@<4*=2!R4<0!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!50%=!2<%1!*=%!0:2!+%%=!@*,1&%<%(!<0%=!4<!42!1*224+&%!

<*!E*!*=!<*!2<%1!<R*-!/0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-!/0%!:E%=(:!4=!2<%1!<R*!42!<*!+%E4=!@0:=E4=E!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%! <0$*'E0!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!1$*E$:,-!/0%! <$:=23*$,:<4*=!*3 ! <0%!%=<%$1$42%!@*,%2!

<0$*'E0 ! <0:< ! <0% !AK!E$*'1!0:2 !+%%=!%2<:+&420%(\ ! <0% !?04%3 !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@< !:=( !: ! <$:,!*3!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2!0:M%!2<:$<%(!<*!(*@',%=<!0*R!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!(%24E=%(!:=(!

R0:<!@*==%@<4*=2!<0%$%!:$%!:,*=E!<0%!M:$4*'2!@*,1*=%=<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!L<!42!R*$<0!<*!,%=<4*=!

<0:<!R0%=!@0**24=E!:!3$:,%R*$6!<0%=!4<!4,1&4%2!<0:<!<0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@<!:&2*!@0*2%2!:!,%<0*(!3*$!

0*R!<*!(*@',%=<!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-

8<%1!<0$%%!+:24@:&&F!(%:&2!R4<0!'24=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:2!:!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%-!/0$*'E0!<0%!

3$:,%R*$6!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2!:$%!:+&%!<*!4(%=<43F!$%('=(:=<!3'=@<4*=2\!4=%334@4%=<!1$*@%22%2!

:=(!E:12!:,*=E!M:$4*'2!3'=@<4*=2-!/0%!422'%2!4(%=<434%(!4=!2<%1!<0$%%!=%%(2!<*!+%!:(($%22%(!+F!

:$<4@'&:<4=E!:=(!%2<:+&420!:!2%$4%2!*3!1$*`%@<2-!/0%!1$*`%@<2!0:M%!<*!+%!*$E:=4V%(!4=!:!1$*E$:,!:=(!

<0$*'E0 ! <0% ! (%&4M%$F ! :=( ! 4,1&%,%=<:<4*= ! *3 ! %:@0 ! *3 ! <0% ! 1$*`%@<2 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 42 ! :+&% ! <*!

4=@$%,%=<:&&F!<*!,*M%!<*R:$(2!R0:<!42!(%34=%(!:2!<0%!a/Q![!NAb!2<:<%-!/0%!a/Q![!NAb!2<:<%!42!

(%34=%(!*=!R0:<!42!:22',%(!<*!+%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!%-E-\!<0$*'E0!:=:&FV4=E!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!

<0%!2<$:<%EF-!/0%!1$*@%22%2!*3!:&4E=4=E!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!<0$*'E0!:!2F2<%,4@!:11$*:@0!42!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!

2<%1!3*'$-!i%%(&%22!<*!2:F!<0:<!<0%!1$*E$:,!20*'&(!+%!2@*14=E!*=!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

L=!2<%1!3*'$!<0%!1$*@%22!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!+%E4=2!24=@%!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<2!+%E4=2!<*!

$%(%24E=!:=(!:&4E=!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!2@*1%2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!<0$*'E0!<0:<!<0%F!<$:=23*$,!<0%!2<$'@<'$%\!

@'&<'$%!:=(!<:262!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:=(&%2-!50%=!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!2@*1%!:=(!:&4E=,%=<!0:2!+%%=!(%34=%(\!

!"!#$%&!+M

Page 62: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0%=!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!0:2!<*!+%!<$:=23*$,%(!<*!2'4<%!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!@*=<%Y<-!K3<%$!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!0:2!

+%%=! <$:=23*$,%(! <0%!%=<%$1$42%! ^<0% !2<$'@<'$%\ ! <0%!@'&<'$%!:=(! <0%! <:262_ ! <0%=! <0%!$%1*24<*$F! 42!

'1(:<%(!:=(!%Y1*2%(!<*!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2-!50%=!<042!42!(*=%!<0%=!F%<!:=*<0%$!$*<:<4*=!@:=!<:6%!1&:@%!

R0%=!*$!43!<0%$%!:$%!%,%$E%=<!2<$:<%E4%2!*$!@0:=E%2!<0:<!0:M%!*@@'$$%(!('$4=E!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!

1%$4*(-!L3!<0%$%!0:M%!+%%=!=*!@0:=E%2!<0%=!<0%!2<$'@<'$%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!+%!4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V%(!

2*!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!@:=!E%<!'2%!<*!<0%!@0:=E%2!:=(!:@<!:@@*$(4=E!<*!<0%!@0:=E%2-!/0%!$%:2*=!3*$!R0F!

<0%!$%1*24<*$F!42!<4<&%(!a9=b!42!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!,4E0<!0:M%!<*!4,1&%,%=<!,*$%!<0:=!*=%!$%1*24<*$F!

<*!%=:+&%!<0%!'=@*M%$4=E!:=(!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!1$*@%22-

L=!<0%!,%:=!<4,%!<0%!?04%3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<!0:2!<*!,*M%!*=!<*!2<%1!34M%-

8<%1!34M%!(%:&2!R4<0!@$%:<4=E!:!2F2<%,!<0:<!%=:+&%2!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!<0%!?04%3!K$@04<%@<!<*!:(($%22!

<0%!@0:=E%2\!%21%@4:&&F!43!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22!@:=!+%!(*=%!+%<<%$\!:=(!4=!2<%1!24Y!4<!R4&&!+%!

1*224+&%!<*!*$E:=4V%!<0%!2'EE%2<4*=2!4=<*!1$*`%@<2!<0:<!<*E%<0%$!R4<0!:!$%B2<:$<4=E!<0%!@F@&%!+%!:+&%!<*!

:@04%M%!:!2F2<%,4@!2<%1!@&*2%$!<*!<0%!%Y<%=(%(!:$@04<%@<'$%\!:=(!R0%=!<0%!%Y<%=(%(!:$@04<%@<'$%!42!

:@04%M%(!<0%=!4<!42!:22',%(!<0:<!<0$%%!<*!34M%!@F@&%2!3$*,!:@04%M4=E!<0%!%,+%((%(!:$@04<%@<'$%!2<:<%-

/0%!%,+%((%(!:$@04<%@<'$%!2<:<%!R4&&!%=2'$%!'2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!:@04%M%!:22'$:=@%\!:&4E=,%=<!

:=(!:E4&4<F-!50%=!:11&F4=E!<0%2%!<0$%%!3:@<*$2!@*$$%@<&F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&& !+%!:+&%!<*!:@04%M%!:!

2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-

!"O#7! E:&)6:.+;,!$+Q6)4,!6!2(,:6.;683&!=+9*&:.:.G&!B4G6;:6D&

K2!L!0:M%!,%=<4*=%(!:+*M%!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!:=!%=<%$1$42%!@:=]<!

:@04%M%!:!2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!<0$*'E0!:!20*$<!1%$4*(!R0%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!LSLK"7!

3$:,%R*$6-!W%$V',!,%=<4*=%(!4=!042!1:1%$!*=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!,:<'$4<F!<0:<!$%+'4&(4=E!*$!

$%B2<$'@<'$4=E !:= !A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% !@:=]< !+% !@*,1:$%( ! <* ! $%+'4&(4=E !: ! 3*'$ !1%$2*= ! 3:,4&F!

0*'2%\!+'<!4<!@:=!+%!@*,1:$%(!<*!$%+'4&(4=E!:=!%=<4$%!26F2@$:1%$!^W%$V',!7JJ;\!1-!;_-

50%=!,:<'$4=E!:=!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<0%=!4<!0:2!<*!+%!:22',%(!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!E*!

<0$*'E0!:!]26F2@$:1%$]!$%B@*=2<$'@<4*=!:!3%R!<4,%2!+%3*$%!4<!,:<'$%2!3$*,!<0%!+:24@!:$@04<%@<'$%!<*!

<0%!%Y<%=(%(!:$@04<%@<'$%-!P46%R42%!R4&&!4<!1$*+:+&F!<:6%!:+*'<!34M%!<4,%2!*$!,*$%!3*$!:=!%=<%$1$42%!

<*!,:<'$%!4<2!:$@04<%@<'$%!<*!<0%!%,+%((%(!:$@04<%@<'$%-

/0%!<4,%!4<!<:6%2!<*!4<%$:<%!*=%!@F@&%!*3!<0%!LSLK![!3$:,%R*$6!42!3&%Y4+&%!3*$!%:@0!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!

E*%2!<0$*'E0!4<-!/0%$%!:$%!,:=F!3:@<*$2!<0:<!4=3&'%=@%2!0*R!3:2<!<0%!@F@&%!@:=!+%!@*,1&%<%(-!/0%!

1$4,:$F!3:@<*$!42!<0%!:&&*@:<4*=!*3!$%2*'$@%2!<*!<0%!@F@&%\!<0%!2%@*=(!3:@<*$!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!R4&&!<*!

"7 L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!L,1&%,%=<:<4*=!K11$*:@0!

!"!#$%&!+K

Page 63: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

@0:=E%!<0:<!42!&*@:<%(!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!:=(!<0%!&:2<!3:@<*$!R4&&!+%!0*R!R%&&!<0%!4=(4M4(':&2!4=!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$%!:+&%!<*!:(`'2<!<*!<0%!1$*E$:,!:=(!:@<!:@@*$(4=E!<*!<0%!1$*E$:,-

K2!L !0:M%!,%=<4*=%(!R4<0 ! <0% !2@0**& !*3 !@*$1*$:<% !2<$:<%EF! <0%=! <0% !@*$1*$:<% !2<$:<%EF!1$*@%22!

20*'&(!+%!<:64=E!%,%$E4=E!2<$:<%E4%2!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=\!:=(!:(:1<!R0%=!@0:=E%2!0:11%=2!4=!<0%!

(*,:4= !*3 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42%- !/042 ! (*%2 ! :&2* ! :11&4%2 ! 3*$ !R*$64=E !R4<0 ! <0% ! 4<%$:<4*=2 !*3 ! <0% ! LSLK!

3$:,%R*$6-!L3!<0%$%!*@@'$2!,:`*$!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,:4=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!<0%!1$*`%@<!1$*E$:,2!

0:M%!<*!@0:=E%!:@@*$(4=E!<*!4<-

7--)*/1'/+3%&]F&74;'5/*&3,&5#'%0$*&+%&/#$&234'+%&3,&/#$&$%/$1;1+*$?

/0%!4&&'2<$:<4*=!:+*M%!20*R2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!422'%2!^%,%$E%=<!2<$:<%E4%2\!%,%$E%=<!1$*+&%,2\!

%,%$E%=< ! :11$*:@0%2_ ! <0:< ! @:= !*@@'$ !('$4=E ! <0% !1$*@%22 ! <0:< !R*$62 ! <*R:$(2 ! <0% !%Y<%=(%( !:=(!

%,+%((%(!:$@04<%@<'$%-!H*'@%<!%<!:&!(%('@%(!<0:<!<0%!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,:4=!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!

4=@$%:2%!*M%$<4,%\!:=(!<0:<!42!<0%!$%:2*=!3*$!R0F!4,1:@<2!R4&&!4=@$%:2%!*M%$!<4,%!R04@0!42!4&&'2<$:<%(!

+F!<0%!(*<<%(!&4=%!+%<R%%=!<0%!<R*!:$$*R2!:=(!42!:22*@4:<%(!R4<0!<0%!<%Y<!L=-!

/4,%!42!:!3:@<*$!R0%=!R*$64=E!4=!:=!4=('2<$F!<0:<!%Y1%$4%=@%!8@0',1%<%$4:=!@*,1%<4<4*=!24=@%!<0%!

%=<%$1$42% ! =%%(2 ! <* ! :(($%22 ! <0% !,*M%2 ! <0:< ! 4<2 ! @*,1%<4<*$2 ! 4=4<4:<% ! *M%$<4,%- ! /0%$%3*$% ! 4< ! 42!

'=2'4<:+&% ! 3*$ !,:=F !%=<%$1$42%2 ! <* !,:6% !'2% !*3 ! 3*$,:& !1$*@%22 ! 3*$ ! :$<4@'&:<4*= !*3 ! : ! @*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF!*$!*$E:=4V4=E!M424*=2!3*$!0*R!:=!%=<%$1$42%!1&:=2!<*!<$:=23*$,!<*!:@04%M%!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%-

/0%!?04%3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<!=%%(2!<*!:(($%22!<042!4=!042!@*=24(%$:<4*=2!:=(!R*$6!R4<0!$%BR4$4=E!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

9#$&7G7I@,1'4$A31N&+*&;1$*$%/$2&3%&/#$&%$J/&;'0$?

!"!#$%&!+'

!:3%Y3/2P$E132

G=5A1E&5E/=&

DVE&2P&P

G=5A1E&5E/=&

DJR&PP&P

G=5A1E&5E/=&

,JF$5E

,JF$5E

,2

Page 64: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

7--)*/1'/+3%&aF&9#$&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&74;-$4$%/'/+3%&I;;13'5#&67G7I:

/0%!3&*R!+%<R%%=!<0%!(433%$%=<!2%@<4*=!0:M%!42!:<!:!04E0!&%M%&\!:=(!<0%!3&*R!:11%:$2!*=&F!<*!3&*R!4=!

!"!#$%&!+(

K

' '

:

?*+%7/"+%1&F'G%/*"*A%

./=212%!F4$E?3=J

D0E$R410A!$2!DG!%=3/F D0E1J$E&!EA&!C$4/&!3?!D2E&=F=10&!G=5A1E&5E/=&

UA$2%&!EA&!3=%$21W$E132!EA=3/%A!EA&!/0$%&!3?!D2E&=F=10&!G=5A1E&5E/=&

DVE&=2$4!

#=&00/=&

,2E&=2$4!#=&00/=&

U344&5E!0/%%&0E1320!?3=!1JF=3C&J&2E0

)

*

(

DG!Y=$J&93=>

#=3O&5EG41%2J&2E

(@K

Q=%$21W&!EA&!0/%%&0E1320\!121E1$E&!EA&!F=3&O5E0!$2P!1JF4&J&2E!EA&!F=3O&5E0

Q=%$21W$E132!HE=/5E/=&\!E$0>0!$2P!5/4E/=&

M

RX

,-!%3C&=2$25&

,-!0E=$E&%6HE=$E&%15

I$2$%&J&2E

<3=>?3=5&#4$2212%

Page 65: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

*=%!(4$%@<4*=-!/*!:M*4(!,42:&4E=,%=<!+%<R%%=!<0%!@*=@%1<':&!1&:=2\!1$*`%@<2!:=(!<0%!

4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!:@<!:@@*$(4=E&F!R0%=!$4262!*3!,42:&4E=,%=<!0:M%!+%%=!

4(%=<434%(!:=(!@0:=E%!<0%!@*=<%=<!:=(!2@*1%!*3!<0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=-!T*$!%:@0!*3!<0%!2<%12!<0%!

:@@*'=<:+&%!:@<*$2!=%%(2!<*!<04=6!*=!0*R!<0%F!@:=!%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!1$*@%22%2!<0%F!%2<:+&420!42!

%=2'$%(!<0$*'E0!Z':&4<F!,%:2'$%,%=<-!/0%!:R:$%=%22!*3!1$*+&%,2!R4<0!<0%!Z':&4<F!=%%(2!<*!+%!

4(%=<434%(!:=(!<042!@:=!*=&F!+%!(*=%\!43!<0%!:@<*$2!%2<:+&420!3%%(+:@6!&**12!3*$!%:@0!*3!<0%!1$*@%22%2!

^4=!<042!@:2%!%:@0!*3!<0%!2<%12_-!L=!<0:<!R:F!2*,%!3%%(+:@6!1$*@%22%2!0:M%!+%%=!%2<:+&420%(!+%3*$%!

2<%1!34M%!:=(!24Y-!T$*,!2<%1!<0$%%!<*!2<%1!34M%!4<!42!1*224+&%!<*!E*!+:@6!:@$*22!2%M%$:&!*3!<0%!2<%12!:=(!

R4<04=!%:@0!*3!<0%,-&L<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!%2<:+&420!:=(!%=3*$@%!<0%!3%%(+:@6!@0:==%&2!*<0%$R42%!R4&&!

<0%!:11$*:@0!<*!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!E$*R!*'<!*3!@*=<%Y<-

!"O#<! W.):(&,!+-!E;:&D)6:&4!S+G&);6;>&

/0%$%!:$%!<0$%%!,:`*$!M4$<'%2!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-!/0%!34$2<!*=%!42!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!1$*('@4+4&4<F\!

<0%!2%@*=(!*=%!42!:(:1<:+4&4<F!:=(!<0%!&:2<!M4$<'%!42!@*,1:<4+4&4<F-

&-QB;B-& ./'10A:#:$:+8

/0%!@*=@%1<!*3!1$*('@4+4&4<F!(%:&2!R4<0!+%4=E!:+&%!<*!1$*('@%!$%2'&<2!3$*,!<0%!3$:,%R*$6-!W*R!

*3<%=!@:=!:=!%=<%$1$42%!+%!:+&%!<*!1$*('@%!2*,%<04=E!24,4&:$!^4=!<042!@:2%!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%_!

<0$*'E0 ! E*4=E ! <0$*'E0 ! : ! 2%< ! *3 ! 4=2<$'@<4*=2 ! *$ !R0:< ! @:= !+% ! (%34=%( ! :2 ! : ! @0:=E% ! 1$*E$:, !*$!

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!1$*E$:,X!/0%!,*$%!&46%&F!<0%!2'@@%22!$:<%!4<!<0%!+%<<%$!4<!42!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

<0:<!'=(%$<:6%2!4<!+'<!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!4<!R4&& !&%:(!<*!,*$%!%=<%$1$42%2!R4&& !1'$2'%!:=(!:@04%M%!

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

L<!42!(42@'22:+&%!43!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!:$%!:2!(433%$%=<!:2!1%*1&%!@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3!:!E%=%$4@!:11$*:@0!<*!

:@04%M%!$%2'&<2\!+'<!4=!<0%!2:,%!4<!,4E0<!1*224+&%!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!:11$*:@0!4=!

R0%=! 4< !:$<4@'&:<%2! 4<2 !*R=!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!1$*E$:,!:=(!'2%! <0%!LSLK!3$:,%R*$6!:2!:=!

%Y:,1&%-

50%=!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!:$%!:$<4@'&:<4=E!4<2!*R=!@'2<*,4V%(!:11$*:@0!<*!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!<0%=\!

<0%!@04%3!:$@04<%@<!20*'&(!<:6%!4<!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!0*R!<0%F!(%24E=!<0%4$!,%<0*(!<*!:@04%M%!<0%!

2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-!/0%!,%<0*(!0:2!<*!+%!1$*('@%:+&%!24=@%!4<!0:2!<*!+%!@*=242<%(!

&46% ! <0% ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 3$:,%R*$6- ! L3 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 42 ! =*< ! :+&% ! <* ! 1$*('@% ! $%2'&<2!

@*=242<%=<&F !R4<0 ! 4<2 ! L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@%!1$*E$:,! <0%=! 4< !R4&& !+% !0:$( ! <* ! `'2<43F ! <0% ! 3'$<0%$!

:&&*@:<4*=!*3!$%2*'$@%2!<*!<0%!1$*E$:,-

!"!#$%&!+)

Page 66: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&-QB;B4& @1"<+"#:$:+8

/0%!2%@*=(!M4$<'%!42!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!:(:1<4=E!<*!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!24<':<4*=!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!:=(!&46%R42%!

(*%2!<0%!:(:1<:+4&4<F!(%:&!R4<0!:(:1<4=E!<0%!3$:,%R*$6!<*!<0%!4=(4M4(':&!%=<%$1$42%-

Q=%!*3!<0%!E$%:<%2<!@0:&&%=E%2!<*!:@04%M4=E!:!2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!42 !:(:1<4=E!<0%!

3$:,%R*$6!4=!:!1$*1%$!:=(!%334@4%=<!R:F-

&-QB;B9& )'3<"+:#:$:+8

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!LSLK![!3$:,%R*$6!<0%!1$4,:$F!Z'%2<4*=!R4&&!+%@*,%!43!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!

@*,1:<4+&%!R4<0!4,1&%,%=<4=E!<0%!3$:,%R*$6-!/0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!R*$6!R4<0!4<2!@*,1:<4+4&4<F!

<0$*'E0 ! *$E:=4V:<4*=:& ! <$:=23*$,:<4*=- ! /0% ! Z'%2<4*= ! <0%= ! +%@*,%2 ! R0%= ! := ! %=<%$1$42% ! 42=]<!

@*,1:<4+&%!R4<0!<0%!LSLK![!3$:,%R*$6X!

L3!:=!%=<%$1$42%!2'33%$2!3$*,!<**!,'@0!(4:&%@<4@!2<$'EE&%!:,*=E!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!:@<*$2!R4<04=!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%-!K!(4:&%@<4@!2<$'EE&%!<0:<!42!3'%&%(!+F!%Y<%$=:&!*$E:=4V:<4*=!%-E-\!:!<$:(%!'=4*=-!/0%!$%:2*=!

3*$!R0F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!4=@*,1:<4+&%!42!+%@:'2%!<0%!2<$'EE&%!3*$!1$*,*<4=E!2'+B*1<4,4V%(!:E%=(:2!

R4&&!+%!0:$(!<*!*M%$@*,%!:=(!4<!R4&&!%M%=<':&&F!'=(%$,4=%!<0%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0-!

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&53%5-)*+3%&3,&/#$&-+/$1'/)1$&1$=+$A?

!"!#$%&!+*

Page 67: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&--& )'*A$0,:'*

/042!@0:1<%$!42!<0%!@*=@&'24*=!*3!<0%!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R-!L!R4&& !:=2R%$!<0%!Z'%2<4*=2!2<:<%(!4=!<0%!

1$*+&%,!2<:<%,%=<-

!""#"! /%6:!.,!E;:&D)6:&4!S+G&);6;>&X

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!:!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!<0:<!4=@&'(%2!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF\!L/![!2<$:<%EF\!L/!

E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!R*$63*$@%!1&:==4=E-!/0%$%!:$%!M:$4*'2!R:F2!<*!0:=(&%!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!<*!

:@04%M%!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%d!4=!<042!1:1%$!*=%!1:$<4@'&:$!:11$*:@0!0:2!+%%=!:$<4@'&:<%(-!D:=F!

@*,1&%Y!%=<%$1$42%2!*3<%=!0:M%!(%<:@0%(!2<$:<%E4%2!3*$!<0%!M:$4*'2!(%1:$<,%=<2!:=(!<0%!M:$4*'2!&4=%2!

*3!+'24=%22-!/0%!,:=:E%$2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!*3<%=!:@<!(433%$%=<&F!:=(!=*<!:&4E=%(!<*!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!

<0:<!0:M%!+%%=!:$<4@'&:<%(\!:=(!<042!&%:(2!<*!,42:&4E=,%=<-!/*!@*1%!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!

S*M%$=:=@%\!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!@:=!+%!:!6%F-

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!+*<0!:!3*$,!*3!(*@',%=<:<4*=!:=(!:!3*$,!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!43!4<!42!:11&4%(!

@*$$%@<&F-!/0%!3*@'2!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!:=(!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!<*!%=3*$@%!:!0*&42<4@!

,:=:E%,%=<!2<F&%!<0:<!%=2'$%2!:!@*0%$%=<!E*M%$=:=@%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0$*'E0*'<!<042!$%M4%R!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!2<$:<%EF!2@0**&2!:=(!L/!2<$:<%E4%2!0:M%!+%%=!(%:&<!R4<0!:=(!

:@@*$(4=E!#*<<2!<0%=!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!<0%!,*2<!4,1*$<:=<!<04=E!R0%=!4<!

@*,%2!<*!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF-!#*<<2!:$E'%2!43!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!(%<:@0!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!3$*,!<0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!24=@%!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!4=!*'$!1:$<!*3!<0%!R*$&(!R*'&(!0:M%!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!L/!

2*,%0*R!<*!2'11*$<!4<2!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2-!/0%$%3*$%!4<!R*'&(!+%!,%:=4=E&%22!=*<!<*!4=@*$1*$:<%!L/!

:2!:!1:$<!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

K2!4<!R:2!(42@'22%(!4=!<0%!L/!E*M%$=:=@%!@0:1<%$!<0%=!4<!42!(%24$:+&%!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!

,*(%&2!R0%$%!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:=(!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!3$*,!<0%!+'24=%22!@*&&:+*$:<%!*=!(%34=4=E!R0:<!

=%%(2!<*!+%!(*=%!R4<0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!L/!:$@04<%@<'$%\!2<$:<%EF!:=(!L/!4=M%2<,%=<2!%<@-

W*R%M%$ ! <0% !E%=%$4@ ! :11$*:@0%2 ! <0:< !9*22 !) !5%4&& ! E4M%2 !,4E0< !=*< ! 2'4< ! :&& ! %=<%$1$42%2 ! 24=@%!

%=<%$1$42%2!:$%!:2!'=4Z'%!:2!<0%!1%$2*=2!R0*!:$%!4=!<0%,-!/0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!:=F!E4M%=!E*M%$=:=@%!

:11$*:@0!^4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%\!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!L/!E*M%$=:=@%_!+%!:(:1<%(!:=(!<0%=!

:(*1<%(!+F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

L=!<0%!:(*1<4*=!*3!:=F!E%=%$4@!:11$*:@0%2!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!0:M%!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%$%!,4E0<!+%!

2*,% ! $%242<:=@% ! <* ! @0:=E% !:=( !:2 ! 2'@0 ! <0%$% !:$% ! <R* !M4%R2 !*= !0*R! <* ! 2*&M% ! <0% !Z'%2<4*= !*3!

<$:=23*$,4=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%!+%2<!R:F-!K22',4=E!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!42!:!&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!2F2<%,!

!"!#$%&!++

Page 68: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

R0%$% ! <0%$% ! :$% ! M:$4*'2 ! 3*$,2 ! *3 ! <0% ! @*'1&4=E ! 1$%2%=<- !/* ! @*1% !R4<0 ! @0:=E% ! <0%= ! 4< ! @:= ! +%!

@*=24(%$%(!:!=%@%224<F!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!<0%!:11$*:@0!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!8#';/$1&3%&I&b1'4$A31N&,31 &

74;-$4$%/+%0&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$?

/0%!:11$*:@0!=%%(2!<*!(%:&!R4<0!4=!:!R:F!R0%$%!:!<*1!(*R=!:11$*:@0!:(($%22%2!:=!%Y%@'<4M%!

@*,,4<,%=<!<*!@0:=E4=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!<0:<!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!:(($%22%2!<0%!2*@4:&!=%<R*$62!R4<04=!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/0%!2*@4:&!=%<R*$62!=%%(2!<*!+%!:(($%22%(!<*!,:6%!1%*1&%!:(:1<!<*!<0%!@0:=E%2!<0:<!

=%%(2!<*!*@@'$!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!%=:+&%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!+F!<0:<!L=<%E$:<%(!

S*M%$=:=@%-

A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! @:= ! +% ! <0% ! E&'% ! <0:< ! 0*&(2 ! 4=<%E$:<%( ! E*M%$=:=@% ! <*E%<0%$\ ! :=( ! <0%!

?*0%$%=@F !D:=:E%,%=< ! @:= ! +% ! <0% ! R:F ! <* ! ,:<'$% ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! :$@04<%@<'$% ! <* ! $%B%=3*$@%!

L=<%E$:<%( ! S*M%$=:=@%-

/0%!%22%=@%!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!@:=!+%!2',,%(!'1!4=!<0%!Z'*<:<4*=!+%&*R-

S&9#$&53%5$;/&3,&+%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$&2$'-*&A+/#&4'N+%0&2$5+*+3%*&/#'/&'1$&133/$2 &

+%&,'5/*&3%&#3A&/#$&$%/$1;1+*$&A31N*<&'%2&4'N+%0&/#$&='1+3)*&*/'N$#3-2$1*&+%&/#$&

310'%+O'/+3%&A31N&'-3%0&*+2$&/#$&2$5+*+3%*&('*$2&3%&/#$&,'5/*?!

B!^8`*%&4=!7J"J\!1-!CC_

!""#1! V+Q!.,!.;:&D)6:&4!D+G&);6;>&!>+98.;&4!Q.:%!=+%&)&;>C!L6;6D&9&;:X

L=<%E$:<%( !S*M%$=:=@% ! @:= ! +% ! 4=2<4<'<4*=:&4V%( ! <0$*'E0 ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! :=( ! %=3*$@% ! :!

(%24$:+&%!0*&42<4@!:11$*:@0!<*!,:=:E%,%=<-!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!(%:&2!R4<0!,:<'$4=E!<0%!R:F!

A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!42!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

L=<%E$:<%( ! S*M%$=:=@% ! =%%(2 ! <* ! +% ! 1'< ! 4=<* ! : ! @*=<%Y< ! R0%$% ! A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% ! 42 ! <0%!

3$:,%R*$6!<0:<!%=:+&%2!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!:=(!1$*@%22%2!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

?*0%$%=@F ! D:=:E%,%=< ! (%:&2 ! R4<0 ! <0% ! ,:<'$4<F ! *3 ! <0% ! :$@04<%@<'$% ! <0$*'E0 ! *$E:=4V:<4*=:&!

(%M%&*1,%=<\ ! :=( ! 0*R ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% !,:6% ! 2%=2% ! *3 ! '24=E ! %=<%$1$42% ! :$@04<%@<'$% ! <* ! :@04%M%!

:22'$:=@%\!:E4&4<F!:=(!:&4E=,%=<-

?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!0:2!<0$%%!2<:E%2!3*$!<0%!,:<'$4<F!*3!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!43!<0%!

%Y%@'<4M%2!4=M%2<!<0%4$!<$'2<!4=<*!'24=E!:=!%Y1&4@4<!:11$*:@0!<*!:@04%M%!:!@*0%$%=<!:11$*:@0!<*!(*!

!"!#$%&!+:

Page 69: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<04=E2-

L=!*<0%$!R*$(2\!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<2!=%%(2!<*!<:6%!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!4=<*!

@*=24(%$:<4*=!:=(!:11&F!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:2!:!3*$,!*3!E&'%!<0:<!%=2'$%2!:!@*0%$%=<!M4%R-!

50%=!A=<%$1$42% !K$@04<%@<'$% !0:2 !+%%=!:11&4%( ! <0%= ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% ! @:= ! 2<:$< !R*$64=E!R4<0 ! <0%!

@*=@%1<!*3!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<-

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!20:$%2!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!:(($%224=E!*<0%$!1:$<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:=!`'2<!<0%!L/!

(%1:$<,%=< ! :=( ! 4<2 ! =%%(2 ! <* ! :&4E= ! <0% ! L/ ! 1$*`%@<2 ! R4<0 ! <0% ! @*$1*$:<% ! 1$*`%@<2 ! ^+*<0 ! :$% ! <0%!

%,+*(4,%=<!*3!2<$:<%EF_

!""#7! V+Q!>6;!E;:&D)6:&4!S+G&);6;>&!6;4!=+%&)&;>C!L6;6D&9&;:!8&!>+98.;&4!.;!6!,.;D3&!-)69&Q+)0X

L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!@:=!+%!4=<%E$:<%(!R4<0!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!<0$*'E0!'24=E!A=<%$1$42%!

K$@04<%@<'$%!2*!4<!+%@*,%2!<0%!E&'%!<0:<!+4=(2!<0%!M:$4*'2!@*,1*=%=<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!?*0%$%=@F!

D:=:E%,%=<!42!<0%=!<0%!1$*@%22!*3!,:<'$4=E!<0%!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<*!,:6%!<0%!3*'=(:<4*=!3*$!

4,1&%,%=<4=E!<0%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!:11$*:@0-

K! 2'EE%2<4*= ! 3*$ ! : ! 3$:,%R*$6 ! (%:&4=E !R4<0 ! :$<4@'&:<4=E ! : ! 3$:,%R*$6 ! (%:&4=E !R4<0 ! 4=<%E$:<%(!

E*M%$=:=@%!:=(!<0:<!(%:&2!R4<0!%&%,%=<2!*3!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!0:2!+%%=!:(($%22%(!4=!<0%!

@0:1<%$!(%:&4=E!R4<0!:!3$:,%R*$6!3*$!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-

/*!:=2R%$!<0%!Z'%2<4*=!:+*M%!<0%=!R0%=!:$<4@'&:<4=E!:!3$:,%R*$6!<0:<!(%:&2!R4<0!+*<0!@*0%$%=@F!

,:=:E%,%=<!:=(!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!<0%=!<0%!422'%2!*3!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<0%*$F!^@'&<'$%\!2<$'@<'$%!

:=(!1*R%$_!:=(!422'%2!*3!0*R!<*!4,1&%,%=<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!<0$*'E0!<0%!3$:,%R*$6-!/0%!

:11$*:@0!42!@*0%$%=<!R4<0!'2:E%!*3!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!24=@%!<0%!:11$*:@0!0:2!+%%=!+:2%(!*=!<0%!

:22',1<4*=!<0:<!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!42!:=!4=<%E$:&!1:$<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!^24=@%!<0%!1'$1*2%!

42!<*!:&4E=!<0%!@*,1*=%=<2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!@*=242<!*3_-!

K!1*<%=<4:&!3$:,%R*$6!=%%(2!<*!R*$6!R4<0!%2<:+&4204=E!:!3*$,:&!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!E$*'1!:=(!

%2<:+&420!:!?04%3!K$@04<%@<!<0:<!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!:(,4=42<$:<%!<0%!E$*'1!:=(!<:6%!@0:$E%!*3!M:$4*'2!

<:262!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

!""#<! V+Q!4+&,!:%&!E;:&D)6:&4!S+G&);6;>&!?;683&!6;!P)D6;.U6:.+;!:+!B>%.&G&!=+9*&:.:.G&!B4G6;:6D&X

L=<%E$:<%( ! E*M%$=:=@% ! @:= ! %=:+&% ! @*,1%<4<4M% ! :(M:=<:E% ! 3*$ ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! <0$*'E0 ! %=3*$@4=E!

0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<-

!"!#$%&!+;

Page 70: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

W*R%M%$!:2!4<!R:2!,%=<4*=%(!4=!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!@0:1<%$!<0%=!*=%!24=E&%!

1$*@%22!*$!:@<4M4<F!@:=!%=2'$%!:!2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!^=*<%!<0:<!20*$<B<%$,!@*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E%2!*3<%=!+%@*,%2!%Y1%=24M%!<*!:@04%M%!:=(!4=M%2<,%=<2!4=!L/!<'$=2!*'<!<*!+%_!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!

20*'&( ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% ! 3*@'2 !*= !@*=34E'$% !: ! 2'4<:+&% !:,*'=< !1$*@%22%2 !*$ ! :@<4M4<4%2 ! <* !%=:+&% !:!

@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%-

/0%!:22',1<4*=!*=!R*$64=E!R4<0!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!<0:<!<0%!@*=@%1<!:2!2'@0!%=:+&%2!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!%Y%@'<4M%2!R4<0!:!0*&42<4@!M4%R!*M%$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/0%!%Y%@'<4M%!R4&&!<0%=!,:6%!

'2%!*3!<042!M4%R!<*!,:6%!+%<<%$!(%@424*=2-!

50%=!@*,+4=%(!R4<0!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!:=!:11$*:@0!<*!:&4E=!<0%!

@*,1*=%=<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<*!@$%:<%!2F=%$EF\!<0%!2F=%$EF!42!'2%(!4=!@*,+4=:<4*=!R4<0!<0%!@*=@%1<!

*3 ! :E4&4<F ! ^<0% !:+4&4<F ! <* ! :(`'2< !:=(!:(:1< ! <* ! <0% !@0:=E%2 ! 4= ! <0% !(*,:4=_ !:=( !:22'$:=@% ! 4= ! <0%!

%=<%$1$42%!42!(*4=E!R0:<!42!=%%(%(!<*!<$%:<!4<2!@'2<*,%$2!:=(!1:$<=%$2!<0%!$4E0<!R:F!4=!%:@0!:=(!%M%$F!

<4,%!<0%F!4=<%$:@<-

50%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!<0%=!4<!42!=*<:+&%!<0:<!=*!%=<%$1$42%!2*!3:$!0:2!+%%=!:+&%!

<* ! 4,1&%,%=<%( ! <0% ! %,+%((%( ! :$@04<%@<'$%\ ! :=( ! <0% ! @*,1%<4<4M% ! :(M:=<:E%2 ! +F ! 4,1&%,%=<4=E!

?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!42!F%<!<*!+%!2%%=-

W*R%M%$!<0%!+%=%34<2!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!42!=*<! <*!+%!(421'<%(!43 !<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!3:@%!<0%!

@0:&&%=E%!*3!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!0*&42<4@!M4%R!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!@0:=E%!R0:<!42!=%%(%(-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&'&2+*5)**+3%&3%&A#'/&/#+*&;';$1&5'%&($&)*$2&,31<A#'/&%$$2*&/3&($&23%$&/3&+%=$*/+0'/$ &

/#$&/3;+5&3,&7%/$01'/$2&G3=$1%'%5$&$=$%&,)1/#$1?

!"!#$%&!+L

Page 71: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&-4& M:,A0,,:'*

/042!@0:1<%$!(%:&2!R4<0!R0:<!@:=!+%!&%:$=%(!+F!$%:(4=E!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R\!:=(!R0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!

(*=%!<*!E%=%$:&4V%!<0%!34=(4=E2!*3!<0%!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R\!2*!<0%!34=(4=E2!*=%!(:F!@:=!+%!:11&4%(!4=!

%=<%$1$42%2!:@$*22!<0%!E&*+%-

!"1#"! /%6:!=6;!8&!N&6);&4!T)+9!$%.,!5&G.&QX

/042!$%M4%R!0:2!+%%=!+:2%(!*=!:22',1<4*=2!<0:< !L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!(%:&2!R4<0!:&4E=4=E!<0%!

2<$:<%E4@!:11$*:@0!:=(!E*M%$=:=@%!1$*@%22%2-!/0%!1:1%$!0:2!:&2*!R*$6%(!R4<0!(%&4,4<:<4*=!*3!R0:<!

64=(!*3!2<$:<%E4%2!:=(!3*$,2!*3!,:=:E%,%=<!<0:<!@:=!+%!:11&4%(!<*!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%\!:=(!4<!42!

M%$F!&46%&F!<0:<!,:=F!,*$%!3*$,2!*3!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=!+%!4=<%E$:<%(!<*!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!

S*M%$=:=@%-

/0%!(%&4,4<:<4*=!,4E0<!0:M%!0:(!:=!4,1:@<!*=!<0%!E%=%$:&!34=(4=E2!*3!0*R!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!:&4E=!:=(!

4=<%$:@<-!W*R%M%$!<0%!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!2'EE%2<2!<0:<!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%!@:=!&%:(!<*!:!2'2<:4=:+&%!

@*,1%<4<4M% ! :(M:=<:E% ! 24=@% ! 4< !R4&& ! &%:( ! <* ! : ! @*0%$%=< ! :=( ! 0*&42<4@ !,:=:E%,%=< ! :11$*:@0 ! <*!

E*M%$=:=@%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!(*%2!:&2*!2'EE%2<!<0:<!,*2<!%=<%$1$42%2!:$%=]<!:2!24,1&%!:2!<0%!,%,+%$2!*3!<0%!

%Y%@'<4M%2!+%&4%M%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!,4E0<!+%-!/0%!%=0:=@%(!@*,1&%Y4<F!&%:(2!<*!@*,1&4@:<4*=2!R0%=!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!E*!<0$*'E0!:!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22-

/0%!<$:=23*$,:<4*=!1$*@%22!=%%(2!<*!+%!:(($%22%(!<0$*'E0!:11&F4=E!(433%$%=<!<0%*$4%2!3$*,!(433%$%=<!

34%&(2!*3!<0%*$F!%-E-\!4==*M:<4*=!<0%*$F\!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!<0%*$F!:=(!2F2<%,4@!<0%*$F-

P46%R42%!(*%2!<0%!1:1%$!2'EE%2<2!<0:<!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%!:=(!?*0%$%=@F!D:=:E%,%=<!@:=!+%!

'2%(!<*!%=:+&%!0*&42<4@!,:=:E%,%=<!<0$*'E0!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%-!

/0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!*$!@0:=E%!:E%=<2!4=!:=F!%=<%$1$42%!$%B<04=6!<0%4$!:11$*:@0%2!<*!

@0:=E%!:=(!0*R!<0%F!'2':&&F!:$<4@'&:<%!2<$:<%E4%2!:=(!1*&4@4%2-!L3!<0%F!(*=]<!@0:=E%!<0%!R:F!<0%F!

<04=6 ! :+*'< ! <0% ! *$E:=4V:<4*=\ !,:=:E%,%=< ! :=( ! <$:=23*$,:<4*= ! <0%= ! 4< ! 42 ! M%$F ! &46%&F ! <0:< ! <0%4$!

%=<%$1$42%2!R4&&!%Y1%$4%=@%!&*22!*3!@*,1%<4<4M%=%22!:=(!%M%=<':&&F!(4%!*'<!('%!<*!&:@6!*3!:(:1<4*=!

:=(!:E4&4<F-

L=!*<0%$!42!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!:!64=(!*3!1:$:(4E,!2043<\!:=(!<0*2%!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!R4&&!=*<!:(:1<!

<*!<0%!=%R!@*=(4<4*=2!*3!(*4=E!+'24=%22!:=(!E*M%$=4=E!%=<%$1$42%2!R4&&!(4%!*'<-

!"!#$%&!:M

Page 72: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"1#1! T():%&)!2:(4.&,

/0%!@*=@%1<!*3!L=<%E$:<%(!S*M%$=:=@%!:=(!0*R!<*!:@04%M%!:!2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!0:2!

<*!+%!4=M%2<4E:<%(!3'$<0%$!+F!2@4%=<434@!2<'(F!%-E-\!<0$*'E0!<0%!R*$6!R4<0!:!,:2<%$!<0%242\!*$!3*$!<0:<!

,:<<%$!<0$*'E0!:!2@4%=<434@!1$*E$:,!%-E-\!<0$*'E0!:!#0H!2@0*&:$2041-

L<!42!,F!4=<%=<4*=!<*!,:6%!3'$<0%$!2<'(4%2!4=!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%-!L=!:!2%=2%!L!@*=24(%$!<042!1:1%$!:!

1$%B2<'(F!<*!,F!,:2<%$!<0%242-

!"!#$%&!:K

Page 73: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&-9& @<<%*1:U

N%$=:$(\!8-K-\!7JJ.-!I%&7%/132)5/+3%&93&\%/$1;1+*$&I15#+/$5/)1$F&U$53%2&\2+/+3%!7=(!%(-\!

K'<0*$W*'2%-!!

T4=6%&2<%4=\!8-\!W:$M%F\!?-!)!P:R<*=\!/-\!7JJC-!T1$'N3)/&U/1'/$0.F&`$$/+%0&/#$&8#'--$%0$&3, &

B3)(-$@B+0+/&G13A/#\!D@S$:RBW4&&!#$*3%224*=:&-!!

W%$V',\!#-\!7JJ;-!K11&F4=E!A=<%$1$42%!K$@04<%@<'$%-!8)//$1&83%*31/+)4&\J$5)/+=$&P$;31/\!C^;_\!;C-!

D4=<V+%$E\!W-\!7JJJ-!9#$&P+*$&'%2&b'--&3,&U/1'/$0+5&W-'%%+%0\!T4=:=@4:&!/4,%2e!#$%=<4@%!W:&&-!!

D@K3%%\!K-!)!N$F=`*&322*=\!A-\!7JJG-!L=M%2<4=E!4=!<0%!L/!<0:<!,:6%2!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!(433%$%=@%-!

Z'1='12&T)*+%$**&P$=+$A\!GC^OeG_\!IG["JO-!!

g*<<%$\!f-#-\!7JJG-!I&U$%*$&3,&c10$%5.\!W:$M:$(!N'24=%22!8@0**&!#$%22-!!

D4=<V+%$E\!W-\!K0&2<$:=(\!#-N-!)!P:,1%&\!f-N-\!7JJG-!U/1'/$0.&U','1+F&9#$&834;-$/$&G)+2$&9#13)0#&

/#$&"+-2*&3,&U/1'/$0+5&`'%'0$4$%/!7=(!%(-\!T4=:=@4:&!/4,%2e!#$%=<4@%!W:&&-!!

i%R%&&\!8-!%<!:&-\!7JJO-!`'%'0+%0&X%3A-$20$&"31N!"2<!%(-\!i%R!c*$6m!#:&E$:M%!D:@D4&&:=-!!

#*$<%$\!D-A-\!"IG.-!834;$/+/+=$&I2='%/'0$F&81$'/+%0&'%2&U)*/'+%+%0&U);$1+31&W$1,314'%5$\!i%R!

c*$6m!T$%%!#$%22-!!

#*$<%$\ !D-A-\ ! "IIC- !50:< ! L2 ! 8<$:<%EFX !Z'1='12 & T)*+%$** & P$=+$A\ ! O>^C_\ ! C"BOG- !KM:4&:+&% ! :<m!

0<<1mee%2@BR%+-&4+-@+2-(6e&*E4=X'$&o0<<1mee2%:$@0-%+2@*0*2<-@*,e&*E4=-:21YX

(4$%@<o<$'%)(+o+<0)KioIC"""GOI.>)24<%o%0*2<B&4M%)2@*1%o24<%!pK@@%22%(!f:=':$F!7C\!7J"Jq-!!

8`*%&4=\ !#- !T- !/\ !7J"J- !/0% ! L/!8<$:<%EFm !K=!K$<4@'&:<4*= !*3 ! <0% ! L/!8<$:<%EF! 3$*,!: !?*0%$%=@F!

K$@04<%@<]2!#*4=<!*3!U4%R-

8*==4@02%=\!7JJI-!/0%!T'<'$%!*3!A=<%$1$42%!9%2*'$@%!#&:==4=E-

Q$<*=!)!5%4@6\!"IIJ-!P**2%&F!?*'1&%(!8F2<%,2m!K!?*=@%1<':&4V:<4*=-!K@:(%,F!*3!D:=:E%,%=<!

9%M4%R-

5%4&&\!#-!)!9*22\!f-5-\!7JJ>-!79&G3=$1%'%5$F&Z3A&93;&W$1,314$1*&`'%'0$&79&B$5+*+3%&P+0#/*&,31 &

U);$1+31&P$*)-/*\!W:$M:$(!N'24=%22!8@0**&!#$%22-!!

5%4&&\!#-!)!9*22\!f-\!7JJI-!L/!8:MMFm!50:<!/*1!AY%@'<4M%2!D'2<!g=*R!<*!S*!3$*,!#:4=!<*!S:4=\!

W:$M:$(!N'24=%22!8@0**&!#$%22-!

!"!#$%&!:'

Page 74: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&-;& O*A$',0/%&-

/042!%=@&*2'$%!(%:&2!R4<0!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!<0:<!D4=<V+%$E!@0:$:@<%$4V%!4=!042!+**6!a8<$:<%EF!

8:3:$4b!3$*,!7JJI-

!"<#"! 2>%++3,!+-!2:)6:&D.>!$%+(D%:

D4=<V+%$E!%<!:&-!0:2!(%M%&*1%(!:!=':=@%(!M4%R!*3!0*R!<0%!M:$4*'2!2<$:<%E4@!2@0**&2!<0:<!0:M%!+%%=!

(%M%&*1%(!*M%$!<4,%\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!4=@&'(%!<0%4$!M4%R2!4=!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R-!L!

0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&\ !1&:==4=E!2@0**&!:=(!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&- !/0%!

$%:2*=!3*$!<042!42!<0:<!3*'=(!<0%2%!2@0**&2!,*2<&F!$%&%M:=<!3*$!<0%!1'$1*2%!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%-

&-;B-B-& !6%&M%,:7*&=A6''$

/0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!42!:@@*$(4=E!<*!D4=<V+%$E!*=%!*3!<0%!(*,4=:<4=E!2@0**&2-!/0%!2@0**&!0:2!+%%=!

+'4&(!'1*=!<0%!4(%:!*3!'24=E!@:2%!2<'(4%2!:2!:!R:F!<*!@*,,'=4@:<%!<0%!3*'=(:<4*=2!*3!0*R!<0%!

2@0**&!R*$62-

/0%!,*2<!+:24@!,*(%&!*3!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!2@0**&!42!<0%!85Q/B,*(%&!24=@%!<0%!3*'=(:<4*=!:=(!+:24@!

:22',1<4*=!*=!0*R!<*!@$%:<%!:!E**(!2<$:<%EF!4=!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!42!<*!:$<4@'&:<%!:!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!

0:=(&%2!<0%!+:$$4%$2!:=(!(4334@'&<4%2!<0:<!42!4(%=<434%(!4=!<0%!%=M4$*=,%=<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!

P46%R42%!42!4<!:!=%@%224<F!<*!+$4(E%!<0%!E:1!+%<R%%=!<0%!4=<%$=:&!@*,1%<%=@%2!:=(!<0%!+:$$4%$2!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!3:@%2!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!11-!7.!B!7O_-!!D4=<V+%$E!(%('@%2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!3*'$!3:@<*$2!!<0:<!

@:=!2<$%22!<%2<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!R4<04=!<0%!](%24E=!2@0**&]!:=(!4<!42!:!$%Z'4$%,%=<!<*!:(($%22!<0%!2<$:<%EF!

<0$*'E0!<0:<m

"_!?*=242<%=@F!R04@0!,%:=2!<0:<! <0%!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(=]<!20*R!:=F!4=@*=242<%=@F!+%<R%%=!

E*:&2 ! :=( ! 1*&4@4%2 - !

7_!?*=2*=:=@%!R04@0!,%:=2!<0%!2<$:<%EF!=%%(2!<*!+%!:(:1<!<*!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,4=*!:=(!4=!

<0% ! %=<%$1$42% - !

;_!K(M:=<:E%!,%:=2!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!3*@'2!*=!@$%:<4=E!:!2'2<:4=:+&%!@*,1%<4<4M%!

:(M:=<:E% ! R4<04= ! : ! 2%&%@<%( ! :$%: ! :=( !

>_ !T%:24+4&4<F !,%:=2 ! <0:< ! <0% !2<$:<%EF !20*'&(=]< !@$%:<% !1$*+&%,2! ^%-E-\ ! 2'+!*1<4,4V:<4*=_!

R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=*$!20*'&(!4<!*M%$<:Y!$%2*'$@%2-!/0%!1$4,:$F!*+`%@<4M%!*3!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!42!

<*!6%%1!<0%!2<$:<%EF!@&%:$\!24,1&%!:=(!21%@434@!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!1-!7G_-

!"!#$%&!:(

Page 75: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"<#"#"#"! ')&9.,&,

K@@*$(4=E! <* !D4=<V+%$E!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\ !11- !;J!B !;;_ ! <0%$%!:$%!2%M%=!1$%,42%2 !*3 ! <0% !(%24E=!

2@0**&m

"_ H%&4+%$:<%!1$*@%22!*3!@*=2%=2'2!<0*'E0<-

7_ /0%!?AQ!42!<0%!@04%3!%Y%@'<4M%!:=(!:2!2'@0!0%!20*'&(!0:M%!<0%!'&<4,:<%!$%21*=24+4&4<F!:=(!

@*=<$*&-

;_ /0%!2<$:<%EF!3*$,:<4*=!0:2!<*!+%!6%1<!24,1&%!:=(!4=3*$,:&-

>_ /0%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!'=4Z'%-

._ /0%!(%24E=!1$*@%22!42!@*,1&%<%(!R0%=!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!2%%=!:2!:!1%$21%@<4M%-

C_ /0%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!6%1<!24,1&%!:=(!%Y1&4@4<-

O_ 50%=!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!3'&&F!3*$,'&:<%(!^%Y1&4@4<\!'=4Z'%\!3'&&!+&*R=!^@*0%$%=<_\! !24,1&%!:=(!

+'4&(!*=!<0%!@*=2%=2'2_!@:=!<0%!2<$:<%EF!+%!4,1&%,%=<%(-

K2!2'@0!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!(*!2'EE%2<!<0%!<*1!,:=:E%,%=<!@*,,4<,%=<!<0$*'E0!<0:<!<0%!?AQ!0:2!<*!

+% ! @*=24(%$%( ! <0% ! *=% ! $%21*=24+&% ! 3*$ ! :$<4@'&:<4=E ! :=( ! (%M%&*14=E ! <0% ! 2<$:<%EFd ! 0*R%M%$ ! <0%!

1$%,42%2!(*%2!=%E&%@<!<0%!3:@<!<0:<!<0%!?AQ!@:=]<!6=*R!%M%$F<04=E!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!0*R!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:@<2-!8%@*=(&F!(*%2!<0%!1$%,42%2!2'EE%2<!<0:<!:!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!%Y1&4@4<!:=(!<042!@:=!+%!

'=(%$2<**(!:2!<0%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!1'<!*=!1:1%$d!<0*'E0!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!*=!1:1%$!<0%=!4<!(*%2=]<!

%=2'$%!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!%,+*(4%(!4=!<0%!:@<4*=2!*3!<0%!?AQ\!%Y%@'<4M%2\!,4((&%!,:=:E%$2!*$!

R*$6%$2!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!K2!2'@0!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!42!=*<!%=<4$%&F!*'<!*3!2@*1%!R4<0!0*R!:!2<$:<%EF!

20*'&(!+%!:$<4@'&:<%(!24=@%!4<!%,10:24V%2!24,1&4@4<F!^R04@0!:4(%2!<0%!@*,,'=4@:<4*=!1$*@%22!:=(!4=!

R04@0!@:=!:2242<!4=!R4==4=E!*M%$!*<0%$!1:$<2!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<0:<!,4E0<!+%!0*2<4&%!<*!@0:=E%_-

!"<#"#"#1! =).:.Y(&

D4=<V+%$E!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!11-!;.B>>_!(*%2!4=4<4:<%!:!@$4<4Z'%!*3!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!:=(!:2!2'@0!4<!42!

@$4<4@4V%(!3*$!=*<! `'2<43F4=E!&%:$=4=E!4=!<0%!1$*@%22!*3!%Y%@'<4=E!<0%!2<$:<%EF!:=(!=*<!3*$!<:64=E!

%,%$E%=<!2<$:<%E4%2!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!:3<%$!<0%!3*$,'&:<4*=!10:2%!0:2!%=(%(-!L=!:((4<4*=!<*!<0:<!<0%=!

<0%!2<$:<%EF!2@0**&!%,10:24V%!<**!,'@0!*=!@:2%!2<'(4%2!:=(!*=!<0%!85Q/B,*(%&!:2!:!R:F!<*!(%24E=!

:=(!1*24<4*=!:=(!%=<%$1$42%-

P46%R42%!(*%2!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&!(4@<:<% !<0:<! <0%!2<$'@<'$%!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!@0:=E%!3*$,!

R0%=!2<$:<%EF!42!:&<%$%(-!D4=<V+%$E!%,10:24V%2!<0:<!,*2<!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!:2!2'@0!@:=]<!`'2<!a@&%:=!<0%!

+&:@6!+*:$(b!:=(!2<:$<!:&&!*M%$!*=!:!=%R!+%E4==4=E!R04@0!42!:!$%2'&<!<*!*$E:=4V:<4*=!@'&<'$%-

!"!#$%&!:)

Page 76: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

L!:((4<4*=!(%<:@04=E!<0%!2<$:<%EF!3$*,!<0*2%!R0*!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!@'2<*,%$2!e!@&4%=<2!@:=!&%:(!<*!<0:<!

2<$:<%EF!+%@*,%2!*+2*&%<%!:=(!<0:<!42!%=3*$@%(!<0$*'E0!:=!%Y1&4@4<!2<$:<%EF!R4&&!&4,4<!<0%!:+4&4<F!<*!

:(:1<!<*!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!%=M4$*=,%=<!'=(%$!:=(!('$4=E!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF-!H*'@%<!%<!

:&-!^H*'@%<!%<!:&-!7JJI\!1-!>"C_!:$E'%2!<0:<!@*,1%<4<4*=!:=(!<0%!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,4=*!R4&&!@0:=E%!

,*$%!3$%Z'%=<&F!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!:(:1<%(!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!(*%2!4<!2%%,!'=$%:2*=:+&%!

<*!R*$6!*=!R4<0!<0%!:22',1<4*=!*3!:=!%Y1&4@4<!2<$:<%EF-

/0%!,%:=4=E!*3!(%M%&*14=E!:!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%=!(%<:@0!4<!3$*,!<0*2%!R0*!R*$6!R4<0!<0*2%!R0*!

+$4=E2 !,*=%F ! <* ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! :=( ! <* ! <0% ! :=( ! (%<:@04=E ! <0% ! 2<$:<%EF ! 3*$,'&:<4*= ! 3$*, ! <0%!

4=<%E$:<4*=!^4,1&%,%=<:<4*=_!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!:<!+%2<!:!'<*14:=!4(%:!24=@%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!0:2!<*!

&%:(!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&;-'%%+%0&*5#33-?

&-;B-B4& !6%&.$"**:*7&=A6''$

K@@*$(4=E!<*!D4=<V+%$E!42!<0%!#&:==4=E!8@0**&!*=%!*3!<0%!1$%3%$$%(!2@0**&2!3*$!@*=2'&<:=<2!:=(!:2!

2'@0!4<!42!$%&%M:=<!3*$!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!24=@%!4<!0:2!:!1$*3*'=(!4,1:@<!*=!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!

<0%!$%21*=24+&%!1%*1&%!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!$%:@<!:=(!4=<%$:@<!<*!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2-

D4=<V+%$E!@0:$:@<%$4V%!<0%!2@0**&!R0%$%!<0%!1&:==%$2!:$%!(%<:@0%(!3$*,!<0%!1$*('@<4*=-!P46%R42%!42!

4<!2<%$%*<F14@:&!<0:<!<0%!1&:==%$2!:$%!=%4<0%$!3$*,!<0%!R*$63*$@%!=%:$!<0%!1$*('@<4*=!*$!&*@:<%(!=%:$!

<0%!<*1!%Y%@'<4M%2-!/0%!E%=%$:&!1$4=@41&%!42!<0:<!<0%!1&:==%$2!:$%!&*@:<%(!<*!(*!]*+`%@<4M%]";!1&:==4=E!

<0:<!E4M%2!<0%!<*1!%Y%@'<4M%2!4=<%&&4E%=<!@0*4@%2!<*!@0*4@%!3$*,!:=(!:2!2'@0!:!&*<!*3!1*R%$!:=(!

$%2*'$@%2!0:M%!<*!+%!:&&*@:<%(!<*!<0%!1&:==4=E!E$*'1-

L<!42!:!1$*+&%,!<0:<!<0%!1&:==%$2!:$%!(%<:@0%(!3$*,!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%F!^:2!4<!42!R4<0!<0%!

(%24E= !2@0**&_ !:$% !R*$64=E!R4<0 ! 4(%:2 ! <0:< !:$% !=*< !+:2%( !*=! <0% !24<':<4*= ! 4= ! <0% !@*$%">! *3 ! <0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=-

!"<#"#1#"! ')&9.,&,

D4=<V+%$E!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!1-!CJ_!(%34=%2!<0$%%!1$%,42%2!<0:<!:$%!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0%!1&:==4=E!

2@0**&-!/0%!34$2<!1$%,42%!(%:&2!R4<0!8<$:<%EF!42!:!$%2'&<!*3!:!@*=<$*&&%(\!@*=2@4*'2!1$*@%22!*3!3*$,:&!

1&:==4=E!<0:<!0:2!+%%=!@*=M%$<%(!4=<*!<*!(42<4=@<!2<%12-!/0%2%!2<%12!:$%!2'11*$<%(!@0%@6&42<2!:=(!

2'11*$<%(!+F!<%@0=4Z'%2-!/0%!2%@*=(!1$%,42%!42!<0:<!4=!1$4=@41&%!<0%!$%21*=24+4&4<F!3*$!<0%!*M%$:&&!

1$*@%22!42!:&&*@:<%(!<*!<0%!?AQd!0*R%M%$!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!&4%2!R4<0!<0%!1&:==4=E!

"; #&:==4=E!+:2%(!*=!0:$(!3:@<2-

"> /0%!@*$%!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!1$*('@<4*=!2%@<4*=!^<0%!3&**$_!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=-2

!"!#$%&!:*

Page 77: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<:33-!/0%!<04$(!1$%,42%!(%:&2!R4<0!<0:<!2<$:<%E4%2!:11%:$!3'&&!+&*R=!3$*,!<042!1$*@%22!:=(! !<0%2%!

0:M%!<*!+%!,:(%!%Y1&4@4<!2*!<0%!1$*1%$!:<<%=<4*=!@:=!+%!4=M%2<%(!4=!$%&:<4*=!<*!*+`%@<4M%2\!+'(E%<2\!

1$*E$:,2\!:=(!*1%$:<4=E!1&:=2!*3!M:$4*'2!64=(2-

/0%!1$%,42%2!:$%!+:2%(!*=!<0:<!<0%!1&:==%$2!0:M%!:!&*<!*3!1*R%$!R4<04=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<0%!M:&'%!

:((%(!3'=@<4*=!*3!<0%!?AQ!@:=!<0%=!+%!(42@'22%(!24=@%!0%!*=&F!0:2!<0%!*M%$!:&&!$%21*=24+4&4<F\!:=(!

<0%!1&:=%$2!0:M%!<0%!$%21*=24+4&4<F!:=(!<0%!1*R%$!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!L<!2%%,2!*'<!*3!<*'@0!

R4<0!$%:&4<F!43!<0%!?AQ!42!*'<!*3!<*'@0!R4<0!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!0%!R4&&!&*2%!<*'@0!

R4<0!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!*1%$:<%2!:=(!:2!2'@0!R4&&!=*<!+%!:+&%!<*!@*,,4<!04,2%&3!<*!<0%!2*&'<4*=-!

T$*,!:!(433%$%=<!1%$21%@<4M%!<0%=!:!1$*3%224*=:&!1&:==%$!,4E0<!+%!+%<<%$!<*!4(%=<43F!0*R!<0%!(*,:4=!

*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!@0:=E%-

!"<#"#1#1! =).:.Y(&

D4=<V+%$E!@$4<4@4V%(!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!2<$:<%EF!2@0**&!+F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!<0%!1&:=%$2!R0%$%!<**!

(%<:@0%(!3$*,!*=%!:=*<0%$!<*!,:6%!:=F!3*$,!*3!2F=%$EF-!P46%R42%!(4(!D4=<V+%$E!@$4<4@4V%!<0:<!<0%$%!

R:2!:=!:22',1<4*=!*=!<0:<!1&:==4=E!R:2!<0%!%=<4$%!1$*@%22!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!,:64=E-

K2!,%=<4*=%(!'=(%$!<0%!1$%,42%2!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!1-!O"_!<0%=!<0%$%!:$%!2*,%!422'%2!R4<0!E4M4=E!

1*R%$ ! *3 ! 2<$:<%EF ! 3*$,'&:<4*= ! <* ! <0% ! 1&:==4=E ! 2<:33 ! 24=@% ! <0%F ! 0:M% ! : ! <%=(%=@F ! <* ! 6%%1 ! <0%!

%Y%@'<4M%2 ! *'< ! *3 ! <0% ! &**1 ! :=( ! 4=2<%:( ! *3 ! 1&:==4=E ! <0%F ! +'4&( ! %,14$%2 !R4<04= ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42%-!

D4=<V+%$E!<0%=!%,10:24V%!<0:<!<0%!1$*@%22!*3!3*$,'&:<4=E!<0%!2<$:<%EF!+%@:,%!<0%!(*,4=:<4=E!3*@'2!

:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!3*@'2!3$*,!<0%!2<$:<%EF!:=(!2<$:<%E4@!$%:&4<F!R:2!(%,*<%(-!P46%R42%!(*%2!D4=<V+%$E!

@$4<4@4V%!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!3*$!=*<!1$*('@4=E!:=F!$%2'&<2!+F!<0%!'2:E%!*3!<0%!M:$4*'2!3*$,'&:<4*=!

1$*@%22%2 !:=(! <0% !1&:=2 !(4(=]< ! 3*@'2 !%=*'E0!*=!+'24=%22 !(%M%&*1,%=< ! ^=:<'$:& !E$*R<0_ !+'< !*=!

D%$E%$2!)!K@Z'424<4*=-!

/0%$%<*!(4(!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!3*@'2!<**!,'@0!*=!@0**24=E!:!2<$:<%EF!4=2<%:(!*3!@0**24=E!<0%!+%2<!

2<$:<%E4@!@0*4@%- ! !Q3<%=!(4(!<0%!1&:==%$2!=%E&%@<!<0%!+:$$4%$2!*3! <0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!2<$'@<'$%!:=(!

@'&<'$%-

D4=<V+%$E]2 ! @$4<4Z'% !*3 ! <0% !1&:==4=E ! 2@0**& ! @:= !+% ! `'2<434%( !+F !1&:==4=E ! <0:< ! (*%2=]< ! <:6% ! <0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=!:=(!4<2!2<$'@<'$%!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!(*%2=]<!@*M%$!<0%!%=<4$%!21%@<%$!*3!<0%!(*,4=*!*3!

%=<%$1$42%-!K(M:=<:E%2!*3!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!@:=!+%!,:(%!*=!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!1$*3%224*=:&2!

R*$64=E!R4<0!1&:==4=E!@:=!,:6%!4=<%&&4E%=<!:=(!0*&42<4@!1&:=2!<0:<!@:=!E4M%!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!^?AQ!

:=(!*<0%$!<*1!&%M%&!,:=:E%$2_!4=<%&&4E%=<!@0*4@%2!R0%=!@*,4=E!<*!2<$:<%EF-

D4=<V+%$E!@$4<4@4V%2!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!1-!O.![!OC_!<0:<!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!3*@'2!<**!,'@0!*=!<0%!

!"!#$%&!:+

Page 78: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

0:$(!3:@<2!4=!<0%4$!1&:==4=E!1$*@%22!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!(*%2!D4=<V+%$E!@*=@&'(%2!<0:<!0:$(!3:@<2!@:=]<!+%!

'2%(!R4<0*'<!@*,+4=:<4*=!*3!0',:=!^2'+`%@<4M%_!`'(E%,%=<-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&2+*5)**+3%&3,&/#$&$%/1$;1$%$)1&*5#33-?

&-;B-B9& !6%&O*+/%</%*%0/&=A6''$

P46%R42%!42!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&!4,1*$<:=<!<*!<042!&4<%$:<'$%!$%M4%R!24=@%!<0%!2@0**&!42!+'4&(!'1*=!

0*R!<0%!&%:(%$!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:@<2!:=(!%=3*$@%2!2<$:<%EF-!/0%!&%:(%$!42!:@@*$(4=E!<*!D4=<V+%$E!:!

1%$2*=!R0*!R:=<2!<*!@0:=E%!<0%!2<:<'2!Z'*d!0*R%M%$!4=!2*,%!@:2%2!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!,4E0<!20:$%!

@0:$:@<%$42<4@2!R4<0!2*@4*1:<02!:=(!12F@0*1:<02!R04@0!,4E0<!%=(!'1!+%4=E!:!(42:(M:=<:E%!3*$!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%-!/0%!,:=:E%,%=<!2<F&%!:=(!<0%!@0:$:@<%$42<4@2!@:=!&%:(!<*!:=!'=3*$<'=:<%!%,1&*F,%=<!

2<$:<%EF!24=@%!&%:(%$2!:=(!,:=:E%$2!0:M%!:!<%=(%=@F!<*!04$%!1%$2*=2!<0:<!$%,4=(2!*3!<0%,2%&M%2-!K2!

2'@0!<0:<!@:=!&%:(!<*!E$*'1!@*=3*$,4<F!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!E$*'1!R4&&!+%!<:64=E!'=B=%@%22:$F!$4262!

^i%R%&&!%<!:&!7JJ7\!11-!."B.7_-

!"<#"#7#"! ')&9.,&

D4=<V+%$E!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!24Y!1$%,42%2!<0:<!@0:$:@<%$4V%2!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&m

"_ /0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!0:2!<0%!M424*=!:=(!4<!42!*3<%=!%,+*(4%(!4=!<0%!,4=(!*3!<0%!?AQ!^R0*!:@<2!

:2!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$_-

7_ /0%!2<$:<%EF!:$<4@'&:<%(!+F!<0%!&%:(%$d!0*R%M%$!4<!42=]<!:&R:F2!@&%:$!0*R!<0%!&%:(%$!(%M%&*12!

<0%!M424*=!<0:<!42!<0%!2<$:<%EF-

;_ /0%!M424*=!42!*3<%=!,:4=<:4=%(!:=(!%=3*$@%(!+F!<0%!&%:(%$!R0*!R*$62!R4<0!<0%!M424*=!24=E&%!

,4=(%(!:=(!:2!2'@0!:&2*!(%M%&*12!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<*!+%@*,%!24=E&%!,4=(%(-

>_ /0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$4:&!2<$:<%EF!*3<%=!3*@'2!*=!0*R!<*!(%M%&*1!:!2<$:<%E4@!1*24<4*=!:2!:!2,:&&%$!

2<:$<!'1!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!=*<!:2!2'@0!*=!E$*R4=E!*$!,:<'$4=E!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

._ /0%!*$E:=4V:<4*= ! 42 !(%24E=%(! <* !0:=(&% ! <0% !*$(%$2 !*3 ! <0% ! &%:(%$ !:=(!:2 ! 2'@0! <0% !1*R%$!

2<$'@<'$%2 ! :=( ! 2*@4:& ! &4=62 ! :$% ! (%24E=%( ! <* ! @*,3*$< ! <0% ! &%:(%$2041 ! :=( ! $%21*=( ! <* ! <0%!

(%,:=(2!*3!<0%!&%:(%$2041-

C_ /0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2<$:<%EF!*3<%=!3*@'2%2!*=!:!=4@0%!:11$*:@0-

/0%!24Y!1$%,42%2!0:M%!E$%:<!24E=434@:=<2!*=!0*R!<0%!2@0**&!@:=!+%!4=<%$1$%<%(!:=(!0*R!<0%!2<$:<%E42<!

:@<2!:=(!0:=(&%2!R0%=!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!(*,4=*-!K2!2'@0!<0%!1$%,42%2!3*$!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2<$:<%EF!42!

+:2%(!*=!<0:<!<0%$%!42!<$%,%=(*'2!1*R%$!:=(!$%2*'$@%2!:&&*@:<%(!<*!<0%!?AQ!R0*!@:=!3*$@%!<0%!

8,:&&!*$!D%(4',!8%4V%(!A=<%$1$42%!^8DA_!*$!<0%!,*$%!,:<'$%!:=(!@*,1&%Y!%=<%$1$42%!<*!:&<%$!<0%!

!"!#$%&!::

Page 79: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!](4$%@<4*=!*3!,*M%,%=<]-

!"<#"#7#1! =).:.Y(&

/0%!1$4,:$F!@$4<4Z'%!*3!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&!42!<0:<!4<!$%&4%2!<**!,'@0!*=!:!24=E&%!1%$2*=!^<0%!

?AQ_!R0*!42!1*$<$:F%(!:2!<0%!1$4,:$F!($4M%$!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!P46%R42%!,4E0<!<0%!%=<$%1$%=%'$!

0:M%!:!+4:2%(!:=(!'=$%:&42<4@!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R*$62-

50%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:=(!4<2!2<$:<%EF!42!%Y<$%,%&F!(%1%=(%=<!*=!*=%!1:$<4@'&:$!1%$2*=!:=(!43!<042!

1%$2*= ! 2'((%=&F ! &%:M%2 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! <0%= ! <0% !%=<%$1$42% ! :2 ! 2'@0 !R*'&(=]< !0:M% ! :=F ! %33%@<4M%!

&%:(%$2041!*$!2<$:<%EF!^D4=<V+%$E!7JJG\!1-".7_-

9#+*& -$'2*&/3&/#$&2+*5)**+3%&3,& /#$&/#1$$&*/1'/$0.&*5#33-*&'%2&'*&*)5#&7&'//$%2&/3&2+*5)**&A#'/&

$-$4$%/* &3, & /#$ &*5#33-* & /#'/ &5'%&($&4'2$&)*$&3, & +% &534;'1+*3%& /3 & +%/$01'/$2&03=$1%'%5$&'%2 &

83#$1$%5.&`'%'0$4$%/?

!"<#1! $%&!2:)6:&D.>!2>%++3,

N%&*R!L!0:M%!2',,:$4V%(!^1$%,422%2_!<0%!2@0**&2!:=(!:3<%$R:$(2!L!R4&&!+%!(42@'224=E!<0%!2@0**&2!

:=(!R04@0!*3!<0%!2@0**&2!<0:<!@:=!+%!'2%(!3*$!<0%!3'$<0%$!2<'(F!*3!4=<%E$:<%(!E*M%$=:=@%-

!"!#$%&!:;

Page 80: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!6%&M%,:7*&=A6''$ !6%&.$"**:*7&=A6''$ !6%&O*+/%</%*%0/&=A6''$

-V! N&41R&=$E& ! F=35&00 ! 3?!

5320&20/0!EA3/%AE@

4V!-A&!UDQ!10!EA&!5A1&?!&V&5/E1C&!

$2P!$0 !0/5A!A&!0A3/4P !A$C&! EA&!

/4E1J$E&!=&0F3201R141E6!$2P!532E=34@

9V! -A& !0E=$E&%6 ! ?3=J$E132 !A$0 ! E3!

R&!>&FE!01JF4&!$2P!12?3=J$4@

;V!-A&!0E=$E&%6!A$0!E3!R&!/21]/&@

>V! -A& ! P&01%2 ! F=35&00 ! 10!

53JF4&E&P ! 9A&2 ! EA& ! 0E=$E&%6 ! 10!

0&&2!$0!$!F&=0F&5E1C&@

DV! -A& ! 0E=$E&%6 ! A$0 ! E3 ! R& ! >&FE!

01JF4&!$2P!&VF4151E@

HV &<A&2 ! EA& ! 0E=$E&%6 ! 10 ! ?/446!

?3=J/4$E&P ! ^&VF4151E\ ! /21]/&\ ! ?/44!

R4392!^53A&=&2E_\!01JF4&!$2P!R/14P!

32 ! EA& ! 5320&20/0_ ! 5$2 ! EA&!

0E=$E&%6!R&!1JF4&J&2E&P@

-V!HE=$E&%6!10!$!=&0/4E!3?!$!532E=344&P\!5320513/0!F=35&00!3?!?3=J$4!F4$2212%!EA$E!A$0!R&&2!532C&=E&P!12E3!E3!P10E125E!0E&F0@!-A&0&!0E&F0!$=&!0/FF3=E&P!5A&5>410E0!$2P!0/FF3=E&P!R6!E&5A21]/&0@!

4V!,2!F=1251F4&!EA&!=&0F3201R141E6!?3=!EA&!3C&=$44!F=35&00!41&0!$E!EA&!UDQ`!A39&C&=!EA&!1JF4&J&2E$E132!3?!EA&!0E=$E&%6!41&0!91EA!EA&!F4$2212%!0E$??@

9V!HE=$E&%1&0!$FF&$=!?/44!R4392!?=3J!EA10!F=35&00!$2P!$0!0/5A!EA&0&!A$C&!E3!R&!J$P&!&VF4151E!03!EA&!F=3F&=!$EE&2E132!E3!3RO&5E1C&0\!R/P%&E0\!F=3%=$J0\!$2P!3F&=$E12%!F4$20!3?!C$=13/0!>12P0@

-V!-A&!&2E=&F=&2&/=!A$0!EA&!C10132!

$2P ! 1E ! 10 ! 3?E&2 ! &JR3P1&P ! 12 ! EA&!

J12P!3?!EA&!UDQ!^9A3!$5E0!$0!EA&!

&2E=&F=&2&/=_@

4V! -A&!0E=$E&%6!$=E15/4$E&P!R6!EA&!

4&$P&=` ! A39&C&= ! 1E ! 102aE ! $49$60!

54&$=!A39!EA&!4&$P&=!P&C&43F0!EA&!

C10132!EA$E!10!EA&!0E=$E&%6@

9V! -A&!C10132! 10 !3?E&2!J$12E$12&P!

$2P ! &2?3=5&P ! R6 ! EA& ! 4&$P&= !9A3!

93=>0 ! 91EA ! EA& ! C10132 ! 012%4&!

J12P&P!$2P!$0!0/5A!$403!P&C&43F0!

EA&!0E=$E&%6!012%4&!J12P&P@

;V! -A& ! &2E=&F=&2&/=1$4 ! 0E=$E&%6!

3?E&2! ?35/0 !32!A39! E3 !P&C&43F !$!

0E=$E&%15!F301E132!$0!$!0J$44&=!0E$=E!

/F!&2E&=F=10&!$2P!23E!$0!0/5A!32!

%=3912%!3=!J$E/=12%!EA&!&2E&=F=10&@

>V!-A&!3=%$21W$E132!10!P&01%2&P!E3!

A$2P4& ! EA& ! 3=P&=0 ! 3? ! EA& ! 4&$P&=!

$2P!$0!0/5A!EA&!F39&=!0E=/5E/=&0!

$2P ! 0351$4 ! 412>0 ! $=& ! P&01%2&P ! E3!

53J?3=E ! EA& ! 4&$P&=0A1F ! $2P!

=&0F32P ! E3 ! EA& ! P&J$2P0 ! 3? ! EA&!

4&$P&=0A1F@

DV!-A&!&2E=&F=&2&/=!0E=$E&%6!3?E&2!

?35/0&0!32!$!215A&!$FF=3$5A@

9'(-$&KF&W1$4+**$*&3,&/#$&*/1'/$0+5&*5#33-*?

/0%!2@0**&2!0:M%!M:$4*'2!:(M:=<:E%2!:=(!(42:(M:=<:E%2!<0:<!0:M%!<*!+%!<:6%=!4=<*!@*=24(%$:<4*=!3*$!

<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!:=(!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:$@04<%@<2-

K2!2'@0!:!@*,+4=:<4*=!*3!<0%!(%24E=!2@0**&\!%=<$%1$%=%'$!2@0**&!:=(!<0%!1&:==4=E!2@0**&!R*'&(!+%!

(%24$:+&% ! 43 ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% ! 20*'&( ! 2'@@%%( ! R4<0 ! <0% ! <$:=23*$,:<4*=- ! ! 84=@% ! <0% ! 1*R%$ ! :=(!

$%21*=24+4&4<F !:=(! <0%!(%24$% ! ^=%%(!3*$ ! <0% !21%@4:&4<F_! 3*$ !:=!%Y1&4@4< !2<$:<%EF\! <0%!1*R%$!*3 ! <0%!

%=<$%1$%=%'$!?AQ!:=(!<0%!E'4(:=@%!*3!%Y1%$<2!<*!:(M4@%!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!*=!<0%!4=<%&&4E%=<!@0*4@%2!

!"!#$%&!:L

Page 81: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

<0%F!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!:=(!4=!<0%!%=(!2%&%@<-

!"<#7! T+()!T+)9,!+-!I)&60+(:!2:)6:&DC

T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&!^T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&!7JJI\!1-!7J_!(%34=%2!3*'$!(433%$%=<!3*$,2!3*$!<0%!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%EF!

<*!+%!:11&4%(!:=(!<0%!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%EF!0:M%!3*'$!(433%$%=<!@*=(4<4*=2-!/0%!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!

'2%(!4=!:!,:$6%<!<0:<!42!=:$$*R!:=(!4<2!+%E4==4=E!^:=(!:2!2'@0!2'+*$(4=:<%_!<*!<0%!%2<:+&420%(!,:$6%<!

:=(!<0%4$!4=('2<$4%2-!/F14@:&&F!<0%!<R*!3*$,2!*3!@*=(4<4*=2!^<:64=E!+F!2<*$,\!%Y1:=(4=E!0*$4V*=_!:$%!

<*!+%!3*'=(!4=!<0%!=:$$*R!,:$6%<-!L=!<0%!+$*:(!,:$6%<!<0%=!<0%!&:EE:$(!<*!&%:(%$!:=(!2043<4=E!20:1%!

3*$,!42!<*!+%!3*'=(-

7--)*/1'/+3%&dF&b+%N$-*/$+%&CDD_<&;?&CD?

/0%$%<*!(*%2!T4=6%&2<%4=!%<!:&!(%34=%2!3*'$!3*$,2!*3!+$%:6*'<!@*,1:=4%2!:=(!:2!2'@0!:&2*!3*'$!3*$,2!

*3!+$%:6*'<!2<$:<%E4%2-!/0%!3*'$!(433%$%=<!+$%:6!*'<!3*$,2!:$%!*$E:=4V%(!*=!%,%$E%=<!,:$6%<2!:=(!

%2<:+&420%(!,:$6%<2-!/0%!%,%$E%=<!,:$6%<2!:$%!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!42!R4<04=!

<0%,!42!:+&%!<*!R*$6!R4<0!:!=%R!3*$,!*3!<%@0=*&*EF\!2%$M4@%!*$!,:$6%<!21:@%!<0:<!42!:(:1<:+&%!<*!<0%!

1$*('@<!*$!2%$M4@%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!2%&&2-!/0%!%2<:+&420%(!,:$6%<2!:$%!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0:<!<0%F!:$%!

,:<'$%!,:$6%<2!2'@0!:2!<0%$%!:$%!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!@*,1%<%2!*=!E:4=4=E!,:$6%<!20:$%-!/F14@:&&F!R4&&!

<0%!4=('2<$F!E*!4=<*!:!214$:&!R0%$%!<0%!1$*('@<2!:$%!2%%=!:2!@*,,*(4<4%2!:=(!:2!2'@0!@*,,*(4<4%2!

!"!#$%&!;M

!"L:*7&#8&=+'/3 OU<"*1:*7&W'/:J'*

X"77"/1&+'&X%"1%/ =6:(+:*7&=6"<%

,21E1$4!,2P/0E=6!HE$2P12%

,21E1$4!H53F& X$==39

.=3$P

H/R3=P12$E& N3J12$2E

Page 82: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

:$%!2*&(!1$4,:$4&F!+:2%(!*=!<0%!1$4@%!*3!<0%!1$*('@<-

7--)*/1'/+3%&^F&b+%N$-*/$+%&$/&'-?&CDD_<&;?&KK?

T*$!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!,:$6%<2!<0%!3*$,2!*3!+$%:6*'<2!:$%!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!:2!<0%!<$'%!*$4E4=:&2\!

$%M*&'<4*=:$4%2\!<0%!R:M%!$:4(%$2!:=(!<0%!+4E!4,1$*M%,%=<2-

/0%!*$4E4=:&2!'2':&&F!20:1%2!:=(!(%M%&*1!:!=%R!,:$6%<!%-E-\!+F!4=M%=<4=E!=%R!2'1%$4*$!2%$M4@%2!

%-E-\!<0%F!E*!3$*,!:!$%(!*@%:=!<*!:!+&'%!*@%:=-!L=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!<0%!$%M*&'<4*=:$4%2!4=!:=!%2<:+&420%(!

,:$6%<!$%B4=M%=<!<0%4$!%=<%$1$42%!4=!:!R:F!<0:<!,:6%2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:+&%!<*!@*,1%<%!+F!

(433%$%=<4:<4=E!<0%!1$*('@<2!*$!2%$M4@%2-

/0%!R:M%!$4(%$2!R*$6!R4<0!<0%!:22',1<4*=!<0:<!<0%F!34=(!,:$6%<!21:@%!:=(!<0%!,:$6%<!21:@%!*M%$!

<4,%!R4&&!%Y1:=(-!!/0%!+4E!4,1$*M%$2!4=@&'(%!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!42!:+&%!<*!(%34=%!:!+'24=%22!,*(%&!:=(!

M:&'%!1$*1*24<4*=-!P46%R42%!42!4<!:+&%!<*!$%3:204*=!4<2!+'24=%22!,*(%&-

!"!#$%&!;K

!/0%&I/:7:*"$,U$=C&!3/E\!0A$F&\!$2P!P&C&43F!$!2&9!J$=>&E

R%G'$0+:'*"/:%,b&P&?12&!EA&!%=3/2P!=/4&0!

?3=!53JF&E1E132!12!$4=&$P6!&0E$R410A&P!J$=>&E@

K"G%&R:1%/,I1%=$E&!E3!355/F6!$!=$F1P46&VF$2P12%!J$=>&E!0F$5&

Y:7&?3</'G%/,,2E=3P/5&!$!53JF&4412%!2&9

C$4/&!F=3F301E132!3=./012&00!J3P&4!E3!

=&?$0A132!$!432%!&0E$R410A&P!J$=>&E@

B=39EA!QFF3=E/21E1&0

.=&$>3/E!-6F&

-$>12%!R6!0E3=J

8$%%$=P!E3!4&$P&=

DJ&=%&2E!I$=>&E0 D0E$R410A&P!I$=>&E0

Page 83: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&->& O*A$',0/%&4

/042!%=@&*2'$%!(%:&2!R4<0!<R*!(433%$%=<!:11$*:@0%2!<*!L/!2<$:<%EF!:=(!0*R!<0%!M:$4*'2!:11$*:@0%2!

,4E0<!2%%,!:&46%!:=(!R0%$%!<0%F!(433%$2!3$*,!*=%!:=*<0%$-

!"F#"! $%&!2&*6)6:&4!2:)6:&DC!B**)+6>%

9*22!)!5%4&&!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!:=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&\!:=(!4<!42!'1!<*!<0%!?LQ!:=(!<0%!

%Y%@'<4M%2!<*!(%34=%!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&-!/0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!=%%(2!<*!+%!%2<:+&420%(!3$*,!<0%!

M424*=!<0:<!0:2!+%%=!:$<4@'&:<%(!3*$!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!

/0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!(%34=%(!:2!:=!:11$*:@0!<*!R04@0!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!^<F14@:&&F!<0%!?LQ_!0:2!<*!

%=E:E%!:!1$*@%22!<0:<!'=@*M%$2!<0%!M424*=!:=(!3$*,!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!:(($%22!<0%!Z'%2<4*=2!*3!0*R!

<0%!$%:@0!:=!4=<%E$:<%(!1&:<3*$,!<0$*'E0!:!2<$:<%EF!^<F14@:&&F!L/!$%&:<%(_\!:=(!0*R!<*!:(($%22!<0%!

M:$4*'2!2<:6%0*&(%$2-!/0%$%<*!0:2!<0%!?LQ!<*!:(($%22!<0%!Z'%2<4*=2!*3!0*R!<*!'<4&4V%!<0%!3:@4&4<4%2\!

0*R ! <* !,:$6%< ! <0% ! L/ ! [ ! :=( ! @0:=E%2 ! ^*'<24(% ! <0% ! 34$,_\ ! 0*R ! <* ! 2@*'< ! 3*$ ! %,1&*F%%2 ! :=(!

*11*$<'=4<4%2\!:=(!0*R!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!E:4=!1$*34<!:=(!E$*R<0-!

aH%M%&*14=E!:=!L/B2:MMF!34$,!42!:!24,4&:$!%Y%$@42%-!T4$2<!F*'!0:M%!<*!(%34=%!:!M424*=-!

/0%=!F*'!:(($%22!0*R!F*'!R4&&!@$%:<%!:=!4=<%E$:<%(!1&:<3*$,!*3!2<$:<%EF\!1&:F%$2\!

3:@4&4<4%2\!,:$6%<4=E\!2@*'<4=E\!:=(!<$:4=4=E!<*!1$*34<!:=(!E$*R<0b

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!77_

L=!:((4<4*=!<*!<042!<0%=!9*22!)!5%4&&!(%34=%2!3*'$!E%=%$4@!:11$*:@0%2!<*!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&2-!/0%!34$2<!

*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!<4<&%(!(4M%$2434@:<4*=\!<0%!2%@*=(!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!<4<&%(!@**$(4=:<4*=\!<0%!<04$(!

*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!<4<&%(!$%1&4@:<4*=!:=(!<0%!3*'$<0!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!<4<&%(!'=434@:<4*=-

K2!2'@0!9*22!)!5%4&&!,:6%2!'2%!*3!:!,*(%&!<0:<!:$%!(%24E=%(!:$*'=(!<R*!:Y%2-!/0%!34$2<!:Y42!(%:&2!

R4<0!+'24=%22!1$*@%22!2<:=(:$(4V:<4*=!:=(!<0%!2%@*=(!:Y42!(%:&2!R4<0!+'24=%22!1$*@%22!4=<%E$:<4*=-!

T*$!+*<0!:Y%2!<0%$%!42!<0%!2%1:$:<4*=!*3!&*R!:=(!04E0-

Q=%!1*4=<!<0:<!9*22!)!5%4&&!%,10:24V%2!4=!<0%4$!R*$62!*=!L/!2<$:<%EF!^$%1$%2%=<%(!4=!<0%!+**6!L/B

2:MMF_!<0:<!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!:$%!*=&F!E**(!3*$!<R*!<04=E2-!/0%!34$2<!<04=E!42!<0:<!L/!42!E**(!

3*$!2<:=(:$(4V:<4*=!:=(!2%@*=(!L/!42!E**(!3*$!4=<%E$:<4*=-!/0%2%!<R*!422'%2!:$%!$%1$%2%=<%(!4=!<0%!

4&&'2<$:<4*=!+%&*R-

!"!#$%&!;'

Page 84: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

7--)*/1'/+3%&_F&P3**&Q&"$+--&CDD_<&;?&K]?

/0%!@**$(4=:<4*=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!+'24=%22!&4=%2!<0:<!%:@0!

*1%$:<%2!:2!'=4Z'%!+'24=%22%2!+'<!<*!E:4=!:!@*,1%<4<4M%!:(M:=<:E%!<0%=!<0%!+'24=%22!&4=%2!=%%(2!<*!

6=*R!*3!<0%!+'24=%22!<$:=2:@<4*=2!^20:$4=E!(:<:_-

/0%!(4M%$2434@:<4*=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!(4M%$2434@:<4*=!42!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0:<!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!0:2!(433%$%=<!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22!<0:<!0:M%!(433%$%=<!@'2<*,%$2!:=(!*R=2!(433%$%=<!%Y1%$<42%-!

9*22!)!5%4&&!%,10:24V%2!<0:<!<0%!6%F!3*@'2!*3!<0%!L/!1&:<3*$,!0:2!<*!+%!*=!(%&4M%$4=E!%@*=*,4%2!*3!

2@:&%!<0$*'E0!'24=E!<0%!2:,%!1&:<3*$,!<0$*'E0!<0%!+'24=%22d!0*R%M%$!4=!<0%!2:,%!<4,%!E4M%!<0%!&4=%2!

*3!+'24=%22!<0%!4=(%1%=(%=@%!:2!4<!=%%(2!<*!*1%$:<%!%33%@<4M%&F!R4<04=!<0%4$!@*=<%Y<2-

/0%!'=434@:<4*=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!:=!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!0:M%!<0%!2:,%!64=(!*3!

@'2<*,%$2\!:=(!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!+%%=!:+&%!<*!%2<:+&420!<0%!2:,%!64=(!*3!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:@$*22!

<0%!%=<%$1$42%!^%M%=!3$*,!@*'=<$F!<*!@*'=<$F_-!/0%!1$4,:$F!E*:&!3*$!<0%!L/B1&:<3*$,!42!<*!%=3*$@%!

2<:=(:$(!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:=(!20:$4=E!*3!(:<:!:@$*22!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

/0%!$%1&4@:<4*=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!42!@0:$:@<%$4V%(!+F!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!,:(%!'2%!*3!:=!

4=(%1%=(%=<!:11$*:@0!<*!+'24=%22!%2<:+&420,%=<-!/0%!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22!R4<04=!<0%!3$:,%R*$6!*3!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:$%!24,4&:$-!/0%!1$4,:$F!3*@'2!<0:<!9*22!)!5%4&&!%,10:24V%2!4=!3*$!<0%!L/B1&:<3*$,!3*$!

<042!1:$<4@'&:$!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&-

50%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!<0%!$*&%!*3!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&\!<0%=!4<!42!R*$<0!<*!@*=24(%$!<0:<!9*22!)!5%4&&!

@*=24(%$2!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!:2!<0%!1$4,:$F!<**&!3*$!2<$:<%E4@!(4$%@<4*=!3*$!+*<0!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!

2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!(4E4<4V%(!1&:<3*$,-!K2!2'@0!<0%F!@&:4,!<0:<!R0%=!<0%!M424*=!:=(!&:<%$!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!

!"!#$%&!;(

U33=P12$E132 c21?15$E132

N1C&=01?15$E132 b&F415$E132

839 T1%A

839

T1%A

./012&00!#=35&00!,2E&%=$E132

./012&00!#=35&00!HE$2P$=P1W$E132

Page 85: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

2<$:<%EF!0:2!+%%=!:$<4@'&:<%(!<0%=!<0%!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!@:=!+%!:!2*'$@%!3*$!:&4E=,%=<!+%<R%%=!<0%!

@*$1*$:<%!$%Z'4$%,%=<2!:=(!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!'2:E%!*3!L/-

SU$-$5/+%0&'%&3;$1'/+%0&432$-&+*&'&5344+/4$%/&/+&'&A'.&3,&23+%0&()*+%$**?&9#'/&5'% &

($ & 2')%/+%0 & 5#3+5$< & ()/ & +/* & %3/ & ;3**+(-$ & /3 & ()+-2 & ' & 2+0+/+O$2 & ;-'/,314 &A+/#3)/ &

5#33*+%0&'%&3;$1'/+%0&432$-?&I%2&5#33*+%0&'%&3;$1'/+%0&432$-&;'.*&3,,?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!>J_

9*22 ! ) !5%4&& ! :$E'%2 ! <0:< ! %=<%$1$42%2 ! :$% ! :+&% ! <* ! :@04%M% ! @*,1%<4<4M% ! :(M:=<:E% ! +F ! '24=E!

L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF!:2!2'@0!<0%F!(%2@$4+%!<0:<!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!0:M%!34$,!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!0*R!

<0%4$!L/B1&:<3*$,!:=(!L/B'2:E%!42!R*$64=E!*3<%=!(*!+%<<%$!4=!@*,1%<4<4*=!<0:=!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!(*=]<!

'=(%$2<:=(!<0%4$!L/B1&:<3*$,!*$!L/B'2:E%-

SP$-'/+=$ & /3 & '-- & 3/#$1*< & ,+14* &A+/# & ' & */13%0 & 2+0+/+O$2 &;-'/,314 &#'=$ &Ed &;$15$%/ &

01$'/$1 & '-+0%4$%/ & ($/A$$% & */1'/$0+5 & 5';'(+-+/+$* & /#$. & 5-'+4 & /#$. & %$$2 & '%2 & /#$&

5';'(+-+/+$* &#'=$ & +4;-$4$%/$2 &e &' &4$/1+5 &;3*+/+=$-. &5311$-'/$2 &A+/# &;13,+/'(+-+/.? &

9#$*$ & ,+14* & '-*3 & 1$;31/$2 & #+0#$1 & 3;$1'/+3%'- & $,,+5+$%5. & 6KE & ;$15$%/:< & 5)*/34$1&

+%/+4'5.& 6KK &;$15$%/:< &;132)5/ & -$'2$1*#+; & 6KR &;$15$%/:< &'%2&*/1'/$0+5 &'0+-+/. & 6C_&

;$15$%/:?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!>J_

/0%!24=E&%!+%2<!<04=E!<0:<!%=<%$1$42%2!<0:<!0:M%!@0*2%=!:=!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&!(*!42!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%2!

6=*R2!R0:<!R4&&!=*<!+%!@0:=E4=E!*M%$!<4,%\!:=(!<0%F!:$%!:+&%!<*!4(%=<43F!<0%!$%Z'4$%,%=<2!3*$!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!:=(!0*R!4<!20*'&(!@*=2<$'@<!4<2!(4E4<4V%(!1&:<3*$,!:=(!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2-

ST.&2$,+%+%0&A#'/&+*&*/'(-$&'(3)/&.3)1&,+14L*&()*+%$**&;135$**$*&'%2&5#33*+%0&'% &

3;$1'/+%0&432$-<&.3)&$*/'(-+*#&/#$&+%/$01'/+3%&'%2&*/'%2'12+O'/+3%&1$H)+1$4$%/*&,31&

'&2+0+/+O$2&;-'/,314?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!>"_

9*22!)!5%4&&!:$E'%2!<0:<!R0%=!<0%!+'24=%22!&%:(%$2!'=(%$2<:=(!<0%!L/!1&:<3*$,!<0%=!<0%F!:4(%!R4<0!

4==*M:<4=E ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42%]2 ! +'24=%22 !,*(%&- !/0%4$ !,%<0*( ! <* ! 4=M%2<4E:<% ! <042 ! 0:2 !+%%= ! <0$*'E0!

:=:&FV4=E!:!2%$4%2!*3!@:2%!2<'(4%2!3$*,!:@$*22!<0%!E&*+%-!9*22!)!5%4&&!0:2!E%=%$:&4V%(!<0%!34=(4=E2!

*3!<0%!@:2%2!<*!@*=@&'(%!<0:<!<0%4$!:11$*:@0!0:2!&%:(!<*!2'@@%22-

9*22!)!5%4&&!<0%=!(42@'22!<0%!1$*@%22!3*$!+'(E%<4=E!<0%!(4E4<4V%(!1&:<3*$,!+'<!,*$%!4,1*$<:=<&F!

!"!#$%&!;)

Page 86: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

0*R!<*!+'4&(!<0%!1&:<3*$,-!9*22!)!5%4&&!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!CO_!@&:4,2!<0:<!<0%!+'4&(4=E!*3!<0%!

%=<%$1$42%!(4E4<4V%(!1&:<3*$,!42!:!1$*@%22!^*$!$:<0%$!:!1$*E$:,_!<0:<!42!$:<0%$!$%2*'$@%!(%,:=(4=E-!

/0%!%=<%$1$42%!20*'&(!+%!3*@'24=E!*=!:!@0:=E%!1$*E$:,!<0:<!%,10:24V%2!<0%!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!$4E0<!

1&:@%2-

SY%-. & /#+* & /+4$< & .3)L1$ & /'N+%0 & .3)1 & #)%21$2*< & /#3)*'%2*< & 31 & /$% & /#3)*'%2* & 3, &

53--$'0)$* &A+/#&.3)&3%&.3)1& M3)1%$. & /3A'12&2+*5+;-+%$2< &A31-2@5-'**< &$%2@/3@$%2&

()*+%$**&;135$**$*?&"$&1$,$1&/3&/#+*&'2=$%/)1$&'*&.3)1&79&*'==.&M3)1%$.&!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!CO_

/0%!L/!`*'$=%F!0:2!3*'$!2<:E%2!:=(!<*!$%:@0!%:@0!2<:E%!<0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!0:2!<*!1'<!:=!%33*$<!4=<*!4<-!

/0%!%33*$<!@:=!+%!@*2<!3'&&!+*<0!4=!<4,%!:=(!,*=%F!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%]2!%Y%@'<4M%2!0:M%!<*!

4=M%2<!<0%4$!<$'2<!:=(!<0%4$!@*,,4<,%=<-!L=!:=F!*$E:=4V:<4*=!@0:=E%!%33*$<!42!<042!<0%!@:2%!:=(!<042!

0:2!<*!+%!:(($%22%(!+F!<0%!&%:(%$2041!:=(!,4((&%!,:=:E%$2!+%3*$%!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!+%E4=2!*=!<0%4$!

]`*'$=%F]-

/0%!34$2<!2<:E%!*=!<0%!`*'$=%F!42!<4<&%(!&*@:&4V4=E\!<0%!2%@*=(!2<:E%!42!<4<&%(!2<:=(:$(4V4=E\!<0%!<04$(!

2<:E%!42!<4<&%(!*1<4,4V4=E\!:=(!<0%!3*'$<0!2<:E%!42!<4<&%(!$%'24=E-

/0% ! 34$2< ! 2<:E% ! 42 ! @0:$:@<%$4V%( !+F ! <0:< ! <0% ! %=<%$1$42% !0:2 ! : ! &*< ! *3 !(433%$%=< ! 2*&'<4*=2 ! <0:< ! :$%!

*1<4,4V%(!3*$!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!&4=%!*3!+'24=%22-!L<!42!<F14@:&&F!<0%!0%:(!*3!<0%!&4=%!*3!+'24=%22!<0:<!0:M%!

(%@4(%(!R0:<!2F2<%,2!<0:<!0:M%!+%%=!4=<%$%2<4=E!:=(!'2:+&%!3*$!<0%!1:$<4@'&:$!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22-

/F14@:&&F!R4&&!<0%$%!+%!1$*+&%,2!R4<0!20:$4=E!(:<:!:@$*22!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-

S[35'-+O+%0F&b+14*&1';+2-.&013A&%$A&*.*/$4*&'*&/#$.&1$*;3%2&/3&5)*/34$1&2$4'%2*&

'%2&*$$N&/3&$*/'(-+*#&/#$+1&)%+H)$&='-)$&;13;3*+/+3%?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!OJ_

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&*/'%2'12+O+%0&*/'0$?&

/0%!Z'%2<4*=!*3!2<:=(:$(4V:<4*=!*3<%=!@*,%2!R0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!3:@%2!@*,1%<4<4*=!:=(!:2!2'@0!

=%%(2!<*!E*!<0$*'E0!<0%!@*2<!*3!*1%$:<4*=2!:=(!:2!2'@0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!<$F!<*!,4=4,4V%!<0%!@*2<!*3!

L/-!8<:=(:$(4V:<4*=!@:=!&%:(!<*!%@*=*,4%2!*3!2@:&%\!:=(!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!:+&%!<*!:@04%M%!:!@*2<!

%33%@<4M%!:11$*:@0-

!"!#$%&!;*

Page 87: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

SU/'%2'12+O+%0F & b+14* & 1$/1$'/ & ,134 & 1';+2 & ,+1$ & 1$*;3%*$* & '%2 & -33N & ,31 & /#$ & 79&

$,,+5+$%5+$*&/#13)0#&/$5#%3-30.&/#13)0#&*/'%2'12+O'/+3%&'%2&*#'1$2&+%,1'*/1)5/)1$?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!OJ_

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&3;/+4+O+%0&*/'0$?

/0%!*1<4,4V4=E!2<:E%!42!R0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:2!2'@0!2%%2!<0%!$%&:<4*=!:=(!+%=%34<2!*3!+'24=%22!

1$*@%22%2!:=(!L/B:&4E=,%=<-!/0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!+%!2<:$<4=E!R4<0!(%M%&*14=E!1:$<4@'&:$!+'24=%22!

1$*@%22%2!<0:<!:$%!(%24E=%(!3$*,!2@$:<@0!R4<0!L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF!4=!,4=(\!:=(!<0%2%!1$*@%22%2!

:$%!+'4&(!*=!<0%!@*=@%1<!*3!4=3*$,:<4*=!<%@0=*&*EF!@:=!+%!:=!%=:+&%$!*3!,*$%!%334@4%=<!:=(!%33%@<4M%!

1$*@%22%2-

SY;/+4+O+%0F&b+14*&+4;-$4$%/&2+*5+;-+%$2&$%/$1;1+*$&;135$**$*&'%2&*#'1$2&2'/'&'* &

;1$*51+($2&(.&/#$+1&3;$1'/+%0&432$-?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!O"_

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&-'*/&*/'0$&3,&/#$&79&e&3;$1'/+%0&;-'/,314&/+/-$2&1$)*+%0?

/0%!$%'24=E!*1%$:<4=E!1&:<3*$,!42!(%:&4=E!R4<0!<0:<!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!2%%2!:=!4(%:!4=!,:64=E!1$4=@41&%2!

3*$!0*R!<0%!3'<'$%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!:$%!<*!+%!(%24E=%(!:2!2'@0!<0%!+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!0:M%!

%,+%((%(!<%@0=*&*EF!4=<*!<0%,-!K2!2'@0!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!:4,2!:<!,:64=E!<0%!1$*@%22%2!'=4M%$2:&&F!

(%1&*F:+&%!4=!:=F!E4M%=!@*=<%Y<!4=!:=F!E4M%=!&4=%!*3!+'24=%22!*$!!,:$6%<-

SP$)*+%0F&b+14*&*/'1/*&/3&/#+%N&3,&/#$+1&()*+%$**&;135$**$*&'*&1$)*'(-$&534;3%$%/*&

/#'/&/#$.&5'%&5)*/34+O$&,31&%$A<&()/&1$-'/$2<&()*+%$**&3;;31/)%+/+$*?!

B!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!1-!O"_

T$-3A&'1$&/#$&,3)1&*/'0$*&+--)*/1'/$2?

!"!#$%&!;+

Page 88: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

7--)*/1'/+3%&EDF&P3**&Q&"$+--&CDD_<&;?&dE?

P*@:&!&4+%$<F!3*$!<0%!+'24=%22!'=4<2!42!:@@*$(4=E!<*!9*22!)!5%4&&!&*R%2<!4=!<0%!*1<4,4V4=E!2<:E%d!

0*R%M%$!R0%=!,*M4=E!<*R:$(!<0%!$%'24=E!2<:E%-!L<!42!=%%(&%22!<*!2:F!R0%=!<0%!&4=%2!*3!+'24=%22!42!

R4<04=!<0%!&*@:&4V4=E!2<:E%!0:2!<0%!04E0%2<!:,*'=<!*3!:'<*=*,F!:=(!3&%Y4+4&4<F!^9*22!)!5%4&&!7JJI\!

1-!GC_\!+'<!0*R!%33%@<4M%!42!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!43!<0%!(:<:!@:=]<!+%!20:$%(!*$!:!@*0%$%=<!M4%R!@:=]<!+%!

@*,14&%(!('%!<*!(433%$%=@%2!4=!%=<%$1$42%!2F2<%,2-!P46%R42%!42!4<!(%+:<:+&%!43!<0%$%!:$%!*=&F!3*'$!

2<:E%2!^*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&2_!<0:<!:=!%=<%$1$42%!@:=!,:6%!'2%!*3-!/0%!3*'$!*1%$:<4=E!,*(%&2!(*!:&&!0:M%!

:(M:=<:E%2!+'<!:&2*!(42:(M:=<:E%2!:=(!4<!42!'1!3*$!<0%!@*$1*$:<4*=!:=(!4<2!2<$:<%E4@!:11$*:@0!*=!<0%!

,:$6%<2!^(*,4=*_!4<!*1%$:<%2!<0:<!42!*3!4=<%$%2<-

9#+*& -$'2*&/3&/#$&+%/$01'/$2&*/1'/$0.&';;13'5#<& & /#'/&#'=$&*34$&3;;3*+%0&+2$'*&3%&A#'/&'%&79 &

*/1'/$0.&+*&'%2&#3A&+/&+*&2$;-3.$2&+%&'%&$%/$1;1+*$?

!"F#1! $%&!E;:&D)6:&4!2:)6:&DC!B**)+6>%

/0%! 4=<%E$:<%(!:11$*:@0!(%:&2!R4<0!<0:< ! <0%!3*@'2 !*3!:=!%=<%$1$42% !20*'&(=]< !+%!<* !2%1:$:<%! <0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF! 4=<*!2%M%$:& !(433%$%=< ! 3*$,2 !*3 !%Y1&4@4< !1&:=2 !:=(! 4(%:2- !/042 !,%:=2! <0:< ! <0%!

@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!4=@&'(%!<0%!'2:E%!*3!L/-!/0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0!0:2!+%%=!+:2%(!

*=!<0%!+**6!aT$'4<4*=b!+F!?0$42!#*<<2-!/0%!+**6!42!R$4<<%=!:2!=*M%&\!:=(!?0$42!#*<<2!0:M%!:((%(!:!

!"!#$%&!;:

835$41W12% b&/012%QFE1J1W12%HE$2P$=P1W12% Y1=J91P&!./012&00G%141E6

Z&'(&S:/3,?!&E&Y017%+

'*d

KMMd

)+d

;)d

':d

L'd

'd

K)*d

835$446!3FE1J$4R/012&00!034/E1320

D2E&=F=10&91P&E&5A2343%60E$2P$=P0

b&/0$R4&3F&=$E12%F4$E?3=J HE=$E&%15!$%141E6!

?=3J!R/012&00!J3P/4&0

Page 89: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

3%R!1:E%2!4=!<0%!%=(!*3!%:@0!@0:1<%$!(%<:4&4=E!R4<0!R0:<!@:=!+%!&%:$=%(!3$*,!%:@0!*3!<0%!@0:1<%$2-!L!

R$*<%!:!+&*E!1*2<!^8`*%&4=!7J"J_!_!(%:&4=E!R4<0!:!$%M4%R!*3!<0%!+**6\!L!0:M%!@0*2%=!<*!,:6%!'2%!*3!:!

,*(434%(!%(4<4*=!*3!<0%!+&*E!1*2<!<*!(%:&!R4<0!<0%!4=<%E$:<%(!2<$:<%EF!:11$*:@0-

&->B4B-& !6%&=+/"+%78&@/+:A0$"+:'*&./'A%,,

#*<<2!:$E'%!<0:<!('$4=E!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!1$*@%22!*3!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!<0%$%!:$%!".!2<%12!:=(!422'%2!<0:<!

=%%(2!<*!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!";_m

O_ D*2<!$*+'2<!2<$:<%E4%2!%,10:24V%!04E0!M:&'%!*=!4<2!%=M4$*=,%=<:&!3%%(+:@6-

G_ D:6%!2'$%!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!,%:=4=E3'&!<*!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF-

I_ H42<4=E'420!+%<R%%=!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!&%M%&!:=(!<0%!*1%$:<4*=:&!&%M%&!<04=64=E-

"J_H424=<%$%2<!20*'&(!=%M%$!+%!'=(%$2<**(!:2!<$'2<-

/0%!3*&&*R4=E!34M%!2<:<%,%=<2!:$%!+:2%(!*=!#*<<2]2!+**6!a3$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!7._m

""_ K!(*@',%=<!<0:<!@*=<:4=2!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!=*<!<0%!2<$:<%EF-

"7_ /0%! &:=E':E%!'2%(! <* !:$<4@'&:<% !: !2<$:<%EF!20*R2! <0%!,4=(2%<!*3 !R04@0! <0%!1%$2*=!R0*!

:$<4@'&:<%(!,:(%!'2%!*3!^*$!0:2_-

";_ L3!<0%!0*2<!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^%=<%$1$42%_!0:2!:=!L/!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!4<!42!=%@%22:$F!<*!4=@&'(%!:&&!*3!

<0%!L=3*$,:<4*=!/%@0=*&*EF!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^%=<%$1$42%_!,:6%2!'2%!*3-

">_ L< ! 42 !:=! 4,1%$:<4M% ! <0:< ! <0% ! L/!2<$:<%EF!0:2 ! <* !2',,:$4V%(! 4= !*=%!,%:=4=E3'& !2%=<%=@%d!

*<0%$R42%!<0%!2<$:<%EF!=%%(2!<*!+%!$%R*$6%(-

"._ L3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^%=<%$1$42%_!0:2!:=!L/!$*:(,:1!<0%=!4<!42!4,1%$:<4M%!<0:<!<0%!($4M%$!*3!<0%!

$*:(,:1!42=]<!<0%!2'11&4%$2!+'<!<0%!<:@<4@:&!E*:&2!:=(!2<$:<%E4%2!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=-!

"C_ L3!<0%!?LQ!$'=2!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!:=!%Y<%$=:&!+'24=%22!^&**2%&F!@*'1&%(!<*!<0%!%=<%$1$42%_!

<0%=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R4&&!<0$%:<!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!:=!%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<F-

/0%!3*&&*R4=E!<0$%%!2<:<%,%=<2!:$%!+:2%(!*=!#*<<2]2!+**6!a3$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!.>_m

""_ 80:1%!<0%!2<$:<%EF!+F!%Y1&*$4=E!R0F!<0%!@*,1:=F!42=]<!:&$%:(F!3'&34&&4=E!4<2!1$*,42%-

"7_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!M:&4(:<%!R0*!<0%!1$*,42%!42!a<:&64=E!:+*'<b-

";_ N'4&(!<0%!2<$:<%EF!*=!:!,*(%&!<0:<!%,10:24V%!<0%!@'2<*,%$!:=(!2'11&4%$!1%$21%@<4M%!:=(!

=%M%$!<0%!aN'24=%22!:=(!L/b!1%$21%@<4M%-!/0%!*M%$!:&&!$%:2*=!3*$!<042!42!<0:<!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!

:=(!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!42!*=%!:=(!<0%!2:,%-

!"!#$%&!;;

Page 90: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

/0%!3*&&*R4=E!3*'$!2<:<%,%=<2!:$%!+:2%(!*=!#*<<2]2!a3$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!7J>_m

">_ L3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!,:=:E%2!4<2!4=M%2<,%=<2!R%&&!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!,*2<!:11$*1$4:<%!

<%@0=*&*EF!R4&&!+%!2%&%@<%(-

"._ /0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!20*'&(!:224E=!:=!%Y%@'<4M%!:@@*'=<:+4&4<F!3*$!,:Y4,4V4=E!<0%!<*<:&!M:&'%!

<0%!@*,1:=F!@$%:<%2!+F!4<2!4=<%$=:&!4=M%2<,%=<2!4=!@0:=E%-

/0%$%3*$%!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!L/!:=(!<0%!+'24=%22!42!*=%!:=(!<0%!2:,%!<04=E\!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!@:=]<!

:!2%1:$:<4*=!*3!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!=*<!%Y42<!R4<0!:=F!,%:=4=E-!P46%R42%!@:=!4<!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!<0%!

4=<%E$:<%( ! 2<$:<%EF ! :11$*:@0 ! (%:&2 ! R4<0 ! <0% ! %,+*(4,%=< ! *3 ! <0% ! 2<$:<%EF ! :=( ! =*< ! (%M%&*14=E!

(*@',%=<2!@*=<:4=4=E!M:$4*'2!422'%2!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF-!L=!:((4<4*=!4<!@:=!+%!@*=@&'(%(!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!

@:=]< !+% !(%:&4=E !R4<0 ! aL/!:=( ! <0% !N'24=%22b ! :=( ! 4< ! 0:2 ! <* ! 4=@&'(% !0*R! 4< !(%:&2 !R4<0 ! <0% !%=(!

@'2<*,%$2!R0*!+'F2!<0%!1$*('@<2!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!,:='3:@<'$%-! !P46%R42%!(*%2!<0%!#*<<2!%,10:24V%!

<0:<!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!=%%(2!<*!<:6%!@0:$E%-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&I-+0%4$%/&;#'*$?

&->B4B4& !6%&@$:7*3%*+&.6",%

#*<<2!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%$%!=%%(!<*!+%!:=!:&4E=,%=<!+%<R%%=!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!:=(!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!

:=(!3*$!<0:<!0%!2<:<%(!2%M%=<%%=!2<:<%,%=<2!<0:<!=%%(2!<*!+%!:(($%22%(m

"_ i%M%$!'=(%$!%2<4,:<%!<0%!1:@%!^*3!@0:=E%_!*3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

7_ /0%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!@*,1:<4+&%!<0:<!2<:6%0*&(%$2!@0:=E%!<0%4$!,4=(2-

;_ N'4&(!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!*=!:!1$*,42%!:=(!=*<!*=!:4,2-

>_ L3!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!42!*$E:=4V%(!:$*'=(!2*&M4=E!:!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*+&%,\!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<0:<!

<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!:&2*!2*&M%2!<0%!1$*+&%,-

._ K$%!<0%!1%$2*=2!R0*!(%M%&*12!:=(!:$<4@'&:<%2!<0%!2<$:<%EF!^2<$:<%E42<2_!E:,%!1&:F%$2X!

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!

>>_m

C_ L3!<0%!+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!1%$@%4M%2!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!:=!%Y<%$=:&!2'11&4%$!

<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:=(!<0%!?LQ!@:=]<!4=3&'%=@%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF-

O_ H433%$%=<!64=(2!*3!2<$:<%E4%2!=%%(2!(433%$%=<!<F1%2!*3!2<$:<%E42<2-

G_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!6=*R!042!$%&:<4M%!2<$%=E<02!:=(!R%:6=%22%2!R0%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!:=:&F242!:=(!

2F=<0%242-!L=!:!2<$:<%EF!4<!42!<0%!!2F=<0%242!1:$<!<0:<!42!<0%!,*2<!4,1*$<:=<!<04=E!<*!0:=(&%-

!"!#$%&!;L

Page 91: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

I_ L3!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!*$!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^%=<%$1$42%_!0:M%!422'%2!R4<0!4(%=<43F4=E!R0:<!M:&'%!<0%!

L/!+$4=E2!<*!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^%=<%$1$42%_!%Y1%$4%=@%!

R4(%$!+'24=%22!$%&:<%(!1$*+&%,2-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!

C"_m

"J_K!@*$1*$:<% ! 2<$:<%EF ! <0:< ! 42 ! 3*@'2%( !*= !%Y1&*4<4=E ! L/! 42 ! 3*@'2%( !*= !M:&'%\ !,*=%F ! :=(!

*$E:=4V:<4*=-!/0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!=*<!3*@'24=E!*=!<%@0=*&*EF-

""_ /0%!(4$%@<*$2!*3!:!@*,1:=F!42!:=!4=(%1%=(%=<!@*,,'=4<F!<0:<!:((2!M:&'%!<*!<0%!@*,1:=F-!

"7_U:&'%!42!(%34=%(!:2!:!1*$<3*&4*!*3!,%:2'$%2!:=(!<F1%2-

";_ /0%!a+'24=%22!24(%b!*3!:=!*$E:=4V:<4*=!R4&&!4=!,:=F!@:2%2!:22',%!<0%!,*=%F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!

42!21%=(4=E!*=!L/!42!:!$:=(*,!=',+%$-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-"7>_m

">_ A:@0!2<:6%0*&(%$!4=!:!2<$:<%EF!0:2!2*,%<04=E!(42<4=@<4M%!<*!*33%$-

"._ P:=E':E%!:=(!@*,,'=4@:<4*=2!:$%!@$4<4@:&!<*!:!2<$:<%EF]2!2'@@%22-

"C_ /0%!@*=@%1<!*3!<0%*$%<4@:&\!1$:@<4@:&!:=(!:+2<$:@<4*=!(%1%=(2!*=!<0%!:'(4%=@%-!/0%!2<$:<%EF!

20*'&(!+%!:$<4@'&:<%(!:=(!:&4E=%(!<*!<0%!:'(4%=@%-

"O_ #%*1&%!4=!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!(%M%&*12!<0%!1$*`%@<2!$:<0%$!34=%!+'<!<0%F!<%=(!=*<!<*!,:6%!<0%!,*2<!

*'<!*3!<0%!1$*`%@<2!R0%=!<0%!1$*`%@<2!0:M%!+%%=!4,1&%,%=<%(-

?*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!0:2!:!<%=(%=@F!<*!@0:=E%!$:<0%$!*3<%=\!:=(!<*!:M*4(!:!E:1!+%<R%%=!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!

:=(!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!=%%(2!<*!6%%1!4=3*$,%(!*=!<0%!@0:=E%2!:=(!@*1%!R4<0!

@0:=E%2-!L3!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!R*$62!R4<0!2*&M4=E!:!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*+&%,!<0%=!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!=%%(2!

<*!:(($%22!<042!1:$<4@'&:$!1$*+&%,!:2!R%&&\!R0%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!+'24=%22!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!0:2!<*!

3*@'2!*=!+%4=E!:!1:$<!*3!<0%!+'24=%22!:=(!=*<!:=!%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<Fd!43!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!42!M4%R%(!:2!:=!

%Y<%$=:&!%=<4<F!<0%=!4<!42!&46%&F!<0:<!?LQ!@:=]<!4=3&'%=@%!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF\!:=(!<0%!?LQ!R4&&!

<0%$%3*$%!+%@*,%!:=!'=(%$(*E-

50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!2<$:<%EF!4=!:=!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!4<!R4&&!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!<0$*'E0!

1$*`%@<2d !,*2< ! *$E:=4V:<4*=2 ! *3<%= ! <%=( ! <* ! +% ! $:<0%$ ! E**( ! :< ! :$<4@'&:<4=E ! +'24=%22 ! @:2%2 ! :=(!

(%M%&*14=E!<0%!1$*`%@<2d!0*R%M%$!R0%=!,:64=E!'2%!*3!<0%!1$*`%@<2!<0%=!,*2<!*$E:=4V:<4*=2!&*2%2-

P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!?LQ!+%!:R:$%!*3!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!(433%$%=<!3*$,2!*3!2<:6%0*&(%$2!:=(!%:@0!*3!<0%,!

!"!#$%&!LM

Page 92: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

,4E0<!0:M%!<0%4$!*R=!:E%=(:!:=(!<0%4$!*R=!+:@6E$*'=(-!/0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!<0%!?LQ!@'2<*,4V%!<0%!L/!

2<$:<%EF ! 3*$ ! %:@0 !*3 ! <0% ! 2<:6%0*&(%$2- !50%= !R*$64=E !R4<0 !,%:2'$4=E ! <0% ! L/! 2<$:<%EF ! :=( ! <0%!

+'24=%22!1$*@%22%2!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!M:$4*'2!<F1%2!*3!,%:2'$%,%=<-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&='-)$&'22+%0&;#'*$?

&->B4B9& C"$0%&@11:*7

#*<<2!:$E'%2!<0:<!M:&'%!=%%(2!<*!+%!M424+&%!3*$!<0%!@*$1*$:<%!1:$<!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%-!/0%!%Y%@'<4M%2!

=%%(!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!0*R!L/!:((2!M:&'%!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!OJ_m

"_ D:=F!$%&:<4*=20412!:$%!+:2%(!*=!1%$@%1<4*=2!:=(!04E0!1$*34&%!@0:$:@<%$42<4@2-

7_ /0%!+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!%Y1%@<2!2%$M4@%!:=(!<0%$%3*$%!20*'&(!2%$M4@%!&%M%&2!

+%<R%%=!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<!:2!:!2'11&4%$!:=(!<0%!@'2<*,%$2!+%!=%E*<4:<%(!:=(!4=@*$1*$:<%(!

4=<*!<0%!2<$:<%EF-

;_ /0%!@*$1*$:<%!2<$:<%EF!42!:+*'<!=',+%$2-!/0%!3*@'2!*3!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!+%!<0%!2:,%-

>_ Q3<%=!<0%$%!42!:!E:1!+%<R%%=!<0*2%!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!R0*!:((2!M:&'%!:=(!<0*2%!R0*!21%=(2!

<0%!M:&'%-!L2!<0:<!:&2*!<0%!@:2%!3*$!<0%!L/!2<$:<%EFX

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-!

".I_m

._ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!,:6%!'2%!*3!@*&*$!@*(4=E!<*!(42<4=E'420!<0%!+'24=%22!4=M%2<,%=<2!3$*,!<0%!

L/!4=M%2<,%=<2-

C_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!1$*M%!<0:<!&**64=E!:=(!,:=:E4=E!<0%!L/!4=M%2<,%=<!:2!2*,%<04=E!:1:$<!3$*,!

<0%!+'24=%22!4=M%2<,%=<!42=]<!2'334@4%=<-

O_ /0% ! ?LQ ! 20*'&( ! 20*R ! <0:< ! <0% ! 2<$:<%E4@ ! 1$*`%@<2 ! :$%=]< ! =%@%22:$F ! <0*2% ! 1$*`%@<2 ! <0:<!

:EE$%E:<%!<0%!04E0%2<!9QL-

G_ AY1&*$%$!<0%!@:'2%!:=(!%33%@<!R4<0!*3!L/!4=M%2<,%=<2!:=(!+'24=%22!4=M%2<,%=<2-

/0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!%2<:+&4204=E!$%&:<4*=20412!:=(!0%!*$!20%!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!

+$%:64=E!(*R=!<0%!2<%$%*<F1%2!<0%!$%2<!*3!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!<%:,!,4E0<!0:M%!$%E:$(4=E!L/\!:=(!&46%R42%!

20*'&(!<0%!?LQ!R*$64=E!R4<0!+$%:64=E!(*R=!042!*$!0%$!*R=!2<%$%*<F1%2!*3!<0%!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!:=(!

<0%4$!R*$6B:$%:2-!/*!@*,,'=4@:<%!4=!:!2%=24+&%!R:F!R4<0!<0%!*<0%$!%Y%@'<4M%2!<0%=!<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!

+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!<0%!4(%=<43F4=E!@*2<2!4=M%2<%(!4=!+'24=%22!:=(!L/!4(%=<43F!:=F!@*$$%&:<4*=!43!4<!42!

!"!#$%&!LK

Page 93: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

1*224+&%-!P46%R42%!20*'&(!<0%!@:'2%!:=(!%33%@<!+%!%Y1&*$%(!43!4<!42!1*224+&%-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&5#'%0$&4'%'0$4$%/&;#'*$?

&->B4B;& !6%&)6"*7%&5"*"7%3%*+&.6",%

#*<<2!:$E'%2!<0:<!R0%=!:!2<$:<%EF!0:2!+%%=!:$<4@'&:<%(!<0%=!@0:=E%2!=%%(2!<*!+%!4,1&%,%=<%(!2*!<0%!

%=<%$1$42% ! 42 !:&4E=%(!R4<0 ! <0% !2<$:<%EF- !/0% !%,1&*F%%2 !R4&& !%M%=<':&&F !+% ! <0% !2<:6%0*&(%$2 ! <0:<!

(%<%$,4=%2!43!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!R4&&!+%@*,%!:!2'@@%22!^#*<<2!7JJG\!1-O7_m

"_ 50%=!@0:=E%2!*@@'$!^:2!4<!R4&&!R4<0!<0%!4,1&%,%=<:<4*=!*3!:!=%R!2<$:<%EF_!<0%=!<0%!@0:=E%!

1$*@%22!R4&&!:&2*!4,1:@<!<0%!%,1&*F%%2!^:=(!,:=:E%$2_!1%$2*=:&!&43%-

7_ i',+%$2!42!:!(421:224*=:<%!R:F!<*!:=:&FV%!<0%!2<$:<%E4@!&:=(2@:1%!R4<0-!L<!20*'&(!4=@&'(%!

R0:<!<0%!?LQ!:=(!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!6=*R2!:=(!(*%2=]<!6=*R-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-G"_m

;_ /0%!L/!2<$:<%EF!0:2!<*!+%!:$<4@'&:<%(!4=!:=!4<%$:<4M%!:11$*:@0-

>_ P**6!:<!<0%!=',+%$2!4=!<0%!+'(E%<!:=(!%M:&':<%!43!<0%F!21%:6!3*$!<0%,2%&M%2-

._ /0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!%Y1&*$%!0*R!<0%!@*,1:=F!+'(E%<2\!,:=:E%2\!:=(!,%:2'$%2!+'24=%22!@0:=E%!

<0:<!@*,%2!<0$*'E0!L/!$%&:<%(!1$*`%@<2-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-"O._m

C_ /0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!@:'2%!*<0%$!1%*1&%!<*!@0:=E%-

O_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!6=*R!R0:<!0%!R*'&(!(4%!4=!<0%!(4<@0!3*$-

G_ /0%!+'24=%22!24(%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!*3<%=!%Y1%$4%=@%!<0%!L/!24(%!*3!<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!:2!

+%4=E!a1$*,424=E!:!&*<!:=(!=%M%$!6%%12!<0%!1$*,42%2!:=(!4<!(*%2=]<!@:$%!:+*'<!<0%!+'24=%22!

24(%b-

I_ "JJj!:&4E=,%=<!:,*=E!2<$:<%E4%2!@:=!+%!(:=E%$*'2!:=(!4<!*@@'$2!$:$%&F!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%E4%2!

:$%!"JJj!:&4E=%(-

"J_ /0%!3'<'$%!$*&%!*3!<0%!?LQ!42!=*<!:22'$%(-

""_ /0%!?LQ!0:2!<*!'=(%$2<:=(!<0:<!<0%$%!:$%!@*,1%<%=@4%2!%&2%!R0%$%!4=!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0:<!42!4=!

('1&4@:<4*=!*3!<0%!<0*2%!@*,1%<%=@4%2!<0:<!:$%!4=!<0%!L/!(%1:$<,%=<-

!"!#$%&!L'

Page 94: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

"7_ /0%!=%R!2<$:<%EF!3*$!L/!(%,:=(2!:!=%R!*1%$:<4*=!,*(%&-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-"GJ_m

";_ 8<$:<%E42<2!(%:&!*=&F!4=!2'@@%22!:=(!2*!20*'&(!<0%!?LQ-

">_ L<!@:=!+%!0:$(!3*$!<0%!?LQ!:=(!<0%!?*0%$%=@F!K$@04<%@<!<*!@0:&&%=E%!<0%!*$<0*(*Y4%2!*3!<0%!

*$E:=4V:<4*=-

"._ L3!<0%!?LQ!R4&&!=*<!@$*22!<0%!+$4(E%!<0%=!&%<!2*,%*=%!%&2%!<:6%!@:$%!*3!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-"G7_m

"C_ P%:(4=E!2<$:<%EF!@:=!+%!:!&*=%&F!`*+-

"O_ /0%!*M%$!:&&!3*@'2!*3!:!2<$:<%EF!42!:+*'<!R4==4=E-! !L3!<0%!?LQ!42!=*<!@*,,4<<%(!"JJj!<*!

:@04%M4=E!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<0%=!4<!42!=*<!$%:&&F!:!2<$:<%EF-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-"I"_m

"G_ 8%<!(*R=!F*'$!#$*,42%\!#$4=@41&%2!:=(!/:@<4@2!3*$!<0%!6%F!2<:6%0*&(%$2!<*!%Y1&*$%!:=(!$:<43F-

"I_ /0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2 !R:=< ! <* !2%% ! <0% !@*,+4=:<4*=!*3 ! 4(%:2 ! 4= ! $%&:<4*= ! <* ! <0% !*$E:=4V:<4*=:&!

2F2<%,-

7J_ /0% ! 2<$:<%EF ! @:= ! &**6 ! &46% ! <0% !*+M4*'2 !+'< ! 4< ! 42 ! 4,1*$<:=< ! <0:< ! <0% !?LQ !*$ !?*0%$%=@F!

K$@04<%@<!%,10:24V%!<0:<!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42=]<!:11&4%(-!

7"_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!<%2<!<0%!+%2<!1$:@<4@%!*3!<0%!4=('2<$F-

77_ /0%!2<$:<%EF!42!R0:<!<0%!?LQ!*$!(*%2!^(%!3:@<*!2<$:<%EF_-

/0%$%!42!*=&F!*=%!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!,%:=2!2*,%<04=E!:=(!<0:<!42!R0:<!<0%!?LQ!(*%2!^%,+*(4,%=<!*3!

2<$:<%EF_-!#*<<2!42!*3!<0%!*14=4*=!<0:<!4<!42!$:$%!<0:<!:=F!64=(!*$!:=F!<F1%!*3!2<$:<%EF!@:=!:@04%M%!

"JJj!:&4E=,%=<-!/0%!?LQ!20*'&(!1'<!21%@4:&!:<<%=<4*=!<*!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%\!:=(!<0:<!

,%:=2!<0:<!042!$*&%!,4E0<!@0:=E%!3$*,!+%4=E!<0%!L/!,:=:E%$!<*!+%@*,4=E!:=(!4=M%2<,%=<!,:=:E%$\!

#*<<2!2'EE%2<2!<0%!<4<&%!?04%3!L=<%$=:&!L=M%2<,%=<2!Q334@%$-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&+4;-$4$%/'/+3%&;#'*$?

!"!#$%&!L(

Page 95: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

&->B4B>& !6%&?3<$%3%*+"+:'*&.6",%

#*<<2!:$E'%2!<0:<!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!=%%(2!+%!!@*=M4=@%(!:=(!4=M%2<!<0%4$!<$'2<!4=<*!<0%!2<$:<%EF!^#*<<2!

7JJG\!1-IC_m

"_ h2%!<0%!a#$*,42%\!#$4=@41&%2!:=(!/:@<4@2b!3$:,%R*$6!R04&%!<0%!2<$:<%EF!42!4=!<0%!:$<4@'&:<4*=!

1$*@%22!:=(!R0%=!4<!42!:+*'<!<*!+%@*,%!%Y%@'<%(-

7_ /0%!a#$*,42%!:=(!#$4=@41&%2!:$%!<0%!2<:+4&%!@*$%!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF-!/:@<4@2!:$%!,*$%!3&'%=<!*$!

:(:1<:+&%!R0%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!%M%=<2-

;_ K(($%22!%:@0!*3!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!4=(4M4(':&&F!^1$%3%$:+&%!1%$2*=:&&F_!+%3*$%!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2!

:$%!:(($%22%(!:2!:!E$*'1-

>_ P%:(!<0%!%Y%@'<4*=!*3!:!2<$:<%EF!(*=]<!,:=:E%!4<-

._ 50%=!4<!@*,%2!<*!<0%!4=M%2<4E:<4*=!*3!L/!4=M%2<,%=<2!<0%=!2<:$<!R4<0!4(%=<43F4=E!M:&'%!:=(!

<0%=!R*$6!+:@6R:$(2-!50%=!'24=E!:!21$%:(20%%<!<0%=!<0%!3*@'2!20*'&(!+%!*=!@*&',=2!:=(!

=*<!*=!$*R2-!/042!20*'&(!0%&1!@$%:<%!<0%!*M%$M4%R!<0:<!42!=%%(%(!^:@@*$(4=E!<*!#*<<2_-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-"J;_m

C_ /0%!2<$:<%E42<!^?LQ_!42!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF-

O_ Q$E:=4V%!<0%!@*&&:+*$:<4*=!:$*'=(!*=%!2%<!*3!=',+%$2!:=(!2<$:<%E4@!<0%,%2d!0*R%M%$!%:@0!

1%$2*=!R0*!R*$62!R4<0!<0%!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!+%!E4M%=!<0%!*11*$<'=4<F!<*!0:M%!:=!4=3&'%=@%!*=!

<0:<!1:$<!*3!<0%!2<$:<%EF!<0:<!<0%F!R*$6!R4<0-

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-""._m

G_ K!$%&:<4*=2041!42!*R=%(!+F!<R*!1%*1&%-

I_ AY1%$4,%=<4=E!R4<0!<0%!=',+%$2!^4=!<0%!+'(E%<_!@:=!'=@*M%$!:!=%R!'=(%$2<:=(4=E!*3!<0%!

1$*+&%,-

"J_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!,:6%!'2%!*3!:!+*<<*,!'1!M:&'%!1*$<3*&4*-

""_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!%M:&':<%!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<!2<$:<%EF!<*!21:$6&%!:!(42@'224*=!*=!R0:<!1$4*$4<4%2!

<0%!*$E:=4V:<4*=!^%=<%$1$42%_!0:2-

"7_ /0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!3*@'24=E !*=!<0%!%Y1*24=E! <0%!2@%=:$4*2 !3*$!R0:< !R4&& !0:11%=!43 ! <0%!

4=M%2<,%=<!2<$:<%EF!42!@0:=E%(-

!"!#$%&!L)

Page 96: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

/042!2%@<4*=!42!+:2%(!*=!<0%!(%34=4<4*=2!<0:<!#*<<2!(%:&2!R4<0!4=!042!R*$6!aT$'L/4*=b!^#*<<2!7JJG\!

1-";>_m

";_ 8<$:<%EF!42!%22%=<4:&!:+*'<!*1<4*=2!:=(!*11*$<'=4<4%2!:=(!4<!42!=*<!:+*'<!+%4=E!$4E0<-

">_ /:6%!<0%!&%22*=2!3*$!R0:<!(4(=]<!R*$6!:2!%Y1%@<%(-

"._ /0%!$%&:<4*=20412!<0:<!1%*1&%!+'4&(2!:$%!4=3&'%=@%(!*3!1$%M4*'2!%M%=<2!:=(!$%&:<4*=20412-

"C_ P**6!3*$!<0%!2'+<&%<4%2!4=!<0%!$%21*=2%2!*3!<0%!2<:6%0*&(%$2-

/0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!R*$64=E!R4<0!(433%$%=<!M4%R2!*=!0*R!L/!2<$:<%EF!20*'&(!+%!(%:&<!R4<0!4=!$%&:<4*=!

<*!@0:=E%2!4=!<0%!R:F!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!4=M%2<2!4=-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!L/!<0%=!<0%!,*2<!4,1*$<:=<!<04=E!

<0%!?LQ!20*'&(!+%!<04=64=E!*3!42!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!042!:@<4*=2!^:2!%:$&4%$!,%=<4*=%(!<0%=!<042!

,%:=2!<0%!%,+*(4,%=<!*3!2<$:<%EF_-!50%=!R*$64=E!R4<0!2%M%$:&!(433%$%=<!1%$2*=2!4=!<0%!%Y%@'<4M%!

+$:=@0!*3!<0%!%=<%$1$42%!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<0:<!<0%!?LQ!'=(%$2<:=(2!<0:<!<0%!$%&:<4*=20412!:$%!

*R=%(!+F!<R*!1%*1&%!:=(!@:=]<!+%!@*=<$*&&%(!+F!<04$(!1:$<4%2-

L=!$%&:<4*=!<*!4=M%2<4E:<4=E!<0%!M:&'%!*3!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2!<0%=!4<!42!:!=%@%224<F!<*!R*$6!R4<0!:!+*<<*,!

'1!M:&'%!1*$<3*&4*!:=(!%:@0!*3!<0%!4=M%2<,%=<2!=%%(2!<*!+%!4=M%2<4E:<%(-

9#+*&-$'2*&/3&/#$&2+*5)**+3%&3,&79&*/1'/$0.?

!"!#$%&!L*

Page 97: Integrated Governance: A Way to Achieve Competitive Advantage

!"#$%&'#$()

*+,$&"'"-$

!"#$%"&'"!()*+,+"-'./+&*&*,+"!0,$1&$2+3

.$#$&)/0$112"%)3$4"255$")67+$02"!"#$$%&'()'!"#$%$&'()%'#*+$'+,'"-'(*+',-&&%*)".'/-&0-1*$'('2(0)%&'#3'4,1%*,%'1*'5*3#&6()1#*'7%,8*#"#$.9':;<-01*%00'()')8%'57'=*1>%&01).'#3'?#/%*8($%*@