insikt - data driven nyc (27)
DESCRIPTION
Insikt Founder and CEO James Gutierrez presented at May's edition of Data Driven, which focused on p2p lending.TRANSCRIPT
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
Insikt: Alternative Credit!
1
Data Driven Conference!
May 20, 2014!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
ALTERNATIVE CREDIT: WHY NOW?!
BACKGROUND!
2
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
NEW REGULATIONS HAVE CHANGED LENDING IN THE U.S. FOR GOOD!
3
BANKS
Dodd Frank1
2010 + 5 = 2015
Basel III 2018 + 5 = 2023
Basel II/II.5 2012 + 5 = 2017
Card Act 2009 + 5 = 2014
Revises Regulatory Capital Definition Capital requirements
+ Liquidity requirements + Stress testing
= Lower Risk Appetite and Balance Sheet Reduction
Addresses Accountability, Responsibility & Disclosure
Interest rate hike limitation + Longer notification period + Late fee limitation
= Lending Decrease
Addresses Wall Street Reform & Consumer Protection
Asset level data disclosure + Capital requirements + Risk retention requirements + Proprietary trading prohibition + Ring fencing + Removes credit rating reliance
= Lower Risk Appetite and Balance Sheet Reduction Addresses Credit, Operational,
& Market Risk Risk weighting categories
+ Implements VAR + Capital charges + Trading book limitations
= Lower Risk Appetite and Balance Sheet Reduction
“Elevated supervisory stringency impacts total loans/loan capacity for 20 quarters after the onset of the tighter supervisory standards”
—SBA Office of Advocacy
1 Conflicts with Basel III requirements
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
REVOLVING CREDIT AVAILABILITY HAS DECLINED SIGNIFICANTLY SINCE 2008!
4
Revolving Credit (Home Equity & Credit Card) Limits & Balance1 !
$2.0T
$1.0T $2.5T
$3.0T
2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004
2003
$0.5T 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004
2003
Banks have reduced both the available & outstanding amounts of revolving consumer credit!
$930B
$3.5T $1.5T
$360B
$4.0T $2.0T Available! Outstanding!
1 Source: FRBNY Consumer Credit Panel/Equifax
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
SMALL BUSINESS LENDING BY BANKS HAS ALSO FALLEN!
5
Lending by Depository Lenders to Small Businesses 2003-20121!
750 700
600 550
650
2012!2011!2010!2009!2008!2007!2006!2005!2004!2003!
$120B
1 Source: United States Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis
Small firm bank lending rose from $308bn (1994) to $659bn (2008) but declined from 2008 to 2012 by $120B!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
AMONG CONSUMERS, NON PRIME BORROWERS HIT THE HARDEST
6
$(50)
$(40)
$(30)
$(20)
$(10)
$-
$10
$20
$30
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Change to Revolving Credit Extended to Borrowers with FICO <660 ($B)!
$120B reduction in nonprime credit card
availability (2009-2012)!
Data Source: Jefferies Equity Research
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
TECHNOLOGY IS CHANGING LENDING!
7
1 Conflicts with Basel III requirements
Application Underwriting Servicing Payments Better Lending
More Profitable
• Higher Volume • Higher Conversion • Lower CPA
• Lower Servicing Costs • Lower Losses
Online Applications
• Faster Process • Better Execution • Reduced Friction
Increased Volume Lower CPA
Big Data • More Data Sources • Better Segmentation • Faster Trend Analysis
Lower Risk Increased Uptake
ACH Payment System • Lower Cost • Faster Tracking/
Reconciliation • Faster Trend Analysis
Lower Cost, Lower Risk
Mobile • SMS Payment • Reminders • Mobile Barcodes • 3rd Party Locations
Lower Cost, Lower Risk
Driving Improvements across the Value Chain!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
NON-BANK, ALTERNATIVE LENDERS EMERING TO FILL THE VOID!
8
1 Conflicts with Basel III requirements
All Loan Products Are Being Transformed!
Business!Secured Business Installment
Unsecured Business Installment Merchant Cash Advance
Receivable Factoring!Secured Real Estate
Purchase Order Financing Leases!
Consumer!Unsecured Installment Unsecured Revolving
Rent to Own!Payday
Online Title Lending!Student Loans
Secured Real Estate Leases!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
MY START: ALT CREDIT BACK IN 2005!
BACKGROUND!
9
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
STARTED IN A SUPERMARKET:1st Progreso Finaniero Store!
10
1 Conflicts with Basel III requirements
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
CHALLENGE: HOW DO WE HELP MARIA AND MAKE HER A LOAN?!
11
1 Conflicts with Basel III requirements
Hard working, wants the America dream, but doesn’t have a traditional data in a credit bureau or a FICO score…!
!…And No FICO = No Approval and worse, No Identity!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential. 12
1 Conflicts with Basel III requirements
NO FILE THIN FILE THICK FILE (540 AVG. FICO)
Challenging Population to Underwrite!
§ E-HARMONY APPROACH: Start with Robust Application § Application data is very valuable
§ BOOK SOME BAD LOANS: Invest in loans before data scientists § Most valuable data is performance data § 1000 “bads” helps to build a model
§ ALTERNATIVE DATA: Merge alternative data with bureau data
§ Not only for scoring, conversion is also important § Adverse action reasons / regulation B
LESSONS LEARNED!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential. 13
500,000 LOANS LATER…HAPPY CUSTOMERS AND SINGLE DIGIT LOSSES!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
INSIKT APPROACH IN P2P LENDING!
DATA FOR LENDERS!
14
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
Data and Analytics are core to both sides of our business!
15
Origination Technology!(B2B, white label)!
Investors!(B2C, branded)!
Underwriting / Selection of Loans:!!(1) Risk Model Development!(2) Loan Valuation
Framework!(3) Stress Resilience!
Enhanced transparency and access to data for investors:!!(1) Bond Performance!(2) Loan Performance!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
Prosper Case Study!
16
Significantly Better in Bad Times! Consistent and Steady in Good Times!25!
20!
15!
10!
5!
Months since origination!0!
1! 9! 18! 27! 36! 1! 9! 18! 27! 36!
2008!Financial Crisis!
2009-11!Averaged!
Cum
ulat
ive
loss
rate
%!
!Prosper!
!Insikt!
!
Months since origination!
100 years of Experience. Robust Models.!Goal = Outperform Prosper in Good & Bad times!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(1) Risk Model Development!
Developing our Underwriting / Loan Selection Strategy!
17
• Max data attributes available!
• Scorecard-ed logistic regression used to balance sloping power and processing speed!
• Risk Model used to create discrete risk segments with differentiated performance expectations!
!• NPV & ROE
optimization!
• Apply observed loss rate performance through 2008 recession NPV valuations as economic stress test!
(2) Loan Valuation Framework!
(3) Valuation Stress Testing!
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(1) De-average key performance dimensions as much as possible!
18
§ Data is the most important part of your model build § Test early and often § Many things can influence your outcomes, incorporate as many as
possible into your testing strategy: § Price § Credit Line § Marketing Channels
§ Incorporate data from a variety of sources: § Clean your data! Many insights are buried in missing values and error
codes
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(1) Risk Decision Tree Combining Multiple Risk Model Dimensions
§ Insikt leverages a decision tree to effectively combine multiple risk models across unique population segments and data sources
19
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(1) Optimize KS!
20
Insikt V2 PMI V4 PMI V5 FICO
2011(PMIv5 Eligible) 29.60 22.06 24.02 9.88
20121H(PMIv5 Eligible) 27.11 18.97 25.30 13.79
20122H(PMIv5 Eligible) 27.73 23.09 21.67 9.08
KS comparison
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(2) Valuation Framework -- Loss rates!
21
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
AA 2011 selected 2011 non-selected
2012 selected 2012 non-selected
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
A 2011 selected 2011 non-selected
2012 selected 2012 non-selected
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
B 2011 selected 2011 non-selected
2012 selected 2012 non-selected
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
D* 2011 selected 2011 non-selected
2012 selected 2012 non-selected
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
E* 2011 selected 2011 non-selected
2012 selected 2012 non-selected
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
C 2011 selected 2011 non-selected
2012 selected 2012 non-selected
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(2) Apply valuation framework at the most granular level (optimize marginal decisions)!
22
§ Value your decisions across your population dimensions and your product dimensions
§ Granular ROE Assessment across credit grades, model deciles, and credit line buckets:
Base Case IRR2010 -‐ 2012 Loss Performance & Current Pricing Strategy
0-‐$5,000 Loan Amounts $5,001-‐$10,000 Loan Amounts $10,001-‐$14,999 Loan Amounts1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+
AA 7% 3% -‐10% 14% -‐21% 8% 15% 16% AA 7% 4% -‐3% -‐8% 16% 14% 16% -‐108% AA -‐3% 0% -‐1% -‐39% 15%A 32% 19% 17% 4% -‐20% -‐18% -‐37% -‐21% A 23% 16% 0% 5% 6% -‐11% -‐50% -‐42% A 10% 20% 18% 2% 18% 35% 42%B 57% 31% 31% 17% 28% -‐6% -‐20% -‐31% B 15% 38% 47% 30% 22% -‐21% -‐31% -‐13% B 61% 56% 48% 26% 64% 13% -‐91% 59%C 74% 61% 50% 45% 44% 27% 12% 0% C 31% 31% 41% 64% 1% 43% -‐24% -‐39% C -‐135% 79% 53% 15% 28% 85% -‐1%D 120% 98% 65% 46% 30% 67% 10% D 110% 67% 61% 49% 27% 39% -‐59% D 114% 99% 113% 116% -‐101% -‐31% 99%E 150% 70% 57% 92% 80% 77% 51% E 155% 149% 106% 81% 53% 47% 25% E 155% 147% 149%HR 112% 166% 89% 25% 48% HR -‐13% 105% -‐2% 118% HR 169%
Stress Case IRR2x Base Loss Performance & Current Pricing Strategy
0-‐$5,000 Loan Amounts $5,001-‐$10,000 Loan Amounts $10,001-‐$14,999 Loan Amounts1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+
AA 6% -‐4% -‐30% 14% -‐55% 1% 15% 16% AA 5% -‐2% -‐18% -‐28% 16% 14% 16% -‐230% AA -‐13% -‐10% -‐12% -‐88% 15%A 30% 4% -‐2% -‐29% -‐78% -‐76% -‐113% -‐84% A 12% -‐1% -‐36% -‐26% -‐25% -‐60% -‐139% -‐120% A -‐14% 8% 0% -‐30% 0% 35% 42%B 57% 4% 3% -‐25% -‐4% -‐72% -‐101% -‐122% B -‐29% 18% 36% 2% -‐16% -‐101% -‐121% -‐88% B 61% 56% 39% -‐6% 64% -‐36% -‐241% 59%C 74% 43% 20% 10% 8% -‐29% -‐58% -‐83% C -‐15% -‐14% 3% 49% -‐78% 5% -‐131% -‐162% C -‐350% 79% 28% -‐50% -‐27% 85% -‐86%D 120% 80% 19% -‐23% -‐53% 21% -‐93% D 110% 19% 6% -‐16% -‐61% -‐36% -‐231% D 114% 99% 113% 116% -‐315% -‐174% 99%E 150% -‐11% -‐34% 35% 12% 6% -‐47% E 155% 149% 63% 13% -‐46% -‐52% -‐99% E 155% 147% 149%HR 61% 166% 12% -‐114% -‐70% HR -‐196% 44% -‐170% 70% HR 169%
Historical Vintage Sample Size
0-‐$5,000 Loan Amounts $5,001-‐$10,000 Loan Amounts $10,001-‐$14,999 Loan Amounts1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+
AA 196 176 72 20 18 7 3 3 AA 192 187 87 41 8 7 2 4 AA 55 60 31 12 1A 95 295 217 164 118 62 40 31 A 112 246 222 164 86 59 32 30 A 33 67 57 32 22 6 5B 28 139 177 185 165 123 77 62 B 17 100 127 120 115 98 53 43 B 2 17 24 21 11 11 3 3C 7 91 188 242 241 250 193 225 C 6 51 99 113 121 142 102 113 C 2 7 12 16 6 2 3D 8 32 67 76 123 103 165 D 2 24 18 36 47 56 72 D 1 2 2 4 4 3 1E 3 14 24 31 79 64 127 E 1 4 14 22 24 23 49 E 1 2 4HR 4 3 9 19 46 HR 5 7 6 18 HR 1
Base Case IRR2010 -‐ 2012 Loss Performance & Current Pricing Strategy
0-‐$5,000 Loan Amounts $5,001-‐$10,000 Loan Amounts $10,001-‐$14,999 Loan Amounts1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+
AA 7% 3% -‐10% 14% -‐21% 8% 15% 16% AA 7% 4% -‐3% -‐8% 16% 14% 16% -‐108% AA -‐3% 0% -‐1% -‐39% 15%A 32% 19% 17% 4% -‐20% -‐18% -‐37% -‐21% A 23% 16% 0% 5% 6% -‐11% -‐50% -‐42% A 10% 20% 18% 2% 18% 35% 42%B 57% 31% 31% 17% 28% -‐6% -‐20% -‐31% B 15% 38% 47% 30% 22% -‐21% -‐31% -‐13% B 61% 56% 48% 26% 64% 13% -‐91% 59%C 74% 61% 50% 45% 44% 27% 12% 0% C 31% 31% 41% 64% 1% 43% -‐24% -‐39% C -‐135% 79% 53% 15% 28% 85% -‐1%D 120% 98% 65% 46% 30% 67% 10% D 110% 67% 61% 49% 27% 39% -‐59% D 114% 99% 113% 116% -‐101% -‐31% 99%E 150% 70% 57% 92% 80% 77% 51% E 155% 149% 106% 81% 53% 47% 25% E 155% 147% 149%HR 112% 166% 89% 25% 48% HR -‐13% 105% -‐2% 118% HR 169%
Stress Case IRR2x Base Loss Performance & Current Pricing Strategy
0-‐$5,000 Loan Amounts $5,001-‐$10,000 Loan Amounts $10,001-‐$14,999 Loan Amounts1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+
AA 6% -‐4% -‐30% 14% -‐55% 1% 15% 16% AA 5% -‐2% -‐18% -‐28% 16% 14% 16% -‐230% AA -‐13% -‐10% -‐12% -‐88% 15%A 30% 4% -‐2% -‐29% -‐78% -‐76% -‐113% -‐84% A 12% -‐1% -‐36% -‐26% -‐25% -‐60% -‐139% -‐120% A -‐14% 8% 0% -‐30% 0% 35% 42%B 57% 4% 3% -‐25% -‐4% -‐72% -‐101% -‐122% B -‐29% 18% 36% 2% -‐16% -‐101% -‐121% -‐88% B 61% 56% 39% -‐6% 64% -‐36% -‐241% 59%C 74% 43% 20% 10% 8% -‐29% -‐58% -‐83% C -‐15% -‐14% 3% 49% -‐78% 5% -‐131% -‐162% C -‐350% 79% 28% -‐50% -‐27% 85% -‐86%D 120% 80% 19% -‐23% -‐53% 21% -‐93% D 110% 19% 6% -‐16% -‐61% -‐36% -‐231% D 114% 99% 113% 116% -‐315% -‐174% 99%E 150% -‐11% -‐34% 35% 12% 6% -‐47% E 155% 149% 63% 13% -‐46% -‐52% -‐99% E 155% 147% 149%HR 61% 166% 12% -‐114% -‐70% HR -‐196% 44% -‐170% 70% HR 169%
Historical Vintage Sample Size
0-‐$5,000 Loan Amounts $5,001-‐$10,000 Loan Amounts $10,001-‐$14,999 Loan Amounts1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8+
AA 196 176 72 20 18 7 3 3 AA 192 187 87 41 8 7 2 4 AA 55 60 31 12 1A 95 295 217 164 118 62 40 31 A 112 246 222 164 86 59 32 30 A 33 67 57 32 22 6 5B 28 139 177 185 165 123 77 62 B 17 100 127 120 115 98 53 43 B 2 17 24 21 11 11 3 3C 7 91 188 242 241 250 193 225 C 6 51 99 113 121 142 102 113 C 2 7 12 16 6 2 3D 8 32 67 76 123 103 165 D 2 24 18 36 47 56 72 D 1 2 2 4 4 3 1E 3 14 24 31 79 64 127 E 1 4 14 22 24 23 49 E 1 2 4HR 4 3 9 19 46 HR 5 7 6 18 HR 1
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
(3) Stress test your assumptions to understand sensitivities!
23
§ What is the biggest risk to your strategy? § Valuation sensitivity § Historical Volatility
§ Develop scenarios based on historical volatility § e.g. 2008 Economic Downturn
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
INSIKT DATA & TOOLS FOR INVESTORS!
DATA FOR INVESTING!
24
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
DATA FOR INVESTORS: Info that actually matters and tools a CRO would use
§ Access to detailed performance data § Static pool history, loan level reporting, and ability to compare across
platforms § Access to detailed bond performance data
§ Full cash flow breakdown § Performance flags to identify variance concerns
25
Insikt.com ©2013 Insikt Inc. All Rights Reserved. Private and Confidential.
MYCRO TOOL
26