improving disaster resilience among older adults · older adults can also contribute important...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
C O R P O R A T I O N
Research Report
Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults
Insights from Public Health Departments and Aging-in-Place Efforts
Regina A. Shih, Joie D. Acosta, Emily K. Chen, Eric G. Carbone,
Lea Xenakis, David M. Adamson, Anita Chandra
![Page 2: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Limited Print and Electronic Distribution Rights
This document and trademark(s) contained herein are protected by law. This representation of RAND intellectual property is provided for noncommercial use only. Unauthorized posting of this publication online is prohibited. Permission is given to duplicate this document for personal use only, as long as it is unaltered and complete. Permission is required from RAND to reproduce, or reuse in another form, any of its research documents for commercial use. For information on reprint and linking permissions, please visit www.rand.org/pubs/permissions.
The RAND Corporation is a research organization that develops solutions to public policy challenges to help make communities throughout the world safer and more secure, healthier and more prosperous. RAND is nonprofit, nonpartisan, and committed to the public interest.
RAND’s publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors.
Support RANDMake a tax-deductible charitable contribution at
www.rand.org/giving/contribute
www.rand.org
For more information on this publication, visit www.rand.org/t/RR2313
Published by the RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, Calif.
© Copyright 2018 RAND Corporation
R® is a registered trademark.
![Page 3: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
iii
Preface
Thisreportusesinterviewdatacollectedfrompublichealthdepartmentsandaging-in-placeefforts—specifically,fromcoordinatorsofage-friendlycommunitiesandvillageexecutivedirectors—toexplorehowcurrentaging-in-placeeffortscanbeharnessedtostrengthenthedisasterresilienceofolderadultsandwhichexistingprogramsornewcollaborationsamongpublichealthdepartmentsandtheseorganizationsshowpromiseforimprovingdisasterresilienceforolderpopulations.
Thecontentsofthisreportwillbeofparticularinteresttopoliticalleaders(e.g.,mayors’offices);emergencypreparedness,response,andmanagementstaff;healthdepartmentsatthelocal,state,andnationallevels;andleadersofage-friendlycommunitiesandvillages.
ThisresearchwassponsoredbytheCentersforDiseaseControlandPreventionthroughcontract200-2014-59627andconductedwithinRANDHealth.
AprofileofRANDHealth,abstractsofitspublications,andorderinginformationcanbefoundatwww.rand.org/health.
![Page 4: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
iv
Contents
Preface....................................................................................................................................iiiSummary..................................................................................................................................vAcknowledgments...................................................................................................................viBackground:OlderAdultsandDisasters..................................................................................1PurposeandMethods..............................................................................................................4VillageInterviews.................................................................................................................5AFCInterviews......................................................................................................................5PublicHealthDepartmentInterviews..................................................................................6
Results......................................................................................................................................6PrioritizingPreparedness.....................................................................................................6GapsinPreparednessActivities.........................................................................................10BarriersEncounteredbyStakeholders...............................................................................13SuggestedMetricstoTrackOlderAdultResilience............................................................14
InsightsforStakeholders........................................................................................................15RecommendationsforAFCs...............................................................................................15RecommendationsforVillages...........................................................................................16RecommendationsforPublicHealthDepartments............................................................17RecommendationsforResearchers...................................................................................18RecommendationsforPolicymakers..................................................................................18
References..............................................................................................................................20
![Page 5: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
v
Summary
• Theincreasingfrequencyandintensityofweather-relatedandotherdisastereventscombinedwiththegrowingproportionsofolderadultspresentanewenvironmentinwhichpublichealthprogramsandpoliciesmustactivelypromotetheresilienceofolderadults.
• Preparednessprogramsconductedbypublichealthdepartmentsaredesignedtoreducemortalityandmorbidityand,consequently,willbecomeevenmorecritical,giventheincreasingproportionofolderadultsintheUnitedStates,largelyduetoagingbabyboomers.
• Interviewswithstakeholdersrevealedthatmostage-friendlycommunities(AFCs)andseniorvillagesdidnotplaceahighpriorityonpromotingdisasterpreparedness.Whilemostpublichealthdepartmentsweintervieweddidengageindisasterpreparednessandresilienceactivities,theywerenotnecessarilytailoredtoolderadults.
• AFCsandseniorvillageintervieweescitedolderadults’challengeswithcommunicationandlowprioritizationoftheneedtoplanfordisasters.Theseorganizationsalsoacknowledgedtheirlimitedawarenessofdisasterpreparednessandlackofdemandfromtheirconstituentstoprovideservicestohelptheircommunitiesbebetterprepared.
• Currentaging-in-placeeffortscanbeharnessedtostrengthenthedisasterresilienceofolderadults.Existingprogramsandnewcollaborationsbetweenpublichealthdepartmentsandtheseorganizationsshowpromiseforimprovingdisasterresilienceforolderpopulations.
• Theworkofpublichealthdepartmentsandaging-in-placeeffortsiscomplementary.Improvingtheeverydayengagementofolderadultswithfamily,friends,neighbors,andtrustedinstitutionssupportsotherorganizations’andagencies’preparednessworkbystrengtheninginformaltiesandbuildinginformationnetworks.Likewise,theworkofhelpingolderadultsbecomemoreresilienttodisastersprovidesanopportunityforolderadultstoengagewithothersandlearnskillsneededtoremainsafelylivingathomeastheyage.
• Aligningandextendingpublichealthdepartments’currentpreparednessactivitiestoincludeaging-in-placeeffortsandgreatertailoringofexistingpreparednessactivitiestotheneedsofolderadultscouldsignificantlyimprovetheirdisasterpreparednessandresilience.
• Forjurisdictionsthatdonothaveanexistingaging-in-placeeffort,publichealthdepartmentscanhelpinitiatethoseeffortsandworktoincorporatepreparednessactivitiesattheoutsetofnewlydevelopingaging-in-placeefforts.
![Page 6: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
vi
Acknowledgments
Thankyoutothevillages,age-friendlycommunities,andpublichealthdepartmentsthatparticipatedinthisstudy.WewouldalsoliketothankClaraAranibar,NinaRyan,andChanelSkinnerfortheirhelpinschedulingtheinterviews,aswellasourcolleaguesRodneyHarrellatAARP,NatalieGaluciaatVillagetoVillageNetwork,GailKohnandNickKushneratAge-FriendlyDC,andLauraBiesiadeckiandGeoffreyMwaunguluattheNationalAssociationforCountyandCityHealthOfficialsfortheirinputandtheirhelpwithrecruitinginterviewees.ThankstoJaimeMadriganofromRANDandJonathanAdrianofromtheEastCentralHealthDistrictinAugusta,Georgia,whoreviewedthisreportandprovidedideasandguidancethathavehelpedusarticulatethekeyfindingsandtheirimplications.Inaddition,wewouldliketothankAmyWolkin,theVulnerablePopulationsOfficerintheOfficeofPublicHealthPreparednessandResponseattheCentersforDiseaseControlandPreventionforherthoughtfulreviewofthereport.Finally,wewouldliketothanktheCentersforDiseaseControlandPreventionforfundingthestudythatmadethisworkpossible.
![Page 7: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
1
Background:OlderAdultsandDisasters
Intensestormsandotheremergencieshavebecomemorefrequentandsevereinrecentyears—inpart,becauseofclimatechange(NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministration,NationalCentersforEnvironmentalInformation,2017;NationalAssociationofInsuranceCommissioners,CenterforInsurancePolicyandResearch,2017).Itisincreasinglyimportanttobuildresilientcommunities—thatis,communitiesthatcanrecoverfromdisastersandfromotherproblems,suchasviolenceandeconomicdownturns,andemergestrongerandbetterabletowithstandfutureadverseevents(Acosta,Chandra,andMadrigano,2017).Aresilientcommunity(Figure1)requiresstrongconnectionsatalllevels:betweenneighbors,betweenneighborhoodsandcommunityorganizations,andbetweenlocalgovernmentandnongovernmentalgroups(Chandraetal.,2011).
Figure1.BuildingBlocksofaResilientCommunity
Olderadults,definedforthisreportasadultsage65orolder,areespeciallyvulnerable
duringandafterdisasters(Beietal.,2013;Maliketal.,2017;Weisler,Barbee,andTownsend,2006).Forexample,halfofthedeathsfromHurricaneKatrinawereadultsage75andolder(Brunkard,Namulanda,andRatard,2008),and63percentofthedeathsafterthe1995heatwaveinChicagowereadultsage65orolder(Whitmanetal.,1997).Olderadultsaremorelikelythanothersinacommunitytobesociallyisolatedandhavemultiplechronicconditions,limitationsindailyactivities,decliningvisionandhearing,andphysicalandcognitivedisabilities
Individuals/familieshavetheknowledgetoprepareforandrespondtodisaster
Thereareenoughvolunteerstohelpinadisaster
Organizationsarereadyandpreparedtorespondandrecover
Therearestrongrelationshipsbetweenorganizations
Peoplecanrelyoneachother(neighbortoneighbor)
RESILIENTCOMMUNITIESRESILIENTCOMMUNITIES
![Page 8: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
2
thathampertheirabilitytocommunicateabout,preparefor,andrespondtoanaturaldisaster(Levac,Toal-Sullivan,andO’Sullivan,2012;AldrichandBenson,2008).Asizablenumberofadultsage65orolder(aboutone-thirdofMedicareenrollees,orapproximately16millionnationally)livealone(Komisar,Feder,andKasper,2005).Disasterscanalsodisruptessentialservicesthatallowolderadultstoliveinthecommunity,suchasassistancefromfamilycaregiversandsocialserviceslikehome-deliveredmeals,choreservices,andpersonalcare(BensonandAldrich,2007).A2012surveyfoundthat15percentofU.S.adultsage50orolderwouldnotbeabletoevacuatetheirhomeswithouthelp,andhalfofthisgroupwouldneedhelpfromsomeoneoutsidethehousehold(NationalAssociationofAreaAgenciesonAging,NationalCouncilonAging,andUnitedHealthcare,2012).A2014surveyofadultsage50orolderfoundthat15percentofthesampleusedmedicaldevicesrequiringexternallysuppliedelectricity(Al-Rousan,Rubenstein,andWallace,2014).Thus,powerinterruptionscouldposeadversehealtheffectsforthisgroup.
Olderadultscanalsocontributeimportantassetstodisasterresponse.A2017qualitativestudyof17focusgroupswithat-riskindividualsfoundthatadultsage65oroldercontributetheirexperience,resources,andrelationship-buildingcapacitytopreparethemselvesandtosupportothersduringanemergency(Howard,Blakemore,andBevis,2017).Specifically,olderadultsbothgenerateandmobilizesocialcapitalatthelocallevelduringadisaster.
Yettherearecriticalgapsindisasterpreparednessforthisgroup.Althoughpreparednessguidelinesandresourcesexistforolderadults,the2014surveymentionedearlierfoundthattwo-thirdsofadultsage50orolderhadnoemergencyplan,hadneverparticipatedinanydisasterpreparednesseducationalprogram,andwerenotawareoftheavailabilityofrelevantresources(Al-Rousan,Rubenstein,andWallace,2014).Morethanathirdofrespondentslackedabasicsupplyoffood,water,ormedicalsuppliesincaseofemergency(Al-Rousan,Rubenstein,andWallace,2014).Adultsage65andolderwillmakeupnearly25percentoftheU.S.populationby2060(U.S.CensusBureau,2017).AstheU.S.populationagesandweathereventsbecomemoresevere,theneedtoaddressthevulnerabilityandleveragethestrengthsofolderAmericansindisasterswillgrow.
Publichealthandpreventionplanningandprogramsareneededtoidentifyolderadultsatelevatedriskintheeventofdisasters,addresstheirneeds,andleveragetheirstrengths(Al-Rousan,Rubenstein,andWallace,2014).Publichealthdepartmentsarethegovernmententityprimarilyresponsiblefordisaster-relatedpublichealthandsafety.However,publichealthdepartmentsareoftenfocusedontheentirecommunity,andeventheirtailoredprogramsmaybelimitedtoindividualswithfunctionallimitationsandmaynotnecessarilymeettheneedsofallolderadults.Onesetofresourcesforimprovingthedisasterresilienceofolderadultsmayalreadyexistincommunities:currenteffortstopromoteaginginplace.TheCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention(CDC,2009)defineaginginplaceas"theabilitytoliveinone'sown
![Page 9: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
3
homeandcommunitysafely,independently,andcomfortably,regardlessofage,income,orabilitylevel."A2015surveyfoundthat75percentofrespondentsage60orolderintendedtocontinuelivingintheircurrenthomefortheremainderoftheirlives,inlargepartdrivenbytheirdesiretobenearfamilyandfriends(NationalAssociationofAreaAgenciesonAging,NationalCouncilonAging,andUnitedHealthcare,2015).
TherearetwoprimarytypesofnationwideorganizationsthatpromoteaginginplaceintheUnitedStates(Greenfield,2012):
• Age-friendlycommunities(AFCs)aretypicallycollaborationsorpartnershipsbetweenorganizations(whichmayincludelocalgovernmentagenciesandcommunitygroups)thatpromotethesocialconnectednessofolderadultsacrossamunicipalorregionalarea(e.g.,citiesandcounties)andfacilitatetheirinclusionincommunitylife.TheWorldHealthOrganizationoverseestheGlobalNetworkforAge-FriendlyCitiesandCommunities.AARPoverseesanetworkofU.S.Age-FriendlyCities.
• Villagesaremembership-drivengrassrootsnonprofitorganizationsthatseektohelpolderadultsageinplacesuccessfullythroughanumberofprogramsandservices,suchashealtheducation,socialgatherings,accesstoalistofservicevendorswhohavebeenvetted,transportation,andbookkeeping.Villagesgenerallycoveraneighborhoodoracitybutinsomecasescancovermultipleadjacentcountiesinmoreruralareas.Villagesdifferbasedontheirsize,governancestructure,membershipcharacteristics,andregionalcoverage.TheVillagetoVillageNetworkisanationalnonprofitorganizationthatprovidesexpertguidance,resources,andsupporttohelpcommunitiesestablishandmaintainvillages.
Likeresilience,successfulaginginplaceemphasizesconnectedness.Forolderadultsinparticular,thismeansengagementwithcommunitylifeandneededservices.
Thefollowinglistsummarizestherationaleforfocusingonolderadults’preparednessandourhypothesisthataging-in-placeeffortsmayserveasresourcestopublichealthdepartmentstobolsterthedisasterresilienceofolderadults(Keim,2008):
1. TheU.S.populationisagingrapidly,inpartbecauseoftheagingbabyboomercohorts.2. Intensestormsandotheremergencieshavebecomemorefrequentandsevereover
time,andolderadultstendtoliveinareasmorepronetodisasters.3. ThemajorityofolderadultsintheUnitedStatesareunpreparedforanemergency,and
manyaresociallyisolatedorarenotabletoreceiveorrespondtomessagestypicallyemployedbypublichealthdepartments.
4. Olderadultsarevulnerableandhavespecificneedsinthefaceofanemergencythatarenotfullycoveredbymostpublichealthdepartments’preparednessactivities.
![Page 10: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
4
5. Emergencypreparednessprogramsaredesignedtoreducemortalityandmorbidity,whichwillbecomeevenmorecritical,giventheagingU.S.population.
6. Aging-in-placeeffortsmaybeanationalresourcetosupportdisasterresilienceofolderadults.
PurposeandMethods
Thepurposeofthisstudyistoidentifythekeycomponentstohelppublichealthdepartments,whicharechargedwithgeneralpreparednessefforts,andaging-in-placeefforts,whichstrengthengeneralresilienceamongolderadults,tobetteraligntheiractivitiesandrelationshipswitheachothertofillthegapsinresilienceofolderadultstodisasters(seeFigure2).Wesoughttoanswertwomainquestions:(1)CancurrentAFCandvillageeffortstopromoteaginginplacebeharnessedtostrengthenthedisasterresilienceofolderadults?(2)Whichexistingprogramsornewcollaborationsamongpublichealthdepartmentsandaging-in-placeorganizationsshowpromiseforimprovingdisasterresilienceforolderpopulations?Figure2.Aging-in-PlaceInitiativesandPublicHealthDepartmentsRarelyCollaboratetoBolsterPreparednessSpecifictoOlderAdults
Aging-in-placeinitiatives
SocialsupportDailyquality-of-life
needs
PublichealthdepartmentsGeneral
preparednessGeneralhealth
resilience
Currentgapisinconductingpreparedness
tailoredtoolderadults
In2016,aresearchteamconductedkeyinformantinterviewswiththreegroupsofstakeholders—publichealthdepartmentstaff,AFCleaders,andvillageexecutivedirectors—withthreegoalsinmind:
![Page 11: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
5
• Improveunderstandingofwhatpublichealthdepartments,AFCs,andvillagesarecurrentlydoingtoaddressdisasterresilienceinolderpopulations.
• Identifypromisingavenuesforimprovingcurrenteffortsorlaunchingnewones,includingprograms,partnerships,andcollaborations.
• Gatherrecommendationsforusefulmetricsofresilienceinolderadults.
Asemistructuredprotocolwasestablishedtoguidetheinterviewswiththesestakeholders.Itincludedquestionsaboutthegreatestneedsaroundhelpingolderadultspreparefordisasters;thetypesofresilienceactivitiesengagedinbytheirorganizations,bothgenerallyandforolderadults;othertypesofolderadult–focusedprogrammingconductedbytheirorganizations;wholeadsresilienceactivitiesforolderadultsintheirserviceareas;awarenessofandcollaborationwithotherolderadult–servingandresilience-focusedorganizationsandagenciesintheirregions;andideasforhowtoassessprogressaroundemergencypreparednessandresilienceforolderadults.Whilethisqualitativeresearchsoughttoreachsaturationofinformationwithineachstakeholdergroup,itisimportanttonotethattheseresultsarenotrepresentativeofallviewpointsforeachstakeholdergroup.Allinformantsgaveverbalconsenttoparticipate,andthemethodswereapprovedbytheRANDCorporation’sHumanSubjectsProtectionCommitteeandtheFederalOfficeofManagementandBudget.
VillageInterviews
Weinterviewed16villageleadersfromtheapproximately175villagesthatwereoperatinginearly2016whenwebeganrecruitinginterviewees.Inmostcases,theintervieweewastheexecutivedirector.WerecruitedtheseexecutivedirectorswiththehelpoftheVillagetoVillageNetwork,amember-basedorganizationofvillagesacrosstheUnitedStateswithanationalstaffthatprovidesguidance,resources,andsupporttohelpcommunitiesestablishandmaintaintheirvillages.OurrecruitmentstrategywastolocatevillagesrepresentingdiversityinsizeandgeographicregionacrosstheUnitedStates.Thevillagesinoursamplewereformedbetween2008and2015andhadbeeninexistenceforanaverageof5.5years.
AFCInterviews
Beforewebeganrecruitingintervieweesin2016,therewere26AFCswithcompletedactionplans.WiththehelpoftheAARPPublicPolicyInstitute,werecruitedleadersfromtenAFCs,representinganevendistributionacrossallU.S.geographicregionsandruralorurbanstatus.Weinterviewedthesetenleaders,whoweregenerallyrepresentativesofthecoordinatingbodiesofaparticularAFC.Mostrespondentswereemployedbylocal
![Page 12: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
6
governments,butafewrespondentshadprimaryrolesatacademicinstitutions,communityfoundations,orothertypesofcommunity-engagedorganizations.
PublicHealthDepartmentInterviews
WithassistancefromtheNationalAssociationforCountyandCityHealthOfficials,werecruited11staffmembersfrompublichealthdepartments.These11intervieweeswereprimarilyresponsibleforimplementingemergencypreparednessandresilienceactivities.OursamplerepresentedanevendistributionacrossallU.S.geographicregionsandruralorurbanstatus,withalldepartmentslocatedinareasthathadanAFCinthesamejurisdiction.Inthecaseofacountypublichealthdepartment,thecitylocatedwithinthecountywiththepublichealthdepartmenthadanAFC.Inmostcases,participantswereemergencypreparednesscoordinators.TheintentofselectingpublichealthdepartmentsinanareathathadanexistingAFCwastoidentifywhetherexistingentitieswereawareoftheircounterparts’activitiesandhowtheycouldbebetteraligned.Totheextentthatpublichealthdepartmentsarecapableandcangetleadershipbuy-in,theycanserveaskeystakeholdersforinitiatingthedevelopmentofanAFCorvillage.Thisreportdescribeshowpublichealthdepartments,AFCs,andvillagescanencouragealignmentofkeygoals,complementaryactivities,andsharingofinformationtoincreasepreparednessofolderadultsattheoutsetofanewlydevelopingaging-in-placeeffort.
Interviewswereledbyamemberoftheresearchteam,withanotherteammembertakingdetailednotes.Interviewswerealsoaudio-recorded.Recordingswerereferredtoforclarificationofthewrittennotesandtoconfirmverbatimquotes,asneeded.
Onceinterviewswerecomplete,tworesearchersindependentlyreviewedandsummarizedinterviewthemesforeachgroup.Leadresearchersontheproject,bothofwhomparticipatedinconductinginterviews,thenreviewedthesummaryofthemes,verifyingmajorthemesandsuggestingclarificationorexpansionofkeypointswhenneeded.Themeswerethenrefinedandexpandediterativelybytheresearchteam.
ResultsPrioritizingPreparedness
WhatStakeholdersAreDoing
Overall,wefoundthatmostAFCsdidnotplaceahighpriorityonpromotingdisasterpreparedness.Althoughvillagesdidpromotedisasterpreparednessactivities,mostofthesefocusedonbuildingsocialcohesionandsupportoronpreparingforhealth-relatedemergencies.Publichealthstaffgenerallyreportedthatresilience-buildingprogramsforolderadultswerelimitedornonexistentintheiragencies.Theyexpressedtheviewthattheirmission
![Page 13: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
7
waspreparednessforallagegroupsinthegeneralpopulationandthatolder-adultprogramingtypicallyfellunderthejurisdictionofanotheragency,suchasastateorlocalDepartmentofAging.Someoftheirworktargetedvulnerablepopulationsorindividualswithfunctionallimitations,whichmayincludesomebutnotallolderadults.
Villages
Themajorityofvillageswereengagedinatleastoneactivityaimedatimprovingolderadults’resilience.Theactivitiesvaried,basedontheneedsofthevillagemembers,butcanbegroupedintothreegeneralapproaches:
• information-sharingandoutreach,whichincludedprovidingbrochuresonpreparedness,callingmembersduringandafterdisasters,andremindingmembersaboutchangingsmokedetectorbatteries
• improvingcommunicationwithfirstresponders,includinghelpenrollinginsmart911registriestomakerespondersawareofmembers’needs,hostinginformationsessionsfromlocalemergencyresponders,andmedicalalertsystems
• assessmentandplanning,includinghomesafetyinspections(e.g.,forfiresafety),supportforemergencyplanning,andsupportforadvancecareplanningconversations—thatis,wishesincaseofdeathoranincapacitatinghealthevent.
Abouthalfofthevillageleadersinoursamplenotedthattheirvillageengagedinsomekindofemergencyplanning.Theseactivitiesare,asnoted,focusedmostlyonpreparingforhouseholdemergencies,suchasfiresorhealthcrises.However,severalvillagerespondentsdrewconnectionsbetweenpreparingfordisastersandpreparingforhealth-relatedemergenciesasakeycomponentofsupportforaginginplace,sinceolderadultstendedtoplaceahigherpriorityonpreparingforhealth-relatedemergencies.Thevillageintervieweesalsonotedthatdespitetheseactivities,manyoftheirmemberswouldstillbehighlyvulnerableintheeventofnaturaldisaster.
Inpartnershipsandcollaborations,villagesweremorelikelytoworkwithnonprofits,suchasseniorcenters,thanwithgovernmentagencies.Manysawthepotentialvalueofpartneringwithpublichealthdepartments,thoughsomeexpressedtheoppositeview—thattheydidnotviewpublichealthpartnershipsasworthwhilebecausethevillagelackedthestafftimetomaintainapartnership,didnotknowhowapartnershipwouldbenefittheirwork,orwereconcernedthatpartneringwithgovernmentagenciesmightbringwithitregulationsthatwouldrestricttheactivitiesofthevillage.
![Page 14: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
8
AFCs
Ingeneral,AFCswerelessengagedthanvillagesinactivitiesthatfocusedexplicitlyondisasterresilience.Unlikevillages,whichare“bottom-up”membershiporganizationscreatedtoaddresstheneedsoftheirmembers,AFCsaremore“topdown”;theiractivitiescenteronthemodelsetforthbytheWorldHealthOrganizationandAARP,whichidentifieseightdomains:thebuiltenvironment,transport,housing,socialparticipation,respectandsocialinclusion,civicparticipationandemployment,communication,andcommunitysupportandhealthservices(WorldHealthOrganization,2017).
Noneofthesedomainsexplicitlyaddressdisasterresilienceorpreparedness,andmostAFCrespondentsdidnotseeaclearintersectionbetweenthesedomainsanddisasterpreparedness.OfthetenAFCrespondents,onlythreewereengagedinresilienceactivities.ThesethreeAFCrespondentsexpressedtheviewthatpreparednesswasanextensionoftheirworkonneighborhoodcohesionandsocialengagement.TheleaderofoneoftheseAFCsarticulatedtheviewpointthatimprovingtheeverydayengagementofolderadultswithfamily,friends,neighbors,andtrustedinstitutionssupportedotherorganizations’andagencies’preparednessworkbystrengtheninginformaltiesandbuildinginformationnetworks.EachofthesethreeAFCleadersobservedthattheiractivitieswerefillingaroleinhelpingtolinkcommunitypreparednessingeneralwiththespecificneedsofolderadultsandthatbridgingthisgap—ratherthandeliveringanyspecificservices—maybethebestwaytosupportolder-adultpreparedness.
AFCsthatusedacommunity-engagedstrategytosetprioritieswerelesslikelytofocusonresilienceanddisasterpreparednessbecausethesearetypicallyoflessimmediateinteresttoolderadultsthanthedailyquality-of-lifeissuesaddressedintheeightdomains.Incontrast,AFCsthatwereformallyaffiliatedwithmultiplecityagenciesorissue-specificorganizationstypicallyhadmorediverseagendasthatleftmoreroomforconsideringresilienceanddisasterpreparednessinsomeform.
Intermsofpartnershipsandcollaborations,AFCsarealmostentirelycollaborativeefforts,ofteninvolvingcommunityleadersandrepresentativesofcityorlocalgovernmentagencies,whichinsomecasesincludedpublichealthdepartments.MostoftheAFCsinoursamplewerestaffedbyacombinationofgovernmentemployees(whoseparticipationwaspartoftheirjobs),communityleaders,interns,andvolunteers.
PublicHealthDepartments
Allofthepublichealthdepartmentsinoursamplewereengagedinpreparednessplanningandeducation.Inmostcases,theplanningfocusedonpreparingforhealthemergenciesorthe
![Page 15: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
9
health-specificpieceofadisasterevent,suchasrapidmedicationdispensingorcontaininginfectiousdiseases.Mostpublichealthdepartmentsdidnothaveobjectivesorprogramsspecifictoolderadults.Asnotedearlier,theytypicallydidnotperceiveprogrammingforolderadultstobe“intheirlane.”However,somehadprogramsfocusedonindividualswithfunctionallimitations(alsocalledat-riskorvulnerablepopulations).Somealsohadprogramsrelatedtochronicdiseasepreventionandmanagement(e.g.,depressionanddiabetes),aswellasreductionofhealthrisks,suchastobaccouseandfallprevention.Alloftheseissuesdisproportionatelyaffectolderadults.Manypublichealthdepartmentleadersfeltthattheirprogramshadbroadrelevancetoolderadultsand,therefore,feltthattheymettheneedsofolderadultsadequately.
Withrespecttopartneringactivities,allofthepublichealthdepartmentsinoursampledescribedextensivecollaborationandcoordinationwithothermunicipalagencies.Somepartneredwithareaagenciesfocusedonagingtodisseminateinformationabouthealthpromotionprogramsforolderadults.Othersparticipatedinlargerregionalcoalitionstopromotehealthandwellnessgoalsthatwerepartofabroaderstrategicplan.
Inaddition,mostpublichealthleadersdescribedcollaborationswithnongovernmentalgroupsandcommunityorganizations,suchashospitalsystems,churches,andcharities(e.g.,theRedCrossandCatholicCharities).Theirmotivationforthesepartnershipswastouselocalnetworksandcommunicationchannelstodeliverpublichealthmessagesandtoconducteducationandoutreach.Oneadditionaltypeofengagementwitholderadultsthatafewpublichealthdepartmentsmentionedwasoutreachtoolderadultstorecruitvolunteersfordisasterexercises,suchasamedication-dispensingexerciseduringapublichealthemergency.Onepublichealthleaderalludedtothefactthatthisvolunteeropportunityforolderadultsengagespeopleinapracticalwaywhileprovidinganopportunityforpreparednesseducationmoregenerally.Thisisjustoneexampleofhowolderadultsareanassetforbolsteringcommunityresilience.
Somepublichealthleadersexpressedinterestinpartneringorcoordinatingwithnonprofitorganizationsandothergovernmentagenciestoconductoutreachdirectedtoolderadultpopulations,thoughnonecurrentlydidso.Abouthalfofpublichealthdepartmentsworkedwithlong-termcarefacilitiesorotherresidentialfacilitiesforolderadultstohelpthosefacilitiesplanforemergencies.AnynursinghomeacceptingMedicareorMedicaidisrequiredbylawtohaveanemergencyplan(CDC,2012a),andallpublichealthdepartmentsappearedproactivelyengagedwiththesesitestodevelopplansforevacuationorshelteringinplaceandconductededucationactivitieswithresidentsinconjunctionwiththefacilities.MostpublichealthleadersindicatedtheywereawareofalocalAFC,butonlytworeportedinteractingwithAFCleadershiponpreparednessactivities.Veryfewpublichealthleadersreportedbeingawareofvillagesintheircommunity,andnonereportedinteractingwiththemonpreparednessactivities.Ofthe
![Page 16: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
10
11publichealthleadersweinterviewed,sevenwerefromcommunitieswithoneormorevillages.Inseveralcases,thepublichealthdepartmentleadersdidnotlooktotheAFCorvillageforcollaborationbecauseanothergovernmentagencywastaskedwithfocusingonolderadult–focusedprogramming(althoughnotrelatedtopreparednessactivities),and,therefore,thosepublichealthdepartmentsdidnotconsiderthemselvestobetheagenciesthatwoulddirectlypartnerwiththeAFCsorvillages.Similarly,villageleadersandAFCsdidnotviewpublichealthdepartmentsasaprimarypartnerforolderadult–focusedprogramming.However,therewasstrongagreementamongpublichealthleadersthattheirdepartmentalmissionshadsignificantoverlapwiththoseofAFCs,suchthatapotentialcollaborationwitheithertypeoforganizationwouldbewellalignedwithagencygoals.
RecapofKeyFindingsonStakeholderActivities
AFCsandvillagesfocusedonsuccessfulaginginplace,helpingolderadultsfunctioninandstayconnectedtotheircommunities.Many,especiallyvillages,wereengagedinprogramsdirectlyrelevanttodisasterpreparedness,althoughtheydidnotviewtheseprogramsasahighpriority.Publichealthdepartmentsfocusedondisasterpreparedness,aswellaspreventingandmanagingchronicdiseaseamongthelocalpopulation,buttheydidnothaveprogramstargetedspecificallytoolderadults.Publichealthdepartmentsdidhaveprogramsforindividualswithfunctionallimitations(whichcanencompasssomeolderadults,butnotall),butpublichealthleadersdidnotviewprogrammingforallolderadultsastheirresponsibility.
GapsinPreparednessActivities
WeexploredAFC,village,andpublichealthdepartmentviewsofhowwelltheirpreparedness-relatedactivitiesalignedwiththegreatestneedsthatolderadultsface.Allacknowledgedongoinggapsinthisalignment.
AFCs
AFCsacknowledgedgapsbetweenthegreatestneedsofolderadultsandtheavailableservicesorsupportforpreparedness.AFCrespondentsidentifiedseveralareasofpreparednessneedsforolderadults,includingchallengesrelatedtocommunication,connectedness,andindividualplanning(e.g.,lackofplanningaroundspecifichealthneeds,medicationmanagement,lackoftransportation,andmedicalneeds).
MostAFCrespondentssuggestedthatcertainneedsaremorecommonamongolderadultsduringadisasterresponse.Forexample,transportationorhealthneedsareparamountforolderadultsand,ifleftunaddressed,canpreventolderadultsfrombeingresilientfollowinga
![Page 17: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
11
disaster.Providingorobtainingappropriatetransportationforpeoplewithfunctionaldisabilities(e.g.,dialysisornonemergencymedicaltransport)maypresentmajorchallengesintheeventthatevacuationisnecessary.Similarly,olderadultswhousemedicalequipmentorsupplies(suchassupplementaloxygen),relyonhomecareservices,orneedmedicationsmayexperiencehealthcaredisruptionsduetolossofpower,interruptionofservices,orinabilitytogettoanopenpharmacy.Thiscouldcreateaserioussituationthatcompoundsthewideremergencyeventinagivenlocation.Accordingtorespondents,understandingtheseuniqueneedsandplanningforthem—onthepartofindividuals,publichealthdepartments,andfirstresponders—isanareaofgreatneed.
Theabilityofmunicipalitiesorfirstresponderstotrackvulnerableand/orisolatedindividualswasalsoidentifiedasagap.Afewrespondentsraisedthecorollaryoffunctionaldisabilityregistriesthatarekeptbysomecities,buttheycitedchallengesrelatedtogettingpeoplesignedupfortheseregistriesandmaintainingtheminawaythatwouldbeusefulduringanemergency.TheissueofcommunicationandtrackingofvulnerableolderadultsrelatedtooneAFCrespondent’sbeliefthatdevelopingsocialcohesionwasoneofthegreatestpreparednessneedsofolderadults.Inthisrespondent’sview,olderpeoplearemorelikelytobevulnerable,isolated,andcautiousandtoneedtrustworthyrelationshipswithneighbors,friends,organizations,orotherswhocanreachthemorbereachedouttoinanemergency.
AfewAFCsalsocitedthereadinessoffirstrespondersandemergencymanagementpersonnelasanareaofneedforolderadultsandpeoplewithdisabilities.Respondentsbelievedthatemergencyserviceswerenotalwaysmindfuloforequippedtoaddresstheuniqueneedsoftheolderadultsintheircommunitiesandthatfurthereducationandtrainingwasneeded.
Villages
Villageleadersnotedthattoofewmemberswereeducatedortookaction,whichwassometimesbasedonmembers’failuretoprioritizeortakeseriouslythepotentialbenefitsofpreparedness.Consequently,villageleadersnotedthattheirabilitytopromotepreparednessamongtheirmemberswaslimited,basedonthelackofinterestorwillingnesstoengage.
Arelatedchallengeforvillagemembers,discussedmoregenerallyinthecontextofserviceprovision,isthatmanymembers’needsaredynamic;asmembersdealwithacutehealtheventsandsubsequentrecoveryorfacemoresteadydeclinesinhealth,theirneedsandimpairmentswillchange.Thisrelatestopreparednessandresiliencebecause,inlightofthefluctuatingmedicalneedsofvillagemembers,gapsinpreparingforthosemedicalneedswillhavetobecontinuallyassessedandreassessed.
![Page 18: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
12
PublicHealthDepartments
Publichealthrespondentscitedseveralreasonsthatolderadultsmaybemorevulnerableintheeventofanemergency.Respondentsfocusedonolderadults’healthandmedicalneeds,includingmedication,medicalequipment,andfunctionallimitations;socialisolation—thatis,beingmorelikelytolivealoneandlesslikelytoknowneighbors;andlackofawarenessandpreparednessforemergencies.Lackofknowledgeaboutpreparednessandlackofreadinesswereviewedasproblemsforolderadults,butrespondentsnotedthatthischallengeisalsowidespreadinthegeneralpopulation.Nevertheless,olderadultsmightbelessawareofpreparednessguidelinesandrecommendationsforemergencyresponse;lesslikelytomakeaplanandbuildakit;andlessabletoactivateanemergencyplanwhenneeded,suchasevacuatingorgoingtoashelter.Mostrespondentsdescribedolderadultsasgenerallylackingthetechnologicalskillsneededtouseacellphoneorcomputertofollownewsorsocialmediaupdatesduringanemergency;thisputsolderadultsatriskofbeingdisconnectedfromemergencyresponseinformation.Anotherspecialneedofolderadultswithregardtoemergencyresponseistransportation;whenwalkingtoashelterisnotfeasibleforanurbanresident,orifanindividualnolongerdrives,lackoftransportationislikelytoposeaseriouschallengetotimelyevacuation.
Publichealthleadersalsopointedtogapsinthenationalpolicyandlegalframeworkintendedtoprotectolderadultsaspartofemergencypreparedness.MostofthepoliciesthatguideU.S.disasterpreparedness,response,andrecovery(e.g.,theNationalResponseFramework,theNationalDisasterRecoveryFramework,theHomelandSecurityAct,theStaffordAct)donotspecificallyaddressplanning,preparedness,orresilienceofolderadults(CDC,2012a).OneexceptionisthePandemicandAll-HazardsPreparednessAct,whichfocusesonpublichealthandmedicalpreparednessandresponseandprovidesgrantstostrengthenstateandlocalpublichealthsecurityinfrastructure.ThispolicypermitstheSecretaryofHealthandHumanServicestorequirethosereceivinggrantstoincludethestate-levelagencyresponsibleforaging-relatedissuesintheirpreparednessplans(CDC,2012b).Acomplementarypolicy,theOlderAmericansAct,requiresstateandlocalareaagenciesthataddressagingtoengageinpreparednessplanning.Eachagencyisrequiredtodevelopapreparednessplanforhowitwillcoordinatewithprivate,nonprofit,andgovernmentdisasterresponseagencies.Inaddition,stateagenciesonagingarerequiredtobeinvolvedinthedevelopment,revision,andimplementationoftheirstate’spublichealthemergencypreparednessandresponseplan.Muchlikethepublichealthpolicy,thisrequirementforpreparednessplanningistiedtograntfundingforthesestateandlocalagingagencies(CDC,2012b).
Despitetheserequirements,ourfindingshighlightthelackofasingleleadagencyresponsibleforpreparingorprotectingolderadultsduringadisaster.Formostofthepublic
![Page 19: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
13
healthdepartmentsinoursample,thepublichealthleaderwasnotassignedthisresponsibility.Infact,fewlocationshadanyagencyordepartmentspecificallyaddressingolderadults’preparednessorresilience;rather,thefocuswasonvulnerablepopulations,inwhicholderadultswereoftenoverrepresented(e.g.,thosewithfunctionaldisabilities),butwhichwerenotdefinedinanage-specificway.
Respondentsfromthelargerpublichealthdepartmentsinoursamplealsopointedtogapsandlimitationsininteragencycollaborationaroundemergencypreparednessandmanagement.Respondentsnotedhowcollaborationwithmanyotheragenciesworkingonpreparednessplanningrequiredthemattimestolimittheirownplansandscope.Forexample,somerespondentsexplainedtheirlackofprogrammingandoutreachtoolderadultsbythefactthatanotheragencyordepartmentwastheleadagencyforolderadult–focusedservices,and,therefore,theydidnotperceiveaneedtoaddressthispopulation.
BarriersEncounteredbyStakeholders
Weaskedthosestakeholderswhoexpressedinterestinpreparednessactivitiesforolderadultsaboutbarrierstoincludingthemintheirprogramportfolios.Theypointedtothreetypesofbarriers:
• limitedknowledgeorawarenessoftheproblem,includingtheperceptionthatdisasterpreparednessforolderadultswasoutsidetheirorganizationalmissionorscope
• lackofdemandfromconstituents• resourceconstraints.
LimitedKnowledgeorAwareness
Abarriercommonlycitedbystakeholderswaslimitedawarenessorknowledge.Insomecases,stakeholders,particularlyAFCandvillageleaders,werenotawarethatdisasterpreparednessforolderadultswasitsownfieldofactivityorhadonlypassingacquaintancewiththespecificissues.Inothercases,stakeholdersdidnotseealignmentbetweentheseactivitiesandthegoalsandmissionsoftheirorganizations.Whilestakeholdersgenerallyunderstoodthevalueofresilienceforolderadults,theyoftenperceivedthatotherorganizationswereresponsibleforthis.Publichealthdepartmentsperceivedthatagenciesforagingplayedthisrole.ManyAFCandvillageleadersfeltthatotherorganizationswerealreadydoingthisworkintheirlocalarea.
![Page 20: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
14
LackofDemandfromConstituents
Invillages,theconstituentsaretheolderadultmembers;inAFCs,theconstituentsareorganizationalleaderswhocommittoimprovingcommunityconditionsinapredefinedsetofdomainsdevelopedbytheWorldHealthOrganizationandAARP.Althoughtheseconstituentsareslightlydifferent,theprioritiesforAFCandvillageconstituentsaresimilartoeachotherbecausethefocusisonagingolderadults,whereaspublichealthdepartmentsfocusonemergencypreparednessmostlywithoutcustomizationtoolderadults.AFCsandvillagesprioritizedsocialengagementissuesandsocialservicesforolderadultsinlargepartbecauseconstituentsinAFCsandvillageswerefocusedonday-to-dayproblemsandimprovingoverallqualityoflife.AFCandvillageleadersbelievedthattheirconstituenciesdidnotnecessarilyseethevalueofhelpingthemtobemoreresilienttodisastersbecausetheywerenotasvisibleasquality-of-lifeissues,nordidtheyseepossibleconnectionsbetweenthoseeffortsandhelpingthembecomemoreresilientindailylife.
ResourceConstraints
ResourceconstraintswereabarrierforAFCsandvillages.ManyAFCshadminimaldedicatedstaffandhadtoprioritizeactivitiesandprograms.Asnoted,theyoftendidnotperceivepreparednessasapriority.Villageleaderswhoseorganizationsdidnotengageinpreparednessactivitiestypicallyhadevenless“bandwidth”fortakingtheseon.Villagesalsonotedlimitationsintheirabilitytoprovidehigh-qualitypreparednesssupport,asthesmalldedicatedstaffandvolunteersgenerallydidnothaveexpertiseinpreparednesseducation.
SuggestedMetricstoTrackOlderAdultResilience
Wealsoaskedourintervieweeswhattypeofmetricwouldbeimportanttoassessinordertomeasureortrackwhetherolderadultsinanareaweremoreresilientovertime.Respondentsfocusedmainlyonindividuals’preparednessknowledgeandwhattangiblestepshavebeentaken.Forexample,theysuggestedmeasuringthenumberofpeoplewhohavedevelopedaplan,includingknowingwhomtocallinanemergencyorwheretogoforinformation,andhavephonenumbersoftheirfamilymembersorcaregiverswrittendown.
Othersuggestionsincluded
• conductingfocusgroupsamongolderadultswithdiversefunctionalstatusandserviceagenciestargetingolderadultpopulationstoassesstheneedsandinterestsofolderadultsaroundpreparedness
• evaluatingthepenetrationofoutreacheffortsanduptakeofinformationandactivities
![Page 21: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
15
• trackinghealthserviceutilization,suchasemergencyroomvisits,overtimetounderstandtheimpactoftargetedpreparednessactivitiesonhealthcrisesduringanemergency(thisrespondentexpectedimprovedpreparednesstoaverthealthcrisesintheeventofadisaster)
• atthehigherleveloforganizationalpreparedness,assessinghowmanysupportiveserviceagencies,suchasnursinghomevisitingprograms,haveresponseplans,communicationsplans,andcontinuity-of-operationsplansinplacetoassistolderadultsduringanemergency.
InsightsforStakeholders
TheinterviewssupportedourhypothesesthattheactivitiesofAFCs,villages,andpublichealthdepartmentsaresupportiveofeachother:Publichealthdepartments’effortstobuildresiliencetodisastersamongolderadultswillhelpthemageinplacemoresuccessfully,andtheworkofvillagesandAFCstobettermanagechronicdiseaseandreducesocialisolationcanhelpmakeolderadultsmoreresilienttodisasters.TherecognitionofthealignmentandextensionoftheseeffortstoexpandcurrentpreparednessactivitiesforAFCsandvillagesandmoretailoringofexistingpreparednessactivitiesamongpublichealthdepartmentstoolderadultscouldsignificantlyimprovethepreparednessandresilienceofolderadults.Althoughthefindingsfromthesequalitativeinterviewsarenotrepresentativeofallvillages,AFCs,andpublichealthdepartments,weoffersomerecommendationsfornextstepstoimproveolderadults’disasterpreparednessandresilience,basedonthedatawecollectedwithinthislimitedsamplerecruitedfromtheentirepopulationofthesethreestakeholdergroupsacrosstheUnitedStates.
RecommendationsforAFCs
• AFCsarepublic-privatepartnerships,withrepresentationfromlocalgovernmentandcommunitymembers.Theyarewellpositionedtoprovideleadershipincultivatingpositiverelationshipsbetweenolderadults,publichealthdepartments,andemergencymanagementagencies.
• Theycanalsofacilitateimprovedcommunicationandoutreachbypublichealthdepartmentstoolderadults.
• Morebroadly,AFCscanamplifyandsupportotheragencies’work—ratherthanduplicatetheireffort—byleveragingexistingprogrammingandexpandingdisseminationofthework.
![Page 22: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
16
• SomeAFCsfelttheneedtofocusoneverydayquality-of-lifeissuesorbasic-needsissuesinordertomaintainvalueintheeyesofendusers,sponsors,andpartners.AFCleadersnotedthattheseconstituentsmaynotperceivetherelevanceofpreparednesstoqualityoflifeormakingcitiesmorelivableforolderadults.WesuggestthatAFCscouldhonetheirmessagingaroundresilience,perhapslinkingitmorebroadlytootherhealth-relatedandquality-of-lifeissues,inordertoincreasethesalienceofdisasterpreparednessforolderadultsasastrandoftheAFCs’work.
• Inaddition,AARPandtheWorldHealthOrganizationcouldalsoconsidermoreexplicitlylinkingpreparednessandresiliencetooneoftheeightlivabilitydomainsintheirframework—oraddinganinthdomainfocusedontheseissues.Likewise,preparednesspermeatesmany,ifnotall,ofthedomains,suchassocialparticipation,communicationandinformation,communityandhealthservices,andtransportation.Socialcohesioncanimproveimmediatesupportsavailabletoolderadults,information-sharingiscriticalintheeventofanemergency,andbuildingcontingenciesintransportationneedsisparamounttofacilitateaccesstomedicationsandmedicalservices,suchasdialysis,inthecaseofaninterruptionofpowerorservices.
RecommendationsforVillages
• Villagescancultivaterelationshipswithlocalresourcesthatpromoteemergencypreparedness(publichealth,emergencymanagement,andfirstresponders).Thisisimportantforvillages—especiallyforsmalltomid-sizevillagesthatlackthestaffingcapacityorresourcestodesigntheirownpreparednesseducationalmaterialsorcurriculum.Smallvillagesandthosewithresourceconstraintswereabletooffersomepreparednessprogrammingorguidancetotheirmemberswhentherewerelocalresourcesinthecommunity.
• Incaseswherelocalresourcesarelacking,thenationalVillagetoVillageNetworkresourcesmightoffertechnicalassistancebyprovidinginformationonthetypesofentitiesthatconductpreparednessandideasforhowvillageleaderscanmakeconnections,aswellasprovidingnationalpreparednessandresilienceresourcestailoredforolderadults.
• Havinglocalpreparednesspartnershipsandstrongprogrammingaroundpreparednessdoesnotguaranteeuptakebyvillagemembers;lackofmemberinterestand/orperceivedneedwasnotedasabarriertodoingeffectivepreparednesswork.
• However,ourinterviewsshowedahighinterestamongnearlyallvillages—andtheirmembers—relatedtoplanningfororpreventinghealthemergencyevents,andnearlyallvillagesofferedservicesrelatedtopreparingforhealthevents(e.g.,medicalalert
![Page 23: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
17
systemsandtheVialofLifeandFileofLifeprograms,whichaskparticipantstogathernecessarymedicationsandhealthinformationincaseofemergency).Thus,onecriticalwaytoincreasethesalienceofpreparednessactivitiestovillagesandtheirmembersisforadvocatesinthesecommunitiestofocusoncoreresilienceactivities.Theseareactivitiesthatcutacrossavarietyofhealthandmedicalstressesandemergencies,naturalandman-madedisasters,economicandsocialthreats,andstressesthatarepresenteverydayandnotjustduringalarge-scaledisaster—suchashavingalistofcontacts,documentationofhealthinformation,extrasuppliesonhand,andawaytocommunicatewithoutpower.Focusingontheseactivitiescouldmotivatepeoplewhoaremorecomfortablefocusingonday-to-dayquality-of-lifeissuesandstresses,ratherthanonpreparingforaneventthatmayormaynotoccur(e.g.,ahurricane).Villagemembersmaybemoremotivatedandwillingtoputtimeintotheseactivitiesiftheyperceivethemashavingbroadapplicabilityormultiplebenefitsbeyondthedisasterscenariothatmightbeeasiertoignoreasunlikely.
• Villagesneedtolearnmoreaboutplayinganeffectiveroleinpreparednessfortheirmembers.Severalvillageleadersseemedintimidatedbytheideaofsupportingpreparednessfortheirmembersbecauseoflackoftrainingorknowledgeortheinabilitytoprovidecomprehensiveservices.
• Villagesmayneedtobecoachedintounderstandingtheuniqueroleandvaluetheycanaddtopreparednessforolderadultsintheircommunities—namely,thatvillagescanbeatrustedbrokertoconnectmemberstootherservicesandinformation.Villagescanalsoworkwithpartnerstodevelopmessagingthatdrawsconnectionsbetweenresiliencedealingwitheverydaystressandhealth-relatedemergencypreparednessanddisasterresilience.
RecommendationsforPublicHealthDepartments
• Publichealthdepartmentsneedtobeabletoreacholderadultswhomightbesociallyisolatedandhavelimitedcommunicationorinformationchannels.Theycouldconsidertesting“reverse911”systemsthatenableemergencymanagementorotherauthoritiestodistributerecordedinformationtonon-cellularhometelephonenumbersthroughautomatedcallingandpromoting“opt-in”registries,inwhicholderadultscouldelecttomakefirstrespondersoremergencymanagementagenciesawareoftheirlocationandtheirneedssothattheycouldbelocatedandsupportedintheaftermathofanemergency.
• Publichealthdepartmentscouldconductorparticipateinresearchtoidentifybestpracticesrelatedtothesetypesofcommunicationandtrackingsystemsandhelp
![Page 24: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
18
disseminatethisinformationacrossAFCs,villages,andnationalnetworksofpublichealthdepartments.Tohelpdisseminatethesetrackingsystems,educationaleffortsmaybeneededtohelpolderadultsrecognizetheirassetsandvulnerabilities.Successfuldisseminationcouldspurcollaborationaroundthedevelopmentorenhancementofthesetypesofsystemsinotherlocations.Forexample,followingHurricaneKatrina,a2014studyinNewOrleanshighlightedpublichealtheffortstouseMedicaredatatoidentifyindividualswhouseelectricity-dependentmedicalequipmentinanefforttoimprovetheirdisasterpreparedness(DeSalvoetal.,2014).ThisspurredtheU.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServicestocreatetheemPOWERmapforhospitals,firstresponders,electriccompanies,andcommunitymemberstofindMedicarebeneficiarieswithelectricity-dependentequipmentwhomaybevulnerabletoprolongedpoweroutages(U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,2016).
• Healthandsocialservicesagenciesthathavecontactwitholderadults,suchashomecare,dialysiscenters,nursinghomes,andhospicecare,couldplayalargerroleinhelpingtheiruserspreparefordisasters.Theseagenciesshouldalsosetupcontinuity-of-operationsplanssothatthevitalmedicalornutritionalservicestheyprovidetheirclientsarenotdisruptedintheeventofanemergency.Healthcarecoalitionswerealsocitedascollaborativeorganizationsthatcanassistwithpreparednessforolderadults.ThesecoalitionsaredefinedbytheU.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServicesasamultiagencynetworkofhealthcareorganizationsandpublic-andprivate-sectorpartnersthatassistwithpreparedness,response,recovery,andmitigationactivitiesrelatedtohealthcareorganizationdisasteroperations(U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,undated).
RecommendationsforResearchers
Researchintoeffectivepreparednesspracticesforolderadultsisstilldevelopingasafield.Moreevaluationofexistingpracticesisneededtoidentifypromisingpractices,and,ultimately,evidence-basedpractices,forimprovingpreparednessandresilienceamongolderadults.
Inaddition,researchersneedtocontinuetotrackbarriersandprogresstowardaddressinggapsidentifiedinthisreport.
RecommendationsforPolicymakers
Giventheremaininggapsinpreparednessactivitiesforolderadultsandthelackofplansoradesignatedentitytoaddressthesegaps,policymakersatalllevelsofgovernment,particularlyatthestateandcommunitylevels,needtoagreeonaleadentitythatisaccountableforolder
![Page 25: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
19
adults’protectionandresilience.Currentfundingmechanismsforpublichealthdepartmentsdictatetheprioritizationofdeliverablesthat,inmostcases,donotrequiretailoringservicestoolderadults.Currentpoliciesthatneedtobeaddressedincludeconsiderationofolderadults’uniqueneedsinrespondingtodisasterandsubsequentrecovery.Governmentcouldalsoagreeonastandarddefinitionoftheseneeds,whichdifferfromtheneedsofvulnerablepopulationsatlarge,especiallybecauseofolderadults’highlevelofsocialisolation.BecauseAFCsandvillagesplayanimportantroleinhelpingolderadultsbolstertheirresilience,publichealthdepartmentsandothergovernmentleaderswithinjurisdictionsthatdonothaveanaging-in-placeeffortcanhelpanAFCorvillagebuildconnectionswiththoseorganizationstomoreformallyincorporatepreparednessofolderadultsattheoutset.
Giventheabilityofolderadultstogenerateandmobilizesocialcapitalafteradisaster,currentpolicyshouldalsoacknowledgethemasanasset.Engagingolderadultsinpreparednesseducationandimprovingtheirsocialcohesioncouldimprovenotonlytheirpreparednessbutalsotheirgeneralwell-being,providingsynergisticeffectsforbothpublichealthdepartmentsandaging-in-placeefforts.Experienceovertimewillsuggestadditionalspecificwaysthatolderadultscanbeleveragedasassets.GiventhechangingdemographiclandscapeoftheU.S.population,thebolsteringofolderadultpreparednessisakeywaytobuildcommunityresilience.
![Page 26: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
20
References
Acosta,J.D.,A.Chandra,andJ.Madrigano,AnAgendatoAdvanceIntegrativeResilienceResearchandPractice:KeyThemesfromaResilienceRoundtable,SantaMonica,Calif.:RANDCorporation,RR-1683-RWJ,2017.AsofDecember14,2017:https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR1683.html
Aldrich,N.,andW.F.Benson,“PeerReviewed:DisasterPreparednessandtheChronicDiseaseNeedsofVulnerableOlderAdults,”PreventingChronicDisease,Vol.5,No.1,2008,pp.1–7.
Al-Rousan,T.M.,L.M.Rubenstein,andR.B.Wallace,“PreparednessforNaturalDisastersAmongOlderU.S.Adults:ANationwideSurvey,”AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.104,No.3,2014,pp.506–511.
Bei,B.,C.Bryant,K.M.Gilson,J.Koh,P.Gibson,A.Komiti,H.Jackson,andF.Judd,“AProspectiveStudyoftheImpactofFloodsontheMentalandPhysicalHealthofOlderAdults,”Aging&MentalHealth,Vol.17,No.8,2013,pp.992–1002.
Benson,W.F.,andN.Aldrich,CDC’sDisasterPlanningGoal:ProtectVulnerableOlderAdults,Atlanta,Ga.:CDCHealthyAgingProgram,2007.
Brunkard,J.,G.Namulanda,andR.Ratard,“HurricaneKatrinaDeaths,Louisiana,2005,”DisasterMedicineandPublicHealthPreparedness,Vol.2,No.4,2008,pp.215–223.
CDC—seeCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,“HealthyPlacesTerminology,”lastreviewed
October15,2009.AsofNovember1,2017:https://www.cdc.gov/healthyplaces/terminology.htm
CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,IdentifyingVulnerableOlderAdultsandLegalOptionsforIncreasingTheirProtectionDuringAll-HazardsEmergencies:ACross-SectorGuideforStatesandCommunities,Atlanta,Ga.:U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,2012a.AsofNovember1,2017:https://www.cdc.gov/aging/emergency/pdf/guide.pdf
CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,“AuthoritiesAddressingVulnerableOlderAdults,”lastupdatedMarch14,2012b.AsofNovember1,2017:https://www.cdc.gov/aging/emergency/legal/federal.htm
Chandra,A.,J.Acosta,S.Howard,L.Uscher-Pines,M.Williams,D.Yeung,J.Garnett,andL.Meredith,BuildingCommunityResiliencetoDisasters:AWayForwardtoEnhanceNationalHealthSecurity,SantaMonica,Calif.:RANDCorporation,TR-915-DHHS,2011.AsofDecember14,2017:https://www.rand.org/pubs/technical_reports/TR915.html
![Page 27: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
21
DeSalvo,K.,N.Lurie,K.Finne,C.Worrall,A.Bogdanov,A.Dinkler,S.Babcock,andJ.Kelman,“UsingMedicareDatatoIdentifyIndividualsWhoAreElectricityDependenttoImproveDisasterPreparednessandResponse,”AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.104,No.7,2014,pp.1160–1164.
Greenfield,E.A.,“UsingEcologicalFrameworkstoAdvanceaFieldofResearch,Practice,andPolicyonAging-in-PlaceInitiatives,”TheGerontologist,Vol.52,No.1,2012,pp.1–12.
Howard,A.,T.Blakemore,andM.Bevis,"OlderPeopleasAssetsinDisasterPreparedness,Response,andRecovery:LessonsfromRegionalAustralia,”Ageing&Society,Vol.37,No.3,2017,pp.517–536.
Keim,M.E.,“BuildingHumanResilience:TheRoleofPublicHealthPreparednessandResponseasanAdaptationtoClimateChange,”AmericanJournalofPreventiveMedicine,Vol.35,No.5,2008,pp.508–516.
Komisar,H.L.,J.Feder,andJ.D.Kasper,“UnmetLong-TermCareNeeds:AnAnalysisofMedicare-MedicaidDualEligibles,”INQUIRY:TheJournalofHealthCareOrganization,Provision,andFinancing,Vol.42,No.2,2005,pp.171–182.
Levac,J.,D.Toal-Sullivan,andT.L.O’Sullivan,“HouseholdEmergencyPreparedness:ALiteratureReview,”JournalofCommunityHealth,Vol.37,No.3,2012,pp.725–733.
Malik,S.,D.C.Lee,K.M.Doran,C.R.Grudzen,J.Worthing,I.Portelli,L.R.Goldfrank,andS.W.Smith,“VulnerabilityofOlderAdultsinDisasters:EmergencyDepartmentUtilizationbyGeriatricPatientsAfterHurricaneSandy,”DisasterMedicineandPublicHealthPreparedness,Vol.44,2017,pp.1–10.
NationalAssociationofAreaAgenciesonAging,NationalCouncilonAging,andUnitedHealthcare,TheUnitedStatesofAgingSurvey,2012.AsofNovember1,2017:https://www.aarp.org/content/dam/aarp/livable-communities/learn/research/the-united-states-of-aging-survey-2012-aarp.pdf
NationalAssociationofAreaAgenciesonAging,NationalCouncilonAging,andUnitedHealthcare,TheUnitedStatesofAgingSurvey,2015.AsofDecember12,2017:https://www.ncoa.org/resources/usa15-full-report-pdf/
NationalAssociationofInsuranceCommissioners,CenterforInsurancePolicyandResearch,“NaturalCatastropheResponse,”lastupdatedJuly28,2017.AsofNovember1,2017:http://www.naic.org/cipr_topics/topic_catastrophe.htm
NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministration,NationalCentersforEnvironmentalInformation,“Billion-DollarWeatherandClimateDisasters:TableofEvents,”2017.AsofNovember1,2017:https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/billions/events/US/1980-2017
U.S.CensusBureau,“ProfileAmericaFactsforFeatures—OlderAmericansMonth:May2017,”March27,2017.AsofNovember1,2017:
![Page 28: Improving Disaster Resilience Among Older Adults · Older adults can also contribute important assets to disaster response. A 2017 qualitative study of 17 focus groups with at-risk](https://reader035.vdocuments.mx/reader035/viewer/2022071213/603ae8b22aa1676c3b56743b/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
22
https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/newsroom/facts-for-features/2017/cb17-ff08.pdf
U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,AssistantSecretaryforPreparednessandResponse,“HospitalPreparednessProgram:AnIntroduction,”undated.AsofNovember1,2017:https://www.phe.gov/Preparedness/planning/hpp/Documents/hpp-intro-508-old.pdf
U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,“HHSemPOWERMap2.0,”lastupdatedDecember30,2016.AsofNovember1,2017:https://empowermap.hhs.gov
Weisler,R.H.,J.G.BarbeeIV,andM.H.Townsend,“MentalHealthandRecoveryintheGulfCoastAfterHurricanesKatrinaandRita,”JAMA,Vol.296,No.5,2006,pp.585–588.
Whitman,S.,G.Good,E.R.Donoghue,N.Benbow,W.Shou,andS.Mou,“MortalityinChicagoAttributedtotheJuly1995HeatWave,”AmericanJournalofPublicHealth,Vol.87,No.9,1997,pp.1515–1518.
WorldHealthOrganization,“Age-FriendlyinPractice,”2017.AsofNovember1,2017:https://extranet.who.int/agefriendlyworld/age-friendly-in-practice/