Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle

Dep

arta

men

to d

e Ju

stic

ia y

A

dmin

istr

ació

n Pú

blic

a 2011 A

lberto Ortiz de Zárate

a-ortizdezarate@ej-gv.es @alorza

The public policy cicle

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

FIRST RING:

A simplified version of the key stages of the public policy cycle

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

FIRST RING:

A simplified version of the key stages of the public policy cycle

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

imagine

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

FIRST RING:

A simplified version of the key stages of the public policy cycle

assess

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

imagine

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

FIRST RING:

A simplified version of the key stages of the public policy cycle

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

FIRST RING:

A simplified version of the key stages of the public policy cycle

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

account-ability

SECOND RING:

Core subjects, from the OPEN point of view

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

public deliberation

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

SECOND RING:

Core subjects, from the OPEN point of view

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

public deliberation

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

SECOND RING:

Core subjects, from the OPEN point of view

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

SECOND RING:

Core subjects, from the OPEN point of view

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

transparency

THIRD RING:

The Open Government values

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

THIRD RING:

The Open Government values

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

THIRD RING:

The Open Government values

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

THIRD RING:

The Open Government values

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

citizen control

OUTER SPACE:

Political issues

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

citizen control

deliberative dem

ocracy

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

OUTER SPACE:

Political issues

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

deliberative dem

ocracy

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

OUTER SPACE:

Political issues

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

THE PARCHEESI FOR PUBLIC POLICY

You can start on any color, but always within the Open Government’s main rule:

-you'll never walk alone!

OUTER SPACE:

Political issues

Levels of openness

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

INFORMATION:

0 degree of openness: no power devolution

Emisor/transmitter: public authorities

Can/should include feedback

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

INFORMATION:

0 degree of openness: no power devolution

Emisor/transmitter: public authorities

Can/should include feedback

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

public exhibition

INFORMATION:

0 degree of openness: no power devolution

Emisor/transmitter: public authorities

Can/should include feedback

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

public exhibition

information on decisions taken

INFORMATION:

0 degree of openness: no power devolution

Emisor/transmitter: public authorities

Can/should include feedback

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

public exhibition

information on decisions taken

publicity of achievem

ents

INFORMATION:

0 degree of openness: no power devolution

Emisor/transmitter: public authorities

Can/should include feedback

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

CONSULTATION:

Intermediate degree of openness: some power is devolved to citizens

It represents a conversational government system

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

CONSULTATION:

Intermediate degree of openness: some power is devolved to citizens

It represents a conversational government system

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

assessment + opinion

CONSULTATION:

Intermediate degree of openness: some power is devolved to citizens

It represents a conversational government system

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

betastate

CONSULTATION:

Intermediate degree of openness: some power is devolved to citizens

It represents a conversational government system

assessment + opinion

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

DELEGATION:

Highest degree of openness: devolving the power to citizens

Decentralized network approach for some issues, in which the Government can be only an important node

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

DELEGATION:

Highest degree of openness: devolving the power to citizens

Decentralized network approach for some issues, in which the Government can be only an important node

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

citizen rating

DELEGATION:

Highest degree of openness: devolving the power to citizens

Decentralized network approach for some issues, in which the Government can be only an important node

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

open innovation

DELEGATION:

Highest degree of openness: devolving the power to citizens

Decentralized network approach for some issues, in which the Government can be only an important node

citizen rating

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

delegation of decisions

DELEGATION:

Highest degree of openness: devolving the power to citizens

Decentralized network approach for some issues, in which the Government can be only an important node

citizen rating

open innovation

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGov

participation

participation

collaboration

transparency

public deliberation

joint execution

consensus building

account-ability

imagine

make

decide

assess

direct democracy

citizen control

civil society

deliberative dem

ocracy

responiability + subsidiarity

DELEGATION:

Highest degree of openness: devolving the power to citizens

Decentralized network approach for some issues, in which the Government can be only an important node

citizen rating

open innovation

delegation of decisions

Identifying your public program

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGOV RADAR:

0 = information

1 = consultation

2 = delegation

assess

decide

imaginemake

012

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGOV RADAR:

0 = information

1 = consultation

2 = delegation

assess

decide

imaginemake

012

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

oGOV RADAR:

0 = information

1 = consultation

2 = delegation

assess

decide

imaginemake

012

What is missing from this model?

Implementing the Open Government principles to the public policy cycle 2011 Alberto Ortiz de Zárate

DEEP LISTENING:

Incorporating the voice of citizens who do not formally participate in an open government initiative

And incorporate other voices in the assessment, deliberation, consensus building ... and detect cases of public value creation by the civic society

thanks | moltes graciès | gracias

Alberto Ortiz de Zárate Terceroa-ortizdezarate@ej-gv.eshttp://eadminblog.netlinkedin.com/in/alorza@alorza