impact of overnight separation on wounding frequency in … · data collection and analyses 2....

1
6. Discussion & Implications There is a significant relationship between wounding in bachelor groups and overnight housing practices, but it must be contextualized to demographic factors such as age and social history. In groups that have been together as a social unit for longer (6+ years), total wounding is lower for groups that are separated overnight while wounding is higher in groups that are housed together overnight (Fig. 1). For groups introduced at previous facilities, wounding is lower in groups that are separated overnight. Among groups that are housed together overnight, groups that were introduced at their current facility had lower rates of wounding than groups who were introduced either at previous facilities or had originated in mixed-sex family groups together (Fig. 2). Older individuals (mature silverbacks 18+ years of age) received significantly more wounds than younger individuals (young silverbacks, blackbacks, and subadults under 18 years of age) if and only if groups are kept together overnight. (Fig. 3). It is likely that overnight housing will be an increasing factor in wounding rate the longer that a social unit remains intact and the older group members become. In partnership with group behavioral assessments, we recommend that groups with long (6+ years) social histories or primarily adult (14+ years) members be separated overnight should housing facilities allow for separation. Distributed surveys covered a broad range of topics including demographics and histories for both groups and individuals, management practices surrounding training, feeding and housing, wounding, and facility design. We divided the compiled data into a set for social groups and a set for individuals. In addition to separating individuals by age, we also subcategorized them as “young” (<18 yrs) and “old” (>18 yrs) to allow for more in-depth analysis of age factors. We ran a set of two-way ANOVA models to examine variation in wounding by group duration, introduction history, and individual age within the context of overnight housing practices. 4. Data Collection and Analyses 2. Objectives of the Study Evaluate the impact of overnight housing practices on wounding rates Assess which group and individual factors contribute to wounding frequency 3. Subjects We collected survey data from 19 organizations totaling representation of 59 individual gorillas and 21 social groups. 5. Results 1. Background Many initial and continuing concerns within the management of bachelor groups in human care focus on the potential for elevated aggression and wounding. Despite the inherent challenges of maintaining bachelor units over long periods and concerns over aggression and wounding, bachelor units have emerged as stable housing solutions. Repeated studies have demonstrated that age (particularly presence of young silverbacks), not group type, is a significant influencing factor on wounding rate in zoo-managed gorillas [1,2] . However, continued investigations into factors which may exacerbate or mitigate wounding are vital for continued management improvement. Impact of Overnight Separation on Wounding Frequency in Bachelor Groups of Western Lowland Gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla) Kylen N. Gartland 1 , Jodi Carrigan 2 , and Frances J. White 1 1 Department of Anthropology, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon 2 Zoo Atlanta, Atlanta, Georgia Acknowledgments We would like to thank the Western Lowland Gorilla SSP for their endorsement of this study and all participating AZA zoos who contributed data. Group-Level Results There was a significant relationship between group duration, overnight housing, and wounding (F=4.84, df=3,17, p=0.013) (Fig. 1). There was a significant relationship between introduction history, overnight housing, and wounding (F=3.51, df=3,17, p=0.038) (Fig. 2). Individual Results There was a significant relationship between individual age, overnight housing, and wounding (F=1.90, df=31,28, p=0.045). For individuals housed together overnight, there was significant variation in wounding depending on whether individuals are “old” or “young” (F=5.29, df=1,28, p=0.029) (Fig. 3). References [1 Stoinski, T.S., Lukas, K.E., Kuhar, C.W., 2013. Effects of age and group type on social behaviour of male western gorillas (gorilla gorilla gorilla) in North American zoos. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 147, 316–323. [2] Leeds, A., Boyer, D., Ross, S.R., Lukas, K.E., 2015. The effects of group type and young silverbacks on wounding rates in western lowland gorilla (Gorilla gorilla gorilla) groups in North American zoos. Zoo Biol. 34, 296– 304. Fig. 1: Interaction of Group Duration and Overnight Housing Practices in the Context of Average Wounding Rate Fig. 3: Wounding in Young versus Old Individuals when Separated Overnight and Housed Together Overnight Fig. 2: Interaction of Group Introductions and Overnight Housing Practices in the Context of Total Group Wounding

Upload: others

Post on 09-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Impact of Overnight Separation on Wounding Frequency in … · Data Collection and Analyses 2. Objectives of the Study • Evaluate the impact of overnight housing practices on wounding

6. Discussion & Implications

• There is a significant relationship between woundingin bachelor groups and overnight housing practices,but it must be contextualized to demographic factorssuch as age and social history.

• In groups that have been together as a social unit forlonger (6+ years), total wounding is lower for groupsthat are separated overnight while wounding is higherin groups that are housed together overnight (Fig. 1).

• For groups introduced at previous facilities, woundingis lower in groups that are separated overnight.

• Among groups that are housed together overnight,groups that were introduced at their current facilityhad lower rates of wounding than groups who wereintroduced either at previous facilities or hadoriginated in mixed-sex family groups together (Fig.2).

• Older individuals (mature silverbacks 18+ years of age)received significantly more wounds than youngerindividuals (young silverbacks, blackbacks, andsubadults under 18 years of age) if and only if groupsare kept together overnight. (Fig. 3).

• It is likely that overnight housing will be an increasingfactor in wounding rate the longer that a social unitremains intact and the older group members become.

• In partnership with group behavioral assessments, werecommend that groups with long (6+ years) socialhistories or primarily adult (14+ years) members beseparated overnight should housing facilities allow forseparation.

Distributed surveys covered a broad range of topics includingdemographics and histories for both groups and individuals,management practices surrounding training, feeding andhousing, wounding, and facility design.

We divided the compiled data into a set for social groups and aset for individuals. In addition to separating individuals by age,we also subcategorized them as “young” (<18 yrs) and “old”(>18 yrs) to allow for more in-depth analysis of age factors.

We ran a set of two-way ANOVA models to examine variation inwounding by group duration, introduction history, andindividual age within the context of overnight housing practices.

4. Data Collection and Analyses

2. Objectives of the Study

• Evaluate the impact of overnight housing practices onwounding rates

• Assess which group and individual factors contribute towounding frequency

3. Subjects

We collected survey data from 19 organizations totalingrepresentation of 59 individual gorillas and 21 social groups.

5. Results 1. Background

Many initial and continuing concerns within the managementof bachelor groups in human care focus on the potential forelevated aggression and wounding. Despite the inherentchallenges of maintaining bachelor units over long periods andconcerns over aggression and wounding, bachelor units haveemerged as stable housing solutions. Repeated studies havedemonstrated that age (particularly presence of youngsilverbacks), not group type, is a significant influencing factor onwounding rate in zoo-managed gorillas [1,2]. However, continuedinvestigations into factors which may exacerbate or mitigatewounding are vital for continued management improvement.

Impact of Overnight Separation on Wounding Frequency in

Bachelor Groups of Western Lowland Gorillas

(Gorilla gorilla gorilla)Kylen N. Gartland1 , Jodi Carrigan2, and Frances J. White1

1Department of Anthropology, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon2Zoo Atlanta, Atlanta, Georgia

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank the Western Lowland Gorilla SSP for theirendorsement of this study and all participating AZA zoos whocontributed data.

• Group-Level Results• There was a significant relationship between group

duration, overnight housing, and wounding(F=4.84, df=3,17, p=0.013) (Fig. 1).

• There was a significant relationship betweenintroduction history, overnight housing, andwounding (F=3.51, df=3,17, p=0.038) (Fig. 2).

• Individual Results• There was a significant relationship between

individual age, overnight housing, and wounding(F=1.90, df=31,28, p=0.045).

• For individuals housed together overnight, therewas significant variation in wounding dependingon whether individuals are “old” or “young”(F=5.29, df=1,28, p=0.029) (Fig. 3).

References

[1 Stoinski, T.S., Lukas, K.E., Kuhar, C.W., 2013. Effects of age and group type on social behaviour of male western gorillas (gorilla gorilla gorilla) in North American zoos. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 147, 316–323.

[2] Leeds, A., Boyer, D., Ross, S.R., Lukas, K.E., 2015. The effects of grouptype and young silverbacks on wounding rates in western lowland gorilla(Gorilla gorilla gorilla) groups in North American zoos. Zoo Biol. 34, 296–304.

Fig. 1: Interaction of Group Duration and Overnight Housing Practices in the Context of Average Wounding Rate

Fig. 3: Wounding in Young versus Old Individuals when Separated Overnight and Housed Together Overnight

Fig. 2: Interaction of Group Introductions and Overnight Housing Practices in the Context of Total Group Wounding