iahperd poster 2014 (1)

1
BLOOD FLOW ADAPTATIONS IN BASEBALL PITCHERS Jesse Nelson 1 ; Kevin Laudner, PhD, ATC 1 ; Nick Burke, ATC 1 ; Noelle Selkow, PhD, ATC 1 ; Keith Meister, MD 2 1 School of Kinesiology & Recreation, Illinois State University, Normal, IL; 2 Texas Metroplex Institute for Sports Medicine and Orthopedics, Arlington, TX INTRODUCTION There has been a recent increase in the diagnoses of upper extremity neurovascular injuries among baseball players. 1,2 The repetitive nature of baseball which causes various adaptations in shoulder flexibility and strength may cause similar alterations of the vascular tissue. An improved understanding of these potential adaptations may aide in the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of vascular pathologies among baseball players. PURPOSE METHODS Participants 20 professional baseball pitchers and 16 position players volunteered to participate in this study (Table 1). Table 1. Participant demographics. All participants had no recent history of upper extremity injury or any upper extremity surgery. All participants provided informed consent prior to testing as mandated by the university’s institutional review board. REFERENCES ILLINOIS STATE UNIVERSITY Procedures To determine if blood flow among pitchers and position players changes after a competitive baseball season. Following the competitive baseball season, the pitchers had significantly less blood flow volume when in the provocative shoulder position (p = 0.009) (Table 1). There was no difference in the blood flow of pitchers with the shoulder in a resting position (p = 0.48) (Table 2). Following a competitive baseball season, pitchers had significantly less blood flow in a provocative position compared to position players. These results should be considered in the prevention, diagnoses, and treatment of the various upper extremity neurovascular pathologies common among baseball players. CONCLUSION Our results support these previous findings and additionally show that a further decrease in blood flow is present among pitchers when provocatively tested following a single competitive season. Standard current methods of testing may not show as clearly a decrease in flow if the arm is not provoked. As this study and prior studies have shown, a position of rest or arm positions of less than extremes of abduction and external rotation, may not elucidate the severity of the problem in a measurable way. Blood Flow Measurement Blood flow measurements were taken at the beginning of two consecutive competitive seasons using a Terason t3000 M-series diagnostic ultrasound (Teratech, Burlington, MA) Blood flow was measured in the following positions: Standing with test arm at participants side Standing with test shoulder abducted, retracted, and externally rotated until diminution of radial pulse (Figure 1). 1. Rohrer MJ, Cardullo PA, Pappas AM, Phillips DA, Wheeler HB. J Vasc Surg. 1990. 2. Duwayri YM, Emery VB, Driskill MR, Earley JA, Wright RW, Paletta GA, Jr., Thompson RW. J Vasc Surg. 2011. 3. Laudner KG, Selkow NM, Burke NC, Lynall RC, Meister K. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2014. DISCUSSION The provocative position used in our study is similar to the late cocked position of the throwing motion. Recent research has shown that baseball pitchers have less blood flow than position players when the arm is assessed in a provocative position, but not while at rest. 3 RESULTS We conducted separate one-way analyses of variance tests to compare year 1 and year 2 blood flows for both groups using IBM SPSS Statistics 20 (p<0.05). ILLINOIS STATE UNIVERSITY Statistical Analysis Pitchers Year 1 Year 2 Difference Resting 26.4±12.8 26.2±8.2 -0.19±15.2 Provocative* 20.7±6.7 14.7±7.3 -5.6±9.5 Position Players Year 1 Year 2 Difference Resting 21.3±15.1 24.6±11.9 3.4±14.3 Provocative 15.6±7.6 12.8±4.8 -2.8±8.5 Figure 1. Blood flow measurement in provocative position. The position players did not have any changes in blood flow between years while in either the rest (p = 0.18) or provocative test positions (p = 0.11) (Table 3). Group Age (yrs) Height (cm) Mass (kg) Pitchers 22.1±1.5 188.2±6.6 94.3±10.1 Position Players 21.4±2.2 182.2±3.0 89.9±5.8 Table 2. Year-to-Year Changes in Pitchers Blood Flow (mean ± standard deviation in ml/min) *Indicates statistically significant difference over time (p=0.009). Table 3. Year-to-Year Changes in Position Players Blood Flow (mean ± standard deviation in ml/min)

Upload: jesse-nelson

Post on 22-Jan-2018

99 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IAHPERD Poster 2014 (1)

BLOOD FLOW ADAPTATIONS IN BASEBALL PITCHERSJesse Nelson1; Kevin Laudner, PhD, ATC1; Nick Burke, ATC1;

Noelle Selkow, PhD, ATC1; Keith Meister, MD2

1School of Kinesiology & Recreation, Illinois State University, Normal, IL; 2Texas Metroplex Institute for Sports Medicine and Orthopedics, Arlington, TX

INTRODUCTION

• There has been a recent increase in the

diagnoses of upper extremity

neurovascular injuries among baseball

players.1,2

• The repetitive nature of baseball which

causes various adaptations in shoulder

flexibility and strength may cause similar

alterations of the vascular tissue.

• An improved understanding of these

potential adaptations may aide in the

prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of

vascular pathologies among baseball

players.

PURPOSE

METHODSParticipants

• 20 professional baseball pitchers and 16

position players volunteered to

participate in this study (Table 1).

Table 1. Participant demographics.

• All participants had no recent history of

upper extremity injury or any upper

extremity surgery.

• All participants provided informed

consent prior to testing as mandated by

the university’s institutional review

board.

REFERENCES

ILLINOIS STATE UNIVERSITY

Procedures

• To determine if blood flow among

pitchers and position players changes

after a competitive baseball season.

• Following the competitive baseball

season, the pitchers had significantly

less blood flow volume when in the

provocative shoulder position (p =

0.009) (Table 1).

• There was no difference in the blood

flow of pitchers with the shoulder in a

resting position (p = 0.48) (Table 2).

• Following a competitive baseball

season, pitchers had significantly less

blood flow in a provocative position

compared to position players.

• These results should be considered in

the prevention, diagnoses, and

treatment of the various upper

extremity neurovascular pathologies

common among baseball players.

CONCLUSION

• Our results support these previous

findings and additionally show that a

further decrease in blood flow is

present among pitchers when

provocatively tested following a

single competitive season.

• Standard current methods of testing

may not show as clearly a decrease

in flow if the arm is not provoked. As

this study and prior studies have

shown, a position of rest or arm

positions of less than extremes of

abduction and external rotation, may

not elucidate the severity of the

problem in a measurable way.

Blood Flow Measurement

• Blood flow measurements were taken

at the beginning of two consecutive

competitive seasons using a Terason

t3000 M-series diagnostic ultrasound

(Teratech, Burlington, MA)

• Blood flow was measured in the

following positions:

– Standing with test arm at

participants side

– Standing with test shoulder

abducted, retracted, and externally

rotated until diminution of radial

pulse (Figure 1).

1. Rohrer MJ, Cardullo PA, Pappas AM,

Phillips DA, Wheeler HB. J Vasc Surg.

1990.

2. Duwayri YM, Emery VB, Driskill MR,

Earley JA, Wright RW, Paletta GA, Jr.,

Thompson RW. J Vasc Surg. 2011.

3. Laudner KG, Selkow NM, Burke NC,

Lynall RC, Meister K. J Shoulder Elbow

Surg. 2014.

DISCUSSION• The provocative position used in our

study is similar to the late cocked

position of the throwing motion.

• Recent research has shown that

baseball pitchers have less blood

flow than position players when the

arm is assessed in a provocative

position, but not while at rest.3

RESULTS

• We conducted separate one-way

analyses of variance tests to compare

year 1 and year 2 blood flows for both

groups using IBM SPSS Statistics 20

(p<0.05).

ILLINOIS STATE

UNIVERSITY

Statistical Analysis

Pitchers Year 1 Year 2 Difference

Resting 26.4±12.8 26.2±8.2 -0.19±15.2

Provocative* 20.7±6.7 14.7±7.3 -5.6±9.5

Position

Players

Year 1 Year 2 Difference

Resting 21.3±15.1 24.6±11.9 3.4±14.3

Provocative 15.6±7.6 12.8±4.8 -2.8±8.5

Figure 1. Blood flow measurement in

provocative position.

• The position players did not have any

changes in blood flow between years

while in either the rest (p = 0.18) or

provocative test positions (p = 0.11)

(Table 3).

Group Age (yrs) Height (cm) Mass (kg)

Pitchers 22.1±1.5 188.2±6.6 94.3±10.1

Position

Players

21.4±2.2 182.2±3.0 89.9±5.8

Table 2. Year-to-Year Changes in Pitchers Blood

Flow (mean ± standard deviation in ml/min)

*Indicates statistically significant difference over

time (p=0.009).

Table 3. Year-to-Year Changes in Position

Players Blood Flow (mean ± standard

deviation in ml/min)