hse assignment 3 final
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
1/21
HEALTH SAFETY AND
ENVIRONMENT
Assignment 3
CASE STUDY OF AUTOMOBILE WORKSHOP
GROUP MEMBERS : LUQMAN HAKIM BIN ROSLI 16098
CHAN SIN WEI 16173
POR HONG YANG 16148
ABDULQODOS MOHAMMED AL-ORABI 1780
ARE!OO SHAHRA!AD 1774
LEC"URER#S NAME : DR ABRAR INAYA"
Table of Content
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
2/21
1. Summary
2. Introduction of Case Study
3. Developing risk scenario4. ustification of t!e met!od used
". #rocedure of met!od
$. %ault Tree Dra&ing'. Identifying and assessing all possible risks &it! !a(ards
). Conse*uences if an accident occurs
+. ,et!od of controlling t!e risk1-. Solution to minimi(e risk
11. Conclusion
12. eference
Summary
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
3/21
In t!is case study/ &e &ill be talking about t!e various !a(ards and t!e risk associated &it! t!em
in our industry of interest/ automotive &orks!op. 0e &ill be focusing mainly on t!e &orks!ops
activities suc! as t!e type of &ork for everyday operation and t!e !a(ards t!at come &it! t!at
&orking operation. 0e &ill be discussing &!at kind of !a(ards a &orker is eposed to and t!e
risks !e may face. %or t!is matter/ &e &ill use %ault Tree nalysis to create a risk scenario to
better understand t!e !a(ards and risks. In addition/ &e &ill also be discussing t!e advantages
and disadvantages of using %T and look at t!e procedure of %T to fully understand it. %inally/
after all t!e !a(ards and risks !ave been identified/ &e &ill proceed to discuss t!e met!ods and
solutions to rectify t!e problems.
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
4/21
Introduction to Case Study
0e !ave decided to make automotive factory as our case study for our ealt! Safety
5nvironment 6S57 assignment.
In ,alaysia/ automotive manufacturing !as contributed to t!e nations annual income. T!is
industry !as !elped t!e country make a !uge fortune by selling t!e automobiles locally or
eporting to ot!er countries. %urt!ermore/ t!e country !as also successfully attracted prestigious
automotive brands from overseas suc! as 8,0/ ,ercedes98en( and onda to build t!eir
assemble plants in t!e country. T!ere are currently 2) automotive companies from overseas to
date. T!is in turn !as created a :ob opportunity for ,alaysians as &ell as foreign &orker to
involve t!emselves in t!is industry so as to cater t!e needs of t!e rapid9gro&ing industry.
;nfortunately/ every year too many people are in:ured &!ile &orking in automotive &orks!ops.
In:uries are considered as a menace to t!e industry as &ell as for t!e &orkers. 0orkers are
constantly eposed to uncertain !a(ards t!at could be life9t!reatening. ccording to
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
5/21
of t!e systems of &ork used by employees and t!e proper training and supervision of employees
to keep t!em safe at &ork. egulations made under t!e ct provide additional instruction on !o&
particular !a(ards/ suc! as asbestos/ !a(ardous substances/ manual !andling and plant/ are to be
managed. 5mployees also !ave t!eir o&n duty to take reasonable care for t!eir o&n !ealt! and
safety at &ork and to avoid endangering t!e !ealt! and safety of any ot!er person by anyt!ing
t!ey do/ or fail to do/ at t!e &orkplace.
s &e kno&/ accidents are avoidable at some costs if necessary safety measures are considered at
t!e &orkplace. It is !ig! time t!at risks at automotive &orks!ops s!ould be minimised to protect
t!e lives of &orkers. ,aking t!e environment safer is important so t!at every &orker &ill feel
comfortable &!ile &orking &it! !a(ardous components and mac!inery. %or t!is assignment/ &e
!ope to develop a risk scenario at t!e automotive factory and find a solution to minimise t!e risk.
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
6/21
Developing risk scenario
Various Hazards in Automotive Workshop
s mentioned earlier in t!e introduction/ our pro:ect is focused on t!e events and activities t!at
!appens in automotive &orks!op. T!e construction and repair process of automobiles gives a lotof benefits to mankind but one must not forget t!e !a(ard t!at comes &it! t!e :ob. 0!ile t!e :ob
scope seemed &it! increasing &ork related eperience/ t!e !a(ard faced everyday by t!e &orkers
pose a great deal of problem to t!e &orker and surrounding.
mong t!e !a(ards t!at are present in automotive &orks!op are listed belo& in t!eir respective
areas
Working with automotive vehicles in the workshop
17 8usy traffic and no eclusion (ones or barriers for specified areas or &orkplaces for cars
and &orkers.27 ;nsupervised usage of ve!icles &it!out clearance &it!in t!e &orks!op37 ;nmonitored civilian movement &it!in dangerous area suc! as near po&er tools and too
close to ve!icle repairing area
47 Be!icle in repair not tied do&n properly
"7 ;nmaintained floors of t!e &orks!op suc! as oil spill and uneven or cracked floor
$7 ;nsafe &ork conditions suc! as &orking near !ig!ly flammable or !armful c!emical
materials
'7 ;sage of po&er tools and e*uipment &it!out certificate of competency
Usage o liting e!uipment
17 ;sage of damaged or uninspected ve!icle !oists
27 ;nmaintained !ydraulic and trolley :acks. o ve!icle stands used &!en ve!icle is raised
by !ydraulic :ack
37 ;nsecured ve!icle ramps &!ic! may cause ve!icle movement
Storage and "acking o #arts
17 ;nbalanced and tyres stacked too !ig! &!ic! !as a !ig! c!ances of tyres falling27 Tyre or parts storage racking above s!oulder !eig!t
37 ;nsecured ladders to pick up parts
47 Tyres or !eavy e*uipment lifted or moved by !and instead of assisting e*uipment
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
7/21
Handling o heavy parts
17 5ngines t!at needs to be replaced are removed &it!out calculations on t!e strengt! of
supporting e*uipment
27 #arts are removed &it!out !andling aids
"isk Scenario
ll t!e !a(ards t!at are commonly meet during t!e &orking period inside t!e &orks!op !ave
been listed before!and. To better understand all t!e !a(ard listed/ it is best &e see !o& t!ey relate
to eac! ot!er. 8elo& is a risk scenario developed by using fault tree analysis.
Top event Serious #ersonnel In:ury> in all &orking eperience/ &e take precaution to avoid
getting in:ured at &ork.
%irst case serious personnel in:ury can come in many factor/ one of t!em is &it! an accident
&it! a repair ve!icle. ormally/ a repair ve!icle re*uires t!at it be !oisted up in order to accesst!e lo&er part of t!e ve!icle but sometimes t!e ve!icle can move or slip t!us resulting in an
accident bet&een t!e ve!icle and t!e &orker. T!e slipping can come from 2 factor/ eit!er t!e
!andbrake of t!e ve!icle &as turned off or t!e c!ocks for t!e &!eels are damages. ccident &it!
t!e repair ve!icle can also come from eternal factor suc! as an unsupervised driving from
civilian into t!e &ork area &!ic! is caused by confusion of t!e customer. 0!en t!ere is no
specific &aiting area for t!e customer to drop off !is or !er ve!icle/ s!e or !e mig!t drive into
t!e &orks!op &it!out supervision resulting in an accident
Second case serious personnel in:ury can also come from a simple case of tripping &!ile
&orking. T!e main reason from tripping is from an oil spill &!ic! &as left alone &it!out any
cleaning or covering. T!is result in a !ig! c!ance of slipping in &!ic! t!e &orker mig!t slip and
fall
T!ird case t!e least probable event in &!ic! a &orker could get !urt is if s!e or !e carries
!eavy parts of t!e ve!icle &it!out any !andling aid. s t!e parts are sometimes very !eavy/ for
eample t!e engine/ t!e &eig!t mig!t be too muc! too bear and can result in dropping and !itting
a &orker.
$ethod to develop the risk scenario
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
8/21
s mentioned earlier/ &e !ave developed a risk scenario from all t!e !a(ards t!at !ave been
identified in t!e &orks!op. o&ever/ to develop a good and efficient risk scenario is difficult if
t!e met!ods to create t!em are not used. To develop a risk scenario/ &e can eit!er use %ault Tree
nalysis/ 5vent Tree or EA#. %or our risk analysis/ &e !ave c!osen t!e %ault Tree nalysis.
0!at is a %ault Tree nalysisF
%ault Tree nalysis or %T in its simplicity is a top do&n approac! starting &it! t!e un&anted
conse*uences as t!e top event and identifying all possible factors t!at could contribute to t!e top
event. %T is a failure analysis tec!ni*ue/ it involves eamining preceding events t!at leads up to
t!e top event &!ic! is a normally a system failure. %T are deductive met!od for identifying
&ays in &!ic! !a(ards can lead to an accident.
T!e procedure of developing t!e fault tree is s!o&n belo&.
%ault Tree nalysis
1. Determine t!e most undesirable event &!ic! is considered t!e Top 5vent. T!e Top 5vent
must only be one.2. %rom t!e Top 5vent/ &e must determine t!e events t!at contribute to it. T!e number of
contributing events can be as many as possible.
3. %rom t!e contributing event t!at causes t!e Top 5vent/ &e must identify t!e relations!ip
bet&een t!em in terms of D and A gates.4. If t!ere are any events t!at leads to t!e contributing events/ &!ic! are called 8asic
5vents/ it must also be listed in t!e %ault Tree. T!e 8asic 5vents can be as many as
possible.
". T!e relations!ip bet&een t!e 8asic 5vents and t!e contributing events must also be
identify.
T!ere are many uses for %T/ belo& are some of t!em
;nderstanding t!e logic leading to t!e top event
#rioriti(ing t!e contributing events t!at causes t!e top event To assist in designing a more efficient system
s a diagnostic tool to identify and correct causes of t!e top event
%ustiication o the method
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
9/21
0!y do &e use %T to create t!e risk analysisF T!e ans&er is simply because t!e advantages of
using it is more t!an t!e disadvantages.
dvantages of %T
It is very simple to understand at first glance and t!e contributing events t!at can be
easily interpreted.
It can be used to s!o& multiple failures or combinations of failures t!at leads to t!e top
event.
T!e pat! t!at leads to t!e top event can easily be seen and rectified.
T!e pat! generated is easily understood by &orkers to avoid doing t!e events.
Disadvantages of %T
To understand t!e events re*uire deep kno&ledge of t!e system and t!e &ork situation
ot practical on systems &it! large numbers of safety critical failures.
T!e pat! can gro& to become very comple.
s listed above/ it can be seen t!at a %T risk analysis is best for a &orks!op environment due to
t!e fact t!at t!ere are not muc! safety critical failures as t!e !a(ards are simple and t!e %T &illnot be comple due to t!e simplicity of t!e &orking environment in t!e &orks!op. T!e pat!
developed is easy enoug! for all t!e &orkers to understand at first glance and it !as covered over
+-? of t!e possible risks and !a(ards. %inally/ t!e &orks!op environment does not rely too
!eavily on mac!inery until it poses a t!reat rat!er !uman error &!ic! is most of t!e times can be
rectify before t!ings get out of !and
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
10/21
&ault 'ree Drawing
%ustiication o the methodC$%&' (%)
W$''*+
D,,.'
H,/),&
' "2)/ O
O
S*55/. %(
'$*'
O* S5** %/
$' *%%)
N%
S5'
W,/.
U/+25');+'
D);/.
O
A'/
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
11/21
0!y do &e use %T to create t!e risk analysisF T!e ans&er is simply because t!e advantages of
using it is more t!an t!e disadvantages.
dvantages of %T
It is very simple to understand at first glance and t!e contributing events t!at can be
easily interpreted.
It can be used to s!o& multiple failures or combinations of failures t!at leads to t!e top
event.
T!e pat! t!at leads to t!e top event can easily be seen and rectified.
T!e pat! generated is easily understood by &orkers to avoid doing t!e events.
Disadvantages of %T
To understand t!e events re*uire deep kno&ledge of t!e system and t!e &ork situation
ot practical on systems &it! large numbers of safety critical failures.
T!e pat! can gro& to become very comple.
s listed above/ it can be seen t!at a %T risk analysis is best for a &orks!op environment due to
t!e fact t!at t!ere are not muc! safety critical failures as t!e !a(ards are simple and t!e %T &illnot be comple due to t!e simplicity of t!e &orking environment in t!e &orks!op. T!e pat!
developed is easy enoug! for all t!e &orkers to understand at first glance and it !as covered over
+-? of t!e possible risks and !a(ards. %inally/ t!e &orks!op environment does not rely too
!eavily on mac!inery until it poses a t!reat rat!er !uman error &!ic! is most of t!e times can be
rectify before t!ings get out of !and
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
12/21
Identiying and assessing all the possi(le risk with hazards
0!at are t!e !a(ardsF 0!o mig!t be !armed
and !o&F
0!at are you already doingF
a(ardous substances
Contact &it! used
engine oil etc during
servicing
Skin contact over a
long period can lead
to severe dermatitis
and skin cancer.
G itrile gloves supplied and used
G @arage overalls supplied and used
G Contract for regular cleaning of overalls
G 0orkers informed to clean !ands t!oroug!ly
and use skin creams provided after contact &it!
!a(ardous substances
Car engine running
inside/ toic e!aust
fumes/ eg carbon
monoide
T!e fumes may cause
eye irritation and
breat!ing difficulties.
G Car e!aust attac!ed to etractor system &!en
engine is running
G 5tractor system maintained and tested to
prevent leaks
%ire
#etrol and
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
13/21
is overc!arged and
eplodes.
5lectrical e*uipment
#ortable appliances/
eg !and lamps.
0orkers could get
electrical s!ocks or
burns from faulty
electrical e*uipment
or on installation.
5lectrical faults can
also lead to fires.
G
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
14/21
0ork involving air
conditioning systems
0orkers could suffer>
G frostbite t!roug!
skin or eye contact
&it! refrigerant li*uid
or gas G asp!yiation
if sufficient
*uantities of gas
escape into confined
space
G eposure to !armful
gases t!roug!
t!ermal
decomposition of
refrigerant if eposed
to a naked flame.
G 0orkers are trained in correct procedures
Compressed air
5plosion of
e*uipment tyres
0orkers could suffer
blast in:uries from
tyre or e*uipment
eplosion. 0orkers
could suffer damage
to internal organs if
air is introduced into
t!e body.
G ll &orkers trained in safe &orking procedures
and dangers of !orseplay
G irline !as deadmans !andle
G System inspected and serviced every year by
insurers
andling ve!icle air
bags
ir bags could
eplode &!en not
fitted/ causing in:ury.
G ;nits are stored in suitable cabinet of t!eir
o&n
G 0orkers are trained in correct !andling and
fitting G %aulty units are returned to supplier for
disposal
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
15/21
,anual !andling
,ovement of
components
0orkers risk in:uries
or back pain or pain
else&!ere from
!andling !eavy andHor
bulky ob:ects.
G 0orkers are trained in safe manual !andling
and to ensure contractors follo& safe manual
!andling tec!ni*ues
G ,anual !andling aids are available/ eg lift
truck
Be!icle movements 0orkers and
customers risk
potentially serious
in:ury if struck by a
moving ve!icle
G Safe parking provided for customers &it!out
need for reversing
G ,arked &alk&ays for pedestrians
G Be!icles driven slo&ly around premises
G 0orkers ensure t!at cars being manually
pus!ed al&ays !ave a person seated at t!e &!eel/
to keep t!e ve!icle under control
Slips and trips Door&ays 6rain7/spillages/ uneven
surfaces
0orkers and
customers may be
in:ured if t!ey trip
over ob:ects or slip on
spillages/ eg oil or
&ater.
G @ood !ousekeeping standards maintainedt!roug! training and monitoring
G %loors degreased &eekly
G bsorbent granules and sa&dust put on spills
as soon as possible
G 5ntrances and eits maintained
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
16/21
0orking at !eig!t %alls from any !eig!t
can cause bruising
and fractures and
potentially serious
in:uries.
G ppropriate access e*uipment is provided for
&ork on trailers and tops of commercial ve!icles
G andrails fitted at edges of raised storage
areas and access stair&ay provided
G 0orkers are competent to use ladders &!ere
appropriate
G Be!icle inspection pits clearly marked and
covered &!en not in use
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
17/21
$ethod o controlling the risk
1> Do not rely on safe be!avior as t!e main means of preventing in:ury Safety solutions t!at rely
on administrative controls suc! as training/ supervision/ and procedures/ re*uire constant
vigilance and effort to maintain. #!ysical c!anges suc! as improved &orkplace layout do notre*uire t!e same level of effort and are more effective and a sustainable means of in:ury
prevention.
2> ;se mec!anical devices to reduce !eavy lifting/ a&k&ard postures/ sustained postures and
ot!er body stressing ,any mec!anical devices are already in use/ suc! as tools po&ered by
compressed air/ !oists/ cranes and lifting !ooks/bead breakers/and body under slides to get under
ve!icles. Some devices are &idely kno&n but used less often/ suc! as vacuum lifters for
&indscreen insertion/using !oists &!en detailing/!ip9!eig!t roller conveyor and ramps to load
and move tyres/ order picking ladders &it! load tables for stock access/ pads and body tables for
comfortable &ork in foot&ells and under das!es and castors on !eavy toolboes. fe&&orkplaces apply innovative ideas suc! as tyre under slide and using over!ead9mounted body
support !arnesses for &ork over t!e engine bay. If t!e e*uipment eists to reduce t!e risk of body
stressing t!en it s!ould be purc!ased and used.
3> Searc! &idely for solutions and c!allenge t!ats t!e &ay it !as al&ays been done
8ecause people do not epect to go !ome in:ured or maimed from &ork/ &!at people accept as
t!e normal &ay of doing t!ings !as c!anged. ,anagers/ o&ners and employees need to
recogni(e t!is. %or eample/ for &orking safely &it! ale stands and :acks t!e ustralian
Standards are t!e reasonable best starting point/ !o&ever some automotive &orks!ops do not
apply t!e safety standards in t!ese document.
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
18/21
Solution to minimize the risk
Documented traffic management plan and signage &!ic! does not permit customers to drive t!eir
ve!icle &it!in a &orks!op/ e.g. customer service area for ve!icle drop9off employee movesve!icle out of &orks!op and into customer car parkHpick up area.
Be!icle traffic is p!ysically segregated from service personnel and pedestrians.
5mployees drive &it!in t!eir license and competency.
0!en &orking on trucks/ trailers/ eart! moving e*uipment or farm ve!icles ve!icle dropped off
and moved to designated repair area by licensed operator &it! appropriate eperience.
Be!icle is prevented from moving by using t!ree of t!ese met!ods
J =eys are removed from t!e ignition
J T!e !and brake is on
J 0!eels are c!ocked on bot! sides of t!e ve!icle using serviceable purpose9built c!ocks
J Be!icle raised on a pillar !oist &it! all &!eels off t!e ground.
ll leads are stored out of t!e &ay/ e.g. retractable reels. #o&er and pneumatic outlets located
close to t!e service area. Spills/ including &ater spills/ are covered &it! absorbent material and
immediately cleaned up. non9slip surface coating is applied to potential slippery surfaces/ e.g.
steps.
t t!e time of contracting t!e &ork t!e employer of t!e tyre KtterHmec!anic and t!e !ost
employer discuss and agree on !o& t!e !ealt! and safety and supervision of t!e employee &ill be
managed. 8ot! employers take responsibility for t!e safety of t!e tyre KtterHmec!anic and
develop safe systems of &ork t!at &ill apply for t!e duration of t!e :ob
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
19/21
0ork takes place on a Lat even surface t!at is able to bear t!e general load of t!e ve!icle/ and is
able to bear t!e point load of :acksHlifting e*uipment.
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
20/21
Conclusion
s a conclusion/ &e !ave learned &!at kind of &ork is done at t!e automotive &orks!op suc! as
servicing ve!icles and moving of !eavy spare parts. T!ere is no &ork t!at is void of !a(ards/ t!us&e !ave listed do&n all t!e !a(ards available and t!e risks associated &it! it. T!roug!out t!e
case study/ it is s!o&n t!at even in a &orks!op/ safety must be taken into account and prioriti(e
it. s t!e saying goes M T!ere is no &ork so urgent t!at it cannot be done safelyN / &e must
al&ays follo& t!e rules and guidelines set by t!e management to avoid any unseen problems and
conse*uences.
-
7/25/2019 HSE Assignment 3 Final
21/21
"eerence
1? $5:@@