how does the eastern mediterranean photosynthetic community work cyclops addition experiment and...
TRANSCRIPT
How does the Eastern How does the Eastern Mediterranean photosynthetic Mediterranean photosynthetic
community work community work
CYCLOPS Addition experiment CYCLOPS Addition experiment and resulting modeland resulting model
Why is the Eastern Med special?
• It is Ultra-Oligotrophic
• The annual productivity in the Sargasso Sea is 120-130 gC m-2 y-1
• The annual productivity in the E. Med is 60 gC m-2 y-1
The normal situation in the ocean: The Redfield Ratio
106CO2 + 16NO3-+1HPO4
2-
C106H263O110N16P1+138O2
Photosynthesis Respiration
N:P = 16:1
Progressively higher N:P ratio in deep water towards the E. Mediterranean
16:1
23:1
28:1
How do we know that the E. Med is P-limited in winter?
• In winter, when nutrients are mixed into surface waters, there is a phytoplankton bloom
• Bloom stops when system runs out of phosphate, but there is still nitrate present
Cyprus Eddy centre: Feb 1989
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
0 0.1 0.2 0.3
P (M) and Chl-a (g/l)
De
pth
(m
)
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
0 2 4 6 8
N (M)
P
Chl
N
Aim of the CYCLOPS programme
• To understand how the microbial food chain operates in the eastern Mediterranean
• To determine whether the Eastern Mediterranean is P-limited and what exactly that means
• To find out why the Eastern Mediterranean is P-limited
New data on Eastern Mediterranean
• The system is entirely P starved
• We knew that nitrate/phosphate in LDW (28:1)
• We found that PON:POP (30:1)
• And DON:DOP (~50:1)
• But both nitrate and phosphate are depleted in the photic zone
Nutrient Limitation elsewhere in the oceans
• Most of the ocean is N & P co-limited
• Some areas have high nutrients & low chlorophyll (HNLC)
• Iron limitation?
How these areas were shown to be Fe limited
• Dissolved iron was measured and found to be unusually low
• Bottle experiments showed an increase in chlorophyll when Fe was added.
Still not enough
• Designed and carried out an in-situ addition experiment
SOIREE iron addition experiment
Add Fe and an inert tracer (SF6) to a patch of water
Follow the chemical and biological effects
Fe addition in the Southern Ocean(SOIREE, February 1999)
CYCLOPS Addition CYCLOPS Addition experimentexperiment
May 2002
CYCLOPS addition CYCLOPS addition experimentexperiment
May 2002
-10 0 10-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
-10 0 10-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
-10 0 10-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
-10 0 10-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
-10 0 10-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Day 0.6 Day 2.0 Day 3.9
Day 5.7 Day 8.0
CYCLOPS P addition experiment: fertilized patch
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0 2 4 6 8
Days from T0
[PO
4]
Observed surface PO4Predicted surface PO4 from SF6Predicted surface PO4 from dilution
Particulate-P average <20m SE
PO4 turnover time
1
10
100
13/05 15/05 17/05 19/05 21/05 23/05
Date
hours
Biological uptake of P
Increase in bacterial growth after P addition
CYCLOPS PO4 Addition Experiment
May 2002, E Mediterranean
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
0.02
0.025
0.03
0.035
0.04
Av
e C
hl a (
g/L
) in
0 -
30 m
Laye
r IN Patch
OUT Patch+ P04
F Mantoura Plymouth Marine Laboratory
Total ciliates, Total ciliates, mean (cells / l)mean (cells / l)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
CYC19
CYC24
CYC27
CYC30
CYC32
CYC38
CYC43
CYC48
CYC53
CYC62
CYC44
beforeOUT
d1
d1
?
abundance biomassafter / OUT 1.2 1.5after / before 1.4 1.3after / d1 (CYC27) 2.1 3.9
0
20
40
60
80
100
16.5 17.5 18.5 19.5 20.5 21.5 22.5 23.5 24.5 25.5
Gut
ful
lnes
s (%
with
foo
d)
Herbivores Omnivores Carnivores
Gut Fullness of the zooplankton in the patch
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
16.5 17.5 18.5 19.5 20.5 21.5 22.5 23.5 24.5
Abu
ndan
ce o
f co
pepo
d eg
gs (
n m
-2)
Abundance of copepod eggs in the patch after P addition
Conclusion
• When the ‘limiting’ nutrient is added to the E. Med the first rapid response is – an increase in bacterial activity
– a reduction in the phytoplankton
– an increase in micrograzers and in macrograzer egg production
Microcosm experiment on-board
4 treatments x 3 replicates
• Patch water only
• Patch water with ammonia
• Out of patch water only
• Out of patch water with ammonia
CYCLOPS Shipboard Mesocosm
The effect of NH4 addition on phytoplankcon
Chlorophyll in IN Patch (PO4 enriched) and OUT Patch (control) waters
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
0.14
0.16
0.18
IN St IN St + 1.6uM NH4
OUT St OUT St +1.6uMNH4
Mesocosm Treatment
Ch
l a
(u
g/L
)
20-May
24-May
Nature of the nutrient limitation of the Phytoplankton
• How much N is available before the entire microbial system becomes N & P co-limited?
• Alkaline Phosphatase Bioassay
Slope of this curve is 17:1
Intercept is 230nM-N bioavailable-N
Heterotrophic Bacteria BL-DOC
Heterotrophic Flagellates, H
Pico and Nano-phytoplankton
Ciliates C
BCD
Diatoms D
Meso-zooplankton, M
phosphate & ammonium/nitrate
Silicate
Offshore microbes Coastal microbes
Schematic of the microbial ecosystem in the Eastern Mediterranean
Why is Productivity in the Why is Productivity in the Eastern Mediterranean Eastern Mediterranean Phosphorus-Limited?Phosphorus-Limited?
Is the high N:P ratio due to excess supply of N relative to P?
New Hypothesis:
• The N/P ratio of nutrients supplied to the E. Mediterranean is >> 16:1.
Calculated nutrient inputs to the Eastern Mediterranean basin
All values given in 109 moles/y
Source N input P input Ratio
Atmospheric input 111 0.95 117
Po and adjacent area 20 0.90 22
Nile input 15 0.25 60
Other river input 28 1.20 23
Black Sea 8 0 -
Total input 180 3.3 53
Calculate Steady-State Flux of nutrients through the Straits of Sicily
Calculated nutrient outputs from the Eastern Mediterranean basin
All values given in 109 moles/y
Source N input P input Ratio
Straits of Sicily 142 5.0 28.4
Sediment deposition 27 0.6 45.0
Denitrification 7
Total output 176 5.6 31.0
Total input 180 3.3 53.0
But this is not the complete story!
The GLOBAL Supply of N:P is >> 16:1
• The N:P ratio of nutrients supplied to the world’s oceans is > 50:1 (Smith, 1984)
• Yet most of the world’s oceans have a N:P ratio of ~16:1
Why?
Biological feedback mechanisms control N:P ratio in the oceans
• If there is excess P
– N fixing phytoplankton flourish and produce fixed N in the water column
• If there is excess N – Nitrate reduction in coastal sediments
or oxygen minimum zones which remove N (Seitzinger and Giblin 1996)
Why don’t global feedback mechanisms work in the E. Med?
• It is ultra-oligotrophic due to its unique anti-estuarine circulation
• Little excess organic matter and no pelagic oxygen minimum - almost no areas in which nitrate reduction occurs in the sediment.
Test of this hypothesis
• Are there any areas of the E.Med where the deep water N:P ratio is 16:1?
• Yes - the Northern Adriatic where nitrate reduction DOES occur
Why is the Eastern Mediterranean P limited?
• There is more N supplied to the basin than P
• The normal biological feedback mechanism does not work because the system is ultra-oligotrophic
• There is no evidence of N fixation
Summary
• P-limitation is not as simple as Fe-limitation; it is both time and organism dependant.
• Bacteria are P-limited throughout the year because they can access DON
• Phytoplankton recycle excess N to a form that is not bioavailable and become N & P co-limited in summer
• Grazers are P-starved and respond very rapidly to an external source of P
Summary: Why is the system is P-starved?
• N:P input >>16:1
• Normal global buffer mechanism does not work in the E Med
– the system is ultra-oligotrophic
– no excess organic matter to fuel nitrate reduction
Any Questions?