how can public libraries compete leicestershire june 2008
DESCRIPTION
Public libraries face increasing competition from free and low cost web based 'library' services that deliver a user experience that surpasses conventionla OPACs and a range of fulfilment options.TRANSCRIPT
Ken ChadDirectorKen Chad Consulting [email protected]: +44 (0)7788 727 845www.kenchadconsulting.com
how can public libraries compete? Digital Futures
Leicestershire Libraries Staff Conference June 2008
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
compete with what?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
let’s try to see the wood before we look at the trees
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
Something big is going on..and
(as in so many times in the past) technology is a major driving
force for change…..
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘For more than 150 years, modern complex democracies have depended in
large measure on an industrial information economy…….In the past
decade and a half we have begun to see a radical change in the organisation of information production. Enabled by
technological change, we are beginning to see a series of economic,
social and cultural adaptations that make possible a radical
transformation of how we make the information environment….’
Yochai Benkler a Professor of Law at Yale Law School ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘..organize the world's information and make it
universally accessible and useful..’
Google’s mission statement
the library function is big business
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘Google generation’ ….. ‘a shorthand way of referring to a generation whose first port of call for knowledge is the internet and a search engine, Google being the most popular one. This is in distinction to previous generations …… whose source of knowledge was through books and conventional libraries.
Wikipedia
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
removing barriers
‘.. technology is unleashing a capacity for speaking that before was suppressed by
economic constraint. Now people can speak in lots of ways they never before could have,
because the economic opportunity was denied to them’
Mother Jones Magazine (website)
Interview with Lawrence Lessig: Stanford Law School Professor, Creative Commons Chair
June 29, 2007
http://www.motherjones.com/interview/2007/07/lawrence_lessig.html
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
disruption
‘We-Think changes how we access and organise information and so is bound to disrupt libraries and librarians’
‘ The library of the future will be a platform for participation and collaboration with users increasingly sharing information amongst themselves as well as drawing on the library’s resources’
Charles Leadbeater. ‘We Think. The future is us’ Profile Books Ltd. 2008 ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
as well as new services there are new business models
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘Open access is a practical, efficient and sustainable model to unlock the
potential of the web for disseminating the results of publicly
funded research’
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘Convinced that changes in the industry and the spread of digital piracy have made it ever more
difficult to make money from selling records, the Crimea plan to turn the economics on
their head by giving away downloads of their self-financed second album,
Secret of the Witching Hour’.
Davey MacManus of the Crimea. Photograph: Gareth Davies/Getty
Owen Gibson, media correspondentMonday April 30, 2007
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
you decide what to pay….
technology has enabled web based global providers to deliver free or low cost ‘library’ services direct to users without the need for library
buildings or (in the main) librarians
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
so what’s the competition?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
here are some competitors..
Google: c£5,000,000,000 revenues, over 1m digitised books
Amazon: ‘we seek to be the earth’s most customer centric company where customers can find and discover anything they want to buy online’
AbeBooks: >100 million titles, over 18,000 ‘branches’.
LibraryThing:over 300,000 members.Over 20m books catalogued. Over 150K works reviewed
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
This too..
So commercial = chargeable and public sector = free?
Really?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
Free?• charges for non book loans• charges for some services• fines if items returned late?
so what does it cost to borrow a book?
(the RAC puts the all-inclusive cost of driving a typical three-year-old 1.8 litre family saloon at 53.6p per mile)
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
a free public library service?
libraries are inefficient and expensive in providing resources
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
libraries are inefficient and expensive in providing resources
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
cost to put a book on a shelf (prior to London Libraries Consortium) £5.46
Source: Anne Rennie. Havering Libraries 2007 NAG Conference
libraries are inefficient and expensive in providing resources
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
libraries are inefficient and expensive in providing resources
In 2005 Library staff at the University of Wales in Bangor were threatened with job cuts, the university consultation paper making the case for the cuts stated:
‘Librarians do not deliver “value for money” when compared to the internet.’
libraries aren’t being singled out……
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘in the past month I’ve bought 15-20 books.
They’ve cost what would you say? £150? £180?
Actually, it’s somewhere in in the region of £12’
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘Until recent years most charity shops were "low-key" shops, let often at a peppercorn rent in order to keep the premises occupied : this is no longer
true. Many charity shops are now professionally refitted and wish to be sited on the main street in town centres : charity shops are seen as a "risk-free" tenant by landlords, much the same as estate agents or
building societies, and are now often paying premium rents’.
"Oxfam specialist bookshops will be a shock to people expecting the clichéd image of dark, dusty second-hand bookshops selling scruffy
paperbacks," said [Murray] Winters. "The shops are bright, light and well-designed, and offer a vast array of books, including many specialist,
rare, antique and unusual titles. Many books on offer are no longer available from mainstream book retailers. Customers appreciate
that diversity of choice."
http://www.inprint.co.uk/thebookguide/shops/oxfam.shtml
competition on the high street
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
high street bookshops could soon be killed off ?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘I, along with almost everybody I know, stopped buying in bookshops
years ago. Why bother? Online, Amazon and AbeBooks have
everything I need; in fact, they have everything anybody could ever
need, and AbeBooks, especially, is absurdly cheap’.
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
let’s compare…….public libraries vs.
commercial ‘library’ services
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
search: the library (OPAC) experience
information provided and options for action
a title search goes straight to:-
• bibliographical inc summary information
• holdings (locations)• availability• context search (by author and subject)• request
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
this is fine……..as far as it goes..
search: the Google Book Search experience
Does your OPAC do this?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
The ‘default’ Google link to library holding is via OCLC WorldCat
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ngwhy isn’t your library on this list?
The OCLC WorldCat ‘platform’ links through to the local OPAC
Other ways of linking (e.g. through Talis) are available but OCLC remains the Google default
let’s try another search……
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
The book is not in the library catalogue and no alternatives are offered. There is a ‘place request’ option but this presents a another set of ‘barrier’
Why is it made so hard?
What does this mean? Where do I go from here?
Here’s an example from another library catalogue
compared to this…
The same search on Amazon
One click to fulfilment….
Also…genuinely helpful suggestions
Other helpful information too…..
a random selection of requests in May
• Prescott, John ‘Prezza – pulling no punches’• Blair, Cherie ‘Speaking for Myself’• McFadyen, Cody ‘The Darker Side’ • Gardner, Lisa ‘Say Goodbye’ • Clevely, A.M. ‘The Allotment Seasonal Planner and
Cookbook’ • Abnett, Dan ‘Everyone Says Hello’ • Cabot, Meg ‘To the Nines’• Coben, Harlan ‘Hold Tight’• Jardine, Quentin ‘Wearing Purple’• Kamen, Henry ‘Spain’s Road to Empire’
all are available on Amazon
these were found on the Leicestershire catalogue
• Abnett, Dan ‘Everyone Says Hello’ • Coben, Harlan ‘Hold Tight’• Kamen, Henry ‘Spain’s Road to Empire’
25 items found on Amazon, lowest price 3.94 + 2.75 p&p
Kamen, Henry ‘Spain’s Road to Empire’
1 item found on Leicestershire Library Catalogue, 2 copies/1
available at OADBY SO So from Loughborough that’s a 30 mile round trip at £0.53.6
per mile….and what does that ‘SO’ mean anyway?
fulfilment alternatives
engaging people with books..a key public library
mission..
what does the competition look like?
how is the library domain responding?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
a national aggregation: search across the whole of Wales – ‘Cat Cymru’
why not the whole of the UK?
A response from Huddersfield
(the university. Dave Pattern)(Embedding the library in other people’s services)
borrowing suggestionsHuddersfield Uni had details of over 2,000,000 checkouts
spanning 10 years stored in the library management system and gathering virtual dust
ratings and commentsHuddersfield: Dave Pattern again..
‘chat’ with an expert…California State University
AquaBrowser from Media Labs showing a ‘tag cloud’
Boston College (US) using (ExLibris) Primo
adding user content to WorldCat
but..barriers? you have to log in, register and adhere to these content
guidelines
are you interested???
thinking about business models…
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
ken
ch
ad
con
su
ltin
g
(some) elements of the business model
• value proposition• market segment• value chain• value network• competitive strategy
‘Another aspect of the challenge for .. competing in the commercial network economy is that there is a strong set of mission-based reasons for why not-for-profit [resources] should be available to all potential users without charge.
This ethos has been reinforced by the rise of free-to-use sites operating in the commercial environment, many of which are generating revenue primarily, if not exclusively, through advertising’.
Sustainability and revenue models for online academic resourcesDraft March 31, 2008. By Kevin Guthrie, Rebecca Griffiths, Nancy Maron. Ithaka
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
commercial services can be
free too….
To maximize the likelihood of success…..
• Clearly define the mission• Hire a great leader, often from outside the organization• Establish an advisory or governance board with
outsiders• Allow the leader the flexibility to adjust• Develop a viable economic model, matching value
generated to sources of support• Communicate effectively and aggressively the value of
the enterprise to constituents and stakeholders
(adapted from)Sustainability and revenue models for online academic resources
Draft March 31, 2008. By Kevin Guthrie, Rebecca Griffiths, Nancy Maron. Ithaka
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
what’s distinctive about libraries?
‘A library’s competitive advantage lies in its user intelligence – this enables it to tailor services to meet genuine needs, to present them attractively, to innovate effectively and to achieve real impact.’
Brophy, P. (2007)The Library in the Twenty-First Century. 2nd ed. Facet.
Useruniverse User
population
InformationuniverseInformation
populationLibrary as intermediary
Userintelligence
Informationintelligence
User interface Source interface
(potential) library assets
• unique collections• welcoming spaces and
people• in the community• staff expertise• trust
• user clickstreams & context• vertical ‘business’ context• collective critical mass?
A few concluding remarks
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
• technology, cost and complexity barriers are coming down– enabling more participants (not everyone likes this!)
• ‘Pro-Ams’ in the library sector
• an increasing contribution from non ‘traditional’ library businesses
• new biz models will emerge
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
libraries at the heart of the wider culture and technology debate?
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
‘It is the feasibility of producing information, knowledge and culture
through social, rather than market and proprietary relations - through
cooperative peer production- that creates the opportunities for greater autonomous action, a more critical
culture, a more discursively engaged and better informed republic, and perhaps a more equitable global
community’
Yochai Benkler a Professor of Law at Yale Law School ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng
www.kenchadconsulting.com
Ken ChadDirectorKen Chad Consulting [email protected]: +44 (0)7788 727 845www.kenchadconsulting.com
how can public libraries compete? Digital Futures
Leicestershire Libraries Staff Conference June 2008
ken
ch
ad
con
su
lti
ng