hit-supported chronic disease management: the maccabi experience
DESCRIPTION
HIT-supported Chronic Disease Management: the Maccabi Experience. Kaye R. eHealth week 2010 (Barcelona: CCIB Convention Centre; 2010)TRANSCRIPT
Nearly 70-80% of health care costs result from chroniccare
70% of the disease burden is due to 5 chronic conditions
Congestive heart failure
Asthma
Coronary artery disease.
Diabetes
Depression
Diabetes
Ischemic Heart Disease
Trying to adapt acute care model to Chronic Disease
care
Reactive, not pro-active
Rushed practitioners not following established
practice guidelines
Lack of care coordination and
follow-up
Patients inadequately trained to manage their illness
Informed,
Activated
Patient
Productive
Interactions
Prepared,
Proactive
Practice Team
Delivery
System
Design
Decision
Support
Clinical
Information
SystemsSelf-
Management
Support
Health System
Resources and
Policies
Community
Health Care Organization
Improved OutcomesWagner et al, Health Affairs 2001;20(6):64-78.
Clinical information Systems
Decision Support
Self-management Support
Delivery System Design
Provide timely reminders for providers and patients
Identify relevant sub-populations for proactive care
Facilitate individual patient care planning
Share information with patients and providers to
coordinate care
Monitor performance of practice team and care
system
Electronic Medical Record
In Maccabi used by all providers for over 15 years,
capturing demographic and medical data and
providing the clinician with support in caring for his
patient.
Medical (Disease) Registries
Based on all of the information in the data base,
enable tracking individual patients as well
as populations to manage chronic illness and
preventive care.
Medical
History
Family
History
Visits &
Hospitaliza-tions
Demographic
parameters
ImagingTreatments
Medications
Lab
Results
1st year of data
collection
n
(2007)
% of MHS
population
Home Care 1998 5,500 0.3
Infertility 1998 10,000 0.6
Cancer 2000 36,300 2.1
Cardiovascular 1998 72,720 4.0
Diabetes 1998 85,000 4.7
Hypertension 1998 233,000 13.0
All of the above 442,520 25.0
The Clinical Decision Support System provides an integrated
comprehensive view of patients status including data on the
patient’s status relative to prevention, disease management ,
medication management etc.
The system is based on clinical guidelines and alerts the provider,
in real time, to the following:
Patient information indicative of aberrations in patient status.
Recommendation for needed tests/treatment based on cumulative data
on the patient in the system.
Links to relevant medical knowledge.
Drug interaction warnings
Prescription prioritization recommendations
Mandatory data fields (BP, smoking)
Recommended laboratory test alerts
Diagnosis-related lab test panels
Organizational alerts
Rules engine based alerts
Active Health
Problems Chronic Medication
Allergies
Last Visit
Risk Factors
Dr. Jones - FP
Robert Smith
Refer for Cholesterol test
Refer for Diphtheria/tetanus
Document results & blood pressure measurement
List
Confirm
Cancel
Recommendations for present visit:
• recommended referrers
• delay to next visit
delay all next visit
Action
Reason
Patient suffers from hypertension. No documented
Blood Pressure Measures in the last year
Gantt Chronic Medications
Gantt Past Medications
Blood Pressure Trend
Gantt Chronic Medications
Gantt Past Medications
Blood Pressure Trend
Blood Pressure Trend
Patient Allergy to Penicillin.
Wish to prescribe despite sensitivity?
ApproveCancel
Lists of Patients with Diabetes
Status Reports with patient names and phone numbers:
Last HbA1C Test – when done and value
Last Eye Exam
Last Foot Examination
Last LDL test and value
Diabetic Patients without flu shots
Patients in Diabetes Registry
Statistics: Diabetes Patients
Average HbA1C% HbA1C
Average LDL% Done LDL
% Done Creat% Done Urine
% Done Eye Exam% Patients Aspirin
% Patients Ace Inhibitors% Visit Dietician
% Patients HbA1C over 9.5
% Patients HbA1C under 7% Patients HbA1C under 100
Clinic: TA Clinic Address: hazionot 17 Dr.: R. Smith Year: 2008
Average Patient Age: 52.6
Numbers of Visits: 348
Maccabi Region Clinic
ID #Last NameFirst NamePhone Num.Eye
Patients in Diabetes Registry
Patients who have not had an Eye Exam
Time Period Between October 2007 – September 2008
Computerized consultation with specialists
Virtual consults by e-mail and video conference
Diabetes expert teaching program
Diabetes education team visits
Joint consults
E-learning
Stress patient’s role in managing health
Strategies including assessment, goal-setting,
action planning, problem-solving and follow-up
Appropriate infrastructure
Patient education materials
Share information with patients
Eye Examination: this is not a test that can be performed by an optometrist or a test for a driver's license but
rather an in-depth eye examination by a qualified ophthalmologist. This test is very important for the early
detection of eye problems as a result of diabetes. There are excellent methods for treating these problems if they
are detected at the early stages. It is recommended that this test be done once a year
Urine protein test: The objective of this test is to identify potential damage to the kidneys as a result of diabetes.
If the discharge of protein or albumen in the urine is high, it can be treated by medication. It is recommended to
do this test (micro-albumen/creatnine or 24 hour urine collection for micro albumen or protein) once a year.
Here are the results over time of the test results in our system
Dear Joseph Kern ID# 500000000 Data last updated 31/5/2009
Dear member,
We are presenting you with your personal data with regard to your Diabetes, The control of your diabetes is largely dependent on
your understanding and your cooperation with your doctor. Here is your personal information with respect to several items critical to
your healthHBA1C Information
These data are based on your blood test results and indicate the
extent to which your diabetes was under control for the 3 months
prior to the test. It is recommended to do this test twice a year or
according to your doctor's recommendation. The recommended level
for this test is less than 7%
Recommended Value – 7%
LDL Cholesterol Information
This is the type of cholesterol that is known to be a risk factor for
cardiovascular disease. It is important that a diabetic patient do this
test once a year or according to his doctor's recommendation. The
recommended value for this test is less than 100/dl
HbA1C trend
LDL trend
Date: 30/9/2009 most recent HbA1C value:8.4%
According to our records, your last HbA1C test was more
than a year ago, Please contact your doctor for a referral
for this lab test
MaccabiOnLine
Built in guidelines based on the patient’s personal
medical information, clinical guidelines and his care plan
Input from sensors (weight, blood pressure, pulse,
glucometer, ECG) and from the patient
Input from doctor’s EMR, case management record
Interactive – provides instruction, answers patient
questions
Proactive – provides response to inputs, alerts to patient,
doctor, nurse case manager
Remote intervention by care providers based on patient
input, input from sensors, alerts
Willingness of doctor to take responsibility for
comprehensive care of patient including Disease
Management
New role for the nurse, as case manager, educator
Willingness of Patient to take responsibility for
managing his disease
Willingness of doctor, nurse and patient to work
together to manage the disease
Providing both the clinicians and the patient with the tools
for Disease Management:
Electronic Medical Record
Clinical Data exchange (test results, drugs purchased,
etc.)
Central medical record or data warehouse
Medical Registries for chronic disease
For the doctor – alerts, reminders, embedded clinical
guidelines, feedback, patient lists
For the patient - courses, education, interactive Patient
Health Record. alerts, reminders