hillsdale, new jersey worksession meeting april …€¦ · hillsdale, new jersey worksession...
TRANSCRIPT
HILLSDALE BOARD OF EDUCATION HILLSDALE, NEW JERSEY
WORKSESSION MEETING
APRIL 13, 2015
MINUTES
1. CALL TO ORDER
The Board of Education of the Borough of Hillsdale held a Worksession Meeting at the George G. White School Lucia A. Drake Media Center on Monday, April13, 2015. The meeting was called to order at 7:06p.m. by Mrs. Kathleen O'Flynn, President and Presiding Officer.
2. SALUTE TO THE FLAG
3. OPENING STATEMENT
The New Jersey Open Public Meetings Law was enacted to insure the right of the public to have advance notice and to attend the meetings of public bodies at which any business affecting their interests is discussed or acted upon. In accordance with the provisions of the Act, the Hillsdale Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date, time and place thereof posted at the Hillsdale Borough Hall, Hillsdale A venue, Hillsdale; the Hillsdale Public Library, 509 Hillsdale A venue, Hillsdale; the Hillsdale Board of Education Office, 32 Ruckman Road, Hillsdale; and sent to the Board's designated newspapers: The Record, and the Ridgewood News on April28, 2014. This meeting's agenda has been posted and sent to The Ridgewood News and The Record on March 31, 2015.
4. ROLLCALL
Members Present Dr. Tim Santo Mrs. Krista Flinn Mrs. Shane Svorec Mr. Sal Sileo Mrs. Kathleen O'Flynn
Members Absent None
Mr. Donald Bergamini, George White Principal was also present.
2
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
5. PRESENTATION FOR THE UNDEFEATED BASKETBALL TEAM
PRESENTATION FOR THE UNDEFEATED BASKETBALL TEAM
Mrs. Kathleen O'Flynn, Board President read the following:
On behalf of the Board of Education, I would like to extend our congratulations to the basketball team and Coach Walden on another successful season and the added special award of an undefeated season. As you are all aware, the reward does not come without many hours of hard work, practice and team work. You should be proud of your accomplishments - Congratulations.
I'd like to invite Mr. Walden to say a few words before we give out some special gifts to the undefeated team.
Mr. Patrick Walden, Girls' Basketball Coach, read the following statement and, thereafter, distributed the sweatshirts to the team members present:
Good evening distinguished Board members, administrators, teachers, parents, hawks, and friends. I have the honor and privilege to introduce the George G. White Middle School Girls' Basketball Team. These student-athletes exemplify the dedication and hard work it requires to be remembered as an indomitable team! Know it is not the critic who counts; not the person who points out how the other stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the girl who is actually on the court. Whose face is marred by sweat, dust, and sometimes blood. Who strives valiantly, who err and comes up short again and again .... Who spends herself in a worthy cause; who, at best, knows, in the end, the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if she fails, at least she fails while daring greatly! We did not fail, with a record of 14 wins and no losses, the hawks were undefeated! Stand and be recognize: Kelly Andreasen, Melanie Brentnall, Caitlin Carlson, Colleen Coyle, Nicole Crea, Isabella Garabo, Kate Henderson, Mackenzie Klink, Skylar Murphy, Nicole Perrone, Paige Skene and Brianna Smith.
MOTION TO ADJOURN FOR A RECESS ADJOURNED FOR RECESS
Motion passed by consensus vote: 5-0.
MOTION TO RECONVENE TO MEETING RECONVENE TO MEETING
Motion was made by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Flinn to reconvene to the meeting.
Motion passed by consensus vote: 5-0.
6. PRESENTATION PRESENTATION
Presentation did not take place because Ms. Dansky, BCSBA President, did not attend.
3
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
Moved by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Flinn that the Board approve the following resolution:
APPROVAL OF RESOLUTION REGARDING PENSION AND HEALTH BENEFITS REFORM
APPROVED RESOLUTION REGARDING PENSION AND HEALTH BENEFITS REFORM
WHEREAS, the health of New Jersey's public employee retirement systems affects the state's economy and its citizens' quality of life, and impacts critical functions, ranging from the state's ability to borrow to finance public works projects to its annual budget including state aid to education and, consequently, the operation of the public schools; and
WHEREAS, the New Jersey Pension and Health Benefits Study Commission, appointed by Governor Chris Christie in 2014, has issued its final report," A Roadmap to Resolution," which proposes monumental changes in how public employee benefits, particularly the Teachers' Pension and Annuity Fund (TPAF) and the School Employees' Health Benefits Program (SEHBP), are financed and administered; and
WHEREAS, the Hillsdale Board of Education believes that reform must balance the health of the state's retiree benefits programs with local school boards' responsibility to provide sound educational programming; and
WHEREAS, TP AF benefits are established by the state and not through local school board action; and
WHEREAS, post-retirement medical benefits are provided to TP AF retirees through state legislation, not local school board action; and
WHEREAS, the Hillsdale Board of Education believes that the TP AF and any new retirement program for certificated school district staff must be funded by the state government; and
WHEREAS, the Hillsdale Board of Education believes that transferring payment of the employer's contribution to the teacher retirement plan and post-retirement medical benefits from the state to local school districts would have a detrimental impact on the resources necessary to maintain educational programming; and
WHEREAS, to restore solvency to, and avert future default of, the state's retirement programs, the pension and benefits reform act of 2011 (P.L. 2011, c.78) includes a schedule of annual state payments designed to close the deficit of the plans that serve school district employees; and
WHEREAS, medical benefits for retired school employees, which will total over $1 billion in 2015-2016, are a major cost-driver in the state budget; and
4
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
WHEREAS, the Hillsdale Board of Education supports the current statutorily required employee contributions toward health benefits, which reflect current practice in the private sector and in public employment in other states, and have provided significant financial relief for local school districts, thereby enabling them to direct resources toward educational programming, including teacher employment.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Hillsdale Board of Education urges the state Legislature and Governor to ensure that the employers' cost for teacher pensions and postretirement medical benefits- financial obligations created by the state- are not transferred to local school districts; and be it further
RESOLVED, that to provide local school districts and local property taxpayers with financial relief, the Legislature should amend P.L. 2011, c.78 to make the current employee contributions toward health coverage a permanent requirement and not a subject of labor negotiations; and be it further
RESOLVED, that to provide further control over the cost of health benefits, the Legislature should give local boards of education unilateral authority to enroll in the School Employee Health Benefits Program if the board determines that such action would generate financial savings; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Hillsdale Board of Education supports the goal of reducing the overall costs of public employee health and retirement benefits and urges the state Legislature and Governor to take a studied and comprehensive approach that will ensure the long-term solvency of the state's public employee retirement programs without unduly burdening local school district budgets and endangering educational programming; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this resolution be delivered to Governor Chris Christie, State Senate President Stephen M. Sweeney, Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto; and the three (3) Legislative District's representatives in the state Senate and General Assembly; and be it further
RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be sent to the New Jersey School Boards Association.
Motion passed by roll call vote: 5-0.
7. HEARING OF CITIZENS AND DELEGATIONS CONCERNING ITEMS ON AGENDA
HEARING OF CITIZENS AND DELEGATIONS
No dialogue transpired and no comments were made regarding the items on the agenda.
5
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
8. GENERAL
1G. CORRESPONDENCE TO BOARD CORRESPONDENCE TO BOARD
None
2G. INTERIM SUPERINTENDENT'S REPORT
INTERIM SUPERINTENDENT'S REPORT
Mr. Raymond, J. Albano reported on the following: 1. Update on P ARCC 2. Kindergarten Registration to date: 55 at Smith; 43 at Meadowbrook 3. George White School Girls' Basketball Team 4. George White School Graduation 5. Bergen County Teacher Recognition Program
3G. APPROVAL OF BOARD MINUTES APPROVED BOARD MINUTES
Moved by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Flinn that the Board approve the following Board Minutes:
January 6, 2015 January 6, 2015
Motion passed by roll call vote: 3-0.
OrganizationfW orksession Meeting Executive Session Meeting
Mrs. Shane Svorec and Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the January 6, 2015 Organization/ Worksession Meeting and the Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
January 19, 2015 January 19, 2015
Motion passed by roll call vote: 3-0.
Regular Meeting Executive Session Meetings
Mrs. Shane Svorec and Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the January 19,2015 Regular Meeting and the Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
January 20,2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting
Motion passed by roll call vote: 3-0. Mrs. Shane Svorec and Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the January 20,2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting.
February 3, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting
Motion passed by roll call vote: 3-0. Mrs. Shane Svorec and Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the February 3, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting.
WORKSESSION MEETING
February 10, 2015 February 10, 2015
Motion passed by roll call vote: 3-0.
6
MINUTES
WorksessionfRegular Meeting Executive Session Meeting
APRIL 13, 2015
Mrs. Shane Svorec and Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the February 10, 2015 Worksession/ Regular Meeting and the Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
March 5, 2015 March 5, 2015
Motion passed by roll call vote: 4-0.
Special Meeting Executive Session Meeting
Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the March 5, 2015 Special Meeting and Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
March 9, 2015 March 9, 2015
Motion passed by roll call vote: 4-0.
Worksession Meeting Executive Session Meeting
Dr. Tim Santo abstained on the March 9, 2015 Worksession Meeting and Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
March 10, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting
Motion passed by roll call vote: 4-0. Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the March 10, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
March 11, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting
Motion passed by roll call vote: 4-0. Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the March 11, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
March 18, 2015 March 18, 2015
Motion passed by roll call vote: 4-0.
Regular Meeting (Approval of Tentative Budget) Executive Session Meeting
Dr. Tim Santo abstained on the March 18, 2015 Regular Meeting (Approval of Tentative Budget) and the Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
March 30, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting
Motion passed by roll call vote: 4-0. Mr. Sal Sileo abstained on the March 30, 2015 Closed Executive Session Meeting Minutes.
7
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
9. APPOINTMENT OF 2015 COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSONS AND MEMBERS
APPOINTED 2015 COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSONS AND MEMBERS
Mrs. Kathleen O'Flynn, Board President appointed the following 2015 Committee Chairpersons and Members for the following committees:
BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS .......................... CHAIRPERSON: SAL SILEO MEMBER: KRISTA FLINN
EDUCATION .......................................................... CHAIRPERSON: TIM SANTO MEMBER: SAL SILEO
FINANCF/AUDIT .................................................. CHAIRPERSON: KRISTA FLINN MEMBER: SHANE SVOREC
PERSONNEL. ......................................................... CHAIRPERSON: TIM SANTO MEMBER: SHANE SVOREC
POLICY ................................................................... CHAIRPERSON: KRISTA FLINN MEMBER: SAL SILEO
TRANSPORTATION ........................................... CHAIRPERSON: SHANE SVOREC MEMBER: TIM SANTO
NEGOTIATIONS .................................................. CHAIRPERSON: KRISTA FLINN MEMBER: KATHLEEN O'FLYNN ALTERNATE: TIM SANTO
NEW JERSEY AND BERGEN COUNTY SCHOOL BOARDS ASSOCIATION ........... REPRESENTATIVE: KATHLEEN O'FLYNN
ALTERNATE KRIST A FLINN
PASCACK VALLEY ADMINISTRATIVE COUNCIL. ................... REPRESENT ATIVE: KATHLEEN O'FL YNN
ALTERNATE: TIM SANTO
REGION II SPECIAL EDUCATION ............. REPRESENTATIVE: TIM SANTO ALTERNATE: SHANE SVOREC
REPRESENTATIVE TO N.J. SCHOOL BOARDS DELEGATE ASSEMBLY AND LEGISLATION CHAIRPERSON: SAL SILEO
ALTERNATE: KRISTA FLINN
Board President will be the alternate member to all committees
8
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES
10. INTERIM SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS' RECOMMENDATIONS
EDUCATION COMMITTEE: TIM SANTO, CHAIRPERSON; SAL SILEO, MEMBER
Discussion Only, No Action will be taken)
APRIL 13, 2015
1E. APPROVAL OF 2015 SPECIAL EDUCATION SUMMER ENRICHMENT PROGRAM
2E. APPROVAL OF CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENTS; 2015-2016
3E. APPROVAL OF GRADUATION DATE, TIME AND LOCATION; 2015
4E. APPROVAL OF SCHOOL CALENDAR REVISION; 2014-2015
9
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE: TIM SANTO, CHAIRPERSON; SHANE SVOREC, MEMBER
ACTION ITEMS
Moved by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Svorec that the Board approve the following Personnel recommendations:
1PA. APPROVAL TO ACCEPT TEACHER AIDE RESIGNATIONS; 2014-2015
APPROVED TO ACCEPT TEACHER AIDE RESIGNATION
It is recommended that the Board retroactively accept, as per the Interim Superintendent's recommendation, the resignations of teacher aides, Allison Stahl and Rita Zamlout, effective Thursday, April 2, 2015.
2PA. APPROVAL OF OBSERVATION FIELD EXPERIENCE; 2014-2015
APPROVED OBSERVATION FIELD EXPERIENCE
It is recommended that the Board approve, as per the Interim Superintendent's recommendation, an observation field experience for William Paterson student, Kathleen Daly from April15, 2015 through May 2015 with Smith School fourth grade teacher, Donna Rosenbaum.
3P A. APPROVAL OF PAYMENT FOR CPR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER COURSE INSTRUCTOR; 2014-2015
APPROVED PAYMENT FOR CPR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER COURSE INSTRUCTOR
It is recommended that the Board approve, as per the Interim Superintendent's recommendation, the payment of $180.00 to Rose Bauerle for providing the CPR Health Care Provider Course to fellow nurses Christina Fanelli and Melanie Fraiman.
Motion passed by roll call vote: 5-0.
10
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE: TIM SANTO, CHAIRPERSON; SHANE SVOREC, MEMBER (continued)
Discussion Only, No Action will be taken)
APRIL 13, 2015
1P. APPROVAL OF CHILD REARING LEAVE OF ABSENCE; 2015-2016
2P. APPROVAL OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT DAYS; 2014-2015
11
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
11. BUSINESS ADMINISTRATOR/BOARD SECRETARY'S RECOMMENDATIONS
FINANCE COMMITTEE: KRISTA FLINN, CHAIRPERSON; SHANE SVOREC, MEMBER
(Discussion Only, No Action will be taken)
1F. APPROVAL OF BUDGET TRANSFERS
2F. APPROVAL OF FINANCIAL REPORTS
3F. APPROVAL OF MONTHLY BUDGET STATUS CERTIFICATION; MARCH 2015
4F. APPROVAL OF MARCH 2015 BILL LIST
SF. APPROVAL OF APRIL 2015 BILL LIST
6F. APPROVAL OF TUITION RATE FOR THE 2015 SPECIAL EDUCATION SUMMER ENRICHMENT PROGRAM
7F. APPROVAL OF TUITION RATE FOR THE 2015-2016 INTEGRATED PRESCHOOL PROGRAM
12
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES
FINANCE COMMITTEE: KRISTA FLINN, CHAIRPERSON; SHANE SVOREC, MEMBER
SF. APPROVAL OF FLEXIBLE SPENDING ACCOUNT (FSA) WITH HORIZON BCBS; 2015-2016
APRIL 13, 2015
9F. APPROVAL OF CASH INCENTIVE OPTION TO WAIVE HEALTH BENEFITS; 2015-2016
lOF. APPROVAL TO ACCEPT RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE PROCUREMENT OF GOODS AND SERVICES THROUGH STATE AGENCY FOR THE 2015-2016 SCHOOL YEAR
11F. APPROVAL OFT AX SHELTER VENDORS; 2015-2016
13
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
12. OLD BUSINESS OLD BUSINESS
Mrs. Kathleen O'Flynn gave an update on the Superintendent Search process. She also mentioned that we are in the discussion phase with the finalist, etc. and that the Board hopes to make an announcement on April 27, 2015. Mr. Raymond Albano also mentioned that the Public Hearing is on April27, 2015.
13. NEW BUSINESS NEW BUSINESS
Mrs. Garcia discussed the roof repair/replacement project at George G. White School.
APPROVAL OF GEORGE WHITE SCHOOL ROOF REPAIRS/REPLACEMENTS
APPROVED GEORGE WHITE SCHOOL ROOF REPAIRS/REPLACEMENTS
Moved by Trustee Sileo, seconded by Trustee Flinn that the Board hereby authorizes the Business Administrator/Board Secretary to request bids for the George G. White School roof repairs/replacements and effectuate any documentation relating to such project.
Motion passed by roll call vote: 5-0.
14. SECOND HEARING OF CITIZENS ON ANY TOPIC OF CONCERN
SECOND HEARING OF CITIZENS
Mr. DeRosa inquired if there would be any overlapping time between the Interim Superintendent and the incoming Superintendent. He also congratulated the new Board of Education members on their appointments and the entire Board on their achievements. Mr. Pizzella gave his congratulations again to the Board of Education on their achievements; and feels they are doing a great job.
14
WORKSESSION MEETING MINUTES APRIL 13, 2015
Moved by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Svorec that the Board move the meeting to an Executive Session at 7:30p.m.
15. EXECUTIVE SESSION EXECUTIVE SESSION
WHEREAS, the Open Public Meetings Act and the Hillsdale Board of Education reserve the right within the constraints of State Law to sit in Executive Session, and
WHEREAS, there now exists a need for this Board of Education to meet in Executive Session, now therefore
BE IT RESOLVED that the Hillsdale Board of Education recess into Executive Session to discuss exempt matters pertaining to personnel contracts and WNBC litigation, and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the public will be informed 1. When the Board reconvenes to the Worksession Meeting business portion of this meeting
this evening; or 2. At a later date, undetermined at this time.
Moved by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Svorec that the Board adjourn the Executive Session and reconvene to the Worksession meeting at 8:04p.m.
Motion passed by consensus vote: 5-0.
16. ADJOURN MEETING ADJOURN MEETING
Moved by Trustee Santo, seconded by Trustee Flinn that the Board adjourn its Worksession Meeting at 8:04 p.m.
Motion passed by consensus vote: 5-0.
Reseect~ully Submitted b~ •>), -1-'J?. . /
.. )l.--L--t>cr.__...- //,/ ~ -"1 / "
i
Lirca Garcia Business Administrator/Board Secretary