harry clarke la trobe university economic society of australia, victorian
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
1/37
Harry Clarke
La Trobe University
Economic Society of Australia, Victorian Branch.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
2/37
Plan
1.Background science & politics role ofscientific uncertainty.
2.Core economics of climate policy underuncertainty
3.Australian policy
4.Final remarks
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
3/37
1. Climate science
Climate science has developed over 2 centuries inapplied & fundamental directions.
Predictions of theory are convincingly supportedby evidence.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
4/37
Science we know
Warming is occurring. With very high probability
due to anthropogenic GGEs. TheAGWhypothesis.
Charney Sensitivity. Doubling of CO2 over pre-
industrial times (ignoring slower feedbacks) brings 30C (mgs) temp. increase. More at poles.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
5/37
Science uncertainty.
Lots ofgenuine uncertainty...
Climate sensitivities uncertain & time horizon-variable. Some feedbacks drive higher
sensitivities, aerosol cleanup may unmaskgreater heating. Ice sheet melting createsstronger LR responses. Regional effects.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
6/37
IPCC & uncertainty
Uncertainties a focus ofIPCC reports - clouds, aerosols,
Antarctic sea ice.etc.
e.g. in Physical Science Basis Report 43 key uncertaintieslisted.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
7/37
A low weight on AGW scepticism isappropriate
Garnaut on Garnaut Review:
accepted views of mainstream science on abalance of probabilities. There is a chance that itis wrong. But it is just a chance. To heed insteadthe views of the small minority of genuinesceptics in the relevant scientific communitieswould be to hide from reality. It would beimprudent beyond the normal limits of humanirrationality.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
8/37
Is human activity significantly changingtemperatures?
Doran-Zimmerman(2009)
75/79climatologists saidyes.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
9/37
Doran-Zimmermanconclusion
1. The debate on the authenticity of AGWlargely nonexistent in science.
2. The challenge, is to communicate this to
policy makers & to a public thatcontinues to mistakenly perceive adebate among scientists.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
10/37
Politics
1957 Revelle & Suess - heating a policy concern CO2
emissions - large scale geophysical experiment.
Unanimity of policy concern led to 1992 ClimateConvention & ongoing role for IPCC.
But late 1980s marked the birth ofclimate changedelusionism.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
11/37
Delusionism
An influential political movement rejecting science &
seeking to sow seeds of doubt regarding AGW.George C. Marshall Institute & the Heartland Institute.
Same groups have denied passive smoking damage,
CFCs cause ozone layer hole, SO2 cause acid rain etc.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
12/37
More...
Delusionism fostered by press balanceideas right to equal treatment.
Science has addressed delusionist claims
but claims get repeated (warming stoppedin 1998).
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
13/37
More
As an economist I refuse to debate the science.
No more reason to question validity ofscience than to take seriously the views ofphysicists who push crank money theories.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
14/37
2. Climate change
economicsAmbitious seeks to determine opportunity costs
of mitigating & not-mitigating GGEs.
Complex irreversibility, nonlinear responses,threshold effects thrown together in dynamicsetting with system & ethical uncertainties.
Some simplification from relatively small rolemacroeconomic role of energy sector.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
15/37
Evaluating via CBA a realoptions task:
Risk/uncertainty - Valuation of costs/benefitsstochastic processes.
Dynamics stock pollutant & learning dynamics
Irreversibility sunk cost & ecological/environmental.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
16/37
CBA Methodology
Use use CBA with uncertainty,irreversibility & dynamics.
Many issues...
I t t l
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
17/37
Intertemporalvaluations
Low discount rates make sense.
Intra-generationalattitudes.
Discount factor convex in discount rate.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
18/37
Promptness or wait-to-learn
Increasing costs of abatement create incentives to act now.Technology might provide an offset.
Differing irreversibilities tug analysis in opposite directions.
Sunk cost irreversibilities delay to learn offset byno regrets options.
Catastrophic irreversibilities act decisively now increased flexibility via backstop options.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
19/37
Convexity of damages
Forecasts of 3oC mean increase in temps, will causemoderate damage (5-10% of GDP).
3oC = mean(2oC& 4oC) = mean (00C & 6oC)
In last case, no warming, no damage. But equal
probability of 60C warming, a catastrophe.
More uncertainty strengthens case for decisive action.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
20/37
Catastrophic uncertainties
Given various possible states of world but one where:
Catastrophic costs occur with non-negligibleprobability.
Should act to avoid that state irrespective of discountrates or strategic issues. Favours unilateralism & takingprompt action.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
21/37
CBA under Knightianuncertainty
If losses large relative to policy costs (the case!)activism sensibly motivated by minimax regret.
A probability-free insurance principle.
In remote case where climate science gets it wrong
we will have squandered a small bit of GDP.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
22/37
Technology uncertainty
Substantial on CCS technologies, new nuclear.
Explore a portfolio of technologies
(renewables, nuclear) & focus on CCS.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
23/37
General empirical
observation
Even with uncertainty there ispresumption - cost of active policy lowrelative to doing nothing.
e.g. Stern & Garnaut Reviews, IPPC(2007), Nordhaus, Weitzman (2009).
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
24/37
3. Australian policy
Australia heavily impacted on by unmitigatedclimate change. A fringe climate society.
Australia a small country - our GGEs a small
fraction of global total.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
25/37
Policy resolves into
focus on:
Adaptation
Mitigation
Policies helping good global response.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
26/37
Adaptation
Plausibly expect 1.8-2oC warming from
current GGE concentrations.
So case for adaptation in agriculture,
industry, urban settlements & biodiversityresources.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
27/37
Adaptations not subject to free-rider marketfailure issues of mitigation policies.
Can rely on market-driven responses & policyresponses encouraging market-driven
responses.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
28/37
Example - agriculture
Policy - provide info & expand technological
choices farmers have. Market failures meaninfo investment & R&D need to be a majorfocus.
Redesign policies which reduce need to adapt e.g. drought relief.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
29/37
Mitigation
If only adaptation pursued - a race tocollective disaster.
US & China provide 50% of GGEs, but 15countries provide 80%, another 158 providing
20%. Small countries are important.
& Australia should not provide negative moralsuasion.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
30/37
ETS the cheapest way to limit GGEs. Regulation
more expensive. Global ETS reduces costs by20%. A key message for industry.
Preferred option - best ETS should charge for
GGEs on a consumption basis. Exempt exports& subject imports to BTAs unless exportingcountry charge carbon production.
Eventually all countries should charge carbonproduction.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
31/37
Australian CPRS will be phased in - unlimitedpermits @ $10/tCO2 from 2011/12 with full
permit auctioning from 2012/13 @ $29/tCO2.
Revenues returned to households, fuel excise
offsets, trade-exposed firms, electricitygenerators.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
32/37
Main effect - electricity prices will rise 25% in2012/13 consumers face substitutioneffects.
Impacts on brown coal generators but 93% ofcapacity still in place by 2020.
Potential for nuclear power & renewables but limited background capacities.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
33/37
Assessment
Should pursue ambitious targets & commit to imposeBTAs after 2025 (cf.Waxman-Markey).
Australia gains with CCS initiatives a sound R&Dfocus. Agriculture contributes 1/3 of world CO2 & most
NO & CH4. Australia should watch NZ.
Need to reduce policy uncertainty by setting upcredible climate change institutions.
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
34/37
4. Final Comments
Major parties could not approve CPRS in Senate. Unlessthe Coalition seeks electoral oblivion the Bill will pass.
Proposed CPRS reasonable apart from exemptions toelectricity sector.
Waiting to 2013 to decide on agriculture - but musteventually be bought into CPRS - carbon sequestration
synergies with sustainable agriculture .
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
35/37
Australian Government plans will match a
comprehensive agreement in Copenhagen.
Sensible conditional & unconditional targets.
Stronger targets not sensible now thoughthey will be.
Fi l d
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
36/37
Final words picked (almost) atrandom
The new climatology of the American south-west..Science 25 May 2007:
Vol. 316. no. 5828, pp. 1181 1184
Model Projections of an Imminent Transition to a More Arid Climate in SouthwesternNorth America
Richard Seager,1* Mingfang Ting,1 Isaac Held,2,3 Yochanan Kushnir,1 Jian Lu,4 Gabriel
Vecchi,2 Huei-Ping Huang,1 Nili Harnik,5 Ants Leetmaa,2 Ngar-Cheung Lau,2,3 Cuihua Li,1Jennifer Velez,1 Naomi Naik1
How anthropogenic climate change will affect hydroclimate inthe arid regions of southwesternNorth America has implicationsfor the allocation of water resources and the course of regional
development. Here we show that there is a broad consensus amongclimate models that thisregion will dry in the 21st centuryand that the transition to a more arid climate should alreadybeunder way. If these models are correct, the levels of aridityof the recent multiyear drought or the
Dust Bowl and the 1950s
droughts will become the new climatology of the American Southwest
within a time frame of years to decades.
Note broadconsensus &imminent!
-
8/14/2019 Harry Clarke La Trobe University Economic Society of Australia, Victorian
37/37