grid+ mapping and gap analysis, kpis, eegi labelled projects...gap analysis : preliminary outcomes...
TRANSCRIPT
GRID+ Mapping and Gap Analysis, KPIs, EEGI labelled projects
Ilaria Losa (RSE), Gareth Bissell (ENEL)
TOOLS TO SUPPORT THE EUROPEAN ELECTRICITY GRID INITIATIVE: THE ROLL-OUT OF SMART GRIDS - 24th June 2014
Smart grids projects in EU
R&D (45%) almost as numerous as Demo & Deployment (55%)
More National (63%) than Multinational
Numbers: 459 smart grid projects
mostly Demo & Deployment (73%)
National funding (57%) weighing a bit more than Multinational (43%)
Investment: € 3 150 million
2 Source: JRC DATABASE 2013
Structure of the EEGI roadmap (distribution)
Cluster 1: Integration of
Smart customers
D1. Active Demand Response
D2. Energy Efficiency from integration
with Smart Homes
Cluster 2: integration of DER
and new users
D3. DSO integration of small DER
D4. System integration of medium DER
D5:Integration of storage in network
mgt
D6: Infrastructure to host EV/PHEV
Cluster 3: Network
operation
D7: Monitoring and control of LV network
D8. Automation and control of MV
network
D9. Network management tools
D10. Smart metering data processing
Cluster 4: network planning
and asset management
D11. New planning approaches
D12. Asset management
D13. New approaches for market design
Structure of the EEGI roadmap (transmission)
Cluster 1: Grid Architecture
T1 -Definition of scenarios for pan-European network
expansion
T2 - Planning methodology for
future pan-European
transmission system
T14 -Towards increasing public
acceptance of transmission
infrastructure
Cluster 2: Power technologies
T3 - Demonstration of power technology
to increase network flexibility
and operation means
T4-Demonstration of novel network
architectures
T5 -Interfaces for large-scale demos of RES integration
Cluster 3: Network
Operation
T6 - Innovative tools and methods to
observe and control the pan-European
network
T7 - Innovative tools and methods for
coordinated operation with stability margin
evaluation
T8 - Improved training tools and methods to
ensure better coordination at the regional and pan-Eu
levels
T9 - Innovative tools and approaches for
pan-European network reliability
assessment
Cluster 4: Market rules
T10 - Advanced pan-European
market tools for ancillary services
and balancing, including active
demand management
T11 - Advanced tools for capacity
allocation and congestion
management
T12 - Tools & market
mechanisms for ensuring system
adequacy and efficiency
integrating very large amounts of
RES
Cluster 5: Asset Management
T15 - Developing approaches to
determine and to maximize the
lifetime of critical power
components for existing and
future networks
T16 -Development
and validation of tools which
optimize asset maintenance at
the system level, based on
quantitative CBA
T17 - Demonstrations
of new asset management
approaches at EU level
Joint TSO/DSO projects
TD1 - Increased observability of the distribution system
for transmission network MNGT &
control;
TD2 - The integration of demand side
management at DSO level into TSO
operations
TD3 - Ancillary services provided
through DSOs
TD4 - Improved defense and
restoration plan
TD5 - Methodologies for scaling-up and
replicating
GRID+
Gap analysis: methodology-1
• To highlight transversal issues with respect to key aspects for the large scale
deployment of the innovations tested in pilot projects
• To assess the maturity level of each Functional Objective with respect to the EEGI
priorities
• To compare the results achieved by ongoing and past demos with the relevant EEGI
priorities and to identify research priorities for future research programmes
DOMAIN EEGI ROADMAP Priorities EXPECTED RESULTS
Hardware
Software tools Toolbox to build scenarios.
• Tools to perform network simulations at Pan EU level integrating new emerging technologies.
Integration into the system
To define pan-European network expansion scenarios; identify maximum volume of RES and DER for pan-European network; identify investments required to achieve 2050 vision
To provide methods for identifying rates of storage needed at European level to
develop a sustainable and efficient network
Gap analysis: methodology-2 Maturity categories- transmission
Hardware
Software tools
Integration into the system
Cost-benefit analysis
Regulation of grid services
Stakeholders involvement
System reliability
Data privacy
Maturity categories- distribution
Hardware
Software tools
Integration into the system
Business model
Cost-benefit analysis
Regulation of grid services
Stakeholders involvement
System reliability
6
the maturity categories are a limited set metrics orthogonal (independent) to the structure of the EEGI clusters and functional objectives, applicable to a large set of objectives, able to assess as closely as possible the key goals of each objective without redundancy. Maturity categories consider incremental smart grid characteristics and capabilities that represent key elements defined in the roadmap: grid planning, development, operation, management
Gap analysis: methodology-3
Ranking scheme
7
DISTRIBUTION
Based on EEGI roadmap 2012 Maturity levels assigned in cooperation with the members of EDSO4SG
GAP ANALYSIS : preliminary outcomes
D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D8 D9 D10 D11 D12 D13
Hardware 0 2 2 1 2 2 1 0 2 0 -1 3 -1
Software tools 3 1 3 1 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 3
Integration into the system 2 3 3 2 2 2 2 1 -1 1 2 2 0
Business model 2 2 2 2 3 2 2 -1 -1 2 -1 3 2
Assessment of system reliability 2 3 2 1 2 2 3 0 2 2 2 3 1
Regulatory framework 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 3 -1 2 1 3 2
Stakeholders involvement 2 2 3 2 3 2 1 -1 -1 2 3 3 2
Data privacy 1 2 2 1 -1 3 2 -1 -1 2 -1 -1 2
PRIORITIES 2014 PRIORITIES 2015
Link With EEGI implementation plan
• requires fundamental research for: software tools; business model; stakeholders involvement
• Requires moderate development for: Hardware, Business model, Assessment of system reliability, Regulatory framework
D5 - Integration of storage in network management
• Requries moderate development for: Business model; Assessment of system reliability; Regulatory framework; Stakeholders involvement; Data privacy
• Need more demonstration for Integration into the system
D10 - Smart metering data processing
• Requires fundamental research for : Hardware; Business model; Assessment of system reliability; Regulatory framework; Stakeholders involvement; Data privacy
• Requries moderate development for: Software tools; Integration into the system;
D12 - Asset management
DSO Topics 2014 DSO Topics 2015
• requires fundamental research for: software tools; Integration into the system; stakeholders involvement
• Requires moderate development for: Hardware, Business model, Assessment of system reliability, Regulatory framework; data privacy
D3 - Integration Small DER
• Requries moderate development for: Integration into the system; Business model; Regulatory framework; Stakeholders involvement;
• Need more demonstration for Hardware; software tools; System reliability; data privacy
D4 - Integration medium DER
• Requires fundamental research for : Assessment of system reliability;
•Requries moderate development for: Software tools; Integration into the system; Business model; Data privacy; •Need more demonstration for Hardware; Regulatory framework; Stakeholders involvement;
D7 - Monitoring and Control LV network
TRANSMISSION
• Based on EEGI roadmap 2012 • Maturity levels assigned in cooperation with the members of ENTSO-E • Validation with external stakeholders on 24° March 2014
GAP ANALYSIS : preliminary outcomes
T1 T2 T14 T3 T4 T5 T6 T7 T8 T9 T10 T11 T12 T15 T16 T17
Hardware -1 -1 3 1 3 2 1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 3 -1 2
Software tools -1 2 3 2 2 2 2 3 2 3 2 2 3 2 3 -1
Integration into the
system 3 1 -1 2 2 2 3 2 2 3 2 3 2 2 3 2
Business model -1 2 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 -1 2 3 3 3 -1 -1 -1
Cost-benefit analysis 2 2 3 2 2 2 -1 -1 -1 2 3 2 2 3 3 2
Regulation of grid
services -1 1 3 -1 -1 2 -1 1 -1 3 3 2 3 -1 -1 3
Stakeholders
involvement -1 2 3 -1 -1 1 -1 -1 2 2 3 2 2 2 -1 3
System reliability -1 3 3 2 3 2 2 3 -1 3 3 2 2 3 3 2
PRIORITIES 2014 PRIORITIES 2015
Link With EEGI implementation plan
• Requires moderate development for: software tools, Integration into the system, Cost Benefit Analysis, Business model, Assessment of system reliability, Regulatory framework
• Need more demonstration for: Hardware
T3 - Demonstration of power technology to increase network flexibility and operation means
• requires fundamental research for; Integration into the system;
• Requries moderate development for: Software tools involvement; Data privacy
• Need more demonstration for Hardware
T6 - Innovative tools and methods to observe and control the pan-European network
TSO Topics 2014- 1 Demonstration of future smart HV substations
TSO Topics 2014- 2: Novel cross border balancing market mechanisms and tools for ensuring system reliability
• requires fundamental research for: Business model; CBA; Assessment of system reliability, Regulatory framework; stakeholders involvement
• Requires moderate development for: software tools, Integration into the system
T10- Advanced pan-European market tools for ancillary services and balancing, [..]
• requires fundamental research for: Software tools; Integration in the system; Assessment of system reliability, Regulatory framework
• Requries moderate development for: Business model; CBA; Stakeholders involvement;
T9 - Innovative tools and approaches for pan-Eu ntwk reliability asses.
• Requires fundamental research for : Integration into the system; Business model
•Requries moderate development for: Software tools; CBA; Assessment of system reliability, Regulatory framework; stakeholders involvement
T11 - Monitoring and Control LV network
TRANSMISSION / DISTRIBUTION INTERFACE
GAP ANALYSIS : preliminary outcomes
TD1 TD2 TD3 TD4 TD5
Hardware -1 2 1 -1 -1
Software tools 2 2 2 3 -1
Integration into the system 2 3 2 3 3
Business model -1 3 3 -1 -1
Cost-benefit analysis -1 3 3 -1 3
Regulation of grid services 2 3 3 3 3
Stakeholders involvement 2 2 3 2 3
System reliability 2 3 2 2 -1
• Based on EEGI roadmap 2012 • Maturity levels assigned in cooperation with the members of ENTSO-E • RESULTS WILL BE VALIDATED DURING A WEBINARS
PRIORITIES 2014
PRIORITIES 2015
Link With EEGI implementation plan
• Requires fundamental research for: Integration into the system; Business model; Cost-benefit analysis; Regulation of grid services
• Requires moderate development for: Hardware, Software tools, Stakeholders
involvement;
TD2 - Integration of demand side management at DSO level into TSO operation.
TSO/DSO Topics 2014 TSO/DSO Topics 2015
• requires fundamental research for: Software tools; Integration into the system; Cost-benefit analysis; Regulation of grid services; Stakeholders involvement
• Requires moderate development for:
Assessment of system reliability,
TD5 - Demonstration of Power Load Control Mechanisms at TSO and DSO levels
• requires fundamental research for: Integration into the system; Cost-benefit analysis; Regulation of grid services; Stakeholders involvement;
TD1 - Increased Observability of the Distribution Systems for Transmission Network Management
Validation with external stakeholders 24 March 2014 in Brussels (ENTSO-E)
• Workshop with stakeholders about Gap analysis results and Identification of R&I priorities
09 April 2014 in Madrid (IBERDROLA)
• Interaction Workshop on Network Planning & Asset management (DSO) – Configuring the systems, transforming the networks
27 May 2014 in Copenhagen (ENERGINET.DK)
• Interaction Workshop with Nordic projects – In cooperation with ENERGINET.DK, SINTEF and Norwegian Smart Grid Centre
10 June 2014 in Rome (GSE)
• Interaction Workshop on Market design Issues (DSO) – Market Design for a future European energy system -
19 June 2014, Rome (T&D EUROPE)
• Workshop with manufacturers related to WP1 Mapping and Gap Analysis
EEGI Project Labelling Scheme
15 300 projects ~
Why should I apply?
18
Knowledge sharing
Dissemination
Collaboration
Community
Online Application Form
19
www.gridplus.eu
Project results EEGI Roadmap objectives
20
www.gridplus.eu
R&I Roadmap Objectives
Cluster NameFunctional
ObjectiveFull names of Functional Objectives
T1 Definition of scenarios for pan-European network expansion
T2 Planning methodology for future pan-European transmission system
T14 Towards increasing public acceptance of transmission infrastructure
T3 Demonstration of power technology to increase network flexibility and operation means
T4 Demonstration of novel network architectures
T5 Interfaces for large-scale demonstration of renewable integration
T6 Innovative tools and methods for pan-European network observability and controllability
T7 Innovative tools and methods for coordinated operation with stability margin evaluation
T8Improved training tools and methods to ensure better coordination at the regional and pan-
European levels
T9 Innovative tools and approaches for pan-European network reliability assessment
T10Advanced pan-European market tools for ancillary services and balancing, including active demand
management
T11 Advanced tools for capacity allocation and congestion management
T12Tools and market mechanisms for ensuring system adequacy and efficiency in electric systems
integrating very large amounts of RES generation
T15ObjectivesDeveloping approaches to determine and to maximize the lifetime of critical power
components for existing and future networks
T16Development and validation of tools which optimize asset lifetime at the system level, based on
quantitative cost/benefit analysis
T17 Demonstrations of potential at EU level for new approaches to asset management
Grid architectureC1
Power technologiesC2
Network operationC3
Market designsC4
Asset managementC5
Cluster NameFunctional
ObjectiveFull names of Functional Objectives
TD1Increased observability of the distribution system for transmission network management and
control
TD2 The integration of demand side management at DSO level into TSO operations
TD3 Ancillary services provided through DSOs
TD4 Improved defense and restoration plan
TD5 Tools for scaling-up and replicating at EU level
TDJoint TSO/DSO
Activities
Cluster NameFunctional
ObjectiveFull names of Functional Objectives
D1 Active demand for increased flexibility
D2 Energy Efficiency from integration with Smart Homes
D3 DSO integration of small DER
D4 System integration of medium DER
D5 Integration of storage in network management
D6 Infrastructure to host EV/PHEV
D7 Monitoring and control of MV network
D8 Automation and control of MV network
D9 Network management tools
D10 Smart metering data processing
D11 New planning approaches for distribution networks
D12 Asset management
C5 Market Design D13 Novel approaches for market design analysis
C1Integration of smart
customers
C2
C3
C4
Integration of DER and
new users
Network Operations
Network Planning and
asset management
EEGI Key Performance Indicators
www.gridplus.eu 21
Two Categories
• Implementation Effectiveness
• Impact KPIs
5,7% 11,8% 4,9% 10,6% 3,6%
17,2% 7,0% 19,6%
29,6%
13,0% 11,2%
1,8% 14,0% 0,7%
0,3%
75,4%67,3%
74,8%59,4%
87,0% 85,2%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
R&D Plan Cluster 1 Cluster 2 Cluster 3 Cluster 4 Cluster 5
Progress of the ENTSO-E R&D Plan
Not started yet
Under proposal
Ongoing
Completed
Budget
Results
www.gridplus.eu 22
Implementation Effectiveness
R&I Roadmap Objectives
5,7% 11,8% 4,9% 10,6% 3,6%
17,2% 7,0% 19,6%
29,6%
13,0% 11,2%
1,8% 14,0% 0,7%
0,3%
75,4%67,3%
74,8%59,4%
87,0% 85,2%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
R&D Plan Cluster 1 Cluster 2 Cluster 3 Cluster 4 Cluster 5
Progress of the ENTSO-E R&D Plan
Not started yet
Under proposal
Ongoing
Completed
EXAMPLE FIGURES
Current investment with respect to the allocated budget
www.gridplus.eu 23
Impact KPIs
Objective of Impact KPIs Expected benefits of R&I activities vs BaU approach
www.gridplus.eu 24
Expected benefits
R&I
BaU
Impact KPIs
www.gridplus.eu 25
Overarching KPIs
“To allow European electricity networks continuously deliver effective
flexible capacities to integrate actions of grid users at affordable costs”
Overarching Goal:
1. Increased network capacity at affordable cost
2. Increased network flexibility at affordable cost
Impact KPIs
www.gridplus.eu 26
Specific KPIs
1. Increased RES and DER hosting capacity
2. Reduced energy curtailment of RES and DER
3. Power quality and quality of supply
4. Extended asset life time
5. Increased flexibility from energy players
6. Improved competitiveness of the electricity
market
7. Increased hosting capacity for electric vehicles
(EVs) and other new loads
Impact KPIs
www.gridplus.eu 27
Scalability & Replicability
KPIs covered by projects used to evaluate EEGI Programme and Cluster Level KPIs
The definition of these are out of the scope of the GRID+ project
Results of R&I projects aggregated using Scalability and Replicability studies
www.gridplus.eu
28
Project KPIs
%100&%
BAU
BAUIR
HC
HCHCEHC
Project A
%100&%
BAU
BAUIR
HC
HCHCEHC
Project A
%100&%
BAU
BAUIR
HC
HCHCEHC
Project A
%100&%
BAU
BAUIR
HC
HCHCEHC
Project A
EEGI Programme
‘Specific’ KPI
%100&%
BAU
BAUIR
HC
HCHCEHC
Scalability and
replicability studies
Evolution of technology
Modularity
Interface design
Technological standardization
Interoperability
Plug & play characteristics
Availability
Regulatory conditions
EEGI Programme KPIs
29
• Evaluation
• Scalability and Replicability
• Validation of EEGI KPIs
• Definition of EEGI KPIs – D3.4
Thank you