goals and intent of cflow explosivity of lava domes estimate of gas overpressure heterogeneity of...

19
GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT WALLS 2-D PRESSURE STATE IN THE CONDUIT MT UNZEN, JAPAN MT ST HELENS, USA CFLOW H. Massol, C. Jaupart

Upload: virgil-potter

Post on 05-Jan-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW

EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES

ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE

HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES

GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT WALLS

2-D PRESSURE STATE IN THE CONDUIT

MT UNZEN, JAPAN

MT ST HELENS, USA

CFLOW H. Massol, C. Jaupart

Page 2: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

VISCOUS ANDCOMPRESSIBLEFLOW

INCOMPRESSIBLEFLOW

BUBBLY SECTION

MAGMA CHAMBER

Exsolution level

INTEGRATIONDOMAIN

SCHEMATIC VIEW OF A VOLCANIC CONDUIT

ORIGINALITY: 2-DMETHOD: Finite Element

Page 3: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

= -2 e + 23

( .v) + Pg - K ( .v)

Pg: Gas pressure Shear viscosityK: Bulk viscosity

Pg = P + K ( .v)

RHEOLOGY (1)

VISCOSITY+COMPRESSIBILITY

GAS OVERPRESSURE

DOME EXPLOSIVITY

Page 4: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

bR

Pg

o , p

f

Pml

K,

RHEOLOGY (2)

= pg -

2b

- 4µl

˙

RR2

b 31 -

b 3

R3[ r r ] r=R ( )

K =43µ

l

1 -

[ r r

] r=R = pm

- 3KR

R

p m

= p b-

2b

Page 5: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

0

z

ra

h

H

zz = p s u = 0

zz = p atm

u = 0or rz = 0

u = 0w = 0

u = 0

rz = 0

DOMAINAND BC

Page 6: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

BASIC EQUATIONS

Artificial time

Mass lumping

Petrov Galerkin weighting

[ D ] U = SU

[ D ] W = SW

[ M ] = S

Conservation of momentum

Conservation of mass

Criteres d’arret

10-2 10-8

Criteres d’arret

10-2 10-8

Page 7: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

CAPABILITIES

VARIABLE MELT VISCOSITY

VARIABLE CONDUIT GEOMETRY

HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL VELOCITY COMPONENTS

VARIABLE COMPRESSIBILITY

ASSUMPTIONS AND LIMITS

EQUILIBRIUM DEGASSING

ONLY VALID BEFORE FRAG. LEVEL

Page 8: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

ANALYTICAL SOLUTION

HYPOTHESES

- No horizontal velocity - Constant compressibility - Constant viscosity

BUT: Gas pressure varies in both directions

Numerical model benchmark

Page 9: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

RESULTS

PARABOLIC PRESSURE PROFILE ACROSS THE CONDUIT

DIMENSIONLESS NUMBER, D

PH-PaP0-pa

= P K+4/3

a2

H2= D

Page 10: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

EXAMPLERESULT (1)

U = 0

= 106 Pa.s

x0 = 0.5 Wt%

P(0,H) = 0.56 MPa

Page 11: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

OVERPRESSURE AT THE CENTER OF THE CONDUIT EXIT

Compatiblewith theanalytical solution

Page 12: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

EXAMPLERESULT (2)

x0 = 0.5 Wt%

P(0,H) = 0.56 MPa

Variable viscosity(Hess and Dingwell, 96)

rz = 0

P(a,H) = 1.5 MPa

Page 13: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

EXAMPLERESULT (3)

x0 = 0.5 Wt%

P(0,H) = 0.34 MPa

P(a,H) = 1.1 MPa

Page 14: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

CONCLUSIONS

GAS PHASE IS OVERPRESSURED / DOME EXPLOSIVITY

HORIZONTAL PRESSURE GRADIENT / VITRIFIED MARGINS, HETEROGENEITY IN GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES

IMPORTANCE OF THE EXIT BOUNDARY CONDITIONS / CREASE STRUCTURE

Page 15: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

FUTURE WORK

BOUNDARY CONDITIONS

- CONDUIT WALLS AND - COUPLING WITH FLOW

CRYSTALS

Page 16: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

Fragmentation Level

Laminar Flow

Turbulent Flow

Nucleation of Bubbles

NUCLASCENT

1-D Finite differenceCylindrical GeometrySteady state

Variable viscosityNon-equilibrium degassing

(H. Massol, T. Koyaguchi)

Page 17: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

EVOLUTION OF DISSOLVED WATER IN THE MELT

H=5000 ma = 50 m0 = 106 Pa.sx0 = 4wt%= 0.02 N m-1

D = 10-11 m2 s-1

Page 18: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

H=5000 ma = 50 m0 = 106 Pa.sx0 = 4wt%= 0.02 N m-1

D = 10-11 m2 s-1

EVOLUTION OF PRESSURE AND NUMBER OF BUBBLES

Page 19: GOALS AND INTENT OF CFLOW EXPLOSIVITY OF LAVA DOMES ESTIMATE OF GAS OVERPRESSURE HETEROGENEITY OF GAS CONTENT IN FLOWS AND DOMES GAS LOSS THROUGH CONDUIT

OUTPUT OF THE MODEL

BUBBLE SIZES BUBBLE DENSITY

PRESSURE INSIDE BUBBLES

NEXT STEP: CONTINUOUS BUBBLE SIZE DISTRIBUTION