ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet

Upload: still-rage

Post on 06-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    1/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 1 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goesveggie to lose weight and save planet Belgian city hopes radical experiment will catch on

    Meat, fish and seafood off the menu every Thursday

    Ian Traynor in Ghent

    The Guardian, Thursday 14 May 2009

    Vegetarian delights such as soya fritters, eggless mayo and aubergine caviar will become part of Ghent's diet every

    Thursday. Photograph: Gianni Barbieux

    On the bouncy play platform outside Ghent's 15th century slaughterhouse, the banana

    was thumping the beefsteak.

    The two boys battled in the drizzle yesterday, the one in the fruity yellow costume

    serving up another veggie victory over his rival in bloody scarlet.

    The parent onlookers laughed and munched another soya fritter. Mmm, yummy, said

    the man with a heart condition. They queued five-deep in the rain to dip their organic,

    wholegrain bread in the aubergine caviar, to smear their lips with eggless mayo. Another

    pure fruit vitamin cocktail under the marquee?

    "This is pretty special, pretty unique," said Tobias Leenaert, an anti-meat campaigner.

    "An entire city proclaiming one day a week a veggie day."

    Ghent embarks on a radical experiment today, seeking to make every Thursday a day

    free of meat and of the fish and shellfish for which the city is renowned.

    On the eve of what is being touted as an unprecedented exercise, the biggest queue in

    the Flemish university town of 200,000 yesterday was for signatures to collect a bag

    of wholefood goodies and sign up for "Donderdag Veggie Dag", turning the burghers

    of Ghent into pioneers in the fight against obesity, global warming, cruelty to animals

    and against the myth that meat-free eating amounts to a diet of soggy lettuce, a slice of

    tomato, and a foul-tasting bean burger.

    The city council says it is the first town in Europe and probably the western world to tryto make the entire place vegetarian for a day every week. Tom Balthazar, the Labour

    party councillor pushing the scheme, said: "There's nothing compulsory. We just want

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    2/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 2 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Ads by Google100K+ Pension In Italy?

    Want Increased Benefits & Returns? Move To QROPS, Free Guide & Advice!

    QROPSpensiondesigner.com/Guardian

    New Business Opportunity

    Run Your Own Energy Saving Business Complete Start-Up Pack from $14k

    www.Enigin.net/BusinessOpportunity

    Yewfield Vegetarian B&B

    5 star lake District guest house lovely walks organic groundswww.yewfield.co.uk

    to be a city that promotes sustainable and healthy living."

    Every restaurant in the city is to guarantee a vegetarian dish on the menu, with some

    going fully vegetarian every Thursday. From September, the city's schools are to make a

    meat-free meal the "default" option every Thursday, although parents can insist on meat

    for their children. At least one hospital wants to join in.

    A small, dreamy city of spires, bicycles, and canals, prospering since the Middle Ages,

    Ghent may be on to something. It appears to be tapping into a zeitgeist awareness of thecost to human health and the environment of intensive meat and dairy farming. Other

    towns in Belgium and the Netherlands are making inquiries; there has even been one

    from Canada.

    "We hope that the university, other institutions, enterprises and other towns will jump

    on the train," said Leenaert, director of the local branch of Flanders' Ethical Vegetarian

    Association (EVA).

    The organisers cite UN data arguing that meat production and consumption are to

    blame for 18% of greenhouse gases more than cars. "If everyone in Flanders does not

    eat meat one day a week, we will save as much CO2 in a year as taking half a million cars

    off the road," said the EVA.

    "I never touch meat, unless I'm at my grandmother's and I need to be polite," said

    Karien De Temmermann, a young EVA member.

    "This is not a plan for everyone to be forced into vegetarianism," said Wim Coenen, a

    vegan who works as an importer of vegetarian pet food from Italy. "But it will reduce

    our carbon footprint. The basic premise is to introduce a way of lessening our meat

    consumption."

    The revolution starts today with a foodie festival at the vegetable market. Ninety

    thousand town maps listing the best eateries for the meat-shy are being handed out.

    Recipe booklets and food samples are being distributed, with fair trade wine to wash

    down the nibbles. A nearby restaurant is serving a four-course veggie lunch for !12. The

    kebab house on the market is eschewing the doner for broadbean falafel and haloumi

    cheese.

    Ghent boasts a string of outstanding restaurants and is well-known for gourmet

    vegetarian cuisine. The council reckons it has more veggie eateries per capita than

    London, Paris or Berlin.

    The Lib-Lab coalition running the city was persuaded to back the idea when Philippe

    van den Bulck, an outstanding culinary talent, served up a veggie gastronomic tour de

    force at the town hall. He is one of Flanders's top chefs and food writers, doing time atEl Bulli in Spain, to many the best restaurant in the world. He is also a vegetarian.

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    3/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 3 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Comments in chronological order (Total 102

    comments)Staff

    Contributor

    mochila14 May 2009 9:40AM

    Obviously, the western diet cannot be adopted by the planet's entire population, the

    land required is simply not available. It is great to see a whole city kick-start what is a

    debate which is over-due on this scale.

    It has put Ghent on the map for me, and I'll be paying the place a visit to take in the vibe

    of a place changing its collective consciousness. I'd love a follow-up report on this in the

    future.

    Recommend (23)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    gatz

    14 May 2009 9:46AM

    Every restaurant in the city is to guarantee a vegetarian dish on the menu, with some

    going fully vegetarian every Thursday.

    Now that's a very different proposition to 'forcing' everyone to go veggie one day a week,

    as much coverage has suggested, isn't it? Even as a vegeterain of more than 20 years

    standing (and one who weighs about 90k - a veggie diet doesn't automatically convey

    sveltness) I know that coercing people into doing anything about their diet is bound tobackfire.

    Oh, and if the point is not to reinforce cliches, why the insistance on refering to the

    bread as organic wholegrain? Even if it was on this occaision it is not difficult to eat

    nothing but junk on a vegetarian diet if that is what you wish to do.

    Recommend (8)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Intersubjective1

    14 May 2009 9:51AM

    It's amazing how most people think that they haven't eaten properly or enough if they

    don't eat meat, even for a day, when you can swap beef or chicken for a pasta dish or a

    pizza.

    Recommend (11)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    4/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 4 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    teaboy

    14 May 2009 9:55AM

    No comments yet? I'll start- it's a great idea!

    Recommend (5)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuseClip

    | Link

    ariel3

    14 May 2009 9:55AM

    surprised no flesheater has mentioned extra-methane yet.

    Recommend (0)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Nattydread69

    14 May 2009 9:56AM

    Ghent is a lovely city, I used to live near there, very vibrant.

    Unfortunately not all veggie food is healthy. Bet most of you don't know that soya causes

    brain damage in men. Its not healthy at all.

    But on a whole less meat can only be a good thing for the world.

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    OneForTeam

    14 May 2009 10:03AM

    Ghent is a wonderful city. Now there's an extra reason to visit!

    Recommend (9)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuseClip

    | Link

    CandiceMarie

    14 May 2009 10:03AM

    I was thinking of booking a trip to Ghent anyway, this has made up my mind. These are

    the kind of sacrifices we are going to have to make on an increasing basis. Maybe in a

    decade they will be leading us to only having meat once a week.

    Recommend (4)

    Responses (0)Report abuse

    Clip

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    5/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 5 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    | Link

    Intersubjective1

    14 May 2009 10:10AM

    Nattydread: your news is ten years old the most up-to-date research on soya suggest

    othewise:

    From the Institute of Food Research Website:Evidence for soya causing breast cancer or reducing the risk of breast cancer is scarce

    and inconclusive. Conversely, research from the USA supports an inverse relationship

    between the intake of non-fermented soya products and prostate cancer. Other studies

    suggest that frequent consumption (> once a day) of soymilk is associated with a

    reduction in prostate cancer risk For more information on the studies conducted visit

    the Food Standards Agency (FSA) website.

    Recommend (9)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    languedocienne

    14 May 2009 10:12AM

    One meatless day a week is a great idea, and no loss for those who want a tasty diet. I

    love meat, but vegetables too and have at least one meatless day per week. Beef is the

    least sustainable meat and I hardly ever eat that. Pork and chicken, locally produced,

    can be perfectly sustainable and good for the whole cycle of food production.

    Local food is important too. Transporting food causes huge amounts of CO2 emissions

    and it's better to eat eggs and meat produced nearby than fruit and vegetables from the

    other side of the world. Bananas, for instance, do not grow anywhere near Ghent.

    Aubergine for the caviar does, but in heated greenhouses. It makes a good news story

    and it makes people think, but we have to be sensible about the choices we make to save

    the planet.

    http://olives-and-artichokes.blogspot.com

    Recommend (8)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    hannaka

    14 May 2009 10:15AM

    Ghent is a great place, as is Belgium. I love how Belgians often surprise me (as an expat)

    with such excellent measures! Can you imagine not allowing cars into London for a day

    to allow people to cycle and roller skate across the whole city? And yet Brussels does it

    every year!

    I think the article could also have mentioned how unethical it is that the majority of the

    grain produced in the world goes towards feeding cattle which will be used for meat,

    when there are people in many parts of the world who cannot afford that grain as a

    result.

    There are many reasons to cut down our meat consumption, and this is a great way for a

    city to set a good example.

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    6/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 6 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Recommend (15)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    ashie25914 May 2009 10:16AM

    Sounds as if they're going about it the right way. Great idea - something entirely

    positive.

    Recommend (11)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    McMuggins14 May 2009 10:17AM

    ..And to think, the only time I had been conscious of Ghent was a poem featuring

    someone bringing good news to the place ( from Aix? , I think) and flogging his horse to

    death in the process. Roll on with the good ideas.

    Cheers.

    Recommend (2)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    juanveron

    14 May 2009 10:18AM

    Imagine the reactions of a starving African or Asian family when they hear that,

    somewhere in Europe, people will abstain fron eating meat for one day (what a

    sacrifice!) in order to save the world!

    Recommend (2)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    ciderguard

    14 May 2009 10:26AM

    Right, that's the holiday booked! Ghent here I come!

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Dunnyboy

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    7/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 7 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    14 May 2009 10:27AM

    At least they are not forcing people to become vegetarians, so children and civil servants

    won't have to suffer at the hands of the faddists.

    I liked the line "It appears to be tapping into a zeitgeist awareness of the cost to human

    health and the environment of intensive meat and dairy farming." It's amazing how a

    tiny minority of well-organised activists can think of their obsession as the zeitgeist.

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    2345678

    14 May 2009 10:34AM

    Excellent! And Brussels has just had another car free day.

    Public transport is so bad in Uk prob. not possible.

    Recommend (4)

    Responses (0)Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    zubzub

    14 May 2009 10:35AM

    Intersubjective wrote

    It's amazing how most people think that they haven't eaten properly or enough if they

    don't eat meat, even for a day, when you can swap beef or chicken for a pasta dish or a

    pizza.

    In the nicest way possible, that is quite the most stupid thing I've ever read on CiF.

    Comparing pasta to meat as like for like - you can't be serious?

    I'd agree with vegetarians, to a degree, that economically and environmentally a meat

    based diet can't sustain the planet's population. But physiologically, it's free range meat

    - with all of the accompanying saturated fat - for me thank you.

    Recommend (2)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Voluspa

    14 May 2009 10:35AM

    Excellent idea. Anything however small it is that offers an alternative to the diet we in

    the west are currently killing ourselves with is a good thing. Well done Ghent.

    Recommend (7)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    8/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 8 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    calumsquire

    14 May 2009 10:36AM

    This is such a great idea!

    Spreading word such as this is great. Having been vegan for over a year now - can say

    it's the best thing ever happened to me. Mostly veggie since reaching double figures.

    Should happen in more places!Very positive outlook!

    Recommend (8)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    RedRicky1

    14 May 2009 10:37AM

    Whether is meat or veggie is irrelevant, it's how the food is produced which causesglobal warming. Diverting rivers for crops and ploughing up fragile land causes far more

    damage then grazing in some cases (think Australia). You should eat if possible local

    ethically produced food the rest of this PC Veggie bollocks like the import of veggie pet

    food. Just kill and eat the pet and turn the skin into a coat if you want to be really green

    :-)

    Recommend (9)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    zubzub

    14 May 2009 10:47AM

    Voluspa wrote

    Excellent idea. Anything however small it is that offers an alternative to the diet we in

    the west are currently killing ourselves with is a good thing. Well done Ghent.

    The diet we are currently killing ourselves with? I presume you must mean the carbs

    with carbs with a big side of extra carbs diet (dessert if still hungry - more carbs).

    Organic, fairtrade, low GI spelt pasta or a f*%king Mars Bar: it doesn't matter, it all ends

    up as a shitload of glucose. Do you think your insulin cares whether the glucose comes

    from grains or a can of Coke?

    Recommend (1)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    MrLondonKiwi

    14 May 2009 10:53AM

    Yet another pointless exercise by unimaginative people who think they are saving the

    plant -- yawn.

    I agree with Redricky1 to an extent, however even eating local is not a black and white

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    9/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 9 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    decision. importing product from countries that can grow / raise it more efficiently due

    to favourable climate for example may offset the freight impact in some cases.

    We were designed to eat meat and it is yummy.

    Recommend (4)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Touchy

    14 May 2009 10:54AM

    Hannaka is right - Belgium is AWESOME!

    Recommend (2)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    DianeDrinkwater

    14 May 2009 10:59AM

    I think learning to eat dandelions and chickweed would be more beneficial to the planet.

    It seems to be what we grow most of around the places we live.

    I appluad them for trying though.

    Recommend (0)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Gingecat

    14 May 2009 11:04AM

    Today I shall eat all the (meat) pies.

    Recommend (1)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Kaz1

    14 May 2009 11:15AM

    These are the kind of sacrifices we are going to have to make on an increasing basis

    It is great news and hopefully Ghent is just the first of many places to take a similar

    position. However referring to not eating animal-based products as a 'sacrifice' is an

    indication of just how far there is to go before we can reverse the meat-dependent

    culture in which we live. Vegetarian (and preferably vegan) food is not a sacrifice, both

    literally and metaphorically!

    Recommend (16)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    10/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 10 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Clip

    | Link

    Sipowicz

    14 May 2009 11:18AM

    Ghent was already pretty cool for veggies. Try the Tasty-World veggieburgers at

    Hoogpoort 1 and Walpoortstraat 38 for great fast food also Greenway Foods atNederkouter 42 for salads, pasta, hot baguettes and burgers. For something a bit more

    special try Panda at Oudburg 38 for great organic food. However be careful at Avalon,

    Geldmunt 32, which advertises itself as vegetarian but includes fish in some of its

    dishes.

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    defendyourself

    14 May 2009 11:21AM

    Well said zubzub.

    It seems to be too much to ask that people acquaint themselves with a bit of basic

    physiology. The diet that is currently killing us? Well that must explain why in the West

    we are living longer than ever before, growing taller, stronger and have relegated dietary

    deficiencies to the dustbin of history. There is an ever growing tendency to ignore the

    gains made in human health and wellbeing by the last one hundred and fifty years of

    technological and industrial development. That is not to say that there have been no

    mistakes and that there are not even better ways of doing things waiting to be

    discovered. Try looking on the positive side for once eh!What you eat should be a matter of choice, sadly for all too many people that is not the

    case, because there isn't enough food available. Eating less meat will not help them,

    eating your veg will not help them, buying their produce might.

    How about we have a mind your own business day. Sounds good to me.

    Recommend (5)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Robcris

    14 May 2009 11:26AM

    Fantastic, great, well done!! Let all happy and civilized cities and towns follow Ghents

    lead! Bravo!

    Recommend (8)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    bigeggo

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    11/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 11 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    14 May 2009 11:27AM

    This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community

    standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.

    Robcris

    14 May 2009 11:34AM

    Hey "defendyourself", have you tried researching the facts? People in the west may bestronger and taller than the poor starving masses, but that doesnt mean that

    westerners are healthy! Have you any idea of the problems facing the National Health

    Service in the UK?! We eat too much fatty food, too much sugar and salt, and drink way

    too much alcohol, and you must know that. Did you know that 1 kilo of beef uses up the

    resourses for 10 kilos of the equivalent crop foods? Meat production is a very very

    inefficient use of the worlds resources, and if we cut back, maybe there would be more

    for the poor. You may think you are a free-eating man of the world, but the fact is that

    you are talking like a selfish and careless person!

    Recommend (13)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuseClip

    | Link

    FFScat

    14 May 2009 11:37AM

    Lentil burghers! Ha-hah! Good one.

    Recommend (1)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Melkan

    14 May 2009 11:41AM

    It is great news and hopefully Ghent is just the first of many places to take a similar

    position. However referring to not eating animal-based products as a 'sacrifice' is an

    indication of just how far there is to go before we can reverse the meat-dependent

    culture in which we live. Vegetarian (and preferably vegan) food is not a sacrifice,

    both literally and metaphorically!

    It is. Its a potentially-extinction-inducing threat. The human body evolved to eat

    omniverously, and needs both animal and non-animal products to survive and prosper

    (for example vitamin B12). You can get by short-term on not eating animal products but

    in the long term, reproductive fitness can only be assured by eating a mixed and

    balanced diet. This is basic scientic fact.

    And can I remind any "but I've been a vegan since the year dot and I'm healthy" type-

    responders that the plural of "ancedote" is not "data"?

    And besides, vegans are utterly misable as sin, all of them. As the great Anthony

    Bourdain said, "My body is an amusement park, not a temple".

    Recommend (7)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    12/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 12 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    | Link

    neecheecat

    14 May 2009 11:49AM

    I think it's a great idea.

    Recommend (1)

    Responses (0)Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    aussibum

    14 May 2009 12:03PM

    This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community

    standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.

    steve3742

    14 May 2009 12:05PM

    Whether is meat or veggie is irrelevant, it's how the food is produced which causes

    global warming. Diverting rivers for crops and ploughing up fragile land causes far more

    damage then grazing in some cases (think Australia). You should eat if possible local

    ethically produced food the rest of this PC Veggie bollocks like the import of veggie pet

    food. Just kill and eat the pet and turn the skin into a coat if you want to be really green

    :-)

    OK, but given that the relatively huge amounts of meat in the western diet require

    intensive farming of animals and that this, in turn, requires intensive farming of veg

    (between 5-10 times as much land is required to produce enough crops to feed animalsto produce the same amount of calories as if you just grew crops to eat), then it seems

    this "PC Veggie bollocks" micght just have a point?

    The diet that is currently killing us? Well that must explain why in the West we are

    living longer than ever before, growing taller, stronger and have relegated dietary

    deficiencies to the dustbin of history. There is an ever growing tendency to ignore the

    gains made in human health and wellbeing by the last one hundred and fifty years of

    technological and industrial development.

    Perhaps advances in medicine and sanitation in particualar, not to mention increases in

    general standard of living are responsible for our increased lifespan? The western diet is

    responsible for a) ever increasing obesity, which is killing people and b) environmental

    destruction, which is also killing people.

    What you eat should be a matter of choice, sadly for all too many people that is not the

    case, because there isn't enough food available. Eating less meat will not help them,

    eating your veg will not help them, buying their produce might.

    How about we have a mind your own business day. Sounds good to me.

    The lack of food is more due to political factors, however when food production is short,

    going veggie or partially veggie can help feed a larger population because of that 5-10

    times factor mentioned earlier. This is, more or less, what we did in WWII.

    Adolf Hitler was a vegetarian,i say no more.

    No he wasn't. And even if he was, it would make no difference. Under Godwin's Law,

    you've just lost this argument.

    Recommend (6)

    Responses (0)

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    13/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 13 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    gatz

    14 May 2009 12:12PM

    And can I remind any "but I've been a vegan since the year dot and I'm healthy" type-responders that the plural of "ancedote" is not "data"? ...

    And besides, vegans are utterly misable as sin, all of them

    I trust you'll make the evidence for your scientific research on the effect of a vegan diet

    on mood available for review, Melkan?

    Recommend (6)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Bartel

    14 May 2009 12:15PM

    Tried camel for the first time at the weekend; bit like tough roast beef, must be all the

    sandy seasoning. Still rather chow down on a Ship of the Desert burger than a bloody

    soya fritter, mind. And how exactly is 'eggless mayo' doing its bit for the global

    economy?

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    reasoning

    14 May 2009 12:17PM

    MrLondonKiwi

    We were not designed to eat meat! Eating meat we are killing ourselves slowly....

    Just check it in some biology books and look at the comparison of the digestive systems

    of carnivores, omnivores, herbivores, and humans. Ours is closest to herbivores!

    Many of the present diseases are caused by our eating meat!

    Recommend (6)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    steve3742

    14 May 2009 12:21PM

    It is. Its a potentially-extinction-inducing threat. The human body evolved to eat

    omniverously, and needs both animal and non-animal products to survive and prosper

    (for example vitamin B12). You can get by short-term on not eating animal products but

    in the long term, reproductive fitness can only be assured by eating a mixed and

    balanced diet. This is basic scientic fact.

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    14/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 14 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Basic scientific fact my arse. Post a reference, if you can.

    B12 exists naturally in many vegetarian foods. It exists artificaially in a lot of vegan ones

    (Marmite, for example.)

    And can I remind any "but I've been a vegan since the year dot and I'm healthy" type-

    responders that the plural of "ancedote" is not "data"?

    Like to produce some data yourself, as you're so fond of scientific method?

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    nairobiny

    14 May 2009 12:22PM

    And can I remind any "but I've been a vegan since the year dot and I'm healthy" type-

    responders that the plural of "ancedote" is not "data"?

    Though your comment was the plural of bollock.

    Recommend (4)Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    ASueDenim

    14 May 2009 12:31PM

    I think this a really great idea (and I'll definitely be looking at visiting Ghent). It would

    be nice if a few towns in the UK could do something similar: e.g. one day a week

    consuming locally produced food.Oh and Melkan - you forgot to cite the name of the publication, where the research

    citing

    vegans are utterly misable as sin, all of them

    was examined and proved one way or the other.....

    Recommend (2)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Bartel

    14 May 2009 12:32PM

    And this isn't snottiness but a genuine question: presumably if we stop raising livestock

    then all those sheep and cattle will be returned to the wild to fend for themselves? No

    more wasteful expenditure of crops to feed them? Well then, why don't we start by

    getting rid of all pets? Does anyone know offhand exactly how many tonnes of grain,

    crops and meat - basic sustenance that surely could be better used feeding the world's

    hungry - the West goes through every year just keeping their dogs, cats, parrots and

    rabbits fed? How can we justify devoting so much food to animals that give nothing

    back?

    Recommend (4)

    Responses (0)

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    15/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 15 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Bartel

    14 May 2009 12:35PM

    "We were not designed to eat meat! Eating meat we are killing ourselves slowly....Just check it in some biology books and look at the comparison of the digestive systems

    of carnivores, omnivores, herbivores, and humans. Ours is closest to herbivores!

    Many of the present diseases are caused by our eating meat!"

    Twaddle. I'll back my assertion up with facts whenever you do the same.

    Recommend (0)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Thropplenoggin

    14 May 2009 12:37PM

    This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community

    standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.

    ianfischer

    14 May 2009 12:47PM

    This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community

    standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.

    HarrocknRoll

    14 May 2009 12:50PM

    Adolf Hitler was a vegetarian,i say no more.

    Reductio ad Hitlerum

    Mahatma Gandhi was also vegetarian.

    (Reductio ad Gandhium)

    Recommend (1)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    keepsmiling

    14 May 2009 12:56PM

    defendyourself

    There is an ever growing tendency to ignore the gains made in human health and

    wellbeing by the last one hundred and fifty years of technological and industrial

    development.

    There is an ever growing tendency to ignore the facts that (a) the last the last one

    hundred and fifty years of technological and industrial development are the result ofabundant fossil fuels. The scienctific and medical base we take for granted, and which,

    in addition to clean water and sanitation, are the reason why we live longer, are mainly a

  • 8/3/2019 Ghent Goes Veggie to Lose Weight and Save Planet

    16/16

    01/12/11 13.37Day of the lentil burghers: Ghent goes veggie to lose weight and save planet | Environment | The Guardian

    Pagina 16 di 16http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/may/13/ghent-belgium-vegetarian-day

    result of cheap and abundant energy, e.g. mostly oil. This age is coming to an end and

    agriculture will change with it. Agriculture is 95% fossil-fuel dependent - for fertilizers,

    pesticides, machinery and transport - if we want to eat, over the next few decades, we

    need to reduce that dependency.

    What you eat should be a matter of choice, sadly for all too many people that is not the

    case, because there isn't enough food available. Eating less meat will not help them,

    eating your veg will not help them, buying their produce might.

    Not maintaining spurious debt which transfers vast amounts of wealth from poor to richcountries might help them even more. Then they could feed themselves instead of us -

    which we'll all have to do once the cost of global transport become prohibitive. Oops, we

    only produce about 40% of our food - what shall we do?

    Oh, and we need to reduce populations everywhere and quickly. The carrying capacity of

    the earth before oil was around a quarter of what it is now - also soils were less depleted

    and less land had been built over with things you can't grow food on, like car parks and

    runways.

    Recommend (3)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    langley

    14 May 2009 1:01PM

    great, Ghent leads the way once again. In the past they have shown the way with proper

    community care for those with mental illness.

    Recommend (0)

    Responses (0)

    Report abuse

    Clip

    | Link

    Comments on this page are now closed.

    2011 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.