geog3839.23, frontiers in dendrochronology

68
FRONTIERS IN DENDROCHRONOLOGY Photograph: Nestor Jarquin

Upload: scott-st-george

Post on 10-May-2015

821 views

Category:

Education


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

F R O N T I E R S I N D E N D R O C H R O N O L O G Y

Photograph: Nestor Jarquin

Page 2: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

755 m3/s847 m3/s809 m3/s770 m3/s823 m3/s787 m3/s901 m3/s840 m3/s

Page 3: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

empirical comparisons

Page 4: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Ring-width index

Page 5: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 6: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

THED I V E R G E N C E

PROBLEM

Page 7: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

[L]inear empirical–statistical analyses alone cannot be used to prove a physical or biological mechanism for variability or change in the climate-tree growth relationship.

“”Anchukaitis et al., Geophysical Research Le!ers, 2007

Page 8: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Vaganov et al., In Dendroclimatology, 2010

Page 9: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Vaganov-Shashkin model of tree-ring formation

Gr(t) = gE(t) • min[gT(t), gW(t)]Temperaturegrowth rate

Water balancegrowth rate

Solar radiationgrowth rate

Totalgrowth rate

Page 10: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Upper Sapawe Region Northwestern Ontario

Page 11: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Tracking changes in limiting factor through the growing season

Page 12: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Tracking changes in limiting factor through the growing season

Page 13: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Tracking changes in limiting factor through the growing season

Page 14: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Tracking changes in limiting factor through the growing season

Page 15: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Conrad Bakker

Page 16: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Source: Evans et al., Journal of Geophysical Research, 2006

Observed and simulated tree ring-width in southern Russia

Page 17: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Anchukaitis et al., Geophysical Research Le!ers, 2007

Page 18: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

empirical comparisons

Page 19: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

This [modeling approach] would represent a significant step toward validating and improving statistically based but ultimately subjective data standardization techniques and identifying decadal climate variability reliably.

“”Evans et al., Journal of Geophysical Research, 2006

Page 20: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

There are relatively few long high-resolution terrestrial proxies from the tropics

Page 21: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 22: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

nispiro (Sapotaceae)Monteverde, Costa Rica

eastern white pine (Pinaceae)Deep Gap, North Carolina

Photograph: Kevin Anchukaitis

Page 23: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Abdalla Mohamed Abdi

Page 24: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

[Establish] a strategy to develop chronometric estimates in tropical trees lacking demonstrably annual ring structure, using high resolution stable isotopic measurements in tropical woods.

Evans and Schrag 2004, GCA, 68, 16

“ ”

Page 25: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 26: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

O16 O18

Page 27: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Stable isotopes of oxygen

O1699.76%

O180.2%

O170.04%

Page 28: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Source: Bowen and Wilkinson, Geology, 2002

δO18 in precipitation

Lots of O18

Li!le O18

Page 29: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Monteverde Cloud Forest, Costa Rica

Source: Kevin Anchukaitis

Page 30: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Source: Kevin Anchukaitis

Page 31: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Denise Jesudason

Cloud forest Monteverde, Costa Rica

Page 32: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

“more positive” δO18 = “heavy”

= “enriched”

“more negative” δO18 = “light”

= “depleted”

-1 ‰-5‰

Page 33: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

PINE NEEDLEleaf stomata

Page 34: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

PINE NEEDLEleaf stomata

Page 35: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

LEAF CROSS-SECTIONabundant water

Page 36: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

CO2 CO2

LEAF CROSS-SECTIONabundant water

Page 37: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

CO2 CO2

H2O H2O

LEAF CROSS-SECTIONabundant water

Page 38: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

LEAF CROSS-SECTIONwater shortage

Page 39: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

CO2CO2

CO2CO2

CO2CO2

H2OH2O

H2O H2OH2O

LEAF CROSS-SECTIONwater shortage

CO2 CO2

Page 40: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Source: Kevin Anchukaitis

Page 41: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Kevin Anchukaitis

Page 42: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

nispiro (Sapotaceae)Monteverde, Costa Rica

eastern white pine (Pinaceae)Deep Gap, North Carolina

Photograph: Kevin Anchukaitis

Page 43: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Todd Vanderlin

Page 44: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 45: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 46: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 47: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Source: Anchukaitis et al., Journal of Geophysical Research, 2008

Page 48: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Source: Anchukaitis et al., Journal of Geophysical Research, 2008

Page 49: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

3 TREES16 YEARS

1200 δ018 MEASUREMENTS

Page 50: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 51: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

FINAL EXAMMay 10 @ 4PM

105 Blegen

Page 52: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Nevada Tourism Media Relations

Page 53: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 54: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 55: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Reconstructed annual flow of the Colorado River at Lees Ferry [Meko and Woodhouse, 2010]

Page 56: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Fire-scar chronologies in the Gila WIlderness, New Mexico [Swetnam and Brown, 2010]

Page 57: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

I N T R O D U C T I O N T O D E N D R O C H R O N O L O G Y

Page 58: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 59: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

52

Page 60: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 61: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: Joe Mabel

Page 62: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Photograph: daveynin

Page 63: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Tree-ring display at elementary school

Photograph: Tom Swetnam

Page 64: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 65: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Ed Cook Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory

Page 66: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology
Page 67: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

Tree-ring analysis is one of the most powerful tools available for the study of environmental change and the identification of fundamental relationships between tree growth and climate.

Cook and Pederson, 2010

“”

Page 68: GEOG3839.23, Frontiers in dendrochronology

DENDROCHRONOLOGY IS

MUCH MORETHAN JUST

COUNTING TREE RINGS.