genomics of hairy cell leukemia and its translation into ... 20 sett/falini.pdf · hcl cb cc n m fl...
TRANSCRIPT
Genomics of hairy cell leukemia and its
translation into new diagnostic and
therapeutic opportunities
Brunangelo Falini M.D.
Institute of Hematology, University of Perugia
Perugia, Italy
Conflict of interests: nothing to disclose.
Homing of HCL cells to selected body sites
Spleen: pre-IFN era BM: “fried-egg pattern”
Red pulp involvementLiver: sinusoidal pattern
PB smear: hairy morphology
Distinct mature B-cell leukemia entity:
- Adults/older people, predominantly male (M/F ratio= 4:1)
- Indolent course. Presenting with progressive pancytopenia and
splenomegaly, usually no lymphadenopathy
- Highly responsive to purine analogs (2-CDA, Pentostatin)
Leukemic cells show:
- Distinctive features (hairy morphology)
- Unique dissemination pattern (PB , BM, spleen, liver)
- Unique immunophenotype (CD20+, CD25+, CD11c+, CD103+)
- Mutated IgV genes (~85% cases)
- Probable derivation from memory B cell
- Unknown underlying genetic lesion (difficult to study: pancytopenia,
dry tap, no splenectomy in the purine analogues era)
Hairy cell leukemia (WHO 2008)
Whole exome sequencing of one HCL patient
Purified leukemic
hairy cells
Purified normal cells
(granulocytes)
In-solution exome
capture
In-solution exome
capture
Illumina
sequencing
Illumina
sequencing
Discovery of BRAF mutation in HCL
BRAF
Serine/threonine kinase of the RAS-RAF-MEK-ERK pathway.
BRAF is activated by RAS in a GTP dependent manner.
BRAF is a major activator of MEK 1/2 that in turns activates
ERK, leads to nuclear ERK translocation and promotes
proliferation and survival
BRAF is the kinase-encoding oncogene most frequently
mutated in human cancers: ~50% melanomas
~40% papillary thryoid carcinomas
≤10% colon, prostate, lung, ovary
Rare in hematological tumors
(57% LCH, 4% multiple myeloma)
> 90% mutations are T1796A transversion (exon 15) leading to
BRAF-V600E. This phosphomimetic substitution (valine with
glutamate) leads to constitutive activation of MAPK pathway
RTK
RAS
MEK
ERK
BRAF
SurvivalProliferation
P
P
Ligand
V600E
BRAF-V600E mutation is the disease-defining genetic event in HCL:
- First activating point mutation of a kinase-encoding gene with high
recurrence in B-cell lymphomas
- Somatic and present in the entire tumor cell clone
- Present in 100% of HCL cases, encompassing the whole clinical
spectrum of the disease. Disease-defining genetic event of HCL
- Stable at relapse up to many years and following several lines of
therapy
- Absent in HCL-variant and splenic MZ lymphoma
BRAF-V600E causes continuous phosphorylation of MEK and ERK
with consequent constitutive activation of MAPK pathway
BRAF mutations in Hairy Cell Leukemia (Tiacci et al, NEJM 2001)
Diagnostic implications of genomic studies
(GEP and WES) in HCL
News specific markers
Annexin A1 IImmunohistochemistry
BRAF-V600E Molecular assays
Improved
diagnosis
HCL-specific genes
CB CC N MHCL FL BL B-CLLDLBCL MCL
Normal B cells B cell lymphomas
- ANXA1
- FLT3
- CD63
- SCNB1- SDC3
- FGF2
- CCND1
- IL3Ra
- TIMP1
- MYF6
- PLXNC1
- FGFR1
- PTPRM
- SYT1
- TIMP4
- arrestin BPreviously known
IHC performed
- EPB41L2
- CXCR5
- GAS7
(Falini B., Lancet 363:1869, 2004)
0% 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
3.1
%
1.6
%
0.8
%
0.2
%
0.1
%
0.0
5
% 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Mutant
BRAF
amplicon
Wild-type
BRAF
amplicon
Mutant
BRAF
amplicon
Wild-type
BRAF
amplicon
Mutant BRAF alleles* HCL pre-therapy
(1%-10% cells)
HCL-variant SMZL
Allele-specific PCR for the qualitative detection
of BRAF-V600E in whole-blood samples
* Serial DNA dilution of two cell lines, one homozygous for BRAF-V600E and one wild-type
HCL post-
therapy
(0.1% cells)
(Tiacci, Schiavoni et al. Blood 2012;119:192)
MATURE B-CELL NEOPLASMS
Chronic lymphocytic leukemia /Small
lymphocytic lymphoma
B-cell prolymphocytic leukaemia
Splenic marginal zone lymphoma
Hairy cell leukemia
Splenic lymphoma/leukaemia, unclassifiable
(HCL variant, splenic diffuse red pulp B-cell
lymphoma)
Lymphoplasmacytic lymphoma
Waldenström macroglobulinemia
Heavy chain diseases (alpha, gamma, mu)
Plasma cell myeloma
Solitary plasmacytoma of bone
Extraosseous plasmacytoma
Extranodal marginal zone B-cell lymphoma
of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue
(MALT lymphoma)
Nodal marginal zone B-cell lymphoma
Pediatric type nodal MZL
Follicular lymphoma
Pediatric type follicular lymphoma
Primary cutaneous follicle centre lymphoma
Mantle cell lymphoma
RAS
RTK
V600E
MEK
ERK
RAF
Survival
Proliferation
Transformation
VEMURAFENIB
DABRAFENIB
Effect of BRAF-V600E inhibitors on constitutively activated MAPK
pathway in HCL
Increased
phosphorylation
Dr. Lessia Santi - Abstract S1300: Sunday, 8.00-8.15 AM, Room Red 1+2 (NW-1)
Session: NHL & HL – Biology: Novel genetics and signaling)
Analysis of:
GEP, morphology,
apoptosis of HCL
vs HCL-like cells
N=23 HCL
N=10 HCL-like
The BRAF inhibitor Vemurafenib causes dose-dependent
MEK-ERK dephosphorylation
**
* Same results with Dabrafenib and Trametinib.
** Blot exposure in HCL-like cells: dozens of minutes (versus dozen of seconds in HCL cells).
The BRAF inhibitor Vemurafenib does not induce MEK-ERK
dephosphorylation in HCL-like neoplasms *
Vehicle Vemurafenib
48 h 72 h 48 h 72 h
*in melanoma and colon carcinoma (Pratilas et al, PNAS 2009)
Vehicle versus Vemurafenib
NES 1.83
p-value 0.002
Genes induced (n=48) by the BRAFV600E-MEK-ERKpathway in melanoma and colon carcinoma
HCL (n=6)
*
48 genesIN HCL, VEMURAFENIB SILENCES
THE BRAF-MEK-ERK PATHWAY
TRANSCRIPTIONAL OUTPUT *
Gene set enrichment
analysis
BRAF inhibition changes the GEP of hairy cell leukemia
30 genes upregulated* by
Vemurafenib:
105 genes dowregulated* by Vemurafenib:
- MAFF, ETV5, DUSP6, EGR1, SPRY2
- CCND1, Actin beta, trombospondin 1 (THBS1)
(red: known trascriptional targets of the MAPK
pathway)
* ≥ 2 fold; corrected p-value <0.05
HCL-specific genes
CB CC N MHCL FL BL B-CLLDLBCL MCL
Normal B cells B cell lymphomas
- ANXA1
- FLT3
- CD63
- SCNB1- SDC3
- FGF2
- CCND1
- AIF1
- TIMP1
- MYF6
- PLXNC1
- FGFR1
- PTPRM
- SYT1
- Beta Actin
- Arrestin B
- CXCR5
- GAS7
- Trombospondin
- SPRY2
Loss of the HCL-specific gene expression
signature* after BRAF-V600E inhibition
*Basso et al, JEM 2004
BRAF inhibition changes the GEP of hairy cell leukemia
30 genes upregulated* by
Vemurafenib:
105 genes dowregulated * by Vemurafenib:
- MAFF, ETV5, DUSP6, EGR1, SPRY2
- CCND1, Actin beta, trombospondin 1 (THBS1)
- CD25 (IL2RA), TRAP (ACP5)
* ≥ 2 fold; corrected p-value <0.05
Ctrl. Drug-1μM
Ctrl.
Ctrl.
Drug-1μM Drug-1μM
Ctrl.
Drug-1μM
Double staining: phalloidin* / ANXA5*
HCL cells HCL-like cells
Loss of hairy morphology in primary HCL cells
exposed to Vemurafenib for 48 hours
Phalloidin (green): marker for F-Actin; ANXA5 (red): marker for apoptosis
MEK and ERK
dephosphorylation
(minutes/hours)
Loss of the HCL
expression
signature and
morphology
(2-3 days)
Double staining phalloidin / ANXA5
Santini
PLX 4032 Axon
PLX 4032 Roche
1000
1000
DM
SO
90’ 6h
ERK1/2
p-ERK1/2
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
30’
1000
1000
DM
SO
90’ 6h
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
30’
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
p-MEK1/2
30’ 90’ 6h
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SOMEK1/2
30’ 90’ 6h
pERK
Santini
PLX 4032 Axon
PLX 4032 Roche
1000
1000
DM
SO
90’ 6h
ERK1/2
p-ERK1/2
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
30’
1000
1000
DM
SO
90’ 6h
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
30’
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
p-MEK1/2
30’ 90’ 6h
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
1000
1000
DM
SO
MEK1/2
30’ 90’ 6h
pMEK
0.5 hr 1.5 hr 6 hr
Drug-1μm Drug-1μm Drug-1μm
Ctrl. Drug-1μM
Apoptosis
(3-4 days)
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
1
2
Series1
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
1
2
Series1
100806040200
% live cells (ANXA5-/PI-)
Ctrl.
Drug 1μm
120
Effects of BRAF inhibition in in vitro-cultured primary HCL cells
HCL-PG01 CLINICAL TRIAL
Sponsor: Institute of Hematology, Perugia (PI: B. Falini)
Vemurafenib (Zelboraf – Roche): oral, ATP-competitive, reversible inhibitor of
the active conformation of the BRAF kinase
Results presented by Enrico Tiacci at the
Presidential Symposium, EHA meeting
(Milan, 12-15 June, 2014)
Main inclusion criteria:
1) HCL patients refractory to purine analogs
2) HCL patients relapsed after purine analogs therapy (≤ 2ys CR/PR
after the 1st cycle or ≤ 4ys CR/PR after 2nd or more cycles)
3) HCL patients with severe side effects during/after previous purine
analog therapy
Recruitment of the 28 patients was started on May 2011 and was
completed on April 2012.
HCL-PG01 CLINICAL TRIAL
(N=28 patients)
Vemurafenib
960 mg twice/day
(8 weeks)
CR
Stop therapy X 2 weeks
Stop drug
Vemurafenib
960 mg twice/day
(4 weeks)
no CRCR
no CR
Vemurafenib
960 mg twice/day
(4 weeks)
Stop drug
Stop drug
CR= According to standard criteria
(normalization PB count and
absent HCs by morphology)
Vemurafenib in HCL: conclusions
- The drug is highly active in refractory/relapsed HCL
(> 90% overall response rate). Patients are in follow-
up for duration of response.
- The drug is generally well tolerated. Side effects are
similar to those observed in melanoma trials
- The drug is not myelotoxic
- Vemurafenib-resistant HCL cells are detectable in
all cases.
BRAF inhibitors in HCL: open questions
- Which are the mechanisms underlying resistance
to Vemurafenib in HCL ?
- Therapy: which are the next steps ?
Dual targeting of MAPK: BRAF + MEK inhibitors.
Non myelotoxic therapy: BRAF inhibitors + Rituximab.
PERUGIA (COORDINATING CENTER):
B. Falini (PI)
E. Tiacci
L. De Carolis
S. Ascani
F. Falzetti
M.P. Martelli
F. Falcinelli
S. Ballanti
P. Sportoletti
OTHER CENTERS AND COLLABORATORS:
P.L. Zinzani, S.A. Pileri (Bologna)
A. Pulsoni, R. Foà (Rome)
M. Mazzucco, F. Zaia (Udine)
M. Cimminiello, M. Pizzuti (Potenza)
D. Rossi, G.L. Gaidano (Novara)
G. Motta, F. Di Raimondo (Catania)
M. Varettoni, L. Arcaini (Pavia)
A. Anastasia, G. Rossi (Brescia)
A. Ambrosetti, G. Pizzolo (Verona)
A. M. Carella (Genova)
A. Rambaldi (Bergamo)
P. Leoni (Ancona)
V. Fraticelli (Campobasso)
HCL-PG01 CLINICAL TRIAL - ACKNOWLEDGMENTS