functional model : mind the gap - prize presentation
DESCRIPTION
Dr Ankush SinghalTRANSCRIPT
Functional model: Mind the Gap
Dr Ankush Singhal MBBS, MD (AIIMS), MRCPsych
ST6 (General adult psychiatry)
BIPA Annual Conference 2010
My ContributionConceived the idea and led the study.Literature review, the protocol and ethics
approval. Collected the data. Co-ordinated.Merged the data & analysed it.Prepared the manuscript and sent for publication. Revisions as first & corresponding author.Presented in RCPsych AGM, Liverpool and in my
Trust.
BackgroundNWW: enabling consultant psychiatrists,
among others, to deliver effective and person-centred care.
Acute care pathway – CRHT + In-patient.Functional model.Acute in-patient psychiatry – a subspecialty?
Community consultant
In-patient consultant
Service user
Mind the gap
AimTo investigate
health professionals’, service users’ and carers’
opinions about the provision of separate consultants
for in-patient settings and the community
DesignMulticentre study : North Hertfordshire; the
south lakes region of Cumbria; and Winchester.
Tool semi-structured semi-qualitative questionnaire (paper and online version)
An information leaflet (without introducing any bias).
Data CollectionPersonally, by post and online.
Through CMHTs, out-patient clinics, mental health wards and other places (e.g. the local centre of MIND).
Admitted patients were not invited.
Reminder - after a month.
AnalysisQuantitative data – descriptive statistics.
Qualitative data – framework analysis.
Carers: too few to be included in the analysis.
Results
Quantitative: Service providers170/330 responded - response rate about
50%.
56 participants left after introductory questions.
72% participants having > 6 years experience in mental health.
GPs
CPNs
Psych
iatr
ists SW
staff
nur
ses
Suppo
rt w
orke
rs
Man
ager
sOT
Psych
olog
ists
Oth
ers
3734
30
23
12
7 73 2
15
Distribution of respondents
Distribution of Respondents
CMHT; 63
Primary care; 37
In-patient; 35
CRHT; 19
AOT; 10 Liaison; 2 Addiction; 2 Others; 2
Results: contd...
Yes; 134
No; 36
Awareness
Yes; 47
No; 49
Need
No; 30
Yes; 66
Would it stay?
No; 88
Yes; 8
Subspecialty?
Satisfaction of service providers
Quantitative: Service users
20/43 respondents had a history of admission.
Duration of contact with mental health: 2-10 years.
Awareness: 16/43 (36%) aware
Satisfaction of service users
Qualitative resultsNeed of functional model:
Unaware; divided opinions.to save money and/or time to reduce workload on consultantsto improve patient care.Service need, no clinical need.
Long-term future:driven by financial issues, so will stay (2/3)would be reversed (1/3)
Qualitative resultsAdvantages
1/3 : no advantages of this changeDisadvantagesIn-patient psychiatry – NOT a separate sub-
specialty.Skills Training
Qualitative data
CONTINUITY/COMMUNICATION•Both consultants attend CPA•Care-coordinators•Shared electronic records
Functional Model:
Mind the Gap
DYNAMICS•Disagreements•ResponsibilitySuggestions:•Communication•Shared decisions PATIENT CARE
•Easily available consultant.•Time/cost efficient.•↓ trust.•Problems with discharge.Suggestion: Communication
SU’s SATISFACTION•Poor engagement•Repetition•2nd opinionSuggestion: Involve SU & C in service designing.
STRESS, SKILLS & TRAINING
•Less stress, more time.•De-skilling Vs specialisation,•Poor training.Suggestion: Rotation
In their own words...Assessment tools & referral notes - not a
substitute for first hand knowledge of a patient and their circumstances.
......... a GP.
Smooth running of wards.Likely to improve in-patient and community care
individually but discontinuity will offset advantage.
.......... Mental health professionals.
The old system was on paper and we were seeing a different consultant every 3 months anyway.
.......... A service user
DiscussionAwareness.Driving force for NWW.It would continue despite a high level of
dissatisfaction.The most consistent view - continuity of care,
the therapeutic alliance, the doctor-patient relationship and trust
Ensuring continuity of care was already a challenge
Evidence basePioneering work at Guy’s hospital.East Suffolk (pilot in 2005).
A survey of psychiatrists (Dale & Milner, 2009) : Generally negative attitudes, particularly effect on patient care, the erosion of the professional role of the consultant and quality of work life.
Malik et al (2008) : the implications on training.
StrengthsExplorative studyMulticentre Both service providers (primary and
secondary care, medical and non-medical) as well as service users included
Highly relevant and Topical.Solution focussed.
LimitationsSample size and response rate.
Response bias.
Many participants did not experience this model.
Admitted service users were not included.
Future directionsTo study that ‘actual’ long term impact of
functional model on these issues.
Thanks