“from the ‘cotton to’ fields of utopia to the corridors of the university” the mound bayou...
TRANSCRIPT
““From the ‘Cotton To’ Fields of Utopia From the ‘Cotton To’ Fields of Utopia to the Corridors of the University”to the Corridors of the University”
The Mound Bayou Research Team ProjectThe Mound Bayou Research Team Project
Jackson State UniversityJackson State University
J. M. StevensonW. LeeC. Crockett
Proposed Mixed Methods Study Proposed Mixed Methods Study on Mound Bayou:on Mound Bayou:
Lessons Learned from A Lessons Learned from A Phenomenological Ecosystem Phenomenological Ecosystem
Deep in the Mississippi DeltaDeep in the Mississippi Delta
ii
Table of ContentsTable of ContentsTopic:Topic: PagePage
Executive SummaryExecutive Summary 33
Definition of Phenomenological StudyDefinition of Phenomenological Study 44
Subtext #1: Poverty to ParadiseSubtext #1: Poverty to Paradise 55
Historical OriginHistorical Origin 6-76-7
Subtext #2: People and SituationalitySubtext #2: People and Situationality 88
DemographicsDemographics 99
Phenomenological EcosystemPhenomenological Ecosystem 1010
Research PurposeResearch Purpose 1111
SignificanceSignificance 1212
Conceptual FrameworkConceptual Framework 1313
Subtext #3: Cultural Action and AnalysisSubtext #3: Cultural Action and Analysis 1414
Research Questions (General)Research Questions (General) 1515
Research Questions (Specific)Research Questions (Specific) 1616
Research MethodologyResearch Methodology 1717
iiii
Table of ContentsTable of Contents
Topic:Topic: PagePage
Research ReportResearch Report 1818
Qualitative StrategiesQualitative Strategies 1919
Qualitative Data AnalysisQualitative Data Analysis 2020
Quantitative DataQuantitative Data 2121
Quantitative Data AnalysisQuantitative Data Analysis 2222
Research Sources/ResourcesResearch Sources/Resources 23-2523-25
Benefits and Costs of the StudyBenefits and Costs of the Study 2626
Research TeamResearch Team 27-2927-29
IHEP Fact SheetIHEP Fact Sheet 3030
Principal InvestigatorPrincipal Investigator 3131
Definition of UtoptiaDefinition of Utoptia 3232
Appendix AAppendix A 33-3633-36
Appendix BAppendix B 37-3837-38
11
CorinthiansCorinthians
““A body is not a single organ, but A body is not a single organ, but many. If one organ suffers, all suffer many. If one organ suffers, all suffer together. If one flourishes, then all together. If one flourishes, then all
rejoice together.”rejoice together.”
22
The Definition of “Cotton To”:The Definition of “Cotton To”:
““Befriend, Like, Embrace, Help, Befriend, Like, Embrace, Help, Receive, Succor, Stand By, Support Receive, Succor, Stand By, Support Incline Toward, Take Up, Take Up Incline Toward, Take Up, Take Up
With, Hit It Off…”With, Hit It Off…”Doubleday RogetDoubleday Roget
33
Dear Mound Bayou School District Board Members:
RE: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF PROPOSED RESEARCH PROJECT
The attached document describes this project in research terms, but what follows is a more simplified explanation of the project. This research project is about determining whether Mound Bayou students are enrolling in college more than other school districts in Mississippi and, if so, why, how, when and where. We will do several things to conduct the study for this project, which will probably take at least one year. We would like to begin the project during summer, 2007.
•First, we will identify some presuppositions and presumptions about the Mound Bayou community.
•Second, we will consider some of the peripheral factors or external forces in and outside the local community.
•Third, we will examine the internal inputs, like tech support, operational systems, infrastructure, facilities, structural resources, environmental reinforcements, etc.
•Fourth, we will examine the interior outputs, like activities, events, programs, services, etc. “Internal inputs” are more like non-human structural-institutional resources, while “interior outputs” are more like human resource support mechanisms. Some of the interior outputs could also be external to the school district sites and based in the community.
•Fifth, we will examine the outgrowths or aftereffects that consequently result in the successful progression, persistence, and production of students graduating from high school in Mound Bayou and enrolling in institutions of higher learning around the world.
The research team will do all of the above by reviewing historical and present documents, collecting, interpreting and analyzing data (Appendix A), conducting observations, administering surveys, interviewing people, and conducting focus groups in the local community.
44
Definition of Phenomenological StudyDefinition of Phenomenological Studyfor Purposes of this Research Projectfor Purposes of this Research Project
This project will study the phenomenon of African American students’ academic success in Mound Bayou. This study will include a historical analysis of the community’s evolution, the socioeconomic conditions of the area by verifying documentation (Appendix A) and validating the perceptions of key principal stakeholders in a community called Mound Bayou. The analysis will include personal experiences of the researchers, interviewees, focus groups, surveys and other qualitative/quantitative approaches. The ultimate goal is to validate, verify and determine the “essence” of student success that manifests progression, success and persistence from the community’s school district to colleges or universities
55
SUBTEXT #1FROM POVERTY TO PARADISE
"The truth is ... the oppressed are not 'marginals', are not people living 'outside' society. They have always been 'inside' -- inside the structure which made them 'beings for others'. The solution is not to 'integrate‘ them into the structure of oppression, but to transform that structure so that they can become 'beings for themselves' "(pg 74)
From "Pedagogy of the Oppressed" by Paulo Freire (1970, 1993, 2004)
66
Historical Origin of Mound BayouHistorical Origin of Mound Bayou
Mound Bayou traces its origin to the community of Davis Bend, Mississippi, which originally started in the 1820’s as a model slave community by Joseph E. Davis. The community was influenced by the utopian ideas of Robert Owen. Davis Bend developed into an autonomous free community in the aftermath of the American Civil War. Upon its economic failure, Mound Bayou was founded in 1887 under the leadership of Isaiah Montgomery, and his leadership continued through the 1920’s.
77
Historical Origin of Mound Bayou (Continued)Historical Origin of Mound Bayou (Continued) On July 12, 1887, the city of Mound Bayou, Mississippi was founded by Isaiah T. Montgomery and his cousin, Benjamin T. Green, former slaves of Joseph Emory Davis. Mound Bayou is situated halfway between Vicksburg, Mississippi and Memphis, Tennessee off of Highway 61. Mound Bayou remains the oldest bastion of Black municipal government in the South. Montgomery and Green founded Mound Bayou to serve as a sanctuary for African-American families and culture. Throughout the years, Mound Bayou has continued its long tradition of community self-empowerment that has produced numerous African American leaders, innovators, and proud family lineages. Mound Bayou has always been a model city for the capabilities of African-Americans to rise above inequality in the South.
88
SUBTEXT #2:PEOPLE AND SITUATIONALITY
..."People as beings 'in a situation' find themselves rooted in temporal-spatial conditions which mark them and which they mark. They will tend to reflect on their own 'situational' to the extent that they are challenged by it to act upon it ..." (pg 109)
From "Pedagogy of the Oppressed" by Paulo Freire (1970, 1993, 2004)
99
Mound Bayou DemographicsMound Bayou DemographicsAs of the census of 2000, there were 2,102 people, 687 households, and 504 families residing in the city. The racial makeup of the city was 98.43% African American, 0.81% White, 0.05% Native American, 0.24% Asian, 0.05% from other races, and 0.43% from two or more races. Hispanic or Latino of any race were 0.38% of the population.
There were 687 households out of which 38.4% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 24.7% were married couples living together, 43.7% had a female householder with no husband present, and 26.5% were non-families. 24.7% of all households were made up of individuals and 9.8% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 3.06 and the average family size was 3.66.
In the city the population was spread out with 34.7% under the age of 18, 12.9% from 18 to 24, 23.5% from 25 to 44, 19.1% from 45 to 64, and 9.8% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 27 years. For every 100 females there were 78.3 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 67.6 males.
The median income for a household in the city was $17,972, and the median income for a family was $19,770. Males had a median income of $21,700 versus $18,988 for females. The per capita income for the city was $8,227. About 41.9% of families and 45.6% of the population were below the poverty line, including 58.5% of those under age 18 and 34.5% of those age 65 or over.
1010
Phenomenological EcosystemPhenomenological EcosystemEducational disparity between African Americans and Whites is a longstanding problem in the United States and has been the topic of research conferences, public policy agendas and educational initiatives for more than thirty years. The academic performance of African Americans, even in the most affluent communities, lags behind Whites. Research shows that factors of race and income are contributors to racial disparity. The gap in academic performance between African Americans and Whites has, in many ways, become an expected condition or a societal-cultural norm.
Mound Bayou is a community founded by former African American slaves in the late 1800s and has a 42% families who are below poverty. However recent community folklore suggests that this remarkable town has, and continues to have, more high school graduates go to college than any other town in Mississippi. This phenomenon of African American educational success in an under resourced community in the Mississippi Delta is the focus of this proposed research.
1111
Research PurposeResearch Purpose
The purpose of this research is to explore a reported phenomena of African Americans’ educational success in a small community in the Mississippi Delta. The ultimate goal is to verify, validate and understand the “essence” of student success that manifests in progression, success and persistence from the community’s school district to colleges or universities.
1212
Significance of the StudySignificance of the Study
The proposed study would be a major contribution to our understanding of how communities foster the academic success of African American students in the face of modest community revenue. The study will tell a different story regarding the academic success of African American students than the pervasive expectation of academic failure or under performance as compared to Whites. The study will contribute to our understanding of how political, economic, and social systems work together to affirm the educational future of African Americans.
1313
Working Conceptual Framework forWorking Conceptual Framework forMound Bayou Research ProjectMound Bayou Research Project
Optimal Resource
Maximization
Systemic Economic Conditions:
EnvironmentalConditions
HealthConditions
EducationalSystem
Emerging CommunityPractices
Systematic SocializationProcesses:
InteractionFrequencies
Support Mechanism
Tracking System
CurriculumAlignment
Innovation Methods
African American Students’ Educational Success
1414
SUBTEXT #3:CULTURAL ACTION AND SYNTHESIS
...Cultural action is always a systematic and deliberate form of action which operates upon the social structure, either with the objective of preserving that structure or of transforming it. As a form of deliberate and systematic action, all cultural action has its theory which determines its ends and thereby defines its methods". (pg 179)
From "Pedagogy of the Oppressed" by Paulo Freire (1970, 1993, 2004)
1515
General Research QuestionsGeneral Research Questions
What plausible grounded theory could be drawn? How does the community promote educational
success for African American students? How does students’ internal locus of control
contribute to their academic success? How do the social system and social networks in
Mound Bayou contribute to students academic performance?
Other research questions that emerge during the course of the research process.
1616
Specific Three-Fold Research QuestionsSpecific Three-Fold Research Questions(Inquiry, Validation & Verification)(Inquiry, Validation & Verification)
One:One: Why do more African American students graduate Why do more African American students graduate from the Mound Bayou School District and enroll in from the Mound Bayou School District and enroll in higher education than (percentage/per capita) any higher education than (percentage/per capita) any other school district in Mississippi?other school district in Mississippi?
Two:Two: If verified, why does this occur from the district; how If verified, why does this occur from the district; how does this occur from the district; when does the does this occur from the district; when does the preparatory progression and persistence toward preparatory progression and persistence toward college occur; and where do the students enroll in college occur; and where do the students enroll in higher education after they graduate from the district?higher education after they graduate from the district?
Three:Three: What type of socialization and infrastructure support What type of socialization and infrastructure support occurs in the Mound Bayou community to propel occurs in the Mound Bayou community to propel students upward toward higher education?students upward toward higher education?
1717
Research MethodologyResearch MethodologyThis proposal for funding is to support a small group of social scientists to conduct field research in a small rural town, Mound Bayou, located in the heart of the Mississippi Delta to examine what appears to be, according to locals, an educational phenomenon in the poorest State in the United States.
The proposed research will consist of a mixed methods design that draws from the qualitative and quantitative research paradigms. The research recognizes the importance of understanding the depth of the phenomena and the breath of the African American students’ academic success. The mixed methods methodology affords an opportunity for both exploration, validation and inferential analysis of data that will inform future decisions in other communities.
1818
Anticipated Content of the Anticipated Content of the Project Research ReportProject Research Report
Overview of the StudyOverview of the Study Problem Statement Problem Statement Purpose Purpose Research Questions Research Questions Significance Significance Conceptual FrameworkConceptual Framework Methodological DesignMethodological Design Results and FindingsResults and Findings Recommendations Recommendations
1919
Qualitative Data Collection StrategiesQualitative Data Collection Strategies
Interviews Interviews Parents, Grandparents, Teachers, Parents, Grandparents, Teachers, Students, Principals and AlumsStudents, Principals and Alums
Focus GroupsFocus Groups School-Based and Community-Based School-Based and Community-Based GroupsGroups
ObservationsObservations Classroom, Home-place and Classroom, Home-place and WorkplaceWorkplace
DocumentationDocumentation Archives, Curriculum, School, Archives, Curriculum, School, Policies, Procedures and ProcessesPolicies, Procedures and Processes
2020
Qualitative Data AnalysisQualitative Data Analysis
Pattern matching Pattern matching Emerging themesEmerging themesGrounded theory developmentGrounded theory development
2121
Quantitative DataQuantitative Data
Primary Data: Surveys (Alums and Graduates)Primary Data: Surveys (Alums and Graduates)
Secondary Data: Statistical Reports, Evaluation Secondary Data: Statistical Reports, Evaluation Reports, Other Data Records (school system Reports, Other Data Records (school system data, city/county data, state data, national data)data, city/county data, state data, national data)
2222
Quantitative Data AnalysisQuantitative Data Analysis
Drop-out Rates & Persistence TrendsDrop-out Rates & Persistence Trends Matriculation Rates & Persistence TrendsMatriculation Rates & Persistence Trends Curriculum Alignment & Persistence TrendsCurriculum Alignment & Persistence Trends Test Scores & Persistence TrendsTest Scores & Persistence Trends Graduation Rates & Persistence TrendsGraduation Rates & Persistence Trends College Placement Rates & Persistence College Placement Rates & Persistence
TrendsTrends
2323
Mound Bayou: A Phenomenological Ecosystem?Mound Bayou: A Phenomenological Ecosystem?Possible Research Sources & Resources of DataPossible Research Sources & Resources of Data
School-Based Principal Stakeholders (Internal)
Parents
Teachers
Principals
Counselors
Others
A
2424
Mound Bayou: A Phenomenological Ecosystem?Mound Bayou: A Phenomenological Ecosystem?Possible Research Sources & Resources of DataPossible Research Sources & Resources of Data
Community-Based Principal Stakeholders (External)
Faith Leaders
Political/Government Leaders
Business/Commerce Leaders
Alums/Graduates
B
2525
Mound Bayou: A Phenomenological Ecosystem?Mound Bayou: A Phenomenological Ecosystem?Possible Research Sources & Resources of DataPossible Research Sources & Resources of Data
Historical/Archival-Based Data
School Data
City Data
County Data
State Data
C
Federal Data
2626
Benefits and Costs of the StudyBenefits and Costs of the Study First, the continuing legacy of Mound Bayou as a model community First, the continuing legacy of Mound Bayou as a model community
for African-Americans in Mississippi and the U.S.for African-Americans in Mississippi and the U.S. Second, the maintenance, adherence and compliance of continued Second, the maintenance, adherence and compliance of continued
state and regional accreditation for the school district.state and regional accreditation for the school district. Third, the development of a prototype for continued student success Third, the development of a prototype for continued student success
for other African-American communities—hence, “it takes a whole for other African-American communities—hence, “it takes a whole village to educate a child” (Nigeria).village to educate a child” (Nigeria).
Fourth, the development of research documentation to support Fourth, the development of research documentation to support economic growth and educational advancement.economic growth and educational advancement.
Fifth, the development of an international network for a community of Fifth, the development of an international network for a community of practice.practice.
Sixth, the creation of hard data and factual documentation to support Sixth, the creation of hard data and factual documentation to support fund-raising and external support by philanthropic and corporate fund-raising and external support by philanthropic and corporate organizations.organizations.
Seventh, the identification of documentation to support data-driven Seventh, the identification of documentation to support data-driven and diagnostic decision making for continued success.and diagnostic decision making for continued success.
The research team will seek funding from governmental and corporate sources to support the funding for the study. A budget is being developed. The research team may request office space and other related support from the district as an in-kind contribution.
2828
Mound Bayou Faculty Research Team Mound Bayou Faculty Research Team
Joseph StevensonJoseph Stevenson Qualitative (QL)Qualitative (QL)
Wynetta LeeWynetta Lee Quantitative (QN)Quantitative (QN)
Matthew HoldenMatthew Holden QL and QNQL and QN
Elaine BakerElaine Baker QL and QNQL and QN
Estus SmithEstus Smith Historical Documentation (HD)Historical Documentation (HD)
Luther BrownLuther Brown HDHD
2929
Mound Bayou Project Mound Bayou Project Research AssociatesResearch Associates
Ernest BrothersErnest Brothers Greenville, MSGreenville, MS
Linda BourgeoisLinda Bourgeois Brandon, MSBrandon, MS
Kendricks HookerKendricks Hooker Clarksdale, MSClarksdale, MS
Jerald Jones-WoolfolkJerald Jones-Woolfolk Greenville, MSGreenville, MS
Tracy MimsTracy Mims Sumner, MSSumner, MS
Mary Frances MitchellMary Frances Mitchell Clarksdale, MSClarksdale, MS
Francis OffiongFrancis Offiong Memphis, TNMemphis, TN
Alfredda PayneAlfredda Payne Baltimore, MDBaltimore, MD
LaToshia StampsLaToshia Stamps Jackson, MSJackson, MS
3030
Fact Sheet from Institute of Higher Education PolicyFact Sheet from Institute of Higher Education Policy Higher Education provides economic and social benefits both to individuals and society as a Higher Education provides economic and social benefits both to individuals and society as a
whole. whole. People with more education tend to have higher salaries, higher savings, more leisure People with more education tend to have higher salaries, higher savings, more leisure
time, and better health/life expectancy.time, and better health/life expectancy. However, for a significant number of people—low-income students, students of color, first However, for a significant number of people—low-income students, students of color, first
generation college-goers—our higher education system does not work well, it at all.generation college-goers—our higher education system does not work well, it at all. In 2003, while 80 percent of high-income high school completers were enrolled in In 2003, while 80 percent of high-income high school completers were enrolled in
college by the following October, only 53 percent of low-income students were.college by the following October, only 53 percent of low-income students were. A study of 19 selective public and private colleges found that roughly 11 percent of their A study of 19 selective public and private colleges found that roughly 11 percent of their
students came from families in the lowest-income quartile, and only 6 percent were first-students came from families in the lowest-income quartile, and only 6 percent were first-generation students.generation students.
About 63 percent of all students who were first-time students at four-year institutions in About 63 percent of all students who were first-time students at four-year institutions in 1995-96 earned a bachelor’s degree within six years. But only 54 percent of students 1995-96 earned a bachelor’s degree within six years. But only 54 percent of students with family incomes in the lowest quartile had earned their degree, and 46 percent of with family incomes in the lowest quartile had earned their degree, and 46 percent of Black students.Black students.
Over the coming decade, it will become increasingly important for the higher education Over the coming decade, it will become increasingly important for the higher education system to close enrollment gaps and better educate currently underserved students.system to close enrollment gaps and better educate currently underserved students. Projections indicate that more than 40 percent of the graduating high school seniors will Projections indicate that more than 40 percent of the graduating high school seniors will
be of a racial or ethnic minority by 2014.be of a racial or ethnic minority by 2014. By 2015, 80 percent of the new undergraduate students will be African American, By 2015, 80 percent of the new undergraduate students will be African American,
Hispanic, or Asian/Pacific Islander. In all, students of color will represent 37 percent of Hispanic, or Asian/Pacific Islander. In all, students of color will represent 37 percent of all enrollments.all enrollments.
3131
About the Primary Principal Investigator
Joseph Martin Stevenson was born at Hubbard Hospital of Meharry Medical College and raised on the campus of Fisk University in Nashville, Tennessee . He has a BA and two MAs from California State University and a MS and PhD from the University of Oregon. All of his degrees are either in the field of education or social science.
An advocate of systemic pre-collegiate and post-secondary institutional synergy, Joseph has served as a school superintendent in New Jersey and as a provost/academic vice president in New York, California and Mississippi. An author of many scholarly publications and presentations, Joseph is known for his persistent encouragement for action, applied and scientific research to improve human conditions in impoverished communities. He has and continues to coordinate many field initiatives in the Mississippi Delta. One of these initiatives will result in a collaborative book with former Grambling State president, Dr. Neari Warner and his doctoral students entitled, "Planning Principles and Perspectives for Applying Knowledge Management, Aligning Stakeholders and Building Communities in the Mississippi Delta".
Joseph is a member of the Mid-South Delta Leadership group, a distinguished professor of urban higher education at Jackson State University, a senior fellow at the University of Georgia, and a lecturer at Stanford University. Joseph can be reached at: [email protected]
3232
“Utopia is what the imagination of man has to say about the possibilities of the human spirit.”
Howard ThurmanA Search for Common Ground, 1971
3434
Enrollment by GradeEnrollment by GradeP
re-K
ind
erg
arte
n
Sp
ecia
l E
du
cati
on
Pre
-K
Kin
der
gar
ten
Sp
ecia
l E
du
cati
on
Kin
terg
arte
n
Ele
men
tary
Sp
ecia
l E
du
cati
on
Gra
de
1
Gra
de
2
Gra
de
3
Gra
de
4
Gra
de
5
Gra
de
6
Gra
de
7
Gra
de
8
Gra
de
9
Gra
de
10
Gra
de
11
Gra
de
12
Sec
on
dar
y S
pec
ial
Ed
uca
tio
n
Sec
on
dar
y G
ED
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Num
ber of
Stu
dent
s E
nrol
led
Grade Level
Source: Mississippi Department of Education, Office of Research and Statistics
3535
Dropout / Graduation Data by Dropout / Graduation Data by GenderGender
3.7
27.5 26.6
96.3
50.0
61.1
0
20
40
60
80
100
Dropout Graduation
Females - N=343 Males - N=353 State - N=51,391
Source: Mississippi Department of Education, Office of Research and Statistics
3636
Dropout / Graduation DataDropout / Graduation Databy Gender & Raceby Gender & Race
3.7 0.0
27.5
0.0
26.6
96.3
0.0
50.0
0.0
61.1
0
20
40
60
80
100
Dropout Graduation
Black Females - N=343 White Females - N=0 Black Males - N=352
White Males - N=1 State - N=51,391
Source: Mississippi Department of Education, Office of Research and Statistics
"We must make ourselves whole again. We must restore and renew. We must look into the open MAAFA wounds, grieve and remember those lost to us through miseducation, collaboration, and those who resisted. As we conquer our oppression we give ourselves permission to follow the Sankofa Bird and look deep into the well of our own culture. We don't glorify the culture, we use it. We will create ourself out of ourself.“
Nana Baffour Amankwatia II (Asa Hilliard)