football fan base growth strategy by e nitiate integrated solutions
DESCRIPTION
This document contains a proposal for growing soccer club's fan baseTRANSCRIPT
1 January 2011
Digital Activations
Fan Base Growth StrategyProposal By
eNitiate © 2011
Purpose of this session
• Present fan club growth proposal• Agree on way forward
– Next steps and timelines
2
eNitiate © 2011
Contents
• Fire starter
• Background
• Proposed fan base growth strategy and implementation overview
• Way forward
– Next steps and timelines
• Why us
– Competencies and Profiles
3
eNitiate © 2011
Siwelele video
4
eNitiate Integrated Solutions & C-2 © 20105
FIRE STARTER
eNitiate © 2011
Fire starter
6
In fact, there were more Siwelele supporters in Bloemfontein Celtics’ last league encounter with Moroka Swallows @ Dobsonville stadium on the 30th of October 2010
There were more Kaizer Chiefs supporters than Supersport in the latter’s
Telkom Charity Clash with Orlando Pirates
@ Loftus Versveld Stadium
on the 5th of November 2010
eNitiate © 2011
Fire starter
There were more Kaizer Chiefs supporters than Supersport in the latter’s
Telkom Charity Clash with Orlando Pirates
@ Loftus Versveld Stadium
on the 5th of November 2010
7
eNitiate © 2011
Questions1. Which has been the best performing football club in South Africa
over the last 3 years?
–
–
2. Which club has the largest fan base?3. What is more important – 1 or 2?4. Which is the richest club?
• Brand value• Overall revenue generation
– Sponsorships– Commercialisation– Matchday gate takings
5. Is there a link between 1, 2 & 3? 8
eNitiate © 2011
When it comes to “sales” in the football business, the main
attention is created by the supporters, with regard to ticket
sales and merchandising.
– Globalisation of Sport (2005) by Dr Harald Dolles & Professor Sten Soderman
9
eNitiate Integrated Solutions & C-2 © 201010
BACKGROUND
eNitiate © 2011
Top 5 European club stats
• Top 5 richest football clubs ($bil)
1. Man U - 1.82. Real Madrid - 1.33. Arsenal – 1.24. Barcelona - 15. Bayern Munich - 0.990
11
• Top 5 best supported clubs in Europe (mil)
1. FC Barcelona – 57.82. Real Madrid – 31.33. Man U – 30.64. Chelsea – 21.45. Bayern Munich – 20.7
Source: Sport + Markt
Source: Forbes
• Top 5 highest earning football clubs ($mil)
1. Real Madrid – 650.32. FC Barcelona – 592.83. Man U – 529.74. Bayern Munich – 4695. Arsenal – 426.1
Source: Deloitte
• Top 5 world’s best selling Nike football shirts (est. mil)
1. Man U – 1.352. FC Barcelona – 1.13. Arsenal – 0.84. Juventus – 0.55. Inter Milan – 0.5
Source: PR Marketing
• Top 5 world’s best selling Adidas football shirts (est. mil)
1. Real Madrid – 1.352. Liverpool – 0.83. Chelsea – 0.84. Bayern Munich – 0.85. AC Milan – 0.5
Source: PR Marketing
• Top 5 most visited European football club sites monthly (mil)
1. Man U – 1.2 (43% local)2. Liverpool – 1.5 (53% local)3. Arsenal – 1.4 (47% local)4. Real Madrid – 1.1 (33% local)5. Barcelona – 1.0 (26% local)
Source: ComScore
eNitiate © 2011
Revenue structure of Top 5 earners
12
27%
41%
32%
Gate-Takings
Broadcasting
Commercia
l
Top 10 Overall
25%
40%
35%
Broadcasting
Commercia
l Gate-Takings
Real Madrid
39%
36%
25%
Broadcasting
Commercia
l Gate-Takings
Man U
26%
43%
31%
Broadcasting
Commercia
l Gate-Takings
Barcelona
21%
24%
55%
Broa
dcas
ting
Com
mer
cial Gate-Takings
Bayern Munich
45%
34%
21%
Broadcasting
Commercial
Gate-Takings
Arsenal
eNitiate © 2011
Key insight: driving force behind growth of European football clubs
• A paper written by Dr. Harald Dolles and Prof. Sten Soderman titled “ Globalisation of Sports - The Case for Professional Football and its International Management Challenges”; indicates that growth of leading European football clubs; e.g. Man U and Real Madrid; is driven by globalising their brands
13
eNitiate © 2011
Case studies
• Man U – Off-season games to connect with international fans in Asia . – Has the most-recognisable Asian player in the squad – Ji-Sung Park
(who is 1 of only 3 Asians playing in European soccer as at May 2010)
• Real Madrid – Transfer of Beckham to the club ensured increased penetration in
Asian market, where the player is hugely popular– Appointment of Morinho is going to also add interest to the club
due to his popular global brand
• Kaizer Chiefs– Participation in competitions such as Macufe Cup is endearing the
team to its fans
14
eNitiate © 2011
Benchmark: multimedia approach to growing fan base
15
eNitiate © 2011
Benchmark – fan base growth & revenue generation
16
Strength of the club on social networks can be measured
Demonstration of clear understanding of club’s fan base
Focus on merchandising sales for revenue generation
eNitiate © 2011
Benchmark – social responsibility
17
Active participation
by fans encouraged
eNitiate © 2011
• Why do supporters choose one team over another? Cost is certainly not the argument in the football business for fans, whereas fun, excitement, skillful players, regional embeddedness might be good reasons for supporting a team.– Globalisation of Sport (2005) by Dr Harald Dolles & Professor Sten
Soderman
18
eNitiate Integrated Solutions & C-2 © 201019
FAN BASE GROWTH STRATEGY AND IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW
eNitiate © 2011
Project Sisqo
• Unleashing…
20
eNitiate © 2011
Sisqo: Unleash The Dragon
21
eNitiate © 2011
Bloemfontein Celtics SWOT
Strengths•Strong home base that is fully behind the club•Club has a long history in top-flight soccer•Bloem Celtics received a lot of goodwill due to admirable conduct of fans
Weaknesses• Bloem Celtics is seen along ethnic lines, in the same way as Amazulu & Maritzburg United•Great site that is not consistently been updated, e.g. Skype fan chats with early 2009 dates
Opportunities•Bloem Celtics is close to Gauteng, where there are a lot of “Regional Migrants” from Free State•Club’s home base is gaining popularity from the Gauteng’s young adults who come through regularly for entertainment
Threats•Gauteng-based clubs have easy access to Free State’s soccer fan base
22
eNitiate © 2011
Brand personality: BLOEMFONTEIN CELTICS
• A football club that – Offers the alternative home– Is Steeped in tradition, but multi-cultural in outlook– Keeps a good balance between originality that is fused with
environmental awareness
• The anti-hero
23
VS
eNitiate © 2011
Regional expansion
• Choosing battles
24
eNitiate © 2011
Growth strategy overview
25
Step 1: Consolidation (1-2 yrs)
Step 2: Expansion (from year 2)
• Validation of current database record• New registrations• Entrench game attendance culture• Referral marketing
• Grow penetration into selected key Regions
Enablers:• Solid pitch performances• Meaningful social responsibility campaigns• Active fan participation• Effective communication:• Club’s health status• Changes & signings• Fan feedback
• Database management system
eNitiate © 2011
Consolidation
• “Bird in the cage is worth more than one in the bush”
– Ensures entrenchment of brand advocay
– Leverage for referral marketing
– Offers immediate revenue generation opportunities
26
eNitiate © 2011
How
• All interactive platforms must be leveraged– On-the-ground activations are key
• Community-based prospective, new and existing supporter drives
• Supporter activations at Bloem Celtics soccer games – home games vs away games
– Social responsibility campaigns must be used to tie and strengthen bonds with targeted communities
– PR must focus on developing/maintaining rapport with and leverage key media – newspapers and radio stations
– SMS Marketing must be used for disseminating and receiving information
– The Website must be integral to fan social networking
27
eNitiate © 2011
Thoughts on social responsibility
• Idea: Adopt a school
– Have local high school soccer teams competing each year, with the winning team being adopted by Celtics for a year and being exposed to coach-the-coach sessions, training facilities, etc.
• Get closer to the community
• Build affinity with the club
• Maybe identify talent for inclusion in the Bloem Celtics academy
28
eNitiate Integrated Solutions & C-2 © 201029
IMPLEMENTATION OVERVIEW
eNitiate © 2011
Implementation of the fan base growth strategy• Outsource the fan base business to a trusted entity on a 5-
year deal, to be reviewed at the end of 3rd year– Develop database model
• Invitation, registration, issuing of supporters club cards, warehousing, categorisation, anlysis and management
– Monetise the database
• Run the merchandising store
• Construct, market and sell all relevant products to club supporters
– Develop (where applicable) and maintain online communication channels
• Financial benefit to Bloemfontein Celtics– Share of 5% to Bloemfontein Celtics across revenue streams
30
eNitiate © 2011
Financial sustainability of fan base growth strategy
• Short-term
– Sale of branded merchandise
– Mobile marketing revenue generation opportunities
• Medium to Long term
– Sponsorships
– Increased gate-takings
– Selling of white labeled products
– Other database monetisation initiatives
31
eNitiate © 2011
Roll-out
• Establishment of current status – by end of December
– Assessment of fan database
• A deep-dive to get clearest picture of the state of affairs
– Analysis of associated revenue streams and potential
• Report and recommendations – by middle of January
– Findings
– Way forward
• Low-hanging fruit vs slow burns
32
eNitiate Integrated Solutions & C-2 © 201033
WHY US
eNitiate © 2011
Why us
• Excellent strategic and implementation competencies
• Technological infrastructure
– Shortcode distribution
– SMS database capturing and management facilities
• Statistical research and analysis skills
34
eNitiate © 2011
THANK YOU
35