food adulteration
TRANSCRIPT
Food adulteration is probably not a term that people are familiar with. That being said, it's
important to know where your food comes from and what sort of practices are used in
manufacturing the food that you consume. As the organically grown movement grows,
people have become more interested in growing and farming methods. Contaminated
foods and drinks are common sources of infection. Among the more common infections
that one can get from contaminated foods and drinks are typhoid fever Escherichia coli
infections, shigellosis or bacillary dysentery, giardiasis, cryptosporidiosis, other
salmonelloses, cholera, rotavirus infections, also a variety of worm infestations. Many of
the infectious diseases transmitted in food and water can also be acquired directly
through the faecal-oral route.
Food adulteration
Food Adulteration is the act of intentionally debasing the quality of food offered for sale
either by the admixture or substitution of inferior substances or by the removal of some
valuable ingredient. Food is declared adulterated if:
a substance is added which depreciates or injuriously affects it
cheaper or inferior substances are substituted wholly or in part
any valuable or necessary constituent has been wholly or in part abstracted
it is an imitation
it is colored or otherwise treated, to improve its appearance or if it contains any
added substance injurious to health
Food-preservatives have a very extensive use, which often constitutes adulteration. Salt is
the classic preservative, but is seldom classified as an adulterant. Salicylic, benzoic, and
boric acids, and their sodium salts, formaldehyde, ammonium fluoride, sulphurous acid
and its salts are among the principal preservatives.
Many of these appear to be innocuous, but there is danger that the continued use of food
preserved by these agents may be injurious. Some preservatives have been conclusively
shown to be injurious when used for long periods.
1
Coal-tar colours are employed a great deal,
pickles and canned vegetables are
sometimes coloured green with copper salts;
butter is made more yellow by anatta;
turmeric is used in mustard and some cereal
preparations. Apples are the basis for many
jellies, which are coloured so as to simulate
finer ones. In confectionery, dangerous
colours, such as chrome yellow, prussian blue, copper and arsenic compounds are
employed. Yellow and orange-coloured sweets are to be suspected. Artificial flavouring
compounds are employed in the concoction of fruit syrups, especially those used for soda
water. Milk is adulterated with water, and indirectly by removing the cream. The addition
of water may introduce disease germs. Cream is adulterated with gelatin, and
formaldehyde is employed as a preservative for it. Butter is adulterated to an enormous
extent with oleomargarine, a product of beef fat. Brick dust in chilli powder, coloured
chalk powder in turmeric, injectable dyes in
watermelon, peas, capsicum, brinjal, papaya seeds in
black pepper etc.
To avoid illness, one is advised to select foods with
care. All raw foods must be checked for
contamination particularly in areas where hygiene and
sanitation are inadequate. One is advised to avoid
salads, uncooked vegetables, and unpasteurised milk and milk products such as cheese,
and to eat only food that has been cooked and is still hot. Undercooked and raw meat,
fish, and shellfish can carry various intestinal pathogens. Cooked food that has been
allowed to stand for several hours at ambient temperature can provide a fertile medium
for bacterial growth and should be thoroughly reheated before serving. Consumption of
food and beverages obtained from street food vendors has been associated with an
increased risk of illness.
2
History
Food adulterants can be traced back as far as 1820. Frederick Accum, a German chemist,
investigated the use of adulterants when he identified metal colorings in drink and food
that turned out to be toxic. Food suppliers during this time were upset by Accum's work
and he was discredited. However, Arthur Hill Hassall, a physician, later conducted
studies, which were published and led to further legislation and the 1860 Food
Adulteration Act.
Common Food Adulterants
Mogdad coffee , whose seeds have been used as an adulterant for coffee Roasted chicory roots, whose seeds have been used similarly, starting during the
Napoleonic era in France (and continuing until today as a moderately popular additive for cheaper coffee)
Roasted ground peas, beans, or wheat, which have been used to adulterate roasted chicory
Diethylene glycol , used by some winemakers to fake sweet wines Oleomargarine or lard, added to butter Rapeseed oil , commonly added to sunflower oil and soybean oil, brassicasterol
being a marker of its presence Rye flour, corn meal or potato starch, used to dilute more expensive flours; alum
is also added to disguise usage of lower-quality flour Apple jellies, as substitutes for more expensive fruit jellies, with added colorant
and sometimes even specks of wood that simulate strawberry seeds Artificial colorants , often toxic - e.g., copper, zinc, or indigo-based green dyes
added to absinthe Sudan I yellow color, added to chili powder, as well as Sudan Red for red color Water , for diluting milk and beer and hard drinks Low quality black tea, marketed as higher quality tea Starch , added to sausages Cutting agents , often used to adulterate (or "cut") illicit drugs - for example, shoe
polish in solid cannabis Urea , melamine and other non-protein nitrogen sources, added to protein products
in order to inflate crude protein content measurements Powdered beechnut husk aromatized with cinnamic aldehyde, marketed as
powdered cinnamon. High fructose corn syrup or cane sugar, used to adulterate honey; C4 sugars serve
as markers, as detected by carbon isotopic signatures Glutinous rice coloring made of hazardous industrial dyes, as well as tinopal to
make rice noodles whiter (to serve as bleach) Noodles , meat, fish, tofu preserved with formaldehyde in tropical Asia, to prevent
spoilage from the sun
3
Examples
Some examples of adulterating food by adding
substances to them include: Selling sugar water that
has been artificially flavored and claiming that it's
apple juice; spraying water on grain that's being
stored to increase its value and weight;
contaminating milk or infant formula with
melamine. Adding "fillers" to foods instead of using pure ingredients is probably the
most common form of food adulteration.
Here are dangerous ill-effects of some common adulterants in food substances
Tea: Artificially colored saw dust or foreign leaves are mixed in tea leaves or teas dust. This leads to cancer and several health hazards.
Milk: Not only water but also starch, wheat flour, rice flour, arrow root etc are added to
milk. Also dangerous substances like Pulverized soaps, detergents, Ammonium sulphate,
Urea, boric acid are also added lead to cancers, Acute Renal failure etc.
Coffee Powder: Coffee powder is adulterated with roasted chicory. In recent days it is
found that mixture of coal, clay, indigo and lead chromate are added to coffee powder
which leads to paralysis and brain damage.
Ghee (Clarified Butter): Merchants used to adulterate Ghee by using vanaspathi
(hydrogenated vegetable fat), but these days it is adulterated in a dangerous way; that is
the bones of cows, donkeys, monkeys, horses, pigs, dogs etc were boiled in a huge pan
and the obtained fat is added to ghee and mixed with some scented substances. This leads
to chronic chest infections.
Food grains and pulses: Stones, sand and filth are mixed in food grains and pulses
which damage the digestive tract.
4
Edible oils and fats: If the edible oils or fats are adulterated with Argemone oil, it leads
to Glaucoma and sometimes cardiac arrest and the adulterant white oil and other
petroleum fractions lead to cancer. In case oils are adulterated with Rancid oils it destroys
vitamin A and E whereas if the adulterant is TCP it leads to severe paralysis.
Mustard seeds: Argemone seeds are mixed in mustard seeds and lead to epidemic
dropsy.
Turmeric powder: Turmeric powder is adulterated with lead chromate. This leads to
paralysis, anemia, brain damage and abortion.
Alcoholic liquors: These are contaminated with methanol which cause blindness and
often death.
Fruits: It is a sad thing that these immoral merchants won’t leave even the natural foods.
Fruits particularly apples and mangoes are sprayed over with lead arsenate that leads to
chills, cramps, paralysis and death.
Injurious Adulterants/Contaminants in Foods and their Health Effects
S.No Adulterant Foods Commonly
Involved
Diseases or Health
Effects
Adulterants in food
1 Argemone seeds
Argemone oil
Mustard seeds
Edible oils and fats
Epidemic dropsy,
Glaucoma,
Cardiac arrest
2 Artificially coloured foreign
seeds
As a substitute for cumin
seed,
Poppy seed, black pepper
Injurious to health
3 Foreign leaves or
exhausted tea leaves, saw
dust artificially coloured
Tea Injurious to health, cancer
5
4 TCP Oils Paralysis
5 Rancid oil Oils Destroys vitamin A and E
6 Sand, marble chips,
stones, filth
Food grains, pulses etc. Damage digestive tract
7 Lathyrus sativus Khesari dal alone or Mixed
in other pulses
Lathyrism (crippling spastic
paraplegia)
Chemical
Contamination
8 Mineral oil (white oil,
petroleum fractions)
Edible oils and fats, Black
pepper
Cancer
9 Lead chromate Turmeric whole and
powdered, mixed spices
Anemia, abortion, paralysis,
brain damage
10 Methanol Alcoholic liquors Blurred vision, blindness,
death
11Arsenic
Fruits such as apples
sprayed over with lead
arsenate
Dizziness, chills, cramps,
paralysis, death
12Barium
Foods contaminated by rat
poisons (Barium carbonate)
Violent peristalisis, arterial
hypertension, muscular
twitching, convulsions,
cardiac disturbances
13Cadmium
Fruit juices, soft drinks, etc.
in contact with cadmium
plated vessels or
equipment. Cadmium
contaminated water and
shell-fish
‘Itai-itai (ouch-ouch)
disease, Increased
salivation, acute gastritis,
liver and kidney damage,
prostrate cancer
14Cobalt
Water, liquors Cardiac insufficiency and
mycocardial failure
15Lead
Water, natural and
processed food
Lead poisoning (foot-drop,
insomnia, anemia,
constipation, mental
retardation, brain damage)
6
16Copper
Food Vomiting, diarrhoea
17Tin
Food Colic, vomiting
18Zinc
Food Colic, vomiting
19Mercury
Mercury fungicide treated
seed grains or mercury
contaminated fish
Brain damage, paralysis,
death
NOTE: Safe limits have been prescribed for above metals in different
food. Continuous use of food contaminated with these metals beyond
safe limits may cause these diseases
Bacterial
contamination
20Bacillus cereus
Cereal products, custards,
puddings, sauces
Food infection (nausea,
vomiting, abdominal pain,
diarrhoea)
21Salmonella spp.
Meat and meat products,
raw vegetables, salads,
shell-fish, eggs and egg
products, warmed-up
leftovers
Salmonellosis (food infection
usually with fever and chills)
22Shigella sonnei
Milk, potato, beans, poultry,
tuna, shrimp, moist mixed
foods
Shigellosis (bacillary
dysentery)
23Staphylococcus aureus
Entero-toxins-A,B,C,D or
E
Dairy products, baked foods
especially custard or cream-
filled foods, meat and meat
products, low-acid frozen
Increased salivation,
vomiting, abdominal cramp,
diarrhoea, severe thirst, cold
7
foods, salads, cream
sauces, etc.
sweats, prostration
24Clostridium botulinus
toxins
A,B,E or F
Defectively canned low or
medium-acid foods; meats,
sausages, smoked vacuum-
packed fish, fermented food
etc.
Botulism (double vision,
muscular paralysis, death
due to respiratory failure)
25Clostridium.perfringens
(Welchii) type A
Milk improperly processed
or canned meats, fish and
gravy stocks
Nausea, abdominal pains,
diarrhoea, gas formation
26Diethyl stilbestrol (additive
in animal feed)
Meat Sterlites, fibroid tumors etc.
273,4 Benzopyrene
Skoked food Cancer
28Excessive solvent residue
Solvent extracted oil, oil
cake etc.
Carcinogenic effect
29Non-food grade or
contaminated packing
material
Food Blood clot, angiosarcoma,
cancer etc.
30Non-permitted colour or
permitted food colour
beyond safe limit
Coloured food Mental retardation, cancer
and other toxic effect.
31BHA and BHT beyond
safe limit
Oils and fats Allergy, liver damage,
increase in serum
chloresterol etc.
32Monosodium
glutamate(flour) (beyond
safe limit)
Chinese food, meat and
meat products
Brain damage, mental
retardation in infants
33Coumarin and dihydro
coumarin
Flavoured food Blood anticoagulant
34Food flavours beyond safe
Flavoured food Chances of liver cancer
8
limit
35Brominated vegetable oils
Cold drinks Anemia, enlargement of
heart
36Sulphur dioxide and
sulphite beyond safe limit
In variety of food as
preservative
Acute irritation of the gastro-
intestinal tracts etc.
37Artificial sweetners
beyond safe limit
Sweet foods Chances of cancer
Fungal
contamination
38Aflatoxins
Aspergillus flavus-
contaminated foods such as
groundnuts, cottonseed, etc.
Liver damage and cancer
39Ergot alkaloids from
Claviceps purpurea Toxic
alkaloids, ergotamine,
ergotoxin and ergometrine
groups
Ergot-infested bajra, rye
meal or bread
Ergotism (St.Anthony’s fire-
burning sensation in
extremities, itching of skin,
peripheral gangrene)
40Toxins from
Fusarium sporotrichioides
Grains (millet, wheat, oats,
rye,etc)
Alimentary toxic
aleukia(ATA) (epidemic
panmyelotoxicosis)
41Toxins from Fusarium
sporotrichiella
Moist grains Urov disease (Kaschin-Beck
disease)
42Toxins from
Penicillium inslandicum
Penicillium atricum,
Penicillium citreovirede,
Yellow rice Toxic mouldy rice disease
9
Fusarium, Rhizopus,
Aspergillus
43Sterigmatocystin from
Aspergillus versicolour
Aspergillus nidulans and
bipolaris
Foodgrains Hepatitis
44Ascaris lumbricoides
Any raw food or water
contaminated by human
faces containing eggs of the
parasite
Ascariasis
45Entamoeba histolytica
Viral
Raw vegetables and fruits Amoebic dysentery
46Virus of infectious
Hepatitis (virus A)
Shell-fish, milk, unheated
foods contaminated with
faeces, urine and blood of
infected human
Infectious hepatitis
47Machupo virus
Foods contaminated with
rodents urine, such as
cereals
Bolivian haemorrhagic fever
Natural
Contamination
48Flouride
Drinking water, sea foods,
tea, etc.
Excess fluoride causes
fluorosis (mottling of teeth,
skeletal and neurological
disorders)
49Oxalic acid
Spinach, amaranth, etc. Renal calculi, cramps, failure
of blood to clot
10
50Gossypol
Cottonseed flour and cake Cancer
51Cyanogenetic compounds
Bitter almonds, apple seeds,
cassava, some beans etc.
Gastro-intestinal
disturbances
52Polycyclic Aromatic
Hydrocarbons(PAH)
Smoked fish, meat, mineral
oil-contaminated water, oils,
fats and fish, especially
shell-fish
Cancer
53Phalloidine (Alkaloid)
Toxic mushrooms Mushroom poisoning
(Hypoglycemia, convulsions,
profuse watery stools,
severe necrosis of liver
leading to hepatic failure and
death)
54Solanine
Potatoes Solanine poisoning
(vomiting, abdominal pain,
diarrhoea)
55Nitrates and Nitrites
Drinking water, spinach
rhubarb, asparagus, etc.
and meat products
Methaemoglobinaemia
especially in infants, cancer
and tumours in the liver,
kidney, trachea oesophagus
and lungs. The liver is the
initial site but afterwards
tumours appear in other
organs.
56Asbestos (may be
present in talc, Kaolin,
etc. and in processed
foods)
Polished rice, pulses,
processed foods containing
anti-caking agents, etc.
Absorption in particulate
form by the body may
produce cancer
57Pesticide residues
(beyond safe limit)
All types of food Acute or chronic poisoning
with damage to nerves and
vital organs like liver, kidney,
etc.
58Antibiotics (beyond safe
limit)
Meats from antibiotic-fed
animals
Multiple drug resistance
hardening of arteries, heart
disease
11
How to Prevent Food Adulteration?
Like any other crime, food adulteration would continue. However, everyone will wish
that this menace, like any other crime, be controlled significantly. Food adulteration is
common in almost all developing countries. But its ugly face is not the same everywhere.
In a developing country which is at the lowest rung of the development ladder, food
adulteration consists of relatively simple measures. The enforcers which mean the
government, municipal bodies and all others responsible directly or indirectly with the
control of food adulteration will opine that the control of this menace needs a number of
measures; only legal enforcement will not be enough. The basic requirements are
providing adequate food supply at a reasonable price, setting up of realistic food
standards which are enforceable and which can be attained by majority of the traders (not
only the big food industries but the common agricultural producers, traders and the
medium and petty food processor), the minimum basic honesty on the part of the traders
and the law enforcers, a band of committed inspectorate staff and of course, a harsh
deterrent punishment for those who commit this crime. It has been mentioned for decades
that if deterrent punishment is prescribed for food adulteration, this crime will disappear.
Food adulteration in Bangladesh
The people of Bangladesh are the victims of food adulteration. But effective measures to
check this public health related problem are not in sight. They expressed concern over
mixing toxic substances with all types of fruits in the current fruit season by the
unscrupulous traders, and asked the government to take appropriate measures to protect
public health. Food encompasses cereals, starchy tubers, meat and fish, pulses,
vegetables, fruits, eggs, milk and milk products, fats and oils, and flavourings and
stimulants. According to the Pure Food Ordinance, 1959 "food means any article used as
food or drink for human consumption, other than water or drug, and includes ice and
aerated water, and any substance which is intended for use in the composition or
preparation of food; any flavouring matter or any spice or condiment; and any colouring
matter intended for use in food." The problem of food adulteration has, however, reached
an alarming stage at marketing level. Hardly any category of food, whether cereal,
12
vegetables, fish or meat, milk or milk products, fruits, pulses, fats and oils, is available in
the markets unadulterated. The areas of concern for the public health scientists, members
of medical profession, Consumers' Association of Bangladesh (CAB), and civil society
members include: (a) using urea fertilizer and artificial colour for processing rice to make
it whiter and colourful; (b) spraying harmful and spurious chemicals on fruits for early
ripening, increasing shelf-life, and providing attractive gloss on the skin; (c) colouring
vegetables with harmful dyes for giving a look of freshness; (d) using formalin, a
chemical used by the medical students to prevent dead bodies from degrading, in fish to
make them appear fresh; (e) artificial colouring of pulses; (f) adulterating milk and milk
products including sweetmeat; and (g) adulterating aerated water. The public health
scientists and members of the medical profession have warned that if the alarming
situation of food adulteration is not checked, people's health will be at stake, and
particularly the country's future generation will suffer from many complicated diseases
and in the long run they may get intellectually disabled.
There are laws to ensure supply of safe food and foodstuff for protection and preservation
of public health. The Pure Food Ordinance, 1959, is intended to curb and remedy the evil
of food adulteration.
The Pure Food Rules, 1967, contains the details for the purpose of carrying out the
objectives of the Pure Food Ordinance, 1959.
The Cantonments Pure Food Act, 1966, and the Cantonment Pure Food Rules, 1967, aim
at preventing the adulteration of food in cantonments.
The Pesticide Ordinance, 1971, including the amendments of 1980 and 1983 and the
rules made thereunder in 1985 aim at regulating the import, manufacture, distribution,
sale and use of pesticide chemicals. Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institute (BSTI)
Ordinance, 1985, and the rules made thereunder, relate to the testing and quality control
of certain industrial and commercial products including food and drinks.
The reasons for widespread adulteration of food and foodstuff in Bangladesh may be identified as follows:
13
First, a number of organisations such as health department, food department, BSTI, city
corporations, municipalities, police department, etc. are responsible, severally and
collectively, for the enforcement of food laws. But there is a lack of effective
coordination among them. There even exists confusion among them regarding certain
action(s) to be taken to combat adulteration of food. A report published in The Daily Star
of March 13, 2004, regarding the use of formalin in fish showed that top officials of the
Ministry of Health, Dhaka City Corporation, Public Health Laboratory, and BSTI pointed
fingers at one another, no-one knowing which body should combat the practice of using
formalin in fish.
Second, food laws mentioned above have become inadequate to cope with the advanced
techniques of food adulteration. So, these laws have to be updated keeping in view the
prevailing circumstances of adulteration.
Third, as far as it is known, there is no coordinating body in the government to oversee
and monitor the enforcement of food laws by different organisations under different
ministries.
Fourth, adulteration of food affects people at all strata of the society. But political parties
in the country are not normally seen raising their voice for combating food adulteration
problem. Further, the rules of procedure (ROP) of parliament contain provision for
discussing matters of public interest in the House. But hardly any discussion on this
matter of general public interest takes place in parliament.
Fifth, the common people of the country are not conscious about the disastrous effects of
adulterated food and foodstuff on human health. The traders, both wholesalers and
retailers, face no resistance from the relevant government agencies and the people in the
operation of their unholy business.
The public health scientists, the agricultural scientists, the CAB and the civil society
leaders have come out with their views and suggestions to combat the food adulteration
problem in the country. These include:
14
*Since the continued use of chemical pesticides has been a matter of growing public
concern for their effects on human health, wildlife, and the environment, steps should be
taken to reduce chemical pesticide use in favour of integrated pest management,
biological controls, and plant breeding for inherent pest resistance.
*Chemicals sprayed on fruits and vegetables should be tested in properly equipped
laboratories to ascertain the ingredients injurious to human health. An expert committee
should closely monitor the results of these tests. Follow up action(s) should be taken on
the recommendations of the expert committee.
* Food laws have not only to be updated keeping in view the prevailing circumstances of
food adulteration, but their strict enforcement has to be ensured.
* A high-powered coordinating body in the government may be established to oversee
the enforcement of food laws and government policies in this regard.
* Political parties should raise their voice, both inside and outside the parliament for
combating the food adulteration problem.
*The CAB and the civil society leaders have been demanding enactment of an act for
protecting the rights of the consumers. It is learnt the draft law is awaiting approval of the
cabinet. Since the proposed law will have impact on the rich and the poor, the
government may solicit the opinion of the people and the media by disclosing the draft
law to the print media. This will help the cabinet in according approval in principle to the
draft law. Our lawmakers may also be benefited from the public opinion in the passage of
the law.
*Public awareness about the hazardous effects of consumption of adulterated food has to
be built. The consumers, particularly the rich consumers, should restrain themselves from
the buying spree. This will act as a silent resistance to the unscrupulous traders' business.
15
References
http://doctor.ndtv.com/storypage/ndtv/id/3731/type/feature/Food_adulteration.html
http://answers.encyclopedia.com/question/food-adulteration-87042.html
http://www.ehow.com/about_5104539_food-adulteration.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_adulteration
16
http://www.kreativegeek.com/2009_06_07_archive.html
http://nihfw.org/Publications/material/J144.pdf
http://www.newagebd.com/2005/aug/12/met.html
http://www.encyclopedia.com/topic/Genetically_engineered_foods.aspx
http://agmarknet.nic.in/adulterants.htm
http://www.thedailystar.net/2005/06/22/d50622020323.htm
17