fonterra farmgate milk price statement€¦ · milk price for the milk season that ended on 31 may...
TRANSCRIPT
Fonterra Farmgate mILK PrICe statement
Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited
31 may 2012
2 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
thIs Farmgate mILK PrICe statement:
•outlinesthewaythatFonterraCo-operativeGroupLimited(‘Fonterra’)hascalculatedtheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceforthemilkseasonthatendedon31May2012(2012Season);and
•setsoutinformationabouttheFonterraFarmgateMilkPrice.
AreportbyFonterra’sexternalauditorstoconfirmthattheFonterraFarmgateMilkPrice(FarmgateMilkPrice)forthe2012SeasonhasbeenderivedinaccordancewiththePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulesinFonterra’sFarmgateMilkPriceManualisattachedtothisStatementfollowingsection7.
ThepurposeofthisStatementistohelpfarmershareholdersandotherinterested
partiesbetterunderstandtheFarmgateMilkPrice.Thisstatementcoversthefollowing:
•Section2setsoutthefinalFarmgateMilkPriceforthe2012Season.ItalsodescribesthewaytheFarmgateMilkPricerelatestotheCo-operative’sfinancialyearended31July2012.
•Section3providesanoverviewoftheFarmgateMilkPrice.ItalsosetsouttherevenueandcostcomponentsoftheFarmgateMilkPriceforthelastthreeseasons.
•Section4describesthekeyfactorsthatinfluencerevenue.ThisisthemostsignificantfactorthataffectstheFarmgateMilkPricefromseasontoseason.
•Section5describesthecoststhatgointotheFarmgateMilkPrice.
•Section6describeshowadjustmentscanbemadetotheFarmgateMilkPriceManual,andsetsoutrecentlyapprovedadjustmentsthatwilltakeeffectfromthe2013Season.
•Section7containsaglossaryoftermsusedinthisStatement.
Therearefiveattachmentsthatprovidefurtherdetail,forthelastthreeseasons,onthemostsignificantfactorsthatimpacttheFarmgateMilkPrice.
NumbersinthisStatementhavebeenroundedand,asaresult,sometablesmaynotexactlytotalorsumto100%.
AFarmgateMilkPriceStatementwillbemadeavailableeachyearwiththeCo-operative’sannualresultsonwww.fonterra.comandFencepost.AhardcopycanberequestedbyphoningtheSupplierServicesTeamon0800656568.
IntroDUCtIon1
the Farmgate mILK PrICe For the 2012 season2
TheFarmgateMilkPriceManualsetsoutthewaytocalculatethetotalamounttobepaidbytheCo-operativeformilksuppliedtoFonterrainNewZealandinaseason.Fonterra’sMilkPricePaneladvisestheFonterraBoardonmattersconcerningtheFarmgateMilkPriceManual,includingthecalculationoftheFarmgateMilkPrice.Forthe2012Season,theFonterraBoardhasdeterminedthatthisamountisNZD9.082billion.
TheFarmgateMilkPriceisdescribedinthisStatementasthetotalamountcalculatedundertheFarmgateMilkPrice
ManualofNZD9.082billion.Forease,thistotalamountisdividedbyFonterra’stotalNewZealandmilksupply(1.493billionkgMS),toarriveatanaveragepriceofNZD6.08perkgMS.
ThetotalamountcalculatedundertheManualofNZD9.082billionisusedforpaymentsforNewZealandmilksuppliedinthe2012Season.Itincludespaymentsformilksuppliedbyfarmershareholders,milksuppliedoncontract,andaportionofthepremiumspaidforwintermilk.However,itexcludespremiumpaymentsforspecialtymilk,andtheremaining
portionofthepremiumspaidforwintermilk.1
ThecostofNewZealandsourcedmilksoldasdisclosedinFonterra’smostrecentfinancialstatementsisNZD9.033billion.TheNZD49milliondifferencebetweenthisamountandtheNZD9.082billioncalculatedundertheManualarisesbecausethefinancialstatementsreportthecostofmilkforthefinancialyearbeingthe12monthsended31July2012,whiletheFarmgateMilkPricefortheseasonisbasedonthe12monthsended31May2012.
Farmgate mILK PrICe overvIew3
3.1ratIonaLe For Farmgate mILK PrICe
TheCo-operativecurrentlycollectsaround89%ofNewZealand’smilkproduction.
BecauseFonterrapurchasessuchalargeproportionofNewZealand’stotalmilk,thereisn’ta‘marketprice’formilkthatisindependentofthepricepaidbyFonterra.Asaresult,sinceitsformationin2001,FonterrahascalculatedaFarmgateMilk
1AcommoditymanufacturerofmilkpowdersisunlikelytopaypremiumsforspecialtymilkortopaythelevelofpremiumsforwintermilkthatanintegratedprocessorsuchasFonterrawouldpay.ThesepaymentsarethereforenotfundedfromthetotalamountcalculatedundertheManualandarepaidoverandabovethistotalamount.Forthe2012Season,thisamountwasNZD22million.
Price.ThisenablestotalreturnstobeallocatedbetweenpaymentsformilkandreturnsonthesharecapitalinvestedbyfarmershareholdersintheCo-operative.
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 3
3.2Farmgate mILK PrICe methoDoLogy
Sincethefinancialyearended31July2009,theFarmgateMilkPricehasbeencalculatedinaccordancewiththeFarmgateMilkPriceManual.
TheFarmgateMilkPricedeterminestheamountpaidformilkdeliveredtothefarmgatebyfarmershareholders.ItiscalculatedinaccordancewiththeManualby:
•DeterminingtherevenuethattheCo-operativewouldearniftheequivalentofallthemilkFonterracollectswasconvertedintocommodityspecificationsofwholemilkpowder(WMP),skimmilkpowder(SMP)andtheirby-products,whicharebuttermilkpowder(BMP),butter,andanhydrousmilkfat(AMF).TheseproductsarereferredtointheManualas‘ReferenceCommodityProducts’.PricesprimarilyreflectUSdollarpricesachievedonthetwice-monthlyGlobalDairyTrade(GDT)tradingevents,convertedtoNewZealanddollarsusingFonterra’sactualaveragemonthlyforeign-exchangeconversionrate.2
•Deductingcosts,includingthecostoftransportingrawmilktofactories,andthecostofefficientlymanufacturingReferenceCommodityProductsandthentransportingthemtothepointofexportfromNewZealand,alongwithsellingandadministrationexpenses.Theyalsoincludeamounts
fordepreciationoffixedassetsandanappropriatereturnoninvestment,includinginvestmentinworkingcapital.
•Thebalancecomprisestheaggregateamountpayabletosuppliersformilk.Whilethisisanaggregateamount,itisusuallyreferredtoonthebasisofaFarmgateMilkPriceperkgMS.
3.3 ratIonaLe For reFerenCe CommoDIty ProDUCts
ManufactureoftheReferenceCommodityProductscomprisedaround75percentofFonterra’stotalNewZealandingredientsproductioninthe2012Season.
AlmostalladditionalmilkcollectedoverthelastdecadeinNewZealandbyFonterraanditscompetitorshasbeenusedtomakemilkpowders.Becausereturnsfromthesaleofmilkpowdersandtheirby-productsrepresentthe‘marginal’returnsthatwoulddrivethepriceofmilkinacompetitivemarketinNewZealand,theFarmgateMilkPriceisbasedontheseproducts.Returnsfromnon-powdercommodities,suchascheeseandcasein,havelargelybeenirrelevantindrivinginvestmentinthedairyindustryoverthelastdecadeandarethereforenottakenintoaccountindeterminingtheFarmgateMilkPrice.
TheFarmgateMilkPriceapproachdoesnotincludeanyreturnsearnedbytheCo-operativefromvalue-addproducts(suchasinfantformulaandspecialisedproteinproducts)andbrandedproducts.
Thesetypesofproductsearnpremiumsoverandabovethereturnstostandardcommodityingredients.ItisthereforeappropriatethatthesepremiumsarerecognisedinFonterra’searningsratherthanintheFarmgateMilkPrice.
3.4 DIra ‘DeFaULt’ PrICe
TheFarmgateMilkPriceisalsousedtodeterminethe‘default’pricepaidbyindependentprocessorsformilkobtainedfromFonterraunderDIRA.TheCo-operativeisrequiredunderDIRAtosupplyindependentprocessorsupto600millionlitresofrawmilkintotaleachseason(justunder5percentofthemilkcollectedbyFonterra).
TheDIRAregulatedpriceissetattheFarmgateMilkPrice,adjustedtoexcludetheportionofwintermilkpremiumspaidfromtheaggregateamountcalculatedundertheManual.IndependentProcessorstendtodemandproportionatelymoreoftheirmilkduring‘shoulder’earlyspringandautumnperiodscomparedtoFonterra’sactualseasonalpatternofmilksupplybecausetheirdemandprofiletendstobe‘flatter’thanFonterra’sactualmilkcollections.ThisimposesextracostsonFonterra,sinceiteffectivelypaysmoreformilkduringtheshoulderperiodsthanitdoesformilkcollectedduringpeakproductioninlatespring.3Fonterraisabletorecoveraportionoftheseadditionalcostsbychargingapremiumof10centsperkgMSontheadjustedFarmgateMilkPriceformilksuppliedundertheRegulations.
MILK PRICE PANEL
INTERNAL
• Responsible for forecast Farmgate Milk Price• In-depth knowledge of Farmgate Milk Price Manual• Co-ordination of Farmgate Milk Price related matters with Milk Price Group • Understand drivers of business performance against the Farmgate Milk Price• Delivery of Farmgate Milk Price inputs• Provide management input on issues / desirable amendments to the Manual
• Provide assurance over forecasting process controls and data integrity
MILK PRICE MANAGEMENTSTEERING COMMITTEE
INTERNALAUDIT
EXTERNAL
• Provide expert advice into various inputs & assurance over accuracy of financial models
• Participate in 4-yearly review
EXTERNALREVIEWERS
• Ensure the Farmgate Milk Price is calculated in accordance with the Milk Price Principles• Guardian of the Manual• Calculate actual Farmgate Milk Price • Calculate 10-year forecast Farmgate Milk Price• Provide assurance over forecast Farmgate Milk Price to Board• Provide assurance over inputs• Manage engagement with External Reviewers• The MPG Head is independent of Management and reports to Chair of Milk Price Panel• Functions of Group undertaken largely by Ernst & Young
MILK PRICEGROUP
• Ensures 10 year forecast Farmgate Milk Price used as input into valuation fully reflects Farmgate Milk Price Principles
VALUER EXTERNALAUDITOR
Provides assurance that the Farmgate Milk Price has been derived in accordance with the Principles, Methodologies and Detailed Rules of the Manual
•
FIgUre 1: Farmgate mILK PrICe governanCe
2ForWMP,SMPandAMF,whichcomprised89%ofrevenueinthe2012MilkPrice,allpricesweresourcedfromGDT.ButterisnotcurrentlysoldonGDT,andcomprises9%ofMilkPricerevenue.3HighereffectivepaymentsformilksuppliedinshoulderperiodsareaconsequenceoftheCapacityCharge,whichresultsinfarmerswithaboveaverageratiosofshouldermilktopeakmilkreceivingahigheraveragemilkprice.
4 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
3.5Farmgate mILK PrICe governanCe
TheFonterraBoardisaccountablefortheoverallsettingoftheFarmgateMilkPrice.However,asshowninFigure1onthepreviouspage,ithasputinplaceagovernancestructuretoensurerobustnessandtoprovidefarmershareholdersandotherinterestedpartieswithassurancearoundtheapplicationoftheManual.
TheMilkPricePanelplaysakeyrole.Ithasfivemembers-twoareFonterraappointeddirectors(oneofwhomistheChair),oneafarmer-electeddirectorandtwoareappropriatelyqualifiednomineesoftheFonterraShareholders’Council.ThecurrentmembersofthePanelare:JohnWaller(Chair)andDavidJacksonwhoareappointedFonterradirectors;JohnWilsonwhoisafarmer-electedFonterradirector;andRichardPunterandPaddyBoylewhoarenomineesoftheCouncil.
ThePaneloverseesthegovernanceoftheFarmgateMilkPriceandtheManual,includingchangestotheManualandverificationbyindependentexternal
expertsofkeyparameters(suchasresourceusagerates,productyieldsandfixedmanufacturingcosts).ThePanelisresponsibleforprovidingrecommendationstotheBoardonchangestotheManualandassurancetotheBoardthattheFarmgateMilkPriceeachyearhasbeencalculatedinaccordancewiththeManual.
TheMilkPriceGroupadministerstheManualdaytoday.TheheadofthisgroupisappointedbytheBoard,mustbeindependentofFonterra,andreportsdirectlytotheMilkPricePanel.ThegroupislargelyresourcedbyErnst&Young.AninternalFonterraunit,theMilkPriceManagementSteeringCommittee,co-ordinateswiththeMilkPriceGrouptoprovidemanagementinputonFarmgateMilkPricematters,whileFonterra’sInternalAuditfunctionprovidesassuranceovertheintegrityofdatasourcedfromFonterra’ssystems.TheFarmgateMilkPriceisalsoauditedeachyearbyFonterra’sexternalauditors,PwC.
3.6CommerCe CommIssIon mILK PrICe oversIght
UnderSubpart5ofDIRA,whichwaspassedintolawinJuly2012,theCommerceCommissionwillberequiredtoundertakeannualreviewsofboththeFarmgateMilkPriceManual,andthefinalFarmgateMilkPriceforaseason,commencingwiththe2012/2013Season.Priortopassageofthelegislation,theCommerceCommissionundertooka‘dryrun’reviewoftheFarmgateMilkPriceManualandoftheforecast2012FarmgateMilkPriceasat31January2012.ThepurposeofthereviewwastoassesstheextenttowhichtheCommerceCommissionconsideredtheMilkPricemethodologyandFonterra’sapplicationofthemethodologytobeconsistentwiththepurposeandprinciplesoftheMilkPriceregimenowcontainedinSubpart5ofDIRA.Asaconsequenceofthereview,twominoramendmentshavebeenmadetotheManual,andtwoadjustmentswillbemadetoinputsintotheFarmgateMilkPriceforthe2013Season.Thesechangesareoutlinedinsection6.
TheCommission’sfinalreportwasreleasedon27August2012,andisavailableathttp://www.comcom.govt.nz/review-of-fonterra-s-farm-gate-milk-price/.
tabLe 1: Farmgate mILK PrICe sUmmary
SeaSon 2012 2011 2010 2012/2011 2011/2010
NZD bN $/kgMS NZD bN $/kgMS NZD bN $/kgMS % ChaNge $/kgMS
% ChaNge $/kgMS
FARMGATEMILkPRICEREvENUE
12.4 8.29 13.1 9.76 10.5 8.17 (15.1) 19.5
LACToSE (0.6) (0.42) (0.3) (0.25) (0.3) (0.22) 68.0 13.6
net revenue 11.7 7.86 12.8 9.51 10.2 7.95 (17.4) 19.6
FARMGATEMILkPRICECASHCoSTS
(1.6) (1.10) (1.5) (1.13) (1.4) (1.08) (2.7) 4.6
FARMGATEMILkPRICECAPITALCoSTS*
(1.0) (0.68) (1.1) (0.78) (1.0) (0.77) (12.8) 1.3
totaL CoStS (2.7) (1.78) (2.6) (1.91) (2.4) (1.85) (6.8) 3.2
FarmGate miLk priCe 9.1 6.08 10.2 7.60 7.8 6.10 (20.0) 24.6
MILkCoLLECTIoNS(MILLIoNkgMS)
1,493 1,346 1,286 10.9 4.7
*Includesdepreciation,taxandcapitalcharge
Farmgate mILK PrICe overvIew ContInUeD
3
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 5
3.7sUmmary oF Farmgate mILK PrICe revenUe anD Cost
Table1summarisestheFarmgateMilkPriceforthemilksuppliedinthe2010,2011and2012Seasons.Table1onthepreviouspageandFigure2aboveshowthatchangesintheFarmgateMilkPriceoverthelastthreeseasonshavebeen
drivenalmostentirelybychangesincommoditypricesconvertedintoNewZealanddollars.keydeterminantsofthemovementsinaveragecostsbetweenthe2011andthe2012Seasonsareexplainedinsection5.
NET
REV
ENU
E
MIL
K PR
ICE
CA
SH C
OST
S
MIL
K PR
ICE
CA
PITA
L C
OST
S
MIL
K PR
ICE
MIL
K PR
ICE
CA
SH C
OST
S
MIL
K PR
ICE
CA
PITA
L C
OST
S
MIL
K PR
ICE
MIL
K PR
ICE
CA
SH C
OST
S
MIL
K PR
ICE
CA
PITA
L C
OST
S
MIL
K PR
ICE
NET
REV
ENU
E
NET
REV
ENU
E
7.95 (1.08)
(0.77)
6.10
9.51 (1.13)
(0.78)
7.60 7.86 (1.10)
(0.68)
6.08
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
9.00
10.00
NZD
/ k
gMS
2010 SEASON 2011 SEASON 2012 SEASON
FIgUre 2: Changes In the Farmgate mILK PrICe: seasons 2010-2012
4.1 sUPPLy, ProDUCtIon, saLes voLUmes
FarmgateMilkPriceRevenuereflectsacombinationofmilksuppliedduringtheseason,productmix,salesvolumesandpricesinNewZealanddollars.FarmgateMilkPriceRevenueisthemostsignificantdriveroftheFarmgateMilkPrice.
Figure3onthefollowingpageshowstherelationshipbetweenwhenmilkiscollectedduringaseason(thelightblueline),thevolumeofproductsmanufacturedfromthatmilk(thedarkblueline)andwhenthatproductis
shipped(thelightgreenline).Thekeypointstonoteareasfollows:
•Milksuppliedduringthe2012Seasonwas1.493billionkgMS.Attachment1providesinformationonmilkcollectedeachquarterforeachofthelastthreeseasons.
•ThisamountofmilkisthenconvertedintoReferenceCommodityProducts.ThemixbetweenthevariousproductsthatgoesintotheFarmgateMilkPricewasupdatedonaforward-lookingbasisduringtheSeasontoreflectFonterra’sprojectedmixbetweenWMPandSMP,andbetweenbutter
andAMF.(ProductionofBMPisaresidualamount.)Attachment1providesFarmgateMilkPriceproductionbyquarterforeachReferenceCommodityProductforthelastthreeseasons.
•ProductsalesreflectFonterra’sactualshipmentsofReferenceCommodityProductsmanufacturedfrommilksuppliedduringtheseason.Figure3showsthenormallagbetweenproductionandshipment,aswellasthefactthatminimalmilkissuppliedinJuneandJuly.Thesefactorsmeanthatshipmentsofproductsmanufacturedfrommilkcollectedinaseason(beginning1June)donotnormally
farMgate Milk priCe reveNue
4
6 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
commenceuntilAugustattheearliest.Shipmentsarenormallycompletebytheendofoctoberinthefollowingyear,againasillustratedinFigure3.Attachment2setsoutsalesvolumesbyquarterforeachofthelastthreeseasons.
Revenuesarerecognisedwhensalesareinvoiced,atthetimeofshipment.SalespricesincludedintheFarmgateMilkPricearealwayssetpriortothemonthofshipment(primarilyviaGDTevents).Figure4belowshowstheaveragelagbetweenwhenpricesarestruckand
whenproductisshipped.ThismatchesFonterra’sactualaveragelagforproductthatissoldontermsthataretypicalforthesaleofcommodityproductsfromNewZealand.Toensurethisisthecase,contractswithmorethaneightmonthsbetweenwhenapriceissetandshipment
FIgUre 3: tImIng oF sUPPLy, ProDUCtIon & saLes voLUmes
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
MET
RIC
TO
NN
ES '0
00
s
kgM
S M
ILLI
ON
S
MILK SOLIDS (kgMS) PRODUCTION (MT) SALES VOLUME (MT)
OCT 12SEP 12AUG 12JUL 12JUN 12NOV 11 DEC 11 JAN 12OCT 11SEP 11AUG 11JUL 11JUN 11 MAY 12APR 12MAR 12FEB 12
FIgUre 4: Lag between when PrICes are strUCK anD shIPments
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
MET
RIC
TO
NN
ES '0
00
s
CUMULATIVE CONTRACTED CUMULATIVE SHIPMENTS
OCT 12SEP 12AUG 12JUL 12JUN 12OCT 11 NOV 11 DEC 11SEP 11AUG 11JUL 11JUN 11 MAY 12APR 12MAR 12FEB 12JAN 12
farMgate Milk priCe reveNue CoNtiNueD
4
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 7
occursarenottakenintoaccountindeterminingshipmentprices.4
Attachment3setsouttheaveragenumberofmonthspriortoshipmentthatpriceswereestablishedforeachquarteroverthelastthreeseasons.Attachment3alsosetsouttheaveragepercentagesofsalescontractedineachmonthpriortoshipmentinthelastthreeseasons.
4.2 PrICes
Forthe2012Season,GDTwasthesolesourceofpricesforWMP,SMPandAMF,andwastheprimaryreferencepointfor
BMP.Non-GDTcontractsthatFonterraenteredintowereusedtoestablishpricesforallbuttershipments(asbutterisnotcurrentlysoldthroughGDT),andsomeshipmentsofBMP.
DetailedRulesintheManualdictatewhichcontractscanbetakenintoaccount.Contractsthatareexcluded,forexample,includesalestoFonterrasubsidiaries.
Attachment1highlightsthatWMP,SMPandAMF(2,517,000MT)accountedfor89%oftheFarmgateMilkPriceproductionofReferenceCommodityProducts(2,819,000MT)inthe2012Season.
Theaverageshipmentpricesincorporateprovisionsforthelowerpricesreceived
for‘downgradeproduct’.Theseareproductsthatdonotmeetmanufacturingspecifications,someofwhichmayonlybesuitableforuseasstockfeed.
Table2belowshowstheweightedaverageUSDcontractpricesofReferenceCommodityProductsforthelastthreeseasons.Table2showsthatpricesformilkpowdersdecreasedslightlybetweenthe2011Seasonandthe2012Season(5.4%onaweightedaveragebasis),butthatthedecreaseinpricesforcreamproducts(butterandAMF)wassignificantlyhigher(22.2%onaweightedaveragebasis).AverageUSDpricesperMTforeachReferenceCommodityProductbyquarterforeachofthelastthreeseasonsaresetoutinAttachment4.
tabLe 2: weIghteD average UsD PrICe 2010-2012 seasonsWeighted average price (uSd) per mt
SeaSon 2012 2011 2010 2012/2011 2011/2010
% ChaNge % ChaNge
WMP 3,359 3,606 2,905 (6.8) 24.1
SMP 3,285 3,321 2,658 (1.1) 24.9
BUTTER 3,546 4,344 3,033 (18.4) 43.2
AMF 3,825 5,258 3,368 (27.3) 56.1
BMP 3,163 3,259 2,234 (2.9) 45.9
TheManualprovidesfortheconversionofnotionalUSDMilkPricereceiptsforeachmonthtoNZDattheaveragerateatwhichFonterraactuallyconvertsitsUSD-equivalentforeigncurrencyreceiptsforthemonth,takingintoaccountthecostsandbenefitsofFonterra’shedgingactivities.Fonterra’spolicyistohedge100%ofthenetrecognisedforeigncurrencytradereceivablesandpayables.Italsorequireshedgingofupto100%offorecastcashreceiptsfromsalesforaperiodofupto18monthswithinlimits
approvedbyFonterra’sBoard.Fonterrausesbothforwardforeignexchangecontractsandcurrencyoptionstohedgeitsforeignexchangerisk.
Figure5onthenextpageshowstheaverageforeignexchangeconversionrate(USD:NZD)fortheFarmgateMilkPricerevenueforeachquarterinthe2012SeasonbasedonFonterra’sactualhedgingcontractsinplacecomparedtotheweightedaveragespotratethatprevailedinthequarter.Figure5,inconjunctionwithAttachment5,showsthatthe
Co-operative’shedgingpolicyresultedinanaverageforeignexchangeconversionrateforthe2012SeasonofUSD:NZDexchangerate0.7706againstaspotrateof0.7965.Attachment5alsoprovidesequivalentinformationbyquarterforthe2010and2011Seasons.Althoughthedataoverthelast3yearsshowsFonterraachievingabetterratethroughitshedging,theoppositesituationcanalsooccur.Thiswasthecaseinthe2009Season,thedataforwhichwaspublishedinthe2011FarmgateMilkPriceStatement.
4Fromthefinancialyearending31July2013,onlycontractswithpricessetnoearlierthan5monthspriortoshipmentwillbetakenintoaccount.
8 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
0.6800
0.7200
0.7600
0.8000
0.8400
AUG 11 TO OCT 11 NOV 11 TO JAN 12 FEB 12 TO APR 12 MAY 12 TO JUL 12 AUG 12 TO OCT 12
FONTERRA'S AVERAGE CONVERSION RATESPOT EXCHANGE RATE
FIgUre 5: average UsD:nZD ConversIon anD sPot rates by QUarter
Asat31July2012,Fonterrahadforeignexchangecontractsinplaceinrespectofapproximately60%oftheUSD-equivalentoperatingcashflowexposureexpectedtoimpactontheMilkPriceforthe2013Season.Ataspotexchangerateof0.8089,thesecontractswouldresultinanaverageUSD:NZDconversionrateof78.0cents.5
4.3LaCtose
LactoseisusedasaningredientinthemanufactureofWMP,SMPandBMPtoachieveastandardproteincompositionalignedtointernationallyrecognisedspecifications.MostofthelactosecontentofmilkpowdersisobtainedfrommilksuppliedtoFonterra.However,a
portionispurchasedatinternationalprices.Becausethecostofpurchasedlactosedependsonglobalpricesandtheexchangerate,itispresentedinTable1asadeductionfromFarmgateMilkPriceRevenue.
Table3belowprovidesthebasisforthecostofpurchasedlactoseinthe2012,2011and2010Seasons.
SeaSon 2012 2011 2010 2012/2011 2011/2010
% ChaNge % ChaNge
PURCHASEDLACToSE(’000METRICToNNES)
310 275 260 12.7 5.8
AvERAGEPRICE(USD)PERMT 1558 848 717 83.7 18.3
5Asnotedabove,Fonterrausescurrencyoptionsaswellasforwardexchangecontractstohedgeitsforeigncurrencyreceipts.Useofoptionsmeanstheaveragehedgedconversionratemayvarywiththespotexchangerate
tabLe 3: PUrChaseD LaCtose & PrICe
farMgate Milk priCe reveNue CoNtiNueD
4
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 9
5.1Farmgate mILK PrICe Cash Costs
FarmgateMilkPriceCashCostsreflect:
•Fonterra’sactualsupplychainandcollectioncosts.
•CostsassociatedwithFonterra’sactualsitefootprint,whichincludesmorethan20manufacturingsites(someofwhichcontainmultipleplants)with
associatedoverheadcosts.ThecostsofoperatingtheseplantsarebasedondailyprocessingcapacitiesthatmatchFonterra’saverages,andwithoperatingparametersthatreflectmanufacturers’specificationsandFonterra’sperunitcosts.
•overheadandsellingcoststhataretypicalofacommodity-onlybusinessthatsellsproductfromNewZealand.overheadcostsarecalculatedby
referencetoFonterra’sactualcosts,butexcludecoststhatareattributabletothemuchbroaderscopeofFonterra’sbusiness.SellingcostsreflectthesaleofproductsthroughanequivalentplatformtoGDTwithanoffshoresupportingnetwork.
Table4andFigure6summarisethemajorcategoriesofcashcosts,andthesourcesofmovementsineachcategorybetweenthe2011and2012Seasons.
farMgate Milk priCe CoStS
5
tabLe 4: sUmmary oF movements In Cash Costs
nZd miLLion F11
voLume/ produCt mix
eFFeCtCoSt
movementSStruCturaL
ChanGeSone-oFF
CharGeS F12
% ChanGe due to
CoSttotaL % ChanGe
SALESCoST 145 7 – (35) 117 0.0 (19.3)
vARIABLEMANUFACTURING&SUPPLYCHAINCoSTS
618 66 20 – 704 2.9 13.9
FIxEDMANUFACTURING/SITEovERHEADS&SUPPLYCHAINCoSTS
191 – 6 – 197 3.3 3.3
oTHERCoSTSINCLUDINGCoLLECTIoN
563 20 21 22 (4) 622 3.7 10.5
totaL CaSh CoStS 1,517 94 47 (13) (4) 1,640 2.9 8.1
F11 ADJUSTEDF11 FINAL VOLUME COSTMOVEMENTS
ONE OFFCHARGES
F12 FINALSTRUCTURALCHANGES
$1.13$0.03 ($0.01) $0.00 $1.10
$1.08
($0.05)
$0.70
$0.90
$1.10
10 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
Themovementsincostsshownonthepreviouspagereflectthefollowing:
•Thevolume-relatedimpactonfixedcostrecoveriesofthe10%increaseinmilksupplyoverthe2011Season.(Averagecostsinthe2011Seasonwouldhavebeen5clower,at$1.08perkgMS,ifthehigher2012volumeofmilkhadbeensupplied.)
•Anaverageincreaseof3.1%duetocostinflation.
•Achangeintheapproachtocalculatingsalescostsforthe2012Season.Previously,salescostswerecalculatedonabasisthatassumedtheNotionalMilkPriceBusinesspaidacommissiontoathirdpartysalesagent,andthattheagent’scostsreflectedFonterra’scoststructureplusaprofitmargin.ThisapproachwasbecomingincreasinglyinconsistentwiththeincreasingrelianceplacedonpricesachievedonGDT,andwasthereforeadjustedatthebeginningofthe2012SeasontobeconsistentwithanassumptionthatmostMilkPriceproductissoldonGDT.TherevisedapproachreflectsanassumptionthattheNotionalMilkPriceBusinesssells90%ofitsproductonGDT,atthecommissionrateschargedbyGDTtothirdpartysellers,andthatitalsomaintainsanin-marketstructuretoserviceitscustomers.
•Thereclassificationasfarmtofactorymilkcollectioncostsofcertaincostspreviouslyclassifiedasinter-sitediversioncosts.
•AnetdecreaseofNZD4millionin‘one-off’costsin2012relativetothe2011Season.one-offcostsinrespectoftheChristchurchearthquakewereincorporatedin2011.In2012aprovisionwasincludedforone-offcoststhatcouldreasonablybeexpectedtohavebeenincurredasaconsequenceofhigher-than-forecastpeakmilksupplyandthefailureinoctober2011oftheMauigaspipeline.
5.2Farmgate mILK PrICe CaPItaL Costs
TheCo-operativeoperatesarangeof
powderplantswithcapacitiesfrommorethan25tonnesperhourtoapproximatelyonetonneperhour.Notwooftheseplantsareexactlyalike.Somemakeonlyafewproducts,whileothersareusedtomanufacturearangeofproducts,includinghigher-valueproducts.
Itwouldbeamajorexercisetoadjustthecostsactuallyincurredinalltheseplantstoexcludethecostsrelatingtotheproductionofhighervalueproducts.Also,thecapitalcostsassociatedwithsomeofFonterra’ssmallerandolderplantsarenotrepresentativeofthefullcostsofusingmodernplantstomanufacturecommoditymilkpowders.
Toaddresstheseissues,bothoperatingandplant-relatedcapitalcostsarecalculatedbyreferenceto‘standard’plantswithcapacitiesequaltoFonterra’sactualaveragedailycapacitiesforeachtypeofplant,andwhichreflectcurrenttechnologyofthetypetypicallyemployedacrosstheindustry.6These‘standard’plantsarelessefficientthanFonterra’snewestmanufacturingplants,suchastheED4drierinstalledatFonterra’sEdendalemanufacturingsiteinSouthlandin2009,andthenewly-commissionedplantatDarfieldinCanterbury,butaremoreefficientthanFonterra’solder,smallerplants.
Thebasisforderivingthebenchmarkdepreciation,taxcostsandcapitalchargeissetoutindetailintheManual.Inbroadterms:
•Thecapitalchargeonfixedassetsisdesignedtorecoverthefullcost(throughadepreciationcharge)ofthemanufacturingandotherassetsrequiredtomanufactureReferenceCommodityProductsovertheassets’economiclives,andtogenerateareturnatthebenchmarkWeightedAverageCostofCapital(WACC,seebelow)ontheundepreciatedbalanceeachyear.
•Thecapitalchargeisalsocalculatedinamannerthatresultsinitsaggregateamountgrowingeachyearapproximatelyinlinewithmilksupplyandcapitalgoodsinflation,solongastheWACCdoesnotchange.Thismeansthatchangesintheaverageageoftheassetbasedonotresultinmaterialyearonyearmovementsinthecapitalcharge,
andthereforeintheFarmgateMilkPrice.
•TheFarmgateMilkPricecostbasealsoincludesaprovisionforacapitalchargeonthemonthlynetworkingcapitalbalancesimpliedbythesaleandmanufactureoftheReferenceCommodityProducts,andbythephasingofFonterra’spaymentsformilktoitssuppliers.Eachoftheseitemsvariessomewhatbetweenyears,resultinginsomeannualvariationinthiselementofthecapitalcharge.However,thisvariationdidnotexceed2centsperkgMSbetweenthe2010and2012Seasons.
•TheWACCusedtodeterminethecapitalchargeisspecifiedonanafter-taxbasis,sotheFarmgateMilkPricecostbaseincludesaseparateprovisionforcorporatetax.ThisamountisarelativelyconstantproportioneachyearoftheWACCchargesonfixedassetsandnetworkingcapital.
Table5rightshowscapitalcostsandtheaggregatebookvalueoftheFarmgateMilkPricefixedassetbaseandmonthlyaveragenetworkingcapitalforthe2010,2011and2012Seasons.TheprimarydeterminantofthevariationinaveragenetworkingcapitalbalancesbetweenyearsisdifferencesinthepercentagesofthefinalFarmgateMilkPricepaidtosuppliersineachmonthduringtheyear.
Threemattersarerelevanttoacomparisonofcapitalcostsbetween2012and2011:
•Theimprovementinassetutilisationresultingfromthesignificantincreaseinmilksupplyinthe2012SeasonbyitselfresultedinareductionincapitalcostswhenexpressedonadollarsperkgMSbasis.
•Asexplainedbelow,theWACCreducedfrom8.5%in2011to7.7%in2012.Byitself,thischangeresultedinareductionofNZD48millionintheWACCchargeonfixedassets,areductionofNZD15millionintheWACCchargeonnetworkingcapital,andareductionofNZD6millioninthetaxcharge.
•Thecompanytaxratereducedfrom30%to28%,resultinginafurtherreductionofNZD20millioninthetaxcharge.
6TheaveragedailyprocessingcapacityofthestandardWMPandSMPplantsisapproximately1.9millionlitres.Asaconsequenceofthereviewyearupdates(seesection6),incrementalandreplacementplantsincorporatedintheassetbasefromthe2013SeasonwillhaveanaveragedailyprocessingcapacityofapproximatelyNZD2.4millionlitres.
farMgate Milk priCe CoStS CoNtiNueD
5
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 11
tabLe 5: aGGreGate book vaLue oF Fixed aSSet baSe and monthLy averaGe net WorkinG CapitaL
Inaggregatetheimprovementinassetutilisationresultedinareductionof4centsperkgMSinaveragecapitalcosts,andthechangeinWACCandtaxrateresultedinafurtherreductionof6centsperkgMS.
5.3CaLCULatIon oF benChmarK weIghteD average Cost oF CaPItaL (waCC)
TheWACCusedtodeterminetheFixedAssetCapitalChargesandtheNet
WorkingCapitalChargeiscalculatedusingthe‘simplifiedBrennanLally’methodologyemployedbytheCommerceCommission.7Themethodologyappliedthroughtothe2012SeasonprovidedforinputparametersintotheWACCtobeupdatedeveryfouryears.Consequently,theWACCwasheldconstantat8.5%betweenthe2009and2011Seasons,andreflectedmarketinterestratesasofmid2008.Fromthe2012Season,themethodologyhasbeenrevisedtobebasedonrollingfiveyearaveragesofmarketinterestrates,includingthefiveyearNewZealandgovernmentstockrate,resultinginareductionintheWACCto
7.7%.ThepurposeofthischangewastoavoidpotentiallysignificantstepchangeseachfouryearsintheFarmgateMilkPricecapitalcharge(whichcouldbeeitherpositiveornegative,dependingonmarketconditions).
Applicationofthesameapproachemployedinthe2012SeasonwouldhaveresultedinaWACCof7.3%beingusedforthe2013Season.Asaconsequence,however,ofaddressingmattersraisedbytheCommerceCommissioninits‘dryrun’reviewrelatingtothecalculationoftheassumedcostofdebt,aWACCof7.5%willbeusedforthe2013Season.
farMgate Milk priCe MaNual6
SincetheManualwasintroducedinthe2009Season,variousminorrefinementshavebeenmadeaspracticalissueswereidentifiedandaddressed.SuchrefinementsweretobeexpectedgiventheimportancetoFonterraofensuringtheFarmgateMilkPriceapproachisrobust.AnyrefinementtotheManualisrequiredtobeconsistentwiththePrincipleswhicharesetoutintheFonterraConstitution.
TheManualallowsforadjustmentstobemadewherecircumstanceschange.AnexampleofthisistheDetailedRulethatallowsfortheadditionofnewReferenceCommodityProductsifcertainconditionsestablishedintheManualaremet.TheManualalsoprovidesfor
reviewsofcertainaspectsoftheManualtobecarriedoutatleastonceeveryfouryears.ThesereviewscanresultinchangestotheapplicationofrulesintheManualorinputsintotheFarmgateMilkPrice.Thefirstofthesefour-yearlyreviewshasrecentlybeencompleted.Thereviewhasresultedinanumberofminoramendments,noneofwhich,eitheronitsownorinaggregate,willhaveamaterialimpactontheFarmgateMilkPriceforthe2013Season.
AmaterialimpactontheFarmgateMilkPriceisconsideredtobe2.4centsperkgMS(inaggregateorforanyindividualchange).
TheBoardapprovedanumberofminor
amendmentstotheManualinJuly2012,andanupdatedversionoftheManualisnowavailableonFonterra.com.Twoamendments–theincorporationinPartCofaprovisiontoallowforadditionalcostsincalculatingthecostofdebt,andanamendmenttoclarifythat‘salesphasings’cannotbeadjustedretrospectively–addressmattersraisedbytheCommerceCommissioninits‘dryrun’reviewoftheFarmgateMilkPrice.TheadjustmenttothecostofdebtisreflectedintheWACCforthe2013Seasonof7.5%,asreportedabove,andwillresultinareductionintheFarmgateMilkPriceof1centperkgMSinthe2013Season.NoneoftheotheramendmentswillresultinasubstantivechangeintheFarmgateMilkPrice.
7Seeforexamplethevariouspapersathttp://www.comcom.govt.nz/cost-of-capital/
SeaSon nZd miLLion 2012 2011 2010
DEPRECIATIoN 218 203 200
WACCCHARGE-FIxEDASSETS 469 498 455
WACCCHARGE-NETWoRkINGCAPITAL 138 130 132
TAx 193 225 209
ToTALFIxEDASSETS(BookvALUE) 6,121 5,915 5,357
AvERAGENETWoRkINGCAPITAL 2,244 1,570 1,301
12 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
InthisStatement,unlessthecontextotherwiserequires,thetermssetoutbelowhavethemeaningssetoutnexttothem:
amFmeansanhydrousmilkfat.
bmpmeansbuttermilkpowder.
detailed rulesmeansthedetailedrulesforcalculatingtheFarmgateMilkPriceassetoutintheManual.
dirameanstheDairyIndustryRestructuringAct2001,whichauthorisedFonterra’sformationandregulatesitsactivities.
Farmgate milk pricemeansFonterra’sFarmgateMilkPriceasdeterminedundertheManual.
Farmgate milk price Capital CostsaredefinedintheManual.
Farmgate milk price Cash CostsaredefinedintheManual.
Farmgate milk price manualormanualmeansFonterra’sFarmgateMilkPriceManualdated21September2011.
Fonterraorthe Co-operativemeansFonterraCo-operativeGroupLimited.
Financial yearmeansFonterra’sfinancialyearwhichrunsfrom1Augusttothefollowing31July.
GlobaldairytradeorGdtmeanstheelectronicauctionplatformthatisusedtosellcommoditydairyproducts.
independent processorsmeansentitieswhoareindependentofFonterraandprocessrawmilk.
kgmSmeanskilogramsofmilksolids.
manualmeansFonterra’sFarmgateMilkPriceManual.
methodologiesmeansthemethodologiesforcalculatingtheFarmgateMilkPriceassetoutintheManual.
milk price principlesorprinciplesmeanstheMilkPricePrinciplessetoutinFonterra’sConstitution.
mtmeansmetrictonnes.
nZdmeansNewZealanddollars.
Seasonmeansthe12-monthperiodfrom1Junetothefollowing31May.
Smpmeansskimmilkpowder.
Specialty milkmeansmilkthathasspecialpropertiessuchasorganicmilk.
reference Commodity productsaredefinedintheManual.
uSdmeansUnitedStatesdollars.
WaCCmeansweightedaveragecostofcapital.
Winter milkmeansmilksuppliedbyfarmersinthemonthsofMay,JuneandJuly.
Wmpmeanswholemilkpowder.
othercapitalisedtermsusedinthisStatementhavethemeaningsgiventothemintheManual.
gloSSary7
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 13
InDePenDent assUranCe rePortto the DIreCtors oF Fonterra Co-oPeratIve groUP LImIteD
Scope WehaveauditedtheapplicationofthePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulesasdefinedintheFarmgateMilkPriceManualof21September2011(the‘Manual’)bytheMilkPriceGroup(‘MPG’)inestablishingtheF12Season’sMilkPriceof$6.08(the‘FonterraFarmgateMilkPrice’).WehaveconfirmedthebalancescontainedintheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceStatementarecorrectlyextractedfromthecalculationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPrice.
Milk Price Group’s Responsibilities TheMPGisresponsibleforthecalculationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPricebasedupontheManual,ensuringtheFonterraFarmgateMilkPricehasbeenderivedinaccordancewiththePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulessetoutintheManual.TheMPGisalsoresponsibleforthepreparationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceStatement.
Independent Auditors’ Responsibilities WeareresponsibleforexpressinganindependentopiniononwhethertheFonterraFarmgateMilkPricehasbeenderivedinaccordancewiththeManualandthattheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceStatementincludesinformationthathasbeencorrectlyextracted,inallmaterialrespects,fromthecalculationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceandreportingouropiniontoyou.
WeconductedourindependentassuranceengagementinaccordancewithInternationalStandardsonAssuranceEngagements(NZ)andStandardsonAssuranceEngagements.Thosestandardsrequirethatwecomplywithethicalrequirementsandplanandperformourprocedurestoobtainreasonableassuranceaboutwhether,inallmaterialrespects,thecalculationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceisfairlystatedinaccordancewiththePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulessetoutintheManual,andthatthebalancescontainedintheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceStatementarecorrectlyextractedfromthecalculationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPrice.
Inherent Limitationsourengagementincludesexamining,onatestbasis,evidencerelevanttotheamountsusedtoderivetheFonterraFarmgateMilkPrice.Italsoincludesassessingthesignificantassumptions,estimatesandjudgementsmadebytheMPGinthecalculationoftheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceandensuringthePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulesappliedareconsistentwiththosesetoutintheManual.Astheproceduresperformedareundertakenonatestbasis,ourassuranceengagementcannotbereliedontodetectallinstanceswherethePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulessetoutintheManualhavenotbeencompliedwith.ouropinionexpressedinthisreporthasbeenformedonthatbasis.
WecarryoutotherassignmentsonbehalfofFonterraintheareasofotherauditrelatedservicesandtransactionandotheradvisoryservices.PartnersandemployeesofourfirmmaydealwithFonterraonnormaltermswithintheordinarycourseoftradingactivitiesofFonterra.WearenotawareofanyrelationshipsbetweenourfirmandFonterraCo-operativeGroupLimited,theMilkPricePanelandtheMPGthat,inourprofessionaljudgement,mayreasonablybethoughttoimpairourindependence.
Independent Assurance Opinion InouropiniontheMPGhascomplied,inallmaterialrespects,withthePrinciples,MethodologiesandDetailedRulesintheManualinderivingtheFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceof$6.08.WehaveconfirmedthebalancescontainedinthisFonterraFarmgateMilkPriceStatementarecorrectlyextractedfromtheFonterraFarmgateMilkPricecalculation.
Restriction on Distribution or UseThisreportismadesolelytothemembersoftheBoard.ourreporthasbeenpreparedattherequestofFonterraCo-operativeGroupLimitedandfornootherpurpose.TothefullestextentpermittedbylawwedonotacceptorassumeresponsibilitytoanyoneotherthantheGroupforthisreport,orfortheopinionswehaveformed.
CharteredAccountants Auckland25September2012
14 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
NumbersinthisStatement(includinginthefollowingAttachments)havebeenroundedand,asaresult,sometablesmaynotexactlytotalorsumto100%.
2012 SeaSon miLk CoLLeCted (miLLion kgmS)
produCtion (‘000 mt) FiniShed produCt
Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
JUN2011ToAUG2011 103 141 29 11 10 3
SEPT2011ToNov2011 567 562 305 112 69 26
DEC2011ToFEB2012 487 578 186 80 55 20
MAR2012ToMAY2012 336 487 65 39 30 12
totaL 1,493 1,768 585 242 164 60
2011 SeaSon miLk CoLLeCted (miLLion kgmS)
produCtion (‘000 mt) FiniShed produCt
Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
JUN2010ToAUG2010 95 139 20 6 11 3
SEPT2010ToNov2010 522 547 262 105 58 23
DEC2010ToFEB2011 434 468 199 88 47 19
MAR2011ToMAY2011 296 409 70 32 33 11
totaL 1,346 1,563 551 232 149 56
2010 SeaSon miLk CoLLeCted (miLLion kgmS)
produCtion (‘000 mt) FiniShed produCt
Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
JUN2009ToAUG2009 91 119 29 8 12 3
SEPT2009ToNov2009 515 514 280 116 54 23
DEC2009ToFEB2010 438 439 226 88 57 20
MAR2010ToMAY2010 242 329 59 29 28 9
totaL 1,286 1,401 593 241 150 55
Milk ColleCteD & proDuCtioN voluMeSattaChMeNt 1:
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 15
2012 SeaSon ShipmentS (‘000 mt) oF FiniShed produCt
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2011TooCT2011 188 58 7 12 3
Nov2011ToJAN2012 512 187 79 52 24
FEB2012ToAPR2012 442 139 65 43 15
MAY2012ToJUL2012 500 131 54 41 11
AUG2012TooCT2012 126 69 37 16 7
totaL 1,768 585 242 164 60
2011 SeaSon ShipmentS (‘000 mt) oF FiniShed produCt
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2010TooCT2010 223 50 18 30 9
Nov2010ToJAN2011 418 171 65 37 18
FEB2011ToAPR2011 506 159 61 33 14
MAY2011ToJUL2011 320 121 46 32 9
AUG2011TooCT2011 96 50 42 16 5
totaL 1,563 551 232 149 56
2010 SeaSon ShipmentS (‘000 mt) oF FiniShed produCt
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2009TooCT2009 203 92 21 34 11
Nov2009ToJAN2010 384 197 77 50 20
FEB2010ToAPR2010 373 155 59 37 12
MAY2010ToJUL2010 365 100 50 25 8
AUG2010TooCT2010 76 49 34 4 3
totaL 1,401 593 241 150 55
SaleS voluMeSattaChMeNt 2:
16 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
average NuMber of MoNthS prior to ShipMeNt that priCeS were StruCk
attaChMeNt 3:
2012 SeaSon averaGe number oF monthS prior to Shipment
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2011TooCT2011 3.3 2.7 2.1 3.1 2.5
Nov2011ToJAN2012 3.5 3.0 2.8 3.2 2.8
FEB2012ToAPR2012 3.5 3.2 3.5 3.6 3.0
MAY2012ToJUL2012 3.2 2.9 2.9 3.1 2.6
AUG2012TooCT2012 3.4 3.3 2.7 3.1 3.1
voLume-WeiGhted annuaL averaGe 3.4 3.0 3.0 3.2 2.8
2011 SeaSon averaGe number oF monthS prior to Shipment
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2010TooCT2010 3.6 2.9 2.4 4.2 3.0
Nov2010ToJAN2011 3.6 3.3 2.5 3.7 2.7
FEB2011ToAPR2011 3.8 3.6 2.6 3.5 3.0
MAY2011ToJUL2011 4.0 3.5 3.0 3.4 2.6
AUG2011TooCT2011 3.1 4.4 2.3 3.1 3.1
voLume-WeiGhted annuaL averaGe 3.7 3.5 2.6 3.6 2.8
2010 SeaSon averaGe number oF monthS prior to Shipment
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2009TooCT2009 3.5 3.7 2.1 3.1 4.2
Nov2009ToJAN2010 3.8 3.7 3.6 3.7 4.2
FEB2010ToAPR2010 3.7 3.2 2.4 3.1 4.0
MAY2010ToJUL2010 4.1 2.9 2.6 3.2 3.2
AUG2010TooCT2010 3.5 3.0 2.1 4.2 3.6
voLume-WeiGhted annuaL averaGe 3.8 3.4 2.8 3.4 4.0
Thetablesonthefollowingpagesupplementthatabovebyprovidinginformationontheaveragepercentagesofsalescontractedineachofmonths1to8priortoshipmentinthe2012Season.
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 17
Thecontracttenorcalculatedusingthe“Average%ofSalesContractedineachofMonths1–8priortoShipment”tablesmaynotreconcilewiththoseinthe“AverageNumberofMonthsPriorto
Shipment”tables,duetothedifferenceinvolumesusedtocalculateweightings.
In2011themethodofcalculationwasrevisedtoexcludeallsalescontractedin
themonthofshipment,onthebasisthatthesesalesinalmostallinstanceswerenotcontractedontermsthatwouldbeachievablebyabusinessthatdidnothaveoffshorewarehouses.
2012 SeaSon: averaGe % oF SaLeS ContraCted in eaCh oF monthS 1 – 8 prior to Shipment
monthS beFore Shipment Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
1 11% 6% 9% 7% 4%
2 33% 33% 35% 38% 35%
3 26% 28% 26% 33% 23%
4 19% 15% 16% 17% 15%
5 7% 11% 6% 5% 11%
6 2% 4% 4% 1% 5%
7 2% 2% 2% 0% 4%
8 0% 2% 2% 0% 3%
2011 SeaSon: averaGe % oF SaLeS ContraCted in eaCh oF monthS 1 – 8 prior to Shipment
monthS beFore Shipment Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
1 3% 6% 12% 4% 8%
2 22% 28% 40% 27% 40%
3 26% 28% 33% 25% 28%
4 20% 19% 10% 16% 13%
5 16% 7% 4% 10% 6%
6 6% 7% 1% 6% 2%
7 4% 3% 0% 9% 0%
8 4% 2% 0% 3% 3%
2010 SeaSon: averaGe % oF SaLeS ContraCted in eaCh oF monthS 0 – 8 prior to Shipment
monthS beFore Shipment Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
0 1% 1% 3% 1% 0%
1 6% 6% 14% 5% 1%
2 28% 27% 31% 26% 20%
3 20% 25% 23% 28% 23%
4 14% 19% 15% 21% 21%
5 9% 10% 8% 13% 16%
6 9% 6% 2% 5% 10%
7 8% 2% 2% 2% 5%
8 5% 3% 1% 1% 3%
18 FONTERRA FARMGATE MILK PRICE STATEMENT – 31 MAY 2012
average uSD priCeSattaChMeNt 4:
2012 SeaSon uSd per mt oF FiniShed produCt
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2011TooCT2011 3,663 3,594 4,081 4,837 3,430
Nov2011ToJAN2012 3,436 3,376 3,829 4,115 3,176
FEB2012ToAPR2012 3,503 3,386 3,728 3,867 3,330
MAY2012ToJUL2012 3,147 3,085 3,337 3,376 3,107
AUG2012TooCT2012 2,925 2,957 2,836 3,167 2,683
annuaL WeiGhted averaGe( INCLUD ING DoWNGRADE ADJUSTMENT ) 3,359 3,285 3,546 3,825 3,163
2011 SeaSon uSd per mt oF FiniShed produCt
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2010TooCT2010 3,513 3,003 3,943 4,548 2,902
Nov2010ToJAN2011 3,346 3,034 4,104 4,821 3,010
FEB2011ToAPR2011 3,579 3,290 4,449 5,529 3,323
MAY2011ToJUL2011 3,992 3,700 4,677 6,022 3,738
AUG2011TooCT2011 3,803 3,800 4,365 5,507 3,702
annuaL WeiGhted averaGe( INCLUD ING DoWNGRADE ADJUSTMENT ) 3,606 3,321 4,344 5,258 3,259
2010 SeaSon uSd per mt oF FiniShed produCt
Shipment period Wmp Smp butter amF bmp
AUG2009TooCT2009 1,999 1,965 1,850 2,178 1,482
Nov2009ToJAN2010 2,553 2,415 2,248 2,812 1,930
FEB2010ToAPR2010 3,091 2,885 3,526 4,291 2,659
MAY2010ToJUL2010 3,433 3,136 3,724 4,494 3,035
AUG2010TooCT2010 3,654 3,246 3,691 4,694 3,228
annuaL WeiGhted averaGe( INCLUD ING DoWNGRADE ADJUSTMENT ) 2,905 2,658 3,033 3,368 2,234
25 SEPTEMBER 2012 19
average uSD: NZD CoNverSioNaND Spot rate
attaChMeNt 5:
8ThespotrateforAugust–october2012istheaveragedailyratebetween1August2012and7September2012,whentheFarmgateMilkPriceStatementwasfinalised.
2012 SeaSon averaGe uSd : nZd rate
Shipment period aChieved ConverSion Spot
AUG2011TooCT2011 0.7391 0.7956
Nov2011ToJAN2012 0.7690 0.7805
FEB2012ToAPR2012 0.7742 0.8253
MAY2012ToJUL2012 0.7804 0.7852
AUG2012TooCT20128 0.7781 0.8019
revenue-WeiGhted annuaL averaGe 0.7706 0.7965
2011 SeaSon averaGe uSd : nZd rate
Shipment period aChieved ConverSion Spot
AUG2010TooCT2010 0.6927 0.7414
Nov2010ToJAN2011 0.7041 0.7623
FEB2011ToAPR2011 0.7231 0.7630
MAY2011ToJUL2011 0.7308 0.8169
AUG2011TooCT2011 0.7519 0.8269
revenue-WeiGhted annuaL averaGe 0.7184 0.7777
2010 SeaSon averaGe uSd : nZd rate
Shipment period aChieved ConverSion Spot
AUG2009TooCT2009 0.6330 0.7258
Nov2009ToJAN2010 0.6531 0.7239
FEB2010ToAPR2010 0.6682 0.7047
MAY2010ToJUL2010 0.6835 0.7007
AUG2010TooCT2010 0.6887 0.7178
revenue-WeiGhted annuaL averaGe 0.6661 0.7120